kroger vs. walmart - planogram analysis

34
PLANOGRAM Eliza Arnold, C.J. Milhoan, Jonathan Sekerak Sunday, April 6, 14

Upload: jonathan-sekerak

Post on 05-Dec-2014

995 views

Category:

Marketing


5 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

 

PLANOGRAM

Eliza Arnold, C.J. Milhoan, Jonathan Sekerak

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 2: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Our Store: Kroger

Our Competitor: Walmart

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 3: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Objective:re-create planograms for the snack food aisle in our store, Kroger, and our competitor store, Walmart, as well as detail our methodology, f indings and recommendations for our store.

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 4: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Methodology:observed snack food aisles, recording brand names, number of SKUs (stock keeping units) per brand, number of facings (consumer-facing SKUs) per brand, and linear feet per brand

observed shopper behavior and customer flow patterns through store aisles

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 5: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Planter’sS:22, F:62

KrogerS:37, F:121

KrogerS:9, F:23

DavidS:4, F:6

Blue Diamond

EmeraldS:8, F:22

Corn Nuts | S:1, F:1Stuckey’s | S:2, F:4

Nuts & Sunflower Seeds Snack Mixes Rice Cakes/SnacksCanned Chips

Chips Tortilla Chips

Corn & Tortilla Chips Private Label Chips Pretzels Chips Discount National Brands

Dips &Salsas

Trail Mix /Jerky

Planter’sS:2, F:4

KrogerS:20, F:57

KrogerS:8, F:24

Jack Link’s*S:8,F:10

Old Wisconsin

S:3,F:3

*

KrogerS:5, F:6

Slim JimS:6,F:8

World KitchensS:1, F:1

Funyuns | S:1, F:2Cracker Jack | S:1, F:1

Rold Gold

Fritos*S:12, F:43

Smartfood | S:1, F:4Munchos | S:1, F:1

Gardetto’sS:1, F:3 Pillsbury

S:1, F:1TGI Friday’s

S:2, F:2

Cheetos* | S:11, F:35

Santita’s | S:1, F:3

MissionS:2, F:2

Cape Cod*S:8, F:20

WiseS:7, F:15

Wise dipsS:3, F:10

Doritos* | S:12, F:30

Tostitos*S:14, F:49

Tostitos(cont.)

AndyCapp’sS:2, F:4

PringlesS:29, F:112

QuakerS:18, F:90

Lay’sStax

S:3,F:15

Chex MixS:10,F:22

Green GiantS:2, F:2

BuglesS:3, F:7

CombosS:3, F:3

%DFN

RI

VWRUH

)URQW

RI

VWRUH

Lay’sS:22,F:77

Frito-Lay Assorted*

S:12,F:43

Sun Chips*S:5, F:10

On the Border*S:3, F:14

Snyder’s

S:28, F:47

Utz

S:31, F:53

Chester’s*S:4,F:11

RufflesS:8, F:25

Rufflesdips

S:1,F:1

* * *

*

**

*

*

*

Snack Food Aisle Planogram

Lay’s Baked & Light

Utz dipsS:3, F:31

Kroger dipsS:8, F:34

Tostitos dipsS:6, F:25

Tostitos dips*S:8, F:38

Fritos dipsS:4, F:10

Tostitos dips

Lay’s dipsS:4, F:12

Aisle 14

Aisle 14 (cont.)

Aisle 14 (cont.)

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 6: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Planter’s*S:19, F:54

Great Value*S:16, F:38

WonderfulS:3, F:6

Blue Diamond* | S:15, F:32

Kettle | S:4, F:7

Smartfood | S:3, F:3Everybody’s Nuts

S:3, F:6World Table*

S:5, F:5 World Table | S:1, F:1

Nuts & Sunflower Seeds

Chips ChipsTortilla Chips & Pretzels

Assorted Snacks Bulk National Brand ChipsDiscount National BrandsChips & Pretzels

Jerky & Summer Sausage

*

*

*

*

*

*

* Great Value*S:7, F:7

Great Value

S:6, F:12

Great ValueS:5, F:7

Andy Capp’sS:2, F:4

TGI Friday’sS:3, F:3

CombosS:2, F:2

Jack Link’s*

S:14, F:14

(variousregionalbrands)S:3, F:3

Sweet Baby

Ray’s* S:2, F:3

MaunaLoa

S:2, F:3

Blue DiamondS:2, F:3

*

***

Sensible PortionsS:3, F:3

BridgfordS:3, F:11

Hannah’sS:2, F:5

Slim Jim*S:3, F:4

*

*

MedallionS:3, F:5

Pringles StixS:1, F:1

Cape Cod | S:2,F:5Fritos dips | S:3,F:32

PringlesS:32, F:106

Lay’s StaxS:11, F:46

Chex MixS:12, F:20

DavidS:4, F:8

*

*

*

*EmeraldS:4, F:4

QuakerS:13, F:25

PillsburyS:2, F:9

Snack FactoryS:4, F:4

Stacy’sS:3, F:3

TerraS:7, F:10

RiceworksS:4, F:4

BuglesS:5, F:8

Gardetto’sS:2, F:4

Rice Cakes/Snacks Assorted Snacks Canned Chips

Rold GoldS:4, F:7

FritosS:8, F:32

Fritos(cont.)

CheetosS:7, F:51

DoritosS:12, F:47

TostitosS:22, F:96

Lay’sS:21, F:96

Lay’s dips

S:4, F:91

Tostitos dips

Lay’s Baked & LightS:9, F:15

Lay’s Natural

Sun Chips*S:4, F:9

Chester’s*

S:3, F:8

Baken-ets

S:2, F:8

RufflesS:6, F:22

Great ValueS:1, F:27

Santita’sS:1,F:4

Rudolph’sS:2, F:6

SchultzS:2, F:5

Mac’sS:2, F:6

WiseS:9, F:19

Snyder’s

S:15, F:21

UtzS:44, F:56

Frito-Lay AssortedS: 15, F:108

Smartfood | S:1, F:3Funyuns | S:1, F:2

MunchosS:1,F:4 Thin & Crisp | S:2, F:5

Snack Food Aisle Planogram

S:10, F:54

Utzdips

aS:44 F:56

)URQW

RI

VWRUH

)URQW

RI

VWRUH

%DFN

RI

VWRUH

%DFN

RI

VWRUH

Aisle 10

Aisle 11

Aisle 11 (cont.)

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 7: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 8: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Findings:

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 9: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

has 1500 more feet of shelf space than

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 10: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

has more product

facings than

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 11: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

carries 28 more brands

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 12: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

for both &

the highest average product price was for the middle two rows

[row 4 & 3]

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 13: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Average Price by Shelf

Top Shelf

Aisle 10 (Snacks) Aisle 11 (Chips)

Eye-Level

Lower Shelves

Bottom Shelf

$3.56

$3.50

$3.70

$4.02 $3.11$3.70

$2.83

$2.16

$3.46

$3.24

$2.91

$3.10

$3.04

$3.61

$2.93

$3.65

$3.55

$3.28

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 14: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

discounted national brands locatedat the beginning of the aisle

discounted national brands locatednear the middle of the aisle

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 15: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

carries almost 25% morein private label brands than

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 16: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

We also observed in the week leading up to the Super Bowl

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 17: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

had massive, Super Bowl-themed entrance displays featuringchips and dips

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 18: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

only had [3] end-cap displays throughout the entire store

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 19: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Recommendations for Kroger:

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 20: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Location of Snack Aisle

1

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 21: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Currently situated between the cleaning aisle & cosmetics aisle

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 22: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Locate near bread, condiments aisle:because of the common association between “sandwich & chips meal”makes snacks a complementaryproduct purchase

Position snack aisle SKUs as “lunchtime necessities,” rather than unhealthy indulgences

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 23: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Organization of Snack Aisle

2

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 24: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Organized by brands in some areas

and by categories in others

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 25: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

1. Nuts2. Seeds3. Beef Jerky4. Snack Mix5. Chips

6. Dips7. Pretzels8. Rice Cakes9. Popcorn10. Individual bags

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 26: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Stand-Alone vs. End-Aisle Displays

3

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 27: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Capitalize on seasonal trends [Super Bowl displays]

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 28: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

End-aisle displays near pairing items, such as peanuts and beer

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 29: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Natural & Organic Snack Items

4

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 30: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Kroger has a separate snack aisle for natural & organic – on the other side of the store

Casual customers don’t go down this aisle: Kroger is missing an opportunity to sell these high-margin items en masse

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 31: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Align items with target’s eyesight

5

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 32: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Keep more expensive and high-margin SKUs on center shelves

But further orient items based on target consumer’s eye-level:

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 33: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

Organic and natural snacks: Located on higher shelves for adults.

Colorful and kid-themed:Located on lower shelves for children.

Sunday, April 6, 14

Page 34: Kroger vs. Walmart - Planogram Analysis

 

Questions?

Sunday, April 6, 14