mariposa grove restoration - national park service · mariposa grove rd, 3 picnic 1 vault...

28
Mariposa Grove Restoration Choosing By Advantages Workshop | June 5-6, 2012

Upload: others

Post on 17-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

Mariposa Grove Restoration Choosing By Advantages Workshop | June 5-6, 2012

Page 2: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

Design Charette #2 Review Concept Evaluation Exercise

Page 3: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

CONCEPT EVALUATION RESULTS:

Red = lowest value per category Green = highest value The general scoring pattern indicated a relatively strong preference for Preliminary Draft Concept B: South Entrance Hub. This result is consistent with previous and subsequent exercises.

Design Charette #2 Review Results of Evaluation Exercise

Page 4: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 5: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

221

Page 6: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

2 Write-in comments

Write-in comments

Page 7: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

Mariposa Grove Restoration

DRAFT ALTERNATIVES

Page 8: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 9: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 10: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 11: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 12: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 13: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

Pacific Fisher Photo © Art Wolfe

Page 14: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 15: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 16: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 17: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 18: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

RESTORATION is paramount Guided by the best available science and information Toward the development of a plan that is feasible

Page 19: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

59

Page 20: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

294

Page 21: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

201

Page 22: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

172

Page 23: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

279

Page 24: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

221

Page 25: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

Photograph by Josh Helling

DRAFT COST ESTIMATING for Value Analysis

• Class C Cost Comparison • Layered Contingency Factors • Life Cycle Costs for Visitor Transportation

Systems

Page 26: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 27: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water
Page 28: Mariposa Grove Restoration - National Park Service · Mariposa Grove Rd, 3 Picnic 1 Vault 1000' Contour Interval - 20' MITHÜN YOSEMITE CONSERVANCY 2000' New Leach Field New Water

We are here

CBA/Value Analysis