lecture - espionage by the numbers: introduction to number stations - delft university 2011

46
Espionage by the Numbers An introduction to Spy Numbers Stations by Peter Staal

Upload: peter-staal

Post on 10-May-2015

1.408 views

Category:

News & Politics


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Espionage by the Numbers

An introduction to Spy Numbers Stations

by Peter Staal

Page 2: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

How they work

Who’s behind it / cases

Q&A

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 3: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

OTP

Tables

How they work

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 4: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

OTP

Tables

How they work

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 5: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

Interval/callsignHeader

- Agent-ID- Message size

5/4 Figure groupsRedundancy

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 6: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

Interval/callsignHeader

- Agent-ID 328 912- Message size 11 66

5/4 Figure groupsRedundancy

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 7: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

Interval/callsignHeader

- Agent-ID 328 912- Message size 11 66

5/4 Figure groupsRedundancy

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 8: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

OTP

Tables

How they work

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 9: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

Page 10: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 11: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 12: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 13: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 14: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

74265 34925 23426 cyphertext18593 47499 45877 OTP------------------------------ +82758 71314 68293 cleartext

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 15: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

One-Time-Pad

74265 34925 23426 cyphertext18593 47499 45877 OTP------------------------------ +82758 71314 68293 cleartext

Add (or substract) without carry

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 16: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Anatomy of a message

OTP

Tables

How they work

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 17: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Tables

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 18: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Tables

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 19: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Tables

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 20: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Tables

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 21: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

How they work

Who’s behind it / cases

Q&A

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 22: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Andy TowerSpokesman British Department of Trade and Industry- 1997

“These are what you suppose they are.

People shouldn’t be mystified by them.

They are not for, shall we say, public consumption”

Telegraph, January 14, 1997

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 23: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Law Enforcement cases

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 24: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

- Erwin van Haarlem / Vaclav Jelinek – arrested 1988 by British Special Branch

- WASP-network - arrested 1998 by the FBI - FBI copied decoding software in 1995

- Cuban Five (arrested 2001)

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 25: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

- Ana Belen Montes (arrested/charged September 21, 2001) - a Senior US Defence Intelligence Agency analyst Affidavit: “… and received her instructions through encrypted shortwave transmissions from Cuba”

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 26: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Kendall & Gwendolyn Myers - arrested and indicted June 4, 2009

Kendall Myers (agent 202): top intelligence analyst at the State Department.

Gwendolyn Myers (agent 123 / E-634).

Spied for about 30 years for Cuba.

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 27: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Meet the MyersPeter Staal - february 2011

Page 28: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Russian Spy Ring (2010)

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 29: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Russian Spy Ring (2010)

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 30: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

Russian Spy Ring (2010)

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 31: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

References in literature

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 32: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

References in literature

- Defector / whistleblower

- Declassified documents- Let the other guy do the talking

- Former employees

- End of the Cold War- End of Soviet Union- End of East-Germany

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 33: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

References in literature Spycraft: Robert Wallace & H. Keith Melton

“The one-way voice link (OWVL) described a covert communications system that transmitted messages to an agent's unmodified shortwave radio using the high-frequency shortwave bands between 3 and 30 MHz at a predetermined time, date, and frequency contained in their communications plan.”

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 34: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

References in literature CIA, Inc.: Espionage and the Craft of Business Intelligence F. W. Rustmann, Jr.

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 35: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Who’s behind it / cases

References in literature

- Defector / whistleblower

- Declassified documents

- Former employees

- End of the Cold War- End of Soviet Union- End of East-Germany

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 36: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documentsPolish Ministry of Interior (MSW) II Department (Counterintelligence)

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 37: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 38: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 39: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 40: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 41: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 42: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 43: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 44: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Declassified documents

Speech / Morse generator Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 45: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Questions & Answers

Peter Staal - february 2011

Page 46: Lecture - Espionage by the Numbers: Introduction to Number Stations - Delft University 2011

Peter Staal - february 2011