jean-michel champomier, forming of audit opinions, sigma, ankara, 26 october 2016
Upload: support-for-improvement-in-governance-and-management-sigma-oecd
Post on 15-Apr-2017
79 views
TRANSCRIPT
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU Workshop on the forming
of Audit OpinionsForming and expressing an
opinion on government’s financial statements
The French SAI La Cour des Comptes
Jean-Michel CHAMPOMIER
Ankara, 26-27 October 2016
2
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUContent
• Introduction: overview of the French SAI• 1. The State’s accounts• 2. The audit approach• 3. The audit organisation and the audit
work• 4. The opinion • 5. How we meet the challenges…
3
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUIntroduction: legal missions of the Court
• The Cour des comptes (Court of Accounts), founded in 1807, is independent- From the executive power- From the legislative power- From the judicial system.
• The Court is...equidistant.
• The Cour des comptes has four missions to fulfil- “Contrôler” : compliance, SFM and performance audit- “Juger”: French specific judgement of accounts- “Evaluer” : evaluation of public policies-“Certifier” : financial audit.
• Further defined in the Code of financial jurisdictions.
4
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUIntroduction: the court’s structure
The First President
The Secretary general
Presidents of chambers
The commitee for public reporting and programming CPRP
The rapporteur général
The public prosecutor
1 Finance budget Financial audit
2 Defense Energy
3 Education
4 ¨Police, Justice
5 Social policies
6 Health Social security
7 Agriculture, infrastructure
The Plenary
Technical support
directorates
7 chambers
Public reports
The inter-chambers committee
I.C.C
5
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUIntroduction: the budget reform act
Constitutional bylaw on Budget Acts (2001)• Programme budgeting
- Missions-Programmes-Actions• Greater autonomy for Departments
- Globalised appropriations ; flexible management• Performance budgeting
- Annual Performance Plans; Annual Performance Reports• Greater Role for Parliament
- Extended power of amendment and scrutiny• New public accounting system
- Certification of the State’s accounts by the Court
6
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUIntroduction: the mandate
« Society has the right to ask any public official to account for his administration » (The 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen) • Financial audit is part of parliamentary assistance
- « The Court of Accounts shall assist Parliament in monitoring Government action.
- It shall assist Parliament and the Government in monitoring the implementation of Finances Acts and of Social Security Financing Acts (...).
- By means of its public reports, it shall contribute to informing citizens ». (Constitution of the French republic 47-2)
7
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUIntroduction: the mandate
The parliamentary assistance• Responding to requests for assistance• Filing specific annual reports
- Preliminary report to parliamentary discussion on public finance trends and national economy
- Report on budget execution, annexed to budget review bill- Report certifying that the State’s accounts are lawful,
faithful and give a true and fair view, annexed to budget review bill = the Opinion
- Certification report on the accounts of the Social security Scheme (2005 Const. bylaw on Social security).
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
1. The state accounts
9
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe state accounts: 3 sets
• The French State shall keep 3 sets of accounts- Budget and revenue accounts- General accounts- An accounting system to analyse the cost of Govt. actions.
• The "General Account of the State" - The balance sheet- The income statement- The table of cash flows- The annexed notes
- notes to the financial statements- assessment of off-balance sheet commitments
- information on sustainability financing requirement of the retirement scheme for civil servants
- The introductory report.
10
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU The state accounts: legal provisions
• The French Constitution and the budget reform act include provisions on accounting principles- The government accounts are true and fair. They give a
true view of the results of the management, the assets and the financial situation. (Constitution).
- The State’s accounts must be lawful, faithful and give a true and fair view of its assets and financial situation. (Budget reform act)
- The rules applicable to the general accounts of the State do not differ from those applicable to companies, except because of the State’s specificity. (idem)
11
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe state accounts: accounting standards
• State’s financial reporting standards- a conceptual framework and a set of 21 accrual based
accounting standards- converging with private sector standards- subject to the specific nature of Government action - based on French rules (Plan Comptable General) and
International Accounting Standards (IAS/IFRS and IPSAS)
- issued by the National Board for Standards on Public Accounts (Conseil de Normalisation des Comptes Publics)
- ongoing discussion on introducing EU Standards : EPSAS.
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
2. The audit approach
13
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: auditing standards
• The Court enforces the ISA as far as - they are compatible with the financial audit of the
accounts of the State and of the social security scheme and they are applicable
- See ISA 200 provisions on the case where the ISA are not applicable due to the specificity of the audit mission
- they are not contrary to provisions of the Code of financial jurisdictions
14
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: a risk based approach
• A risk-based approach • And a methodology which adapts
- to the State’s specificity- to the legal framework of the Court
- internal organisation - relation with audited entities- programming - contradictory procedure- decision process (collegiality)
• Risk assessment makes it possible to adapt the intensity of the final audit
• Court’s focus: IT systems and follow-up on previous audits.
15
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: planning
• The audit strategy - identifying risk and priorities- defining the extent of the verification - setting up a coherent organisation - managing human resources
• The strategy is formalised in an annual instruction of the Premier President
• Each audit cycle has a road map• The planning phase is closed by notification
- pursuant to Code of financial jurisdictions
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: assessing internal control
• Due to its risk based audit approach, the Court pays great attention to risk management in audited entities.
• Key criteria are :- Risk assesment.- Defining an action plan so as to reduce the risk level. - Setting up an effective internal control system.- Internal control is managed by the top
hierarchy of the Ministry.- Internal control system is evaluated by
internal audit.16
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: assessing internal audit
• Development of internal audit in ministries- Line ministries gradually establish internal audit units
based on former inspectorates- Internal audit shall evaluate internal control so as to
improve its effectiveness and efficiency
• The Court’s perspective- « External auditor shall take into account the work of
internal auditor and its potential impact on external audit procedures » (ISA 610)
- the Court assesses the internal audit function - to determine compliance with ISA 610- to evaluate the audit work supporting internal audit
conclusions and recommandations.17
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit approach: working with internal audit• Based on quality criteria
- Independence and objectivity- relation with upper management- no responsibility in defining internal control system - freedom to communicate with external audit- formalised set of standards methodology - programming based on documented risk analysis - follow up of conclusions based on action plan- professionnal competence
• The Court works with internal auditors- exchange of letters with internal ministerial auditors - guidelines for working relation internal/external audit teams- audit meetings : programmation and follow up- permanent contacts- exchange of final conclusions. 18
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
3. The audit organisation and the audit work
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit organisation: cycles and sub-cycles
20
5 audit areas and 12 sub-areas
1. Financial statements
2. Debt and cash
3. Tangible and intangible assets
and stocks4. Financial
assets
5. Net expenditure and
taxes
1.1 IT and internal control
1.2 Off balance sheet liabilities
2.1 Financial debt and financial instruments 2.2 Cash
3.1 Assets and inventories
of civilian ministries
3.2 Assets and inventories
of the ministry of defense
4.1 Equity investment in State owned entities
4.2 Other equity investments and financial assets
5.1 Staff expenses
and pension liabilities
5.2 operating expenses
and subsidies
5.3 State vs. Social
security
5.4 Tax income
21
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit organisation: a matrix
The inter chambers committee (I.C.C.)
chamber chamber chamber chamber chamber chamber chamber coordination
team
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
cycle subcycle
1 1.1
1.2
2 2.1
2.2
3 3.1 3.1 ch 5
3.2
4 4.1
4.2
5
5.1
5.2 5.2 CH 7
5.3
5.4
The audit team leader for each cycle
+ experts (M)
The audit team leader for each sub-cycle
+ experts (M)
The audit coordinator (M)
Each chamber has a
representative at the ICC
A focal point for financial audit in each chamber assessment of
internal control of line ministries
(M)=magistrate
22
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: planning
Risk assessment (now merely on the basis of
previous missions)
Materiality
Understanding the entity and using professional
judgment
Audit planning
Collecting audit
evidence
The audit is based on risk assesment and is planned so as to cover error risks (ISA 300)
23
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: the audit cycle
The interim phase (June to December n)• Review of- accouting procedures- information systems- internal control and audit • Interim reports on
internal control: risk assessment
- by ministry - by audit area
• Consolidated interim report
The final phase(January to May n+1)
Work to support the opinion• Data collection based on risk
assessment • Data IT analysis• Tests on samples• Analytical procedures• Tests on financial information• Drawing up audit
observations - correction- limitation- uncertainty
24
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: key documents
June before starting: audit plan by area
July when starting : internal circular of Premier president (endorsed by ICC and reported to CPRP)
December end of interim audit : interim reports (a summary is reported to ICC and CPRP and submitted to the ministry of budget and accounts)
May end of final audit : final reports (a summary is reported to ICC and CPRP and submitted to the ministry of budget and accounts
End of cycle
Opinion and supporting report (validated by ICC, CPRP et endorsed by the plenary; to finance committee of National Assembly and the Senate)
25
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: interim review
• Interim reports by audit area - mention the extent of the audit- communicate findings and audit conclusions- are subject to validation with management - are sent to Director general of the Public Accounting and
the Directors of all directorates concerned as «provisional conclusions»
• Internal reports per Ministry- evaluation of ministries accounting risk management
systems- specific verification items - interim reports by audit cycle conclusions relating to
each particular ministry- general overview released early March
26
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: final and post review
• Final Audit - starts with the provision (early march) of a “first
stabilised balance” - overall objective : collecting sufficient appropriate
audit evidence to reduce audit risk and deliver the audit opinion.
• Post-review events- the Court implements verification in order to
- identify significant post-review events-modify, if required, the accounts or the
financial information in annexed notes and/orin the Public Report
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: the quality review
27
Audit reporter
(M)
Counter reporter
(M)
Audit report
Counter report
Public prosecutor Conclusions
ICC Collective decision
Audit reportCPRP
THE PLENARY
28
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: quality assurance
• Audits are carried out by teams of highly qualified experts and rapporteurs
• A continuing revision process is in place• The office of the general prosecutor (Parquet
général) provides quality assurance• Audit reports are collegially endorsed by a
chamber and reviewed by a contre-rapporteur• The draft certification act is considered by the
Committee on public report and programs (CPRP)• The opinion is adopted by the council chamber in
plenary session
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: quality assurance (2)
• By Management - Team leader, - Audit cycle manager, - Financial audit central management team
• By Court internal bodies, who are informed in real time of audit findings and reports- ICC- Contre-rapporteur- Public prosecutor - Any member of general assembly
• Peer review by the National auditor of Finland- 2012
29
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: the contradictory procedure
• During interim and final phase, audit observations are sent to accounting departments - Auditors have permanent contacts and exchanges with
State accounting departments- There is a joint technical commitee to discuss
accounting issues• Draft certification report endorsed by ICC is sent
to accounting departement for technical contradiction
• Amended certification report endorsed by CPRP is sent to the Minister of public accounts.
30
31
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe audit work: outputs
• Interim audit : early December- 12 summary reports by audit cycle + risk assessment- 10 reports on line ministries internal control - 270 audit recommendations (in average)• Final audit : March to May- 50 audit observations (in average)- 12 summary reports by audit cycle- one draft certification report to support the opinion
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
4.The opinion
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe opinion: legal basis
• The validation and contradiction process for preparing the opinion is defined by the French law (in accordance to ISA 260 Standard)
• “In view of the statement of findings, the Court certifies that, with regard to the applicable accounting rules and principles, the Central Government general account as at 31 December nn is lawful, truthful and gives a true and fair view of the financial position and holdings of the Central Government, subject to x qualifications detailed in Part II.”
33
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe opinion: a path of progress
Number of qualifications decreases over time
34
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe opinion: 2015 accounts
• A qualified opinion• Qualification n° 1: the financial information
system- The linkage of the core software to other
softwares of the State’s FMIS
• Qualification n° 2: internal control and audit in line ministries- Ministries approach to strenghten internal
control- Effectiveness of internal control in key risky
operational processes.
35
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe opinion: 2015 accounts (2)
• Qualification n° 3: tax income• Qualification n° 4: assets and liabilities of defense
ministry - Inventories- Materials- Lands and buildings
• Qualification n° 5 : financial assets- Equity investments in State owned entities- Other financial assets
36
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
5. How we meet the challenges…
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUSome challenges to meet
How does the judicial role of the Court and the compliance audit work impact on the financial audit and the opinions that are expressed ?How to prevent judicial function and financial audit function from conflicting?
38
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUPeculiarities of the French PFM system
• Judicial audit on accounts held by general accountants
- the general accountants are in charge of regularity checks on payment orders, release of public funds, revenue collection, accounts holding,
- they are liable to the Court for any misstatement in accounts, wrong payment, under collection of taxes (based on fault)…
- their individual accounts are consolidated in the general account of the State
- basis for judgement is a specific compliance audit that the public prosecutor may (or not) use to require a fine or a compulsory reimbursement.
39
40
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe auditor and the judge
Question: How to prevent judicial function and financial audit function from conflicting ?Answer 1: including cooperation arrangements in the work programme on systemic issues• From financial audit to compliance audit
Findings from financial audit, though non material, may help compliance audit to analyse local internal control systems
• From compliance audit to financial audit Performance audit on general accountants (expenditure,
revenue collection, accounts holding) may help to analyse internal control function. Finding may be transmitted to the financial audit team to improve risk assessment of systems.
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe auditor and the judge
Answer 2: including different Court’s departments in the audit process• The Inter-chamber commitee (ICC) follows-up on
the audit process at any step- Audit programme- Interim report- Report on internal control- Members of ICC are responsible for audit areas
• The committee for public reports and programming- idem
• The plenary chamber : the data room- Each magistrate may consult audit files and ask questions
before the session. 41
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUThe auditor and the judge
Answer 3: promoting common work to increase staff awareness and skills• Financial audit experts assist compliance audit
teams- Support compliance auditors on accounting issues
• Compliance auditors assist financial audit teams- Provide knowledge of ministries operations
42
© OECD
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EU
Conclusion
A jo
int
initi
ativ
e of
the
OEC
D a
nd th
e Eu
rope
an U
nion
,pr
inci
pally
fina
nced
by
the
EUAuditor is the judge’s best friend
• The approach of the French Court is to use its own strengths and to include the financial audit procedure in its existing structure, while applying international standards.
• In addition to providing an annual opinion, the Courts have defined a « path of progress » for the State’s accounting departements.
• The outcome is that public accounts are much more reliable now than 10 years ago.
44