n i) - agecon searchageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/144731/1/1989-04-16.pdf · a. n ~l:.of t ••...
TRANSCRIPT
\) In.\an4a.' Gy~f,tS, J", 'Sril\n ~ar.dakeli.. Vili~ .~
" ~n~;Paul .. R~ ·S~i~e~
I)
1,
,:t~ Tc:ng~. a l~'~e, Pttlp.Qrt$.on:. of tbepQp'Qlat.$.(m <iepend'on ta~ng, ~o~
tb$i;:l~v~ilJo<>d$:!t ~h$ t~ad$.;tiontt1 £.~ng 8Y8tQll\;,is'c~l~xi! Xl: ~$ ~a:,ed,
()n:e~ly~qper.ted, ~11'holtlin9a"t~ipallYQtabo\lt3.'Sh..C~Q'p
rot:a:tion8"r.~ 'l>.~ecton):l\lt.h ,,f!allowi».gto tna$ntaip: #Q!l ~et:tility cmd
typiQJl11'Y .incorpQJ;at. it wi~~, .~ang~¢f CU:QP#" WhE;l$eetop$ include long'''''
tttt'ltt c~oP:J,; "$\l¢b.aacQ<!Qntlt$fandoth$t't;~ee C~oP$t '~di.um'!'"t~~Qr~p$,· '$,*ch,
a:l' banan.~;llndpillPppl~$1 an(i ~l1Qtt .... t$=C~Op8t $uCb;,i$s root er.bpa. and,
vegeta})le$.. lnterQr.tlppi~g~seqt1ent:~~lC;:J:opping.ndmult:i -s,toreYQrQPpln~J:' .x:.allptac;~~Qa. '~b£~ ~yste;n, h!'!ls dev~l,cped to suit tlle. s@8*~teX\Qe .i:l~c;t,
(tl;a<;U.tionally- l~t~Q,) c'~hne~~of ,+,C)n9'.n~ral fcuniUe~~
'.rha otJjeQti v~s,ofth:tfJsocl$ty ~t:(I .c;bang-tng ~Ii_p.y w~y!J ..With :tbe:
inQri)aseii\ .r.~C::$ntl'earsofboth pOp\tl~tion"and.we.$tCirn, :i:n,flu.enc::~, ·thet~
;'$ an ~nc:r~:l\si.n9' n~ed ~Qt:fQQa anet c:ash.'t ~ba growth Qt, 'll,';m-~gric~~\tra,l
$eotors Q~ ~heeconQnw (1ar9".11 1;llell~d bY'l.~ an<irem!ttan.ce:flotf~)::mean:s t.hat t.he d¢mest;icma:rket ~Qt;l fOQd is ~owin9', ¢reat:i.ngnewopPQ~tml.ties.
fO~d01tilnf!!r¢i~l.. .;faxn,tprod\1ction, whi1e'ag:ri¢1.l),t\:iral exportsoQnt;i.n\te tQ
aecQunt(orth~majorit:~'ofthe ~Q1;t inc:otneof thecountXl"(Sefanaitl
*J;'apercpntril:)uted to tlte ·~3rd )nnutil. CPo i ... eretl¢eof tl1I!!!A\lsttal~an
Ag-r;icl1l.tl;u;al l!:¢On~c8 ~oeietYt I.dnc:ol.Il. College,:N8w ~eal.inld, ~E;lQrual;1,
1989~
'\\lO
+ J\nUlnda Gyle$ im4Br:tan liardakel:'; $outhPac:ifiQ S~llJlolder
itQjec;t, ttn!versity.ofN(!iWEt9'lancl; A~midale( :~$W .23$1, AJlst~~li.a.
>Vili~' .~, ~ten:slon. Pfficl.;r, Advisory l>;'vision, ,Mini~try' of
,A9'l:,ic:ul~u:r~/r.i.$h$l:~e$and Fo:rest~t 'PO l30x 1." Nu~u.(.~lofa, TOnga"
l?a"Q.l R.. $~~~~r,IJ.ai8on Off;i¢e:t",fOn9an""G9~n Rlantl'~o~ec~ionproj~ct ~(~T~)t~OSolt8S1"Nuku' alofa,'.rong~.
t98$). ,dhi~fJ.Y $ntbft fQ~ 'Q~,'C6praf: 'Q'"n!ll.&t bananas, ;:squa~h t~d .t.Qoe
,p~op4,.
!' ~cent;, dQvelopoeptet,f~rt;~h.v. ~nd£~ei;:~ecl ~u;~ancU,;ngs()me'Qf
)
;th.3.~~Sr a~dt.he~. h"ve.be. Btlfne Suc~.lSses.. llO ... ~.):, attC\!Jllpt.$'t;;o
l.11ten$,i'fr.stltl.¢Qlt~l:,'al· Pr(J~Qt::ton,b~veu~t ll"Haya ,.to 'W1tl1, t.h. ~r" of
:$ucCe'$$ ltp~d foJ!'.. 'NQr' J1~~·th •. ~arus!.,on o~ .~icOlt::ut~l,prQd.\)c:t.i<m.· t9~
tbEr d~8~iema,rke.t been. 'UPI to, dXpect-.ti;C)n$.,O.f·Pla.xm.,tlS ·~cl~l~eYIMl(erl!f.
j(Ql:e.Qve,; t 'tll~;Et ;i.89'rQ"lP.~q'Qncernabout;the 'po!;sil;)l;e .lon9~J! ~ti;11:t
~l~c.tlona 'of i~_ .,O.f t.he. Ch~n.9'$3 tlJa.~ &1:e, \lnder w,ay.tJ,ttbt1:le ;tncre8,s~
i.tlc.~ti ,t:;.oppip9h'~ q~ 9'reat~r 'u$~' 1)ich~9~la,t .such .a~ .. ~8.t~cid~$ 'and.
lM.nera:(, te:,tt~i~e~o. llIQ~e~eb1n(tc~1;!vA~;lon,. Qtten;nc.lutU.-ng; lane!
'Cl.~a~iug"'1th ~g~t.o, anri fl'Vent;\lAl l,os$offti:'~e$ on '(<<~, wl:U.l~.the
l"~h ·ot tbe ~~U:Q": i~J;:;toa, . ana the )p';-~dti<;ef,)fiAt~;Qt'qpl:l:tn~ .;r:tt.b:btb
d~c~as'~ng.~he$. is aI\,ut:~nt"~~~dtQ; Q1'.)t •. :1,.~ .tGQt:, ~ntQrwt.t:!'onal:)Qut .oJ
the$~cba:n.ge$'· .~d ,tf;) ~s'$e~#;the J,.~'aot$:th.y . ate . lik.,tll1t.o h.1lV:~ on the
t Gtt¥l tY'.n4 . ~Qn9"'t,.~ p~<>duQt.t~1ty o~tb.. l~nd,an<l·11~~ee9J;l,.t.l1. ~<tl:.~e
of"tll.~ ~Q~le'.
t>\lrln~.it xec~n.t .~t1.1dy .by tb~S()utllJ?aci;iQS~:\lbold.~ ~l:o~¢dt ($~2),.th._jQt: i:ot1,$t%21~nt':!t9)th.edev~lQ~i\t Q~~~lhQldeJ:~~l;lU1ng
$y.$t~, $.l'1·TQn~we;-.~ illv.$t~9atecllH.r,QakQr, .:ll$lfP;;Ct!.; Fl.n9'ancl
$.tanClia :l9SS). ~ht 'st.\tdY·:!J)lo,;ea th4t;; tJ:?,oX'e '1$ all.b~t~U'lt!.:l variat~Qn 1n
.t.~QbniQal ;.~t1ei~nc:y ~t"'een:fa~.t).¢~illage8/$u$.Jg~$t~t1g ;sco~ .. t'Ql;
tx:an~fe~ 'o~' tec;hno1Qgie$ ,fl::9mbettfill: fa~~$ t9 othe~fa~t:S,.. th~~t'Ud~:
a1$0. .' elQ.Pb~$;t$ed.t.he, ne~a.,· tQ):' JAOtEt p:t;o<l~Qtive..fa~ng t~cbn,ologiEu$"
e~peo:Lally tho$~ that, ,,1U±nQ::ease the. p~odu.ctivit:y of l,@Qu.~wbl,lf)$t;l.1i heingcapi.tal:!e~ono;ni$illg oj.
tt!ll$ ;.g()~le~~l~t~reQf ~11. fa=d.ng $Y'#$tEm). ;in Tong;a, ,tIle cl1AAg'$S,
,occu~r.ing 'tMt; a;r;~ .-nt!cmetial:>ove, anci tn. ;~equi7;ementfc . imprQveCl
t.~c~olo9i~s 'fQJ: $~11liol~r.8, uncifarll.Qtb,e ::need t'Qr ,ef'fec~~ve' al).cl
~.l~vaneagr;"Q'Ult.ural,t:e8ear<.:hlt Tnl.$ . ~y .~ f'Qssil;Jlethroggh ~21rming'
~~~1;~ t;e;,earoha,nclqterusion (~S~'Ja),.~b~r~~n understanding o£the tecbn.ie~l,.t· <tco.log3ee~.l, ~oc;i,.,l;.. al1Q fJ<;,onom:le:a.s~c:t~ Qfthe f~u:tn-hou$eholc!s
t8,U8.~dt'()· .~e).ppinp!llnt: prQble~and pO$.~ibl.e. $ol.u,tions(H~rdaker 1ge 8) "
tb,(#.F.s,~~app~~.Qh (vA~iously ,n~cl)' ~.s as: an essential .qClflponEint
" ~) \ 1\
'3
':;.: ~:',' . ,.'" '. 1? . ' .. ' - ! , .
i;btl, "x:::()~~t Q~t)n""~~ll:'. ttl.l~'.$ '.'._u<>f· ~Z'oYJ.n~ ·tbQ~t~$:,""tw"n ,t.~t.,_~v.ia~~~t~~c.~. 'an4;.!$'1jJ:C,lle;r$.. , 'rh. P.tl .. :o.~ tht. pi~; :~~
_ ,,,,:1:0' ," o:itli~~;. :t,b& "~~~.~ce~·ot .• ',' '#;IO.~tl1 ;.~n:-.bl.l.eh.d PJ.'~~_·Q~ "o~~lt~ d, • ,',~ '.' .\'.~, _1~" • " ,,'~r '.'t> :r,-- " ,J'" ,I' . " .' ' ':,~.,
,:.'~~~~~t-.J;, ~l_n·t.d; •• PUtoE 'an, ,.tt:~t,tQP.tQmot.t;b.~"SR.'$, '.PP;-o,"¢h :.in ' ~:.,-l';"::{,j • ' r'} " . ,,~ . " -, 1'0, \, - 'I'" . _ _ '
, iiot,t~ ;_4'part~alll' 'f~ ,an(1.e~tat.d. c~ thoS~U~ltltat;!tlQ~Ub~lg.:c . Jh:Ql,Ct. .. l-
th. 'ts~~ .pp~oaCb .b •• b_¢ :bQtl\ itsveb~nt;.dv<>b.t..:s~Q. ,tt~; QJiiti;¢f$ :(Cb.W'>.r.~) ~d.~11dy.l 1.9.84" ,lttit1~M :andEtt~$ t$'$$).n:ow..v~;r,
~cm Qttbt de~'t. h •• ~nc;,9n4~¢t~d~~t.tbeo~ett.c.ll$v$lt- ;qc;>o't.n bl' , l'y ,
l;liQ~. ,lfit!h ,:U.ttleol:. ;tlO" fS.~$t~banCt. Q~r!.nQ,e otttilng 'to .• pply, th~
mtt~gd$;' tJie ,~~.~ ~.~ thtlit()~~srin!$ ,.tnth~ ;~$:tl~~~n4eCt Irttetn~tlQri.l. ~." 1-
~t'lq~lf;~l aes4.~cb.e.lttl:.e., ,.ll.oth.:r$ "h4vel)een 1:_the~ ,~~ ... "r'l'0"$Q~ ." .'
tl1_.8.UQq~~8et$, 2Ul¢f~.llu,~~,o'i rSR'Jt:. ~g:~n~t'ai ,.n.4 'Qn.~~a~, t~~a.la ~Q pat:!:i.c;1Jlart .tn ~.',Q"u~c~"¢Qnst~a~eQ. ~.t.tQn.l ;.9l;'tc~ltllt~1 t#$earClt ;~l'~t
,'Gibb<:>~t 1985t, ,l~;r~:rr4.ngt.on ana~.~tin 198'1:'~6 .... 7,) .,~hi." '~ptI,~ i~ ~n,
.t~~t. to xemeQy' tbi# l~¢'k 'of~e~acl¢fc:lr.tfi~g ·Qntl'1e~xi$nQ. of tbe,
.A;,ly~t;t~t:$ top"t:. ... p.ro9'r~, ,Q~ 9n .... ta%tll) ':trl;al~:tnto ()~r..t!p{l"!.th "~
:q'.~ ll$it~tt'b\l4geti~~' v~,'tJ's.llnatiQJ)alp;ogt~,
t
~., }lUq!~t:;y df;agdc,ult\lJ:e,,'1s11.eri~1!J an4 :FQ;.st:l (~):ln~Qn9~
_ J.~ COl'1\J?riSeQ;,ot ~, ~wnb:e~ qfc1ivi$iQna '.nd ,~.¢,t;!Qn~, .. , 'nel!u~ j,noludeth. R.se.rCb,~vi~Q~~d\ ~ve~t¢eFI ,F!$.h.r~.,~And rQ;t~t~P,lv1:S~Qn:st .$ :well.~ _ ~1~g: unit csnd.WQ;nen'tl 'S~ct~Q#t :atrK)ng'oth.t"s. 11:\"l:ea~,
" twQ, ~¢$Q.l;'cb,$t.t4:.Qn~ (an!1_p~~ of4d.v1sQ~Ic#.stl;'iQt$,(,wb,i'Cb, have,
l:.etlntl.¥'~~ r"'4uqe~ !J\n~1::A,pA;r:I!, Qf a ~~st.;:~ct~~~n9' pl::09r~ ~lemente¢ ,*tthe ,~!nu.lt1~ o£3,ga9).
~tb0t19h tbGl;_l1a.$be~n ,~ Pt~~_o£ 'aut1oUltur.l; ~Q$,ear~l1 it1tQn~a
fQ~~n.Y:f~~f:St· '.lt1t~11bstant.l.l, 'f».~nditqx.on t~e Pl:~tc.,'{l\ ,;($,l.~if~ ,19QlH t
; the'Qtu.l ~nft~tt,$;Q~l1hgldcn::J' have ~ot 'bE;lE,ln g.reat~ ·-.rbe,tea~Qns f()~
. .
1 ~,v~~kQfthe$,22 1f~tJ, ft)#l.(ied ~nd"~f>PQrt~ .byt.beA\l$t;J;aliilD;
o.nt. to~ 'Xnetm.tioll.l~~ic~lt\1.ral Res.arc::n (~CIU)# Cil1.)be4r ...
!)
QQunt.~~.a·~trb.!' ,1Aol~~ tb., ~acttln'tth' ",;;.tll'k.age,;$ ~~.fe~t,_~t.$.n~
ttt. ~i,.rdty ~' .. ~ •• 'i:<:bl)1v~8~~n' ;.re(.;",.al· l$i'it.~9a~).... ,~8~,~~t . ~.· ... rQlt'l'I.a~nc~ty or*.nt.t~ .. nd~<itk ·h., l:;IQii,cQAcj~t~.t$tf .Qn
.~~ q~()ps$u(:h illS, l>an.iP·z..s)~.n!.\lA: '~Aa' COC()nut~j . t~ ~ .Jela1;ive .. n~l.c~Qt ·1o~~,\~~t;~ts .. ,Mo~"Qve~,. ·thfl,"O;k ha$ ~.n .. ·di~ct6d 't()'W.~da, ~. 't.chJU¢al. ,.$l>8ot •• ~d ~e;y l~t.tle' QQ~ide1;At;ionba~ ~b"~; .. '~~"fn.t()·:tb4 ,oei()1C()nOa,d,cei.~¢um$t-.n~QS o~ 'ta~;:$;(F~~C!lcn\Ulq,1;988~ .~$~~ o~th~ t~hn!C{Q.. .a.\lggU.t;eQ..t:o fa~t's1:.<N~re~ ~r,ab$t.nt:t.i ;Qb~g!,itl, ~~·>~rt1t~(l.$
,()ttJl._l1","~cal. lSubeistence, .(iU~·.J;:"'\i\f£th"dapt.t;1.<m.t;(r. ~~1t, tel.at1Vel~
¢~- product.ion t_~qq.:. .. 111Qrdt~ tQ.cbi~,", htgh' t~"~~1'
C~'~CU1tlfltb.~ ba:iJ»~n.~~~$UQc.#.~,d~f\t to v:exy il()w~.t • .s,ot
fa~.,,<;ftpta~¢~.nd.dUp,1;.~Qn (lr_ '.Ulllt 1988),'
:In '~flt;~~t 'ec>~t):ellgtll~n t.ll.' ,llo:nk4~~; .~tw"n the. ~ ·ha~.;,ch~.ng i'MVj;jQ,~ 1').$.v.l,$.OJl:!$ 'MQf.~~$,. ~ iMae,;,c~-~~8Q~ ·x.1.~~Qn .O:f~l,.Qel::
ti.9'it;.i'On.~s: creilt-a 1~ ~9EU)'ltM 1,.~.t;~i.teMv~ISQ~ 'Otf£C~2: . f.~Q.~ .t,~e: . .' \'l .' .
't~at1-a.~n ;~).~tJ?~Qt.cttgnt;c>jec~;tG~~J .o~¢up,i .• 4 :tbel'>O$it.1Qn~wi..th.a
'tQ~o!ftq.J: .~'~ttt4tr~ th' .~~e.t~hJ)~vi~.i;Qn .8QO~te~~j;t~, tbe~.
off,t,cel:S .• 1ntain • hi9hlelv-"lO~' ,c.()nt.etw1t.h ~h. ~~e'1;Qhllj,."lS.~:i,:()n.' ·j,nc;l
t-n~, ,,Adv1oory J)i",1si.o~ b,r .tten<U.J1~ wQl;k p~gg:;~ll~ _$t*n~$" _~ing ~l.r tlel~Y$.,1t~, tWU'd,~~ ·t~<;lmi¢al. t~.;n!Jlg'$e:!,~t)n$~hel'P1llrtwitb f'a;M1:,' -.t.i.tii~ .~ l>N'prodl.ieing ~.<U.O" and. v!<l$O 4oq~nt:.t';itonsc .a,.$11 us'
t.chJP;.e~ b\tllot;l:n$~ ;~be: ~aisQ.p;ott4;¢~,;. :pQs.itiOl1 h.~':~n Y~l.u~1;)l., .J.n
&.tx .. n,gtb~ni tll.l.l~s'bf>t.~en ~~sfiti!t:Qbet$f.dv~~o~ ,Qff~~e~#~ .~.nd. f.~~$; bOftV8J:,tbeJ;o;i$ tu~¢~ tp~ tw:t~.~"t;~n!c;.t*QP :betwe~n . t:.1l~~~' "
gr:QPp$(,$isi..~~ 198$): ..
ae~nt:,t.t; 1;he;~. h'~ been: inc~.$ln~.int,~e$t ,i.nt~e ··1'$~~·a\p9rQacb.to '
.• g~!q~.ltlp';al~v()l~n.t:" l1nde~ th~~appt'o~eh, tp~+sl',adV'1$QryQ~f1¢~~b
'an4teC1 •• rcb.~a~ok\t,.~Et;1l~U: . a~.a ~e~to 941-n.· ~tt.e~ lXA~r~t;.~niding Qf
th$"1tu .. tion;Q£tli.f.~,;f~11',t:be qon$t~aint~ 't,QgrQcJ~eeiQn,t.e~c:i,an4 ~A~ p.t'~ttlQ'" ()pportunitie.s. &vall,i>lell, 'l!4Et:$~ t.$~ a~. t.h~n .abletop1n
})oin:e i.".ntl>rQb:l;.~tbl\tf'aJ;Jll, '~~1.~e4: fa¢e :A1\<:1 C;:In :d£~ec,t
:.9'~l'QU,lt.u,~.,l.t,~ei.\#'ch toh~lp' \ov~;c;o~ 'th$'sEJ x~lSt;aint$.. ,An, .;lnIportant
, .~~Q~' !'$~$ J.ef' t:1) t~ o~t; .g~(mPIi:d.pp;,~c1;ieet$in fa~l:$' .fleldb: b~~Qr~
.fQ..u. .. t:$.nf·.t~$c>nl:~~n<1*t';OM(MUt:litM 19.501,1'; On"~.r1\l 'tJ'.l.l'a~~
~~to 1:.,st t.cWq:u.a j\l~. t.oofter l$olutlQl1$ ~Q '.~:r:s'p~Qbl""
~ •. 89l.ct$4 t.(:~qu.3:~,1tu,v.9n~X'9'Qn_ftl(t.nslve '~v.l()~nt·\.nd: t.'t.~n, ,on_.:r: ••• ~;:Cb.f.~I. ;q:rJ\the1'.~$_!Y '~\ ~'t~a:.toptit.m3 ;Q~Q$'~
QP·tlle, b.:d"o:feX1I$Uilc~kn()""~, ~~. be~t'tiC11'\k-.l¥tQ .~~u~c.$.f~l..'th ..
!.q.. ~$ ,l';*?~4, ~ptJlt;p,rQC.$$ •. $ <~f1;.¢bnQl..oglt &$t'e.l.~pi*nb ~4 l1ptake '.1>1
._t.:~l;.t,b!n9' eaJ:ly in ,'the d4v.l.~t ,.ta~.wl1ethe:r;i.t !a. li1tel~ t.t"> btl '.uQ~.~$~1d~r th. :co.nQit;i;()n·$ f..~~sf.~;~¢$o.wt1et)i_r.t:~y,,~ll., l:>tl
l~k.il" ,t;O.40!t ~t. %h.,a.t.tl.1. pl;ov1<le '. key llAk~t.~ .. n ~l:. of
t.~ J'S~J t~., ':.:U.QW~~g t~.o~ :b<)t}1w'-Y4: .~ ;f"~J:' t •• ;not ~tt.J:
_t~fJ;o.. tll.;.$~ax:eb..an.cl:ut~n,"(!n peX",()~"lby ~~l:n~ out n.,. ic;lt!Js j.~th.t~ ;Qltn, .~i*.1(l$.Q~ 1':.1$e81ng ~b~ $.JlttcmuP~1n th. t~eld1$,oftb.it' ~i.g.bbQ~~r t!tXt.~onQ!fJ.¢t;l;' .l •• ¢ _~r__~u.t (faJ:MJ:s', (!ncl;l1~ng', 1QI)~
@Q\lt,.uc<;:e1UJftU, inCli<;r.:oQ()tts t,cb.no).Qgi")Jn<l.a~t;Lttb,.; 1f9;l(Q£ t'b"l~
cQlle'~_$ J.:,i't~ ••• "t:h, an,¢ ~,eU9b,r$,·1.al..~ .mo~. lDop,t ,the. ~.al£t)" "dQW'n
<>#,t~t.x.' .sot~t, ilQtoQl,.y j,#t.h.4ev.l()~~Qf th._s>et,c.itic'
t;~()l.Q91}t.Pt 01\ t~ac~.. but .• 1$0 tll~y, Q~.l'l~tht~gb ,f.~~ ·cont_eta·
"b.t t~~ •• lpt~l:>l..a~ •• lJ.d.Q·vh.t ~.a •• t~. ·p,t'ic;n:;1t~"Q\1gl1ttQ :1;)0
(ta ~.n\Ul~,lllal) ill
X~May '1;9$8 th.; 'SP~:.$sli$tfnl,in·th. ,<:c::m~u.~t, of '~. 'YQ.t:l¢*,boPQrl
.,.,.~~ iSyat...s l:\t".r~. and kteJ):,iQn,f, in '1'ong....J;.n.iOAQff$,o.X'$,
~a •• ;eft .. ~. a#d ·pl.MA .. r4' ~r~ tn • .IIA1't .tt.~$dt.8 • .,l1 .a.8t .• tt £~Qltl otbtt~ .~~icUlt~~al., <)r;l . .ni~n\t1o):u~ .~h.\ ~ .. Qf 'tl1e :WQ~kebop •.• $' ~o'
introdttc.t;ll.' i4e.. ()! ;FllUl :;aQd,:·to •• t~11~hb.o.th;.Q,QI1¢ept-CQt;Ll4. :~;
lJ1QQ~t.,t«4 'i.ntQ! t:lJ.ewQt:k o~ t~~r,. .l\n«Utp41',\$l:on 'of t.,.. U1~~~~9: tathl\u:lWt~ fl:'o9'l':.,.Qf" Qn~f.~· t:r!$, .• l$.w.~ ..... n ·asaf.u-:st .. ~t.~p '~Q ad,ll.v~g tbi$~;
tnlr.b.ve ~,n"~9f on""':t.~~ .tz;.ia~·s: .run in 'tQt1ga in ·;.Of.mt
'y .. r:a an<1;: ·0 ,i4. ~CXI~nly ~CQ\,1tlt.rQ.<11A·Q~h.~CQMt~it#1 181=9.
d.ift.~~c; •• havabe_ Qbae;ve4 ",it.fan yiel(lS in tr1a.1.$ ~,~, :.~r$';f';~l~
.4tldl,1e:ld# :Qt: $~llu;:t:,~.a~t.~ .t~plic.t.a,Ql"t~.~eae.'J:(:b f,,~·..($av~!io.
, 1941,. :S~1:ler1$88l: .. ; ,~$ 1«,btca,,;~,,():f' 1;h& la~9. ~.ri.ti()n itl
, :_v1~q,mwn~l f.act;.or*anc::t magagoment ·P%'4.Q·t,jp.$t·a;~ ,,, •• 11 ,a~ ,l,,,l)Q\1X', ~nc;,\
~plt'l .1;' •• tr$.QUOM !QI;\ .'.rons~ t.~, ¢~,;o,d ~q; :«;h. r.l,.1;~v$ly
:~otJ~rQl1.aenvll;on1l'tent .pnth., r.$,.tC:!i. f'_~.'th •. ·f»C;$~ .• nQe ot such largtl
. :\
etc c
c<.Slil..tMO •• '1111bli4ht •. t~~!;fO~'~n~~ .... t~!;JltJtQ; ~t$!'t ctMcQc_\\l ••
d;:~,~ol~~ ~ .~~'f~C\lq~t.~~t _qtt,~ ~~!l~c1Q#~4; t~q.~ ',,~~i., .. t:.~~~aat;tQ~',. t~, !'=-l:.~ . 11" '-c l
. 7~';··~.~~~.~~~··~li~~~~,,~~~~~~~:~~~'~:,:,-.... ,""~;;"~ cW1, lt9t::;tt'hQP '~ .tl ,Qt1,.~~.ttIl; ,~;J;Il.c .(),f!~~,~ '.0: ·.ppQ,t.Qtt,d. to ttuJ J4tJ.tO:;Y ,
~, .' ,. "'",' ," , ~ '" . ,_ t,.", - ' ,,- " ' ." . h
:J)~"*'.ioo..of' ~~,'b. J\Ul.1~aQ·t;Q. ~.m .... ng;qQ·QJ;'(U~};.t"P~dg't .. ~ . . !'b!tJr, .~tfl~=.'_Q~k4¢iob.~wlt.h: ,t~. ,:i4_$.8~~ ;S.Qt1.~Q9t .,_ •• ,~)':c:m
bl.~ttmf,. t~. ~l:~'A9: ,.Ct!9~:~~.9~'~~~Q~.lf~ ~;,$"~" ~"ttj)f'~t~l}.~.:~:e.ot;l:i . a;n.ib~~1& ~p1 •• ~.'h~l~ ',.tcl ••• t. Qn:~.: .« ~ .. ~
c'~o.:;tJ1:l<=~ p~", cqf ~cc:~1:l..i~;(":~~4!' :to,~ filt~r. ()J\"~'~ :t:r:l.1.,,"jitl~ t;;l1* ~.O~~~~.. ~~t •. ~.i:t:.· .k._tt~ t4 i'tM: 't~l.ll.Id..Yi~¢ •• c~(t.
'\ , , • "., :,' , ' , ;' <, • ,t~ '" ' . .' . " , , ' , o.J.·t~ .• ~. ~JiOf\~iJ,~ xlQt;~t.t!Qn~_· 1JQ1~r\ 1988'. tot.~ C>~ la t7;1 .. ~4:
l.n tlI- ~Oft .. qq '~~;r: w-J: . ot" :Q~i.tfJttl!.l'-et-.tl. ·Qft'u~. '1;~'"': ".~ ~~vtit .. .$# ,t" ~i.'14b,,~J\~ t()~ tl14~. '1;):.1.1., .Q'~.:: h. •• 'COM '.tJ;(ft,
'~"f.tQt1. ~~\l~.1l,.1nQt.t;Qt~~~t :~e:tl\It(1l1_;f$R~)',n4#A.· ~Q#9"n·~.~.
tX~l,\t. '!:Qt..ctiQ;tl'f:~,e:ct .(~;)'.i
kt_$l~' ~d~.a,.~cb. Q~fl~.~8'; •• ~Qou:r.~~~·.-t.Q;t.'l~.· to. f.~tll.tQ. ,.tt~ll: S;du. ~~J:'. ,~n~t.Qt t:ttg#, ·~tl.· • .t*tlltn r~~+~~ to. :o~t . t.'.;o~'~$·tQ' (t.hftt·~~~f.~. ~ri.l#· 'offi,t~~ w1l4 o:si~n~·~ •• ,~~<U~~, Ibd;~,~qn,
~.a.u~r:~i ,t .. tt· ~ncl~.~~' 'w();k:a, ia; .tt •. to ~';t~.t«;l~j)it4~tb.· .
t~;tll"". . '.*.~#f' ·.,1\0) .~.r "l.Qt~by .xt.nlioA:Qf~1<;.r.·t:c> ;~.;t~l~.l ,on ,. t;:~.~~ lQCi1
t .•. ~t.l$U*l~:r41'·.~~,l'laM~ng tQ (~lgt, th_: 'Qt:Q" 'Q:a:~.".~,. tb" .• ~l..tll.t; .• t;. ~it..at~ ·Mci,.~'t IbQ., ~thQ.d._ iQ~ :~tl9 th •.
t~,t~~' tJl.~~,~~ iJl~~U.ll~ ~t.~, ,fe~li •• ;,,".tiq~c:it. .n¢t. C,/t, '
otlW~*IPP,t$'.;.i $\1pp.l!t« lqJ; ~~' fa.~,t,.l1~l. ,ho~QZ: "biSttQvl4e, :l..~~ll~~ '~Jje. ,Q:~t.~t) 'i~ t,tdM<l by, th4t :f,~~ " •• .,,~:ll" ~.Q~:l..,J1)1'la19n.· _t:. 'pl.c.d: Q1.t~.1~tl':~.~~~t'4 t~ info~~pl.,of th~;p~ •• ~i,.~;: ·'!~tJ,tlt.c~.o;~"Q$: •. ed: ~ ·tb. '~Qt;.~ f:atl;"q;y Q~t!q." 'o;tb"Qn"'~.m: ·tr~.l$
Qtt1Q't~ :~.:;~,. ",~~olU!.l;lllvol1te4 *,;: •• ,.cotP:.geq ,to· '~c;:qidtb.
O;W¢n4 '~bO~t::. tl)e· 't.eclUlC:4«t1.~, "1n9 t"t~ Qt lXlt.ll t;~ 't'.tJiIr; llpon .\!Iho,s_ ,c, . c .:) " •
·l.lt4l1;~, t1t.i.~ ,,*.:t;C~' =\.m . .n4·'Qt .'viat~:\.ngt.~z;ol!' 'Xtb.~ '1;>t~ , , ' , ~ , --;
1~,~4tt4 t)1a,t ,.$~ .t~_ '1?Jtti.;clp.ting~.t_i;a' 't;i.-.nt:l"enct. b.:l9.bttou;~ ;.Y' ,~,. ·~ttfl~ ~.~, Qf~t.ting; tb$aotu:l:, op~n!'Q))" t>l th.~.~~.whf>ta41
~l..\. 'cmlll'·~ .. ltl_,.,p4t¢t8Q~th. ·~d.~,tQ l!'e4eaJ;c;b; .nd .xtGn,$lon ";.~$t 1:Nt'"b,Q '." ~,"~.t :tc>rtb,r:i9h.t., :wltb ,oth,;".
~ I "
(l,
.• Aw¢tk,1l9P ''''. h.1(\ in )JQv __ r 19,$$ 1:.<;)' :Qv:tl,\l.t. 1::" • .e~Q9~.a$ o~ tb.
Qn~~.~tt$.~~: l';og;q to~t.. :Q~ttnq.,tl1,* .qr~$b<>p.,4e.pr$.pt~on.ot '.a.qh
tr~.l,_ ... * ~(.a.nt~1t4 'by tl)..:' '·~~l •.. Qr,y Q~i*Qlr!1: In.()lv~~ ,u,lng ;rld.o i~.nd: . '\ . . . '
$~ido" Q~tb. :t~'.l. to ~~. '.'¢!Jpr.oen.tltt;!Qn. !fhe t;ri.l' ••• ~ • .'/
4i$¢U$~ .• nQ; ~.Y.lut.e4, 'bJ'" '.'1,.. g~\J;p :Qf _d.v!eo~ .ti4 ~ •• "J:Qb o~!.t:9;,r$ -t::t.n<;Ung 'tfl •• QrlcoJtop", (p.tl1,P •.. ~b 'wo~d )1.,. bt.nbe,~t.~ ~~.oM, t~~bf.,4 .l~() .~·pJ;.$_~t;,b~~the WQt'ksbop : •• $:t#t.n~p~~:r:;t~¥' ~$ ,
ll' le"tAng ~t.ienQO; fo~ ~·~;T:'Qnn.l~A4, thl$',Ql;ljtQl;$.V., ·;mi~t.h.VQ .
~n' c;oq»;~IS~,Qy. 't;h,., :pt.3'nQ.lQ~f.~t'{$ .•. ), a' br:l.f41~Q~.!5iQn,of ench,
ta~~.l ~,;, p~.I$,.llt~ :. .... "ow''"
(~O X~j"eb po«t<>:v.~~.l:y: t:=1:.1.·~h~$ t;ia.l, •• ~, tn In '.; •• vb_;. po~.t~. ,b.fll'lQt~nq,~Q,,~btf~~..lt ".s,'.Q.QQ-a.sf\i.'l. nO.t Qnl.~ j." ~ •• tin'l
tb,,-,. ',",;i.t" •• ; .~~ t..~r:'QQ1ld1t19~~t l>ut: w.-"i~ ~n.t~.t;:fon ,flQt
fq):PQt .• t~4' wbl~~.:., 'nQ~ W$.de~f :cp:QWP;:r,laoptt. .n.xp.n<Un~, ~l:)Q.l
"tljt"tb.tt"~al;.hO'l~t,b.t.y.~b~~h y;.~~, ,t;' .• cb.t.~ll>.l.: ;1.11 .~.~t.:t
f~.l~" ~~l,~l.~l~ y;Ltb:~l.;: ad;l1,{.r;. :!~9l\ Q ••• tQ1\~~;,b.i'o~ , Qt~1<l.~.:..ao.eve~tt\\¢l\.~'t~.\f;13' a~. ,tl~4 tOQ~t.$.:n =-~~Iiit. ~i;~, wh*¢b
i~
,Ib); $w .•• t: -po.titt<t ~~ult:1v'~ t);;'al" t~J t=tll. ~t$. r.~Qlt. of..~ bt..,t1,'~'V •. ".l.~Q(l TJ;Q.9'~~'QJt ~th •. ;tttJ •• ~cllf.~",()n.;tt;.t;.l ,.. •• '
'#~C.Q!~tt.~l1lt. $.Q -(I"n')lltr.tJ,n~ til'$.'il~w Qult,i.v.1;~ tot' .. ,~~., •. ltbough tb$'
,t~i.l.h"not;y~ ~J)i b'tv •• t:~ .. ' "l'btQtb.~ ,t;;i.l ".$,. ~.~n~tc.~.~ult Qfp.oo~ f.~# ~.l.c~;J..on ..*tl;thei; on~t.~ 't;:t.tal$. ~.V' •• b8.n plant04 'on ~tMt. f_.¥:M~4,f :ield8t.q t_.t ~\1,"b~~ :tll.oe .c;Ult~v.i;$U.na.t ay~u:,i;,t:;l"Qf:
. ,(1on41i:lllns,.;.·
'CQ)$;Qi~.rtl;';tu,,~he.xpf:Ui:;.,nca .J:lO, ~til$~lt~ 'ot tb,i,~t;rial •• t~
'u~t" •• t.,Q~ to' 'otM$:t.=--;~. 1:boto 1f.~nQ ~~vol.v.~t Qt r.ee.;¢h at~f.1! ,:iWl~'" '.; ;J:tUJg1t,t~. ,.$atgn; '.n~aPlPl;i;n~· _tbod:s~.:« in~u:l~q;u.t..~b •. QOIt 9! tb,I~1:t.l w •• blgh :.A~l. th:~~n.flt. tQ'Qth.l; proW¢EWta:,,_ .. lQWli
S) 7:ll~~i~A; tAt. ~.t' ,,,.lu.c>t th., ~.~lt~,,"a": :J:.(l~¢ed ~¢.~~H9l. th. 0'
, ;~~.o.t '~",t.i.<m (~ ,lJ)",~,~*¢n1Ql¢"f1 ._th.eJ(;a\1Sfl(l .~oc::.1·bX'Ql.l'~
"p;:Qduc;ti<>n, :.l.~ Wqng.tQ ¢_.'.'",
(4) .~~'~ov.J:; Q~9Pt~ia1·~ tb,tx. ';i,~ 1,1ttl., ~*""xe1.1 ~~ .. , ,.," .' . ", '. '. ,". -'/ (
»~Odu~t;.to'A ·1~'f/&"'. ~.\t .11e..r:;.,tbet;~~1·1ta:. ·PQPd'Q;ct.ed,$Q tbi.t~iG ... an.), f) , . \ c
ppg.o:t~ •. p~l_ (;~¥ f.c;e(l.. ~~ (.~J; •. intb •• ~...aQlf.V.t". t:ll~\\\ ". ,. . \
't.tQh#l~;c;:o.Ul.4 ~"ppll6d. 'i;c> Qtb.tjt •• $o:tQng.~ 'the :tj$Ult$: .l\owtcl J
tla, t..~Ml~.t:() :_ t.QMl.Qall;Yl_Jld ..• c(m,~c~:J;l1'.$\j.¢Q.·$'~l4".tthQ~ih.
!tu¢A.J: ,. __ rii:t1qr. ;lJtotb.t' :t.~:;,..~.t.eld:$:'a. :nquiZ'~tQ<:;Qnt!=.,~hi#'
tin<;u;~... Wh. 'tt1al""$ ~oll.,it\.n.;.1\ ·lfber:;etb .. 1~;q#e4 •.•. & cov.~
<:;'09 i'iQtut.l.l.)'Qcc-qJ;t.i.ng,,"b~Qb .. ~$' ;~Qt; ~; :c~n $~t.\l.t~Q:J) in. Qthel:i
loq.tloti~., 'o~'b4J\aQ pr.<Xblc;t1on.
(f,J)' a.n4D-. J) .. tQC~~ t.t:.t"1~,ilU.4 va$- ·.lnlY. .X •••• ~Mt
4e • .t9'lJ<l.~~ ~l~t~t~j;.l. ~M~ was' littl., ~.PJI8J'o~.c;l'd.tlQl:t
<>ttt<:.~ 4.nV:91v..-.nt.". :.~thou9h: tl1~·"n.'M- S.x:v~<=,~ Sect;!,ond14 tAk.paa;t:.J.,n
tb..tJ:l.llh"tb.~:$,p1t'Q~tb4ql\·~.~1;tj .• l,.~cc; •• ~fully c:;~l~t;~
COAt.l~ r.aUlttlof tbQ~. l:Uil.ptav,lo1,1alt .Qn. t::b.·;t ••• rq~f.=.. .-t~. l.~
tl~~ .Q,t,tl:~.I~~4I;lAfKl ·~C:4V..'Qtt.h.~;~1_oftb., "Ul\c;bl''tQP'V.i.~
·.~~.t,,· .~::fo~ lll¢to~us.e4;;e.$"l,:cb. Q%l cQ!1,t.rol ofa\ID¢by. ''1»~. v;1:'r\1$:,
9'b'd.Qq$~1 ..• *a~ '-=>~. ~¢AAt p,to'Pl_ than. AM4t~~h.
(tlV.t;.~l;. .itlttrQ;9ppitl$J't;lal. fo# inaect'i.QQAt)';ol.l'btl
$.,l'Q~;LQn, oft:hi~ tr;1.li.squ'$tlQJl.bl;.tQrn'1tla~in9' tb.t _ ~~l'~ 1;t;1.1
pl.nteQ, "It th." %.'~rcb f_= :,t·th. D." t.~.:of. ¥ •• ~ .,~oV,d,u~5\1ec."$t\\l.
MohQWtt .~~ tbe.on"'#1:.t1<>n tl:~ll.,:th.l;'O;~".$ nQ·oi9Jlific;:.ntetfect;o.e
i~t;.;Q~qWiJl9' 9n:$.Q.ll$ ;·"'~th, <;-.bb_g'$$, ·4Xi. th~ in,fe=st",tion .ttbtU~ncll>aQk~d
_1'4 '~ •• jQJ:'et:$t;.. 1M ~<;n:;;\\~.~YQt data col..l*!JQ;i.Q.t).".$ .10w; ·1t a~ch. tl'~.l $.., tQl)e, ;.~at.ed ,it ~ho\U4~,d.c)l\ •. Q~.~;tl • .t: ,ell. ·to .voJ.4b~~t
lQ~n~.~ tit t.~,ot :ir~~t'~.hd :ti.· and;. e£f<>n.of t.h()~u,in"ol.e4.
tg) Xnt.l;c~~l,~ '9£ t>e.n~ 4llQ If.t.~l.on. NQ ~ ••• a);ebQf~:tc~l;5
irfte: inYol.v~ lntb1.$. :tr.i.att" '.n~., tll'~, ~.z;.40ft~~e",¢1.~in: t:d .• l~~19n
:Illd-· l.~O,u,.t.. /.tb:t: 'Cl:·QP·. 'W4la. ~f(.ct.cl ·br~'~~'.lla ~t:Je •. #s.; :po~s.;i.b.lyclu. to
th. '(Jf~;: \1~1ng too; ·l.QM.O.ltQen:ti;at1on Qttbteb_c"l" h •• '.lJp;r:Qvl.d .. cl;
v1tb. Xt. ~$:$~~p$Qt.d; t"t ;tb.ta~.t 'UI$-.d.s4_of tb.' ·~.:'tllie.~.nd
, , ' ' "P~.P'$~ • .i;.d114 4tl~$; ,~<:~op ()~ •• ,t.~lQQ$1! :~d.~b __ ~~.~f.c;t<:m
Ii ~~t144Qt"iM t~~_l pl.~ •• , 'htt."~on .... t~,~, t~!.).t,$tWith .~QV.a\ ~to.nl~f.~ '~):~. ;"t'Qt9,anY ~,j.~l. ~~~~4Att~~ to~ ~~1~g;'
. . -;"~:::,.:-,., '
itll4iJ.,.cto,pf .•• :.l~t.tQ#9p1 ~. '~i_~ t(1f..~~t$!i
'(bl w.t._lOtlt.ti;$.li$~tt!.l\ .th OJ;~g$.,~l_b\, 'ot Ut, t;1.);
~ •• :tot; •• t .:b~,n _lP.\'~".,o 1.;t;il'e~t',...h,i,.¢l1 ,J.. ,~p;.ct.l.q. c;)t,,~
,1~iJ;Wl!o;~ , a~V'~ttNi' 'O~l9'i~.l >>If.n ••• i~M~~d~.t~ 'Ii: Q\ltP~.1t Q~ t.~Q:1,d: ,~,u,,~~t4, :.;!.k,Qtt.ftc;t;iQAt ~d.POJ.A:t;Q'~,~;. ",.'U$5
l~ •• d:"" ~h.~.v .•• 111:;"* ~.~ ... ~hin,,01''''11l·;, in tJ)e.t.t,t.l :*.\l~ •. , tlle: 11
#Jg!l ·.~ .. n~a~ ••• i()~ i.-v.. A1t,bq~ht~~ '~rl.l, w~anQt b~~.1;.4;, tit, the ·t~ ot~.PO~ilft ~t .~~. tb.~ ·Qne· t~.~t ,..$, .tt.¢t~ ,'~ • .b .. d1~1.'<1\ fu~x' ,t\~;i;l1'.;.: '\1~. ~t9;. t:~11~. ~,Q~pdat,tqn.'~.n ."., _~ta
,:r'J:M1:$ ..
(t) ·v'RUl.al1}t'.~~~lng, fl1o·o.·plQ;.$ .• ;.' ~1; •• ~~n ttl
~n.f;J:.t1;Qg, .J)~ot. 'tbu,: 'oA"'1:.~t~'\.l.;. t(¢~t;iq~1ng Qt tb.apl<tt.a ,~ tq
~. ;i~z:~.o t:bf.t;· ,~.o,t ii.telSt. :!l)¢._ _n<1 ,Qtb.Jr: UIp();t,nt,.:f.Q·te>J:!.e. .~,
J,::.C.OX;~"
,j
~~. :t,; ~Q~~, £Ql: _lU~g; ,t~t.u~$i()Q.""f.~ tJ:i.1JlltaQJ:. ~.l_v~t ,to,
.~~J;' ll~.. ,~prQPQ~.l$; f'Qt't~~.l$c~ (lip¢tl1/ .~.~~ *.~ta",
.ttbo~b 'tM;·Pl:Q~~.t~ ~~~ .~i'Qt¥ Q~~.;Q • .t;$tn.9M q....:r.t:l..o;fC$'tb.i
i'a.~'Qf f':;-'~$'lI lloJt., *n"*'~t ¢~tl ••• : waif th.);.;.Pt.t;t~t. tQ$ptlQlf,
fQ$~''Y.,t.;gotg~Q'q:Po~:!.XMrs.(Qr '~te¢Q .. no.t~Qn d~i.n~ )t;Q"hQm
'$~.I~t._r. '~Qt~tq, ~ :4ppl} c~l... ~ncr'''$.a .t.1;~t:~on nee~tQ
ibt; ~lun to ·tlW·'.~RtlQn q~tQP3;e8' to~ Qa-tatm 1;.;i_1.($, 1nQ,l;~<lt~~ .,,~.
tl\~~l1t; t.o .llQc.tS.""9:~tiQl:'~ti.A.tO' t.nt. i~", .... ~: btQ)lg:ht. fo~w.~d~$J:Q.t~t ,p«;1:.ic.~~tiQn of f'.~.;.~ ,1tl 't~ ·,tden1;.;,t1c.tlon 9t:p~1~,.il1 ~tjlp' .c:U.~!lCt Q_ ... ~lt ,t.o •• ~ ~_ ~$t.llfl>Qt:t'l')t: ,i.S$u •• ,t.QcKlblf.~ :~lt.;l •
. ~' ;,el..et.ion ~~~.tMr"p.~Q"d :l~rt~nt,· ebt>wini ~h.t:p~J.Qrj;.t~
.~~d ,. :giv*t\., tcrt.~t'.;who. j,rfJ pl«ooJ:.ng tQqX:QW tlt.Cr~P :Q~tbe:t~'
of l;y,,#to¢t m.,£ng "tx..tntG.e.tll_Y n •• d, .t;Q. ·Oft.' g:f.muin.ly int'..test~d.i.~
~.~t4,tJf ,t~t.cAn.oionan4, tC>11Q"1~stt;be,;t~S;.~ ~!u:o""~b. 'At tl\. a~ t1., t.hw ~to \~, .t*".c:m&b,f,y '"~l!.$.nt.tiv.fQ{Qtl1,~r ;f.~r", 1n~b.~):.~._
e,l
t(rp~"'!da:.v.l~4 1;".~"'~ ~9~ t;.h. ,p;o~#.d t.C~bl..09Y.xn.n~l.' Qf
1;,;£11_«: ;qi..oo. ~r,l~'M ~~.,t~v..Q,~:th •• tW'~' :.ataEf' : •• l:'.~.l.ct..~ .$,~be
~~Q~~~~~" t._~,,'ncl.t 1 ••• ,tQ~.,~l:.i'1...p.l;;J..a 'Q~t.,Qll tb.lan4 ih~th. af.W;t$o~qf~lQ.r 1);\vol,ved,1t $.~¢ll. peQ~l •• l$:-l#ll~k.l.f' to '~, '~.~;.j~t, .. t:l;~."of,t. POP~"~i,.(.)J\ Q( t.~r.\ ,~d, .~Qb.J;>.i.a,ln :'J;Ml: ,.ltat~~r1 .bQ~lclbft.vQi&t4~
~"IIQ~t ~u,PQ.a~(~ t:r:.i.alage~t.Uy i""vol..-t4 ·,~'Qqll.bOr.t.tQ~ ~~~ •• l.o~.~dh$ •• ,r:Ch "QQMtl". .,heJ:e 1ll .4ef1n.tt.~d tQ,
JJap;ov.tb..~nVQJv~t of ,t ..... rc;h ;at$ff',to, ·uti);!; •• ,pr.vJ.out on~'-t .. tton td;a.l~r1..Jlc.a, •••• l:lot~,;' ~qUrc.~jQf knQ.l~,.",,¢b...9V.l;~.'lJ,
W(U:f¢,qt • $~;t.if '».tlJJ:e, ,~Q •. l:Cb.J; ~npij.t. al:'. ,al,OQ ~:t..nt. t(>4Nl,ur.
tll.t t~$.al, ~$i9l\ ;is; a~.t,f,t;tQl: tht ill.tett.~putpO.C. ~I't :f.X'lQ/lJr ...... n .. g'ed
1;~;i41.._bl..~h'~.#tQ~\ehpi;l~~pott.~ a,bqvt ",.~, ,QOlIpl4P~~~nt.l
~~.t9Jl.a~.cl~.~lY ~~.ep.l:'~pJ;i.t«..Ont;b.o1;h_J;ll.nd, AI'" attent;i.QJl to
;)..~out 'Qt tb. t~.i.u~y t.lp t.Q ~:,hdJDi$. po.~.tl,ll. bi •• ,..o'b •• tve4 ,4.#th.
~.t'~9n(.xt~;U,.Q.rtt;i,~ij
D~.~t.ctiv.ene4a:qt' tn. ,Qn"'f_~t!~4.al# yS4~l.l.Q' b41i~.rQ~ dc;;~~~~@lY' ~:ft1.i~, .t. :lxu:o~r~t.¢ 1ntootll~WOl:~,ot1;ba Vf.;;'O\lS
.#~Qt;;t?Xl# Q~ .tb&~' ~,Q' c¢mJ?1~J;ltotb.~·prQg';aul,.aPtQl.l1YQ~th.
~:se.~¢b. :n~V,!!;aiQjl.., 1ht$ i~ ,'r\qt to' 4-'';itlult tb.,.J..qt;iQn Q( t;-t,l;$ :~bo\lld
~,~t.~n .. 4 .bf t.b. AA£,t,ing ,{J.;lc;u::$.;,t.t.fl1Joftb. ,Raa •• ~Qb.l)~v~aion,· ".i.n¢~
:anObjec;1;iQ, Qt thtlu.!eof Qn"'f.~t,J;!'l:J ".tth1~an J'$R~a .Pl?~o'Ql'"i~ :tQ:
In'tl,~.n.<;:,. ~t ,wh.~" l\eo"~$.t.r,t.~l:.qt:; tbj.,$ .O;:kt<>~1;obl__ofmoa,t
l:8iXu:tanC.. ,(mtbe oltb(!u~ li~U'1dt tlf.l"~$ ,on,~ta~,1;'~J. .. l top3.<:;, a~.$ol'Qte¢
.;l.th QlQ8..:.~t.nt::.iQn' itQ,tbetl~~ Qfthe:_jo~it~ otf.~J:., 'the'~,~ogl:aJU
.dt\J.ll~ .dppt~_tt.lid. to,b$..~ tll •• ork,'ot' ,th.,I\fa$~.rch t>J.v1:,.iQA ~w.y
1~"bat i.:$; ~ •• ll3f ~Q;t;~t,.
~b. ;~.k Qf',f.il~re( :in Qn--f_= tl';laJ;s is 3.en,~V) h1gh ,QY"aQM,
ua~.lly, ,;".A~h.1:.'" 1.l1;l(l:,41!. 119tect abovfb ~t\l'0ftbfJ t;:ri414, ,bo~cUdn:ot
p';Qduc. tbl' IQ;,t" oi",Ultas. loottd, foX'. HO'tlev.~, th.X'o .J;e .1wa~a
l.,sonlJ ~(), .~ ~ •• ;trtt;trot&\~ri'llQ.$int~e ~1.l.d/ Hhien c01,lld he
v.l~l. in ';Ei<;l:i~.!;t~n~ :~\.1t~l:.res'4tcbf l:!Qthcm fa= IndQn :#t.4tiqn.
lUt~ .• I:;.~;:O ' •• ~ 't •• ka' ·,og,t.J;Mtc),becama .<;Qua.t~t.o tluJ need1;ol;' .$~1. , ,
t1:J."l •. ~ .• htOfl tit. 4;AyJ.tb: ~.t;M;r;,l ,!»J:IQt:lelltaf .net !e~ Jd~,i,:Qb 'allow ·~a~~·Ul '~ • .,~tl1:'() .~ Qbtilin.d.'1t(otUng' o'Q,t~qat.wJ.l.til) ipo,~#~bl.,t$. el ... ;ly- a
".tt,,,qf ~~.1.tlQO ~~~, i~ '.t~ld.t~n<1 ,Q~ tnQ$k~l~",. and ~nt.r:.~~()f t)l.cQ<;i>Qpf;r;.t;tn.g~.~J;,,, ',th9.i.nlltU;eflt. Q~l..ltl of: tA.;,.QhnQl.~w~tl$~l~
«."'Sf'l 'i,t',~:o"",a 4t,~fiqql.t;· t'Q d~ ,tlit.l l.t9~ki tlith t~*·c,~Q~tb,f;.x:(t *~j.~11~Ju~<>g:rfuu'1v.l.Y" .Jl..tt.~ttcltl!~n"t:ith,9;.:Yl Q1t,QP~th.t;.~.. nC)~111
ban4lit9tJon i* .~n~l.'daY) ~ An~ en th*, #s~PPQtt.~.m¢e~ Q~t.*'ocl "t.oeb. t.~t:l;it .MAIT··!>
·~~d~c; .. Q~tb.$. ·tx:l~iJ· "cQn1;l~ ·th.ex~t.,ti()lt· tbato . '. P~QpO;t~on ·of. Q;};,..famt,'t1.l.$. _l..11 be' ~Qd.op~ 4~.tc> l.ok .. "ff.~~
i ',I'
C(.l()~~.t.*Qtl~\lIl1$Y1,t@l. Ql..~tiQ, c;Qn4tttQ~~, :~$t .~QtiIJ.;.t~Q~t,QJ: otll.t;:
~.'QtQ,~':. Xn pl~lt1q; ,~, on"'~.m, 1;~j.ll~~t09r~. ,tll,;,etox:_;,),;t: ;l;,
~~.,q tQ;' .. QCc;n,m.t ,:0; th •. fJct· tbat:i.~ut: ;S()i~t.:Q .• q~ot '~.~~.l'. ",lllnQt
.~ '~~l..t.~i.s.pl.l'm.<llf
·th. ~i.riQ'" l~~·t:M$p$.lQtp;qg~c)~"'¢);'k'pQint~ t.o tho. n_d:
J;'Q~ _~h .• l;e: ~ll'_!_ .on ~.pli~4tlQn :o~t~ta:L$ .• ,~it4y ,~c~~$. q~ ~~n'.~c1.1, Q~t;~l\t$~,to<) . .-u.qhQ~! . t;h.wC)1:k."of.~' .dQu.: r;,~r.\"$.a, ,8i~lfh
~'Q:l.te4.tr$..l;.~h,i¢ll l'~(rv;.dtf J.'n8~~t.tciellt'dat.a: tt().k.t.ll.~.
~.c~~t;;O!).' ~PQt.t1ctl: t.~l:~~ ';t :!'$:.dv!:1tl'>lil 'tb-t; tr1-.1$: •. tHl.
~.plici1lt~, throQgut,!me .n.:~ ~p.Q(ltQ Pl:od~.tj.~rW11;.. $ot tot d,ttlw:tn$f,
(;q:~lll$ioA$, .Qd.t,ofll~w ¢~ar.i~~~ Q~ t •. $'Qlt$ ·1)etw.en; ~~f.1;.u.t .
• ~t~ti~n,$ to, '9'aj;na\.bett..l.'gn,c:krlt~n¢i.n~ ;oft"" ~rt.n.t e«c;tor.' .~ollt:tl~t~~tc. t;b.:Oll¢¢Q~4 of t.*l~r\l, Qftb~ t.Qllno~~~ tor thi~tq
()Q¢~J,;f! t;l14fire _::It. ~ .IiQ.Q()-.ord..$natiOil 9:- jQtiv.$.ti.s ~tw .. n, , ... ctvi~Q~
d.1/,1tr,i.ct •. ;.4,~.l'l.~. ". ~1;b: X:'$e_~eh.t.tQe~$.~r. t:b..ttll._ t:ti.l.$ ,.~.
*pptopri_te11' ( ~)igned..l,thf\' li~$,Qn a~¢tiC)n ,i$, tlle"\\1t~1. b04,y' tor thi#
t •• lt..
l*'9tov,ment 4..nt.be:~~toring 'Qft::rtala i~n_c •• IS.~tQ~llQW'
,pJJ;Q-p;i.t. an • .tt4'.~ t>£ t:lt!t ;:.$u1.t~tc) ~ .• ~. c.lQS.~\J~l;V'l:.alon Q~tbf;l
:t.~~ .~. t.~.~.~$:tQx) an.et: ~~.~~C;h Qffic.~s 1b .impQ~tat\t, to. .$eQ.tbatthe
1;.l.'V~nt: lnf:Q~t1C)~;i.. t:'co~dtc:l.rt(l tt"-p~<>'Vid9 adv~Q.: .:nd.Q.the~ ~ • .1.ptQ
thtf.X'i1\tt~·t() _~nt.lnb:$.$ 9'; :h.;enthu$i.SrA- Xtwa,.a18.Q,~oun4tQ l;)e
·l~rtf"nt< ,tC: •• \t;:«tb.t, ;t,;t.qcu:a ,\list t;b..f ... n(la oX'inp~t$pr.'ovlQed int:..ht
( .
• t:.t~ .M,.;:~ ;Pge~t~\~*Q:~<>~~~"~t'1.l~tht:Q~~h v~4td.( $UM$.~gc;t _tlXl~3;;~#tb~"~ if •. ~~ '~~~t:~" p,J;OV.a: ~-a1\JAll~ .bJ1~;ta ~()tA$\lb~~tt1.1t.Qt
.¢~~~t. ~.<:;(n:~tlg ofqul.nitt.tlvf;l tt.t. ~Qll.!~t:I~t~\la.<l .• nQQU~p~t·. <, • ',' - , • ,';- ,
()~tl'~'!,
~b.~.;,t~i;. o~t;:b~.¢t t~,t'.tl.· jho.,,4: th~ '~~Qpe:. t¢r~Dlf1;QV~ntof tb __ t_'lo~ ()~. t;:l.l·~Pft~l.<;;Qa~ 1;.<;l th. fl~n9" .¢~n*,t.y: 'tbt(t~i'b a* .. ~.l. ,or;. fQ~ly :O~~M4 't.~t' vl~tlb tb;Q~9hdl.<;~#..~~Q~ .t,Vl1la~
.. t.~119~~ ,~.diQ·1nt.~1 •• 'I" .t,nd. by ··,otll_t; :_~ttodls.
-, ' ,
.;'t~.e~"tl~.n4 ~$. Qe tz:i.J. .~.!S,,:tt.~ . .$;.$.:. v-t1 ~}:t~t ¢~rht%\t <;If r$R6t$
·tofAq$~~t.,t.the ~~.e~ Qt:' ,i1,ltq~tlQllt9. ~tQ,Ef ··~~;I;thet·;.~~l%eh.
,~po;tlJ' on.j.qh t;r;l_l. _a~ £~"'l:~1;ttm; l,lpandl <Uatt"lb~ttd to .;r;.lttv.ll~
~opl.lt. lmtl. ~.th~:: lttt.le t;.~ h •. ' ~:l..Pb.'cl:$tnc, ttl. ::!t.~ iJftbe p;c99~_ln tq~9.ttb.re; *~.~U,~ •• ~ ~tO\ln@;tQ~ :Qon¢~~n . that' in a
"~QpO::t1.on "Q£~$e~ tb1'tfill- nQ.tltJJ?~. "Me.n~,tQ'nQQ\.ttag~Jln4.!f~!~t tb • .Pe:r:$()Q+l~l~n'ftOl.v~tQ, M~i1;. uptll~;t1:.' ~~~ .ne~.4to .~ f()\1#<ir
n., til'1UqS.~lJ· CO$t ,,~c;:t p;9~A$*Qn" ot u$of~ll:.tsUl:t;$y.:;~~'wid..lY' ' .. ,' .,' , ,
~9 ·U.~t~.l$.f l't,· ia: ~1:t~t t:q:kU:P ,ttl~ c.;Qst, of ·, •• Qll t.~1.11.QW .~~
,th~t al~~~. p~~~. Qt:Q~"'!.=, t:l:l"latwith .~ 9~ ••. t.l;.* n~t (j~' 1,;.'l~c.tlona"Q.p. ·~x~n., .~~ .e.l,'t,nc9:in ~<>tl~a,$ll~lI1$:ho\'t '~Qh, c.n .~ . dQl1 •• ~tb1n·. v.~ ~3t~1ld9'e.f, 4n¢ tlJ;et~ 1# nO~Q~t ,$Qa,pj:tQ' blprQve
~tltb.i.~e.~llf :~~;e.nQEt.
th. t~1_l.1i .'e) fa;: h.v. l>$~Ul (;In t;WQO~' the '~1n' i.l.nc!A, .~th ~ittJ. • .. tt.nt.~:Q#1c 9;'vento lUQh.,;~t;.l¥cation$,~ ,f.~;,l.n~t:m. .n(l&,p)l.ft(1'981),
b._v .... ~9tl.d:. tl1.tt~it~e$t:P\Otf) :fx:~ th~pl;!n(d;ilalQo~rQi~1r c~nt:~'$
l?';Q."i~ . .-u@:pot.nt~.l fOJ: ~ •• '.J;¢lUngJ>()~~il>1.~;r:Qv.D,"EU1~. :tn th.
~~.a;~tlQn.:J:. ,t.n:ilng ~'yateJ!l\ .nil t'b4tt'n •. ~-Q~1Qnt~t;Qd:· .:r:;t,s~.~Qb ~hQu.ld ·be
(:Qn~UQ't~, ,intb, •• area".. Cl.1la);l¥t tbecO.{ft;$of; ,1IQ;'lt. intC\Q;r:e ,~te!
l<tQ~t.f.¢il\lt,wl.U1:la lli,:gbo~ffi.ndlo~tbQt;~' ,ot' t~.tal$.tb~tc;:an :~att.~t;ec;t
. \f~ll. 'be., .~t4It.·~ind;t$t, :d\t9- 'to t;he~xtta ditfi.Qul.t!e~ lng4iitting ~tsoni\el ., ,.~d;,_ttl,ti~,l~ 1fit!opl.aQtl .tc~ tn.' ¢C)n4ijc::e.()~ thewQ.;,k. l'$~ th •• o .:r:;$ jU$1;;
t.~~ c;l1t~~¢:ult$.e •. :a~.4'byt:n.· ~a~J:1!t t,bt1'M~lv~$ 4..n tneil:.v.~day li.vQ~,
Il
13
·S~,tJ;j..l#it\ 4~~h:$lt~ati'me~y ,P:rQvt4e.~Qt.q~;Ly' '::f'$l$~lt$ jbol,1t;. 1tap~v~
_tbo~, bu~U8()J.1JatSJltt$ v~l\~~le tQi~lic1_kEJr:e ~ut bow~Qtne of the,.,'
~m:lt_~t '·tQth •• ~ingo~on~ta=t~~.l$,;ie ,n.¢.$b,a~ !,f th.,
'FS~$: Q,Qn¢optt9 ~QOl1epaxtQt.?f.i¢Ultutal..<l$velopmllnt .,In ,~t>1J9'4. ~be
1!~~1 ··cQ .... Qp«!l;'at!Qn; ,and ~nthttSta~' Qf tbe 'clvi'so~()f;liQef: itt, e.t'ud$:.al'As
they pl.alra. 'key ):ole in c~ipat,JI'~D·l:$t".en t.l:i$~~1c.ipat$~g ,faxrers anct r~5".tcll_t. '~$; ;'v$11 a.lShav1n9' ~.,~pos$.blJ..it.y ,~o.t ex,tcmc.ii1,'lg: li:s~tul.".,t;:3.a~
fiJ14in~f.$toot.hel: ~.~rsit1 tbEt, dist.l!i¢t:. lci'l,1$:Qty ottJ.C::9t'5baV.,'~ la.rge
n~r 'Qf ~f!)~pon$ibil!ti~$, '·afJ.d·£'01; tI'Jl,$'reaSOnl' tl1e; n\1lli:)er ,,~,' t..r;1a18~ 'in
eachdiBt~i~'$bQ~l¢ ~. J.U!it'ct4sC)tpat th,e, n~ce~ea.~ '~. i1JQev6tt:t,d eQ, ~aQ:n. t~± .. l~a.e$ea.rch :Q£t:L~e~s, also, ,:b.~v"'· n_l!QUit re:JpoJJ.~d.bili.tle:u
hOweve.r, on~f.~ tr.ial~ ~b,oul<ib&: :~e8l1. 111$: an $s$t!lit1al. 'el~nt ifti it-bet:
c:lutie~' .... to ~··~ef.t~c't~<l J.~ 'tb.e!r dl,t~Y$t,at~nt8'Pto~1;iQnQ~l!t.::i,a,' ~tQ. :lrlnal1)1t tbe' c~i-tmen.u of fW1dl.ng.anct ~'qEport'~~om. th~ploantdn$t'and '
·genio:r: :l.v.l~. Qf ~l' ,1$ ne~ese~~ ,t.o flJ'l~l. ·ti'prQgr~()t .r.l.y@t~nc;l
,pot~ntiallY .$t,1cees:':ful.on"'fa~ trial.a t,o be ~.
As in. In.()$t deve~opin~dount:r:,l:e:51 funds f()~' llg~,tQulf:l~:r:~l xe:s~atch #to
,:t'<>nga.arfll sholj:..~h~:r:etor~t ;eseax:ch methQdst.batw1:11.be, most eO$t
~ftec;tiv$in :gen~ratingeC::6nQtD;i.C:~l\~fi,tstQ the n,.bion ~lld :l;n ra:t.~d.ll~ th~:
~nco.~ Qt,' t)te pooter ;(~u::xners ;a~requ.b::e(:l. ;A'S~.'E ,app;~aohmay :QeoJ1e
'Wf:Y of impi':ov,inicQ~t--ef'feQtivep.~~sl ,an4: l':elevant,:'well 4e~J,gn~don-fa~ t~lalO' ate ian e~se'(lt.!al pate· of tbi" tilppr6.Q:h,., . ~J:u;~, PilQtp:r.o9':r:~ot
,t:r:$.1Il1$ deeCJ:'l.bed ·~Cl~ the~etQre .~ni1npc)~atlt ·~.r~pt .•
!r~ep,rQg~~was ~'Ucc$a8ful. inin.ct:ells;ip,g: th~:f,l'ow of infQt:nIation '
~tw.enfa~t~tadVi~Qry iUlc1 l;.~~arch Q~f£(.'!er:s ..~b~l.Qng'~,t.~rm,~n~~it8;
to th~f~Jlgc~nl.ty :0£ t;.be t~ial$a:r:E!c.U.£~ic~lttoIJnea~u~e at tb~$
'eat:l.y$t.~9~~,Ult~tf;)~y.t l1doPti<>n by fa~l;:80t the \:~stQ(t tecl1nologies
",;'11 ,~.;,a t.~stof ,the$\l.c;u;:~ss ,oft-he rE*~~arch. llecmt~, less(msil~ve
.. \,be$nl .. a~ed~QQut-:iwprov~nt,s ,n~eded in, tb~ ~~:i,gn andrtuud .. ng of.Oll,-\'. \,
:~atm 't:r::,i.al$i~ th~ tl1tu~,. Impro.vement. intl1e: !ci,entif!,.cat!Qn at proble~ \)
ta'Qed, 'br tatra tM;d.lie~J,s iiecessary, so t.ha:~ ,2ll:E)2isQ;f:g:ieatest 'Potent£~l.
',)
· {)
'bUe$1t' Qatt .~. p;l.n .... PQ1nt.d.. tJda; ~~. ~·ach1~'q:~.br·~.r:~at~~. p>l!l~tic£pa;tiQn "c)f f'~~$in J!b~~4iIt:,ea,r:ch ,P::Oq_SiI antl .bY ·J.nC:J:ea.$e~ 'QQ~l~o~~tiQn betW$on .
t:1'J.~es.a~cb 4nda(lvl$9~ ~t.ff. .. ' -TO :h4V. th. :ma*~s:tI.UDl PeZ1~f.tt·ton,"'fa=f
t:~ial·s~bOUl.<:t be (;~~.f~ly:c;1e$~9n..d andclostAytoQ~tQreClio '1'll~ma~imU1#
U~_ $hould ~. liUlde, 'Q:t::at>erif>nce* \i.iller.! in t'o~l;~ti-p~;f)c:~nd~tion$: to
ta~ra; .in' cle8tgn~n9.iagt;!cu.ltill;~~ ~v:elopmantpr()j.u:t$.a#d. in, :pl.Wng
;fu~be;:~~ea~QJt~
~!l~ t}'J.. t.r:i~i,;asQ: '~a:r:e~~et~ he\t~ \,~alt.!tb. p:r;:OJ;tucti.Qt1
qu~sti~ut$ .. ·c'f1~~fl,l'l C)fc,:tQPs. 1# .. ~. CQunt~ jJ~C:b. .a$J'On9«,,· .. b1.ch ia an
~$l~d ,a~cbip,!l·.gctt ~t4 .. ~%'Ont 'Qv.~"e(ll', _t;~et_.,·(, an4' _ltll $~ve~' dt.;>l~ustl.C
t~Antsl»~t ~t:obl,~" .t)tet~·l~~ ~.~,'Qllth~li't of t .. ~:r:S' ( p~Qbl~. :I:g:' .tutuxe, tb.~.fQ~t,*t;VQulQ·l:>e u$.tul to, ;lQokf()~ , \. . . .' . \(jppQJ:.t:.~ti~,· t'¢1:pt.¢tlc.t t'.~~in9'o~ .". n9J(el:,~rk.ting teplmol~e~
o~, .th9tbt' '~. ius,' .paJ:t;.()~ apt9gtPl'Qf .gtiqt\ltural ~)!keti,D~ $y$tems
t_8~.l::c:h ..
~he ;Q~-~ar:l1ltti"¢4p~Qgt_.t~TQn9. t~· by' no, ... ana. ~llli~$ciAl. ~a~ng4!lll'at~.'~os.~;y;ch an¢ iP'it~nslQnpt:oj.ct" '~A.$.: t'l:.1.1_$!lo:uld be
~~~ ).sthef.~:r$t ·~t:.ep,· ~n .th.,ptQC8:S,$.ot. SI.ttl~g~artne.r$'1 .xt~$i:on.
'~l;'~()ooel an(l . .r:es~~rcb 4ta~f ,lDOt:e hVQl.v~1nt.he4.$~elo~nt- of
apptppriAte. .1;echnologio.$. F.u;t.h"x C~J1fig$S ~n ()':9 • .11lsa.t.i~.ndQ~1;.' .. t*on
of tlle, ~td.8t.J:y will, b-. n~ 1fl.t . 1$ .dec;~d~~ to ~l~nt a :lllJ,.~,~eale
FS!l&~, apj?t:o.ch. unot.d,4o •• jordh.nc;lEJ,s :.tn· l-WT' h.v~ ,be~n .<10
:t;ecellt:ty b\,lt It :1$ too .,ar11 ,to ,c~nt ,()~tbe:ix ll.'k.lyc:onst!qt;tetice~.
,t)e$pite the,IM~Y ~~tat~ons andQe.fi~f>nc:it:l$o~ the ti:ial~.so :f~:P
QQnducted,a$ 4i$cl\a.~. 3;n ~i, P~~I .' tbepilQt.Pt<>9'~atAmay .~
$libJ"ct~vel1.$~e$:s.d.$~u<:~.~$~~ PX'Qvj.$<i that.i.t1s:seen anclll~~d bY'
!!UF pl:~rl.ly as: a lecu:niA~~)I:~J!'i@QEh )ijl~t ,is!).~ed~t;l n~. i:$ :tor ·th$
m~i$txy tQ, develop .... conti,nutng- pr()g~.o~ wQ:t:kthat l'>tlil~~, ()~thi~
·~~p6r1e,Ilcean~.tb:e.t;.~t~t$ly~p$n@ . upon. thflg::owing ~rt;~~e "ithi{l:
1'()nga,in tno· .QonduQt.O~.:S~dh.$tudi~~~ i;~tlte!; than'onollt,d.d~as~.i~t.~rtQe.
%'t i~- ·e~coqr~ging: tll.at :t.ltl$nee&l:$r'ee~!:sed in the lSAflr $Q th~t it i$.
PQ#!l$1ble '1:;Q .~ optilld$t~Q ~t:hat:tb •. even.t\l.i o"tc;:~will.. l>eacQele~tQd
t1ev.lop:lnG#to~t;flchnl~e:s..that will bel~ ,improvEl agrioultut:~l' .p~oduetion
-'ndiA¢Q_$ ()f!t'Qngan·,,~:UJ:).()lctert~lit)$.,
.)
'~.1 >
15
.~.u, '~ ~.,tt,attmil~\ .. \\ , . \~ 'l'
tJ .
(t~s,,"e pQtAtQ ~ltl"u t:t:lil. Qtl",,~a~~~.ial~' Ofll$w C~~nfl.' Ot.' :~., •• ~
'~t~t9 .v,lo:~,f;. '. :t>re.t\c;l1n~,p):o9,z;'.·C)Jl ,tb., ~f#~.a;r:Qh, t.l:nt ;(~.uf.to£\t~ ...,t:a.l.,i,986)*;w:e;~t1).gte~t.a·un$lt t.~~ .n.~nt\O;, !th~i:lfI .v"i;~et;:le$. "
,}tl\V\\ ~,~t;.d tQ~;t:.'18tlmQ6itc1~<:.b (ml.s~Q.batat«'l., ~h.3.ghl'te~dst· ')agt~n¢iAid,Chax •. ct~~!$t~Q:S; 'an4;. '9U~*,n't:y,.ct\1.1~:ty" Jrb.r~·b.'Y1l' ~~nttn~ ,o'~~ ... . n - " , . -" ,\ - F_
farAiJ~~.1.U!~'.~,~n¢~OQ~Q~:tl~a,$ f.o~ qQmp.':t:i~dd. <::tfthe l~;fp~¢~o~'fou:r: '
n_\fvad..Ues '..,i,tb :the. I{$w:.:tl 'I1.rt.t~,;, wblcltjjA\';,\<;l1r~etd;:;l~ ,the', :l'I!Zlln.w~et
PQ~.to, 'Va):iet~t .i:n ~Qn,c;J.,~R'$ql.t8.tlb<>,.,tb.e~e ·.!;t;.·v');l.t!Qn·,~Xl 'tbe
~dQ~c., 'ot ' •• cb.$pftC~~a'~~th; dlft~~nt l,:.V.l$lo1:man.gem.Em~ anc;fup~t . ' j ":', ,."
diffflP!;«mt 'tn~1:(l~nt..l,c()nt;1itioJ'1~ <ti~oon""f~u!%Et tri~l~,o~ tb61.~"at
v.J:iet:te.~ ;in wete'pl.nte.dili~<.l198$" an,4 ~t4.rthe;t trials:wore,b$' 'p,lcmter;l £n l.t$, '19.1J$.. ' '
~... tt:i:,l:) 'po.t.1;O;V.l;,t.~Ytl;l.al.,. ~te:t' t'Q:tlrl:~.i$,' 4t ·[email protected],I;i'$1i' pQtatOt the; Rese~U~Qn Dlvt$1on ·tt •• , ~~c.Q_llQec;t fOl.i~~~;J:et;te.$,tQ):' 'l'Qnga.
~~. Q~ tllel!JG. "ret Ql4'var,~$t1e$",()'t~ l?Qntl~c 'lind. $'~~l.a) ;t.he .Qt~':r:t.wQ. ~~$.: ~p: '.clone~(S'~):.M'.~n.4 ·J)al;l".y) ·that*re'1:)elievO<t to,yitt14 .ell. in
~ ~ "' ~ '.' ~
·~onga f>ut l'la.y.n~v.J: ·bilem g;own,b¥ ~"%:n\e~$_ lJ,ighest, y:1t~~ wer •. ~QbiovecJ.
,by tile $erraUA~v~u':let~(.a ·toMe" ~r"p;e)t, fOllow~b1" .);led 1t,Qr,ltt.c, (35
'tonn,ft$ fGl; '¢~h: $$q\lo,i' (31 'tontl~$ pel;' .Q~«l}att~, l).li:s.~t2$tonn$$,' ~1:
'ac'1:t?). ,'~rtbf$J.: trial~Jlre, 'n~d.Qd: 'tote~tdl:;ftu=~,,o. t~.l$:oepl.nti.1n~, \' ,
.e~v1xQ~t~1. ,~Qllai.t!Qn%l· anci ~tb~ .Q1!:,.$'t,Pt4.g., Andl$.~ p;Qd.~<;It!lon;
(pt.,;'Sentl;y ~&::.lQ' pQt.t.Q~~"x; •• ~tt,.d. ea¢l~ Y.,~) .. ,
\
3.. ¥anill~.lnt~~ctoppi.~9' 'w..i;tb: ·kav.f N~ '~\lldbtu'1an.'r A~ter.'~ol.lQw,in9"
,fI~:tt)!"J: r_Q~n@t"t.)+i$· to :%DQnocz;:op v~u~t~l~,1!a~$,az;:.nQ. l.ntf,tz;:.Q~oppin~ '".p.ttl;~, ,,,,itha,,,.;:i6tl'ofd;.'OpS. intb~fil;st to~· f'.~l;"'Qf p;~ct;£Qn' ..
~C:Q~d!liff;Q~'~~v$~al, ;plQ,t~,Qf¥.pi'il.\, ,i#t.rc~<>p~(1 ",i.t.b~k$v., YPl4Jn(l
'b .. n"~.$, ,~~, tiljQ,ngpl~Qa~~. Vav."U. ~be .~~$ct.Q~ interc;.t,'Ql?ping on the
;grOwth otb9.~l:lv~nil;la. ,and, tbe' .~nt.+Q~~PS •. ill ):)e :meae,u~.Cl, :a.n4 ·'Ji.$CQrtQmie
a~J,l,',$s )I~.ll, .~ 4Q~. ~f1;fJ~ b~n49st"
,~, . .
-Q"~. th.1'1el4 'iQ~ ,."t_.1OP. 'i;ntotc;QPP8cl ,.ltb i~4I' .d,t,}),,, •• t.~lQ~ ,
,gt:olm '.fi.;.~OC:l;Qjj~ 1J:.e,'l)'ti.f1t~;o~ ,t:P..,q~p, Q~.t~,t~Qn.' ;i_~tOt.i "~t/ " F" ": • ' ' ,'.( , ' • ~) (.
, ~~~ov~t ,;ltt.,ou. .f:e~illt1...' ~.~t Qf' t1l6 ,f~n9' (ol nlt~n 1n , .. .' 'j ,
'th •• ot.~~' tl't.bt.14$~ '_~th, ~I~l,.,~ro~ .. ~~ !n •• t.~lc)~ t1.1Clt,
. t~t~.i .,tth ,~t.t.t 1nco. .~J:0Il ~.1l;i~9 th •. · ~Q$.
,s. 13.~" Md<:ov.~c:.'¢p~'~b.t!.lcl· 'f'iJ;~,~Il'n~:$ d.n, ., Ql.P ... atd'blcu:k
: 1$;' t>a~t\~ ,~~. ;t<»,Uatoi b~ul.n.s "'ith a,l~"cQv.~ 'Q1:qp,~tto~
"(C~t.tQ'" :p~.c.n_) ~ !.ibi.s Q,OVer Cl:QP$., ~ct;.4!l4 to in~r6.alt, t~' f.~i.l,.l~YQ.~t~. '.oi~#, te4J,lc., tn." ,l.bol1~ nqui~4, to~ (~~ng ~. :p;otfJQt;
t.h .. lJ$o11.t~.t()';l()#.,,'_fl~'yl.1QA, and "t,u~;"~' !()t.m~tq be'
,$i.gn1t*¢~tly,Jll.gh.r :fqttb •. plntwitn, Q.ent:..~o.##"(:Qv •. J;:· ,otqp ~.re~. to , tb~,el. •• n "'Hd44'\'P1Qt~
,6,8;Q1l.x: 'p;~ctiQP;" A .g:r;Q\1pof lQO.cW.cken$ lfI::. ,t.;bl04$ ;lP-¢.l(en
~t .• ~.;:::".J1.ct thG# \;h.9~Q.th.of t~~f)I' £.c:;lf!n:t~b.';" xatJ.on e~~u:~ to
tbqae. ~;;nlY_9.t.~g "X4l'C;QIPf?~~ ~b..' .%.#~lt:S$bt>.ea'-\~hl\t, ~a.~ tlltl
p'~1:1¢Ul.2;' l.~ ;QQA~~9J)a" 8~v.n9'l.1lg: cbidk4UU'CW.,* ~~ghttn:tb&ll tbQtte ~/ .' " . " '
f,q.~iniehl): 'r.t~,olh· .altho\1g.b:!t wa~"~, .,p:qnO$1c.l P,Qt1:.o', 'r6tci ,t~
lit\iQ'.~~'tiQn.fUtJ:.)1tJ::··\;l:lal·a a~ •. t1~1;o.¢Qn~j.Ql ttle :f,;.\ndl.~. , I
f'h,. l~t:qt;ta. tx •• ~t.o~ b.~'J'1a4'" -~u,t1:;.$ o( «: n ... toQl<l~ Q~a;:l$pl\" tr.i..J..run, ~t th. ~.$ •• tqll fa·t;I\·~n '1'9ngata!miQtU:e.t.1;h.t:tll.~t ~ .... t.oc,t4Q
~"'lgi~e$ ,batt.~ q<>~b=Ql. Q.f;tb~ban.~ .• n~t~.lb.*Ph,Ql\1,~~iJdli.1lJ1 tJ$,~n ith• tm:t;(lnt;J:y :c:eQornmen~ n~t6q~d.;· ,t.tl>QfU;"~If' Xn, ·tb..; :t',rlal ~ in >
the ;f.~r'. tl~14t $.tgn,.t.).cl!ni~'4i!!el;.71e.#!t~· _~n b~CliW.l.~ht ",.r., r,>bs8"et.($:tn ~~l, ;t~.t~.~lQt$ ~rtctth$c(»)lt;~QlplOt, .• it~"e.*bot~t'll"
I ~ .• o"t)1.n~~:qf btmctl.~· p~04uee(i.1 ~~_t. IV ••. ,b19l'1<t7;' in t'h' •. ~PlYl.
t:~"fld;,u.plota.. TlUt$o,;esultaf,::orlti~ t.Jt$' ;;tl8ult$ot the 1)ri~.t$t.t1Qn .~ - . " , - . '. " " '
tx:l~.,An~~ of'. t.he()~·t~~t~,i.l~:w~l:~ .b4"nc;iQ~~. due to $ev.~BttnQby f
'f9PP,~ol:>l_'~
'8. C~geatlQ, ';'.t';:o.t:r '1nt:erQtl()p~ .,it;honlOIlS", ttetl1~·Qt! "e4\1cil\gth~
neeafot' ~atip.tfle~ ~w'li .. ~g:.tQ~iQ.~·V.fl90,t~lEl~ .t:~ r&~i~,in ~tQn9...,On:f.on$q
_.y •... ~n lcnl:)~, ];.t?, ~.dt1Q. ~nt'est'~t;'qn. 'in o~het"C~()p$·1.>Y rel..a~~J}9'
'~~l.l.nt.()dQv.J.'.'lIi ttl thi~ ~~:tAl tbt -.ft •. ct. Qf ~nte1:~n:Qppinge@W9'ea and
l\~h~i~t.. '1fttb QntQI1:J '0,' .• nc.·<U.$f#aa~Ir'..a ~stlnc!denc., 'Wli.$ .a$1.1~..~he t.xiU .J' ,I
.: •• b.a,,;ilJ'inf.st~ 1Ii"'1\ J:>1 • .mc>nd *cked"()\:i~ :., .,. ;e$ultotl.atef>laQting <..
" 't ,"r!
I Ii
(I
, .
. ancl ~.Qk-9!.V..;1~1.~P;Al'$~ T~~~ w •• ~nQ" .igQi..el~~tr. 4itf.l:e~Q.\iJl,t!l.
~$t ~~~t,·Q.1;t$P!t wh.t.b~ ~b.l"~e, ;:(nt.~c~()ppod 'W!thoniQn$ t>x:: :not. ,'I
i~'.~.~lQ~ ~~1:tll1 •• rt~.\.:t.,\ ~ •• ~'9',tbI$;t~1.1~'. t.,D ¢~"' tn~ ,RltponeQI ".t.eJ;1'QelQn~cUltj:'.t~ ~i:J,'1Sf.cld,.Qkq, .. nut.tNtl\tf.ct"tg.<l
t.~!l,1",r t.~i~I)· :;u~4.sd.~t~~Qttb. two. :It t"~_Q! 'w~~t!Jlg, ·th. r;,;
,q:tOp'~c1 'nQt ~'n~Pt~.:
,10.,~~Q!o~#tt)r t..~~'.l,., 'l'b,eai_of ,tU,tti-.l $,4 tab,]", ,~~ppl .. o.t. •• pltUy' d:i;ad.f1i~n~ 'f~~ •• t ,~t;.tio •. J: to l:e4,llc .• :th ... ~.t.ctqt '1iin~
4v.pot.1;ln$r~:t;Q ll..l.p _~nt..~J)~., ·sP,pp).y q;t' :1%0.0.04.. "'!f~.~.;'$ A lQn~ ....
t.m .~~i.l, ".$ .nJ~.f1t$"lllPQt; 'be \.vi~t '~Q~ '.' n~~ ot¥.a~!h'
:u,~ ~_ f~,low.:Nt~ht~. ~4IK'Ju~,tlon .tn the· t'llo,", )?er:tQ(lts,: ·"oil
%.~~llit~ l,.b.~4 t.Q,W,dGc~.$!~9' ,in, ,a~ •. ~Jq~T,Qnga: .... ' !tb! •. p1:qbl_
I ~ght, 1 .. :~~~.:1,;~yovet¢~ .t(l~'i ..... ;;e$~tm during". reb., :t.llo\f; f~.~;$.«l
t,o~.~to~r4t,:.n ,to· ~. ;$o$,.~'!!t6$~.~'~ nllti:V. l~tJ·tb"~ J1.~. ·~~·g;o\fAt,t.4$.t1Q;1.1l.Y4U~ing :tb.,· ~.l~QW .J*rl.:~~, $UQA' ., tb.;' fQtl9!~ '~an .
'I.
(~(Q '.~1.~h.. .ill ~. tl11. ,t~l.'l, 3.;~' 'to .n90q;a::J1g.lta~;a::~ 'topl,.nt ./
J,.f~.,,~Qb, ·.,tt'$:ongM ~anQn -th.1l;£-.llow; lallcl+~n1 ,~$~t8. fJ::OIl,
t~ ••. t'z:1uo ,.r:etU.it,~Qt.~ .. to. ·~~pp.l::_t~Ol': 'oe.,.x:..lf •• ;a::tl aft;.l:'tb.tJ:'
~t;.ti.on.,
12!' :J?~~'~lb&~J:Y" ~O,y.;a::i.t.i..49~ ~~Jt ~r~t.. "h:i.~b, ,;1a \t1!Jed, ,to
.k.t.~ "~:dd clQtb:,.;elleing (;~;a::C,;:fQ~ t~~J: ~;a::owth,,,, _t~ o~ "_ '" I,>
.P,;pp_u&tlon: .(oin:ke::$ ve:rflUD¢utting's) .ndQpt~~ :~PlQini~r~.l.Q ~in9'
te$t~.,
'. " ' ".,t~ ,'. ",',,," '" ~""l:.", ~\.~:ti~l4¥..l;, _..,p,~ :(l,$184t f "'9t'~QU1tu~.l ~~,~ •• ~Qb fQJ:
~iiji.i~~~~,·'t'i~;'~·lr·~J:*~·~t.~~~~1:tJt·'ml~l •• t' ,~li:"~""~:" • " " IJ
'~';'8.lit~"t(),,;th. 1f.'ti~QPU A9';:iCUlt~.t '_ ••• ~Qhl~oj.Qt, .9,):kSbo~'i:m, ;tt.tt<)n~ ai~~,l.tUt.).~."at;cfi;, ~~~tt N.t1Q~1 .~~ ,of:,
li);i.Q\1lt;.'f.n:.J; ~._.;Qb, *tta~ .. ~tf ~;gdr.n.~.J;,~dAt~~.4~1fa;t¢h\l
, .. ),~1.U)'Qf;a.Q";1 (1918)" "ltb.to i.t.pU,~g: 'W#ll~,~:;el$"i;Qhud: 'tlxt.noj,Q.nl
"'~t >1. ;t~.,eot,.ntl.1.,i1\:~Qn;',1~ ,t, t~ '~',~\I 'Gl!1,:jJ:_;~ •• ~f.t..lo '(~l ,f' , , '.. ,+ , \ :--- ~l
i~ilSJQ' g#,'t'rb1J' ,'o;~.li~ ,~, t._." lxot_il$H~h ,'~$l, "t!,9~i~ 1I1ll4',#4t tgwPh'~t.9,tItt ,'~" ~, $q\lt;hP .. ~~;l~~lhQld.t1: ,~.t('d .. c;t'f tfn.t:v.t'd~y' Q~;'N_~)..n4, '~,~d.f.~'fS"lQ~
,;F.t:'t'$.,ngt4n;, 'I • • ~ti,Hllr;t;,bt, ,~,,, '(1981).I,tf_.:' bi1='~il?J;9tt II ""t.Qb;I,
~zilt, Qtc-<W~R~i • 'lid'UgJ;~p" 1)l~,QU~Jl,iOJl i?~~ 191 ~l:lQUlt~~<>\:,
~~, l)..(1$8$)fQp~ba "f •• tgj;UJ_AJ,t.'Q,t~: IPPraplllcb "o;t'«;u'~~.QJt,~.pct); ,NQ~t'83" ,$cbQt>l<>f! o.":.lCl~t$t~_." Vniv"::$~tr' ot "'t~,ll., "Notlf,*<m;,.
a.~~lt.t't 1~·'1'J3:..(1988) I \Qb'.ctlv.$;~cl t(ol:uhQJ? o\).~l~~'~~ i~, A.l-,.'G!lee
.n<l ~'" . ~.t;el~, (.~l t ~Jlg;1' ,?f);b, H£lU,b@9n r.~ng:§y.~ J$tt"~, f.QSi·"t;$Ul.,QU,Ht1JJ.tn,rsmSltt '2""1{1· 811 JfI'.t .$putlt .. '.Qlfj,Q '_llliQl~t P,tOj,GQt'iUn1ve1;$J.,t;)! Q~:Ntlf'En9'l'n~,Axmt~l.) 1·$1l
.ij~~.~( .;1., l;l~J:J;)ttlf:()l:e .. ,t1 .. 0"l!;,!'l..u.tJq',$l! tl'" .. #48,£.l1a1., $ ,·(:),98$)·,
_llb91~~MdS;\ltt9;' iQ%9n$lA;, .8@R9;;t 9t: thft~p!ij;li.f'~ ,.J.1l.,na;pr9lf;j:. i.n;()~A .. 19~ .... aa~(2nd..~), soutn~.clfic: _l~hQl~~~:to:i.ct:., tfn.t~t",$.tl" ,Qf ,N.~1n9J:.4nt\t ~tn.U.~1 ••
~'
a'$.~ __ l.i. ~ el~~s~1)' .. ,(~;9B$), J.Fai;mll19' jY.t_:X •. #4ul\;:c:;lnf.11 , <,' 'r .' • ~ f
"V"'~t,~'4pptQ'.ettt~· l~l_ntllti~~", q~;n.ldP" m'QP.t~~t1 *s>:palg,. 36'(1),1' ~9 .... ,SlO
19
~dtt.~tC.;N .. (19'Q):" ~~f.~"l:'!1MJAt~u'QM.~~4.n¢ •• '"tl\ ·e~~~ , , ~.:s,w~ ~ aIiJ.~n~~. (~):~,+~"g;~lr~9QMtU.Jlg. ::Qf 'tit.
SeQQn4$~u_'Qn Xtl~.tc;t~ng; ~n$~ ... ar1d;: It.~''t ,a.14.t: KQi,;;~;Q" t.ti •• ~~b 4-''"1' ~u~a1!,l'98()rl.O"'5 '"
, . '.\ .
~av.U~I'I'~(1$&1)·,i.J:[Q~<.?.Q'i tQUJ;"", •• tpot_tQ:C,~t~Y..t+, ~nQtl.'i"(.~ t%'i~#,~D 1:1\6 ~~$t~~t~Qng.t ·~l~.d 'np,Qrt, ~t~Q~af.
;$~'.m~i. •• $" (1.9S81, 'Ol;~.n1.,.t~onot ;"9f:~Qultp~an t()n~.':' J;nlt.H .• ','~X)~
't~",), ·IMllb9J.ltr ,~t;Q~ll4~;.J,PJ;!tt~ptln . ''(pn~'t ~t:rM\, •• ~J.l~' No~2._~~.,. .i3~5 ..
Sl.1f~b a~ .(19$$) ,·$t~h.m~9: tl1',~;~._ ·Qt:'9~i~t~,~'l;J;.4 •• ,cb ·tQ
~l'~~, •• niQ •• nc;ltu,.;t.~J:'(:l4~o~.; .tn. t.~.~h t*.,.4V~2$,Q~: l~al~QA :poa,*~*oQt PIP4l~p.i .... t,a.b"t.b. ~~~~Ult.t~v., :KQt.~~9 QO
~.gtiJtht"4,&~$Q\\1t.\lt'.1, k\:.I)'~<>n~t(.8"~dJt ."gri~ultu~.t
~<3tlQ~. ·&J)4t.~I;'.,.9""13,"lJ.i1., 1..986; Xll$~J' ,~t~.~o» ~~'.'l:cb~ ~_$l<>n:.~<1 5:1:.~~~ng: :10 ,Ag;lQ~~~J;. (tl$~A);lt,·UDjt~e,1;O.t;ty~f th. -$o~t:h .'P.c.l~fio ,~A}..~\l~Cgp~',,~J?~.'; It'Mt,;n $~., S3~.$ '"
$pt1;.J.",J:~1\t 1198.8)i on .. ~.Qt tdi.J.~· :QU tn. ¢~;,1,$g~, :Qf tt.. n .. tQQt;<le~
(?)(~~ att4, c.~~tut~.~.t. 8~J;~ ·l?,a,,, ~¢n1.n~.~ iknt
t;;Qttct.l~n f~C)l~Qe:t<i~I)/ltf1,;fff lal~~S"
:a\lt_tQtqafe. ,pql't, r'~$ .. ,iU\~ ~ttN.(l;$$61,$¢; .. e."'1~g:.nal:>re.<Un~'
,lo;r:: ·."'.tp.o~.ti~.$ $ctb lll.ino., ·b.t;.1;~~'.l ,te~1'1:ge. 10: tQni.,
:1'~J: ~~.~;~ fQJ; tlb. tmP~It.AQiGfallUTA "'9.tQ~a,1..wo~~:shQP" $-1.1
$.~t~i ll.6" ~i.t ft.$t.~ S~.t ~ .. gi