meeting the challenge...retaining and attracting
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
1/148
Meeting the Challenge:Attracting and Retaining
a World-Class
Work Force
1. Overview andFramework
Meeting the Challenge:Attracting and Retaining
a World-Class
Work Force
1. Overview andFramework
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
2/148
Why it Matters
It is not at all clear how
government can be wellexecuted unless it is able to
compete more effectively for its
fair share of talent.
Government is always
going to be able to fill
vacancies. The important
question is whether we
can fill them with talented
and committed peoplewith the skills we need.
In the globalization system
One of the most important
and enduring competitive
advantages that a country
can have today is a lean,
efficient, honest civil service
system.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
3/148
Why it Matters
Dont give me excuses,
just make the hiring
process work!
In the government, you
get an order and you
follow it. I realize that as
a leader, I need to bemore creative and
innovative.
By the end of the day
I felt I had made a
terrible mistake My
agency lost its shineon my first day.
The challenge is to attract and
retain people who are a cut above
the competition. You need to provide
benefits, good working conditions,
and an environment that caters to
their personal needs and business
needs. Thats a tough balance.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
4/148
Why it Matters
Grant Thornton 2008 surveyHC/HR #1 concern
GT 2009 survey right talent #1
factor in clean audit 2009 survey of corporate CFOs
most critical factors: Strong leadership Hiring best people
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
5/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
6/148
Public Sector Workforce is Graying
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%
Under 30 30-39 40-49 50+
FederalState
Local
Private
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
7/148
Government Agency -- Today
DirectorMgmt. Services
January 21, 1972
Deputy DirectorMay 10, 1971
DirectorProperty Services
June 26, 1989
DirectorEngineering
February 16, 1970
DirectorEquipment Services
April 17, 1970
DirectorWater TreatmentAugust 15, 1966
Director
Field ServicesMarch 20, 1970
Director
Transportation & ParkingMarch 2, 1970
Director
Solid Waste & RecyclingDecember 12, 1991
Director
AdministrationAugust 10, 1970
Chief EngineerJanuary 16, 1995
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
8/148
Same Agency -- in 3 Years
RETIRED
Di i
RETIRED
Deputy Di ector
Director
Property ServicesRETIRED
DirectorEngineering
RETIRED
DirectorEquipment Services
RETIRED
DirectorWater Treatment
RETIRED
DirectorFiel Services
RETIRED
DirectorTransportation & Parking
DirectorSoli Waste & Recycling
RETIRED
DirectorAdministration
Chief Engineer
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
9/148
More Complex Workforce:Multiple Generations
Traditionalists (born before 1946)
Boomers (born 1946-64)
Gen Xers (1965-81)
Millennials (>1982)
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
10/148
More Complex Workforce:Changing Expectations
Free agents
Less loyalty -- transactionalrelationship
Knowledge nomads mobile skill sets
Demand work/life balance
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
11/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
12/148
Guam Division of Accounts Workforce:Today and Tomorrow
Total employees in2008 = 46
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
13/148
Guam Division of Accounts Workforce:Today and Tomorrow
Total employees in2008 = 46
Eligible to retire in5 years = 16
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
14/148
Guam Division of Accounts Workforce:Today and Tomorrow
Total employees in2008 = 46
Eligible to retire in5 years = 16
Eligible to retire in5-10 years = 7
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
15/148
Island Workforces Today and Tomorrow
Employees New Annual 5-Year 10-YearHires Turnover Retiremt. Retiremt.
Guam 46 48% 11% 35% 50%
Palau 125 20% 7% 16% 28%
USVI 107 24% 8% 27%
CMNI 125 33% 14% 8% 25%
American Samoa 147 24% 5% 20% 35%
FSM 77 31% 6% 10% 31%
Yap 25 64% 18% 4% 12%
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
16/148
So Whats It All Mean?
Workforce undergoing dramatic shifts
Tougher to attract and retain talent
Public sector feeling these effects first
Government must adapt to thetalent market, not vice-versa
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
17/148
What Well Cover
1. Recruiting and hiring talent Recruiting v. hiring
Meeting candidates expectations
Recruiting strategies
Effective hiring2. Onboarding effectively
What it is and why its important
How to onboard effectively
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
18/148
What Well Cover
3. Maximizing employee engagementWhat employee engagement means
Why its critical
What drives engagement
How to maximize engagement4. Building the leadership pipeline
What is leadership
Integrated approach to building leadership
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
19/148
What Well Cover
5. Working effectively with HR The evolving role ofHR
Setting mutual expectations
How to meet these expectations
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
20/148
What We Wont Cover
Secret formulas, magic bullets
Easy answers
Simple solutions
One-size-fits-all approaches
Turning you into an HR expert
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
21/148
Research: Creating andApplying New Knowledge
Recruiting on Campus Onboarding NewEmployees
Hiring Baby Boomers
What Students WantH
iringInterns
Building EmployeeEngagement
Finding Jobs
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
22/148
HowDoes Government Meet TheseWorkforce Challenges?
Understand expectations
Develop multiple pipelines fortalent
Recruit aggressively
Make the hiring process work
Maximize engagement and
satisfaction
Theimage cannotbe displayed.Your computer may nothave enough memory toopen theimage, or theimagemay havebeen corrupted. Restartyour computer,and then open thefileagain.If thered x stillappears, you may havetodeletetheimage and then insertitagain.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
23/148
HowDoes Government Meet TheseWorkforce Challenges?
Make performance management work
Build the talent/leadership pipeline
Create more flexible, timely, user-friendly
and responsive civil service systems
Use workforce planning as the foundationTheimage cannotbe displayed.Your computer may nothaveenough memory toopen theimage,or theimagemay havebeen corrupted.Restartyour computer,and then open thefileagain. Ifthe redx stillappears,you may haveto deletetheimageand then insertitagain.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
24/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
25/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
26/148
MissionAccomplished
Business
Strategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
Human Capital Framework
Plan for Succession
Reward/Recognize
Engage
Train/ Develop
Manage Performance
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire /
Onboard
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
27/148
Workforce Planning:What Its Really About
1.What talent do we need to succeed nowand in the future?
2.What talent do we have now?
3.Where are the gaps?4.How are we going to eliminate these gaps?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
28/148
Workforce Planning
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
29/148
There isnt any silver bullet toattract, develop and retain talent
It takes silver buckshot!
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
30/148
NowIts Your Turn!
Your workforce/talent challenges
How youre dealing with them
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
31/148
2. Recruiting and Hiring2. Recruiting and Hiring
Theimage cannotbe displayed.Your computer may nothaveenough memory toopen theimage,or theimagemay havebeen corrupted.Restartyour computer,andthen open thefileagain. Ifthe red x stillappears,you may havetodeletethe imageand then insertit again.
Meeting the Challenge:Attracting and Retaininga World-ClassWork Force
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
32/148
What Well Cover
Recruiting and hiring talent Recruiting v. hiring: whats the
difference?
Need for aggressive recruiting Recruiting strategies your role
Effective hiring Theimage cannotbe displayed.Your computer may nothaveenough memory toopen theimage, or theimagemay havebeen corrupted.Restartyour computer,and then open thefileagain.If thered x stillappears,you mayhavetodeletethe imageand then insertit again.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
33/148
MissionAccomplished
Business
Strategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
Human Capital Framework
Plan for Succession
Reward/Recognize
Engage
Train/ Develop
Manage Performance
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire /Onboard
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
34/148
Why it Matters
It is not at all clear how
government can be well
executed unless it is able
to compete more
effectively for its fairshare of talent.
Government is always
going to be able to fill
vacancies. The important
question is whether we
can fill them with talented
and committed people
with the skills we need.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
35/148
The Research
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
36/148
Recruiting v. Hiring
1. Recruiting Attracting an adequate numberof interested and well-qualified candidates
2.Hiring Evaluating the candidates to decide who to hire
(i.e., who to make the job offer to) Getting the best candidate to accept
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
37/148
Reactive v. Proactive Recruiting
Reactive
Repeat the job description
Create a new brochure
Post an ad newspaper, Web
Sit back and wait
Proactive
Where can I find the bestpeople?
How do I reach them?
How do I convince them toapply? Accept?
How can I best use our limitedresources?
Recruiting is everyones job!
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
38/148
The Universum IDEAL Employer Survey
Annual survey of undergraduatestudents
43,313 respondents
195 colleges/universities
260 employers
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
39/148
What Are the Top Attractors?
Culture that respects my individuality
Work/life balance
Base salary
High level of responsibility
Good reputation Rapid promotion
High ethical standards
Exciting products and services
Friendly work environment
Creative, dynamic work environment
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
40/148
Top 4 Career Goals
1. Work/life balance (66%)
2. Dedicated to a cause, feel that I amserving a greater good (46%)
3. Secure or stable in my job (46%)4. Competitively or intellectually challenged
(40%)
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
41/148
% extremely or very interested in working for
Where Students Want to Work
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
42/148
But FewPlan to Work in Government
37%
24%
18%
3%
3%
2%
1%
1%
3%
8%
Graduat
school or additional
ducation
Jobs in a privat
company or busin
ss
Job in th
f
d
ral gov
rnm
nt
Job in stat or local gov rnm nt
Job in a nonprofit organization
S
rvic
: Am
ricorps, T
ach for Am
rica
Volunt r Work
Military s
rvic
Oth
r
nknown
Which best describes your current plans immediately after graduating?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
43/148
How knowledgeable do you feel about career and internship opportunities in government?
Why? Because Knowledge is Low
13% Total Knowledgeable
B Th M Th K
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
44/148
But The More They Know,the More They Like
Did information -- what you saw, heard or read -- about federal
government job or internship opportunities make you more or lessinterested in government opportunities?
% more interested
L i T l h T bl
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
45/148
Leaving Talent on the Table:Capitalizing on Intern Programs
The numbers Private sector employers hire 50% of interns
Jumps to 59% for co-ops
40% of all vacancies filled byinterns
Employers see internships asone of most effective hiring tools
Students see internships as avenueto full-time employment
R iti St t i
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
46/148
Recruiting Strategies:High Techplus High Touch
Develop a long-term strategy build alliancesand relationships
Identify needs recruiting plan
Avoid drive-by recruiting
Invest to build success Obtain and provide a point of contact
Recruit aggressively market andpersonalize public service to multiple talent
pools
R iti St t i
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
47/148
Recruiting Strategies:High TechPlus High Touch
Use near peers
Hire through internships Provide substantive work
Follow up
Convert students to permanent employees
Use technology but smartly!
Recruiting is everyones job!
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
48/148
Why Become Involved in Recruiting ?
You know the work
You know the culture and workenvironment
You know the skills and competencies
You know the impact
You can provide high touchTheimage cannotbe displayed.Your computer may nothaveenough memory toopen theimage,or theimagemay havebeen corrupted.Restartyour computer,and then open thefileagain.If thered x stillappears,you may havetodeletetheimageand then insertitagain.
P li M ki Diff i
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
49/148
Personalize: Making a Difference inPeoples Lives and Your Own
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
50/148
This Web Site
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
51/148
Or This Site?
The Hiring Process What Job
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
52/148
The Hiring Process -- What JobCandidates are Saying
The overall feel of the
vacancy announcement
is negative and heavy
handed. If the application
is like this, whats it like
to work there and why
would you want to?
Dont give me
excuses, just make
the hiring process
work!
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
53/148
How to Alienate Good Candidates
Use long, bureaucratic, boringannouncements
Use paper-based applications
Take too much time hiring
Conduct bad interviews
Dont communicate with them
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
54/148
1. Be concise, use fewer words, get to the point
2. Tell me exactly what you need -- I have no idea
what your jobs are looking for
3. Let me apply online using my rsum
4. Tell me in plain language -- get rid of jargon
5. Tell me when I will hear from you
6. We want to hear from you. We can take badnews -- just tell us!
What Candidates Desperately Want
How Many Steps Does it Take to Hire a
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
55/148
How ManySteps Does it Take to Hire aGovernment Employee?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
56/148
Were Not Done Yet!
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
57/148
Job Announcement -- Before
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
58/148
It Goes On
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
59/148
And On
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
60/148
After Concise and Appealing
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
61/148
Fixing the Hiring Process
Improve the front end -- get engagedearly, prepare for roles
Make process effective, timely, user-friendlyAutomate -- online
Evaluate smartly
Eliminate steps Communicate early, often
Use flexible certification approaches
Interview well
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
62/148
Hiring Best Practices
Immediate job offers
Hiring/referral bonuses
Realistic job previews (e.g., job video)
Flexible work arrangements
Measure results
i d
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
63/148
In Groups -- Discuss and Report
3 or 4 ways your recruiting can be improved
3 or 4 ways your hiring process can beimproved
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
64/148
3. Onboarding Effectively3. Onboarding Effectively
Meeting the Challenge:
Attracting and Retaininga World-ClassWork Force
H C i l k
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
65/148
MissionAccomplished
Business
Strategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
Human Capital Framework
Plan for Succession
Reward/Recognize
Engage
Train/ Develop
Manage Performance
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire /
Onboard
Wh W ll C
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
66/148
What Well Cover
Onboarding effectively
What is onboarding?
Why is it important?
How to onboardeffectively
Wh i M
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
67/148
Why it Matters
My first week wasterrible.
By the end of the day I felt
I had made a terrible
mistake in leaving my old
job.
My agency lost its shine
on my first day.
Wh i M
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
68/148
Why it Matters
Improves employee performance
Increases employee engagement
Improves employee retention,reduces turnover costs
Accelerates time-to-productivity
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
69/148
BOOZALLEN.COM OURPUBLICSERVICE.ORG
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
70/148
Wh t i O b di ?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
71/148
What is Onboarding?
Integrating and acculturating new employeesinto the organization and providing them with
the tools, resources, and knowledge tobecome successful and productive
From accepted offer to end of first year
h i
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
72/148
My first week was terrible. I
didnt have any equipment, I
wasnt given any
assignments, there was
nothing on my desk, and my
supervisor did not even
come see me for the first
three days I was there.
I was sent to a conference roomwhere someone from HR helped
me complete a bunch of forms. I
was not introduced to anyone, and
no one had set up my computer
access so I sat there and stared at
the wall.
I didnt receive my ID on the first day
so it was hard for me to go anywhere
and my manager did not give me any
work to do. My manager was not
welcoming. By the end of the day I wasterrified that I had left a great job.
What NewHires Have to Say
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
73/148
St t i O b di M d l
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
74/148
Strategic Onboarding Model
Recommendations
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
75/148
Recommendations
Define onboarding goals
Assess your onboarding status
Seek quick wins
Use technology smartly
Tailor onboarding to type of employee
Dont reinvent the wheel borrow it
Measure results
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
76/148
In Groups Discuss and Report
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
77/148
In Groups -- Discuss and Report
1. 1 good and 1 bad onboarding experience2. Barriers to effective onboarding
3. Steps your organizations can take to
improve onboarding
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
78/148
4. Maximizing EmployeeEngagement
4. Maximizing EmployeeEngagement
Meeting the Challenge:
Attracting and Retaininga World-ClassWork Force
What Well Cover
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
79/148
What We ll Cover
Maximizing employee engagement forproductivity and retention
What employee engagement means
Why its critical What drives engagement
How to maximize engagement
Human Capital Framework
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
80/148
MissionAccomplished
Business
Strategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
Human Capital Framework
Plan for Succession
Reward/Recognize
Engage
Train/ Develop
Manage Performance
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire /
Onboard
What is Employee Engagement?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
81/148
What is Employee Engagement?
Heightened connection to work, the organization,the mission or the people they work with
Goes beyond basic job satisfaction -- employees findpersonal meaning in their work
P
ride in what they do and how they do it Believe their organization values them
The more engaged, more likely to go above minimumrequired and expend discretionary effort to deliverexcellent performance
Why it Matters
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
82/148
Why it Matters
High levels of employee engagement correlatewith:
Better program results
Higher customer satisfaction
Less sick leave and missed work time due to work-related injury or illness
Higher retention
Engagement and Financial Outcomes
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
83/148
Engagement and Financial Outcomes
Financial performance consistently strongerin companies that emphasize:
Commitment Job satisfaction
But ... high levels of employee engagementrequire active leadership support
30 Multinational Companies
High Engagement High Retention
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
84/148
High Engagement High Retention
Total Percent Satisfied
Satisfaction with:Employees
planning to stayfor > 2 yrs
Employeesplanning to leave
in < 2 yrsGap
Use of skills and abilities 83% 49% 34%
Ability of top management 74% 41% 33%
Company sense of direction 57% 27% 30%
Advancement opportunities 50% 22% 28%
Opportunity to learn new
skills
66% 38% 28%
Coaching and counselingfrom supervisor
54% 26% 28%
High Engagement Better
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
85/148
Customer Outcomes
Work units with higher overall customer satisfaction scores also have
employees with more favorable opinions
6864
70
65
58
53
70
65
5350
64
58
20
40
60
80
100
Leadership -
Immediate
Supervision
Jo b
Satisfaction
Abili ty to Get
the Job Done
Performance
Management
Pay, Benefi ts,
and Career
Action
Planning
High Customer Satisfactio n Low Customer Satisfactio n
Island Workforces
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
86/148
Today and Tomorrow
Employees New Annual 5-Year 10-YearHires Turnover Retiremt. Retiremt.
Guam 46 48% 11% 35% 50%
Palau 125 20% 7% 16% 28%
USVI 107 24% 8% 27%
CMNI 125 33% 14% 8% 25%
American Samoa 147 24% 5% 20% 35%
FSM 77 31% 6% 10% 31%
Yap 25 64% 18% 4% 12%
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
87/148
The Best Places
to Work2009
bestplacestowork.org
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
88/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
89/148
Why Ratings and Rankings Matter
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
90/148
Why Ratings and Rankings Matter
INCENTIVE to oc on en e ent ndde e op i -per or in or ni tion
ROADMAP for i prove ent
TRANSPARENCYfor public nd jobee er
OVERSIGHT infor tion for Con re
Employee Engagement Score
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
91/148
Considering everything, how satisfied are you withyour job?
Considering everything, how satisfied are you withyour organization?
I would recommend my organization as a good placeto work
Employee Engagement Score
2009 Government Wide Score 63.3
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
92/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
93/148
Workplace Dimensions
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
94/148
Workplace Dimensions
Effective leadership
Employee skills/mission match
Strategic management
Teamwork
Performance-based awards Training and development
Support for diversity
Pay and benefits
Family-friendly culture Work/life balance
What Do These Dimensions Mean?Eff i L d hi
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
95/148
Effective Leadership
My immediate supervisor/team leader doesa good job
Supervisors support employee development
Performance discussions are worthwhile
I have a high level of respect for seniorleaders
Leaders generate high motivation andcommitment
What Do These Dimensions Mean?Eff ti L d hi ( t )
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
96/148
Effective Leadership (cont.)
Leaders maintain high standards of honesty andintegrity
I have a feeling of personal empowerment andownership of work processes
Complaints, disputes or grievances are resolved
fairly
Satisfaction with involvement in decisions thataffect work
Satisfaction with the information received from
management
What Do These Dimensions Mean?E l Skill /Mi i M t h
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
97/148
Employee Skills/Mission Match
My work gives me feeling of personalaccomplishment
I like the kind of workI do
My talents are used well I know how my work relates to mission and
goals
I do important work
What Do These Dimensions Mean?W k/Lif B l
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
98/148
Work/Life Balance
My supervisor supports my need to balancework and family issues
I have sufficient resources
(e.g., people, materials, budget, etc.) to getwork done
My workload is reasonable
What Do These Dimensions Mean?T i i d D l t
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
99/148
Training andDevelopment
I am given a real opportunity to improve myskills in my organization
I have enough information to do my job well
My training needs are assessed I am satisfied with the training received for
present job
Becoming and Staying a Best Place
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
100/148
Systematically obtain employee feedback
Share information a dual responsibility
Figure out what driver satisfaction
Focus on managers/supervisors Manage performance
Train and develop
Track changes over time
g y g
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
101/148
In Groups -- Discuss and Report
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
102/148
p p
1. What are the barriers in your organizationto maximizing employee engagement?
2. 3-4 steps your organization can take tomaximize employee engagement
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
103/148
5. Building the LeadershipPipeline
5. Building the LeadershipPipeline
Meeting the Challenge:
Attracting and Retaininga World-ClassWork Force
Why it Matters
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
104/148
y
In the government, you
get an order and you
follow it. I realize that as
a leader, I need to be
more creative and
innovative. We need an opportunity
to be inspired about our
work and to believe that
we can really make a
difference.
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
105/148
Human Capital Framework
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
106/148
MissionAccomplished
Business
Strategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
p
Reward/Recognize
Train/Develop
Plan for
Succession
Engage
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire/
Onboard
Manage Performance
Integrated Approach toBuilding the Leadership Pipeline
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
107/148
Building the Leadership Pipeline
Program Evaluation
Why the Integrated Approach
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
108/148
Many ways to build leadership pipeline
Because all aligned with strategic plan,workforce plan, competency model, and/orother frameworks, aligned with each other
Pipeline larger -- demand for more talent
Whos in the Pipeline?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
109/148
p
Time
High Potentials and
Replacement Pool for Sr.
Managers
MiddleManagers
1st-line Supervisors
Technical
Specialists
All Employees?
What Are Developmental Needs?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
110/148
p
Understanding other departments
Understanding enterprise and its environment
Building relationships and networks
Getting things done in government
Managing change
Managing the public
Managing the media
Influencing, motivating, developing, retaining talent Managing conflict, dealing with problem employees
Leadership Development Best Practices
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
111/148
p p
Other
Brookings Institution
GeorgetownUniversity
Harvard KennedySchool of Government
Louisiana StateUniversity
Senior ExecutivesAssociation
Young GovernmentLeaders
Public
Army War College
Defense LogisticsAgency
Federal ExecutiveInstitute
GovernmentAccountability Office
Office of Managementand Budget
Office ofPersonnelManagement
Office of the Director ofNational Intelligence
Private
Accenture
Aon Corporation
The Boeing Company
GE
Goldman Sachs
IBM
IDEO
Lockheed Martin
McKinsey & Company
Procter & Gamble
Leadership Development Best Practices
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
112/148
p p
Leadership development part of system (e.g.,
succession planning, competencies,performance management)
Current leaders develop future leaders
(not necessarily expensive) Leaders learn best by doing
Executive coaching addresses unique, real-
time needs
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
113/148
Coursework
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
114/148
Defining Leadership &Managing People
Understanding yourleadership style
Managing people
Building teams
Leading Innovation &Managing Change
Driving innovation
Managing change
Managing Projects &Networking
Delivering results on timeand on budget
Establishing and cultivating
your network for success
Communicating with &Influencing Executives
Making a business case
Selling your ideas Writing and communicating
ContinuousSelf- Development
Creating and managing your
individual development plan Seeking career guidance
Projects:Solving Governments Problems
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
115/148
Project Criteria:
Important managementissue that requires action
Solutions within control ofan agency
Potential for high-impactresults
Agency Criteria:
Leadership committed totesting innovative solutions
Committed to providingnecessary background
materials and data Support participants and their
time away from the job
Solving Government s Problems
Dealing with High-RiskIssues
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
116/148
Improve communication between USDAand FDA to strengthen food safety duringrecalls
Recruit talent required to care for veterans
Ensure sufficient energy for our country
Improve employee morale to enhanceeconomic and homeland security
Coaching
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
117/148
360o assessments anonymous
Coaches identify strengths,weaknesses and blind spots
Personal action-planning tool forlong-term skills development
Personal coach for ongoing advice --government and business leaders
360o repeated after program tomeasure growth
Building Your Leadership Pipeline
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
118/148
1. Engage senior leaders
2. Identify competencies
3. Assess developmental needs
4. Create leadership development strategy
5. UseIndividualDevelopment Plans (IDPs)
6. Tap into talent pool of retirement-eligibleemployees and retirees
7. Dont let $$$ be the barrier8. Assess results
In Groups -- Discuss and Report
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
119/148
1.What are your barriers to developing
leaders?
2.What can you do to address these
barriers?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
120/148
6. Building a StrongPartnership withHR6. Building a Strong
Partnership withHR
Meeting the Challenge:
Attracting and Retaininga World-ClassWork Force
What Well Cover
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
121/148
Building a strong partnership with HR The evolving role ofHR
Setting mutual expectations
How to meet these expectations
Human Capital Framework
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
122/148
MissionAccomplishedBusinessStrategies
Resources
Environment
Workforce
Planning
Plan for Succession
Reward/Recognize
Engage
Train/ Develop
Manage Performance
Core
Purpose/
Values
Recruit and Hire /
Onboard
Why it Matters
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
123/148
It is not at all clear howgovernment can be well
executed unless it is able to
compete more effectively for
its fair share of talent.
HR must give
value or give
notice.
If line managers and HR
professionals are to be the
champions of organizationalcapability, then a new
agenda for both HR practices
and HR professionals mustemerge.
HR Evolving -- Splitting in Two
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
124/148
Administrative and transactional work --increasingly automated or outsourced
Transformational work -- helps developorganizational goals, determines what
capabilities are needed and creates HRpractices
David Ulrich
The Shift in Theory
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
125/148
Personnel management HR management
Rule maker Consultant
Functional orientation Business orientation
One-size-fits-all Tailored programs
Centralized decisions Framework for others to decide
Mutual distrust Partnering
Focus on activities Focus on impact
Internal services Outsourcing
Managements View ofHR
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
126/148
What best describes the way your organization's executive management
views its HR organization?
60.6%
18.4%
13.7%
7.3%
50.0%
15.6%
21.9%
12.5%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%
Strategic Asset
Cost Center
No Strong Opinion
Other
Non-Public Sector Public Sector
N=449
What Do You Think?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
127/148
IsH
R: Strategic asset?
Cost center?
The Current Reality
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
128/148
Very little change in how
HR spendsits time
Instead of playing a central strategic
business partner role, HR hasresponded by maintaining status quo
Ed Lawler
Whats HRs Mission?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
129/148
Implement a system of personnel administration which will
ensure equitable treatment of employees through a meritsystem based on recognized princ1ples ofappointment, promotion, classification, termination andother aspects of government employment.
Plan, organize and implement pre-service training, in-service
and federal programs to rehabilitate, upgrade, and enhancethe skills and work performances of all employees thuspromoting self-reliance, dependability and enhancecompetencies in the quality services for the public.
Whats HRs Mission?
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
130/148
Attract, develop and retain the talentwe need and measure our progress
Value ofHR Transformation
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
131/148
3
19
38
63
43
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
1 (not
important/valuable)
2 3 4 5 (extremely
important/valuable)
How important is HR transformation to your future plans?
N=166
HR Areas Needing Improvement
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
132/148
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%
Workforce Planning
IT
Training / Employee Dev
Comp Admin
Recruitment
BenefitsJob Candidate Testing
Payroll
Orientation
Retirement Plan Mgmt
Workers Comp
Union Contract Negotiation
Other
48%
43%
43%
39%
30%
30%26%
23%
20%
17%
12%
9%
4%
What HR areas need the most transformation & improvement?
Workforce Planning:What Its Really About
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
133/148
1.What talent do we need to succeed nowand in the future?
2.What talent do we have now?
3.Where are the gaps?
4.How are we going to eliminate these gaps?
Workforce Planning
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
134/148
HRs New Roles
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
135/148
BusinessPartner
Change Agent
HR Expert
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
136/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
137/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
138/148
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
139/148
Leader
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
140/148
Promotes merit systems principles
Fosters diversity
Balances employee satisfaction with
organizational requirements and goals
Builds teamwork
Models collaborative problem-solving
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
141/148
What Managers Should Expect from HR
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
142/148
Understand HR business and your businessand howHR can support strategy
Build partnerships -- be flexible, championchange
Rely on data -- deliver measurable resultson outcomes
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
143/148
What You Can Do
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
144/148
Become involved in recruiting and hiring
Do a good job onboarding new employees
Make performance management work
Train and develop
Ask questions and push for change
Understand tomorrows workforce
Resources
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
145/148
International
Public ManagementAssociation for HR ipma-hr.org
Society for Human Resources
Management sh
rm.org Human Capital Institute humancapitalinstitute.org
In Groups -- Discuss and Report
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
146/148
1. 3 or 4 approaches/strategies that youcan discuss with your HR staff when
you return home
2. 3 or 4 ways you plan to engage moredirectly with HR
KeyPoints
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
147/148
Recruit aggressively and widely
Hire quality talent -- efficiently
Onboard well
Maximize engagement
Reach out to HR set expectations
-
8/8/2019 Meeting the Challenge...Retaining and Attracting
148/148
There isnt any silver bullet toattract, develop and retain talent
It takes silver buckshot!