michël toma, mt partenaires ingénierie and didier bouteiller, city of lorient: the french...

Supporting Local Authoritites in the Development and Integration of SEAPs with

Energy management Systems According to ISO 50001www.50001seaps.eu

@50001SEAPs

4th Centralized training session

The French Connection Part 1

Connecting SEAPs with EEA and ISO 50001

Lyon, 19st october 2015

Michaël TOMA, director

MT Partenaires Enginnering,

Bordeaux, France



@50001SEAPs 2

Sustainable development in Bordeaux

Lyon I'll STILL do everything to

save on water !

Beaujolais

nouveau

released tonite !



@50001SEAPs 3

THE FRENCH CONNECTION

Connecting the French context of compulsory energy

& climate plans to SEAPs

Connecting SEAPs to ISO 50001 & EEA



@50001SEAPs 4

TOUR DE FRANCE

Info & training sessions

Informing communities :

Finding project partners

Involving authorities (ADEME

and EEA Cit'ergie advisors)

Participation of AFNOR the

French standardisation body

1

2

3

4

5



@50001SEAPs 5

PARTNER COMMUNITIES

1 City already EEA awardee

1 City - Tours

+ its conurbation : an

integrated metropolis

1 conurbation : Communauté

d'Agglomération du Muretain

Lorient

57 000 hab.

T+: 300 000 h, 22 cities

Tours 135 000 hab.

CAM : 17 cities

90 000 hab.



@50001SEAPs 6

FRENCH CONNECTION

Neary 0,5 M Inhabitants living in 40 cities

Our methodology :

Commitment

Write a SEAP based on Climate Energy Plans

and submit to COM

Set up the EnMS of communities' significant

energy uses

Pre-audit and then audit EnMS

Carry out & monitor community actions



@50001SEAPs 7

BACK TO THE OLD EEA – ISO 50001 ISSUE

EEA : reference tool of the COM

EEA CLAIMS THAT IT HELPS DEPLOY ENMS : IN FACT IT IS A

TOOL FOR SUPPORTING ENERGY POLICY

EEA : 93 % in AT, CH, DE, LU -

SEAP : 80% ES, IT

ISO 50001 : International standard

French panorama (early 2015)

ENTERPRISES < 100 (ELECTRICAL MANUFACTURER, WATER, LOGISTICS, …)

SUPERMARKETS : 800

CITIES : 1 (AND MORE TO COME THANKS TO OUR PROJECT)

WASTE INCINERATOR : 1



@50001SEAPs 8

BACK TO THE OLD EEA – ISO 50001 ISSUE

EEA : reference tool of the COM

EEA claims that it helps deploy EnMS : in fact it

is a tool for supporting energy policy

EEA : 93 % in AT, CH, DE, LU - SEAP : 80% ES, IT

ISO vs. EEA issues are :

Perimeter : significant energy uses of community assets for ISO,

territory for EEA

EEA : initial diagnosis, labelling and then annual assessments

EEA may need a complementary tool to implement EnMS !



@50001SEAPs 9

EEA – Cit'ergie

A global approach of the entire influence sphere of the

community based on 79 actions in 6 domaines

Domaine 1 Territory development policy and planning 84 17 %

Domaine 2 Community assets 76 15 %

Domaine 3Utilities on the territory : water, wastewater and

waste104 20 %

Domaine 4 Mobility 96 19 %

Domaine 5 Internal organisation 44 9 %

Domaine 6 Communication, cooperation 104 20 %

Maximum potential 508 100 %

Points %



@50001SEAPs 10

SEAPPC(A)ET

French connection : EEA vs. ISO 50001 perimeter analysis

Terr. Strategy

Communication

MobilityAssets

Water, En, WasteOrganisation

olicyEN

po

licy Significant

energy uses

Energ

y

Car

fleet

Territorial

energy

approach

(SEAP)

Asset Energy

management

system

Public

trans-

port

Ow

n

op

era

tio

n



@50001SEAPs 11

Item Indicator Action Expectation Limit Target

GHG/pop tCO2-e/pop Strategy diminishing 7,45 5,2

Share of RE % Assets growing 30%

EE kWh/m2/yr

kWh/pop/yr

Assets diminishing 320

50

INSPIRATIONAL APPROACH ON EEA

Huge EU database of some 1500 communities all

over Europe updated yearly

Legal framework is constanly updated

EEA has a very interesting set of 58 indicators.



@50001SEAPs 12

WRAPPING UP

EEA and ISO 50001 are completing each other :

Communities having a strong commitment feel

the need to implement EnMS (ISO 50001) on

significant assets

Brest Metropolis (included opportunity study for ISO in EEA)

Vienne Agglomération (ViennAgglo) quite interested in EnMS

Bordeaux Metropole will deploy ISO 50001

Lorient (EEA award : 60%) – our project partner



@50001SEAPs

Lorient

EEA + SEAP + ISO 50001

Implementing a SEAP + EnMS in a city already

awardee of EEA

Pierre Crépeaux and Didier Bouteiller

City of Lorient



@50001SEAPs

Lorient – 57 000 inhabitants –

Conurbation: ~200 000 inhabitants



@50001SEAPs 15

LORIENT’S CLIMATE ACTION PLAN (SEAP)

2 levels:

-Conurbation (Lorient Agglomération) : “3x20%” in

2020 (ref. 1990)

-City (on its own buildings, and street lights):

“3x30%” in 2020 (ref. 1990)

Patrimoine dit « économique »

68 000 m²

Patrimoine de la Ville de Lorient 292 000 m²

Maintenance

exploitation (5%)

220 000 m² Maintenance

seule (1%)

43 000 m²

Baux (0%)

25 000 m²

Maintenance propriétaire (1%)

263 000 m²

location

4 300 m²

- 292 000 m² of municipal buildings- 179 buildings, 108 + 200 electricity meters, 72 gaz meters, 122 water meters



@50001SEAPs 16


Some good results!

-0,4

-0,3

-0,2

-0,1

0

0,1

0,2

0,3

0,4

0,5

0,6

0,7

0,8

19

78

19

80

19

82

19

84

19

86

19

88

19

90

19

92

19

94

19

96

19

98

20

00

20

02

20

04

20

06

20

08

20

10

20

12

20

14

% downsizing CO2 emissions / 1990



@50001SEAPs 17


Some good results!



@50001SEAPs 18


Some mixed results!

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

Milio

ni

Bois Gaz Fioul Electricité - Bâtiments Electricité - Eclairage public

Objectif 2020

Wood Fuel Electricity – buildings Electricity – street lights

In order to meet

the 2020

objectives, Lorient

must find 10GWh

of reduction of

energy

consumption…



@50001SEAPs 19

EUROPEAN ENERGY AWARDS (EEA)

The European Energy Award is a quality management and certification system for

municipalities and regions. It supports local authorities in establishing

interdisciplinary planning approaches and implementing effective energy and climate

policy measures.

Lorient’s score: 60%

Reachable in four years : 70%



@50001SEAPs 20

EEA



@50001SEAPs 21

EEA



@50001SEAPs 22

ISO 50001 FOR LORIENT2 goals:

- Improving our level of energy/performance reviews, wich seems to be a

little flaw in our climate policy

- Enabling the reach of our -30% energy consumption objective

Perimeter:

-Street lights

-School and main

buildings monitoring



@50001SEAPs 23

Queries ?



@50001SEAPs 24

Thank you 4 Ur

attention

michël toma, mt partenaires ingénierie and didier bouteiller, city of lorient: the french...

Business