juris machina: legal aspects of roboticsrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/juris-machina-we-robot.pdf ·...

32
JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS

Upload: others

Post on 20-May-2020

10 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

JURIS MACHINA:LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS

Page 2: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

PLAN FOR OUR SESSION

1.Basic legal concepts

2.A brief and dizzying tour of robot law

3.Q & A

4.Exercise: Let’s create our own robotics agency!

Page 3: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

NOBODY KNOWS ANYTHING

Page 4: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

THE LAW GETS IT WRONG, OFTEN

Page 5: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

TYPES OF LAW

1. Constitutional law

2. Legislative law

3. Common law

4. Administrative law

5. Equity

6. International law

Page 6: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

LAWMAKERS AND COURTS

Make law Interpret law

Page 7: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

ILLEGALITY AND LIABILITY

Page 8: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

RISK THRESHOLDS AND DISCRETION

Page 9: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

EX ANTE V EX POST

Page 10: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

OVERLAPPING JURISDICTION

NHTSA

FTCProducts Liability

Page 11: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

REASONABLE PERSONS (OBJECTIVITY AND SUBJECTIVITY)

Page 12: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

RULES AND STANDARDS

Page 13: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

TECHNOLOGICAL EXCEPTIONALISM

Page 14: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

A BRIEF AND DIZZYING TOUR OF ROBOT LAW

Page 15: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

A BRIEF AND DIZZYING TOUR OF ROBOT LAW

Private law

1. Torts

2. Contracts

3. Property

Public law

1. Constitutional law

2. Administrative law

3. Criminal law

Page 17: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

LET’S MAKE A DEAL, ROBOT (CONTRACTS)Principal/agent relationships, algorithmic contracts

Page 18: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

I’LL BLOW YOUR ROBOT OUT OF THE SKY (PROPERTY)

Self-defense against robots

Page 19: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

CONSUMER PROTECTION: FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

Page 20: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

CRIMINAL LAW AND PROCEDURE

Page 21: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

DRONES: THE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

Page 22: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION

Page 23: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

AUTOMATED CARS: NATIONAL HIGHWAY TRAFFIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATION

Page 24: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY: UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE

Page 25: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

IMPLANTS: FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION

Page 26: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

HEALTH (AND HEALTH PRIVACY)

Page 27: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT

Page 28: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

NATIONAL SECURITY: DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY

Page 29: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

INTERNATIONAL LAWS

Page 30: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

STANDARDS ORGANIZATIONS

Page 31: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

NOW, AN EXERCISE

The Skinny on

Administrative Agencies

(video)

Page 32: JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICSrobots.law.miami.edu/.../04/Juris-Machina-We-Robot.pdf · JURIS MACHINA: LEGAL ASPECTS OF ROBOTICS. PLAN FOR OUR SESSION 1.Basic legal concepts

WOODROW [email protected]

Twitter:

@hartzog