luisa soares -miranda et al. circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files ›...

73

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 2: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Luisa Soares-Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147-155

Copyright © American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved.

Page 3: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Luisa Soares-Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147-155

Copyright © American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved.

FUNCTION OF:

Walking pace

< 3 km/h to

> 4.8 km/h

Walking distance

0 blocks/wkto

> 49 blocks/wk

Page 4: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Luisa Soares-Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147-155

Copyright © American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved.

Page 5: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

PurposeTo examine work-related physical and

mental health amongst Active Commuters to the U of L

Page 6: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Suzanne McIntosh1

Sue Kovach2,1

Shelby Schumaker3,1

Olu Awosoga4

Jon Doan3,1

1HR - Wellness and Recognition 2Finance – Scholarships and Finance3Kinesiology and Phys Ed - Engineering and Human

Performance Lab4Faculty of Health Sciences

University of Lethbridge

Increased wellness amongst Active Commuters

to a newly urban university campus in Alberta

Page 7: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Suzanne McIntosh1

Sue Kovach2,1

Shelby Schumaker3,1

Olu Awosoga4

Jon Doan3,1

1HR - Wellness and Recognition 2Finance – Scholarships and Finance3Kinesiology and Phys Ed - Engineering and Human

Performance Lab4Faculty of Health Sciences

University of Lethbridge

Increased wellness amongst Active Commuters

to a newly urban university campus in Alberta

Page 8: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

PurposeTo examine work-related physical and

mental health amongst Active Commuters to the U of L

HypothesisActive Commuters would have increased

physical and mental health, plus higher job satisfaction

Page 9: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

ParticipantsTargeted sample of active commuters (AC-L)

- “bike rack recruiting” - packages available with towels at FitC

Page 10: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

ParticipantsTargeted sample of active commuters (AC-L)

- “bike rack recruiting”- packages available with towels at FitC

Targeted sample of conventional commuters (CC-L)- “parking lot recruiting”- packages available with handbooks at FacO

Page 11: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Participants

- No differences in age or commute time- All AC-L started commute in West Lethbridge- 94% of CC-L commuted in personal vehicle- 81% of CC-L commuted alone

Page 12: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

MeasuresWork Ability Index (Tuomi et al., 1998)

- self-report on work-related physical and mental health- target is early identification and intervention- modified for this use

- health conditions with unclear association with work were dropped

Page 13: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

MeasuresWork Ability Index (Tuomi et al., 1998)

- self-report on work-related physical and mental health- target is early identification and intervention- modified for this use

- health conditions with unclear association with work were dropped

Job in General Scale, abridged (Ironson et al., 1989)- self-report on satisfaction with job- target is organizational prosperity

- satisfaction is cause, correlate, and effect of organizational success

Page 14: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - WAI

Page 15: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - WAI

Page 16: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - WAI

MAINTAIN

SEEK SUPPORT

IMPROVE

Prescribed action(Tuomi et al. 1996)

Page 17: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - WAI

- “Very good” WAITOTAL amongst AC-L was result of cumulative small increase on multiple WAIFACTORS

Page 18: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - JIG

Page 19: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Results - JIG

Page 20: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

ConclusionThere is current and future value to

Active Commuting at U of L- associated with higher work ability,

lower frequency illness and absence, and increased job satisfaction

Page 21: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

DiscussionThere is growing interest in Active Commuting

“What, if anything, would you like to do in the next year to improve or maintain your health and wellness?” U of L Employee Health and Wellness Surveys, 2012 & 2015

2012 2015

21% 33%POSITIVE

RESPONSE RATE

YEAR

ACTIVELY COMMUTE TO WORK (walk, bike, run)

Page 22: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Suzanne McIntosh1

Sue Kovach2,1

Shelby Schumaker3,1

Olu Awosoga4

Jon Doan3,1

1HR - Wellness and Recognition 2Finance – Scholarships and Finance3Kinesiology and Phys Ed - Engineering and Human

Performance Lab4Faculty of Health Sciences

University of Lethbridge

Increased wellness amongst Active Commuters

to a newly urban university campus in Alberta

Page 23: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

A challenge and an opportunity

Active Commuting Suburban-to-Urban Campus

Page 24: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Active Commuting• Personal & work and local & global

benefits– Increased physical activity (Sisson & Tudor-Locke, 2008)

– Decreased sick days (Hendriksen et al., 2010)

– Decreased traffic (and environmental) load (Charles-Edwards et al., 2015)

• Universities are prime target– Workplace explicitly and implicitly affects AC

(Wen et al., 2010)

– Staff and student commuters are universities’ largest environmental impact (Tolley, 1996)

– Academia’s role as leaders and advocates (Shannon et al., 2006)

Page 25: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Suburban Campus

• Academic growth model for UK + Canada, post WWII

• New vision of academic campus as “radical, diffuse, non-residential, vocational”

versus “ancient, enclosed, exclusive, educational”

(Abercrombie, 1974)

• U of L the epitome of this phenomenon in Canada

Page 26: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

University of Lethbridge [1967-]

• U of L looking west, 1972

Page 27: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1969

Page 28: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1972 – University Hall opens

Page 29: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1981 – first private home on west side built in 1974

Page 30: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1986 - <8000 people live on west side

Page 31: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1990 – South res. + Whoop-Up overpass complete

Page 32: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

1999 - ~15000 people live on west side

Page 33: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2001 – University Library completed

Page 34: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2003 - ~20000 people live on west side

Page 35: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2007 – 1st Choice Fitness Centre opens

Page 36: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2008 – First secondary schools open on west side

Page 37: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2010 – Campus Daycare, Community Stadium open

Page 38: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2014 - >35000 people (40% of Lethbridge population) live on west side

Thanks to U of L Archives

for slide sequence!

Page 39: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

To successfully integrate with this urbanization, important for U of L to:

1) Identify the current & future value of Active Commuting

1969

2014

Page 40: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

To successfully integrate with this urbanization, important for U of L to:

1) Identify the current & future value of Active Commuting

2) If 1) is positive, champion Active Commuting behaviourand infrastructure

1969

2014

Page 41: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 42: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 43: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

2016

Page 44: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 45: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

U of L Development Plan [Erickson & Massey, 1969]

WALK“external access is possible to all parts of the campus by means of walks and walkways…a great variety of alternate routes with differing aspects and views are available.”

Page 46: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

U of L Development Plan [Erickson & Massey, 1969]

WALK“external access is possible to all parts of the campus by means of walks and walkways…a great variety of alternate routes with differing aspects and views are available.” [Erickson & Massey, 1969]

Page 47: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

U of L Campus Master Plan [2012]

WALK

BIKE

“walking as a primary means of movement on campus should be encouraged…bikes should be encouraged on campus.” [U of L CMP, 2012]

Page 48: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

U of L Campus Master Plan [2012]

WALK

BIKE

“walking as a primary means of movement oncampus should be encouraged…bikes should be encouraged oncampus.” [U of L CMP, 2012]

Page 50: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Next steps

Need to push, pull, and nudge open those gates that will connect

Active Commuters to their campus

Page 51: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 52: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

PUSH

Page 53: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

TEAMSCOMP.

THEME

SCHED.

REWARDSReal

Virtual

PULL

Page 54: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

NUDGE

Page 55: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 56: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

‘Excessive’ parking causes ‘dangerous’ driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

Page 57: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Parking causes driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

Page 58: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Parking causes driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

TIME ORDER

Page 59: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Parking causes driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

Page 60: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Parking causes driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

City centers, 1980

Page 61: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Parking causes driving (McCahill et al., 2016)

STRENGTH

City centers, 1980

Page 62: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

‘Parklets’

Page 63: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools
Page 64: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Commuting at University of Guelph• 2500 campus bicycle rack slots

• 2147 parking passes!• 20 covered bike shelters• 4 bike repair stations

• 900 buses come to campus daily• 2.3 million people took a bus to or from

U of G in 2014

Page 65: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’…..”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

Page 66: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’…..”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

ACTIVE COMMUTING

Page 67: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’. Decades ago, neither wereCopenhagen or Amsterdam.”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

ACTIVE COMMUTING

Page 68: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’. Decades ago, neither wereCopenhagen or Amsterdam.”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

ACTIVE COMMUTING

Copenhagen, 2015

Page 69: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’. Decades ago, neither wereCopenhagen or Amsterdam.”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

ACTIVE COMMUTING

Copenhagen, 2015

Page 70: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

“When discussing more urban biking, Ioften hear ‘We’re not Copenhagen orAmsterdam!’. Decades ago, neither wereCopenhagen or Amsterdam.”

Brent Toderian, Vancouver city planner

ACTIVE COMMUTING

Copenhagen, 2015 Beijing, 2015

Page 71: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

What can we do

Personally• identify some purposeful walks & rides

around your neighbourhoodthen do them!

• start with 1 ‘different’ commute to work per week

• recognise (and embrace) push/pull/nudge effects

Page 72: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

What can we do

Institutionally• be thoughtful about push/pull/nudge

opportunities

• internally support active commuting

• find a way to meet our ‘new’ neighbourhood

Page 73: Luisa Soares -Miranda et al. Circulation. 2016;133:147 -155 › sites › default › files › active... · 2007 – 1. st Choice Fitness Centre opens. 2008 – First secondary schools

Thank you