hiiumaa offshore wind farm hydro pump storage pp in...

26
October 2011 Hiiumaa offshore wind farm & Hydro pump storage PP in Estonia Energiasalv OÜ

Upload: phamngoc

Post on 10-Aug-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • October 2011

    Hiiumaa offshore wind farm&

    Hydro pump storage PP in EstoniaEnergiasalv O

  • Innovative combination of offshore farm

    and hydro pump storage will reduce the

    regions dependence on

    fossil fuels

    Offshore wind farm combined with hydro pump storage

    2

    Strong winds

    average speed 8.5 m/s

    Shallow waters

    10-20 m depth

    Close to the land

    Around 10 km

    Smooth sandy

    seabed

    No rocks

    Combination of offshore wind farm and hydro pump storage is the only feasible opportunity to produce RE in the region at scale, due to limitations in the power system

    Up to 700 MW

    Significant capacity

    Estonia

    Late consenting

    stage

    Hiiumaa offshore wind farm

    Energiasalv hydro pump storage

    Cheap

    Cost 0,54 EUR m per MW installed

    Constructed in granite mine,

    additional revenue from

    graniteIdeal solution to

    integrate wind

    into the system

    Allows reducing CO2 emissions

    by 1,7 MT

    Allows the Baltics function as

    independent energy system

  • Hydro pump storage plant

    3

  • Upper reservoirBaltic Sea

    Lower reservoir

    Maintenance tunnelHigh pressure pipe

    Low pressure pipe

    Turbines

    Electrical grid tunnelLift

    Management centre

    Sub-station Entrance to maintenance tunnel

    Hydro pump storage power plant in Estonia

    Hydro pump storage power station of 500 MW installed capacity

    Estimated construction cost of 0,54 EUR m per MW

    Will allow integration of offshore wind farm into the system

    Upper reservoir is the Baltic sea, while the lower reservoir is a granite mine

    Synergy with granite mining, sales of granite - additional revenue

    The power plant is projected to be commissioned by 2018

    Strong project with positive impact on the environment

    Project snapshot Positive impact on the environment

    Realisation of the hydro pump storage project would allow reducing production of energy from oilshale, meaning reduction of 1,5 MT of CO2 emissions

    Hydro pump storage with contemplated capacity of 500 MW would allow 1,5 TWh production of wind energy per annum

    No reliance on imported resources, no fossil fuels

    Preliminary design

    Key figures

    Plannedcapacity

    500 MW

    Reservoir size 5,4 mln m3

    Water intake flow

    270 th m3

    Depth 500 m

    Max non-stop working hours

    12 h

    Investment ~ EUR 270 m

  • Hydro pump storage power plant

    In times of peak demand and high electricity prices, water is temporarily diverted through hydroelectricity turbines

    5

    In times of excess power on the grid and low electricity prices,water is pumped (returned) to the sea using wind power

    Working cycle: buy cheap & sell expensive

    Daily distribution of electricity prices (average for 2010)

    Plant pumps water up, consuming

    abundant cheap electricity

    Plant produces

    electricity, when it is

    in high demand

    Pump at night & produce in a day

    Pump storage would earn from:

    Capitalising on daily spread in electricity spot prices: night vs peak time

    Capitilizing on spread between times of strong winds (low prices) and no-wind hours (expensive prices)

    Providing balance power service to TSO

    Some part of the capacity could be sold to TSO as emergency reserve

    Pump storage will help facilitate Estonian goal to develop 650 MW onshore plus 500 MW offshore of wind power by stabilizing the variability and intermittent nature of wind generation, essentially acting as a battery for wind power.

    This partnership of wind and pump storage makes wind generated energy more predictable and therefore more reliable and secure

    Off-

    peak

    Peak load

    Source: Riverbank Power

    MW

  • Hydro pump storage power plant

    6

    Need to agree the subsidy scheme with the government

    F carried out pre-feasibility study

    LOI signed with the Port of Tallinn regarding the land plot

    Efficient logistic site for granite sales

    Upper reservoir would be Gulf of Finland

    Port territory is industrial land according to the detail plan

    Seawater intake scheme design completed

    Detail planning and EIA process ongoing

    Ideal solution for covering peak loads and provision of balancing power to wind energy

    Activities so far

    Next steps

    Energy benefits

    Reduce dependence on fossil fuel

    Increase energy independence

    Diversify energy portfolio

    Reduce environmental impacts of energy generation

    Wind Energy Battery stores the intermittent wind energy during low demand periods and shifts it to the peak periods

    Security, Reliability and Assurance:

    Black Start Capability

    Spinning and non-spinning reserves

    Voltage regulation, frequency control and load following

    Energy Storage

    Storing and converting low cost power into peak demand capacity meeting Blatic peak load requirements

    Enhancing Wind

    Converting intermittent wind power into a scheduled renewable electricity source in peak demand period

    Pump storage will help Estonia meet its objective to develop 1,150 MW of wind by 2020

    By adding pump storage to the Baltic energy supply network, Estonia would diversify its resources in a responsible and sustainable manner while enhancing its ability to integrate large quantities of wind generation

    Benefits

  • Hydro pump storage power plant

    7

    Planned location of the station is Muuga Port

    Good grid connections in the planned location

    Preliminary land agreement with Port of Tallinn signed

    Contemplated location

    Location on the Baltic sea coast with good grid infrastructure

  • National Development Strategy envisages building 1 800 MW of reserve and wind parks balancing capacities by 2018

    Wind balancing: 900 MW

    Peak-load reserve: 300 MW

    Emergency reserve: 600 MW

    Significant share of wind energy in the countrys electricity balance will lead to the need for wind farms balancing capacities

    Several offshore wind farms are planed next to Estonian western sea coast

    Excellent conditions for offshore development: strong winds (40-45% capacity factors), shallow waters and smooth sandy seabed

    Possibilities to balance wind energy with other countries electricity systems are limited due to insufficient grid connections

    Need for internal solution

    Hydro pump storage is an ideal solution for balancing of wind farms and as a reserve capacity station due to short start-up times

    0

    400

    800

    1 200

    1 600

    2 000

    2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

    Emergency reserve capacities

    Peak-load reserve capacities

    Balancing capacities to wind parks

    Balancing capacities needed in Estonia

    81 800 MW of reserve and balancing capacities to be built

    MW

    Comments Balancing and reserve capacities needed

  • Project developer: Energiasalv

    9

    Inv

    est

    ors

    Vardar is a Norwegian utility company with annual energy generation is around 3,2 GWh, mostly coming from hydro

    4Energia is focused on developing renewable energy projects and operating wind parks in the Baltics

    Organizational structure

    Energiasalv

    Hydro pump storage project developer

    Voolu Energia

    Competence in development and management of renewable energy projects

    4E Technoinvest

    Ma

    na

    ge

    me

    nt

    co

    mp

    an

    y

    Competence in granite mining

    Vool is an investment company active in energy and mining sectors. Appart from Energiasalv development project, the

    major business line is Maardu Graniidikaevandus, mining of granite from Neeme granite deposit.

    Investment companies of prominent Estonian business angels: Hannes Tamjrv and

    Peeter Mnd

  • Experienced project development team

    10

    Martin Kruus(CEO of 4 Energia)

    Education:

    Tallinn Technical University - Thermal EngineeringPrevious employment:

    Eesti Energia, Director of Business Unit of Renewable Energy. Main responsibility was to establish and run power plants using renewable energy sources wind, hydro, biomassMinistry of Economic Affairs, Department of Management of State CompaniesEstonian Privatization Agency, Project Manager for IPOs

    Main accomplishments:

    Renovation of Estonian biggest hydro power plant Linname HPP Building of Estonian first wind park Virtsu wind parkSeveral feasibility studies and project management about CHPs

    Lembit ValiEnergiasalv CEO

    Kalle Kiigske(CFO of 4 Energia)

    Education:

    Estonian Business School Banking and Financial ManagementPrevious employment:

    United Partners Group, Pan-Baltic investment bank, Partner, responsible for merchant banking and investmentsAS Hansa Capital leading asset-based finance company in the Baltics, Russia and Ukraine with total assets over EUR 1,7 billion, Hansa Capital is the industrys largest company in Eastern Europe and among top 50 in Europe, Member of Board and Head of Factoring and Trade Finance Several positions in Factor Chain International (Amsterdam, the Netherlands) - Member of the Communication Committee, Member of the Internal Audit

    Education:

    Tallinn Technical University Electrical EngineeringPrevious employment:

    Elering, Estonian national grid company CEOEstonian Energy Technical Director, a member of the management boardNarva Elektrijaamad (Narva Power Plants) - CEO

    Main accomplishments:

    Extenstive experience in power industry since 1973Worked on top management positions in energy sector for 18 years

    foto

    foto

    foto

    Hands-on experience in renewable energy and granite mining

    Peep SiitamVoolu Energia CEO

    Education:

    Tallinn Technical University- M.Sc. in civil engineering Estonian Business School - MBA

    Previous employment:

    Vool - Co-founder of of the company having majority shareholding in Maardu Granite MineMerko Mines - Chairman of the management boardEstonian Energy Technology Program - Program Manager

    Main accomplishments:

    Chartered Engineer since 1998Substantial experience as a member of top management in the Baltic leading construction companies

    foto

  • Project schedule

    Expected date

    EIA study 2011- 2012

    Geological reseach 2012

    Construction permit December 2012

    Construction of water intake system 2013

    Construction of water reservoirs, I stage 2013-2015

    Construction of water reservoirs, II stage 2016-2018

    Installation of equipment of the pump storage 2016-2018

    Commissioning 2018

    11

  • Hiiumaa offshore wind farm

    12

  • Hiiumaa wind farm is in advanced stages of development compared to other potential projects in the region

    Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) carried out

    Wind measurements on the sea carried out (100 m measuring mast was installed on the sea)

    Seabed studies carried out

    Wind park impact studies on birds, fish and seaplants carried out

    Socio-economic assessments carried out

    Technical conditions agreed on with the Main Grid, including grid access (connection to two 330 kV substations)

    Scouting for structural design has been done by Ramboll

    Shareholders:

    Vardar Eurus 45% (JV between Vardar, Norwegian municipality energy company and Nothern Environmental Finance Corporation)

    Freenergy 45% (Fund investing in renewable energy projects, EBRD has 33% shareholding)

    4energia 10% (Management company for renewable energy company; JV between Vardar Eurus, Freenergy and the companys management)

    13

    Total Installed Capacity 500-700 MW

    Yearly Net Production 1.7-2.4 TWh/y

    Located on three shoalsApollo, Vinkov, Kuivaluka shoals next to Hiiumaa island, Estonia

    Distance from shoreline 5 km to 20 km

    Depth 6 m to 20 m, sandy seabed

    Grid connectionConnection to substation in Estonia, possibly Sweden and Finland

    Planned erection 2014-2025

    Project snapshot Project status

    Hiiumaa offshore wind farm: project snapshot

  • 14

    Layout of the wind farm

    ContentComments Layout of the wind farm

    Source: 4Energia, EMD

    EMD completed a wind study (production assessment phase) based on the collected onshore-offshore site measurements

    EMD prepared wind park visualization and currently finalizing the wind park turbulence study

    A geophysical study was undertaken and provided maps of water depth

    Maps are used to limit the assigned wind farm area to within 35 m water depth

    Layout optimization in regards to coast guard radars was made

    With current layout optimization, max installed wind park capacity could be 730 MW (with Repower 5MW turbines), where arrary loss is 10,2 %.

    Layouts have been also optimized for production

  • 15

    Wind conditions in the Baltics

    Content Comments Distribution of full load hours in Europe (120 m hub height offshore)

    Source: The UNDP/GEF Baltic Wind Atlas, EBRD Renewable Development Initiative

    The cyclonic activity of the Baltic Sea region results in high mean wind speeds throughout the area

    In general, wind potential in the coastal zone of Estonia is higher than that in the other Baltic countries, however, the Baltic Sea impact dictates the difference in wind regimes on the coastal line and in the inland regions

    In Estonia, there are several areas with annual average wind speed of 7-8 m/s at 10 m height (corresponding to wind speed over 10 m/s at 50m height)

    Estonian wind climate is very volatile with respect to location and seasonality, whereas 2/3 of total energy potential is converted from October to February

    As water has less surface roughness than land (especially deeper waters), offshore wind speeds are considerably higher than onshore

    Thus, offshore wind resources are characterized by higher load hours

    Considerably higher wind speeds due to less land/vegetation interference allows for generation of considerably more power than onshore locations

    3 000-4 500 h/year offshore vs. 2 000-3 000 h/year onshore

    Average 40%-45% offshore capacity vs. 25%-30% onshore

    No onshore areas have resource potentials exceeding 4 000 full load hours

    According to EEA, Estonian unrestricted technical potential of offshore development with less than 10 km to the shore exceeds 200 TWh in annual generation

    Estonia has significant potential for offshore wind energy due to abundant availability of large areas of shallow waters with close distance to the land

    Windy and shallow waters

  • 16

    Wind measurements

    Content Comments Wind speed comparison Pakri and Hiiumaa

    Source: 4Energia

    Offshore wind measurement (on Vinkov shoal) executed with SODAR system

    Measurements showed the average wind speed of 8.5 m/s during the period

    Offshore (Vinkovi) 80 m and Pakri 80 m (onshore) comparison shows 2.0 m/s higher average wind speed in Vinkovi during Jul-Dec 2009

    Average wind speed of 8.5 m/s

    SODAR system installed on Vinkov shoal

    Onshore wind measurement mast in Ristna, Hiiumaa

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    Jul 09 Aug 09 Sep 09 Oct 09 Nov 09 Dec 09

    m/s

    Pakri 80 m Vinkovi 80 m Ristna 80 m

    Wind speed comparison

  • 17

    Enviroment Impact Assessment

    ContentRoute of expedition plane of the bird study (Four times in year) Inventory of biota and habitat

    ss

    Comrehensive EIA studies completed

    Fish study

  • 18

    Grid connection

    Comments Main option for 330 kV AC grid connection

    Source: 4Energia

    Grid connection application made to Elering (TSO) where two possible connection points (new Kanapeeksi 330 kV substation in Hiiumaa or expanded Leisi substation in Saaremaa) are pointed out

    Elering submitted technical coordination for the Hiiumaa offshore wind farm application of building permit

    The total amount of connection payment is up to EUR 0.5 million and additionally there has to be 100% of coverage by the regulating power units what will ascend the total grid investments

    Search for optimal solution for regulating power units started

    A grid connection proposal must be issued for the regulating power units connection

    The connection agreement for regulating power units must be signed simultaneously with the offshore connection contract

  • Legal procedure to receive approval for construction of offshore wind farm

    Estonian offshore: legal procedure and permits

    Source: xxx

    Necessary legislation to regulate offshore developments was passed in February 2010 by the Estonian Parlament

    Hiiumaa offshore wind farm project application has been filled to the Ministry of Economy that currently is processing it

    4Energia requested the Ministry of Environment to approve Hiiumaa EIA program

    Application to Ministry of Economy

    First step for developer is to submit proper application to Ministry of Economy who is responsible for the treatment process and will finally issue the permit for the construction (land use) of offshore wind park

    The annual tolerance fee will be calculated form specific land value (4% during wind park construction and 7% during operation)

    The building of offshore wind park is primarily regulated with superficies

    Application to Ministry of Environment

    The application and further steps will be coordinated with Ministry of Environment, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of the Interior, Maritime Administration and with Civil Aviation Authority

    If application is accepted for further proceedings then all the actions will be determined by the Ministry of Economy (EIA, other requested studies etc.)

    The issued license will be valid for 50 years

    Application for grid connection

    The key components for successful application: overall wind park information (incl. turbine type and foundations), detail lactation maps with exact coordinates, what also includes all the other marine applications (substations and submarine cables routes) plus grid connection conformity from the TSO (Elering)

  • 20

    Hiiumaa offshore wind farm: investment highlights

    Project snapshot

    Offshore wind energy farm in the shoal sea close to Hiiumaa island coast with planned installed capacity of 500-700 MW in the planning stage with wind measurements done and environment impact assessment study in the completion stage

    Harnessing one of the largest, easily scalable domestic energy resource offshore wind would provide a solid answer to the issues of energy security and independence, issues of increasing importance in the region

    Excellent wind to grasp

    Shallow water (primarily appr. 10-20 m) and close distance to the land (10 km) are optimal combination for the offshore development

    Favorable wind conditions at the region with average wind speed of 8.5 m/s

    Limited availability of coastal area land suitable for onshore wind parks should drive offshore wind energy sector

    Favourable market

    environment

    Expected capacity shortage in the Baltic energy market fuels further the need for replacement of existing power generation capacity

    Full liberation of Estonian electricity market since 2013 will lead to electricity prices converging with European average

    Restructuing and uprading of fossil fuel based generation capacities is expensive and drive electricity prices up; as investment costs will be fully reflected in electricity price of newly built blocks of Narva PP

    Undersea grid connections (current Estlink 1 and Estlink 2 to be built by 2013) with combined trandmission capacity exceeding 1,000 MW enable exporting electricity to the Nordic market

    Renewable energy to

    substitute fossils

    Supplies of main fossil fuels used in power generation are becoming more difficult to extract and expensive due to carbon penalty

    High carbon content per GDP in Baltics means increasing costs of electricity generated from fossil fuel

    Increasing importance of CO2-free energy sources, as power sector is geared towards more sustainable use of energy

    Rising profile of environmental issues along with improvements in the technology encourages wider political support

    Regulation to support

    offshore wind sector

    Estonia has a binding target set by EU directive of 25% share of renewable energy in final energy consumptiion by 2020

    Estonian National Energy Strategy envisages 500 MW of offshore wind capacity by 2018

    .

  • Appendix

    Baltic electricity market

  • Estonia is described by political and economic stability, accessibility, ease and low cost of doing business and investor equality

    Estonia is ranked among the top 25 out of all countries in the Ease of Doing Business index by The World Bank Group

    Estonian taxes are low and simple

    There is no corporate income on profit, unless it is paid out as dividends, which is taxed at 21%

    Estonia does not impose any gift, inheritance or estate taxes

    Debt capital is abundant and readily available, as the nearly all banks operating in Estonia are subsidiaries of large Scandinavian players

    In the period of 2007-2013 Estonia is allocated more than EUR 3.4 billion from the EU Structural funds, which stimulates economic development

    Estonian economy is successfully recovering from the crisis

    GDP growth in 2010 was 3,1%; forecast for 2011 6,3%

    Public finances are under control: Estonia is the only EU country with a 2010 budget surplus (0,1% of GDP) and it has the EUs lowest debt (6,6% of GDP)

    Estonia adopted Euro since January 2011

    22

    Key figures (2010)

    Estonia: country snapshot

    Map of Estonia

    Source: Statistics Estonia

    Population, mln 1,34

    Area, 000' km2 45,2

    GDP per capita, % of EUR average 65%

    GDP growth, % 3,10%

    Inflation, % 3%

    Corporate tax, % 21%

    Unemployment, % 14,4%

    Average gross monthly salary, EUR 792

    Attractive place for foreign investments

  • 2

    Electricity market in the Baltics

    Content ContentComments Electricity sources in Baltics, 2010

    The Baltics, especially Latvia and Lithuania, are dependent on imported energy resources

    Estonian oil-shale based electricity production, albeit with relatively low energy efficiency, is a dominating energy source

    Due to its environmental risks, lower competitiveness, the key issue is to reduce oilshale consumption at the expense of renewable energy alternatives

    35% of Estonian energy market was opened since 1 April 2010 and full opening is scheduled for 1 January 2013

    Cost-based electricity pricing will be converted into market-based pricing

    In Latvia electricity is generated mostly by three Daugava hydro power plants

    Lithuanian energy production was substantially dependent on decommissioned Ignalina nuclear power plant (INPP)

    After the decommissioning of INPP Lithuania relies heavily on gas PP and electricity import, this is further exacerbated by lack of viable interconnections with Poland, Sweden and Finland

    Source: Eesti Energia, National Statistical Offices

    Dependent on imported energy

    Hydro 47%

    Gas 20%

    Imports 30%

    Other 3%

    Other4%

    Hydro 11%

    Gas34%

    Imports51%

    Wind 3%

    Wood7% Gas

    4%

    Oilshale86%

  • 0

    1 000

    2 000

    3 000

    4 000

    5 000

    6 000

    7 000

    8 000

    9 000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Installed capacity Peak demand

    2

    Comments Energy production capacities and future imbalance, 2007-2017

    Electricity market in the Baltics

    Source: Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications 1) All old pulverised combustion boilers have to be closed by the end of 2016 according to EU Directive on the limitation

    of emissions into the air from large combustion plants

    Production capacity shortage in the wake of worn-out infrastructure

    Shutdown of Elektrenai Lithuanian Power Plant

    Shutdown of Ignalina NPP (Lithuania)

    Gap to be filled

    Shutdown of old energy blocks in Narva power plants (Estonia)

    Total annual power consumption amounts to around 25 TWh/year:

    Estonia 7,5 TWh/year

    Latvia 7 TWh/year

    Lithuania 10 TWh/year

    Due to environmental reasons and physical amortization there will be shutdowns of several major power plants in Baltics

    Lithuania closed down Ignalina nuclear plant at the end of 2009

    Estonia is forced to shut down 45% of capacity of oil shale power plants by 2018 due to environmental regulation (1,240 MW will be replaced by only 600 MW)

    Although the new plants are planned to be developed, these will require large-scale investments and will not be probably completed before 2016

    It is estimated that there will be a substantial gap between production and consumption capacities in Baltic states amounting to as high as 1,200 MW by 2017

    In addition, 1,500 MW of capacities will be based on natural gas imported from Russia, being therefore with limited reliability and having upwards price pressure

    Importance of the issues of energy security and energy independence is increasing

  • 2

    Electricity market in the Baltics

    Content Content

    Estonia

    Latvia

    Lithuania

    Russia

    Finland

    Sweden

    Belarus

    Poland

    Russia

    Comments Grid connection in the Baltic states and actual power flow in 2009

    650 MW

    350 MW

    800 MW

    2,000

    MW

    1,000

    MW

    1,000

    MW

    2,000

    MW

    2,000

    MW

    1,000

    MW

    700 MW

    1,000

    MW

    Estonian energy system is interconnected with the Russian and Latvian energy systems and starting from 2006 a connection has been established with Finland through an undersea cable Estlink(Baltics and Nord Pool)

    Estlink connects Estonia to the Nordic power market, offering Baltic participants a liquid market and a trustworthy reference price

    Export to Finland has been very active: most of the time Estilinkgrid connection is used at the maximum available capacity

    Estonian electricity prices should converge with the Finnish level, especially after construction of a new undersea grid connection EstLink 2 (650 MW) by 2014, which will increase Estonian export capacity to 1,000 MW

    New transmission capacities between the Baltics and other European countries are to be constructed in next five years, thus electricity price levels should converge

    Planned new interconnections:

    2013-2016 Lithuania-Poland, 1000 MW

    2015-2016 Lithuania-Sweden, 1000 MW

    Possibly additional Latvia-Sweden and/or Estonia-Sweden links will be built Existing grid connection

    Planned grid connection

    Exported: 2,642 GWImported: 205 GWNet import: 2,437 GW

    Exported: 1,875 GWImported: 82 GW

    Net export: 1,793 GW

    Exported: 1,138 GWImported: 497 GW

    Net export: 641 GW

    Source: Baltso

    Increasing connectivity with Scandinavia: converging energy prices

  • 94,5

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    Irel

    and

    Nor

    way

    Ger

    man

    yP

    ortu

    gal

    Spa

    inIta

    lyD

    enm

    ark

    Aus

    tria

    Cze

    ch R

    epub

    licLu

    xem

    bour

    gS

    love

    nia

    Bel

    gium

    Sw

    eden

    Mal

    taF

    inla

    nd EU

    Slo

    vaki

    aC

    roat

    iaF

    ranc

    eU

    KP

    olan

    dH

    unga

    ryC

    ypru

    sT

    urke

    yLa

    tvia

    Gre

    ece

    Lith

    uani

    aR

    oman

    iaE

    ston

    iaB

    ulga

    ria

    Electricity price in Estonia is among the lowest in the EU on the back of fully amortized production facilities of power plants

    Since April 2010 Estonia is a Nord Pool price zone, as 35% of electricity market have been liberalized

    Estonian electricity prices should converge with the Finnish levelin the mid-term

    Convergence will be completed after full market liberalization in 2013 and construction of undersea grid connection EstLink2 by 2014

    Electricity prices on Nord Pools1 spot market will remain mainly influenced in the long run by the level of water in the reservoirs of the Norwegian and Swedish hydropower plants2

    Electricity price reflects production cost of the last unit sold, as such its pricing differs from other commodities

    Electricity cant be stored and has to be available on demand, thus it is the most volatile commodity

    The demand for electric power is inelastic, i.e. consumers do not respond to price changes very quickly

    26

    European electricity prices for domestic users (with taxes) in 2009

    Electricity prices

    EU average EUR 173.5/MWh

    Comments Spot electricity prices in the region (EUR/ MWh)

    Source: Bloomberg, Eurostat, Nord Pool1) Nord Pool is the trade name of the Nordic power exchange where electricity is traded on a day-ahead basis2) It is estimated that around 76% of observed variation in Nord Pool spot price is explained by Nordic hydrological balance

    EU

    R/M

    Wh

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    Apr

    -10

    Apr

    -10

    May

    -10

    Jun-

    10

    Jun-

    10

    Jul-1

    0

    Aug

    -10

    Aug

    -10

    Sep

    -10

    Oct

    -10

    Oct

    -10

    Nov

    -10

    Dec

    -10

    Dec

    -10

    Jan-

    11

    Feb

    -11

    Mar

    -11

    Mar

    -11

    Apr

    -11

    Baltpool (LT)Nordpool EstoniaNordpool Finland

    Electricity prices to converge with Scandinavian level

    EU

    R/M

    Wh