implementation roadmap: identifying stakeholders … · 4.3.4.1 to produce accurate automated bill...
TRANSCRIPT
PERPUSTAKAAN UMP
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 0000092460
MALAYSIAN BUILDING INFORMATION MODELLING (BIM)
IMPLEMENTATION ROADMAP: IDENTIFYING STAKEHOLDERS INTEREST
NOR AINI BINTI ABDUL
Report submitted in fulfilment of the requirements
for the award of the degree of
B.ENG. (HON S.) CIVIL ENGINEERING
Faculty Of Civil Engineering And Earth Resources
UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA PAHANG
JULY 2014
ABSTRACT
Building Information Modelling (BIM) is an approach in which utilise a 3D parametric modelling as a primary technology. The approach brings many advantages and has attracted many players in Malaysian Construction industry and has led the industry to develop a roadmap to strategize the implementation. The roadmap is important to coordinate many activities amongst the industry groups working with adopters of BIM in Malaysia. The aim of the study is to support the development of BIM national roadmap by providing the data of the stakeholders' Interest of BIM implementation at the industrial level. Research methodology used in this research is qualitative in nature by engaging a workshop. The workshop was organised by Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) Malaysia. In the workshop, six groups of stakeholders were formed to provide data and information regarding to the stakeholders' interest for BIM implementation. The stakeholders were academics, vendor & BIM consultant, facilities management, contractor & quantity surveyor, design consultant and public agency. Result from the workshop shows that the stakeholders interest basically tied to the three main objectives of construction delivery which are the quality, cost and time. Combining all the interests, 47 factors of interests were identified with some of them are overlapped between one stakeholders to another. Based on the occurrence that takes place during the discussion, the most discussed factors are the accuracy of BIM data, reduction of delivery time and improve understanding of the project information.
vi
vii
ABSTRAK
Permodelan Bangunan Bermaklumat (BIM) merupakan satu pendekatan yang menggunakan model parametrik 3D sebagai teknologi utama. Pendekatan mi membawa banyak kebaikan dan telah menarik ramai golongan professional dalam industri pembinaan Malaysia dan mi sekaligus telah membawa industri untuk membangunkan pelan tmdakan bagi menyusun strategi pelaksanaan. Pelan hala tuju adalah penting untuk menyelaras pelbagai aktiviti di kalangan kumpulan mdustri pembinaan di dalam pelaksanaan BIM di Malaysia. Tujuan kajian mi adalah untuk menyokong pembangunan pelan hala tuju BIM negara dengan menyediakan data berkaitan faktor galakan yang menarik minat pemam industri pembmaan untuk melaksanakan BIM. Kajian mi menggunakan metodologi kualitatifbengkel industri bagi mendapatkan data. Bengkel mi dianjurkan oleh Lembaga Pembangunan Industri Pembmaan (CIDB) Malaysia. Dalam bengkel tersebut, sebanyak enam kumpulan telah dibentuk untuk berbincang dan menyediakan makiumat mengenai matlamat dan minat terhadap pelaksanaan BIM. Kumpulan yang dibentuk ialah akademik, vendor & perunding BIM, pengurusan fasiliti, kontraktor & ukur bahan, perunding reka bentuk dan agensi awam. Keputusan daripada bengkel tersebut menunjukkan bahawa mmat dan matlamat pemain industri pada dasarnya tenkat kepada tiga objektif utama pembinaan iaitu kualiti, kos dan masa. Sebanyak 47 faktor mmat telah dikenal pasti dengan sebahagian daripada factor berkenaan adalah bertindih antara satu sama lain. Berdasarkan kepada perbincangan berkenaan, faktor ketepatan data BIM, pengurangan masa penghantaran dan memngkatkan pemahaman mengenai makiumat projek merupakan faktor utama pelaksanaan BIM dalam industri pembinaan.
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUPERVISOR DECLARATION
STUDENT'S DECLARATION DEDICATION iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENT v
ABSTRACT vi ABSTRAK vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS viii
LIST OF FIGURES xii
LIST OF TABLES xiii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xiv
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of Research 1
1.2 Problem Statement 2
1.3 Aim & Objective of Research 2
1.4 Scope of Study 3
1.5 Thesis Outline 3
CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction 4
2.2 DefmitiOn of Building Information Modelling (BIM) 4
2.3 Building Information Modellmg (BIM) Concept 7
2.4 MotivaticinforBIM Implementation 11
2.4.1 Commuñicäte the Design Intent Better 11
2.4.2 Reducing the Knowledge Gap between Junior and Senior 11
Staff
2.4.3 Reducing Risk of Losing Project's Information 11
2.4.4 Process Streamline and Time Saving 12
CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction 13 3.2 Preliminary Study 15 3.3 Area of focus and concept development 15 3.4 Research Design and Development 15
ix
35 Exploratory Data Collection 16
3.6 Data analysis and validation 16
CHAPTER 4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1 -'Introduction. 17
4.2 Result Analysis 18
4.3 Stakeholders' Interest 18
4.3.1 Developer 22
4.3.1.1 To optimize. the time to deliver project . 22
4.3.1.2 To increase industry of project information and design interest 23
4.3.1.3 To increase the quality of project 23
4.3.1.4 To reduce the cost of project implementation 23
4.3.1.5 . To reduce V.0 and error during construction stage 24
4.3.1.6 To standardize the process flow of information 24
4.3.1.7 To increase the return of asset 24
4.3.1.8 To assist in get informed decision 25
4.3.2 Design Consultant 26
4.3.2.1 To improve the collaborative design process 26
4.3.2.2 Consistency of the data and information in the model 27
4.3.2.3 Seamless data and information exchange among stakeholders 27.
4.3.2.4 Centralised database (model) to share and restore information 27
43.2.5 To maximize the analysis- usage and potential use of
mformation in BIM model 28
4.3.2.6 To deliver model oriented'working flow 28
4.3.2.7 To increase productivity 28
4.3.2.8 To have better understanding of the project information and
design intent . . 29
4.3.2.9 To reduce the cost operation by optimize the use of manpower 29
4.3.3 Vendor & BIM Consultant 30
4.3.3.1 To define BIM function in the industry 30
4.3.3.2 To educate industry about BIM concept 30
4.3.3.3 To provide platform and technical advice about collaboration 31
4.3.3.4 Train the industry and user 31
4.3.3.5 To define the roles for BIM associated post 32
x
4.3.4 Contractor & Quantity Surveyor 33
4.3.4.1 To produce accurate automated Bill of Quantities 33
4.3.4.2 Accelerate the taking off process 34
4.3.4.3 To better understand the information to construct the building 34
4.34.4 To simplify the Standard Measurement Method 34
4.3.4.5 To have better administer the contract and project 34
documentation
4.3.4.6 To improves control over scope time, cost and quantity 35
4.3.4.7 To reduce the cost 35
4.3.4.8 To minimize the RFI, V.0, clash during the construction stage 35
43.4.9 To have better visualization of design and construction 36
4.3.4.10 Collaboration at early stage among the project participant 36
4.3.4.11 4D modeling to simulate the construction sequence 36
4.3.5 Facilities Management 37
4.3.5.1 To get accurate data and information to be used in facilities 37
management
4.3.5.2 To reduce the cost of operation during facilities management 37
4.3.5.3 To have better technical library requirement 38
4.3.5.4 To reduce the source time. 38
4.3.6 Academics 39
4.3.6.1 To be used as technology to assist teaching 39
4 3 6 2 To help the industry by conducting BIM related research 40 4'16.3 6 3 To equip the student with BIM added value 40
4.3.6.4 To supply the industry with BIM competent personal 41
4.3.7 . Public Agency 42
4.3.7.1 To support national agenda in Construction Industry Master
Plan (CIMP2) 42
4.3.7.2 To change the game in construction industry by delivering
cutting edge technology 43
4.3.7.3 BIM as a source of economic growth 43
4.3.7.4 To improves the project delivery in cost, time and quality 43
4.3.7.5 To support green and sustainability agenda 43
4.3.7.6 To produce high income professional in line with national
xi
agenda to become high income nation 44
CHAPTER 5 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
5.1 Introduction 45
5.2 Conclusion 45
5.3 Recommendation 50
REFERENCES 51
APPENDICES 54
A Transcribed Data Malaysian BIM Implementation Roadmap: 54
Identifying Stakeholders' Interests Workshop
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No. Title Page
2.3
BIM Process Cycle 10
3.1
Researàh Methodology 14
4.2
List of Stakeholders' 18
4.3.1
List of Developer Interest 22
4.3.2
List of Design Consultant Interest 26
4.3.3
List of Vendor & BIM Consultant Interest 30
4.3.4
List of Contractor & Quantity Surveyor Interest 33
4.3.5
List of Facilities Management Interest 37
4.3.6
List of Academic Interest 39
4.3.7
List of Public Agency Interest 42
xl'
LIST OF TABLES
Table No. Title Page
4.3 StakehOIder.Interests of BIM Implementation 19
5.2 Stakeholder Interests of BIM Implementation 47
xlii
LIST OF ABBREVIATION
2D 2•dimensional
3D 3. dimensional
4D 4 dimensional.
5D 5 dimensional
BEM Board of Engineers Malaysia
BIM Building InfOrmatiOn Modelling
CAD Computer Aided Design
CIDB Construction Industry Development Board
CIMP Construction Industry Master Plan
EPU Economic Planning Unit
FM Facilities Management
JKR Jabatan Kerja Raya
KPI Key Performance Indicator
LOD Level of Development
MEP Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing
M&E Mechanical & Electrical
PDM Project Document Management
PRIMA Perbadanan Rumah 1 Malaysia
QS Quantity Surveyor
RFI Request For Inspection
RISM Royal Institute of Surveying Malaysia
ROA Return of Assets
SMM Standard Measurement Method
VO Verification Order••
xlv
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND OF RESEARCH
Building Information Modelling (BIM) is now become natural phenomenon in
construction industry in Malaysia. BIM utilize 3D parametric object tools which give
more advantages to the user. In order to maximise the benefit of BIM, at the national
level a roadmap is important as one of the strategies to implement BIM. The
importance lies on the need to coordinate many activities amongst the industry
stakeholders working with BIM adopters in Malaysia.
On July 24th, 2013 at CIDB Malaysia headquarters in Putra World Trade
Centre, Kuala Lumpur the first meeting was held to establish BIM Steering Committee
at the national level, which was officiated by the Chief Executive Officer of CIDB
Malaysia, Dato' Sri Jr. Dr. Judin Abdul Karim The meeting was chaired by Dato' Jr.
Hj Salehudin Bin Mohd Isa, Senior Director of Cawangan Pengurusan Projek
Kompleks, Jabatan Kerja Raya (JKR) Malaysia and attended by industrial participants
representing Persatuan Arkitek Malaysia, Board of Engineers Malaysia (BEM), Royal
Institute of Surveying Malaysia (RISM), PRiMA, Sime Darby Properties, Economic
Planning Unit (EPU'), Academician from Local Universities etc. The establishment of
the steering committee is to undertake a huge and critical task to oversee and manage
the adoption and implementation of BIM in Malaysia.
1
2
1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT
The key objective of the roadmap is to coordinate the many activities amongst
the industry groups working with adopters of BIM in Malaysia, which unless
coordinated, have the potential to be overlapping, or a duplication of resources,
technically different and incompatible, and not comprising a complete enough solution
that will benefit the Malaysian Construction sector. Many private organisations and
government agencies have interests in the National BIM Roadmap and will identify
stakeholders to ensure a representative position is taken across the industry in
Malaysia. This will not only include direct BIM users, but also take into account Local
Government, the need for coordination with the Infrastructure sector, government
agencies such as major facility procurers - PRiMA, Health, EPU - and agencies
responsible for Geo-spatial data, land information etc.
The roadmap consists of four major elements which are Stakeholders' Interest,
Stakeholders' Objectives, Key milestone and KPI platform. The Stakeholders' Interest
are crucial in the development of the roadmap as all the motivation, expectation and
problems associated with the construction industry and BIM are tied to it. Therefore, a
study must be conducted to explore and identify the stakeholders' Interest and was set
as the main.
1.3 AIM & OBJECTIVE OF RESEARCH
The aim of the study is to support the development of BIM national roadmap by
providing the data of the stakeholders' Interest and Objectives of BIM implementation
at the industrial level. The objectives of the study are:
1. To explore, appraise and systhesise relevant literature related to BIM with
specific focus on the concept, usage, implementation requirement and success factors
2. To explore, appraise and systhesise relevant literature related to roadmap
development with specific focus on the stakeholders' interest.
3. To explore and identify the stakeholders' interest'.
3
1.4 SCOPE OF STUDY
The scope of the study is important as a guidance to minimize the area to focus
on the research. For this research there are three main scope of study need to focus on.
1. Phase of Lifecycle - Construction Lifecycle
2. Level of Implementation - Operational Level
3. Stakeholders' Interest - Industrial Level
1.5 THESIS OUTLINE
This thesis consists of five chapters. Every chapter consists of the subsections
which need to focus on. The five chapters consist of;
Chapter 1 explained the background of research, problem statement, aim and
objective, scope of research and the thesis outline.
Chapter 2 explained about the literature review. This chapter explained about the first
objective which is to explore, appraise and systhesise relevant literature related to BIM
with specific focus on the concept, usage, implementation requirement and success
factors.
Chapter 3 explained about the research design & methodology to produce this
research. In this section every part of methodology use in this research is explained
from the preliminary of study till the data validation.
Chapter 4 explained about the result and analysis of the case study findings of
stakeholders' interest during the workshop. This chapter also fulfill the second and
third objective of the research which is to explore, appraise and systhesise relevant
literature related to roadmap development with specific focus on the stakeholders'
interest and lastly to explore and identify the stakeholders' interest.
Chapter 5 explained about the conclusion and recommendation of the research. In this
chapter also the summary of research was discussed.
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter discussed about the preliminary study of the research with the
related literature review. This chapter also discussed about the first objective of the
research which is to explore, appraise and systhesise relevant literature related to BIM
with specific focus on the concept, usage, implementation requirement and success
factors. In addition in this chapter also focus on the motivation for BIM
implementation.
2.2 DEFINITION OF BUILDING INFORMATION MODELLING (BIM)
BIM is modeling technology and associated set of processes to produce,
communicate and analyze digital information models for construction life-cycle
(Steering Committee, 2013). In another view, R. Vanlande et al. ( 2008) state that
Building Information Modeling (BIM) is defined as the process of generating, storing,
managing, exchanging, and sharing building information in an interoperable and
reusable way. According to Gu & London (2010), Building information modeling
(BIM) is an IR-based approach that involves applying and maintaining an integral
digital representation of all building information for different phases of the project
lifecycle in the form of a data repository. From the other view, BIM refers to a set of
interacting policies, processes and technologies that generate a methodology to manage
the essential building design and project data in digital format throughout the building's
life-cycle (Succar, 2012). In addition in the book of BIM Handbook;
5
According to Eastman (2008) the 3D parametric tool has the following characteristic;
1) Consisting of a geometric definition and associated data and rules;
2) Geometry is integrated non-redundantly and allows for no inconsistencies. When
an object is shown in 31), the shape cannot be represented internally
redundantly, for example as multiple 2D views. A plan and elevation of a given
object must always be consistent. Dimensions cannot be fudged.
3) Parametric rules for objects automatically modify associated geometries when
inserted into a building model or when changes are made to associated objects.
For example, a door will fit automatically into a wall, a light switch will
automatically locate next to the proper side of the door, a wall will automatically
resize itself to automatically butt to a ceiling or roof, etc.
4) Objects can be defined at different levels of aggregation, so the user can define a
wall as well as its related components. Objects can be defined and managed at
any number of hierarchy levels. For example, if the weight of a wall
subcomponent changes, the weight of the wall should also change.
5) Object rules can identify when a particular change violates object
feasibility regarding size, manufacturability, etc.
6) Objects have the ability to link to or receive, broadcast or export sets of
attributes, e.g. structural materials, acoustic data, energy data, etc. to other
applications and models.
Based on the statement by Eastman et al. (2011), BIM is 3D Parametric
Modeling that gives a lot of benefit to the construction industry. This proved by the
other source, the US National Institute for Building Sciences has given a following
vision and a definition for BIM. According to Eastman et al. (2011), BIM is "an
improved planning, design, construction, operation, and maintenance process using a
standardized machine-readable information model for each facility, new or old, which
contains all appropriate information created or gathered about the facility in a format
usable by all throughout its lifecycle."
6
According to the National Institute of Building Science (2007:12) Building
Information Modelling (BIM) is defined as "a digital representation of physical and
functional characteristics of a facility and a shared knowledge resource for information
about a facility forming a reliable basis for decisions during its life-cycle." The
definition however, appears to be generic to include any digital technology as long as it
could contribute to form information on a facility. As further explained by Onuma in
Smith & Tardif (2009), a spread sheet of spatial data is a building information model
and if the use of alphanumeric data contained in the spread sheet is to simulate an actual
business process in the life cycle of a building, then a Building Information Modelling is
engaged. The generic definition of Building Information Modelling is also supported
by Jernigan (2007) by pointing out that the interactions of spread sheets with the
complexity and an interrelationship of organisation is also Building Information
Modelling.
Within the context of Malaysia, Haron (2013) has defined BIM as an approach
to building design and construction through modelling technology, an associated set of
processes and people to produce, communicate and analyse building information
models. The definitions sets a boundary to differentiate BIM with other technologies
such as 2D/3D vector based means of creating objects, and 3D surface modelling
which is used for the purpose of visualisation only, which carries no attribute to the
element and therefore complemented by the definition of Building Information Model
which is defined by Kymmel (2008) as digital representation of physical and functional
characteristics of a facility where the information is contained or attached to the
component of the model. In both definition, the 3D parametric tools is identified as
main BIM tools as has been defined by Eastman et al. (2011) earlier in this subchapter.
Meanwhile, at the national level, according to CIDB (2013), the steering committee has
established the definition to be used by the industry. They define BIM as Modelling
Technology and associated set of processes to produce, communicate and analyze
digital information models for the construction life-cycle.
2.3 BUILDING INFORMATION MODELLING (BIM) CONCEPT
BIM concept is differed with 2D Computer Aided Design (CAD). In the CAD
approach, the focus is given on the drawings production. Contrary with the CAD
approach, the focus of BIM is centred on the 3D BIM models. The models become the
main deliverables where they are first authored before project information can be
extracted from the model. Therefore, the project information are centralised and
coordinated within the same source of model and the model itself becoming the
database of project information (Hardin, 2009). The examples of project information
are the drawings, bill of quantity, specifications and etc. Since the project information
is sourced from the same model, they are all consistent and accurate where changes on
the model will automatically change the interrelated drawings and specification. Within
this approach, the heart of BIM lies on the use of 3D parametric tools. According to
Smith &Tardif (2009) the concept of Building Information Modelling is to build a
building virtually, prior to building it physically, in order to work out problems and
simulate and analyse potential impacts. The heart of Building Information Modelling
lies in an authoritative building information model.
According to Kymmel (2008) virtual building implies that it is possible to
practice construction, to experiment and to make adjustments in the project before it is
constructed. Virtual mistakes generally do not have serious consequences provided that
they are identified and addressed early enough so that they can be avoided in the actual
construction of the project. When a project is planned and built virtually, most of its
relevant aspects can be considered and communicated before the instructions for
construction are fmalized. It is like running a simulation of a construction project by
considering all aspects of the construction life cycle.
In terms of the types of information or data that can be derived within a
Building Information Model, generally, Elvin (2007) and Hardin (2008) explained that
a Building Information Model could provide 2-D and 3D drawing with non-graphical information including specifications, cost data, scope data, and schedules. Kymmel
(2008) on the other hand, categorised several types of information within Building Information Model based on the nature of the link between information and the model.
7
8
This pertains to all information that is part of, or connected to, the components as well
as the physical information inherent in the model itself such as size, location, etc. It is
important that all information required in making an actual analysis be available from
the BIM. The categories of information, as can be summarised from Kymmel (2008) is
as follows:
a) Component Information
Component information is the basic information contained in the 3D model file
where it provides visual information and resides in the nature of the model part
itself. Components in a 3D model also have specific locations in relation to an
origin and to one another. An example of component information is a wall with
material information or quantitative information such as part numbers.
b) Parametric Information
Parametric Information is information contained in the parametric object which
can be edited. It is embedded in the object and the model. Some of this
information can be graphical, while much of it can also be intellectual, such as
area, volume or material-32 related qualities, such as density (providing weight
based on the geometry of the object), R value, etc.
c) Linked Information
Linked Information refers to information that is actually not part of the model,
but is connected to the model through external links. Visible links can be
"flags" that will open a window or file when clicked to display that file.
Invisible links could be, for example, connections to a database with cost
information. When two files are linked, changes in one will result in adaptations
in the other linked file, and vice versa.
d) External Information
External Information refers to information that is generated separate from the
BIM, such as manufacturers" specifications of products. External information
may be linked to the model or remain autonomous. It is possible to provide a
reference to a catalogue without creating a link to an electronic file. Since not all
9
information will be available in a compatible format it may be necessary to keep
it accessible in printed form such as an external reference.
Elvin (2007) further added that another important feature of Building
information Modelling is how it creates an object-oriented database, meaning that it is
made up of intelligent objects, for example representation of doors, windows, and walls
which are capable of storing both quantitative and qualitative information about the
project. So while a door represented in a 2D CAD drawing is just a collection of lines,
in BIM it is an intelligent object containing information On its size, cost, manufacturer,
schedule and more. But BIM goes further by creating a relational database. This means
that all information in the BIM is interconnected, and when a change is made to an
object in the database, all other affected areas and objects are immediately updated. For
example, if a wall is deleted, doors and windows within the wall are also deleted and
all data on project scope are instantly adjusted.
To extend the application of Building Information Modelling to integrated
practice in construction, according to Eastman et al. (2008), the building information
model should be used as a building model repository. A building model repository is a
database system whose schema is based on an object based format. It is different from
existing Project Document Management (PDM) systems and web-based project
management systems in that the PDM systems are file based and carry CAD and
analysis package project files. Building model repositories are object based, allowing
query, transfer, updating and management of individual project objects from a
potentially heterogeneous set of applications. In this context, the integration occurs at
the level of data and could also integrate with other dimensions such as the time
dimension (schedule) and cost dimension, which are known as 4D and 5D modelling
respectively (Zhou et al., 2009; Koo & Fischer, 2000, Dawood & Sikka, 2007; Fischer
& Kam, 2001). This application would allow construction phases to be analysed early
in the design phase which as a result could support early involvement of the contractors in design development.
10
Figure 2.0 shows the concept of whole BIM process cycle. The BIM process
cycle is take place in every part of the project from the conceptual design till the
demolition process.
Figure 2.3: BIM Process Cycle
Source: BlMsolutions
2.4 MOTIVATION FOR BIM IMPLEMENTATION
The BIM Industry Working Group indicates that there are substantial
organisational impacts through BIM implementation for all stages of the construction
process. (Arayici et. Al, 2011). BIM is another key aspect leading to similar improved
accuracy, design and construction is 3D visualisation. (BIMhub, 2012). The benefits of
using BIM is one of the motivation why our construction industry and government
eager to implement BIM. The implementation of BIM brings a lot of benefits. The
benefits are better communication of design intent, knowledge gap reduction between
junior and senior staff, reduced risk of losing project information process; it was
11
streamline, and time saving. The details of the benefits are further discussed in the
following subchapter as adcording 'to Haron (2013)
2.4.1 Communicate the Design Intent Better
All of the interviewees agreed that the implementation of 3D parametric
modelling tools as part of BIM has improved the communication of design intent that
takes place within and outside the organisational boundary. The improvement lies on
the 3D visualisation and drawings consistency where everyone involved has the same
understanding of what is being designed.
2.4.2 Reducing the Knowledge Gap between Junior and Senior Staff
The BIM implementation reduce knowledge gap between junior and senior staff
as compared to using the 21) approach alone. The main reason is the fundamental
nature of 31) modelling where each component is represented with digital 31)
objects that carry attributes and parametric, rules. The tools have assisted the junior
designer to understand every component that they are authoring by providing 3D
visualisation and the attributes that. need "to be assigned. In 2D approach on the
other hand, every
object is made of a collection of lines and requires the designers interpretation and
imagination to define what the object is. The 21) approach therefore requires a longer
technical site experience to understand each component and its attributes and thus
makes it difficult for the junior staff with a lack of experience. Furthermore, the 3D
modelling tool has enabled the junior staff to try and experiment with the design
which helps a lot in sharpening their skills and understanding.
2.4.3 Reducing Risk of Losing Project's Information
BIM help to keep the structure of the projects data and information in .a
digital repository.: somebody in charge is moving out, the newcomer can
simply refer to the BIM database and continue the job from there.
12
2.4.4 Process Streamline and Time Saving
In previous CAD-based process flows, one of the biggest challenges
faced by the industry is to ensure drawings consistency and clash free design.
The massive number of drawings that were produced individually in a project has
made document consistency and clash checking a very time consuming and tedious
process through the manual approach. Therefore, most of the time was spent on
documentation and checking rather than focusing on the aspect of engineering and
design. With the implementation of BIM, since the virtual 3D model is the source for
all drawings, design errors caused by inconsistent drawings are all eliminated.
Meanwhile, the clash checking process and Material Taking Off are taken
automatically by using the software which also shortens the time duration. As an
overall result, the time spent for documentation, checking and taking off material is
reduced significantly and the people can give extra focus to the aspect of
engineering and design. Thus, the company has managed to streamline the process
flow and save time.
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 INTRODUCTION
Research methodology is important and it is refer as the procedure to develop
the research. This statement had been explained by Fellows & Liu (2007), "research
methodology refers to the principles and procedures of logical thought process which
are applied to a scientific investigation." The procedure of the project had been
explored before the research start to ensure that the research achieved their goal. In this
research there are five stages of methodology used, there are;
First stage - Preliminary Study
Second stage -Area of focus andconcept development
Third stage - Research Design and Devôlopment
Fourth stage - Exploratory Data Collection
Fifth stage - Data analysis and validation
This five stages of research methodology will be explained further in the next
subsection. The figure below shows that overall stage involved in this research.
13
I S I •C.;
-
I.E) I ..
f)i • U o
ft ) t4
[I Ut ii: 1HI
C 90
0 0
' - 1)
lu ' ---
t_ uc_ 0'O 0 W—. jI •_Ic
- U). P1 &•55
-.
'C
= .2
l C c
C
r.
H,C 1:1 . WJ C14
.
• 2 o
I.-. . 0
.0
0 0 -
C
C
C
0
(ID a)
U ti U) E -C U C .0 )11 -• .,0.
0 . Ao
-._' 0 t.I Oo
.0 -. U).9.0 .) = U)
ftTh