le traitement de la tuberculose de l' enfant. paris: masson et cie. pp. 354. 80 figs. fr. 2,500

1
I80 THE BRITISH JOURNAL OF TUBERCULOSIS Emphasis is laid on the necessity for a full understanding of the topographical anatomy of the bronchi, especially when one is attempting to interpret tomo- bronchograms, the value of which is repeatedly stressed. The illustrations are clearly reproduced and easy to follow. The price of the book seems to be a trifle heavy when one considers the somewhat limited scope of the material presented. JAMFS MAXWELL. Le Traitement de la Tuberculose de l'Enfant. Paris: Masson et Cie. Pp. 354. 80 figs. Ft. 2,5oo. This transcription in French of the proceedings of the seminar on the treatment of tuberculosis in childhood, held in Paris in i955 under the auspices of the Centre International de l'Enfance, is in the reviewer's opinion by far the best book on tuberculosis in childhood yet published, and this despite the language difficulty, much repetition and some inferior contributions on uninteresting topics. Indeed, the use of French is an advantage, leading many of the contributors (who were drawn from many countries) to adhere to the fine tradition of French medical writing, so much more lucid and balanced than our own. This is particularly evident in the introductions to the papers, where each author takes pains to give an accurate r6sum6 of the field of knowledge to which his work is a contribution: thus what is established is stated lucidly, repeatedly and with authority, while the fact that the papers were given to an audience of experts from all over the world makes it easy for the reader to gauge the quality of the new material presented. Of particular interest are the sections on the medical and surgical treatment of primary glandular complexes, both in the neck and thorax, the survey of the world situation, and the reports of various laboratory workers on recent advances in basic scientific knowledge of the subject. This is an essential up-to-date reference book for anyone responsible for the treatment of tuberculous children and for those teaching on the subject. It is surprisingly well produced for the price. J . A . DAVIS. Tuberculosis Nursing. By J~ssIE G. EYRE. London: H. K. Lewis and Co. Ltd. I957, 2nd edition. Pp. 354. 25 s. This book is practical, informative and highly readable. It is difficult to keep pace with the contemporary rapid changes in treatment, and because of this some of the chapters are not as up-to-date as they might be. For example, there is no doubt that pneumothorax treatment is on the decline and the maintenance of an artificial pneumothorax with a tension cavity is certainly undesirable. From one's own experience, the statement that " patients taking their premature discharge from hospital would almost certainly break down" is shown to be at present inapplicable. It is now recognised that most patients can have satisfactory domiciliary treatment under supervision, provided they are co-operative and their home conditions permit..The chapters on domici- liary treatment are not as comprehensive as they might be. The book is eminently practical, but perhaps more emphasis might have been made on the co-operation between the family doctor, chest physician, health visitor and occupational therapist. FRANCIS M. WILLIAMS, S.R.N.

Upload: ja-davis

Post on 17-Sep-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Le Traitement de la Tuberculose de l' Enfant. Paris: Masson et Cie. Pp. 354. 80 figs. Fr. 2,500

I80 THE BRITISH J O U R N A L O F TUBERCULOSIS

Emphasis is laid on the necessity for a full understanding of the topographical anatomy of the bronchi, especially when one is attempting to interpret tomo- bronchograms, the value of which is repeatedly stressed.

The illustrations are clearly reproduced and easy to follow. The price of the book seems to be a trifle heavy when one considers the somewhat limited scope of the material presented. JAMFS MAXWELL.

Le Traitement de la Tuberculose de l'Enfant. Paris: Masson et Cie. Pp. 354. 80 figs. Ft. 2,5oo.

This transcription in French of the proceedings of the seminar on the treatment of tuberculosis in childhood, held in Paris in i955 under the auspices of the Centre International de l'Enfance, is in the reviewer's opinion by far the best book on tuberculosis in childhood yet published, and this despite the language difficulty, much repetition and some inferior contributions on uninteresting topics. Indeed, the use of French is an advantage, leading many of the contributors (who were drawn from many countries) to adhere to the fine tradition of French medical writing, so much more lucid and balanced than our own. This is particularly evident in the introductions to the papers, where each author takes pains to give an accurate r6sum6 of the field of knowledge to which his work is a contribution: thus what is established is stated lucidly, repeatedly and with authority, while the fact that the papers were given to an audience of experts from all over the world makes it easy for the reader to gauge the quality of the new material presented. Of particular interest are the sections on the medical and surgical treatment of primary glandular complexes, both in the neck and thorax, the survey of the world situation, and the reports of various laboratory workers on recent advances in basic scientific knowledge of the subject. This is an essential up-to-date reference book for anyone responsible for the treatment of tuberculous children and for those teaching on the subject. It is surprisingly well produced for the price. J . A . DAVIS.

Tuberculosis Nursing. By J~ssIE G. EYRE. London: H. K. Lewis and Co. Ltd. I957, 2nd edition. Pp. 354. 25 s.

This book is practical, informative and highly readable. It is difficult to keep pace with the contemporary rapid changes in treatment, and because of this some of the chapters are not as up-to-date as they might be. For example, there is no doubt that pneumothorax treatment is on the decline and the maintenance of an artificial pneumothorax with a tension cavity is certainly undesirable. From one's own experience, the statement that " patients taking their premature discharge from hospital would almost certainly break d o w n " is shown to be at present inapplicable. It is now recognised that most patients can have satisfactory domiciliary treatment under supervision, provided they are co-operative and their home conditions permi t . .The chapters on domici- liary treatment are not as comprehensive as they might be. The book is eminently practical, but perhaps more emphasis might have been made on the co-operation between the family doctor, chest physician, health visitor and occupational therapist. FRANCIS M. WILLIAMS, S.R.N.