minnesota cost of living study annual report 2016
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Department of Employment and Economic Development 1st National Bank Building █ 332 Minnesota Street █ Suite E200 █ Saint Paul █ Minnesota 55101-1351
651-259-7114 PHONE █ 800-657-3858 TOLL FREE █ 651-296-4772 FAX █ 651-296-3900 TTY █ http://mn.gov/deed
An Equal Opportunity Employer and Service Provider
Minnesota Cost of Living Study
Annual Report 2016 Report to the Legislature
as required by MinnesotaStatutes2013,chapter116J,section13
May 2016
Author: John Clay, LMI analyst, principal study author
Steve Hine, LMI director
Oriane Casale, LMI assistant director, director of publications
Amanda Rohrer, LMI database administrator
Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development
Total cost of salaries, printing, and supplies in developing/preparing this report is $1,424.07.
(reported as required by Minn. Stat. 3.197).
![Page 2: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................3StudyMissionandPurpose......................................................................................................................3TypicalUsesoftheCostofLivingData.....................................................................................................3ATypicalMinnesotaFamily?....................................................................................................................4ImprovingtheStudy.................................................................................................................................4
ResultsandAnalysisStatewideandbyRegion............................................................................................5MinnesotaStatewide...............................................................................................................................6EconomicDevelopmentRegion1-Northwest........................................................................................7EconomicDevelopmentRegion2-Headwaters......................................................................................8EconomicDevelopmentRegion3-Arrowhead.......................................................................................9EconomicDevelopmentRegion4–WestCentral..................................................................................10EconomicDevelopmentRegion5–NorthCentral.................................................................................11EconomicDevelopmentRegion6E–SouthwestCentral.......................................................................12EconomicDevelopmentRegion6W–UpperMinnesotaValley............................................................13EconomicDevelopmentRegion7E–EastCentral.................................................................................14EconomicDevelopmentRegion7W-Central........................................................................................15EconomicDevelopmentRegion8-Southwest......................................................................................16EconomicDevelopmentRegion9–SouthCentral.................................................................................17EconomicDevelopmentRegion10-Southeast.....................................................................................18EconomicDevelopmentRegion11-TwinCitiesMetro.........................................................................19
FurtherAnalysisandRecommendations....................................................................................................20MedianWageasaShareoftheCostofLiving.......................................................................................20JobVacancyMedianWageOfferasaShareoftheCostofLiving.........................................................21ImpactonEmploymentRecruitmentandRetention.............................................................................21ImpactonMinorityCommunities..........................................................................................................21
Allindustriesaveragebyrace............................................................................................................22Lowwageindustriesaveragebyrace.................................................................................................22
ImpactonConsumerExpenditures........................................................................................................23ImpactonDemandforSocialServiceSubsidies.....................................................................................24
Sources.......................................................................................................................................................25StatutoryMandate.................................................................................................................................25
AppendixB.................................................................................................................................................26CostofLivingStudyDataSources..........................................................................................................26
AppendixC.................................................................................................................................................26MinnesotaEconomicDevelopmentRegions..........................................................................................26
![Page 3: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
IntroductionTheCostofLivingStudyprovidesanestimateofabasic-needscostoflivinginMinnesotaforindividualsandforvariousfamilysizes,bycounty,region,andstatewide.Thestudyexamineslivingcostsinsevencostcategories:food,housing,healthcare,transportation,childcare,othernecessities,andnettaxes.[1]
TheLaborMarketInformation(LMI)officeoftheDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment(DEED)ismandatedbyMinnesotaStatutes2013,chapter116J,section13toreporteveryFebruaryontheyear’supdatedCostofLivingStudyresultsandtoprovideanalysisandrecommendationstoaidintheassessmentofemploymentandeconomicdevelopmentplanningneedsthroughoutthestate.
StudyMissionandPurpose
ThemissionoftheCostofLivingStudyistoestimateabasic-needscostoflivinginMinnesotaforindividualsandfamilies,bycounty,region,andstatewide.Thestudyexamineslivingcostsinsevencostcategories:food,housing,healthcare,transportation,childcare,othernecessities,andnettaxes.TheCostofLivingrepresentsneitherapovertylivingnoramiddle-classlivingbutratherasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.Therefore,thefollowingcostsareexcluded,eventhoughtheymaybecommonexpenses:savings,vacations,entertainment,eatingout,tobacco,andalcohol.
TheCostofLivingstudyisanimportanttoolbecauseratherthandescribingwhatfamiliesarespending(aswiththeConsumerExpenditureSurvey)itexaminesthecostofbasicneeds.TheCostofLivingstudyalsolooksatdollarcosts,ratherthanlookingattherateofchangeovertime(aswiththeConsumerPriceIndex).
TheCostofLivingstudyresultsconstituteanadditionaleconomicindicatorwhichmaybeusedbypublicandprivateinstitutionsandbyindividuals.Findthemethodologyatmn.gov/deed/data/data-tools/col/method-col.jsp.
TypicalUsesoftheCostofLivingData
Employerswanttosetwagesthatattractandretaingoodworkers.TheCostofLivingToolcanhelpgaugewhetherawageinacertaincountywillpaythebillsandkeepworkersafloat.Jobseekerswanttoknowwhichkindsofworkwillcoverfamilycostsintheircounty.Workforcedevelopmentserviceproviderswanttoknowwhatwages,ifmet,arelikelytosecureaself-supportingcareerfortheclientjobseeker,thusreducingtheneedforre-entryintoservices.Policymakersandplannerswanttoknowiftheneedforpublicsubsidiesislikelytoriseorfall.Regionalwagesthatmeetorexceedthecostoflivingcansignalreducedneedforsubsidies.Policymakersandplannersalsowanttomonitorthepotentialforconsumerexpenditureswhichcandrivefutureeconomicgrowth.Regionalwagesthatmeetorexceedthecostoflivingcansignalapotentialforstrongerconsumerexpenditures.
![Page 4: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
ATypicalMinnesotaFamily?
BasedontheAmericanCommunitySurvey(DP02,5-YearSeries,2014),CurrentPopulationSurvey(C3,LivingArrangementsofChildrenUnder18Years,2015),andCurrentEmploymentStatistics(TotalPrivateSector,2015),aselectionof“Partnered,1full-timeand1part-timeworker,1child”intheonlineCostofLivingtoolbestrepresentsatypicalMinnesotafamily.Thisselectiongivesresultsforafamilyoftwoadultsworkingacombined60hoursperweek(oranaverageof30hoursperworker),andonechildunderschoolage.
TheaveragefamilysizeinMinnesotais3.1personsandtheaveragehouseholdsizeis2.5persons.Themajorityofthestate’shouseholds—65percent—arefamilyhouseholds.Marriedcouplesare79percentoffamilyhouseholds.
Althoughjustunderhalf--45.4percent--offamilyhouseholdshavechildrenoftheirown(bybirth,marriage,oradoption)underage18,DEEDselectedthe“Partnered,1full-timeand1part-timeworker,1child”asastandardbecauseoftheimportanceofmaintainingastateeconomywhichsupportsfamilieswithchildren.
AmongallU.S.childrenunderage18livingwithbothparents,60percenthavebothparentsinthelaborforceand73percentareage12orunder.TheaverageweeklyhoursperworkerinMinnesotais34hours.[2,3,4]
Foradditionalfamilycompositions,seetheonlineCostofLivingtoolatmn.gov/deed/data/data-tools/col/.
ImprovingtheStudy
DEEDmadeseveralimprovementstothewaythestudycalculatescostsforthisyear’sreport.Asaresultsomecostswillbehigherandsomelowerthaninpreviousversionsofthestudy.
Inthisreportallfamilycompositionsaregender-neutral.Thischangestrengthensthequalityofthedatabyallowingustoaveragetogethermaleandfemaledatasetsforalargertotalsample.Largersamplestendtoprovidemorereliableinformation.DEEDmadealong-overduereformoftheOtherNecessitiescostcategorybyaddingtelephoneservices,housekeepingsupplies,andhouseholdfurnishingstothetotalratherthanusingasmall“miscellaneous”sumtocoverthesenecessarycosts.ThehighercostnowassignedtoOtherNecessitiesisbothmoreexplicitlydefinedandmorerealisticthaninpreviousversionsofthestudy.Foranexplanationofthepreviousyears’methodology,pleaseseethe2015CostofLivingAnnualReport.
DEEDrevisedthetransportationmethodologytoapplyanaverageVehicleMilesofTravelbyhouseholdsizeratherthanbreakingoutnumberofadults,adultworkers,orchildren.Again,thischangeisintendedtostrengthenthequalityofthedatabyusingalargersample.
Finally,DEEDexaminedtheprospectsforbreakingoutthetransportationcostsofMinnesotanswhoworkinthesamecountywheretheyliveversusthecostsofthosewhocommutetoanothercountyforwork.Whilethisbreakoutwasnotimplementedinthe2016study,itcouldbeusedinthefuturetohelpemployerscomparethewagecostsofrecruitinglaborfromothercountiesversuslocally.
![Page 5: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
ResultsandAnalysisStatewideandbyRegionCostsforaMinnesotafamilyofthreeareshownforthestateasawholeandforeachofMinnesota’sthirteenEconomicDevelopmentRegions(EDRs).Resultsforthestateandforeachregionarecalculatedasapopulation-weightedaverageofresultsforeachcounty.Calculatingaweightedaveragehelpscorrectforanybiasesinthedatathatmightresultfromdifferencesbetweenthoseincludedinthestudysampleandtheactualpopulation.Thethirteenregionsare:
EconomicDevelopmentRegion1-NorthwestEconomicDevelopmentRegion2-HeadwatersEconomicDevelopmentRegion3-ArrowheadEconomicDevelopmentRegion4–WestCentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion5–NorthCentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion6E–SouthwestCentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion6W–UpperMinnesotaValleyEconomicDevelopmentRegion7E–EastCentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion7W-CentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion8-SouthwestEconomicDevelopmentRegion9–SouthCentralEconomicDevelopmentRegion10-SoutheastEconomicDevelopmentRegion11-TwinCitiesMetro
Thestudyexpressesthecostoflivingasayearlysumandanhourlyrate,inadditiontobreakingoutmonthlycostsineachofthesevencostcategories.
ThehourlywageanalysiscomparesdatafromtheCostofLivingStudywithemploymentdatafromtheOccupationalEmploymentStatistics(OES)programandjobvacancydatafromtheJobVacancySurvey(JVS).[5,6]
Forconvenientuseasareferenceorhand-out,eachregionispresentedonaseparatepageofthereport.
![Page 6: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
MinnesotaStatewide
AnnualCosts:$54,804
HourlyRate:$17.57
LookingatthestateofMinnesotaasawhole,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,withoneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$54,804peryearand$17.57perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$462,food$771,healthcare$408,housing$916,transportation$805,othernecessities$528,andtaxes$667.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinMinnesotais106percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedian
wageofferforjobvacanciesis74percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 7: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
EconomicDevelopmentRegion1-Northwest
AnnualCosts:$44,940
HourlyRate:$14.40
InNorthwesternMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$44,940peryearand$14.40perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$197,food$765,healthcare$408,housing$724,transportation$730,othernecessities$466,andtaxes$455.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinNorthwestMinnesotais114
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis82percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 8: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
EconomicDevelopmentRegion2-Headwaters
AnnualCosts:$46,740
HourlyRate:$14.98
IntheHeadwatersregionofMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$46,740peryearand$14.98perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$229,food$759,healthcare$408,housing$706,transportation$834,othernecessities$458,andtaxes$501.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsintheHeadwatersregionis105
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis69percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 9: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
EconomicDevelopmentRegion3-Arrowhead
AnnualCosts:$46,812
HourlyRate:$15.00
IntheArrowheadregionofMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$46,812peryearand$15.00perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$258,food$757,healthcare$408,housing$748,transportation$758,othernecessities$471,andtaxes$501.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsintheArrowheadregionis111 percent
ofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis77percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 10: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
EconomicDevelopmentRegion4–WestCentral
AnnualCosts:$45,672
HourlyRate:$14.64
InWestCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$45,672peryearand$14.64perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$233,food$760,healthcare$408,housing$700,transportation$773,othernecessities$457,andtaxes$475.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinWestCentralMinnesotais107
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis85percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 11: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
EconomicDevelopmentRegion5–NorthCentral
AnnualCosts:$48,048
HourlyRate:$15.40
InNorthCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$48,048peryearand$15.40perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$231,food$753,healthcare$408,housing$725,transportation$890,othernecessities$463,andtaxes$534.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinNorthCentralMinnesotais93
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis66percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 12: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
EconomicDevelopmentRegion6E–SouthwestCentral
AnnualCosts:$46,248
HourlyRate:$14.82
InSouthwestCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$46,248peryearand$14.82perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$230,food$760,healthcare$408,housing$698,transportation$813,othernecessities$456,andtaxes$489.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinSouthwestCentralMinnesotais111
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis67percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 13: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
EconomicDevelopmentRegion6W–UpperMinnesotaValley
AnnualCosts:$43,788
HourlyRate:$14.03
IntheUpperMinnesotaValley,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$43,788peryearand$14.03perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$190,food$777,healthcare$408,housing$670,transportation$723,othernecessities$453,andtaxes$428.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsintheUpperMinnesotaValleyis109
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis88percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 14: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
EconomicDevelopmentRegion7E–EastCentral
AnnualCosts:$57,588
HourlyRate:$18.46
InEastCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$57,588peryearand$18.46perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$394,food$749,healthcare$408,housing$921,transportation$1,058,othernecessities$523,andtaxes$746.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinEastCentralMinnesotais89
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis54percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 15: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
EconomicDevelopmentRegion7W-Central
AnnualCosts:$52,404
HourlyRate:$16.80
InCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$52,404peryearand$16.80perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$313,food$750,healthcare$408,housing$892,transportation$865,othernecessities$514,andtaxes$625.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinCentralMinnesotais100percentof
thecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis71percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 16: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
EconomicDevelopmentRegion8-Southwest
AnnualCosts:$43,524
HourlyRate:$13.95
InSouthwestMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$43,524peryearand$13.95perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$197,food$769,healthcare$408,housing$665,transportation$718,othernecessities$449,andtaxes$421.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinSouthwestMinnesotais106
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis84percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 17: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
EconomicDevelopmentRegion9–SouthCentral
AnnualCosts:$45,528
HourlyRate:$14.59
InSouthCentralMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$45,528peryearand$14.59perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$220,food$761,healthcare$408,housing$732,transportation$737,othernecessities$467,andtaxes$469.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinSouthCentralMinnesotais110
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis82percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 18: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
EconomicDevelopmentRegion10-Southeast
AnnualCosts:$48,828
HourlyRate:$15.65
InSoutheastMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$48,828peryearand$15.65perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$280,food$760,healthcare$408,housing$817,transportation$762,othernecessities$493,andtaxes$549.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsinSoutheastMinnesotais113
percentofthecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis88percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 19: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
EconomicDevelopmentRegion11-TwinCitiesMetro
AnnualCosts:$60,072
HourlyRate:$19.25
IntheTwinCitiesMetroregionofMinnesota,atypicalfamilyoftwoadultsandonechild,oneadultworkingfull-timeandonepart-timeforacombined60workhoursperweek,needtoearnanestimatedfamilyincomeof$60,072peryearand$19.25perhourperworkertomaintainasimplelivingthatmeetsbasicneedsforhealthandsafety.
Theestimatedmonthlycostsarechildcare$625,food$782,healthcare$408,housing$1,028,transportation$804,othernecessities$566,andtaxes$793.
ThemedianwagepaidtoworkersacrossalloccupationsintheTwinCitiesMetrois106percentof
thecostofliving,whilethemedianwageofferforjobvacanciesis62percentofthecostofliving.
![Page 20: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
FurtherAnalysisandRecommendationsAcomparisonofthecostoflivingandtypicalwagesbyregioncanhelpilluminatesomeoftheeconomicchallengesoropportunitiesforemploymentrecruitmentandretention,minoritycommunitywealth-building,consumerexpenditures,andsocialservices.
MedianWageasaShareoftheCostofLiving
Thestatewide$18.65medianwageofexistingjobsis106percentofthe$17.57costofliving.ThismeansthatalittleoverhalfofallworkingMinnesotansarepaidmorethanthefamily-of-threecostofbasicneeds.TheaveragefamilysizeinMinnesotais3.0personsandtheaveragehouseholdsize,forfamilyandnon-familyhouseholdscombined,is2.5persons.
Ifthelabormarketwereinperfectbalancewitheveryonematchedwiththerightjobs,thehalfofworkerspaidmorethanthemedianwagewouldbethefamilieslargerthanthree(whilethehalfofworkerspaidlesswouldbethefamiliessmallerthanthree).Thiswouldmeanthatamedianwageequaltothecostoflivingwasmeetingmostpeople’sbasicneeds.Buteconomistsknowthatnomarketiseverperfectlybalanced.
Thelimitsofavailabledatameanthateconomistsmustevaluatelivingstandardsbylookingatwhetheranarea’smedianwage,foralloccupationstogether,meetsorexceedsthecostofliving.AccordingtoOccupationalEmploymentStatistics,Minnesota’sstatewidemedianwageexceedsthestatewidecostofliving.ThemedianwagesintenofMinnesota’sthirteeneconomicdevelopmentregionsalsoexceedthecostoflivingwithinthosereasons.Herearethemedianwagesbyregionforthoseareasasapercentageofcostofliving:
• Northwestregion,114percent
• Southeastregion,113percent
• Arrowheadregion,111percent
• SouthwestCentralregion,111percent
• SouthCentralregion,110percent
• UpperMinnesotaValleyregion,109percent
• WestCentralregion,107percent
• Southwestregion,106percent
• TwinCitiesMetroregion,106percent
• Headwatersregion,105percent
TheCentralregion’smedianwageisexactly100percentoftheCostofLiving.MedianwagesintheNorthCentralregionareat93percentoftheregionalcostofliving.MedianwagesintheEastCentralregionareat89percentoftheregionalcostofliving.
![Page 21: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
JobVacancyMedianWageOfferasaShareoftheCostofLiving
Themedianwageofferedtoworkersintheprocessofhiringforjobvacancies,accordingtotheJobVacancySurvey,is74percentofthecostoflivingatthestatelevel.NoneofMinnesota’sthirteeneconomicdevelopmentregionsshowsamedianwageofferforvacancieswhichmeetstheregion’scostofliving.TheSoutheastandtheUpperMinnesotaValleyregionsarethehighestinthiscategory,withmedianwagesofferedtoworkerstofilljobvacanciesat88percentoftheregion’scostofliving.TheWestCentralregionis85percent,theSouthwestregionis84percent,theNorthwestandtheSouthCentralregionsbothare82percent,theArrowheadregionis77percent,theCentralregionis71percent,theHeadwatersregionis69percent,theSouthwestCentralregionis67percent,theNorthCentralregionis66percent,the7-CountyMetrois62percent,andtheEastCentralregionis54percentoftheregion’scostofliving.
Althoughthemedianwagelevelofferedtoworkerstofilljobvacanciesishistoricallylowerthanmedianwagesforfilledpositions—lower-wagejobsmighthavehigherturnoverandbecapturedmorefrequentlybytheJobVacancySurvey—aregionalmedianwageofferbelowtheregionalcostoflivingmaysignaleconomicchallengesaheadforemploymentrecruitmentandretention,minoritycommunitywell-being,andlocalconsumerexpenditures.
ImpactonEmploymentRecruitmentandRetention
AccordingtoemployersinterviewedforDEED’s2013HiringDifficultiesSurvey,demand-sideconditions,includingunsatisfactorywages,havecontributedtohiringdifficultiesintheproduction,industrialengineering,informationtechnology,andnursingoccupations.[7]Ifthesameholdstrueforotherindustries,thenregionswithamedianwageormedianwageofferbelowtheregionalcostoflivingmighttrytoimprovewagesinexistingoccupationsorexpandhigher-payingjobs.
Regionsmostinneedofemployee-retentionstrategiesincludetheNorthCentralandtheEastCentralregions,wherethemedianwageisbelowtheregionalcostofliving,andtheCentralregion,wherethemedianisexactlyequaltotheregionalcostofliving.
AllthirteenMinnesotaeconomicdevelopmentregions,includingtheMetro,showmedianwageoffersforvacantjobsbelowtheregionalcostofliving.Oneoptiontoimproveemployeerecruitmentmightbetoengageindemand-sidestrategies.RegionsthatwouldbenefitmostfromthesestrategiesincludetheCentral,theHeadwaters,theSouthwestCentral,theNorthCentral,the7-CountyMetro,andtheEastCentralregions,wherethejobvacancymedianwageofferasapercentoftheregionalcostoflivingfallsbelowthestatewideaverage.
ImpactonMinorityCommunities
DatashowsthattheaverageannualwageinMinnesotacandifferconsiderablyfromoneraceorethniccommunitytoanother.[8]DEEDusesdatafromtheU.S.CensusLongitudinalEmployer-HouseholdDynamics(LEHD)programtoexaminethesedifferences.WhilethereareafewdifferencesbetweenLEHDdataandtheCostofLivingstudydata,usingthesetwodatasetsprovidestheclosestapples-to-applescomparisonthatwecanget.ItisworthnotingthattheLEHDdataisfrom2014,whiletheCostofLivingStudydataisfrom2015.
![Page 22: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Allindustriesaveragebyrace
ThestatewideannualcostofbasicneedsforaMinnesotafamilyofthree,acrossallindustries,is$45,864.Theaverageannualwageperworkerregardlessofraceorethnicityis$48,733or106percentofthecostofbasicneeds.
TheaverageannualwageforWhiteNon-Hispanicworkersisthehighestinthestate,at$50,200or109%.ThisisalsothelargestpopulationgroupinMinnesota.Theaveragewageforallworkersofcolorcombinedis$36,524or80percentofthecostofbasicneeds.
AmongminorityracialandethnicgroupsinMinnesota,thehighestwageisforAsianworkersat$49,028or107percent,followedbyWhiteHispanicworkersat$34,042or74percent,andAmericanIndian/AlaskaNativeworkersat$31,171or68percent,andfinallyBlack/AfricanAmericanworkersat$30,116or66percentofthecostofbasicneeds.
Lowwageindustriesaveragebyrace
Anotherwaytoexaminedisparitiesistocomparetheaveragewageinthe10largestlow-wageindustriestothestatewideannualcostofbasicneedsforafamilyofthree($45,846),withaspecificfocusondifferencesbetweenracialandethnicgroups.ThisgivesusasenseofhowMinnesota’slowest-wageworkersarefaring.
TheaverageannualwageforWhiteNon-Hispanicworkersinthe10largestlow-wageindustriesofemploymentis$28,203or61percentofthecostofbasicneeds.Thelow-wageindustryaverageforallworkersofcolorcombinedis$21,112or46percentofthecostofbasicneeds.
BreakingoutspecificpopulationsamongminorityworkersinMinnesota,thelow-wageindustryaverageforAmericanIndian/AlaskanNativeworkersis$24,063or52percentofthecostofbasicneeds,for
![Page 23: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Asianworkersis$22,760or50percent,forWhiteHispanicworkersis$22,136or48percent,andforBlack/AfricanAmericanworkersis$19,454or42percentofthecostofbasicneeds.
ThedataalsoshowsthatWhiteNon-Hispanicworkersholdadisproportionatelyhighshareofjobsinveryhighwageindustries,whiletheoppositeistrueforworkersofcolor(whoholdadisproportionatelyhighshareofjobsinverylow-wageindustries).
Forexample,whiteworkersheld85.7percentofalljobsin2014but88.6percentofveryhighwagejobsandonly80.6percentofverylowwagejobs.Bycontrast,workersofcolorheld14.2percentofalljobsbutonly11.4percentofveryhighwagejobsand19.4percentofverylowwagejobs.
Manycommunitiesalreadyrecognizethesetrendsandareactivelyworkingtoimprovewageoutcomesforfamiliesofcolor,eitherwithinthemixofexistingoccupationsorbyhelpingworkersenterhigher-payingoccupations.
ImpactonConsumerExpenditures
TheCostofLivingStudyprovidesanestimateofthecostofbasicnecessaryexpenditures.Incomesbelowthecostoflivingmaylimitbasicconsumerexpendituresandsloweconomicgrowth.Iffamilieshavelittlebuyingpoweroutsideofcoveringtheirbasicneeds,theyareunabletocontributesubstantiallytoaregion’seconomy.
Inordertosustainconsumerexpendituresandgrowahealthyeconomy,regionssuchasNorthCentral,EastCentral,andCentralwherethemedianwageisbeloworequaltotheregionalcostofliving,andtheHeadwatersregionwherethemedianwageisslightlyabovetheregionalcostoflivingbutbelowthestatewideshare,mighttrytodiversifythelocaleconomicsinordertoattractnewandhigher-payingjobs,orimproveinfrastructuretoassistwithbusinessexpansionintheirareas.Ultimately,strategies
![Page 24: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
thatleadtoimprovedlocalwagesortheexpansionofhigher-payingjobswouldbetteralignbuyingpowerwiththeregionalcostofliving.
ImpactonDemandforSocialServiceSubsidies
Peoplewhodonotearnenoughtomeettheirfamily’sbasicneedsmaybemorelikelytoseekoutsocialservicesorothersubsidies.Inregionswherethereareagreaternumberofpeoplewhodon’tearnthecostofliving,regionaleconomiccentersmayhavedifficultyfindingenoughself-supportingjobopportunitiestomeettheneed.Thisinturncouldleadtomorefrequentre-entryoruseofsupportservices,creatingmorestrainonthesystem.
![Page 25: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Sources1.CostofLivingStudy.LaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment.Seemn.gov/deed/data/data-tools/col/.
2.AmericanCommunitySurvey.U.S.CensusBureau.DP-2,5-YearSeries,2014.
Seefactfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/index.xhtml.
3.CurrentEmploymentStatistics.TotalPrivateSector,2015.
Seeapps.deed.state.mn.us/lmi/ces/Results.aspx.
4.CurrentPopulationSurvey.U.S.CensusBureau.C3,LivingArrangementsofChildrenUnder18YearsandMaritalStatusofParents,byAge,Sex,Race,andHispanicOriginandSelectedCharacteristicsoftheChildforAllChildren,2015.Seewww.census.gov/hhes/families/data/cps2015.html.
5.OccupationalEmploymentStatistics.LaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment.FirstQuarter,2015.Seemn.gov/deed/data/data-tools/oes/.
6.JobVacancySurvey.LaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment.SecondQuarter,2015.Seemn.gov/deed/data/data-tools/job-vacancy/.
7.“Areskilledworkersscarce?EvidencefromemployersurveysinMinnesota.”HiringDifficultiesSurvey.LaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment.Seemn.gov/deed/images/SecondRoundReportSkillsGap.pdf.
8.“StuckinNeutral.”MinnesotaEconomicTrends,December2015.LaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopment.
Seemn.gov/deed/newscenter/publications/trends/december-2015/stuck-in-neutral.jsp.
StatutoryMandate
MinnesotaStatutes2013,chapter116J,section013,mandatesthatthecommissioneroftheDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopmentshallconductanannualcost-of-livingstudyinMinnesotaandreportthereonbyFebruary1ofeachyear.
Thestatutereads:
(a)Thecommissionershallconductanannualcost-of-livingstudyinMinnesota.Thestudyshallinclude:
(1)acalculationofthestatewidebasicneedscostofliving,adjustedforfamilysize;
(2)acalculationofthebasicneedscostofliving,adjustedforfamilysize,foreachcounty;
(3)ananalysisofstatewideandcountycost-of-livingdata,employmentdata,andjobvacancydata;and
(4)recommendationstoaidintheassessmentofemploymentandeconomicdevelopmentplanningneedsthroughoutthestate.
(b)Thecommissionershallreportonthecost-of-livingstudyandrecommendationsbyFebruary1ofeachyeartothegovernorandtothechairsofthestandingcommitteesofthehouseofrepresentativesandthesenatehavingjurisdictionoveremploymentandeconomicdevelopmentissues.
![Page 26: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Incompliancewith2013MinnesotaStatutesChapter3,Section195,twocopiesofthisreportalsowillbefiledwiththeLegislativeReferenceLibrary.
AppendixB
CostofLivingStudyDataSources
AgencyforHealthcareResearchandQuality,U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServicesAmericanAutomobileAssociationBureauofLaborStatistics,U.S.DepartmentofLaborCensusBureau,U.S.DepartmentofCommerceCenterforNutritionPolicyandPromotion,U.S.DepartmentofAgricultureFederalHighwayAdministration,U.S.DepartmentofTransportationLaborMarketInformation,MinnesotaDepartmentofEmploymentandEconomicDevelopmentMinnesotaOfficeoftheRevisorofStatutesChildCareAwareofMinnesota,SaintPaul,MinnesotaCouncilforCommunityandEconomicResearch,Arlington,VirginiaNationalBureauofEconomicResearch,Cambridge,MassachusettsU.S.DepartmentofHousingandUrbanDevelopment
AppendixC
MinnesotaEconomicDevelopmentRegions
Region1—Northwest,includesKittson,Marshall,Norman,Pennington,Polk,RedLake,andRoseauCounties.
Region2—Headwaters,includesBeltrami,Clearwater,Hubbard,LakeoftheWoods,andMahnomenCounties.
Region3—Northeast,includesAitkin,Carlton,Cook,Itasca,Koochiching,Lake,andSt.LouisCounties.
Region4—WestCentral,includesBecker,Clay,Douglas,Grant,OtterTail,Pope,Stevens,Traverse,andWilkinCounties.
Region5—NorthCentral,includesCass,CrowWing,Morrison,Todd,andWadenaCounties.
Region6W—UpperMinnesotaValley,includesBigStone,Chippewa,LacQuiParle,Swift,andYellowMedicineCounties.
Region6E—SouthwestCentral,includesKandiyohi,McLeod,Meeker,andRenvilleCounties.
Region7W—Central,includesBenton,Sherburne,Stearns,andWrightCounties.
Region7E—EastCentral,includesChisago,Isanti,Kanabec,MilleLacs,andPineCounties.
Region8—Southwest,includesCottonwood,Jackson,Lincoln,Lyon,Murray,Nobles,Pipestone,Redwood,andRockCounties.
![Page 27: Minnesota Cost of Living Study Annual Report 2016](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061607/629fbe1647468a4a31722e78/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
Region9—SouthCentral,includesBlueEarth,Brown,Faribault,LeSueur,Martin,Nicollet,Sibley,Waseca,andWatonwanCounties.
Region10—Southeast,includesDodge,Fillmore,Freeborn,Goodhue,Houston,Mower,Olmsted,Rice,Steele,Wabasha,andWinonaCounties.
Region11—TwinCitiesMetro,includesAnoka,Carver,Dakota,Hennepin,Ramsey,Scott,andWashingtonCounties.