kmart final draft
TRANSCRIPT
K-mart is expanding beyond the shores of America and our team has determined Hungary to be a
suitable location to open a store. This report examines the situation analysis, communication
objectives, target group, creative strategy, promotion strategy, media strategy, budget allocation
and control & evaluation that this undertaking will involve.
K-SmartLaunching K-mart in Hungary
By
Rebeka Selmeczki, Rina Razali, Elizabeth McCrudden, Aaron Ho (Jin), John Brennan & Danielle Dalla
Table of Contents
Executive Summary....................................................................................................................... 4
Situation Analysis........................................................................................................................... 4Mission and Vision.................................................................................................................................... 5Kmart in Australia..................................................................................................................................... 6Kmart Community Program 2010....................................................................................................... 6Past Failures................................................................................................................................................ 7Past and Current Kmart Communication Campaigns...................................................................8Hungarian Retail Market........................................................................................................................ 9SWOT Analysis............................................................................................................................................ 9
Competitor Analysis.................................................................................................................... 10Hungarian Hypermarkets and Supermarkets..............................................................................10Tesco........................................................................................................................................................... 11Louis Delhaize Group............................................................................................................................. 13
Country Selection......................................................................................................................... 14
Country Overview: Hungary..................................................................................................... 17
Market Environment.................................................................................................................. 19Retail in Hungary.................................................................................................................................... 19Trends in the CE Retail Market...........................................................................................................20
Consumers prefer larger shop formats.........................................................................................................20Retail sales are constantly growing................................................................................................................20Discount stores push super- and hypermarkets out of their position............................................21Cities are reaching the point of saturation..................................................................................................21“Polarization” of customers is continuing....................................................................................................21
Communication Objectives....................................................................................................... 22
Target Audience........................................................................................................................... 24
Message & Positioning............................................................................................................... 30Main Message........................................................................................................................................... 30Justification............................................................................................................................................... 30Competitor Comparison....................................................................................................................... 31Global Image............................................................................................................................................. 32New Positioning....................................................................................................................................... 32Single Selling Idea................................................................................................................................... 33
Media............................................................................................................................................... 35Competitive Environment.................................................................................................................... 36Tone............................................................................................................................................................. 37Non-traditional Media........................................................................................................................... 38
Advent Calendar......................................................................................................................................................38St. Nicholas Day Mail Out.....................................................................................................................................39Loyalty Cards............................................................................................................................................................39Kmart Wishing Tree.............................................................................................................................................. 40
Audience Appeal...................................................................................................................................... 40Action Prompts........................................................................................................................................ 41
2
Differentiation Points............................................................................................................................ 41Cultural Considerations........................................................................................................................ 42Rules and Regulations........................................................................................................................... 43Tag Line...................................................................................................................................................... 43
Evaluation...................................................................................................................................... 44
References:.......................................................................................................................................................... 45
3
Executive Summary
For this report , what will be found inside is a brief situational analysis of K-mart ,
some of their success and failures over the past few years, mission & visions, and
many more.
In this report, we are launching K-Mart into Hungary , and what is expected to be
found inside is information on the Hungarian retail industry, strengths & weakness of
K-Mart and major competitors in Hungary. This will also help explain the market
environment on how it is sustaining over there.
This report also help explains why we have chosen to enter in the country of
Hungary , why we target specific groups, why we launched during Christmas and
most of all how we are going to target the Hungarians during the launch of this
campaign.
The media tools will also be included in this report , in which it will explain some of
the different types of media tools used and why it was selected to be used to
advertised in Hungary specifically.
Situation Analysis
Kmart is a US hypermarket, which is currently the third largest in the US behind Wal-
Mart and Target. Kmart was first established in 1918. It expanded its operation
throughout the United States and into Canada in 1929, and Australia in 1968. It is a
mass merchandising company. As of January 30, 2010, Kmart operates a total of
1,327 Kmart stores across 49 states. Kmart became famous in the US for its "Blue
4
Light Specials." They occurred at surprise moments when a store worker would light
up a mobile police light and offer a discount in a specific department of the store.
The phrase "attention Kmart shoppers" became so infamous that entered into the
American pop psyche and quoted in a number of movies. Kmart sells name-brand
and private-label goods mostly to low and middle-income families along with a
portfolio of exclusive brands and labels. The Company's stores are usually single
floor, freestanding units, in sizes from 40,000 to 190,000 square feet. Kmart stores
are usually free-standing or located within shopping complexes.
Mission and VisionMission Statement:
Kmart will become the discount store of choice for middle-income families with
children by satisfying their routine and seasonal shopping needs as well as or better
than the competition (Kmart.com)
"We are committed to improving the lives of our customers by providing quality
services, products and solutions that earn their trust and build lifetime relationships."
The Five Key Pillars of Our Strategy
1. Creating lasting relationships with customers by empowering them to manage
their lives
2. Attaining best in class productivity and efficiency.
3. Building our brands
4. Reinventing the company continuously through technology and innovation.
5. Reinforcing “The SHC Way” by living our values every day"
What is the image and personality of the brand?
5
Kmart’s personality and image are explicably linked. Kmart’s image is that of a family
friendly, convenient and an affordable store. They cater for the many needs of a
family and the individual and aim to create lasting relationships with their consumers.
The image presented to the public is affordable and quality products and service.
The personality of Kmart is created through their advertisements. This personality
focuses on families and wholesome fun. Kmart also positions itself as a part of the
community through creating and sponsoring events and organisations within
individual communities. This re-enforces its family orientated image and personality.
Kmart in Australia
Kmart currently operates one hundred and eighty two stores throughout Australia
and New Zealand. Currently Kmart has a wide range of philanthropy efforts to re-
enforce its family orientated image and personality.
Kmart Community Program 2010
The Kmart Community program is committed to building strong partnerships with
individuals and organisations that will help create better lives for Australian and New
Zealand families (REF). It aims to support the issues that are important to the
communities that surround individual stores. Kmart finically supported over 1000
small community groups during 2008 and 2009. The Kmart wishing tree is one of the
most well known philanthropic efforts and collected over 400,000 gifts and $90,000
in 2008/2009.
Kmart has focused on the need to not only be differentiated in each country, but also
to do so in each community. It has recognised that the local communities around
6
each of its stores face their own unique social challenges. With this in mind, the
community program allows each store to work directly with its own community on
relevant social needs or issues. Thus “creating lasting relationships with customers
by empowering them to manage their lives”, which is one of the five key pillars of
Kmart’s strategy.
Past FailuresIn 2002 Kmart filed for reorganisation under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy
Code, closing almost 300 stores. The company’s lack of set goals and
communication objectives led to many of their problems. Most of these problems
were ill-conceived expansion initiatives and communication strategies. Kmart began
to run into trouble when the company started to implement elaborate diversifications
in its overall business plan. These large-scale attempts, such as the purchase of the
Sports Authority and Builders Square, distracted Kmart from its primary business of
being a discount retail store. Although Kmart had a successful vision, it lost track of
where it really stood in the marketplace. The communication efforts of the business
became inconsistent and confusing to consumers. Kmart’s slogan during the mid
1990's was “Low prices and extras you won’t find anywhere else”. Consumer
research showed that the advertising led consumers to expect to find great deals, a
pleasant shopping atmosphere and a good selection of merchandise. Shoppers had
difficulty matching the advertising with the reality of a Kmart store. This ultimately led
to a rapid decline in the store’s credibility.
From this failure several key lessons have been identified:
1. Concentrate on brand identity and perceptions of Kmart. Stay consistent.
7
2. Ensure that advertising is a real refection of the image and personality of the
store. Highlight the positive experiences and feelings consumers have of the
brand.
3. Reinvent and diversify Kmart in Hungary, whilst maintaining the key aspects
of the brand identity.
4. Deliver on promises to consumers.
Past and Current Kmart Communication Campaigns
One of Kmart's most successful campaigns in the US used celebrity endorsement.
This campaign was created shortly after Kmart came close to bankruptcy. In an effort
to drive up sales and re-establish credibility Kmart used Rosie O’Donnell and Penny
Marshall in their advertisements. This campaign proved to be a huge success. The
campaign spanned several years. In the second year of the campaign sales
increased 2.9 percent and the overall earnings almost doubled from the previous
years. Rosie O’Donnell and Penny Marshall where successful endorsements as they
were figures consumers could relate to and trust.
In 2002 Kmart established a new brand positioning as a store that understands
family values in an effort to strike an emotional chord with shoppers. The ads were
first shown during the 2002 Olympic closing ceremony. Kmart aimed to be "the store
that understands what really matters in life." It aimed to focus on how the retailer
appreciates values important in shoppers' lives (such as putting family first) and
showing an appreciation for money and practicality. Steven Feuling, Senior Vice
President of marketing at Kmart stated "Kmart's goal with this campaign is to build
an emotional bond with the consumer by re-establishing the role Kmart plays in its
shoppers' lives,” (http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0FNP/is_5_41/ai_83805296/)
8
Hungarian Retail MarketThe majority of Hungary’s retailers are foreign owned. However there are a number
of large domestic business including CBA and Coop. Tesco is the leader in the
hypermarket chains with 164 stores in Hungary. The share of hypermarkets in the
retail market is increasing at the cost of small local corner shops. The rising
affluence in Hungary has affected how people purchase their goods and the channel
in which they do so. Retailing in Hungary follows the German and Austrian model,
with very few retail outlets opened in the evenings or on a Sunday. However, in
recent years there has been an increase in the number of convenient store outlets
operating extended trading hours. Hypermarkets in Hungary account for
approximately 22% of all fast moving consumer goods spending (FMCG). It is
anticipated that the market share of hypermarkets and supermarkets will continue to
expand.
SWOT AnalysisStrengths
- Cheap/affordable – inline with
Hungarian values in shopping
- Differentiated poisoning from
competitors
- Central location and convenient size
- 'One stop shop'
-Success in a variety of foreign markets
in the past
- Hungarian retail hypermarket is
expected to continue expanding
Weaknesses
- New Brand
- No brand loyalty
- American brand – may have some
negative views towards it
- Limited diversification to local wants
and needs and products
- Kmart’s values are brought in from the
US, rather than developed in-country,
means they are set at a global, rather
than local level - can restrict local
9
adaptation
- Ineffective Supply Chain Management
Failure in Prague
Opportunities
- To diversify product lines to local
market
- Create loyalty schemes
- Design the store to be more organized
and attractive
- Chance to learn from past mistakes
Threats
- High amount of established
competition
- Language and culture barriers
- Hypermarkets account for less than 40
percent of retail market in Hungary
- Highly successful competitors
- Consumers holding adverse attitudes
towards foreign business
- Misunderstanding of Hungarian culture
10
Competitor Analysis
Hungarian Hypermarkets and Supermarkets
(http://www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/retail-consumer/pdf/hungary.pdf)
Tesco
Tesco is the current market leader in Hungary. It first opened in 1995 and currently
has 164 stores and 21, 365 staff. Hungary has been the most successful market for
Tesco in Central Europe. Tesco’s largest store in the world is in Budaors, Budapest.
It is 15,000 sq m which is the equivalent of 72 tennis courts.
Unlike many other retailers Tesco aims to appeal to all segments of the market. It
achieves this through the use of its own-brand products. This includes the up market
"Finest" range of products, a mid-range Tesco brand and low-price "Value" range.
These encompass several product categories such as food, beverage, home,
clothing, Tesco Mobile and financial services. Tesco's main advertising slogan is
"Every little helps". This slogan has been translated appropriately for the Hungarian
market.
11
Their core purpose is to create value for customers and to earn their lifetime loyalty.
Tesco has a large focus on people, stating that:
“Our success depends on people: the people who shop with us and the people who
work with us. If our customers like what we offer, they are more likely to come back
and shop with us again. If the Tesco team find what we do rewarding, they are more
likely to go that extra mile to help our customers”.
Tesco’s Value and Mission statement is “Creating value for customers, to earn their
lifetime loyalty”. Tesco strive to fully understand their customers, be the first to meet
their needs and act responsibly for our communities. Tesco in Hungary offers a
clothing line and personal finance services. This finance service is in line with
Tesco’s mission to create value for customers and to earn their lifetime loyalty.
Tesco has created an “Every Little Helps” International Strategy. With more than ten
years of experience overseas, Tesco has evolved an international strategy based on
six elements:
1. Be flexible - each market is unique and requires a different approach.
2. Act local - local customers, local cultures, local supply chains and local
regulations require a tailored offer delivered by local staff.
12
3. Maintain focus - we understand that customers want great service, great choice
and great value. To become established as the leading local brand is a long term
effort and is not about planting flags in map.
4. Use multi-formats - no single format can reach the whole of the market. A whole
spectrum from convenience to hypermarkets is essential and you need to take a
discounter approach throughout.
5. Develop capability - it's not about scale, it's about skill - so we make sure we
have capability through people, processes and systems.
6. Build brands - brands enable the building of important lasting relationships with
customers.
Louis Delhaize Group
Louis Delhaize currently has six hypermarkets in Hungary and is working on the
construction of another three hypermarkets across the country. All of the group's
stores in Hungary target the Budapest area and the larger eastern region. The
consumer goods stocked by Louis Delhaize include food and 'near-food' goods, i.e.
products such as toiletries, cleaning products and other hygienic products bought. In
addition, it also provides non-food products such as cloths, sport equipment,
13
household electronic appliances, etc. The stores are located on the outer locations of
towns/cities, often up to a thirty minute drive. Louis Delhaize has a strong brand
affiliation with eco-homecare products. The Belgium company has committed itself to
enlarging and promoting the set of eco-friendly product ranges within their points of
sale from 2009 to 2012.
Country Selection
14
For this campaign, we have shortlisted 2 countries that we decided would be the
best selection to launch our Kmart store. The countries are Malaysia and Hungary.
In order to make the selection, we had to go through various kinds of research, find
out information on both countries and make comparison on which would be the best
country for our Kmart campaign.
This research seeks to provide a broad picture of the economic, social and cultural
background to the country selected, as well as highlighting the challenges and
opportunities for retail and consumer goods companies, like Kmart, wishing to invest
there.
The template of this research was structured around three main investigation topics:
1. Economic overview and regulatory environment;
2. Demographics and consumer behaviour;
3. Retail & consumer goods sector: performance, challenges, opportunities
and emerging trends.
15
Source: PwC Country reports, Observatoire Vigie
Among all the countries listed, the study pinpoints both our choices; Malaysia and
Hungary as being safe investment destinations which represent general
opportunities for development in the short or longer term.
Increasing consumer demand and the existence of a burgeoning middle-class make
Malaysia an extremely interesting destination for investment. In addition, a young
population, low unemployment and a growing modern retail sector all contribute to
this country’s extremely attractive investment climate.
On the other hand, Hungary is in the first group of countries to have acceded to the
EU and Budapest, its capital, has a tradition of being a financial and managerial hub
in the region.
16
Although it has a fast maturing retail and consumer market, there are still
opportunities left for investment there for hypermarkets, convenience stores and
specialised outlets especially outside the capital.
In order to launch our investment programmes for the long-term, we have to be
aware of the current regulatory constraints in the retail sector and always bear in
mind the unstable political climate in the selected countries. Malaysia has some
constraint and potentially low risk to that as opposed to Hungary, which has non-
significant constraint on the regulatory and has no risk, which puts Hungary slightly
ahead as a choice.
Country Overview: Hungary
Population: 9.9 million.
The main cities are Budapest (1.7mn),Debrecen (204,300), Miskolc (175,700) 17
(IGD, 2008).
Official Language: Hungarian (also known as Magyar)
Currency: Hungarian Forint
€1 = 261 Forints
(ECB, October 2008)
Economy is one of the weakest among the new EU countries.
Huge budget deficit (10% of GDP),rising inflation (due to foreign exchange
differences), and tax hikes forecast
(IMF, 2007).
Unemployment rate
The percent of the labour force that is without jobs is 10.8% (2009) It is at no. 121 in
comparison to the world.
Disposable income
Hungarians have an average of €5,549 per year at their disposal. Budapest is by far
Hungary’s most affluent city with an average per person disposable income of
€7,503, an amount around €1,000 more than the neighbouring county of “Budaors”,
whose inhabitants have a purchasing power of €6,568. Despite Budapest’s high-
ranking position within Hungary, its inhabitants still only have half as much money at
their disposal as Germany’s poorest county. Even so, 21 of Budapest’s 23
municipalities are among Hungary’s 40 most affluent. The most affluent municipality
“Budapest 12” – boasts a purchasing power of €8,988 per person.
(GfK Purchasing Power Europe 2008/2009)
18
Market Environment
Retail in Hungary
Retail market structure Top 10
19
Source: IGD Analysis, Country Presentation, Hungary
Share of shop types in sales of daily consumer goods in Hungary (%)
Source : GfK Consumer Tracking and GfK expert estimate 2013
20
Trends in the CE Retail Market
There are currently several major trends in Central European retail that are to a
certain extent common to all CE countries, such as Hungary:
Consumers prefer larger shop formats
The market share of small businesses, groceries and local markets is constantly
declining in favour of the homogenised supermarkets, hypermarkets and discounts.
Retail sales are constantly growing
Retail sales are likely to continue growing at a substantial rate despite last year’s
slump in some countries. This growth is especially significant in Hungary where,
according to data analyst Mintel, sales are estimated to triple between 2000 – 2010.
Discount stores push super- and hypermarkets out of their position
Discount stores with their aggressive marketing are succesfully attracting increasing
numbers of customers. Partly because of lower levels of income, price is still a
determining factor for a large part of customers in CE. Discount stores are likely to
gain bigger shares of the market and to expand further into more CE countries.
Cities are reaching the point of saturation
As the retail market in major cities is nearing saturation, retail chains are exploring
opportunities further afield in more rural areas, bolstering sales and converting
consumer habits.
“Polarization” of customers is continuing
Despite the determining role of price in consumers decisions described above, the
number of shoppers who choose the best quality products instead of the least
expensive is increasing. More customers are also beginning to better appreciate the 21
quality of services provided as well as ease and comfort of shopping instead of
simply the value for money factor.
The demand for premium products and convenience are the driving factors behind
value growth across the Hungarian retail industry, with consumers increasingly
viewing their purchases as status symbols. Yet, local consumption patterns vary
significantly according to income, with the average wage of US$19,985 being much
lower than professional salaries. The government’s austerity programme, which has
reduced consumer expenditure, also means that many consumers are extremely
price-conscious
Communication Objectives
What we will be trying to achieve with our communication efforts is to launch our
campaign whilst promoting brand awareness among Hungarians. Since K-Mart is an
unknown brand in Hungary, there will be few pre-existing attitudes towards the
company in consumer’s minds. This can be both positive and negative. We will be
entering the Hungarian market with a strategic marketing plan centered on family
and value for money. This approach is grounded in research confirming that
Hungarians are price sensitive shoppers, who treasure their family values and
community spirit. ( Emerald Insight )
Hard discounted shops and hypermarkets are on the rise, and there is a huge
opportunity for stores such as this to be extremely successful. Hungarians seem to
be price sensitive across a range of products and services (Hubpages).
22
Included in our campaign will be information leading to general brand awareness, as
very little is known about the brand throughout Hungary. Through this we will be
promoting the wide variety of products that the store offers.
The positioning we want to occupy in the consumers’ minds is that it is a store that
provides the average family with a range of products to suit their everyday needs.
These will all be provided at an affordable price without compromising quality or
service. Family is important to K-Mart because the stores offer goods that are
suitable for many age groups. This aspect will be even more important in Hungary as
the population places such a large importance on community. Hungarians are more
family orientated than westerners, so it is more appropriate to target families rather
than individuals (Filolog).
This campaign will introduce brand recall into the minds of Hungarians, as it will
ultimately lead to consumers thinking of the brand when they desire one of these
family products.
Our communication objectives will be achieved through incorporating these elements
into all aspects of the campaign. Not only will our advertising and promotion educate
consumers on what stocks the brand carries, but it will create brand awareness and
a more long-term positive attitude in the minds of our target audience.
We will be utilising several forms of media to achieve our objectives. For more
information, please see below.
Our communication strategy hinges on our belief that a positive attitude towards a
brand will bring back customers and promote loyalty in our consumers. We will
achieve this loyalty through effective pricing and promotions designed to appeal to
23
Hungarians natural family values and their instinct for good value. This will result in a
positive brand image and satisfied customers.
Target Audience
K-mart’s target audience in Hungary will be fundamentally defined by the following:
The Hungarian population is extremely price sensitive so there will be a focus
on the fact that K-mart is affordable for this audience.
The target audience will be apart of the middle-lower income bracket as they
are the part of the population that would be most attracted to affordable
goods.
Hungarians are very family orientated more so than western countries, so
there will be a focus on the fact that K-Mart can offer a happy shopping
environment for the entire family
The main age demographics that will be targeted is 25-55 year old mothers,
since females in Hungary engage in household shopping more than the
males
24
The location of K-Mart will be a highlighted feature for the target audience as
all K-Mart stores will be situated in close proximity to smaller cities and towns
throughout Hungary not solely in the bigger cities
Hungary is an ageing population since there are more deaths each year than births.
The average size of a family is 2.6 people. The Hungarian demographic profile
consists of the following recorded statistical fact, recorded in July 2009:
The population rate sits at 9.905.596 million
The age structure shows that 15% of the population is 0-14 years of age
and that 69.3% of the population is between the ages of 15-64 years and
15.8% of the population is over 65 years old
The median age works out to be 39.4 years (Indexmundi)
Teenagers and children are not included as the primary target audience not only
because they are a small percentage of the population but mainly because they do
not have a steady income. The primary target audience is between ages 25-55 year
old mothers, who need to shop for the entire family. The secondary target audience
is the entire family under one collective group. Hungary has many small cities, town
and villages so the location of K-Mart will be spread throughout the country so
consumers can get there easily without having to drive to the closest biggest city.
Some traits in consumer behaviour in Hungary that need to be kept in mind are due
to the fact that the Hungarian market is extremely price sensitive meaning that other
consumer satisfaction measures assume less importance, this means that there is a
huge opportunity for hard discounters to be successful. Consumer brand loyalty and
awareness is not as prominent in Hungary as in other Western countries and lower
than other Central and Eastern European averages. Some ways to improve brand
25
loyalty in Hungary is by the introduction of brand loyalty cards, which can be used in
cinemas, hypermarkets, bookstores and so on. This would work well in Hungary
since price is the most important factor in the consumers mind. Electronics has
become a huge demand in Hungary therefore many chains of electronic goods
stores have opened, employing up to 70 000 people, which is a positive fact in the
Hungarian consumers mind since it has opened opportunity for the unemployed. The
winning formats in Hungary are known to be hypermarkets, discount and DIY stores
(Euromonitor).
It is statistically observed that currently there are 8 million people in the Hungarian
population that are subscribed to a mobile phone, the Hungarian population sits at
10 million. The Internet subscribers sit only at 3 million from the entire population,
therefore there is a significant difference in numbers of mobile and Internet users in
Hungary. There has been an increase in internet usage, meaning that our target
audience’s attention can be obtained over the internet yet majority still use telephone
to communicate more and TV to gather daily information, so TV and other mediums
should be more of a priority over internet for this target audience.
In order to establish a set of psychographics in Hungary, the mentality of the people
in this nation need to be looked upon the values, behaviour and thinking are the core
motives behind this task. Unlike many ‘Communist Eastern European’ Hungarians
are not a collectivist culture instead it is better defined as a ‘moderately
individualistic’ culture, although it is viewed as significantly less so than most Anglo-
Western cultures. Below is a list of key differences between Hungarian mentality and
Anglo-Western mentality, this is important to be able to see what really motivates or
does not motivate the target audience:
26
Anglo-culture is built on key ideas of competence, product, project, task =
“what I accomplish” whereas Hungarian culture has key ideas built upon
relationships “who I am, who I belong to”
People in Hungary are traditionally expected to put the interest of their family
or group where they belong, before their own interest rather than looking after
individual needs and interests
Hungarians are big on forming their own, unique, different opinions (2
Hungarians means 3 opinions) whereas Anglo-westerners are expected to
have a private opinion
Personal happiness comes from relationships: maintaining a happy family,
creating a progressing society, having fulfilling personal relationships, and
being able to “look in the mirror” with self respect (have not over-compromised
personal values) whereas Anglo-Westerners are driven by self-actualization
by each individual is an ultimate goal
The uncertainty inherent in life is felt as a threat which must be fought
whereas in the Anglo-Western world uncertainty is a normal feature of life and
each day is accepted as it comes
Acceptance of familiar risks; fear of unknown situations and of unfamiliar
risks. What is different is dangerous whereas in the Anglo-Western world what
is different, is curious
Pessimism is a state of mind with Hungarians, realism is a value which in
Anglo-Westerners is the opposite, optimism to always assume the good.
(Filolog- Hungarian Mentality)
So it can be seen quite clearly that the psychographics for Hungarians differ to the
Anglo-Western world. This means the way in which we communicate to our 27
audiences will be different. It appears through this list even more that the
psychographics in Hungary match very much our target audience in the way that
they are very family orientated and that these aspects of lifestyle are highly
prioritized.
“Compared to Americans, Hungarians have a significantly stronger tendency to
avoid life’s uncertainties. This means that new situations, unknown people or
circumstances cause greater stress to the individual, and is usually looked at as a
potential problem or danger, rather than a challenge (Filolog- Hungarian Mentality)”
Hungarians can be afraid of trying new things and don’t appreciate constant change
in their lifestyle. It would therefore be wise to slowly introduce K-Mart to the target
audience rather than advertising it too heavily and not to take an ‘in-your-face’
approach to marketing.
28
29
Message & Positioning
Main Message
The main message we are trying to communicate in this communication plan is that
K-mart is affordable and part of the Hungarian community. Both of these aspects of
the creative are directly linked to ingrained Hungarian beliefs and attitudes. As
mentioned previously, family is incredibly important to the almost the entire
Hungarian population, as is value for money and cost-saving. The primary message
of the campaign will therefore focus on these key elements.
In line with the primary message the brand will be launched just prior to Christmas,
with all marketing promotions relating directly to this event. Christmas is integral to
the Hungarian community and complements our key strategic goals perfectly.
Justification
As mentioned above in the Target Audience profile, Hungarians value respect and
inclusion within their family life. The culture echoes that of their previous political
affiliation, with a high degree of socialist values still present within most communities.
Hungary’s culture is not defined as collectivist, but their society still contains more
elements of this than other Western cultures. Because Hungarians value this aspect
of their lives so highly, we will be promoting K-Mart initially as a store that is part of
the community. We intend for this to establish K-Mart as a trusted and highly
regarded brand that is part of the Hungarian way of life.
30
The second key element of our positioning will be the affordability of K-Mart’s
products. Affordability is likely be a determining factor as to whether consumers
decide to shop in our store, as the Hungarian market is extremely price-sensitive.
With brand loyalty exceedingly low, consumers in Hungary, and indeed in most of
Eastern Europe, tend to base their purchase decisions almost purely on price.(REF)
We will therefore be careful to promote K-Mart as a discount brand, one that
represents good value for money. This approach was adopted in a nearby store in
Prague, with great success (REF).
Competitor Comparison
Tesco is Hungary’s main retail hypermarket chain, and will therefore be K-Mart’s
biggest competitor. Tesco’s strategy in Hungary and throughout most countries it has
launched in has been to emphasize its large size and buying power. This approach
has been successful at promoting the company’s superior buying power and the
range of goods available within their stores. However, Tesco has received some
negative publicity centring on their decision to install stores in such large spaces.
Tesco planned to build one of their hypermarkets in Dunaújváros, a small town
located 70km south of Budapest. While residents of the town supported the idea of
having a large retailer nearby, the planned project required that 9 hectares of noise-
reducing forest be cut down. Almost the entire population of the town signed a
petition requesting that Tesco not build there, and legal action was brought against
the company (REF). While these were ultimately unsuccessful, it shows that it is
important for companies entering a new environment to be mindful of local attitudes
and beliefs. Tesco received a large amount of bad press related to the above
incident, with community groups promising to boycott the store once it was
31
completed. When considering the above for K-Mart, it is important to take community
attitudes into account before launching.
Global Image
By focussing on families we are supporting the global brand image of K-mart being a
family friendly, community orientated shopping experience. The campaign will also
echo the brand’s discount image, as there will be a large emphasis on the low prices
and savings that can be taken advantage of throughout K-Mart. Our philanthropic
efforts will be consistent with the company’s continuing work with global charities,
while genuinely benefitting local communities. In Hungary K-Mart we will therefore
build on the brand’s American values and image as a trusted store with quality,
reasonably priced products, whilst establishing new elements of the brand, primarily
in the areas of community and convenience.
New Positioning
As mentioned above, K-Mart will be taking on a slightly different positioning than has
been adopted in other areas. Whilst still focussing on family values and affordability,
we will also introduce convenience to the consumer in a completely new way. This
strategy will be drawing on Tesco’s experiences with promotion of a large store, and
the difficulties of such an operation. We also wanted to differentiate K-Mart from
Tesco through this positioning. This plan is outlined below.
This unique positioning will focus on smaller stores with higher output and quicker
sales. Referring to (REF), this method will promote the store as a “fast retailer,”
which is smarter and more convenient for both the customer and the store owner.
The benefit to the consumer with this approach will be twofold. Firstly, the stores will
be more convenient and centrally located, because they will be smaller and easier to 32
fit into existing shopping centres. This will mean less travel time and expenses for
the consumer, and increased numbers of walk-by shoppers for the retailer.
Secondly, the smaller stores will be more personal and relatable than a store with a
large and unfriendly warehouse design. Consumers will feel more comfortable and
will be able to navigate their way through the stores faster and easily with this layout.
K-Mart will be the fast retailer in both location and size with a limited store layout
ensuring customers don’t spend hours searching for the perfect gifts for their families
during Christmas. The store will however be big enough to offer a range of clothes,
toys, food, electrical appliances and other home goods at reasonable prices.
K-mart will be positioned as a store that is larger than traditional local shops, whilst
maintaining the prices of its ‘superstore’ competitors, such as Tesco. This is because
Tesco promotes their stores size, which has resulted in negative community attitudes
towards the brand. We will instead focus on highlighting why K-mart is smaller and
its benefits to the consumer. The store will be positioned as more conveniently
located and easier to navigate than its major competitors, while still providing similar
low cost, quality products.
Single Selling Idea
K-Mart’s core selling proposition will relate to the values associated with the
Hungarian family. All secondary selling ideas stem directly from families and
Hungarian community values. From this core selling proposition the links to
Christmas and convenience are clearly drawn, and from this the price and the
affordability of goods becomes important. Christmas is a time for families, sharing,
gift-giving and ultimately shopping. Convenience in their shopping experience is
highly important for families as this is crucial period when an individual’s time is so
33
important. And lastly, affordability of family items is crucial for every household,
especially in Hungarian culture, as they are extremely price sensitive. It is clear then
that by focussing on K-Mart’s relationship with the average family in our creatives,
we will encompass all of the relevant selling propositions. This also reinforces part of
K-Mart’s mission statement to create long lasting relationships with its customers.
34
Media
For this campaign we are focusing heavily on media that directly targets women with
families aged 25-45 years in middle to low-income house holds. To do so we are
using media that reaches the audience in their homes and reminds them of their
families. We are using direct mail and radio as our main media lines as well as
newspapers; magazines and event sponsorship to further convey our message.
Hungary has tight regulations regarding what children can be shown doing in
advertisements including touching dogs, eating ice putting things in their mouths,
and walking around without shoes. We have taken these into consideration when
designing our campaign and have ensured that they are adhered to.
We are launching the campaign in time for Christmas in Hungary and are using key
dates such as the 6th of December (St Nicholas day) to launch each phase. Direct
mail will arrive at targeted households on the day (see creative for details), and
advent calendars and radio promotions will keep K-mart in top of mind positioning
throughout.
After the festive season, sporting events such as water polo and football (soccer)
and charity (heart disease & cancer) fundraising days will continue to promote K-
mart to the Hungarian target market.
35
Competitive Environment
In 2009, the Hungarian Competition Office (GVH) fined Tesco HUF8m ($42,000 US)
for its use of "unfair business practices.” Tesco was investigated for infringing
36
Hungary's Act on Unfair Commercial Practices, after it infringed ‘point five’ of the
blacklist, which bans bait advertising. Tesco advertised goods without sufficient
stocks, resulting in consumers not being able to buy the goods they desired to.
Tesco was also found to be advertising electronic devices to have attributes they did
not have in reality. This is an important issue Kmart will have to take into
consideration as Kmart in the past has had serious issues with being out of stock on
fast moving items.
Louis Delhaize has a strong brand affiliation with eco-homecare products. The
Belgium company has committed itself to enlarging and promoting the set of eco-
friendly product ranges within their points of sale from 2009 to 2012.
Tone
The tone of the creative campaign to launch K-Mart in Hungary will be friendly and
personable. It is important that family values and the affordability of K-Mart’s
products are accentuated, whilst differentiating the company from its main
competitors. Because of our unique approach to shop location and size, our
customers will be able to do their Christmas shopping in an area nearby; the K-Mart
will almost act as a local store. The tone of our advertising will highlight this
community orientated personality and image of the store.
We will be communicating to our target audience that won’t have to drive out to the
outlying areas of town for a good deal, but will instead be offered the convenience of
a large retailer in a central location. Our tone will reflect this through advertisements
that are friendly, relatable, and emphasize K-Marts commitment to the Hungarian
community.
37
Non-traditional Media
Both traditional and non-traditional forms of media will be used in this campaign. As
the primary consumption of media in Hungary is through newspapers, magazines
and radio, a series of advertisements will be developed for each of these. As well as
these, several non-traditional forms of advertising will be developed. These include:
Advent Calendar
This promotional effort will reflect the Christmas season and will promote brand
awareness and draw people for the first time into the store. The advent calendar will
be a fun and interactive activity for families. It will essentially be an innovative
catalogue, with a calendar counting down the days until Christmas. It will feature 25
windows (one for each day up until Christmas) that the user may open, inside which
will be information for a discount on a particular item in store, or a simple holiday
greeting. One of the windows will have a direction to draw awareness to the “K-Mart
wishing tree,” which will be operating on that day in stores across Hungary. The
window for the 6th of December will reference St. Nicholas day, and will remind
people to put their stockings out for the event. The calendar will feature Christmas
images, and of course will be K-Mart branded. This form of promotion is integral to
our branding strategy of family, as Christmas is something that the whole family
looks forward to celebrating together; this calendar will help them count down the
days until this is possible.
The advent calendar will be available in-store, but will also be distributed through
direct mail initiatives and will be included as a lift-out in major newspapers and
38
magazines. The calendar encourages interaction and offers genuine discounts to
customers who have one. (See Appendix 2 for sample)
St. Nicholas Day Mail Out
The 6th of December is St. Nicholas day in Hungary, a traditional holiday where
children put their best boots out in order to be filled with presents and Hungarian
string chocolates. We plan to tie K-Mart to this event through a direct mail out
promotion that will be received by customers just before St. Nicholas day. These
mail-outs will be distributed among areas of the population where our target
audience are located, as this is traditionally who celebrates this holiday.
The mail-out will be in the shape of a boot, to make an obvious connection with the
holiday. The user must rip open the envelope through a perforated edge at the top of
the boot, and will find inside a K-Mart branded, flat, string chocolate. These flat
chocolates are traditional in Hungary and are an integral part of the holiday(REF).
Included in each boot will be a special offer for customers, likely a “Buy one get one
free for a friend” type of promotion, used to encourage more first-time customers into
the store. This will draw comparisons between the brand and the event, and will
bring K-Mart to the forefront of the consumers mind when considering St. Nicholas
day. The promotion will also promote goodwill and K-Mart’s commitment to
remaining a family brand. (See Appendix 3 for sample)
Loyalty Cards
Loyalty cards will be available for customers to sign-up to. Users will submit their
details, and in return they will receive a card that entitles them to 5% off in-store. In
addition, loyalty card holders will be invited to special events, be given information
39
about sales and offers in-store via targeted direct mail-outs, and will be privy to
“Loyalty card only” deals on selected items. This tactic is particularly important in
Hungary because consumers rarely practice brand loyalty and are swayed mostly by
price. By introducing a system that effectively tempts consumers to be loyal through
repeated discounts, we will ensure continued sales. The card will also link to our key
selling proposition of family by referring to the loyalty members as part of the “K-Mart
Community Club,” driving sales through consumers need to belong. (See Appendix
4 for sample)
Kmart Wishing Tree
The K-Mart wishing tree is an existing element of the global brand that we feel can
be replicated successfully in Hungary. The idea revolves around helping a charity of
choice (in this case, for disadvantaged children) that has relevance for the local
community. Patrons enter the store and shop as usual, and are able to donate gifts
or money to the cause. This tree helps create the warm and selfless atmosphere that
is present at Christmas and also provides legitimate help to those that need it. The
Wishing tree is consistent with our key selling propositions of Christmas, community
and family, and is also an integral part of the global image of the brand.
Audience Appeal
This campaign will engage our target audience through a variety of appeals. The
principal appeal will be emotional and will be directed at our Target Audience’s family
values and beliefs. Family and community will be emphasised in the campaign
through depiction of the Hungarian way of life, and how K-Mart can influence this
with its affordable products.
40
Action Prompts
Consumers will be driven to action through K-Mart’s association with the festive
season, and through our direct marketing attempts. The original positioning of the
company will involve a strong link with Christmas and everything it stands for. The
values of family, togetherness and community associated with Christmas are
conveniently inherent and are treasured in Hungarian culture. The holiday therefore
synergises well with the launch of K-Mart, as the company will be positioned as a
welcoming, family brand. Christmas is also important in the launch of K-Mart as it
gives consumers a legitimate avenue to purchase gifts, food and other items that are
associated with the event. As K-Mart’s prices are “affordable,” the link with Christmas
will imply that customers will be able to shop for their entire family, whilst keeping
their expenditure low. This is important as shopping demand in Hungary is so price
sensitive.
Several action prompts will also be included in our direct marketing. The advent
calendar that will be distributed will contain special discounts on certain items on
certain days. This will influence consumers by giving them a specific action to
perform, and will also appeal to their sense of value. The discounts will be genuinely
good deals, and will all be on items that might be required for Christmas. Hungarians
will most likely need to buy these products anyway, so we will be promoting K-Mart
as the place to go to get these essentials at an affordable price.
Differentiation Points
The primary method of differentiation from K-Mart’s main competitors will be to
position the company as a smaller and more convenient hypermarket, as previously
41
explained. The focus will be on family, smaller outlets (while still maintaining the
competitive pricing of the larger stores) and central, more convenient locations.
Whilst we would like to differentiate K-Mart from Tesco and other competitors, it is
important to look at their successes. A prime example of integration into the local
culture occurred when Tesco moved into a small town in the UK. When confronted
with a major retailer on her doorstep, a local bookshop owner complained to the
company that it was stealing her customers. She was unable to compete with Tesco
on price, but did offer a much larger range of books than the hypermarket. Rather
than simply continuing to compete and ultimately drive the smaller bookshop out of
business, Tesco arrived at a mutually beneficial agreement. They resolved to
continue selling books at their regular low price, but allowed the smaller bookshop to
advertise their larger range within the Tesco store. From this, both the small
business and the large retail market prospered, and were able to exist in harmony. It
is important to take this success and put the key factors into practice within Hungary.
K-Mart in Hungary would be wise to work with, rather than against, existing small
businesses in order to keep negative attitudes to a minimum.
Cultural Considerations
One important thing to consider when entering the retail market in Hungary, and
Eastern Europe in general, is that most markets and hypermarkets include food in
their product selection (REF). Therefore we will be recommending K-Mart includes
food in their product range. The main types of food included will be semi-perishable,
such as dried meats, pastas and cheeses. Canned goods and other non-perishables
will also be stocked. This is important because Hungarians expect to be able to buy
42
food from major retailers. To deny them of this would be contradictory to their cultural
expectations. This plan will also be relevant when assessing our strategic plan, as
most families need to buy certain foods at Christmas time.
Rules and Regulations
As mentioned above, we have taken all Hungarian advertising regulations into
account when developing our creatives. There are only a few that are relevant to the
retail-marketing sector, and we have adhered to all of them. The rules relating to
children are the most restrictive, so we have been careful not to infringe any of them.
No child will be depicted patting a dog, licking an ice cream, or walking without shoes
on in any of our advertisements.
Tag Line
The Christmas tagline for K-Mart will be: “Your Christmas memories... Brought to you
by K-Mart” in Hungarian it will be “Kelemes Karacsonyi emlekeid… a K-Martol” and
will be integrated into all print and direct mail promotion. After Christmas, K-Mart
Hungary will be united under the one line: “Providing for your family” in Hungarian “A
csaladnak”. Both of these tag-lines will of course be translated into Hungarian to be
accessible to the average family in the country.
43
Evaluation
The success of this campaign will be evaluated and assessed through several
processes:
Brand recognition survey
We will have post-campaign surveys done amongst Hungarians to determine
whether they have more awareness of the brand Kmart. It is a measure of the
extent to which the target audience was exposed to the campaign
respondents able to recall any of the campaign or brand elements.
Sales and number of customers will be monitored
Based on this we will monitor the sales and the number of customer coming to
the store to measure how many people actually comes and spend on our
stores.
Feedback from consumers and clients
We will have questionnaires and focus groups to find out what our consumers
and clients think of the stores. This is to help improve the quality of our
services in the future.
44
References:
B&T (2010) Kmart overhaul marked by new campaign. Retrieved March 5, 2010 from: http://www.bandt.com.au/news/4d/0c066e4d.asp
Boyer, B. (2005). States against markets: the limits of globalization. From Keyness to K-Mart. Routledge, London
Buttle, F. & Coates, M. (1983). “Shopping motives”, Service Industries Journal, Vol. 4 No.1, pp.71-81.
Cateora, P. R., Gilly, M. C., & Graham, J. L. (2009). International Marketing. (14th Ed.). McGraw-Hill Irwin: NY.
Central Intelligence Agency. (2009). The world factbook. Country Comparison: Unemployment. Retrieved April 21, 2010 from https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2129rank.html?countryName=Hungary&countryCode=hu®ionCode=eu&rank=121#hu
Coles, L. (2009). Global economic crime. Retrieved March 25, 2010 from http://www.pwc.com/hu/en/publications/economic-crime-survey/index.jhtml
Csanad. (2010). Porter’s Five forces Analysis in reference to the Hungarian mobile phone industry. Retrieved April 3, 2010 from http://hubpages.com/hub/Porters-Five-forces-Analysis-in-reference-to-the-Hungarian-Mobile-phone-industry
De Mooij, M. (2010). Global Marketing and Advertising: Understanding Cultural Paradoxes. (3rd Ed). SAGE Publications: USA.
P. Dowling (2001). International Business: The Strategy and Structure of international business. McGraw Hill Australia Pty Ltd, Sydney
45
Euromonitor International. (2010). Country Factfile: Hungary. Retrieved April 3, 2010 from http://www.euromonitor.com/FactFile.aspx?country=HU
European Journalism Centre (2009). European Media Governance: The National and Regional Dimensions. Retrieved March 25, 2010 from http://www.ejc.net/media_landscape/article/hungary/
Cart-Tanneur, F. (2003) Louis Delhaize Group: Adding Value. Retrieved April 17, 2010 from: http://www.aon-esolutions.com/CmsData/pdf/Louis%20Delhaize.pdf
Filolog. (2007). Hungarian Mentality: Attitudes, behaviour and thinking. Retrieved March 27, 2010 from http://www.filolog.com/hungarian_mentality.html
GiS Development (2008). GfK Completes “Purchasing Power Europe 2008/2009” Study. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.gisdevelopment.net/news/viewn.asp?id=GIS:N_lvefzxuqsw
Greg, G. (2002). "Retail Giant Kmart Is Bankrupt." Boston Herald, published March 27, 2002.
Howell, D. (2002). New Kmart image campaign revives the value message, BENT Australia. Retrieved March 28, 2010 from: http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0FNP/is_5_41/ai_83805296/
Kmart Corporation. (2010). Our Story. Retrieved March 10, 2010 from: http://www.kmart.com.au/Community.aspx
K-Mart Corporation. (2007). Rosie Odonnell and Penny Marshall Campaign. Retrieved March 25, 2010 from: http://www.jiffynotes.com/a_study_guides/book_notes_add/emmc_0000_0002_0/emmc_0000_0002_0_00155.html
Lichtner, C. (2008). Purchasing power levels vary significantly by region within European countries. Press Release. Retrieved April 2, 2010 from http://www.gfk-geomarketing.com/fileadmin/newsletter/pressrelease/purchasing_power_europe_2008_2009.html
46
Millan, E. S. & Howard, E. (2007). “Shopping for Pleasure? Shopping experiences of Hungarian consumers. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management. Vol. 35, No 6, pp. 474-487. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://demo1.emeraldinsight.com/Insight/ViewContentServlet;jsessionid=6673E5180783D6CCAD0DD98345A218E0?contentType=Article&Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles/0890350604.html
O’Graff, T. (2005). The Locations of Wal-Mart and K-Mart Supercenters: Contrasting Corporate Strategies. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford.
PriceWaterHouseCoopers. (2006) From Beijing to Budapest – winning brands, winning formats. Hungary. Retrieved March 15, 2010 from: http://www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/retail-consumer/pdf/hungary.pdf
Sternquist, B. (2000) International expansion of US retailers: International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Volume 5. Retrieved from: http://assets.emeraldinsight.com/Insight/ViewContentServlet;jsessionid=4967E780401F71FAF464F53D735A2F5B?contentType=Article&Filename=Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Articles/0890250803.html
The World Bank. (2009). Global Economic Prospects: Commodities at a Crossroads. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTGEP2009/Resources/10363_WebPDF-w47.pdf
47