" A Survey of Supersonic Retropropulsion Technology for Mars Entry, Descent, and Landing 1,2 #$%&'( )* +,-./0 1',-234 50$636/6' ,7 8'9%0,&,2( #6&4064: 1# ;<;;=><"?< @A<AB CDA>EEC; 4F,-./0G246'9%*'H/ I/40 J* K-/. L#M# N402&'( J'$'4-9% K'06'- O4PQ6,0: R# =;SC">="DD @E?EB CSA>;"E; I/40*J*K-/.G04$4*2,T J,U'-6 V* W-4/0 1',-234 50$636/6' ,7 8'9%0,&,2( #6&4064: 1# ;<;;=><"?< @A<AB ;C?>S"E" -,U'-6*U-4/0G4'*246'9%*'H/ Abstract X8%3$ Q4Q'- Q-'$'06$ 4 &36'-46/-' $/-T'( ,0 $/Q'-$,039 -'6-,Q-,Q/&$3,0 6'9%0,&,2( 4$ 36 4QQ&3'$ 6, )4-$ '06-(: H'$9'06: 40H &40H302 @YVNB* 8%' -'&'T409' ,7 6%3$ 6'9%0,&,2( 6, 6%' 7'4$3U3&36( ,7 )4-$ YVN 3$ $%,Z0 6, 309-'4$' Z36% U4&&3$639 9,'77393'06 6, 6%' Q,306 6%46 36 3$ &3F'&( -'[/3-'H 7,- %/P40 )4-$ '\Q&,-463,0* 8%' /$' ,7 -'6-,Q-,Q/&$3,0 6, H'9'&'-46' 40 '06-( T'%39&' 7-,P %(Q'-$,039 ,- $/Q'-$,039 9,0H363,0$ 6, 4 $/U$,039 T'&,936( 3$ 6%' Q-3P4-( 7 ,9/$ ,7 6%3$ -'T3'Z* V3$9/$$'H 4-' $($6'P$> &'T'& $6/H3'$: 2'0'-4& 7&,Z73'&H 9%4-496'-3$639$: $64639 4'-,H(04P39$: T'%39&' 40H 7&,Z73'&H $64U3&36( 9,0$3H'-463,0$: 40H 4'-,6%'-P,H(04P39$* 8%' '\Q'-3P'064& 40H 9,PQ/6463,04& 4QQ-,49%'$ /$'H 6, H'T'&,Q -'6-,Q-,Q/&$3,0 6'9%0,&,2( 4-' 4&$, -'T3'Z'H* ]304&&(: 6%' 4QQ&394U3&36( 40H &3P36463,0$ ,7 6%' '\3$6302 &36'-46/-' 40H 9/--'06 $646'>,7>6%'> 4-6 9,PQ/6463,04& 6,,&$ 6, 7/6/-' P3$$3,0$ 4-' H3$9/$$'H 30 6%' 9,06'\6 ,7 %/P40 40H -,U,639 )4-$ '\Q&,-463,0* ":= TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION .......................... .............. ..............1 2 RETROPROPULSION SYSTEMS STUDIES ................2 3 GENERAL FLOW CHARACTERISTICS....................3 4 AERODYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS ......................6 5 AEROTHERMODYNAMIC CHARACTERISTICS .......9 6 EXPERIMENTAL SUMMARY.................................10 7 COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSES..............................11 8 CONCLUDING REMARKS .....................................12 REFERENCES .......................... .............. .............. .....13 BIOGRAPHIES .............. .............. ............................. .15 1 INTRODUCTION 50 P,$6 9/--'06 YVN $($6'P$: H'9'&'-46302 6%' T'%39&' 7-,P %(Q'-$,039 6, $/U$,039 $Q''H$ 3$ 49%3'T'H /$302 6%' 4'-,H(04P39 H-42 ,7 6%' '06-( T'%39&' 40H ,6%'- 4'-,H(04P39 H'9'&'-46,-$ $ /9% 4$ Q4-4 9%/6'$ ^"_* #6 )4-$: %32% '06-( P4$$'$ 40H 30$/77393'06 46P,$Q%'-39 H'0$36( ,76'0 -'$/&6 30 /0499'Q64U&' Q4-49%/6' H'Q&,(P'06 40H ,Q'-46302 9,0H363,0$* #0 4&6'-0463T' H'9'&'-463,0 4QQ-,49% 3$ 6, 3036346' -'6-,Q-,Q/&$3,0 Z%3&' 6%' T'%39&' 3$ $63&& 6-4T'&302 $/Q'-$,0394&&(* M/Q'-$,039 -'6-,Q-,Q/&$3,0 P4( U' 40 '04U&302 6'9%0,&,2( 7,- $($6'P$ Z36% %32% U4&&3$639 9,'77393'06$ ,Q'-46302 30 6%30 46 P,$Q%'-'$ $/9% 4$ 46 )4-$* " ">A=AA>"ACC>"`<C`a=?*<< b=<<C 5YYY* = 5YYY#K Q4Q'- c"=AS: R'-$3,0 "=: d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e'6 7&,Z 40H e'6>U,H( 306'-4963,0$ &43H 6%' 2-,/0HZ,-F 7,- 7/6/-' Z30H 6/00'& 6'$6302 ,7 $/Q'-$,039 0,..&' '\%4/$6 '77'96$ ,0 U,H( $/-749' Q- '$$/-' H3$6-3U/63,0$ 40H 7&,Z73'&H $ 64U3&36(* f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
