judo strategy
DESCRIPTION
Judo StrategyTRANSCRIPT
Faculty Seminar Series
Judo Strategy: Turning Your
Competitors’ Strength to Your Advantage
Professor David B. Yoffie Harvard Business School
Copyright © 2001-2002
1
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Judo StrategyTurning Your
Competitors’ Strength to Your Advantage
David B. YoffieHarvard Business School
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
In the midst of a revolution...
But prediction is dangerous
Wall Street Journalseries on the year 2000,
published 1966-67
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
By the Year 2000 • Man landing on Mars• Cities under huge, climate-
controlled domes• NYC to Tokyo in under 2 hours• Rocket packs & flying
automobiles• 200,000 computers in the U.S.
2
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Favorite Prediction
In 1965, The Commission on the Year 2000 foresaw the Internet:
– A “national information computer-utility”would take form, with “tens of thousands of terminals in homes and offices…providing library and information services, retailing, ordering, billing services, and the like.”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Favorite Prediction
But they also predicted:
“Professors and intellectuals will become
more powerful than corporate CEOs.”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Source: Dataquest, Zona Research, ZD Market Intelligence, AdKnowledge, and authors’ estimates.
Rapidly Changing Marketplace LeadersThe Browser Wars, 1994-99
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Dec-94
Jun-95
Dec-95
Jun-96
Dec-96
Jun-97
Dec-97
Jun-98
Dec-98
Jun-99
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Dec-94
Jun-95
Dec-95
Jun-96
Dec-96
Jun-97
Dec-97
Jun-98
Dec-98
Jun-99
OTHERS
NETSCAPE
MICROSOFT
3
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Intuit
Palm Netscape
David vs. Goliath Confrontations
Microsoft
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
CiscoJuniper Networks
David vs. Goliath Confrontations
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
CNETZiff Davis
IDG
David vs. Goliath Confrontations
4
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Freeserve AOL
David vs. Goliath Confrontations
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Internet has madethese types of David-and-
Goliath struggles more common and more intense
than ever before.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Impact of Network Effects
• Definition: as more people use a product, it becomes more valuable.
• Market with network effects “tip.”• Market share races become life-or-
death struggles.• Increasing returns further intensify
the competition, as companies rush to get down the cost curve.
5
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Judo Strategy
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
What Is Judo Strategy?A Metaphor
Judo is an “art of hand-to-hand fighting in which the weight and efforts of the opponent are used to bring about his defeat.”
Yerkow, Modern Judo, 1942
Courtesy: U.S. Judo Association
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
What Is Judo Strategy?A Metaphor
Yerkow, Modern Judo, 1942
Courtesy: U.S. Judo Association
Through movement the opponent is led into an unbalanced position. Then he is thrown...by some form of leverage...”
In judo, “before an opponent can be thrown there must be movement.
6
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
What Is Judo Strategy?A Metaphor
“Size, weight, and power mean nothing in judo because you employ the efforts of the opponent to defeat him.”–Yerkow, Modern Judo, 1942
Courtesy: U.S. Judo Association
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permissionSource: Kyodo News International.
Russian President Vladimir Putin, a black belt in judo, isthrown to the floor by a 10-year-old school girl in Tokyo.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Judo Strategy as a Mindset
• Don’t go head-to-head against a stronger competitor.
• Find areas to attack where your competitor cannot and will not respond.
7
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Reduce the threat of attack by taking your opponent
out of his game.
Principle #1: Movement
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Minimize the impact of an attack by avoiding
tit-for-tat and exploiting your competitor’s
momentum.
Principle #2: Balance
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Use your competitors’strength and weight to
bring them down.
Principle #3: Leverage
8
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
J. Gelman and S. Salop, “Judo economics: capacity limitation and coupon competition,” Bell J Ec 14:2 (1983): 315-325.
•“To capture the image of a small firm using its rival’s large size to its own advantage, we call this a strategy of
judo economics.”
Judo Economics
The basic model:
• The entrant chooses its price and capacity.
• The incumbent chooses its price.
• If the entrant’s capacity is unlimited, the incumbent maximizes its profits by matching the entrant’s price.
• If the entrant can credibly commit to limit its capacity, it can choose a capacity/price pair such that the incumbent finds it more profitable to accommodate entry (i.e., cede some consumers and serve the rest at a higher price).
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Judo Strategy: Pepsi-Style
In 1934, Pepsi introduced a 12-oz bottle at the same price as a 6½-oz bottle of Coke.
Pepsi-Cola Coca-Cola
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Judo Strategy: Pepsi-Style
“Pepsi-Cola hits the spot.Twelve full ounces, that’s a lot.Twice as much for a nickel too.Pepsi-Cola is the drink for you!”
Pepsi-Cola Coca-Cola
9
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Companies We Studied
• Big & small• Domestic & international• Service & manufacturing• High tech & low tech
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Companies We Studied• In-depth case studies:
– Palm, RealNetworks, CNET, Microsoft
• “Caselets”:– Pepsi, Intuit, Ariba, Juniper, Inktomi,
Frontier Airlines, eBay, Handspring, eToys, Amazon, Sony, Charles Schwab, Capital One, Freeserve, Southwest Airlines, Intel, Cisco,…
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Principle #1: Movement
Mindset: To defeat a master,
you have to take him out of his game.
10
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Principle #1: Movement
“In the fight between the bear and the alligator, the outcome is determined by the terrain.”– Jim Barksdale, former President and
CEO, Netscape
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Puppy Dog Ploy
Look weak and inoffensive so your competitor doesn’t feel compelled to attack.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Puppy Dog PloyPosition yourself
alongside your competitors.
• Palm Computing“We didn’t call it a computer; we didn’t call it a PDA. We said, ‘This is just a little organizer that happens to connect to your PC.’” —Donna Dubinsky
11
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Puppy Dog PloyDon’t go for the jugular
—at least not at first.
• Palm Computing “We always said, ‘Look, if Microsoft had a decent platform we would consider it. We are first and foremost a device company.’” —Donna Dubinsky
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Puppy Dog Ploy
“They must have been on my radar screen by early ‘98, but not at the top of my radar screen.”–Steve Ballmer, CEO, Microsoft
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Define the SpaceChange the paradigm
• Intuit – Personal financial software battles were
fought over features: More was better.– “Quicken was the absolute opposite of the
then-existing software paradigm…we didn’t do most of what the other products did. But what we did do happened to be the things that people actually did all the time, like write checks…And we did that stuff very fast and very intuitively.” —Scott Cook
12
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Define the SpaceSegment the Market
• Juniper Networks – Everyone who attacked Cisco in routers
failed by going head-to-head.– Juniper’s Scott Kriens found a different
answer: “We had one chance, which was to enter at the top.” Juniper grabbed 40% of the high-end market, where Cisco’s technological advantages were the weakest.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Follow Through Fast
Build a strong lead before your
competitors learn how to respond.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Follow Through FastMaster speed to market, speed to market share.
• Palm Computing“3COM kept saying, ‘Why are you lowering prices? You own this market.’ And we just kept saying ‘because we should and we want to be aggressive and we’ve got to keep going to market.’”—Ed Colligan
13
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Follow Through FastFocus, focus, focus.
• Palm Computing“We declined most of our licensing opportunities… It’s very hard to say no, but I think those were decisions that we were very good at making.”—Donna Dubinsky
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Principle #2: Balance
Mindset: The Weebles Principle “Weebles wobble, but they
don’t fall down.”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Aesop’s Fable of the Oak & the Reeds
“An oak hanging over a river was uprooted by a violent wind storm and carried downstream. As it floated along it noticed some reeds growing by the bank, and cried out to them, ‘How do such slight, frail things as yourselves manage to stand safely in a storm which can tear me up by the roots?’”
14
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Aesop’s Fable of the Oak & the Reeds
“It was easy enough,’ answered the reeds. ‘Instead of standing stubbornly and stiffly
against it as you did, we yielded and bowed before every wind that blew, and so it went
over us and left us unharmed.’”“It is better to bend than to break.”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Grip Your Opponent
Get in close to make it harder for your competitor to attack.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Grip Your OpponentUse your opponent’s capabilities
to strengthen your position, while retaining your flexibility.
• eBay– “If they had done an AOL Auctions button, it
could have been very bad for us.”—Meg Whitman
– eBay signed its first big distribution deal with AOL, turning its potential rival into a partner
15
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Grip Your OpponentPreempt future combat, giving potential competitors a stake in
your success.
• eBay– In 1999, eBay agreed to pay AOL $75
million over four years; AOL agreed not to enter C2C auctions for two years.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Avoid Tit-for-Tat
Avoid getting dragged into competinghead-to-head.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Avoid Tit-for-TatStudy the competition and
match only their best ideas.
• eBay– Yahoo! enters auctions with a free
service and superior tutorial. – eBay matches the tutorial—not the
price. “People wouldn’t put their junk up for auction if they had to pay even twenty-five cents.”—Meg Whitman
16
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Avoid Tit-for-TatRemain on the offensive even when responding to attack.
• eBay– Yahoo! advertises Yahoo! auctions on
its site. – eBay re-invests in grassroots
marketing (tradeshows), where Yahoo! has no strength.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Push When Pulled
Use your competitors’momentum to your
advantage.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Threat ResponseCompany
Push When Pulled
• Wal*Mart
• Drypers
• Handspring
• Post Kmart circular & guarantee equal or better price
• Accept P&G’s coupons
• “Embrace & extend”Palm through Springboard
• Kmart circular
• Procter & Gamble
• Palm OS installed base
17
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Principle #3: Leverage
Mindset: “Give me where to stand,
and I will movethe earth.”
—Archimedes
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Principle #3: Leverage
Turn your opponent’s strength and size to your advantage.
The key to leverageis attacking where your
competitors have problems responding.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Turn Your Competitor’s Assets Into Liabilities• CNET vs. Ziff Davis & IDG
– CNET’s problem: ZD & IDG control the tech publishing market.
– CNET’s solution: Launch initiatives, such as real-time news, that the incumbents find hard to match.
– The problem for Ziff Davis & IDG:classic cannibalization dilemma.
18
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Turn Your Competitor’s Assets Into Liabilities• Sega vs. Nintendo
– Sega’s problem: Nintendo’s family-oriented brand dominates the market.
– Sega’s solution: Shake up the competition by launching video games aimed at an older audience (Mortal Kombat, e.g.).
– Nintendo’s problem: Destroy its brand equity or lose share.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Turn Your Competitor’s Partners Into Liabilities
• Dell vs. Compaq– Dell’s problem: Compaq’s distribution
network dominates the market.– Dell’s solution: Create a superior
business model based on direct sales.– Compaq’s problem: Match Dell and
alienate its distributors or share and profitability.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Turn Your Competitor’s Competitors Into
Your Friends• Charles Schwab vs. Fidelity
– Schwab’s problem: Fidelity dominates the mutual fund market.
– Schwab’s solution: Partner with Fidelity’s competitors by creating OneSource & “Select List.”
– Fidelity’s problem: Can’t match Schwab without undermining its proprietary funds.
19
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Responding to Judo Strategy
How do you defeat a judo master?
Superior Techniqueor
Sumo StrategyIn contrast to judo, sumo is a “feat of physical
strength” where “weight is a weapon” that is “essential to winning.” —Hikoyama, SUMO, 1940, and
Schilling, Sumo, 1994
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Sumo MindsetTop Dog Ploy
• Look tough and aggressive to deter entry and imitation.
• If entry occurs, the strategic imperative is to turn every battle into a test of strength and change the match from “judo” to “sumo.”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Sumo TechniquesIn sumo, you use your strength
to force your opponentfrom the ring.
• Unnerve the competition– Signal price, signal capacity, use FUD
• Lock ‘em up– Outspend your opponent, lock up
distribution, segment your offering and target retaliation
20
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Sumo Strategy at Work:Microsoft
Deal with Netscape Deal with Microsoft
Intranet customersChevron October 1996 March 1997KPMG January 1997 August 1997ISPs and OLSsAmerica Online March 1996 March 1996AT&T WorldNet August 1995 July 1996CompuServe March 1996 June 1996MCI November 1994 March 1996Prodigy November 1995 October 1996Sprint August 1996 December 1996OEMs and ISVsApple August 1995 August 1997Intuit October 1995 July 1997Lotus/IBM November 1996 July 1997
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Barnes & Noble’s Failure• 1995-97 Amazon’s weakness:
– Depended on fast-growing revenues to fuel stock
– Weak balance sheet and cash flow• Barnes & Noble (.com):
– B&N could have launched a big price war (early) and perhaps stopped Amazon
• By late 1998, it’s too late: – Amazon has bigger valuation and more cash
than B&N, even though B&N is 5x Amazon’s size
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Sumo TechniquesIn sumo, you use your strength
to force your opponentfrom the ring.
• But at the same time, sumo players must always Remember the Rules
• As companies get bigger, different rules apply
21
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Remember the Rules:Intel
The problem, according to Andy Grove:
“We pay marketing, business development, and sales people to be
aggressive. How do you impose this new guard band behavior on a group of people
for whom antitrust is antithetical?”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
• Provide live antitrust training, annually.• Basic dos and don’ts: no price fixing,
no exclusives.• Random audits of employees’ files:
lawyers seize a manager’s papers, disks, and e-mail.
• Stage intensive mock depositions with outside attorney.
Remember the Rules:Intel
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Concluding Thoughts
22
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Importance of Movement
Don’t MoonThe Giant
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Importance of Movement
A Cautionary Tale: Netscape
• Microsoft = the “Death Star”• Windows = “a mundane
collection of not entirely debugged device drivers”
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Importance of Balance
• Don’t stand “stiffly in the wind.”
• Don’t go head-to-head with a giant.
23
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Importance of Balance
Two Cautionary Tales: Novell and Microsoft
• Novell: When Microsoft attacked Novell in networks, Novell went “tit-for-tat”bought WordPerfect, Borland, & UNIX.
• Microsoft vs. Department of Justice—missed opportunities to settle.
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
If you don’t cannibalize yourself, your competitor will!!
The Importance of Responding to Leverage
A Cautionary Tale:Netscape and the
Free Browser Decision“This whole browser fight is going to be interesting. Their ambition to make money on browsers will hurt them—it’s just a case of getting greedy—they are the one who made the rules that browsers are free.”—Bill Gates e-mail, June 1995
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Lessons for Great Judo Strategists
• Maintain a deep focus on your core– “Singularity of focus was most
important… Our strategy is as much the art of exclusion as it is the art of inclusion, or what you’re going to do.”—Meg Whitman
24
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Lessons for Great Judo Strategists
• Stay on the offensive, but avoid frontal assaults– “Play offense and play to win… [But]
try to avoid a frontal assault into an established competitor. Life is too short.”—Scott Cook
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Lessons for Great Judo Strategists
• Look for leverage in the strangest places– “The big asset of younger, smaller
organizations is they can think outside the box.... When you do that, the big competitor often will never respond. They will never get it. They’ll never see it. Or by the time they do it doesn’t matter.”—Scott Cook
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Lessons for Great Judo Strategists
• Face the music– “Nothing good comes from waiting. If
you’re going to change your business model, face the music.”—Dave Pottruck
25
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Final Thoughts: Metaphors & Strategy
“The companies that succeed will be the ones that…employ great metaphors and analogies to define their business and tell their stories.”
– Scott McNealy, “It’s Like…”Forbes ASAP, 2 October 2000
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
Final Thoughts:Metaphors & Strategy
• Metaphors also have risks.– Metaphors abstract away from the real world
• E.g., in judo, you can focus solely on your opponent– Implications:
• Pick your metaphor wisely• Carefully trace its implications• Observe where it fits and where it fails
– If Judo Strategy fits—it can be a powerful tool
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Key to Beating a GiantA willingness to take risks!
• To laugh is to risk appearing a fool.• To weep is to risk appearing sentimental.• To reach out for another is to risk involvement.• To expose your feelings is to risk rejection.• To place your dreams before the crowd is to risk
ridicule.• To love is to risk not being loved in return.• To go forward in the face of overwhelming odds is
to risk failure.
Source: Anonymous, WWW
26
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Key to Beating a GiantA willingness to take risks!• But risk must be taken because the greatest
hazard in life is to risk nothing. The person who risks nothing does nothing, has nothing, is nothing.
• He may avoid suffering and sorrow, but he cannot learn, feel, change, grow, or love. Chained by his certitudes, he is a slave. He has forfeited his freedom.
• Only a person who takes risks is free.
Source: Anonymous, WWW
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission
The Key to Beating a GiantA willingness to take risks!
Only a person who takes risks is
free.Source: Anonymous, WWW
©David B. Yoffie, not for reproduction without permission