high speed rail issue 02 empire corridor project€¦ · new york state’s vision for high speed...
TRANSCRIPT
New York State has one of the most comprehensive and intensively-used passenger and freight transportation systems in the nation. It provides energy-efficient mobility for passengers and contributes to the economic vitality of the state and the nation. New York State’s Vision for High Speed Rail is to enhance the passenger and freight rail operations in order to:
• Divert traffic from less energy efficient modes
• Improve connectivity among State’s cities and regions
• Increase ridership by:
o Improving On-Time Performance
o Reducing Travel Time
o Increasing Service Frequency
o Improving Stations and Passenger Amenities
The 463 mile Empire Corri-dor stretches from Niagara Falls to New York City. The Tier 1 Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is examining and evaluating potential projects and service improvements in line with this vision.
The sustainability of our local, state and national economy is dependent upon a diversity of transportation options. For high speed intercity passen-ger rail (HSIPR) to be competitive with other modes, the following must be accomplished:
• Increase Service Frequency
o Currently, there are only 4 round trips between Albany and Buffalo per day
• Improve On-Time Performance
o Currently, on-time performance is only 77% on average, and only 64% from Buffalo/Niagara Falls to Albany
o Provide travel times that are Comparable with other modes
o Current travel time between Albany and Buffalo is 5 hours and 15 minutes and is not competitive with other travel modes
High Speed Rail Empire Corridor Project
New York State’s High Speed Rail Vision
Scoping OutreachSuccessful
- Project website visited by more than 4,000 unique visitors
- Approximately 700 people attended the Scoping meetings
- 90% view project favorably
Rochester Public Scoping Meeting
Albany Public Scoping Meeting
Nature of Comments
I s s u e 0 2
S p r i n g 2 0 1 1
IncreaseRidership
ImproveOn-Time
Performance
ReduceTravel Time
ImproveStations & Amenities
IncreaseService
Frequency
Supportive
Neutral
Concerned
Continued on page 3
10%20%
70%
The success of high speed rail is determined to a large extent by the presence of sev-eral market qualities as illustrated below. The Empire Corridor contains several of the market qualities and indicators for successful implementation of high speed rail.
What is High Speed Rail?
There are various definitions of high speed rail in the U.S., but most experts agree that high speed rail (HSR) consists of passenger trips between 100 and 500 miles. A recent announcement from the Obama Administration refined the FRA definition for High Speed Rail as: Emerging (up to 90 mph), Regional (90 - 125 mph), and Core Express (125 - 250 mph).
Market Qualities of Successful High Speed Rail
2
Emerging Regional Core ExpressRoutes: Major pop. centers up to 500 miles apartService: FrequentSpeed: 125 to 250+ mphTrack: Electrified/Dedicated Purpose: Connect large urban areas
Routes: Major/medium cities up to 500 miles apartService: Relatively frequent Speed: 90 to 125 mphTrack: Shared/DedicatedPurpose: Connect mid-sized urban areas
Routes: 100-500 milesService: Relatively frequentSpeed: Up to 90 mphTrack: SharedPurpose: Connect smaller communities
50 190
70 170
90 150110 130
50 190
70 170
90 150110 130
50 190
70 170
90 150110 130
Presence ofMega Cities
Distance: Competitiveness of HSIPR is maximized at distances of 100 - 500 miles.
Peak effectiveness at 200 - 300 miles.
Location withinMega Region
TransitConnections
EconomicProductivity
Highway andAir Congestion
Initial Market Study Findings
A market analysis and ridership forecast were conducted to model travel market conditions and ridership along the cor-ridor. The model produced a preliminary forecast for initial dedicated third track scenarios for maximum authorized speeds of 79, 90, and 110 mph. These preliminary forecasts will be used as a basis for devel-oping the alternatives considered for the Empire Corridor. The preliminary findings from the market analysis and ridership forecast are promising and indicate that a market clearly exists for enhanced passen-ger rail service on the Empire Corridor.
• Links the Northeast and Great Lakes Mega regions and is anchored by a Mega City (NYC)
• Size of cities in corridor well suited for high speed rail
• Length of corridor segments, West & South, are within ideal high speed rail corridor distances (200-300 miles apart)
• Rail service can draw ridership from congested regional air market
• Existing corridor geometry and operations complicates achieving higher rail speeds
• Car-dominated infrastructure and habits
• Segregated and sprawled land uses
• Lack of supporting transit linkages to train stations
Schedule
3
Sample Comments
“Please maintain competitiveness
with airlines or driving cost.”
“...the study should investigate
ensuring good connections between
potential HSR lines and local transit
as this will help increase access to
HSR and thus its potential market
share.”
“I hope New York State will lead the
way to improved travel options with
less negative environmental impacts
and greater economic benefits.”
Comment Categories
Continued from page 1
General
Alternatives
Regional Connection
Stations
Operations
Other
31%
9%13%
12% 10%
25%
EmpireCorridorStrengths
EmpireCorridorBarriers
Prepare Draft EIS Summer — 2011
Distribute Draft EIS — Fall 2011
Distribute Final EIS — Spring 2012
Record of DecisionSummer 2012
Public Hearings — Fall 2011
Elements of Alternatives Being Considered
The alternatives being considered under the Tier 1 EIS will be comprised of various components. Some of these will be criteria that will define the alternative, while others will be outputs of the alternative to measure effectiveness. The following components are being considered, analyzed, and defined for the range of alternatives:
• Physical Improvements (track, signals, stations, yards, etc.)
• Operational Improvements (frequency, maximum authorized speed, trip time, on-time performance, etc.)
• Equipment (new train sets)
• Ridership (revenues)
• Estimated Capital Costs / Operation & Maintenance Costs
4
News Reports Available:
- Public Involvement Plan/ Coordina-tion Plan
- Environmental Methodologies
Available at: www.nysdot.gov/Empire-Corridor/reports
Recent Activities:
Second EPAC meeting held at NYSDOT
Main Office on March 21st, 2011 from
1:30 to 4:30pm
- Presented project progress and preliminary findings
- Gathered input from EPAC members and addressed questions & com-ments
- Approximately thirty EPAC members participated in the meeting
Keep In Touch
Visit the Project Website: www.nysdot.
gov/Empire-Corridor
Send a Comment:
Keep in touch with your local Empire
Corridor Project Advisory Committee
(EPAC) member. For a list of agencies
on the EPAC, visit: www.nysdot.gov/
Empire-Corridor/outreach
Partners/Public
Involvement
EnvironmentalConsiderations
OperationsAnalysis
Market &RidershipAnalysis
PhysicalImprovements/
Engineering