ipa Í # h nm ¡ = l - $ s m ; o r $ 0 Î ï 7 ( t r · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t...

37
IPAǍȏȣɈȑɎmơĝȽɌȚȭȐȤɓ ɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰǎǯȷȨɔɒ 20138Þ27Ó UVĨȗɎȪɈɔɑɔȚȤ 2VŚ ãô ø

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

IPAǍȏȣɈȑɎmơĝȽɌȚȭȐȤɓɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰǎǯȷȨɔɒ�

2013�8Þ27Ó*

UV�ĨȗɎȪɈɔɑɔȚȤ*

2V�Śƺãôƺø­�

Page 2: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ġĠ�

•  ġĠ*

–  ďĭŘÇþ�§p7ĒÂƑõð(IPA)*NjȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵênjɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰdzð­ȌĤȇLjÿĖǮǖȈȅǑDzDZȈlj*

–  ȷȨɔɒǯLjȷȨɔɒȌÀĖǠǧĒėȌĤȇLjőȆdz��qȂȽɐȣȓȚȯDzǓǚȈ÷dzȤȭȫȽǹƑǿħ`Ȍ Ȉlj*

•  �ŸŌ*

–  ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝdz�/ȌìŦǠǭǐȈȧȻȯȒȓȏơĝDzƣ&ǢȈÐlj*

•  4�*

–  Ŭ�ŵêdzɍȻȎɒɏɒȤȘȑȰdzïŝǯÿĖÐþȌűÖǢȈlj*–  ȷȨɔɒǯLjȷȨɔɒȌƗĖǠǧĒėȌűÖǢȈlj*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿ�August*27,*2013�

ãżÍǴLjƺIPA*NjȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵênjȌLĊɓ�ĖǠǭǐǽǢlj*

Page 3: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈ*ȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵêǯǴ�

•  2013�3Þ1ơ*

Džj4ǮȏȣɈȑɎmơĝdzÿĖǕƑǿ.ƷĠ�ídz59�dzȽɌȚȭȐȤdz>ĖĎýȌŵêLj9ƵǠLjȽɌȚȭȐȤdzȽɐȣȓȚȯşóȂȏȣɈȑɎmơĝdzīƵDZǰDzȅȈƗĖĎýdzƖǐLjƗĖǢȈqUdz�zĄ̑ĈDZǰDzǫǐǭLjŵêpZÛǯɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰɖ��ãȘȑȰɗǯǠǭǽǯȀǽǠǧdž*hAp://www.ipa.go.jp/sec/reports/20130319.html*

*

•  1ơǞȉǭǐȈżÍ*

– ŵêïŝpZÛƺɖ39ȿɔȣɗ*– ŵêpZÛƺŵêńLJɖ49ȿɔȣɗ*– ŵêpZÛƺȘȑȰńƺɖ231ȿɔȣɗ*–  ɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*(Word��Lj*

*ȚɍȔȑȭȐȼɓȞɇɒȥɓɌȑȦɒȤɗ*

*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ǀ�

SEC Software Engineering for Mo䡡No䡡Zu䡡Ku䡡Ri

Software Engineering Center 10

ᛦ௹ݣᝋ (3)

Copyright © 2013 IPA, All Rights Reserved.

ࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺ 5

8% ,ࡓ

㒊ࡢ࡞ 4

ศࡃ࠺

42% ,ࡓࡗ࠸

ࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺ 3

ࡀ࠶㠃ࡓ

ࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺

࠶㠃࠸࡞࠸

23% ,

㒊ࡢ࡞ 2

ศ࠸ࡃ࠺

,ࡓࡗ࡞

4%

0 ᮍᅇ⟅, 23%

ᡂຌᗘ (n=26)

ᛦ௹ݣᝋểễỦἩἿἊỹἁἚỉыࡇᵹḤᵏᵻỆếẟềẆˌɦỉ5െ᨞ỂሉửࢽẺẇ

z5ᾉạộẪẟẾẺ

z4ᾉẦễụỉᢿЎỂạộẪẟẾẺ

z3ᾉạộẪẟẾẺờẝỦầạộẪẟẾềẟễẟờẝỦ

z2ᾉẦễụỉᢿЎỂạộẪẟẦễẦẾẺ

z1ᾉạộẪẟẦễẦẾẺ

ẐạộẪẟẾẺẑờẲẪỊẐẦễụỉᢿЎỂạộẪẟẾẺẑểሉẲẺҞૠửҩỜỦἩἿἊỹἁἚỆấẟềỊẆɼỆἩἻἁἘỵἋỉஊјễМဇửӓᨼẲẺẇ

ộẺẆẐɥẪẟẾẺờẝỦầạộẪẟẾềẟễẟờẝỦẑẆẐẦễụỉᢿЎỂạộẪẟẦễẦẾẺẑỆᛆẴỦኖ1/4ỉሉẦỤỊẆɼỆἩἻἁἘỵἋửဇẴỦᨥỉသໜửӓᨼẲẺẇ

ḤᵏᴾыỉࡇݿểẲềỊˌɦỉᚇໜửẝậỦ˖ಅầٶẦẾẺẇ

zỆểẾềỉἥἊἋὉМỉ᭗ẟἉἋἘἲửỂẨẺẦᾎ

zẦỤỉᙲ൭ỉΪឱࡇầ᭗ẦẾẺẦᾎỉஓớἉἋἘἲầỂẨẺẦᾎ

zဇݣјௐầ᭗ẪẆἲἒỉễẟầỂẨẺẦᾎ

zឱࡇὉᎍឱࡇầ᭗ẦẾẺẦᾎ

zỉӋဒࡇầ᭗ẦẾẺẦᾎẦỤỉửࢽỂẨẺẦᾎ

zἳὅἘἜὅἋẲởẴẪẆ٭ତỉ᭗ẟἉἋἘἲầನሰỂẨẺẦᾎ

zԼឋὉኛὉἅἋἚỊܣủẺẦẇဃငỊӼɥẲẺẦᾎ

August*27,*2013�ŵêïŝpZÛ10ȿɔȣȅȇ*

Page 4: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ƬȒȕɔȨɔȻȕɔɎmơĝdzØMŝeǯƗĖƱndzºyDzƣǢȈŵê�•  2012�3Þ1ơ*

DžşóMǶyşóȽɐȣȓȚȯdz�#ȌOƧǠLjƬȒȕɔȨɔȻȕɔɎmơĝdzyşóȽɐȣȓȚȯDzǓǚȈŴƴdzţüÐþȂǦdz�dzŴƴDZǰDz�ǢȈ�zĮdzŵêȌ�Ñdž*hAp://www.ipa.go.jp/sec/

reports/20120328.html*

*

•  1ơ4�*

–  ŵêïŝpZÛ*

–  ŵêpZÛ*

SEC Software Engineering for Mo䡡No䡡Zu䡡Ku䡡Ri

Software Engineering Center 10

ỸỻὊἑὊἧỻὊἽỉဇဌ

ᨥỉἇὊἥἋởᙌԼửᙸễẟể ἥἊἋửᚸỂẨễẟ

ဌ No.3 ởᅈ˟ỉئࠊ

ẲẺẟݣỆ٭

ဌ No.2 ሥἅἋἚửɦậẺẟ

ỸỻὊἑὊἧỻὊἽỂ ἩἿἊỹἁἚầڂẲẺ

ဌ No.1 ᙲˑầỜỤủễẟ

ỸỻὊἑὊἧỻὊἽỉᢠ৸

ࡓࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺

25%

㒊ศࡢ࡞

ࡓࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺

12%

㒊ࡓࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺

ศࠊࡀ࠶

࠸ࡗ࠸ࡃ࠺

ࠋ࠶㠃࠸࡞

63%

јௐỊ… 1. ѣẪἴἠửᙸễầỤỂẨẺ 2. ሥἅἋἚЪถ 3. ᡆᡮễἇὊἥἋỉ੩ ỂẲẺ

ыࡇ

Copyright © 2012 IPA, All Rights Reserved.

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ǁ�August*27,*2013�

ŵêïŝpZÛ10ȿɔȣȅȇ*

Page 5: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ŵêïŝ�

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ǃ�August*27,*2013�

Page 6: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰġ÷ɖ´IJɗ�

1.  ġĠ�2.  "ĖÐþƺ�3.  ȽɌȚȭȐȤţű�

1.  ȽɐȦȤɓȽɐȩȚȯ*2.  ²řɓȬɔɎ*

3.  ȪɔɅƓcɓĻņɓȪɔɅēr*

4.  ĝŞǞȉǧȽɌȚȭȐȤ*

5.  ȽɌȚȭȐȤƗĖ×dzȅǘǏȈaƴǯ�£įƺ*4.  ÿĖ�#*

5.  ÿĖdzɂȑɒȯ*6.  LŋÌĐ*

7.  ķ�*

�ƞ1.*ĝŞǞȉǧ�zǯŴƴ��ƞ2.*�#ǯȽɌȚȭȐȤdz�£�Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� DŽ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰƺġ÷�

Page 7: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjġĠnjNjŏÙnjNjŴƴnjȅȇ�

ŏÙ�• ęĠDzȏȣɈȑɎmơĝǕ�ĀDzDZȇǫǫǏȈ�• ÓãǮǴØMǕƒȉǭǐȈ*

Ŵƴ�

• đqǮÿĖǮǖȈ3�ĠDZ�#dzNjɍȻȎɏɒȤnjǕDZǐ�• őȽɐȣȓȚȯǮĎýDzƗUǢȈLŋ§pǕÄ$ǞȉǭǐDZǐ�

ġĠ�• đq�/dzȱɏȫȣOƧǯÿĖǢȈǧȀdzTipsƧǬǘȇ�• ÓãdzđqǮdz�ƃ�#Ȍ�ǘĹ��

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽƻ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəŵêïŝpZÛ*2O4ȿɔȣ�

Page 8: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjŵêÐþnjȅȇ�

ŵê�

ɂȑɒȯ�

• ŵê�ŸȽɌȚȭȐȤdzį��• j4wdzȏȣɈȑɎmơĝdzŵê�

ŵêĩ�

• ȞɒȭșȤȯ§pdz/¯�• ȽɌȚȭȐȤdzÿĖĎý�

ȸȏɍɒț�

• ȞɒȭșȤȯdzĦŮ�• ďődz�zDzǫǐǭŭĸŵê�

9ç�

• ȷȨɔɒǯǠǭŨƊ�• Ƨť�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƼƼ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəŵêïŝpZÛ*6ȿɔȣ�

Page 9: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

Njŵê�Ÿnjȅȇ�

•  26�#13Ĩ*

– ǮǖȈǨǚxñDZȽɐȣȓȚȯdz�#ȌOƧ*

– yşóƗĖȽɐȣȓȚȯȌYǿ*

– śÊ¯þdzĻǾUȋǤȽɐȣȓȚȯȌYǿ*

•  ŵêī=*

– ȢȤȭɅī=ɖB2C*61%LjĨ4ȢȤȭɅ31%ɗ*– {ijɖőĨơĝ34%LjőĨơĝɖ�ƙȖȻȢɋȏɗ19%LjQŧơĝɖŶŹɗ35%ɗ*

– ¯þɖScrum*35%,*XP*19%,*Scrum+XP*23%,*Scrum+WF*

15%ɗ*– şóɖ�şó77%Ljşó15%Ljyşó8%ɗ*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽƽ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəŵêïŝpZÛ*7O10ȿɔȣ�

Page 10: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjȘȑȰdz"ǐÐnjȅȇ�

•  Œ[dzǏȈȗȭȟɍdzȽɌȚȭȐȤȌĤȈ*–  Nj3.ȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnj*ȌLĊdzǜǯlj*

•  ȽɌȚȭȐȤƗĖdzƦDzĝĔǠǭǐȈaƴǹdz�£įȌÁǢ*

–  Nj3.5.ȽɌȚȭȐȤƗĖ×dzȅǘǏȈaƴǯ�£įnjƺȌLĊdzǜǯlj�•  č�dz�#ǮÿĖǞȉǭǐȈȽɌȚȭȐȤȌÁǢ*

–  Nj4.ÿĖ�#njƺȌLĊdzǜǯlj�•  ŲŌdzĻņLjȽɐȣȓȚȯdzĎýDz�ǠǭdzǓEȀȽɌȚȭȐȤȌÁǢ*

–  Nj5.ÿĖdzɂȑɒȯnj*ȌLĊdzǜǯlj�•  ȽɌȚȭȐȤňÿĖDzƦǠǭdz̨ĈɖȏɒȪȷȨɔɒĮɗȌĤȈ*

–  Nj3.ȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnjdzTȽɌȚȭȐȤdz̨ĈȌLĊ�•  LŋÌĐȌÁǢ*

–  TȽɌȚȭȐȤǴLjTȽɌȚȭȐȤdzĹ�ȿɔȣâ*

–  śÊdzȽɌȚȭȐȤLj�âdzLŋÌĐƺ*•  ȅǘ"ȋȉǭǐȈȽɌȚȭȐȤȌĤȈlj*

–  ïŝŵêpZÛdzNjƗĖī=njLjŵêpZÛɖŵêńɗdz9çļèȌLĊlj*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽƾ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*4ȿɔȣ�

Page 11: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȽɌȚȭȐȤȘȑȰ!ȽɌȚȭȐȤĹ��

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽƿ�August*27,*2013�

Page 12: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjȽɐȦȤɓȽɐȩȚȯnjȅȇ�ȽɌȚȭȐȤW� aƴ�ɍɍɔȤťĘɄɔȭȐɒț

ǐǫǰdzȅǑDZ%(ȌɊɔȡɔDz�ǚȈdzǔǯǐǑġòǕDZǚȉǵLjǧǨȑȭɏɔȢɋɒȌŇȇƉǠǭǐȈǨǚDzDZǪǭǠǽǑlj�

ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒťĘɄɔȭȐɒț

ɍɍɔȤťĘǴƟàĠDZġòdzǧȀLjǦȉǨǚǮǴȑȭɏɔȢɋɒǮ�ȌǰdzȅǑDzơĝǢȉǵŕǐǔȋǔȆDZǐlj�

ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒ ÏǠǐȽɐȩȚȯdzơĝǮǴLjȽɐȩȚȯMǶȽɐȣȓȚȯDzǫǐǭdzĤŷǕ�ƁǠǭǐȈlj�

ȽɌɒȲɒțɂɔȗɔ ơĝdz;àǻǰơĝ�ŸDz�ǢȈĤŷǕ�ƁǠǭǐȈlj�

ȾɐȢȭȐťĄ ȽɐȩȚȯdzơĝşóǕŞĬȁȉǧǯǠǭȁLjȪɔɅdzȑȭɏɔȢɋɒǏǧȇdzơĝƝǕȋǔȆDZǚȉǵLjɍɍɔȤÓȌŞĬȁȈǜǯǕǮǖDZǐlj�

Ó÷ɄɔȭȐɒț §pdz2߃ȉǕaƴȌyǖǘǢȈlj�

Ƿȇǔǒȇ ơĝȪɔɅDzǯǪǭLjÝ;ǔȆÝƗDZơĝȽɐȦȤȌ�ƃǢȈǜǯǴgƪǮǏȈlj�

ǔȍǵȍ �@DzťĘȌĭǭǧǐǕLjǐǫLjǰdzǘȆǐdzŝ�ǕĝĔǢȈdzǔǕ ĄǮǖDZǐlj ȤȽɍɒȯɏȹɉɔ ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒdz­èȌƣ&ŌǮĦŮǢȈõ�ǕDZǚȉǵLjđkdzĎýȌ<ÎǠLj÷dzȑȭɏɔȢɋ

ɒdzƗ:DZťĘȌĭǭȈǜǯǕǮǖDZǐlj�ȨȤȚɁɔȰɖȨȤȚȗɔȰɗ

�LjȪɔɅdz¶ǒȈȨȤȚǕLjǰȉDzPȇ¿ǔȇǮLjǰdzȅǑDZĎªDzDZǪǭǐȈǔȋǔȆDZǐlj�

ȶɔɒȩȒɒȪɈɔȯ ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒȌǜDZǠǭǐȈǨǚǮǴLjȽɐȣȓȚȯ0�ǕưŵDzƑȍǮǐȈdzǔIƥDZĎªDzǏȈdzǔǕȋǔȆDZǐlj�

éƅDZȽɐȦȤ ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝȌǠǭǐȈǕLjǠǪǘȇǜDZǐljĻņdzĎýǯġĠDz�ǠǭƗ:DZĎªDzDZǪǭǐDZǐlj�

ɊɔȡɔȤȯɔɍɔ ŝûȌÖĦDz�ǒȅǑǯLjȰșɉɆɒȯȌŭĸDzÛǐǧǯǠǭȁLjȰșɉɆɒȯȌƌǠǭdzȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒǮǴLj¬ĄȂŰţȌ¸ǖȂǢǐlj�

ȤȽɍɒȯȶȫȚɐț ǦdzȑȭɏɔȢɋɒǮǰdzȽɐȩȚȯȶȫȚɐțȏȑȭɅȌơĝǢȈdzǔLjǰdzȅǑDZ¯ưǮ�đǠǭǐǘdzǔLj¢ŝDZ!íǴ�ǔǕÖȆǔDzDZǪǭǐDZǐlj

ȑɒȦȽȢɋɒȮȫș ȽɐȣȓȚȯDzǫǐǭdzŮŷǕȤȭɔȚɀɎȩɔdzƢǮǦȊǪǭǐDZǐlj�

ȽɐȩȚȯȶȫȚɐțɖ+.ư��ǚɗ

ȽɐȩȚȯȌơĝǢȈ�ǮLj�ǔȆ!íDzPȇ¿ǔȉǵȅǐǔȋǔȆDZǐlj�

ƈƍDZȻȐɔȰȶȫȚ ǏȆȃȈȏȒȯȽȫȯDzǫǐǭȻȐɔȰȶȫȚǕDZǐǯBèȂ%(ǕǏȈdzǔȋǔȆDZǐljƺ Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽǀ�August*27,*2013�

LĊɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰNjȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnj�

Page 13: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

Nj²řɓȬɔɎnjȅȇ�ȽɌȚȭȐȤW� aƴ�ȿȏȽɐțɌɄɒț ĤŷȌȅȇĶÕǘȪɔɅ0�Dz�Ǜǧǐljƺ

őCFǞȉǧd�ȭȤȯ ȭȤȯǴ��ȁŇȇƉǠ�ÑǠDZǚȉǵDZȆDZǐǧȀLjɄȤDZǘLjĥ×ƢǮĺǒȆȉȈȅǑDzǢȈlj�

ȭȤȯƷCơĝ ÏǠǘȽɐȩȚȯȞɔȰȌÛǐǭǐȈÝȁLj�ÛǐǭǐȈȞɔȰǕøǠǐ�ñDzoǬǐǭǐȈdzǔLjȶțȌĻǾƇȍǮǐDZǐǔ��ǮǏȈlj�

ɊȲȫȯȭȤȯdzőCF ɊȲȫȯȭȤȯȌ¯CǮ�ÑǢȈDzǴLjxǘdzaƴǕǏȈlj�

Q/ȭȤȯ ɊɔȡɔȤȯɔɍɔDzǴƶ�ǕQǚ/ȉȈǜǯǕǮǖȈå�Ǖ�SöǮǏȈlj�

ȢȤȭɅɆȨȻȎ ȢȤȭɅdzŪťǴLj·ŸĠDZ¤ŋǨǚǮŘȋȉȈǜǯǕxǐljȢȤȭɅȌĒţǢȈǧȀDzLjơĝŌǯɊɔȡɔdzNÐDzƌĖǢȈ2ƌdzĖůǕ}kǠDZǐlj�

ȤȷȑȚɓȧɍɉɔȢɋɒ §pǕƁȇDZǐǮÂĄȌ,DzơĝȌƑȀȈǜǯǴɍȤȚǮǏȈlj�

ɍȻȎȚȨɍɒț vÚȂ'øȌŇȇƉǠǭǐȈǮȞɔȰǕȗȖȤĎªDzDZȇLjȶțǕ/ȇƇǿ lǕǮǖǭǠǽǑlj�

ȢɒȽɎȮȡȑɒ vÚȌ ĄǠǭ�@DzŪťȌŘǑǜǯǴƪǠǐlj�

Ƌ÷dzľU ľUǢȈƦDzLjśÊdz'øǕYǽȉǭǐȈǯLjǰǜǕaƴǮǏȈǔȋǔȆDZǘDZȈlj�

ĿŀĠȑɒȭțɏɔȢɋɒ ơĝērǮǴC!ǠǭǐǭȁLjērǕvȋǪǧȇLj��dzvÚǯ�ŃDzǢȈǯC!ǠDZǐqUǕǏȈlj�

ƧfDzȅȈȖɔȱɔȢȫȽ ȧɔȤȞɔȰȂíDDzƣǢȈĤŷǕ��FǞȉȈǯLj�dz�ǕǦdzȨȤȚȌ�ÑǢȈǜǯǕǮǖǣDzLj!íȌ�ąFǢȈǜǯǕǮǖǣč�dz�Dz!íǕƧǠǭǠǽǑlj�

ȞɔȮȐɒțşij ȪɔɅǮơĝȌŘǑǧȀDzǴLjU¨�­Ǖy:DzDZȈlj�

ȶț×dz6đȭȤȯ �3UǕĝŞǞȉǧȆLjǦdzJeȌǫǖǯȀǭ'øǠLj6ĝȌƤǕDZǚȉǵDZȆDZǐlj�

ĵɓ¯ÛǖȬɔɎ Vǡq®Ǯ!íȌǢȈȪɔɅdzƢǮLj§p2ßȂȏȑȮȏ8ǠdzǧȀDzǴLjǰȍDZȬɔɎȌĖǐȉǵȅǐdzǨȊǑǔɚ�Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽǁ�August*27,*2013�

LĊɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰNjȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnj�

Page 14: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjȪɔɅƓcɓĻņɓȪɔɅērnjȅȇ�ȽɌȚȭȐȤW� aƴ�ƶ�ȽɐșȢ ƶ�dzuȌōǚǭǐDZǐǧȀDzLjƶ�ȌĉŠǠǧŪťLjơĝȌŘǪǭǠǽǑljļèLjƶ�

dzà�ǢȈȽɐȩȚȯǕ8æ�ǕȆDZǐlj�

ȖɒȠȑȯƶ� ÌÛȂȖɒɌȑɒ�dzȂȇǯȇǮǴȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒǴ-9ǯǴŤǒDZǐlj�

ȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔ NjȞȫȚǕxǢǗȈǯȤɔȽǕǑǽǘǮǖDZǐnjÓãůǮǴNjŔƲxǘǠǭŔ�DzĞȈnj�

ȻȎȢɍȭɔȨɖȤȚɌɅɃȤȨɔɗ őȆdzĎýȌ�ŢĠDzŞȈǜǯǕǮǖDZǐĻņǮǴLjaƴȌŮŷǠLjÆbȂƓĖǕƪǠǐlj�

ȏȣɈȑɎȞɔȪ ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝǴÈĪÛƌȇDz�ÑǠǭȁLjıHDzǴǑǽǘǐǔDZǐlj�

ő�ĻņFȪɔɅ śƨDZƱndzŭĸǽǮPMǕ³ÅǢȈǜǯǴgƪǮ�ÊǕǔǔȈlj�

ȲȞȲȞȗɏɒȩɔ ɆɒȶɔDzžǖǭǐȈĜ�Dzú�ǘǜǯǕǮǖDZǐlj�

»ŀSŐDZȿɔȤ ĉĒȌǠǭǮȁLjƹǐBèȂĔĕ¥ȌŁ»Ǡǧǐlj�

ĻņDzUȋǤǧȏȣɈȑɎȤȨȑɎ ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝȌǠǭǐȈǕLjǠǪǘȇǜDZǐljĻņdzĎýǯġĠDz�ǠǭƗ:DZĎªDzDZǪǭǐDZǐlj�

2ƌdzƙ� ȪɔɅȂƣ&ŌdzȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒǕǑǽǘǐǪǭǐDZǐljÿúǕDZǐlj�

ȪɔɅ0�Ǖ�ǫDz ȪɔɅǕ�ǫDzDZǪǭǐDZǚȉǵLj�ǐdz!íLj~ŊȌȠɂɔȯǢȈǜǯǴDZǘLjļèǯǠǭ­èǕ�ǕȆDZǐlj�

�ädzɐɔȭɔȢɋɒ ȪɔɅȂĻņ4Ǯ�ƠĤŷȂíDĤŷDZǰdz)ȇǕĝĔǠLj��FǠǭǐȈlj�

ȑɒȭțɏɔȢɋɒ�ĖɃȢɒ ȑɒȭțɏɔȢɋɒērǕLj2ĖǨǪǧȇLjƒǔǪǧȇLjãěērǯĜDZǪǭǐǭǴLjȑɒȭțɏɔȢɋɒdz%(Ǖ�ǕǪǭǠǽǑlj�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽǂ�August*27,*2013�

LĊɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰNjȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnj�

Page 15: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjĝŞǞȉǧȽɌȚȭȐȤnjȅȇ�ȽɌȚȭȐȤW� aƴ�ɊɔȡɔȤȯɔɍɔɃȫȺɒțƺ ɊɔȡɔȤȯɔɍɔȂȽɐȩȚȯȶȫȚɐțǨǚǮǴLjȽɐȩȚȯdz0�*Ǵ³ÅǠǬȆǐlj

0�*Ȍ³ÅǠǧ�ǮȤȞɔȽȌüȀDZǐǯȽɐȩȚȯdz%(Ä$ǕǑǽǘǐǔDZǐlj�

Nj��njdz�ʼn* ȪɔɅdzǮNj��njDzǫǐǭdzŮŷǕÃǪǭǐȈǨȊǑǔɚ�

îǠǐ�z* Øùdz��dzǮLjǩȄǪǯǠǧƖ]©ȌŞǫǚǧȇLj¡ĒĠDZȤȯɏȤdzţāþȌóķǠǧȇLj�zǮǖȈǯǜȊȌŞǫǚǧȇǠǭǐȈǕLjDZǔDZǔÆbDzļǶǫǔDZǐlj�

ĻņðƎdzȶȒɒȩɍȌȃȈȀȈ* ĻņȂȽɐȦȤdzðƎǕĔǾ8ǢɁȯɎȳȫȚǕǏȈlj�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� Ƽǃ�August*27,*2013�

LĊɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰNjȽɌȚȭȐȤţűnj�

Page 16: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȷȨɔɒdzȻȕɔɅɖ��ɗ�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽƻ�

ȽɌȚȭȐȤW�

ţüǢǺǖaƴǕĝĔǢȈĎý�

č�dzĎý�ǮĝĔǢȈaƴ*

aƴţüįȌƘµǢȈ�ǮLjŋ«Ĉɓ?ij�Ư�

ȽɌȚȭȐȤȂ�zdzűÖ�

ŵêǮ<ÖǠǧ*

>Ė#�

ǑǽǘǐǔDZǐ*

DZǰdz̨Ĉ�

August*27,*2013�

LĊəŵêïŝpZÛ*18ȿɔȣ�

Page 17: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

����� ���ȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔ(PO) �wq�

��ówqÙ6ąĂBñ��áÎ��½�ühĆ6ÖìÔØðÞăôðĀðÔÏ÷æε�c¶Ć¬âìµ��îĒĪĮğđĶĔįĵĆ'āðÙĀÎ��òĬĵěĞĵĖĆ�éìÔÜÏ�

.¿�

ÑĒĚďÙ7ãÛĂîĖĶĦÙÕ÷ÜíÚðÔÒÂ�

ĤċĶĖ�

À=ñ§��ñðéìûĀÔæÔÙÎÀ=Ù_¶Ć�Üßîó»áÔÏ�\�íĦĴĘďĜƵ�ãĂ¹ñÎ�Zò�ÙL�Ć¡éìÎ�bÙ÷î÷ĀðÔÏ�

 p��

ĦĴĘďĜòOdñ§�ĆSêD�ĆpúìÎÅ�ò��ñ�CìĂßîÏåò�uñ��ò��½�ÞüÎhòp;Ć�Õj¸ĆSæäĂÏ�

�|��

~Lt�

! ÂÍÌÙµ��î¾�ñ�ÕßîÙíÚðÔîÎD�îáìOā�æðÔÏ�ZĦĴĕĊďĜĆ��áìÔĂ4*ðïóÎv;òĦĴĕĊďĜñ?�%ãĂòÙb÷áÔÏ�

! ÍÌĆ�,àăæ�uñj¸Ù9¦àăìÔðÔîÎLJp;ò­BÙ¯ăĂÎp;Ù�àăĂðïò.¿Ù�{ãĂæúÕ÷ÜÔØðÔÏ�

! Ë���ÃÆÈÄò4*óÎ�v;7Zò�|�ñV�ãĂēĶģĖƵ�áìÔæÏåòæú�|�ñó�U�ÕßîóíÚðØéæÏßßíóÎÍÌDòģĕĠĖ }�çÞíðÜε���©ûV�ēĶģĖñêÔ

ì�ÖĂîÔÕ:$ÙFAáìÔæÏ�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽƿ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*85O87ȿɔȣ�

Page 18: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

����� ����������wq�

�4z5ÙĎĖĎĖáæ¼2oíÓéæāÎĦijĚĔĭĶÙÁÔwqíÓéæāÎ�ÜðÔwNíÓĂÏ�

.¿�

`nò�ò�íÎèþéîáæ°-MĆ�êÞæāÎGy�ðĖĜijĖò srĆi�áæāÎ@8íÚĂîߥĆ�êÞæāáìÔĂÙÎðØðØY/ñ�öêØðÔÏ�

ĤċĶĖ�

ĜİĥIJñ>�ãĂ��ò]róÎåòĜİĥIJñ÷éãÝ>IãĂßîíóÓĂÙÎåòwqòĦijĚĔĭĶØĀÎo�ăáìá÷Õ�

 p��

��æèí@8ĆfáûÕÏ÷æÎåòfáÔ@8Ć(Þ�ăÿÕÏ&ñfáùçÞíðÜÎÑfáÜÒØêÑDñ�êÒ@8Ć��áÿÕÏ�

�|��

~Lt�

! �ºàü1»ñPè#êæúñóÎIJĶIJñEÕçÞíó»áÔ4*ÙÓĂÏwqĆÿÜRWáÎÔĄÔĄ¤ãz5Ć|LãĂÏ�

! ßòÿÕð'ā�øĆQ�áÎmúàäĂßîó�&çÏáØáΤáæÔîJéæßîĆ

¤äĂz5ÙÎlòĈġħĶĔįĵñ�öêÜÏ�

! É���ÃÇÄíóÎĢĐÙ�{áæ4*ñÎĢĐîÔÕ¡�ØĀ(ÞĂĠčěćĥðĈĬĶĕíµ��óĖĜijĖĤIJðwqíÓéæÏåßíęĶīóĢĐîÔÕĠčěćĥð�xíóðÜÎÑİĶĬĵò�ÒĆ«!ãĂîÔ

ÕĩĕěćĥðĈĬĶĕíĢĐò£³ĆÞĂÿÕñáæÏ�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽǀ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*115O116ȿɔȣ�

Page 19: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

����� ����ĻņðƎdzȶȒɒȩɍȌȃȈȀȈ �

wq�

ĦĴĘďĜñóÎhÐð��Ù·ąéìÔĂÏęĶīûõîêò��íÓĂáÎåò+2ñûhÐð��ÙÓĂÏ�

.¿�

��üĦĴėĖòg®Ù{ø�ãĨĜIJĠĚďÙÓĂÏ��

ĤċĶĖ�

ĢĉĵĘıĆ^�ñ�ā�ÞÿÕîJéìûÎ�ºíx<�íóðÔÙÎåò+ªßå ®KĆ�XáüãÔîߥíÓĂÏ�

 p��

���ðg®Ù{ø�ãĢĉĵĘıĆýĂúÿÕÏ×�ÔñD�ƨÖìęĶīîáì"ÞÓ×ÕÏ�

�|��

~Lt�

! Âg®Ć6aàäæ�dÎ÷æ\æð�tñ3ëÔæ.¿ñ�ÚCæĂßîÙÓĂϱ�ðĤćĶĝĢĚďĆáðÙĀe¢ãĂÏ�

! Â���k·ðïòH�KñêÔìóÎ�0�üH�ð)²´ðïî¥[ãĂH�Ù

ÓĂÏ�

! Ê���ÃÈÄíóÎĖďİīñ×ÔìĦĴĘďĜČĶĞĶîµ�ęĶīñąØăìÔĂwqíÓéæÙÎĦĴĘďĜČĶĞĶóÎģĕĠĖ }Ùê÷ĀðÜðāÎĨĜIJĠĚďñðĂßîûÓéæÏåòæúÎĦĴĘďĜČĶĞĶ

ûµ�ñêÔì�āε�ęĶīûĦĴĘďĜ }ñ·ąāÎÿā��ñðĂßîĆ�TáæÏ�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽǁ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*117O118ȿɔȣ�

Page 20: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjȽɌȚȭȐȤƗĖ×dz!ȅǘǏȈaƴǯ�£įnjȅȇ�

1.  ȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔǕɁȯɎȳȫȚ*2.  9ɹĈǮ5ĆDZȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒǕǯȉDZǐ�

3.  ȭȤȯdzőCFǕ�dǠDzDZǪǭǠǽǑ�4.  ɍȻȎȚȨɍɒțǕǮǖDZǐ�5.  wǔȆƑŘĎýǕȋǔȇǬȆǐ�6.  ģdzƶ�ǔȆdzȑɒȽȫȯȂȻȐɔȰȶȫȚǕDZǐ*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽǂ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*119O128ȿɔȣ�

Page 21: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ŵêpZÛƺȘȑȰń!ÿĖdzɂȑɒȯĹ��

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽǃ�August*27,*2013�

Page 22: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjÿĖdzɂȑɒȯnjȅȇ�

1.  ĥĴàLjơĝàƢǕĥǐ*

2.  ȤȞɔȽdzvCǕćǠǐ�3.  ûȀȆȉȈ^ŽǕƹǐ*

4.  ȞȤȯŝûǕKǠǐ*

5.  ȪɔɅɆɒȶɔdzȤșɎǕá­ċ*

6.  ȪɔɅDzǯǪǭ;Ȁǭdz²řƱnȂíDĤŷȌ°Ǒ*

7.  ;ȀǭȪɔɅȌĻǿɆɒȶɔǕxǐ*

8.  ȖȻȢɋȏDZǰ9ÉơĝȌŘǑ*9.  ;ȀǭȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzPȇĻǿ*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƽDŽ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*182ȿɔȣ�

Page 23: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjÿĖdzɂȑɒȯnjȅȇ�

ĥĴàLjơĝàƢǕĥǐ*

ȶɔɒȩȒɒȪɈɔȯȌ!­ǠLjȾɐȢȭȐťĄǯǮơĝƍ�ȌťĄǢȈljȤȭɔȚɀɎȩɔǯdzŵËǕy:DZdzǮLjȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔDzȅȈȤȭɔȚɀɎȩɔǯdzŵËǕy:DzDZȈlj*

ȤȞɔȽdzvCǕćǠǐ*

ȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔǴLjȽɐȩȚȯȶȫȚɐțǮŝû0�ǯǦdzư�ȌİĒǢȈljȑȭɏɔȢɋɒǮ�ÑǢȈȤȽɍɒȯȶȫȚɐțȌ!­ǢȈlj*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾƻ�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*183ȿɔȣ�

Page 24: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

�ƞ1.!ĝŞǞȉǧ�zǯŴƴ�ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾƼ�August*27,*2013�

Page 25: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjǷȇǔǒȇnjȅȇ�

W@ Ă­ȪɔɅǮǷȇǔǒȇ

Ďý

ƶ�dzȖȻȐȤǴƩȉǧq®DzDZȈǕLjƐDz2�3ÓǴơĝɎɔɅȌũȉȈljơĝȪɔɅǮǷȇǔǒȇȌ�ÑǠǭǐǧljǷȇǔǒȇdz;¡ŌǕx

ǔǪǧljȽɐȣȓȚȯǴśÊȪɔɅǮð­ǞȉǭǐȈlj�

aƴ �ȪɔɅǹdz¦RǕsǒǭǠǽǐÆbǕŘȋȉDZǐlj*

?ij�Ư ő9ƕǮőƄdz��dzƑȀÐȌÆbǢȈǯǐǑLjǷȇǔǒȇdzƀÔǕĒţǞȉǭǐDZǐlj

ţüį LAɆɒȶɔdz�ƙȌ�ȪɔɅǯɆɒȶɔǯ/ȉÜǒǧȇLjśÊȪɔɅUVǮǷȇǔǒȇȌȂȈǜǯDzǠǧlj

ļè ¯ãǯDZȈȪɔɅdz¾ȈœǐȂŘCȌ~ǶLjÆbǕŘȋȉȈȅǑDzDZǪǧlj*

W@ ȑɒȻȕɔɃɎDZǷȇǔǒȇ

Ďý ǷȇǔǒȇȌǓǜDZǪǭǐȈlj

aƴ ǷȇǔǒȇȌ�ÑǠǭȁLjDZǔDZǔãƭǮūǢǜǯǴgƪǮǏȈlj

?ij�Ư ł�ǠǭǐȈƫhúdzǮǴūǠDzǘǐlj

ţüį �àĠDzȑɒȻȕɔɃɎDzƧǽȉȈq®ȌĖ¨ǠLjǟǪǘǵȆȍDzȹȣȳȤĎýdzūȌǠǭǷȇǔǒȈlj

ļè -

ƾƽ�

W@ ŜȀȈǷȇǔǒȇ

Ďý ǷȇǔǒȇȌǓǜDZǪǭǐȈlj

aƴ ĝŤŌDz�Ǡ±<ĠDZ¨ŞȌŤǑ�ǕǐȈǯLjő9dzĝŤȁ±<ǞȉȈdzǮǴDZǐǔǯ¤ǐLjñNJDZ¨ŞǕŤǐDzǘǘLjĝŤǠDzǘǐƫhúDz

DZǪǭǠǽǑlj

?ij�Ư O

ţüį ǷȇǔǒȇdzǮɆɒȶɔVtȌŜȀUǪǧlj

ļè O

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê*

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰƺ*hAp://www.ipa.go.jp/sec/reports/20130319.html�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*194ȿɔȣ�

Page 26: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒnjȅȇ�

W@ ȖɒɌȑɒɓȪɈȫȯDzȅȈȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒ

Ďý ƶ�dzȖȻȐȤǴƩȉǧq®DzDZȈǕLjƐDz2�3ÓǴơĝɎɔɅȌũȉȈlj

aƴ ČĒĠDZƂƩǕǏȈǧȀLjĦŮ�ƯǕǏȈqUDzȁǢǙDzōǘǜǯǕǮǖDZǐlj

?ij�Ư ȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒƳ�Ȍ�ǛǧǐǕLjƶ�ȁǠǘǴơĝɆɒȶɔǕƢdzq®Dz�ƸǢȈǜǯǴgƪǮǏȈlj

ţüį ȪɈȫȯȢȤȭɅȌ"Ǫǭƶ�ǯɍȏɎȨȑɅDzƏĽǕǯȉȈȅǑDzǠǧlj

ļè ƳŅDzȞɄɉȲȜɔȢɋɒȌǯȉȈȅǑDzDZǪǧlj

Ŵƴ ƶ�dz!í×ƢȌ|ǪǭǠǽǑlj

W@ Ɇɒȶɔi�

Ďý ȖȻȢɋȏȁYȀǧƟàɖÊ�ȤȷɒɗdzȽɐȣȓȚȯǮǏȈlj

aƴ ơĝȪɔɅdzɆɒȶɔǕvȋȈǯLjÏǧDzÈŎǢȈ¢ŝǕǏȈlj

?ij�Ư ɆɒȶɔǴăȈǜǯǕǏǪǭȁsǒȈǜǯǕDZǐȽɐȣȓȚȯĎýǮǏȈlj

ţüį ơĝȪɔɅdzɆɒȶɔdz/ȉÜǒǕžǜȆDZǐȅǑDz¯ƚǠǧlj

ļè ơĝȂíDDzƣǢȈȴȒȵȒǕ­ċǠǧlj

ƾƾ�

W@ &dzɐɔȭɔȢɋɒ

Ďý ȪɔɅDzǴɆȑɒdzơĝ�wDzȁŖNJDZ��ǕǏȈljɖ#:ȶɔɒȩȒɒȪɈɔȯdzȽɐȫȯɗ

aƴ ơĝ�wdz��ȁLjųǔǕȂȆDZǚȉǵDZȆDZǐlj

?ij�Ư ɍɔȩɔǕ¼ħǢȈǜǯǴDZǐlj

ţüį XXX&Ȍ�\ǠǭLj�ƐƢH�ǮdǢȅǑDzǠǧlj

ļè 0_ǕŻ�ȌȁǪǭơĝ�wdz��ȌǮǖȈȅǑDzDZǪǧlj

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê*

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰƺ*hAp://www.ipa.go.jp/sec/reports/20130319.html�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC�August*27,*2013�

LĊəɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*222O223ȿɔȣ�

Page 27: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

NjǽǯȀnjǯNjÄŤnjȅȇ�

•  �yƗĖȽɌȚȭȐȤ*

–  Ó÷ɄɔȭȐɒț*

–  Ƿȇǔǒȇ*–  ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒťĘɄɔȭȐɒț*

–  ȑȭɏɔȢɋɒ*•  ȽɌȚȭȐȤƗĖsA*

–  ScrumdzŮĤX�*

•  şódzƖǐǕƗĖǢȈȽɌȚȭȐȤDzMǼǢ�ƮǏȇ*–  {ijȂȢȤȭɅī=ǴLjǏǽȇ�ƮǕDZǐlj*

•  �#ɖȞɒȭșȤȯɗDzǏȋǤǧ�z*

–  ĎýɓaƴȌLŋDzǠLjNjDZǥǦdzȽɌȚȭȐȤȌƗĖǢȈdzǔnj*

–  180��dzďődz�z*

•  čDzƛŝDZȽɌȚȭȐȤ*

–  ȻȎȢɍȭɔȨɖȤȚɌɅɃȤȨɔɗ*

–  ƶ�ȽɐșȢ*

–  2ƌdzƙ�*

August*27,*2013� Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾƿ�

LĊəŵêïŝpZÛ*25O27ȿɔȣ�

Page 28: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȷȨɔɒDzǫǐǭ�

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵê�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾǀ�August*27,*2013�

Page 29: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȷȨɔɒǯǴɚ�

ȏɏțȡɒȩɔdz�ʼn*

“TȷȨɔɒǕLjērdzǮŇȇƉǠŇȇƉǠĝĔǢȈaƴȌŨƊǠLjǦdzaƴDz�ǢȈţüįdzŝĈȌŨƊǠǽǢljǦdzţüįǴLj0ǘVǡǜǯȌŇȇƉǢǜǯDZǘLj�ğ�dȁƗĖSŐǮǏȈȅǑDzǠǽǢlj”*

*

August*27,*2013� Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾǁ�

Page 30: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȷȨɔɒW@�

ţüįƱn�

aƴƱn�

ȷȨɔɒdzðƎ�

aƴ�

ȻȕɔȤ� ţüį�

ļè*

>ĈɓŴƴ�

Ďý�

IF�

THEN�

ƣƏǢȈ*�ȷȨɔɒ�

ƣƏǢȈ*�ȷȨɔɒ�

ƣƏǢȈ*�ȷȨɔɒ�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾǂ�August*27,*2013�

Page 31: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

DZǥȷȨɔɒDZdzǔ�

•  ĎýǯaƴDzƗǠǧţüįȌƗĖǮǖȈlj*•  ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝǴLjȷȨɔɒǯš]¥Ǖƹǐlj*•  ȧȻȯȒȓȏȂITDzƣǢȈ9ƜǮǴLjȷȨɔɒǕG9Dz>ĖǞȉǭǐȈlj*

•  ȷȨɔɒǴLjśÊdzţüįȌĻǾUȋǤȈǜǯǕǮǖȈlj*

•  ��ŌȂ>ĖŌőȆǕLjǡǸȍǧǩdzȷȨɔɒȌ!ȇLj2ƌŤůǯǠǭ>ĖǢȈǜǯǕǮǖȈlj*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƾǃ�August*27,*2013�

Page 32: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȏȣɈȑɎmơĝǯš]¥Ǖƹǐlj*

James*O.*Coplien*2010*“From*PaAers:*Eastward*to*Lean,*Westward*to*true*object”*

hAp://www.infoq.com/jp/ar`cles/AlexanderFestaReport�Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿƻ�August*27,*2013�

Page 33: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ITȧȻȯȒȓȏ9ƜǮdz£Ė�

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿƼ�

Û�Ǵamazon.co.jpȅȇ�

August*27,*2013�

Page 34: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

śÊdzţüįȌ*ĻǾUȋǤȈǜǯǕǮǖȈlj�

ĥĴàLjơĝàƢǕĥǐqUə*ÿĖǢȈȽɌȚȭȐȤǴLjȾɐȢȭȐťĄǯLjȶɔɒȩȒɒȪɈɔȯǕ½ǛȆȉȈljȾɐȢȭȐDzǫǐǭǴLjƣ&ŌǮǏȈȽɐȩȚȯȖɔȱɔǕĒţǮǖȈoąǮťĄǢȈ¢ŝǕǏȈljǽǧLjȶɔɒȩȒɒȪɈɔȯǴLjƣ&Ōǯ�àĠDz2ßǢȈõ�ȌŪǚȈǜǯǕÿĖdzɂȑɒȯǮǏȈ*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿƽ�

ȷȨɔɒȌHůǯǠǭLjȷȨɔɒɌɒȝɔȣȂȽɐȣȓȚȯɌɒȝɔȣȌĔ­ǢȈlj�August*27,*2013�

Page 35: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ȷȨɔɒĔ­�

ȷȨɔɒ·8�

ő9ǧǩdzŤŗǯáæȌ*ő9ǧǩǮǫǘȈ�

�z·8�

Ò}dz*

ȽɌȚȭȐȤ�

ĎýǯaƴŨƊ�

ƆÛ!­2ß�

�zÿĖťĘį��

aƴţüǹ�

Ďý�

ĎýȂ*

ŴƴĝŞ*

ţüįë*

!­�

�ǠdzÆbǮȁȅǐ�

ő9ǧǩdz2ƌŤůlj*źĕDzɕ�

ǷȇǔǒȇDZǰdz*

ȨȑɄɒțǮŞĢǢ�

ɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰdzȷȨɔɒȌYǿ�

August*27,*2013� Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿƾ�

Page 36: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

LŋżÍ�

•  NjȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵênjdzpZÛǯɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰ*hAp://www.ipa.go.jp/sec/reports/20130319.html*

•  ȷȨɒdzÛǖÐ*

hAp://www.cultureworks.jp/blog/?p=44*

•  ȷȨɔɒɌȑȭȐɒțɑɔȚȢɋȫȽ*Agile*Japan*2013*hAp://www.agilejapan.org/2013/program.html#06*

•  ȧȻȯȒȓȏȷȨɔɒ−×ȌſǒȈȧȻȯȒȓȏdzƔ−:4.ǜȉǔȆdzƺǾȍDZdzǜǯǵɘǾȍDZdzǔǧǩ−ȷȨɔɒɌɒȝɔȣǔȆȽɐȣȓȚȯɌɒȝɔȣǹ*

hAps://ipsj.ixsq.nii.ac.jp/ej/index.php?

ac`ve_ac`on=repository_view_main_item_detail&item_id=75809

&item_no=1&page_id=13&block_id=8*

August*27,*2013� ƿǀ�Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC�

Page 37: IPA Í # H Nm ¡ = L - $ S M ; O R $ 0 Î ï 7 ( T R · 2017. 6. 27. · 6 t r ) r * h t / - o t " k r Ü ñ à í Ð è Ú î ô È = p # /0 Õ ° u ò î Ð ó Ôi ¥ ñ ª ò Ï

ǰǑȁǏȇǕǯǑǝǟǐǽǠǧ�

•  ǽǯȀ*

–  IPANjȏȣɈȑɎmơĝDzǓǚȈȽɌȚȭȐȤÿĖ�#ŵênjɍȻȎɏɒȤȘȑȰdzïŝȌűÖǠǽǠǧlj*

– ȷȨɔɒǯLjȷȨɔɒȌƗĖǠǧĒėȌűÖǠǽǠǧlj*

•  ãôƺø­ɖȁǯǴǠƺǽǞDZȇɗ*– [email protected]*

–  facebook.com/motohasi*

Masanari*Motohashi,*CultureWorks,*LLC� ƿǁ�August*27,*2013�