katherine dydak unc chapel hill make no little plans: the development of the moscow international...

38
Katherin e Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Upload: donald-carpenter

Post on 15-Jan-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Katherine DydakUNC Chapel Hill

MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Page 2: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 3: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 4: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Pudong, Shanghai

Page 5: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 6: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 7: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 8: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

INTRODUCTION

Page 9: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Is the urban form of post-Soviet Moscow converging with the urban form of cities in the West and around the world?

Are Russian planning process and institutions becoming more similar to the ones used in America?

RESEARCH QUESTION

Page 10: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Due to privatization and globalization, Moscow’s urban form is becoming more like the urban form of other world cities.

Processes used to plan projects like the Moscow International Business District are similar to ones used in America and around the world.

However, significant institutional differences remain.

MAIN POINTS

Page 11: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Globalization Moscow’s Urban DevelopmentCase Study: Moscow-City (Москва-Сити)

Moscow International Business Center (MIBC)Conclusions

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

Page 12: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

GLOBALIZATION AND THE DEVELOPMENT

OF WORLD CITIES

Page 13: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

GLOBALIZATION

Page 14: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

GLOBALIZATION

Page 15: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

GLOBALIZATION

Page 16: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

THE HISTORY OF MOSCOW’S URBAN

DEVELOPMENT

Page 17: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 18: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 19: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 20: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 21: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 22: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 23: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 24: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 25: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Characteristi c City Forms Outdated industry in the center city “No-go” zones in the central city Large apartment blocks in rings on the city outskirts Low-quality housing Parks and greenspace Outdoor retail space

Characteristi c City Planning Methods Insuffi cient resources, lag in services Secrecy and insuffi cient coordination Dominance of certain “priority” sectors Consistent underestimation of population size Litt le effi cacy

MOSCOW’S URBAN DEVELOPMENT

Page 26: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY(МОСКВА-СИТИ)

Page 27: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 28: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 29: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 30: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 31: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 32: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 33: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 34: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

MOSCOW-CITY

Page 35: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT
Page 36: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

CONCLUSIONS

Page 37: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

Is the urban form of post-Soviet Moscow converging with the urban form of citi es in the West and around the world?Yes, due to privatization and globalization, Moscow’s

urban form is becoming more like the urban form of established capitalist cities.

Are Russian planning process and insti tuti ons becoming more similar to the ones used in America? In some cases, like the Moscow City Development, yes,

but not uniformly and not for the average Russian city planner.

CONCLUSIONS

Page 38: Katherine Dydak UNC Chapel Hill MAKE NO LITTLE PLANS: THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MOSCOW INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS DISTRICT

I’M READY FOR QUESTIONS.