making an impact with essential oils: a case study on an

23
Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an Emerging Agribusiness in Rwanda | 1 Written by Yeareen Yun, Brettany Tucker, Yamatha Saint Germain, Enkhzul Altangerel and Stephanie T. Coker Edited by Eghosa Asemota Abstract This case profiles Ikirezi Natural Products, the only essential oils company in Rwanda which is considering expanding into the domestic market following several years of slow growth internationally. As a community-interest agribusiness, Ikirezi was founded by Dr. Nicholas Hitimana with the aim “to maximize profits to smallholder farmers, holistically transform communities, and strengthen agribusiness in Rwanda.” [1] Given its limited resources in a country lacking familiarity with the benefits of essential oils, Ikirezi faced the challenge of developing a market strategy beginning in 2017. This case study presents a comprehensive overview of the challenges, opportunities, and constraints often faced by social agribusinesses in emerging markets. It also provides in-depth insight into direct and indirect factors that affect agribusinesses’ operations. This case will be helpful to individuals interested in agribusiness development and management, social entrepreneurship, supply and value chain development, marketing and communication strategies, and market expansion strategies. Introduction In 2005, Dr. Hitimana founded Ikirezi with the intention of addressing poverty in rural areas in Rwanda. Ikirezi defines itself as a community-interest business. It is an organization that “achieves its primary social mission using business methods, through revenue-generating business.” [2] Ikirezi’s vision statement is to be “a leading producer of high-quality essential oils and other natural plant products that maximize profits to small farmers, [and] holistically transforms communities and strengthens agribusiness in Rwanda.” [3] The business model of Ikirezi incorporates social responsibility at its core and emphasizes hiring vulnerable groups. For instance, eight out of ten of Ikirezi’s farm employees are either widows or adult orphans. Farm employees are trained according to Ikirezi’s agricultural production processes and each employee is independently in charge of single plots of leased, Ikirezi farmland. Ikirezi pays its employees above national average wages and provides ongoing skill-based training and materials such as plant seeds for farmers even after they leave the company to start their own farms. As the only Rwandan essential oils producer, Ikirezi has faced many struggles and

Upload: others

Post on 14-Jun-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 1

Written by Yeareen Yun, Brettany Tucker, Yamatha Saint Germain, Enkhzul Altangerel and Stephanie T. Coker

Edited by Eghosa Asemota

Abstract

This case profiles Ikirezi Natural Products, the only essential oils company inRwanda which is considering expanding into the domestic market following severalyears of slow growth internationally. As a community-interest agribusiness, Ikireziwas founded by Dr. Nicholas Hitimana with the aim “to maximize profits tosmallholder farmers, holistically transform communities, and strengthenagribusiness in Rwanda.”

[1]

Given its limited resources in a country lackingfamiliarity with the benefits of essential oils, Ikirezi faced the challenge ofdeveloping a market strategy beginning in 2017. This case study presents acomprehensive overview of the challenges, opportunities, and constraints oftenfaced by social agribusinesses in emerging markets. It also provides in-depthinsight into direct and indirect factors that affect agribusinesses’ operations. Thiscase will be helpful to individuals interested in agribusiness development andmanagement, social entrepreneurship, supply and value chain development,marketing and communication strategies, and market expansion strategies.

Introduction

In 2005, Dr. Hitimana founded Ikirezi with the intention of addressing poverty in rural areasin Rwanda. Ikirezi defines itself as a community-interest business. It is an organization that“achieves its primary social mission using business methods, through revenue-generatingbusiness.”

[2]

Ikirezi’s vision statement is to be “a leading producer of high-quality essentialoils and other natural plant products that maximize profits to small farmers, [and]holistically transforms communities and strengthens agribusiness in Rwanda.”

[3]

The business model of Ikirezi incorporates social responsibility at its core and emphasizeshiring vulnerable groups. For instance, eight out of ten of Ikirezi’s farm employees areeither widows or adult orphans. Farm employees are trained according to Ikirezi’sagricultural production processes and each employee is independently in charge of singleplots of leased, Ikirezi farmland. Ikirezi pays its employees above national average wagesand provides ongoing skill-based training and materials such as plant seeds for farmerseven after they leave the company to start their own farms.

As the only Rwandan essential oils producer, Ikirezi has faced many struggles and

Page 2: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 2

challenges over the years.[4]

From the beginning, it was difficult to operationalize farms, trainnew farmers, break into the essential oils industry, and find buyers. The company, however,persevered and eventually became an established exporter of high-quality essential oils.Today, Ikirezi produces high-quality, one hundred percent pure, and certified organicessential oils.

[5]

Even after over ten years of operation, however, Ikirezi is still struggling to generateenough profits and to increase efficiency. As a result, Dr. Hitimana is reconsidering hiscurrent business strategy, which is focused on exports to international markets. He recentlyreceived a market research study on the domestic Rwandan market for essential oils, whichhas found that there is potential for new target markets within Rwanda.

[6]

Importantquestions for Dr. Hitimana are threefold: first, what is the best business strategy and visionfor his company going forward, and second, should Ikirezi continue to focus on theinternational market or begin looking for new opportunities for growth within Rwanda? Ineither case, how can Ikirezi increase sales given its limited resources? Dr. Hitimana needsto make careful business decisions for the future of his company, staff, and farmers.

Background: Rwanda

Political Landscape

Rwanda is a landlocked country situated in East Africa. With a population of 11,809,295 anda total area of 26,338 kilometers squared, it is one of the most densely populated countriesin Africa. The current political context of Rwanda is largely affected by the civil war of theearly 1990s and the genocide that took place in 1994. A transitional government wasestablished following this genocide to introduce vital changes, which opened the doors forreconciliation and rebuilding. With the introduction of a new constitution in 2003,Rwandans elected Paul Kagame as their head of state for two consecutive elections, whichtook place in 2003 and 2010.

[7]

Under Paul Kagame’s leadership, Rwanda has remained politically stable, which has helpedthe country maintain steady economic growth over the past two decades.

[8]

In 2000, President Kagame launched Vision 2020, an ambitious development strategy withthe goal of transforming the country into a middle-income nation in which Rwandans wouldbe healthier, better educated, and more prosperous.

[9]

As outlined in the Vision 2020 plan, the development policy is based on the following sixprincipal pillars: 1) good governance and increased efficiency in the private sector; 2)

Page 3: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 3

skilled human capital bolstered by education, health, and information technology; 3) vibrantprivate sector; 4) world-class physical infrastructure; 5) modernization of agriculture; and 6)regional integration.

[10]

This strategy is implemented through short-term development plans, and the EconomicDevelopment and Poverty Reduction Strategy 2013-2018 (EDPRS II) guides the actions thatwill lead to the achievement of the Vision 2020 goals.

EDPRS II aims to bolster economic development and poverty reduction through theintensification and commercialization of the agriculture sector. One of the main techniqueswith which the government aims to achieve this objective is the development of private-sector-driven value chains. In this regard, the government supports the greater involvementof the private sector to increase agricultural exports, processing, and value addition. Thegovernment offers various incentives such as tax exemption and low-interest loans tosupport agribusiness in the country.

[11]

As an agri-business, Ikirezi has the potential to takeadvantage of these favorable government policies.

Economic and Business Environment

Rwanda has experienced a period of economic prosperity in the past two decades. RealGross Domestic Product (GDP) grew by an average of eight percent annually during theperiod 2000 to 2013, which is among the highest average growth rates in East Africa.Strong economic growth has resulted in an increase in per capita income from $240 in 2000to $700 in 2015, while poverty levels have reduced from 56.7 percent in 2005 to 44.9percent in 2010, lifting one million Rwandans out of poverty.

[12]

In addition to its booming economy, Rwanda is currently experiencing growth in its middle-class due to job creation and the increasing number of women entering the workforce.

[13]

Experts from the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) believethat members of the middle-class are more willing to spend their disposable income thanindividuals in other income groups.

[14]

Reforms in the business environment have also made it easier for individuals and groups tostart businesses, and for businesses to obtain permits and pay taxes. These reforms haveboosted Rwanda’s ratings in the World Bank’s “Doing Business Report.”

[15]

In 2017, Rwandawas ranked fifty-sixth out of 190 countries and received distinction as the second-easiestcountry in which to do business in Sub-Saharan Africa.

[16]

Page 4: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 4

Rwanda’s economy is primarily agrarian, with ninety percent of the population engaged insubsistence agriculture.

[17]

Under EDPRS II, the government aims for a twenty-eight percentincrease in the value of exports by 2020.

[18]

As a natural plant product with high potential forgenerating additional exports and increasing farmer income, essential oils were selected asone of the priority products for export diversification.

[19]

The country’s warm climate enablesfarmers to harvest multiple times a year.

The increasing global demand for essential oils,[20]

combined with Rwanda’s conduciveclimate for their production, could present unique investment and business opportunities forIkirezi.

Climate Change

Since crop production relies heavily on rainfall, Ikirezi’s operations depend to a largedegree on climate. Typically, Rwanda has two rainy seasons per year, from March to Mayand from October to December, with a dry season in between. Due to climate change,however, the seasons have become increasingly unpredictable. Dr. Hitimana and theoperations manager, Mr. Ntawiheba, have noted that rainfall in Rwanda has been delayedby two months each year for the past three years. According to Dr. Frank Rijsberman, thedirector of the Global Green Growth Institute, water as a natural resource is becomingincreasingly scarce, which is causing the Rwandan agricultural community to increase theiruse of irrigation techniques to reach their production goals.

[21]

Recognizing the risks that climate change poses to the country’s agriculture sector andwater sources, the Rwandan government is working to “expand irrigation infrastructure andimplement integrated water resource management.”

[22]

The government believes that farmerscan decrease their vulnerability to the changing rainfall patterns by using irrigationinfrastructure to gain more control over their water supply. Dr. Hitimana plans to switchfrom pedal pumps to drip irrigation, which would allow Ikirezi farmers to raise the biomassof their harvests and consequently increase the quantity of product available for sale.

The Company

The founding of Ikirezi Natural Products is deeply connected to the painful history of theRwandan genocide of 1994. As a result of the genocide, Dr. Nicholas Hitimana left thecountry with his wife, Elsie, moving first to the Democratic Republic of Congo, then toKenya, and eventually to the United Kingdom where he earned a doctorate in Rural

Page 5: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 5

Development and Applied Entomology at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland. Upon thecompletion of his Ph.D., Dr. Hitimana and his wife felt a deep calling to help rebuild theircountry and decided to return to Rwanda with their children.

In 2003, a few years after his return to Rwanda, Dr. Hitimana participated in an agriculturalpilot project which examined the feasibility of producing essential oils and other naturalplant products in the country. The pilot project revealed that Rwanda had the potential toproduce geraniums with an advantage over South Africa.

[23]

This project led Dr. Hitimana toset a goal of growing geraniums in Rwanda.

In 2005, Dr. Hitimana founded Ikirezi Natural Products as an agribusiness that producesessential oils with a primary and unique focus on poverty alleviation in rural Rwandesecommunities. He decided against creating a cooperative or a non-government organization(NGO): “After much deliberation, we chose the social business model because it wouldmaximize profits for our farmers as we work to solve social issues. NGOs had inundated thecountry and had somewhat weakened Rwandan dignity and self-sufficiency. We were keenon helping communities help themselves.”

[24]

He stated the mission of Ikirezi to be“[producing] high-quality essential oils and other natural plant products in partnership withsmall-scale farmers.”

[25]

The goals of Ikirezi are to recognize every individual’s dignity, toholistically impact communities, sustainably transform communities, and strategicallycollaborate with institutions and individuals to achieve a common vision. Additionally, Dr.Hitimana believes that in order to empower farmers and provide an economic solution topoverty, Ikirezi needs to value grace, humility, and compassion, which are collectivelyreferred to as ‘ubuntu’ in Southern Africa.

[26]

In the beginning, the company had limited capital to become fully operational. But in 2006,Ikirezi received significant funding from World Relief International and United StatesAgency for International Development (USAID) to begin the production of geraniums. Thefollowing year, Ikirezi was able to open a new site at Gahara. The evolution of Ikirezi isdetailed in the following figure:

Page 6: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 6

Figure 1: Ikirezi Historical Timeline

Business Operations

Supply and Value Chain

Currently, Ikirezi is the only company that produces and exports essential oils in Rwanda.[27]

It mainly produces four different types of essential oils– geranium, patchouli, lemongrass,and eucalyptus– as well as small quantities of marigold.

Initially, Ikirezi exported most of their products, with approximately eighty percent of theirsales coming from the international market and the remaining twenty percent of theRwandan market. The global economic crisis of 2008 resulted in a decrease in sales for thecompany, leaving Ikirezi with over fifty kilograms of unsold stock. As a result of thisexperience, the company’s management realized that a shift in strategy might be needed toweather future fluctuations in the global market. Specifically, they realized this needbecause people started to recognize Ikirezi products and approach Dr. Hitimana about whyhe was not selling the products locally. Because of these conversations, Dr. Hitimana andhis staff started wondering if they should target local markets.

[28][29]

Page 7: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 7

Ikirezi’s value chain is a process, in which value-adding activities begin at the onset of allthree of Ikirezi’s production sites. At a single production site, Ikirezi’s “seed to bottle”model begins with seventy to eighty full-time and part-time farmworkers. Eight out of tenfarmworkers employed are either widows or adult orphans. Farmers are trained accordingto Ikirezi’s agricultural production processes and each farmer is independently in charge ofa single plot of leased Ikirezi farmland. On the ground, the land is cultivated –that is, hoedand tilled–until it is ready to receive the seedlings. In the case of geraniums, the essential oilprocess begins with seedlings procured in nurseries that are later transferred to the land.

[30]

During the crop maintenance process, plants are matured–that is, watered, mulched,weeded–and then harvested when the desired biomass of the plant is reached. To avoidcompromising the delicate quality of the plants’ leaves, a select group of farmers is taskedwith harvesting (i.e. cutting) the leaves from their root. Leaves are then bundled andtransferred by foot to be weighed by farm technicians.

[31]

After the leaves are weighted, they are laid on a cement floor outdoors and left to wilt.[32]

Wilted leaves are transferred to the distillation unit (see Figure 2) in which a technicianoversees that the correct heating and cooling processes occur to condense and extract oilfrom the leaves. The distillation time varies depending on the type of oil; for example, thedistillation of geranium leaves may last five hours. Once the technician has extracted,filtered, and evaluated the oil, it is then transported to Kigali. The oil is hand-bottled,labeled, and prepared for packaging in the main office.

Page 8: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 8

Figure 2: Ikirezi’s Supply Chain (Cornell SMART Market Research Study, 2017)

Each step in this assembly line is unique to Ikirezi’s value chain and allows for continuedsuccess in essential oil production.

The essential oil is poured and bottled into small glass vials, which are imported from China.The vials, dark brown in color, are known to preserve the oil’s quality, fragrance, and color.Furthermore, due to the intensive labor processes involved in procuring oils that areECOCERT certified, 100 percent pure, and organic, the production of one liter of anessential oil can vary between six to seven months. At the same time, one single vial ofessential oil has a shelf life of one year after the bottle seal is broken.

[33]

Ikirezi’s production sites, shown in Figure 3, have provided employment opportunities forhundreds of farm employees, most of whom were widowed or orphaned by the genocide.The company has contracted with local communities at production sites to lease communalland for essential oil plant production.

Page 9: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 9

Page 10: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 10

Page 11: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 11

Figure 3:Ikirezi essential oil production sites (Ikirezi Business Plan, 2014)

Products[34]

Ikirezi’s essential oils can be purchased in small vials and in larger quantities by the liter. Other products for retail include geranium roll-ons, sprays and mists, and clay pots used fordiffusing the oils. Domestic orders for Ikirezi products are made to the main office in Kigalivia email, in person, or by phone, while international orders in commodity form are madeelectronically. The product is then packaged and shipped to the customer.

Placement

Since essential oils are a high-end product, their market is very segmented. Most of Ikirezi’s

Page 12: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 12

essential oils are exported to be processed further for the production of beauty products.Domestically, Ikirezi works with retail outlets, hotels, gift shops, and spas catering toexpatriates and to middle- and upper-class Rwandan communities. These retail outletstypically use these essential oils for massage and aromatherapy purposes. Although thedemand for essential oils in Rwanda is rather small, due to their sale as retail products, thecompany’s profit margins are higher for their retail products than their bulk exportation ofoils.

Currently, Ikirezi’s only direct point of sale is its main office in Kigali. The company does nothave a designated list of retail outlets for customers, even though there are several hotelsand spas that sell its products.

Social Impact

At present, Ikirezi works with four cooperatives at four different sites in Rwanda, employingmore than one hundred farmers directly and more during the peak seasons.

In accordance with Ikirezi’s vision to combine sustainable and best business practices with asocial purpose, Ikirezi’s shareholders are committed to utilizing net profits in order to (i)provide a dividend to farmers’ associations/cooperatives, (ii) reinvest in strengthening thecore business, (iii) expand operations into new products or territory, or (iv) provideinfrastructure projects to participating communities. Dr. Hitimana affirmed thiscommitment in a simple manner, stating: “Farmers do most of the work. Why shouldn’t theyget paid the most? They can’t go below thirty percent of the value of the products.”

[35]

Additionally, focus groups and an in-depth interview conducted with Ikirezi farmersrevealed that farmers have received both tangible and intangible benefits through theiremployment with Ikirezi. For instance, Vincent Habimana, a farmer who partners withIkirezi, has built a house and purchased livestock with his savings, which helped himincrease his income and establish a side business. Another farmer expressed how she usesthe farming skills she learned from training with Ikirezi to tend to her family plantations.

Figure 4: Vincent Habimama, an Ikirezi farmer, and his family. (Cornell SMART Market ResearchReport, 2017)

Page 13: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 13

Market Research

Methodology

A mixed methods approach was used. Data was collected through surveys, a focus group,and meetings with the Minister of Agriculture and a representative of MTN. The companyselected four target cities to survey: Kigali, Gisenyi, Musanze, and Huye.

Sample

A total of seventy-five surveys were conducted (seven surveys with existing clients and sixty-eight surveys with potential clients), along with one focus group discussion. Surveysprimarily targeted hotels and spas. A representative from each business was interviewed,usually the general manager.

Survey Design

The survey questionnaire contained both open-ended and closed-ended questions, while thefocus group was semi-structured.

Marketing and Communications

Marketing and communication is a crucial factor in business performance. Especially insmall and medium enterprises. Various studies have found that limited marketing focuscould lead to weak performance (Jones and Rowley, 2011). With this in mind, the company’spresent marketing and communications strategies are analyzed within the framework of amarketing mix approach (that is, the way a product or service is presented to the market).

Promotion

Currently, a small percentage of Ikirezi’s essential oil products are sold on the domesticmarket as value-added products, while the bulk of output is sold to importers in SouthAfrica, the UK, Switzerland, and the U.S. as a commodity. As the international market hasbeen Ikirezi’s primary target, the company’s marketing and branding strategy emphasizethe product’s country of origin— Rwanda– and its business model of social enterprise.

According to Ms. Uwubuntu, Ikirezi’s administrator, the company currently promotes itsproducts using face-to-face communication at church events and international and localfairs organized by expatriate communities. The market research study affirmed the

Page 14: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 14

importance of Ikirezi’s strategy, which uses social networking as the primary means ofpromoting its products. The market analysis revealed that word-of-mouth was the mainchannel through which respondents were familiar with Ikirezi.

[36]

In order to reach a wider audience and increase their brand recognition, Ikirezi in 2016,launched a Facebook page to take advantage of growing numbers of social media users.Telecommunication is the company’s main method of communication with its customers.

[37]

Ikirezi’s website is another means of communication with potential customers. Yet, thewebsite has general information about the company only in English and does not publishdetails about their products’ prices. With increasing demand for detailed productinformation, Marcella and Davies note that “language was thought likely to be highlyinfluential” in customer communication.

[38]

The market research study, as illustrated inFigure 6, found that, in towns closest to the border with the Democratic Republic of theCongo, French was the second most dominant language after Kinyarwanda. Due to the highnumber of French-speaking visitors, hotels and spas in Gisenyi conducted their business inFrench, while Huye, the former colonial capital, also has a high number of French-speakingpeople. By contrast, in the capital city of Kigali and in Musanze–a touristic town– Englishwas the preferred secondary language.

Page 15: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 15

Figure 5: Business Languages for Potential Clients (Cornell SMART Market Research Study, 2017)

Apart from their social media and online presence, the company does not currently utilizeany formal strategy to promote their products. Due to its limited promotional efforts, thebrand has very low recognition among its target audience, as seventy-nine percent ofhospitality survey respondents had not heard of the brand. (See Figure 6.)

Page 16: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 16

Figure 6: Awareness of Ikirezi (Cornell SMART Market Research Study, 2017)

In this regard, it is crucial for Ikirezi to improve its brand recognition to advance sales bothdomestically and internationally. In the short-term, social media promotion can serve as onerecommended channel through which Ikirezi can increase brand recognition, while long-term measures could involve more costly means such as radio and television promotion thatare scaled across local and regional media outlets.

Potential Challenges

Marketing and Competition

While Ikirezi produces high-quality essential oils, it faces the challenge of brand recognitionin Rwanda as essential oils and their benefits are unfamiliar to Rwandans. “Because manypeople in Rwanda don’t know about essential oils, we have to spend time and energyteaching people how to use the oils at market fairs, etc. However, doing so is costly andunpredictable because you can’t predict how many people will buy the products.”

[39]

Additionally, Ikirezi’s earnings have not allowed the company to invest in domestic

Page 17: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 17

commercial advertising. Ikirezi’s experience has shown that marketing techniques thatfocus on educating the potential client about Ikirezi’s products and their uses are necessaryfor creating new customers, but such strategies can be risky given their costs andunexpected returns.

Survey results revealed that Rwandans newly introduced to essential oils find Ikireziproducts too expensive given their small sizes.

[40]

Although Ikirezi has the advantage of being the only Rwandan producer of essential oils, itfaces competition from other producers of essential oils, primarily from South Africa. Ikireziproduces four types of essential oils. Lavender, though in high demand in Rwanda, is notwidely harvested because the country’s climate is not ideal for lavender cultivation.However, Ikirezi has invested in research and development to meet the domestic demandsfor essential oils (see Figure 7). Ikirezi is currently undertaking research to find whetherplants that produce other types of essential oils, such as lavender, tea tree, and rosemary,can be grown successfully in Rwanda.

Page 18: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 18

Figure 7: In-Demand Essential Oils (Cornell SMART Market Research Study, 2017)

In Rwanda, social enterprises are not yet differentiated from private businesses in terms ofpolicies, taxation, and incentives.

[41]

Therefore, Ikirezi depends on the quality of its products,and the stories of its communities to build a strong brand within Rwanda. Despite itsstrengths, Ikirezi faces intense competition from Rwanda’s largest competitor in theessential oil industry, South Africa. Fortunately, the Rwandan government’s recent “Made-in-Rwanda” campaign that promotes the production and consumption of Rwandan goodsmay help the organization in ways that could accelerate brand recognition and increasesales (Domestic Market Recapturing Strategy, 2015). Ikirezi is currently looking to findadditional sources of funding to support future growth and research and development.

Human Resources

Over the years, the responsibilities of each Ikirezi employee have increased, and staffmembers often feel overstretched.

[42]

For example, the employee responsible for marketingalso handles the bottling of the essential oils, manages order placement and delivery, andsupervises the intern’s work. Additionally, she is often asked to attend visitors to the mainoffice. Ikirezi’s limited in-house staff hinders its ability to recruit, hire, and train moreemployees which impedes the company’s ability to meet customer service demandssatisfactorily.

Potential Opportunities

Rwanda’s Emerging Middle-Class

Rwanda’s middle-classes look to spend their income on both local and internationalproducts.

[43]

Because of their willingness to spend, the group has the potential to define thedemand base for products on the market.

[44]

As it continues to expand, Rwanda’s middle-classis experiencing “changes in lifestyle, more recreational time, and greater spending power”which is causing individuals to purchase items that were typically marketed to members ofthe upper-class and tourists, including Ikirezi’s products.

Tourism

Over the past two decades, there has been a substantial increase in the market size ofessential oils. This increase has been attributed to growing demand in the food and lifestyle

Page 19: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 19

industries.[45]

Consumers all over the world are increasingly educated about healthy lifestyles,and there are increasing applications of essential oils in aromatherapy.

[46]

The increase indomestic and global consumer awareness about essential oils, coupled with a simultaneousgrowth of the Rwandan tourism industry, presents a unique opportunity for Ikirezi.According to the Rwanda Development Board, the number of tourist arrivals in Rwanda hasmore than doubled since 2010, which contributes to incremental increases in the nation’srevenue.

[47]

The Ikirezi staff have stated this increase in tourism as a potential opportunity fordomestic growth.

Ikirezi currently has partnerships with hotels to market its products to tourists. As the only“Made in Rwanda,” organic-certified essential oil company, Ikirezi represents adifferentiated brand that is easily marketable to tourists.

Conclusion

It is Dr. Hitimana’s dream to witness Ikirezi grow in the coming years, as exporting costsremain relatively low and untapped markets for essential oils in the West, Central, and EastAfrican regions are forthcoming.

[48]

However, competition looms in the European, Asian, andSouth African essential oil markets, while domestic competition is virtually non-existent.Further, the microeconomic environment in Rwanda is a boon for small and medium-sizedenterprises that seek to expand. Similarly, the Rwandan essential oils industry–albeit in itsinfancy–is positioned in Ikirezi’s favor.

After multiple readings of the market research study, Dr. Hitimana is aware of theopportunities and challenges that lie ahead. Should Ikirezi explore domestic markets? Is itpossible to market the brand in Rwanda successfully amidst limited resources? Aware thatstrategic decisions need to be made in the coming year, Dr. Hitimana is also considering thepotential consequences of the same. With his responsibility for local farmers weighingheavily on his mind, he asks: how can Ikirezi grow in line with the rapid and promisingfuture of Rwanda?

This research was made possible through the support of the StudentMultidisciplinary Applied Research Team (SMART) program within the EmergingMarkets Program (EMP) in the Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics andManagement at Cornell University. Many thanks to Dr. Nicholas Hitimana (CEO ofIkirezi), his staff and partners, and other stakeholders who hosted and supportedthe SMART students in Rwanda.

Page 20: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 20

References

“Vision & Mission.” Ikirezi Natural Products. Accessed May 05, 2018.1.https://www.ikirezi.com/missionandvision/. ↑Katz, Robert A., and Antony Page. “The Role of Social Enterprise.” SSRN Scholarly2.Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network, December 13, 2010.https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1724942. ↑“Vision & Mission.” Ikirezi Natural Products. Accessed May 05, 2018.3.https://www.ikirezi.com/missionandvision/. ↑“Essential Oils.” National Agricultural Export Development Board. Accessed May 5,4.2018. http://naeb.gov.rw/index.php?id=145. ↑“Products Overview.” Ikirezi Natural Products. Accessed May 5,5.2018.https://www.ikirezi.com/productsoverview/. ↑In January 2017, a Student Multidisciplinary Applied Research Team (SMART) of five6.students from Cornell University, working in partnership with the Ikirezi team,conducted two-week long market research for essential oils in Rwanda. See Annex A.↑“About Rwanda.” UNDP Rwanda. Accessed May 5, 2018.7.http://www.rw.undp.org/content/rwanda/en/home/countryinfo/. ↑“Doing Business 2018: Rwanda.” World Bank Group, 2018.8.http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/wbg/doingbusiness/documents/profiles/country/rwa.pdf. ↑“Rwanda Vision 2020.” Kigali, Rwanda: Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning,9.2000.https://www.sida.se/globalassets/global/countries-and-regions/africa/rwanda/d402331a.pdf. ↑“Rwanda Vision 2020.” Kigali, Rwanda: Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning,10.2000.https://www.sida.se/globalassets/global/countries-and-regions/africa/rwanda/d402331a.pdf. ↑“Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy II: 2013 – 2018.” Ministry of11.Finance and Economic Planning, May 2013.http://www.minecofin.gov.rw/fileadmin/templates/documents/NDPR/EDPRS_2.pdf. ↑“Doing Business 2018: Rwanda.” World Bank Group, 2018.12.http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/wbg/doingbusiness/documents/profiles/country/rwa.pdf. ↑“Rwanda: Middle-Class Growing in High Speed Says UNDP Report.” Great Lakes13.Voice, March 18, 2013.

Page 21: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 21

http://greatlakesvoice.com/rwandamiddle-class-growing-in-high-speed-says-undp-report/. ↑Junior Mutabazi, “A Growing Middle-class Will Attract More Investments,” The New14.Times | Rwanda, last modified September 7, 2016,http://www.newtimes.co.rw/section/article/2016-09-08/203336/. ↑“Doing Business 2018: Rwanda.” World Bank Group, 2018.15.http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/wbg/doingbusiness/documents/profiles/country/rwa.pdf. ↑“Doing Business 2018: Rwanda.” World Bank Group, 2018.16.http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/wbg/doingbusiness/documents/profiles/country/rwa.pdf. ↑“Africa: Rwanda.” The World Factbook, May 1, 2018.17.https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/rw.html. ↑“Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy II: 2013 – 2018.” Ministry of18.Finance and Economic Planning, May 2013.http://www.minecofin.gov.rw/fileadmin/templates/documents/NDPR/EDPRS_2.pdf. ↑“Essential Oils.” National Agricultural Export Development Board. Accessed May 5,19.2018. http://naeb.gov.rw/index.php?id=145. ↑The Rwanda Development Board (2017) estimates that the global market demand for20.geranium and patchouli will continue to increase five percent annually. ↑Rijsberman, Frank R. “Water Scarcity: Fact or Fiction?” Agricultural Water21.Management, Special Issue on Water Scarcity: Challenges and Opportunities for CropScience, 80, no. 1 (February 24, 2006): 5–22.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2005.07.001. ↑“Green Growth and Climate Resilience: National Strategy for Climate Change and Low22.Carbon Development.” Kigali, Rwanda: The Rwanda National Strategy on ClimateChange and Low Carbon Development, November 2011.http://rema.gov.rw/climateportal/IMG/pdf/green-growth-strategy-final.pdf. ↑Nicholas Hitimana, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 9, 2017. ↑23.Hitimana ↑24.Hitimana ↑25.Hitimana ↑26.“Essential Oils.” National Agricultural Export Development Board. Accessed May 5,27.2018. http://naeb.gov.rw/index.php?id=145. ↑Nicholas Hitimana, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 9, 2017. ↑28.Michelle Uwubuntu, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 18, 2017. ↑29.In addition to geraniums, lemongrass and patchouli plants are raised in nurseries. ↑30.Altangerel, “From the Farm to the Spa.” ↑31.

Page 22: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 22

Wilting: (of a plant, leaf, or flower) become limp through heat, loss of water, or32.disease; droop. “Wilt.” Merriam-Webster.com. Accessed March 21, 2017.https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/wilt. ↑Michelle Uwubuntu, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 18, 2017. ↑33.For detailed product description, see Annex B. ↑34.Nicholas Hitimana, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 9, 2017. ↑35.Altangerel, “From the Farm to the Spa.” ↑36.Altangerel, “From the Farm to the Spa.” ↑37.Rita Marcella and Sylvie Davies, “The use of customer language in international38.marketing communication in the Scottish food and drink industry,” European Journalof Marketing 38, no. 11/12 (2004): doi: 10.1108/03090560410560155. ↑Michelle Uwubuntu, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 18, 2017. ↑39.Altangerel, “From the Farm to the Spa.” ↑40.Nicholas Hitimana, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 9, 2017. ↑41.Michelle Uwubuntu, Personal Interview. Rwanda, January 18, 2017. ↑42.Mutabazi, “A Growing Middle-class” ↑43.Mutabazi, “A Growing Middle-class” ↑44.“Ikirezi Investment Brief,” Official Rwanda Development Board (RDB) Website,45.accessed December 25, 2016,http://www.rdb.rw/fileadmin/user_upload/Documents/Agriculture/T%20arround%20companies/Ikirezi_InvestmentBrief.pdf. ↑Essential Oil Market Analysis By Product (Orange, Corn Mint, Eucalyptus, Citronella,46.Peppermint, Lemon, Clove Leaf, Lime, Spearmint), By Application (Medical, Food &Beverage, Spa & Relaxation, Cleaning & Home) And Segment Forecasts To Market.Grand View Research (2016). Assessed March 12, 2017. ↑“Ikirezi Investment Brief,” Official Rwanda Development Board (RDB). ↑47.Altangerel, “From the Farm to the Spa.” ↑48.

Yeareen Yun

Yeareen Yun recently earned a Master of Public Administration at the Cornell Institute forPublic Affairs, where she concentrated in Economic and Financial Policy. As a Certified Anti-

Page 23: Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an

Making an Impact with Essential Oils: A Case Study on an EmergingAgribusiness in Rwanda

| 23

Money Laundering Specialist, Yeareen has experience in compliance and management ofregulatory issues involving banking and financial institutions. She has also worked withseveral nonprofits and NGOs, including UNICEF, where she oversaw a volunteermanagement project that led to a creation of a new comprehensive volunteer managementsystem and procedures. Yeareen received her Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy and Economicsfrom Mount Holyoke College in Massachusetts.View all posts