nation branding: concept and theory
DESCRIPTION
Some thoughts on nation branding as a concept and theory.TRANSCRIPT
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
The Place Brand ObserverPlace branding and reputation insights, strategies, thoughts, examples
Some Thoughts on Nation Branding as Concept and Theory
Edited by
Florian Kaefer, PhD
Follow @PlaceBrandOBS on Twitter | Facebook.com/PlaceBrandObserver
As featured on:
PlaceBrandObserver.com
http://placebrandobserver.com/nation-branding-concept-theory/
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Olympic Games and World Expos - Nation Branding Extravaganza
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Introduction
• There is growing interest in nation branding both in theory and practice.
• The academic treatment of nation branding has been narrow and cursory.
• What does nation branding actually mean?
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
“As an emerging area of interest, nation branding is driven largely by practitioners and there is an urgent need for conceptual and theoretical development of the subject”.(Fan, 2010, p. 98)¹
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
“Study of nation branding sits at the nexus of soft power, public diplomacy, and brand communication.” (Jay Wang, 2014, USC Center on Public Diplomacy)
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
“Interdisciplinary approach needed to arrive at a theoretical synthesis.” (Wang, 2014)
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Wang’s (2014) definition of nation branding:
“the application of branding principles to a country’s external communication for desired perception and understanding.”
He highlights that:
“Nation branding is not a balanced portrayal of a country. The congruence between brand perception and reality is a perennial concern.”
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Wang (2014) further:
• Nation branding is a highly selective representation that accentuates the positives.
• By its very nature, it is not a balanced portrayal of a country.
• The congruence between brand perception and reality is a perennial concern in such efforts.
• As the contemporary communication ecology has become decidedly transparent, the content and expressions in a nation-branding program can easily be questioned and contested.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
The potential loss of trust as a result of gross misrepresentation is incalculable and can be very difficult to recover.
That’s why the incentive for credible and authentic branding outweighs that for exaggeration and propaganda. (Wang, 2014)
“Improving a nation’s image does not necessarily lead to structural transformation in global relations. But a positive image—as cultivated through branding—contributes to
a nation’s soft-power resources.”
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Influence of branding on national image is limited
“The function of branding in improving a nation’s image is important, but limited.”
“Branding is never a default solution to solving image problems facing a nation…Even when branding is considered as a viable option, it is only part of the organizational strategy and is never the entire strategy.”
Jay Wang, Director USC Center on Public Diplomacy
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Wang concludes:
While branding is crucial to making a nation’s external communication and interaction more compelling and engaging, it certainly is not a be-all and end-all, and that it would be naïve to assume that one nation-branding program can alter a nation’s image once and for all.
Via Nation Branding Reconsidered | USC Center on Public Diplomacy.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
ThoughtsJay Wang is right, nation branding is a diffuse concept that offers itself to many possible interpretations.
Opinions vary as to what exactly the term means, how useful it is, and whether a nation can or should be branded at all.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Judging from Kaneva’s² (2011) extensive review of scholarly work attributed to nation branding, literature on the topic is far from homogenous but varies significantly.
She offers a useful distinction between technical-economic, political and cultural-critical perspectives on nation branding in academic literature.
Yet, in practice these perspectives often overlap, making a waterproof categorization of nation branding literature difficult.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Jay Wang calls for synthesis. Synthesis, however, is not very likely considering that the various nation branding perspectives are nurtured by diverging underlying ontological assumptions with regard to social power and national identity.
Also, synthesis is not always desirable, as it might lead to the silencing of some of the more marginal (and perhaps most important) voices from the cultural-critical field.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
Nation branding practitioners need to be aware of the potential ramifications resulting from endeavours at branding a nation.
Not just regarding a nation’s image abroad. But the effects it might have on people’s self-perception, sense of belonging and national identity.
Especially when gaps between brand promise and reality receive unfavourable attention from overseas media.
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
Nation Branding: Concept and Theory
As the late Walter Olins and Jeremy Hildreth aptly put it in their 2011 book chapter (p. 56):³
“In the more successful instances of nation branding, the focus seems to be more internal than external – that is, more attention is directed to how the nation perceives itself than to how the nation is perceived by outsiders”
Copyright 2015 The Place Brand Observer
References
¹ Fan, Y. (2010). Branding the nation: Towards a better understanding. Place Branding and Public Diplomacy, 6(2), 97-108.
² Kaneva, N. (2011). Nation branding: Toward an agenda of critical research. International Journal of Communication, 5, 117-141.
³ Olins, W., & Hildreth, J. (2011). Nation branding: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow. In N. Morgan, A. Pritchard & R. Pride (Eds.), Destination brands: Managing place reputation (3rd ed., pp. 55-66). Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann.
Want More? Visit
PlaceBrandOberver.com
FREE Newsletter! Subscribe to The Place Brand Observer
for insights, reports, reviews and exclusive offers.
Subscribe now athttp://placebrandobserver.com/subscribe