jason clark - head of property management, ubs
TRANSCRIPT
Public
6 October, 2016
Soft Landing (Operational Readiness)
5 Broadgate
Jason Clark Head of Property Management
2
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Table of contents
Page
Section 1 Introduction 3
Section 2 Project 5-7
Section 3 Soft Landing 8-20
Section 4 Conclusion 22-23
Section 1
Introduction
4
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx About Us
UBS is a global organisation providing financial services to private, corporate and institutional clients
Globally • Headquartered in Switzerland• Present in all major financial centres
and offices in over 50 countries• Employs more than 65,000 people
around the world
Within the UK • UBS employs around 7,500 people • UBS has a property portfolio of 7
buildings in the London area• A portfolio that equates to
approximately 1,000,000 ft2
• A real estate strategy to reduce the number of buildings and provide a new London home to accommodate all of our business functions
Section 2
The Project
6
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Project
"We cannot develop a new London building without fully understanding the ongoing operational use"
Building operation team engage from inception "Starting with the end in mind"
Background
• When the project started BIM, Soft Landing and Intelligent buildings were on the agenda
• We are currently occupying numerous buildings around the Broadgate area
• Plan to consolidate into one building
UBS • In house team of operational subject matter experts associated with each function
• Moved towards the IFM model during the life of the project
• Drive to reduce cost but maintain quality and service
5 Broadgate • 700,000 ft2 pre let development by BlueButton properties
• One of the largest pre let buildings in the city • Aligned with existing lease breaks • Tenant (UBS) engaged from the outset• Separate design teams for the Base Build / Fit Out
7
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Project
Delivering a flexible world-class office facility for the integrated Firm
Specific aims…
• Maximum flexibility and cost efficiency for London real estate portfolio
• Enhanced client experience through world-class facilities
• Productive and flexible working environment for our staff
• Secure and reliable infrastructure to minimise operational risk
• Excellent sustainability characteristics and energy efficiencies
A building specified in 2009 for full occupation in 2016 :
Section 3
Soft Landing (Operational Readiness)
9
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Soft Landing
What does Soft Landings really entail
"The Government Construction Strategy of May 2011 identified the need to improve the value offered by public sector construction and within this “soft landings” was identified as a way to improve performance of buildings and to meetthe requirements of those that use them." Bim Task Group
"Soft Landings is the BSRIA-led process designed to assist the construction industry and its clients deliver better buildings.Soft Landings helps to solve the performance gap between design intentions and operational outcomes" BSRIA
We wanted a Soft Landings process that covered every function
10
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Objectives and Scope
The right level of trained resources and good governance.
Objectives • To develop a "Soft Landings" strategy and mobilisation plan for Group Corporate Service (GCS) operations in 5 Broadgate.
• To embed operational requirements in the 5 Broadgate design and specifications.
• To implement Soft Landings as part of a wider change management programme
Scope • All GCS services and operational requirements will be analysed in their current, interim and end states.
• Key topics will include:
Other
100LS
1FA
2FA 100LS
1FA
2FA
5BG
Current Interim End
5BG
11
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Soft Landing Framework
The Soft landing Framework follows the traditional project phases
Stakeholder Engagement & mobilisation
Stage 1Inception and
Briefing
Operational Monitoring
Stage 4Construction
Planning for Operation
Stage 3 Pre-
Construction Operation Process, Building and Technology Alignment
Stage 2 Design
Operational Validation
Stage 5Occupation
Stakeholder Engagement & mobilisation· Building Specification
(AFL)· Lessons Learnt· Functional Leads
Inception
Operational Monitoring · Fit Out · Technical reviews · Off site testing · On site Testing· Services Testing
Mobilisation and Testing
Planning for Operation· Process Re
engineering· Change management
programme · Reporting
requirements · SOP/EOP· Service Migration · Fitout Monitring· Planning for Testing· Service Training· IFM Integration· Bim Strategy
Day 0 Strategic Plan
Operation Process, Building and Technology Alignment· Optioneering · Process identification
and gap analysis· Touch Points· Building Plans· Asset Management· Communications· Logistics· RiskSummarised in tender requirements document and specifications
Informing Building Design
Operational Validation · Seasonal
commissioning· User satisfaction
surveys · Data logging
Evaluation
Indu
stry
UB
S
12
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Detailed Soft Landing Approach
12
Optioneering with lifecycle cost analysis Briefing the end users, exhibition, web site & Fly Through Emerging TechnologyO&M requirements specifiedSign off with comments trackedCommunicate building design to operational team and respond to feedbackStorage, workshop, stacking plan & RDS requirements Supplier Visits, Product/Prototype Testing. e.g. cleaning Intelligent building functional requirementsBIM Modelling & Asset DatabaseVisits to potential suppliers Training, warranty, spares, maintenance & reporting requirements Process mapping & gap analysis & touch points identified Intelligent building functional requirements
Building performance definition (AFL)Identify the operation team engagement Lessons learnt & experience RIBA gateways communicated from the outset Benchmarking against our peersSenior management approval Confirm deliverables and timetableCommunicate building design to operational team
Reporting developed Change management mobilisation Process re-engineeringCapital cost or lease agreements agreedOperational team review Tender documentationFunctional team trainingFunction by Function mobilisation & migration planAsset management planCommunication planLogisic planChange management Early Fitout monitoringSeasonal commission strategy User satisfaction survey and measurement strategy
Technical submittals reviewed by operation team Key team members attend factory testO&M production commencesSite walk rounds & inspections On site testing and commissioning witnessUser satisfaction survey (pre move)Building occupier guide developed Building operator technical guide developedOperational teams mobiliseSupplier contract arrangements completed Practical completionOperational team resource planningImplement staff communication programme for migrationOperational systems testing and staff training
Dry / Run in periodMigration Seasonal commissioning Post occupancy evaluation of systems performanceUser satisfaction survey (post move)Data logging & energy performance System adjustments
Stage 2 DesignRIBA Stages C –E
Stage 1 Inception & BriefingRIBA Stages A-B
Stage 3Preconstruction RIBA Stages F_G
Stage 4 Construction RIBA Stages J-K
Stage 5OccupationRIBA Stage L
13
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Objectives and Scope
The basebuild, fitout and operational readiness aligned
Inception Mobilisation and Testing
Day 0 Strategic Plan
Informing Building Design
Evaluation
ü
Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q3Q1 Q22011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
abBluebutton
Detailed Fit-out Design
Below Ground Construction
Above Ground Construction
Fit-out Construction
Final planning consent. (Jul11)
Fit-out Concept Design
Demolition
Planning submission (Dec10)
2010Q4
üü üAgreement Unconditional (Dec11)
Sectional completion
Topping out (Mar 2014)
Base build M&E installations
üüGround Breaking(Mar 2012)
Fit-out Scheme Design
Stage C approved (Sept-11)
üStage D approved (Aug-12)
üStage E Approval(Jan-14)
ü üRevised Stage D approved (June-13)
Fit-out Construction PC (May 2016)
Occupation
Full base build handoverü
Production Design and Mock-ups
Base
Bui
ld
Mon
itor
ing
Fit-
out
Des
ign
& C
onst
ruct
ion
IT & Furniture Installations
Testing & Commissioning
ü
üStart on-
siteJan 2015
14
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Optioneering
Life cycle costing analysis is integral to the design selectionOptions considered
• Disposable Cups v Crockery / Dishwashing
• UPS options• LED v Fluorescent• Chiller options • Centralised mail• Centralised waste management • Locker Strategy • Centralised Food waste• Link Line water distribution • Intelligent building requirements
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
15
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Processes
Our processes define the way we do thingsProcess v Procedure
• Different ways of documenting processes between the functions
• Processes identification and gap analysis carried out
• Differentiated between process and procedure
• All of our processes in a single repository
• Agreed a consistent structure and format for re engineered processes
• Captured in a quality management system and single repository
• Cross fuction review to identify "Touch Points"In
form
ing
Build
ing
Desig
n
16
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Touch Points
Every process is reviewed and touch points articulated
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
P – People T – Technology B – Building
1.
Envi
ronm
enta
l2.
A
rt3.
Corp
orat
e Se
rvice
s3.1
. C
lean
ing
Serv
ices
1.1.1.
Clea
ning
1.1.1.
1.
Rem
oval
of G
ener
al &
Recy
clable
Was
te1.1
.1.2.
Vir
al Cl
eanin
g1.1
.1.3.
Re
spon
se to
helpd
esk c
alls
1.1.1.
4.
One o
ff pu
rchas
es1.1
.1.5.
St
ock l
evel
mon
itorin
g1.1
.1.6.
Ge
nera
l was
te re
mov
al re
ques
ts1.1
.1.7.
Re
cycla
ble pa
per w
aste
– Gr
een b
oxes
and B
lue Bi
ns
Function and Sub Function List1. Environmental
1.1. Environmental Management System (EMS)1.1.1.
1.2. Energy & Utiliites1.2.1. Energy Management Systems1.2.2. Energy Efficiency
1.2.2.1. Building systems, HVAC etc1.2.2.2. Small power and lighting1.2.2.3. Technology
1.2.3. Emissions Reporting1.2.3.1. Mandatory1.2.3.2. Voluntary
Avoiding duplication
• Technology – linking into our intelligent building strategy
• People – Linking into our IFM programme • Building – linking into building design and space
allocation
17
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Building Plans
Operational areas allocated and requirements defined in room data sheets
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
A full review of our current spaces and aligned those requirements more effectively with the new building
• Function by function allocation of spaces, i.e stores etc
• Team awareness of the building flow • Room Data Sheet compiled• Rooms named and numbered • Recognising the difference between operation
and architectural referencing
18
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Communications
Touch Points in communication from a Visual, Technology and Voice Perspective
• Aligning the communication platform with the Asset Management solution
• Tablet solution with FSIGo allows workflow, risk assessments and help desk management direct to the team
• GCS currently utilise the TES radio solution for Incident management Security and Engineering
• Use cases for the system across the working group
• Allows migration and innovation from the existing system
• Building RF survey required• Link and Existing Chat channels will still
play a key role in communication with business lines
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
19
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Risk
Reviewing your risk on a regular basis
• Risk register in line with the operational risk register for ease of migration
• Functional specific risk identified reviewed on a regular basis
• Risk designed out where practicable • Retained risk are known and carried forward
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
20
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Asset Management
All of our assets held in one CMMS system
• Common agreement on asset management: - • Database and asset coding• Agreed asset fields • Platform• Physical Labelling & QR
Code• Tagging
• O&M & H&S file format and platform
• Drawing Protocols • Bim Execution Plan• Training - Requirements • Spares - Requirements• Warranty and Maintenance
Requirements
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
21
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Logistics
Areas that impact every operational team
• Reception, Concierge and Vehicle Management• Storage requirements• Building access working group formed to review: - • All points of access. Cycle entrance, loading bay car
parks etc • Loading bay, Lifts , Car park & Cycle Vehicle
Scheduling/Management • Job Description for Dock Master, Traffic Marshall• Technology requirements • Deliveries
Info
rmin
g Bu
ildin
g De
sign
Section 4
Conclusion
23
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Challenges
Thinking outside the box
• Existing operational activities take priority for the working group
• 5BG building design is very complex and must be understood by the operation teams
• Impact on 5BG Fit out Construction – control budget and avoid 'scope creep'
• Interim operational state may require additional resources
• Agile Pilot may be benificial• Impact of the IFM Programme. When should you
engage your service providers• Change management knowledge & Operational
teams need to embrace change • Employee impact and self interest• Tender specialist requirements early
There are hurdles to overcome in no particular order…
24
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx BIFM – Operational Readiness Guide
There is now a guide to help you through your own journey Creating a
building that has the end user in mind is key:
• Historically Facilities Management professionals have been submissive to the design and construction process and are now a recognised equal stakeholder.
• Developed by BIFM, Academics and Facilities Management Practitioners.
• The guide is aligned to the 8 stages of RIBA Plan of Work, Building Information Modelling (BIM) process Model and Government Soft Landings.
• Focus on Themes and Functions to align with the potential working groups.
• Creating a process for communication, collaboration, integration and defined project deliverable gateways
• Checklist to support design, Construction, Operational Readiness and Post Occupation Evaluation (POE).
• Consider your BIM strategy, common data environment and Facilities Management tools.
Delivering better outcomes
Compliance
People
Process
Procurement
Technical
Space
25
UBSPROD\clarkjaa [printed: October 1, 2016 4:18 PM] [saved: October 5, 2016 6:39 PM] N:\PREM_DIARY\Jason Clark\Property Management\Presentations\2016-10-01_FMP Preesentation_Soft Landings.pptx Contact information
www.ubs.com
Jason Clark Director, Regional Head of Property Management Group Corporate Services +44 207 567 9201 | mobile +44 7824 548460 [email protected] | web: www.ubs.com