imaging the archimedes palimpsest• scholars can see where archimedes text is overwritten different...

73
Roger L. Easton, Jr. Chester F. Carlson Center for Imaging Science Rochester Institute of Technology Keith T. Knox Boeing LTS Maui, HI William A. Christens-Barry Equipoise Imaging and Johns Hopkins University Baltimore, MD Imaging of the Archimedes Imaging of the Archimedes Palimpsest: Lessons Learned Palimpsest: Lessons Learned

Upload: others

Post on 23-Feb-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Roger L. Easton, Jr.Chester F. Carlson Center for Imaging Science

Rochester Institute of Technology

Keith T. KnoxBoeing LTS

Maui, HI

William A. Christens-BarryEquipoise Imaging and Johns Hopkins University

Baltimore, MD

Imaging of the ArchimedesImaging of the Archimedes

Palimpsest: Lessons LearnedPalimpsest: Lessons Learned

Page 2: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

OutlineOutline

� Task

� Exploratory Investigations

� Evolution of Ideas, Advances inTechnology

� “Production” Multispectral Imaging• Constraints

• Procedure

• Results

• Image Stitching

• Access for Scholars

Page 3: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Task:Task:

� Imaging Techniques to Recover OriginalText• Collection of Images• Processing• Rendering

� Success Determined by Scholars• Improvement in Text “Readability”• Defer Efforts Toward “Reproduction”

� Importance of Cost• Equipment• Efficiency

Page 4: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

ExemplarsExemplarsto Illustrate Scope of Taskto Illustrate Scope of Task

Page 5: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

�������

Many Pages are in Good ConditionMany Pages are in Good Condition

Page 6: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

���������

Some are not!Some are not!

Page 7: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Mold DamageMold Damage

� Adjacent pages of quire

� “Split” at fold due to ageand use

� Mold has eaten throughparchments “in parallel”

��������

��������

Page 8: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Forged IconsForged Icons � After Heiberg’s examination,4 leaves were “re-erased”and painted over with iconsof the four Gospels

��� ���

Page 9: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

��������

Text in Gutter is DegradedText in Gutter is Degraded

Page 10: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Leaf 28VLeaf 28V

Archimedes text

Prayer booktext

Page 11: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Original Plan – Phase I, 2000Original Plan – Phase I, 2000

� Exploration of Task, Image 5 Single Leaves

� Propose Techniques to Apply in Phase II• RIT Team:

� Multispectral Imaging + Image Processing toDistinguish Over- and Underwritings

• JHU Team� Multispectral Imaging + Image Processing to

Obscure Overwriting

� Both Teams Used Ultraviolet Illumination toEnhance Contrast of Underwriting

Page 12: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Ultraviolet Fluorescent ImagingUltraviolet Fluorescent Imaging

UBlueFilter

Parchment

B

CameraSensor

UltravioletFluorescent Light

λ = 365 nm (LWUV)and 254 nm (SWUV)

U

B

Fluorescence inthe parchment

Page 13: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

RIT Digital CameraRIT Digital Camera

� SenSys™ fromPhotometrics, nowRoper Scientific

� Small Sensor (1536 ×1024 pixels)

� Filter Wheel

� Liquid-CrystalTunable Filter (LCTF)from CRI• ∆λ ≈ 10 nm• Measure Spectra of

Object Classes

Page 14: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Experimental Image CollectionExperimental Image CollectionWalters Art Museum, May 2000Walters Art Museum, May 2000

Page 15: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

SpectrometersSpectrometers� 5 Glass Bandpass Filters

• Passband width = 100 nm

• Astronomical Filter set: UBVRIC, only BVRIC used• Carried in “filter wheel” between lens and sensor

� Liquid-Crystal Tunable Filter (LCTF)• Vari-Spec™ from Cambridge Research and

Instrumentation (CRI)• 400 nm ≤ λ ≤ 720 nm, Passband ∆λ = 10 nm• 18 mm aperture

• Mounted “in front” of camera lens

Page 16: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Filter TransmittancesFilter Transmittances

Visible Light

UB V

R III

Wavelength (nm)

100

50

0

200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100

Tra

nsm

ittan

ce (

%)

Page 17: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Liquid Crystal Tunable FilterLiquid Crystal Tunable Filter

Wavelength (nm)

400 450 500 550 600 650 700

Tra

nsm

ittan

ce (

%)

10 nm

Tunable

Page 18: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

RIT Phase-I ImagingRIT Phase-I Imaging

� Both Spectrometers, Three Illuminations

� Two Image Sections Per Page• Digitally “Stitch” to Obtain Image of Full Page

� Low Spatial Resolution• ≈ 9 pixels per mm = 220 dpi

� “Custom” Image Registration• Images at Each Wavelength

Page 19: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

MultispectralMultispectral Images from Images from SenSysSenSys™™�����

���

��

��

��� ���� ��� ��

Page 20: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Spectral ResponsesSpectral Responses

� Ink Spectra are Similar

� Parchment Spectrum Dominates Ink

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27

Parchment

Archimedes

Prayerbook

�� �� � ��� �� ���

Page 21: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Spectral Signatures of Two InksSpectral Signatures of Two Inks

� Remove Parchment Spectrum (Normalize)

� Archimedes Ink is Brighter in “Red”

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27

Archimedes

Prayerbook

�� �� � ��� �� ���

Page 22: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

RIT Phase-I Image ProcessingRIT Phase-I Image ProcessingTechniques from Remote SensingTechniques from Remote Sensing� Principal Components

� Matched Spectral Filtering

� Least-Squares Supervised Segmentation• Linear Mixing Model

� Pixel Values are Mixtures of Spectra

� Record Images in Many Spectral Bands

� Spectral Unmixing� Determine Pixel Constituents

� Measured Spectral Signatures

� Pseudoinverse Solution

Page 23: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Principal Component Analysis in Principal Component Analysis in ENVIENVI®®� Software computes weighted sums of the

set of registered multispectral images

� Creates an “equivalent set” of 40 imagesordered by the existing variance in the data• Band 1 of the PCA image exhibits most of the

variation

• Band 40 is the combination with the leastvariation (generally the “noise” in the scene)

Page 24: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Two-Band Example of PCATwo-Band Example of PCA

Projection of Data onto PC1 contains most image varianceProjection of Data onto PC2 distinguishes between classes

Page 25: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Eigenvector Weights

-0.3

0

0.3B

430

B45

0

B47

0

B49

0

G49

0

G51

0

G53

0

G55

0

G57

0

G59

0

G61

0

R56

0

R58

0

R60

0

R62

0

R64

0

R66

0

R68

0

R70

0

Wavelength Band

We

ight

ing

Eigenvector 1 (Euchologion)

Eigenvector 2 (Archimedes)

Page 26: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

48R -- 248R -- 2ndnd Principal Component Principal Component

Page 27: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Comparison of “Comparison of “UncalibratedUncalibrated” Color” ColorImage 48R to PC-2Image 48R to PC-2

Page 28: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Minimum Noise FractionMinimum Noise Fraction

� Cascade of two PCAs

� Second “equates” parchment with noise

Page 29: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

48R Minimum Noise Fraction48R Minimum Noise Fraction

Page 30: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

48R, 48R, MahalanobisMahalanobis Classifier ClassifierThree Classes(1) Parchment(2) Euchologion(3) Archimedes

Two Classes(1) Archimedes(2) Other

Page 31: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Spectral “Matched Filtering”Spectral “Matched Filtering”

� “Supervised” Classification• Select Regions of Known

(1) Parchment(2) Euchologion(3) Archimedes Text

� Determine spectra for each known class

� Look for best “Match” of spectrum of each“unknown” pixel to the three “known” spectra

� Code each determined class as a “false color”

Page 32: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Preliminary Estimate of SpectraPreliminary Estimate of Spectra

Page 33: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

70V70V

Page 34: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Linear Mixing ModelLinear Mixing Model

r0

r1

r2•••

r

0123

spectral bands

E0

=

E00

E10

E20•••

E01

E11

E21•••

E02

E12

E22•••

E1

E2

a0

a1

a2•••

�Er =

Page 35: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Parchment/Ink Log ModelParchment/Ink Log Model

pixel value overwriting underwriting parchment= × ×

log pixel( ) = log overwriting( )+ log underwriting( )+ log parchment( )

� ri = log(pixel value)� Ei0 = log(overwriting)� Ei1 = log(underwriting)� Ei2 = log(parchment)

∑= jiji Er α

Page 36: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Spectral signatures

�Er =

( ) rEEE�TT 1−

=

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27

Par chm en t

Arc him ede s

Pra yer boo k

r

Pixel Value is Linear Combinationof Spectral Signatures

Determines Ink Fraction from PixelValue and Pseudoinverse Matrix

Least Squares Solution,Least Squares Solution,UnconstrainedUnconstrained

Page 37: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Output of Least-SquaresOutput of Least-SquaresSegmentationSegmentation

� Images of Each Object Class• Parchment

• Euchologion Text

• Archimedes Text

Page 38: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

70V Reconstructed Underwriting70V Reconstructed Underwriting

Visual Appearance Archimedes Text Channel

Page 39: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Underwriting on Leaf 70VUnderwriting on Leaf 70V

Page 40: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Underwriting “Channel” on Leaf 70VUnderwriting “Channel” on Leaf 70V

Page 41: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Images of Leaf 28VImages of Leaf 28V

Visible illumination Ultraviolet illumination Pseudoinverse model

Page 42: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Scholars Preferred UV ImagesScholars Preferred UV Images

Ultraviolet illumination Pseudoinverse Processing

������� ���

�� ��

Page 43: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Judgments of ScholarsJudgments of Scholars

Page 44: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Reason:Reason:

� Wished to See BOTH Texts• Distinguish Reason for Text “Gaps”

• Want “Enhanced” Visibility of Undertext Ratherthan “Removal” of Overtext

Page 45: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

JHU Phase-I ImagingJHU Phase-I Imaging

� Investigated SeveralWavelength Bands• Different Cameras

� Success with RGBDigital Camera +Different Illuminations• No Registration Required

Page 46: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

JHU Phase-I Image ProcessingJHU Phase-I Image Processing

� Combinations of Principal Components• Euchologion Text in 1st Principal Component

• Archimedes Text in PC #2+

� Use Thresholded PC#1 as Multiplicative“Mask”• Applied to Image with Archimedes Text

• Fill in “Space” with Parchment

• Produced a “Cookie-Cutter” Image

Page 47: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Proof of Concept, Early 2001Proof of Concept, Early 2001

� Observations• Tungsten “Red” Channel Shows Little

Archimedes text

• Ultraviolet “Blue” Shows Both Writings

� Processing Strategy• Encode Spectral Differences in Color to

Create “Pseudocolor” Images

Page 48: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Images Under Two IlluminationsImages Under Two Illuminations

Tungsten Ultraviolet

92v-93r

Page 49: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Color SeparationsColor Separations

Tungsten Red Ultraviolet Blue

92v-93r

Page 50: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

“Pushbutton” Processing“Pushbutton” Processing

� Observations:• Tungsten “Red” shows little Archimedes’ text

• Ultraviolet “Blue” shows both writings

� Processing Strategy:• Scale color separations to “cancel” Prayer Book

text

• Display difference of color channels asmonochrome image

Page 51: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Difference Image, 93v-92rDifference Image, 93v-92r

� Similar toleast-squaresresult

� “Gaps” whereprayer booktext removed

Page 52: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Production Imaging, Spring 2001+Production Imaging, Spring 2001+� Image all leaves w/ “point-and-shoot” camera

• Kodak DCS-760 professional digital camera

• 3 illuminations

• 3 spectral bands (Red, Green and Blue) perillumination

• Sufficient for about 80% of text

� Remote sensing algorithms do not work• too few spectral bands

� Simpler processing method required

Page 53: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Production Imaging Goals (Phase II)Production Imaging Goals (Phase II)� Conserve Manuscript

• Disbind (to Reveal Archimedes Text in Gutter)

• Clean (Grime, Wax Droplets from Candles)• Repair (Parchment Tears, Mold Damage)

� Image Entire Manuscript• 177 Leaves

� More than 5,000 digital images

• SIMPLIFY IMAGE PROCESSING• Estimate Useful Results for 80% of Text

� Process to Reveal Erased Text for Scholars• Images under Xenon Strobe to Record Visible Appearance

• Ultraviolet Images to Enhance Contrast of Erased Text• Pseudocolor Combination to Highlight Erased Text

Page 54: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Phase-II ImagingPhase-II Imaging

� RGB Digital Camera• “Large” Image Sensor (3K × 2K)

� Spatial Resolution ≈ 25 pixels per mm ≈ 600 dpi

� ⇒ ≈ 7500 × 5000 pixels per bifolium

� ⇒ 10 images per bifolium

• No Registration Problems

� Computer-Controlled Translation Table

� Three Illuminations• Xenon Strobe, Documents Visible Appearance

• Low-Wattage Tungsten

• LWUV (λ = 365 nm)

Page 55: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Production ImagingProduction Imaging� Computer-Controlled Translation Table

(XY + 2 Z Axes, for 2 Cameras)

� Custom Mattes

• Black Backing to Minimize Reflection

Page 56: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

� Photojournalists’ Digital Camera

• Kodak DCS 760

• RGB Color Filter Array over Sensor

• 3 Illuminations: UV, strobe, tungsten

• 10-bit TIFF Output

� Images are “Automatically” Registered

• Combined to Enhance Visibility of Text

� Bayer Color Filter Array

Image CaptureImage Capture

Page 57: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Automatic Grayscale NormalizationAutomatic Grayscale Normalization

3032 × 2008 image

400 × 400

Inside Sliding Window:Change Value of Center Pixel to Equalize

Mean and Variance in Window

Fast Rectangular AverageAccesses Each Pixel Only 4 Times

Instead of 160,000

15 Seconds Instead of “Days”

Normalized Red and BlueImagesRed Blue

Page 58: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

PseudocolorPseudocolor Image Processing Image Processing

� Use same two separations as “Pushbutton”

� Encode differences in color

� Goal• Retain Prayer Book text

� Eliminate gaps in text

• Produce color difference between two texts� “pseudocolor” images

Page 59: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Separations Separations ⇒⇒ Color Channels Color Channels

������

�����

�������

���������

������

�������

��

��

��

Page 60: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Difference Image vs. Difference Image vs. PseudocolorPseudocolor

�� ���

��������� ������

Page 61: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Pseudocolor ResultsPseudocolor Results

48r

Page 62: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Text in Gutter of Prayer BookText in Gutter of Prayer Book

166v-167r

Page 63: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Pseudocolor ProcessingPseudocolor Processing

166v-167r

Page 64: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Summary of Pseudocolor ImagingSummary of Pseudocolor Imaging

� Shows Both Texts• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten

� Different Texts Shown in Different Colors• Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts• Increase in Text Contrast

� Both Color and Gray

� Scholars Use “Pseudocolor” Images to ReadErased Archimedes Text

Page 65: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Stitching SoftwareStitching Software� “Stitcher” (RealViz, France)

• Intended for Electronic Media Industry

• Simple and “Fast” (≈ 20 minutes per page)

• Rotates and Blends “Automatically”

� “DIME” (Positive Systems, Whitefish MT)• Developed for Remote Sensing

• User Sets “Tie Points”

• Image is “Warped” to Fit

• User Intensive, Longer Time, More Expensive� “Pay by the Page”

Page 66: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Problem: “Topography” of PageProblem: “Topography” of Page

AB

C

A B C

A B C

Image 1

Image 2

⇒Spatial “Warping” that must be corrected

1 2

Page 67: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Stitcher DIME 143r-146v

Page 68: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Stitcher ↑ DIME ↓

Effect of Topography on StitchingEffect of Topography on Stitching

Page 69: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Stitching PlansStitching Plans

� Restitch “bad” pages with DIME

Page 70: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Distribution of Images to ScholarsDistribution of Images to Scholars

� 2002• 30 bifolia

• 120 pages

• 1.7 GBytes per bifolium

� Media• 11”×17” double-sided prints

• CD-ROMs (90 per set!)

• DVDs

• Disk Drives� Web-based image navigator

Page 71: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

New Web BrowserNew Web Browser

� Advantages:• Multiple Pages Open at Same Time

• Direct Access to Other Side of Bifolium

• Pan and Zoom Capability

Page 72: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

New Browser WindowsNew Browser Windows

SelectSelect

Page 73: Imaging the Archimedes Palimpsest• Scholars Can See Where Archimedes Text is Overwritten Different Texts Shown in Different Colors • Easily Distinguish Between Two Texts • Increase

Image Selection in New BrowserImage Selection in New Browser