nomos - as formas da sociologia do direito

8/18/2019 Nomos - As Formas Da Sociologia Do Direito

1/436

!"#"$!"#$%&' )* +!*,!'-' )" +.%/,!')0'12* "- )$!"$&* )' 034


2/436

"#$%&%'()*+ ,+-./'(

012+*+ &(34+ 53 2+.(32+ $6+&7(38+ "% -%&7%+2+ $( *&(.9%# :+ (*; /*'(/*&7?


3/436

!"#"$ !56789: ;< +==:?: ;5 +@8/,=:;A:BC< 5? )7=579< ;: 034

3


4/436

!"#"$

!"#$%&' )* +,*-,'.' )" +/%01,')2'34* ". 5$,"$&* )' 678@#$/.+ AB?C — 4/$? D 2+E? CFGB

9)$&*,' 8:";"H+3%*+ I/&+3( J(K($&(3'+

9)$&*,' :";"L(-%3 J-%*'%3# M-#'( N#3'O>$K+-3+

9)$&*, ?%%$%&"@&"P$%**#3 Q#*R N(%( N+$#

8*@%"A:* 9)$&*,$'AAna Maria D’Ávila Lopes >3'S3%# Q#*R >K+$T* U/3+*J(-.+3 I#,+E)V+32# V#2-%8/+EH+3%*+ I/&+3( J(K($&(3'+W$%E(9+'7 "($.S3W-#* X-(/W-%& J(3($)M#-8/+*M+2+-% H% Y+-3(-2%M+-3(32# >-(Z4#

M+-3(32# M(&/-[ "&($#3*# X#3E`$+*0(/$# Y#3(K%2+*L(-%3 J-%*'%3# M-#'( N#3'O>$K+-3+:%$$%* "(3'%(8# X/+--( M%$7#:#$< 0(/$

U#.#*? V+K%*'( 2# 0-#8-(.( 2+ 0S*)X-(2/(aT# +. H%-+%'#2( bMJ?

@? G)Gcde)M#-'($+E(f W2%ag+* b3%K+-*%2(2+ M+2+-($ 2# J+)(-`f 3? *+.+*'-($? h-8T# #


5/436

%*J!" *% '0&*!"% 'D7K5 !/'#- 2( #9-( o"+)

8/-# 2+ >&%2+3'+* 2# L-(9($7#p K#-(&%2(2+


6/436

X(-(3'%(* M/32(.+3'(%* kN+*'-(2#l 2( M(&/$2(2+ 2+ H%-+%'# 2+ @%'S-%(?J##-2+3(2#- 2# X-/,# 2+ 0+*]/%*( W*'(2#f H+.#&-(&%( J#3*'%'/&%#3($ +H%-+%'#* M/32(.+3'(%*? 0-+*%2+3'+ 2( >&(2+.%( Y-(*%$+%-( 2+ H%-+%'#* ^/).(3#* k>YH^l? 0-#2K#8(2#?

)5M785 'D?57;: ;5 'M;=:;5N+*'-+ + H#/'#-(32( +. H%-+%'# ,+$( b3%K+-*%2(2+ 2+ M#-'($+E( – bUi)M5V? Y#$*%*'( J>0W"f 0V5"b0D0V5H>H?

";A:=;< PAM58 ;5 %


7/436

V5WW5=83'%,#$%*? H%-+'#-( 2( J$13%&( jurídica “Empresas e direitos humanos” no âmbito do Mestrado 2 Direitos7/.(3#* + 2%-+%'# 7/.(3%'`-%# 2( bniversidade de Évry Val d’Essonne.J##-2+3( ('/($.+3'+ /. ,-#4+'# 2+ ,+*]/%*(*


8/436

-:=7: &5=5E: 3l+ W*'(2#f 0-#&+**# + *%32%&($%*.# k00XHD0bJ)V"l?


9/436

0D78858 X56T %7D6N=7< ;


10/436


11/436

%0-\!$*

)*0&!$P' P'4$*P'X

-"XQ*! ] #"! )* ^0" V0X,'!_ 'P\X$%" )' 4*P#$#`P4$' )* !",$*P'X$%-* 4*- *-0X&$X'&"!'X$%-* )' *-4

!"#$% '($)* +* ,#"-* ................................................................................................. /0

&"!!*!$%-*a X"$ )* 'J'&" " )$!"$&* b %",0!'P1' P' %*4$")')" )" !$%4* !1+23 4#*5 6%21*1+%5 .............................................................................................. 78

' 4*P4!"&$c'12* )* +!$P4d+$* 4*P%&$&04$*P'X )' %*X$)'!$")')" P* e-J$&* )' #$*X`P4$'%"f0'X 4*P&!' 4!$'P1'% " ')*X"%4"P&"% !1+23#* +* ,#"-* 9(5:* 4%1#5% !";%#+* +% !1+2*+% '(?$@ ......................................................................................... AB

30P12* &!$J0&\!$' " '4$)"P&"% X'J*!'&$#*%_ 0-' 'P\X$%" )*% 40%&*% &!'P%'4$*P'$% !1:C1#( D*E#"#( 6"(2#*1# F%:( G@2$#* 9*2"* H%2%#2* '#


12/436

i'P& " ' 4*P4"+12* 4*P&"-+*!eP"' )" )$!"$&*% Q0-'P*%_ 4*P^0$%&'% " )"%'3$*% b &"*!$',"!'X )*% )$!"$&*% Q0-'P*% >%QQ%25(1 =?#E 62*1R* ............................................................................................... ST/

&0&"X' )" 0!,`P4$' " )" "#$)`P4$' P* P4+4 >?-U1$#( V*5$(1$%"(5 V#*1* .................................................................................... S/0

'% 3*!-'% )' %*4$*X*,$' )* )$!"$&*_ 0-' !")"%4!$12* X0Q-'PP$'P' )* )"J'&" 4"P&"P\!$*"P&!" i"X%"P " "Q!X$4Q =?$*5 6?$$# !;*:( .................................................................................................. SSB

*!)"- P*!-'&$#' $P%&$&04$*P'X ' +'!&$! )* +"P%'-"P&* )" 'f"X Q*PP"&Q G*2$%"( +% 9*5:2( 9?1)* 6#")( G*2$(5 V#1W$#( 9)%#1 6%2%5 .................................................................................... S00

^0"%&h"% )" +*Xd&$4' " ^0"%&h"% )" +!$P4d+$*_ * )$!"$&* b -*!')$' " b +'!&$4$+'12*

+*+0X'! P' +*Xd&$4' )" 0!J'P$c'12* )* ',X*-"!')* )' %"!!'a "- J"X* Q*!$c*P&" G*2#* X%2%E* 6(15%$* 4#*5

=(2%1* G%""( % 6#J?%#2%+( ....................................................................................... SB8

'0&*!!",0X'12* " )$!"$&* ,X*J'X_ *% P*#*% 3"Pg-"P*% V0!d)$4*% P2*/"%&'&'$% G*:%?5 +% M"#-%#2* 6(21*5#%2 =?$#*1( V*E 6%22%#2* ............................................................................................... SI0

' 4*P4"+12* -"&'3d%$4' )* %"! Q0-'P* "- !*0%%"'0 " ' $X",$&$-$)')" )' 3*!1' 4*-*30P)'-"P&* )* )$!"$&* '%J%1*"+( +* 9(5:* ................................................................................................. 8/8

' X"$ HFjIklmFGHH_ +*P)"!'1h"% %*J!" * $P%&$&0&* )'% 4*P&!$J0$1h"% n"P4'!,*%o %*4$'$% "* P"4"%%\!$* )$\X*,* "P&!" '% 3*P&"% ,)%#"* ,:("E '(+2#J( L*"#* .......................................................................................................... 8SB

* 4*P3X$&* '!-')* %d!$* b X0c )'% '!-'% ^0d-$4'%_ +"!%+"4&$#'% +'!' * 4*P%"XQ* )" %",0!'P1')' *P0

Y"#55%5 =%-O ,#"-32#( +(5 '%#5 '(?"#* G(::%]D*?;-(" ............................................................................................... 7T8

X' +!0"J' &"%&$3$4'X p 'X,0P'% 4$!40P%&'P4$'% -*)$3$4'&$#'% )" X' !"%+*P%'J$X$)') +"P'X"P !*-' p "P "X 'P&$,0* !],$-"P =?#5 '(+2WJ?%E K11%5 ............................................................................................. 7/B


13/436

)*0&!$P' P'4$*P'X


14/436


15/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9:

-"XQ*! ] #"! )* ^0" V0X,'!_ 'P\X$%" )' 4*P#$#`P4$' )* !",$*P'X$%-*

4*- * -0X&$X'&"!'X$%-* )' *-4 !"#$% '($)* +* ,#"-*

!"%2.*> (3`$%*+ 2( (,$%&(aT# 2(* %ag+* 4/-12%&(* ,+$#* S-8T#* 2( 5NJ R 2+ */.( %.,#-'q3)

&%(f ,+$# -2#* J#.+-&%(%* V+8%#3(%*? 5,'#/)se por utilizar a expressão “convivência”por ter sido abandonada a expressão “compatibilidade” pelas razões expostas no desenvolvi-.+3'# 2( (3`$%*+? > .+'#2#$#8%( +.,-+8(2( ,(-( +*'( (3`$%*+ *+-` /. +*'/2# +K#$/'%K# + .,()-('%K# +3'-+ # '-(9($7# 2+ (K($%(aT# 2+ .,('%9%$%2(2+ + /'%$%E(aT# 2# N+&(3%*.# ,(-( ( '-(3*)

,(-n3&%( -+($%E(2#* 3# q.9%'# 2# J#.%'n 2+ >-2#* J#.+-&%(%* V+8%#3(%*? @+-%&>3($[*%* #< '7+ (,,$%&('%#3 #< '7+ $+8($ %'%#3*


16/436

9; • $< =:? @2AD9:


17/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9E

b. 2#* .(%#-+* #9*'`&/$#* (# '-(9($7# 2# J>JV R ( (/*n3&%( 2+ %3JV? 0#- +**( -(ET#f JV ,+-2+-(. # *+3)'%2#f .(* .# # N+&(3%*.# JVf -+*/$'(32# 3#


18/436

9F • $< =:? @2AD9:

J#3*+$7# *#9-+ J#.+-&%# 2+ "+-K%a#* #/ J#.%'n *#9-+ J#.+-&%# + H+*+3K#$)K%.+3'#lf +*'(32# */4+%'# ( 3#K( (,-#K(aT#? H%K+-*#* #9*'`&/$#* +=%*'+. 3+*'+,-#&+**# 2+ (3`$%*+ 2( .,('%9%$%2(2+ 2#* >JV k>l + .# -+*/$'(2#f JVf $#&(32# +. 2ZK%2( (&-+2%9%$%2(2+ 2# ,-#&+2%.+3'# kYl?

FjHj *U89[KAD


19/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9G

(,S* 2(


20/436

>D • $< =:? @2AD9:

,(-( # &`$&/$# 2(* 9(--+%-(*p (* '(-%


21/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • >9

FjHjFj "rq=588s58 :?UZ>A:8 ;< :=97>< ff$#

> +*'-/'/-(


22/436

>> • $< =:? @2AD9:

2+-(2# #-%8%3`-%# 2# 9$#f # .R-&%# ,#2+ *+- 2%*'#-&%2#? i**# ,#-]/+ # ,-#)2/'#- K(% #,'(- ,#- %3*/.# 2#.R*'% 3T# 3+&+**(-%(.+3'+ .(%* 9(-('# ,(-(*+-K(- ( K(3'(8+. ,-+LL 3T# 2+-2# *#9-+ V+8-(* 2+ 5-%8+. ]/+ 2+JV (* ,(-'+* 2+K+. +$%).%3(- */9*'(3&%($.+3'+ (* 5VVJ* (# .R-&%# %3'-()E#3( kyyi@pel + ,(-($+)$(.+3'+ 3T# ,#2+. (/.+3'(- #/ &-%(- 3#K(* 5VJ* ,(-( '+-&+%-#* W*'(2#*kyyi@pBl? >$R. 2%**#f #* ,(1*+* ]/+ JV *T# (# .+*.# '+.,# .+.9-#* 2# J>JVf # *+3*# ,-('%&(.+3'+ %3K%)(9%$%E( ( (2#aT# 2+ /. -+$('S-%#f ,-%3&%,($.+3'+ *+ +$+ 2+&$(-(- # >JV %3.),('1K+$ . # *%*'+.( 5NJ?Gc 5* N+.9-#* 2( 5NJ -+%+&+. (* 2+*K(3'()8+3* 2( ,-(=+ 2# *+3*#f .(* 3T# 7` ,-+K%*T# 2+ ]/+ +*'( *+4( ($'+-(2(?

Gd > i32%( *+ .(3%(?21*" (Q d1:%21*:#(1*" =*^f K? cFf 3? Fjf 5&'? Gcctf ,? tCB)tjF?

Gc J#3


23/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • >=

W$+.+3'#* -+$(&%#3(2#* ( 3#'%JV 3T# *T# 3#'%L" -+.+'+ ( $S8%&( 2+*'+.+*.# (-'%8#? b.( 2%L"?

PTA terms to take place and for consensus on their conformity to be found.” "bL^WVI>UHfPeter. L’avenir de l’OMC: relever les défis institutionnels du nouveau millénaire. Rapport duJ#3*+%$ */$'('%< r N? "/,(&7(% 0(3%'&7,(;2%f H%-+&'+/- XR3R-($? X+3}K+p 5-8(3%*('%#3 .#3)2%($+ 2/ ..+-&+f CFFj?

CF 5 '-(9($7# +=+&/'(2# ,+$# N+&(3%*.# 2( '-(3*,(-n3&%( ,(-( #* >JV *+-` (3($%*(2# .(%* (


24/436

>H • $< =:? @2AD9:

FjF *8 W=:K:88


25/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • >:

,+-&+9%2# (# $#38# 2#* (3#*f .,-#.+'+32# %3&$/*%K+ */( +LLl? W*'+ (-2# -%( *#.+3'+ # .R-&%# 2+ &(-KT# + (a#f LL ,(-( ]/+ ,/2+**+. *+- ('%38%2#* #*#94+'%K#* 2( JWJ>?CA

U# &(*# 2( JWWf # '-('(.+3'# LL 2+ 8(-(3'%( 2+ )

formidade do Tratado da CEE com o GATT, estabelecendo “the firm assurance (...) that as long(* '7+ "%= _#/$2 -+.(%3 J#3'-(&'%38 0(-'%+* '# '7+ X+3+-($ >8-++.+3' '7+[ _#/$2 *&-/,/$#/*$[#9*+-K+ '7+%- #9$%8('%ons under this Agreement”. 0WLWV"N>UUf W-3+*')b$-%&7? L7+ WWJ (* (X>LL N+.9+-p I+8($ LL I(_ (32 '7+ W/-#,+(3 J#../3%'[ I(_? i3p^iIMf N+%37(-2w Q>J5Y"f M-(3&%*w 0WLWV"N>UUf W-3+*')b$-%&7? X)% K?2(_%*1 9(;;?1#:O *1+:)% L!XX. H+K+3'+-p x$/_+-f Gcetf ,? Aj?

CB W. 3#K+.9-# 2+ GcBdf # 8-/,# *%.,$+*.+3'+ 2+&$(-#/ ]/+ 3(]/+$+ .#.+3'# 3T# *+-%( ,#**%)K+$ # +=(.+ 2# L-('(2# 2+ V#.( . # (-'? yyi@f .(* ('+ 7#4+ 3T# 7#/K+ /.( 2+


26/436

>; • $< =:? @2AD9:

5 +=(.+ 2+ .,('%9%$%2(2+ 2# 9$# +/-#,+/ . (* -+8-(* 2#X>LLD5NJ 3T# +-(. +*&+32+3'+* .'($ ,-`'%&(? L($ ,+-&+,aT# ./2#/ +. GceCf ]/(32# (&%#3(-(. # S-8T# 2+ *#)

$/aT# 2+ '-#KR-*%(* 2# X>LL '-( ( JWf ($+8(32# K%#$(aT# ,+$( &+**T#2+ ,-+LL +. *%?Ce "+32# (**%.f +*'+ 9$# '%3/#/ ( +=%*'%- %3)2+,+32+3'+ 2( (,-#K(aT# 2( 5NJf (/.+3'(32# # 3Z.+-# 2+ ,(-&+%-#* +(,-#


27/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • >E

ML>f .(* '+.(* .# -+8-(* 2+ #-%8+.f (8-%&/$'/-( + ( ,-+K%*T# 2+ ]/+ # Jb")ML> ,-+K($+&%( +. -+$(aT# (# X>LL %.,$%&(-(. +. 2ZK%2(* ( -+*,+%'# 2( .),('%9%$%2(2+ 2# .+*.#?AF

> (3`$%*+ 2+ .,('%9%$%2(2+ 2# U>ML>f ]/+ */9*'%'/%/ # Jb"ML>f ML> L"? W3'-+ #* 9$#* -+8%#)3(%* 3#'%ML> R # ]/+ .(%* *+ (,-#=%.( 2(* %ag+*2+L"? > $%9+-($%E(aT# .+-)&%($ 3# %3'+-%#- 2# 9$# R */9*'(3'%K( kcc€ 2# .R-&%# -+8%#3($ +. K#$/.+l+ ,(-+&+ 3T# '+- &-%(2# 3#K(* 9(--+%-(* ( ,(1*+* '+-&+%-#*? J#. 9(*+ 3%**#f #*.+.9-#* 2# J>JV +.,-++32+-(. +*


28/436

>F • $< =:? @2AD9:

> (K($%(aT# 2# N+-*/$ ,(**#/ ,#- ]/('-# -#2(2(*f *+32# ( /$'%.( +..(%# 2+ CFFt? N/%'(* 22?Gt? Gt .(% CFFtf ,? FC?AB @+- 5NJ? J#.%'R 2+* (&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=? U#'+ */- $+* ,-#&+2/-+* 2+*'%3R+* (

faciliter et a améliorer le processus d’examen. WT/REG/W/9, 9 octobre 1996. OMC. Comité des(&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=? N#2}$+ 2+ ,-R*+3'('%#3 '[,+ ,#/- $( ../3%&('%#3 2+ -+3)*+%83+.+3'* */- $+* (&-2* ..+-&%(/= -+8%#3(/=? :LDVWXD:Dtf GB (#‚' Gcct? 5NJ? J#.%'R2+* (&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=? I%83+* 2%-+&'-%&+* &+-3(3' $+* ,-#&R2/-+* 2+*'%3R+* (ameliorer et a faciliter le processus d’examen. WT/REG/W/15, 6 mai 1997.

At @+- 5NJ? J#.%'R 2+* (&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=? i3K+3'(%-+ 2+* 2%*,#*%'%#3* 3#3 '(-%)


29/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • >G

tj * -"4'P$%-* +'!' ' &!'P%+'!`P4$' )*% '4!

H%(3'+ 2# ]/(2-# 2+ 2%2#'(2# 3# JVf ,+$# -+$R. 2%**#f'#2(* (* ($'+-(ag+* ]/+ (JV 4` +=%*'+3'+f 2+K+. *+- 3#'%JV

,-#K%*S-%#*f (# l N+*.#*+32# /. *%*'+.( 3#K# + 3T#)2+


30/436

=D • $< =:? @2AD9:

tjHjHj ' 7?q(?2]1*" (Q d1:%21*:#(1*" K$(1(;#$ =*^c K#$. Gdf Gcctf ,? AAG–357; Phillip M. Nichols, ‘Participation ofU#3)X#K+-3.+3'($ 0(-'%+* #< '7+ :#-$2 L-(2+ 5-8(3%E('%#3p W='+3*%#3 #< "'(32%38 %3 :#-$2L-(2+ 5-8(3%E('%#3 H%*,/'+* '# U#3)government Parties’, Y1#-%25#:O (Q H%115O"-*1#* >(?21*" (Qd1:%21*:#(1*" K$(1(;#$ =*^f K#$? Gdf Gcctf ,? CcB–329; G. R. Shell, ‘Trade Stakeholders Model and


31/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • =9

0(-( +3JV 3# *+%#2# J>JV? W3'-+'(3'#f . ( $R. 2%**#f ( JV ,#2+. (/=%$%(- .+.)

9-#* .+3#* 2+*+3K#$K%2#* ( ,(-'%&%,(-+. 3(* 3+8#&%(ag+* + 2+.(%* ,-#&+2%).+3'#* 2( 5NJ?

W**( 9-+K+ (3`$%*+ 2+.#3*'-( ( %.,#-'q3&%( 2# ,-%3&1,%# 2( '-(3*,(-n3)&%( ,(-( # *%*'+.( .# /. '#2#f 3T# *+32# */-,-++32+3'+ # +3'+32%.+3'#

0(-'%&%,('%#3 9[ U#3)"'('+ Parties in the World Trade Organization’, Y1#-%25#:O (Q H%115O"-*1#* >(?21*" (Q d1:%21*:#(1*" K$(1(;#$ =*^f K#$? Gdf Gcctf ,? ABc–381; Chios Carmody, ‘Beyond the Pro-posals: Public Participation in International Economic Law’, !;%2#$*1 Y1#-%25#:O d1:%21*:#(1*"=*^ '%-#%^f K#$? GBf CFFFf ,? GACG)GAjG? STEGER, Debra P. “Introduction to the mini)*[.,#*%/.on transparency in the WTO” >(?21*" (Q d1:%21*:#(1*" K$(1(;#$ =*̂ GG kjlf #&'#9+- CFFef ,,? dFB)dGBf ('? 0? dFc?


32/436

=> • $< =:? @2AD9:

2#* N+.9-#* 2( 5NJ +. /'%$%E(- '($ ,-%3&1,%# ,(-( # '-#$+ + .#3%'#-().+3'# 2#* >JV? J#3'/2#f # -+


33/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ==

,-+q.9/$# 2( H+&$(-(aT# 2+ H#7( R JV ,(-(( ,-#.#aT# 2( $%9+-($%E(aT# + 2+*+3K#$K%.+3'#? jt

5 (K(3a# 2(* 3+8#&%(ag+* '+. *%2# $+3'#f *+32# ]/+ 2%K+-*#* 2#&/.+3)'#* ,(-( (/=%$%(- '(%* 3+8#&%(ag+* LLD5NJ?jd

>* 3+8#&%(ag+* #--+. +. 2/(* K%(*p /.( 2+ -+/3%g+* JV? > K%( %3JV ,-+Kn (3#'% ,(-'%- 2%**#f # "+&-+'(-%(2# ,-+,(-( /.( (,-+*+3'(aT# 2#*


34/436

=H • $< =:? @2AD9:

U( ,-`'%&(f +**+ N+&(3%*.# R *%2+-(2# .(%* #9-%8('S-%# 2# ]/+ # (3'%8#*%*'+.( 2+ 3#'%JV +. CFFB? U+*'( #&(*%T#f #* .+.9-#* 2# J>JV (3($%*(-(.# (-2# 2+ $%K-+).+-&%# +3'-+ J7%$+ + J#-+%( kK#$/3'`-%#* 3# +=+-&1&%#lf 4/$)8(32#)# ,#*%'%K#? i**# -+ ,(-'%- 2+ .(%# 2+ CFFdf. ( $+8%'%.(aT# 2( .+'#2#$#8%(f # "+&-+'(-%(2# ,(**#/ ( -+($%E(- (* ,-%.+%)

-(* (3`$%*+* 2#* >JV 3#'% H+&%*T# ]/+ +*'(9+$+&+ # N+&(3%*.# 2+ '-(3*,(-n3&%( ,(-( #* >JV

.+3&%#3( #* ,-(E#* -+$('%K#* (* 3#'% %3'+-2%aT# 2( /'%$%E(aT# 2#* -+$('S-%#* + +=(.+* ,-#2/E%2#* ,+$# NV0J + ,+$# N+&(3%*.#,(-( ( '-(3*,(-n3&%( 2#* >JV R Z3%&( +. -+$(aT# (#* 2+.(%* ,-#&+2%.+3'#* + 2#&/.+3'#* #


35/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • =:

+*'( (3($%*+ 3T# ,#2+ *+-K%- 2+ /'%$%E(aT# 2# N+&(3%*.# ,(-( ( '-(3*,(-n3&%( 2#* >JV .+a( .# (3Z3&%# ,-RK%#? 5* .+.9-#* ]/+ +*'+4(. 3+8#&%(32# 3#K#* >JV 2+K+.3#'%JV -+&+3'+.+3'+ (**%3(2#* 2+)

K+. &-2* ..+-&%(/=-R8%#3(/=? HR&%*%#3 2/ Gj 2R&+.9-+ CFFt? :LDIDtdGf Ge 2R&+.9-+ CFFtf ,(-(8-(,7+ GF?

BA b.( $%*'( .,$+'( 2#* (3Z3&%#* ,-RK%#* +*'` 2%*,#31K+$ +.p 7'',pDD-'(%*?_'#?#-8DbiD0/9$%&W>V)L>I%*'?(*,= >&+**# +. Fe 2+E CFGB?

Bj 5NJ? N#2}$+ 2+ 3#'%&+**# +. Fe 2+E CFGB?

http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspxhttp://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspxhttps://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/region_e/notification_e.dochttps://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/region_e/notification_e.dochttp://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspxhttp://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspx


36/436

=; • $< =:? @2AD9:

&(*# 2+ >JV


37/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • =E

'-(3*.%'%2(* ,+$# "+&-+'(-%(2# 2( 5NJ . /.( (3'+&+2n3&%( 2+ ,+$# .+3#*]/('-# *+.(3(* (3'+* 2( -+/3%T# #,-+*+3'(aT#


38/436

=F • $< =:? @2AD9:

2%(-%(.+3'+? M($7(* (%32( +=%*'+. 3# JVf K%*'# ]/+ K`-%#* 2#&/.+3'#* *+-K(. *+/ &(-`'+- 2+ $R. 2%**#f ( 5-8(3%E(aT# (%32( 3T# -+($%E#/ +*'/2#* %.,#-'(3'+*.# #* -+$(&%#3(2#* ( $+K(3'(.+3'#* +*'('1*'%* *#9-+ # K#$/.+ 2+ .R-&%#-+($.+3'+ -+($%E(2# ,+$# /3%K+-*# 2+ >JV? @($+ -+**($'(- ]/+ ( 5NJ '-(9($7(

. #* 2(2#* + %3JV +*'` +.


39/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • =G

CARMODY, Chios. ‘Beyond the Proposals: Public Participation inInternational Economic Law’, ?.",$>'@ 6@$#",%$&P J@&",@'&$*@'A H'Q!"#$"Qf K#$? GBf CFFF?

CHARNOVITZ, Steve. ‘Participation of Non)X#K+-3.+3'($ 5-8(3%E('%#3* %3the World Trade Organization’, 6@$#",%$&P *; +"@@%PA#'@$' F*2,@'A *;

J@&",@'&$*@'A 9>*@*.$> H'Q] K#$S Gdf Gcct?J5U"bIL>Li@W Y#(-2 '# '7+ :L5 H%-+&'#-)X+3+-($? L’avenir de l’OMC:-+$+K+- $+* 2RLL? IDBt?Ge 3#K+.9-+ GcBC?

„„„„„„? "/..(-[ V+-2 #< '7+ M%J0)Wb '-(2+ -+8%.+ (32 '7+:L5? 92,*["'@ F*2,@'A *; J@&",@'&$*@'A H'Qf K? GGf 3? Cf CFFF?

^bHWJf V#9+-'? C:" 1?CC A"-'A %P%&". '@) Q*,A) &,')" )$[A*.'>P? U+_•#-;p 0-(+8+-f GcdBf ,? GcB)Gct?

LaNASA III, Joseph. Rules of origin and the Uruguay’s Effe&'%K+3+** %37(-.#3%E%38 (32 -+8/$('%38 '7+.? C:" ?.",$>'@ F*2,@'A *; J@&",@'&$*@'AH'Qf K? cFf 3? Fjf 5&'? Gcct?

N>VJW>bf X(9-%+$$+w VWiN>Uf J#-3+$%*? :7+3 (32 7#_ %* ( -+8%#3($ '-(2+(8-++.+3' .,('%9$+ _%'7 '7+ :L5~ H"-'A J%%2"% *; 9>*@*.$> J@&"-,'&$*@fK? Cef 3? FAf CFFG?

N>L>NY>I•>f M-(3&%*w :5IMf "/E(3(? L7+ J#'#3#/ >8-++.+3' (32 '7+J7($$+38+ #< .(;%38 '7+ 3+_ Wb)>J0 L-(2+ V+8%.+ :L5 .,('%9$+? F*2,@'A *; N*,A) C,')"f K? ABf 3? Gf CFFG?

NICHOLS, Phillip M. ‘Participation of Non)X#K+-3.+3'($ 0(-'%+* #< '7+

:#-$2 L-(2+ 5-8(3%E('%#3p W='+3*%#3 #< "'(32%38 %3 :#-$2 L-(2+5-8(3%E('%#3 H%*,/'+* '# U#3)government Parties’, 6@$#",%$&P *;+"@@%PA#'@$' F*2,@'A *; J@&",@'&$*@'A 9>*@*.$> H'Qf K#$? Gdf Gcct?


40/436

HD • $< =:? @2AD9:

OMC. “Mécanisme pour la transparence des accords comme-&%(/=régionaux.” Décision du 14 décembre 2006. WT/L/671, 18 décembre 2006.

„„„„„„? Y(*+ 2+ 2(2#* 2#* >JVp 7'',pDD-'(%*?_'#?#-8DbiD0/9$%&W>VL>I%*'?(*,=>&+**# +. Fe 2+E CFGB?

„„„„„„? J#.%'R 2+* accords commerciaux régionaux. «Synopsis des “questionssystémiques” relatives aux accords commerciaux régionaux”. WT/REG/W/37.C .(-* CFFF?

______. ______. Champ d’application, processus de libéralisation et2%*,#*%'%#3* '-(3*%'#%-+* 2+* >&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=? :LDVWXD:DjtfB (K-%$ CFFC?

„„„„„„? „„„„„„? HR&%*%#3 2/ t 22?Gt? Gt .(% CFFt?

„„„„„„? J#3&-2* ..+-&%(/= -R8%#3(/=?Communication de l’Inde» TN/RL/W/114. 6 juin 2003.

http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspxhttp://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicEARTAList.aspx


41/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • H9

„„„„„„? „„„„„„? i3K+3'(%-+ 2+* ]/+*'%#3* -+$('%K+* (/= (&-2* ..+-&%(/=régionaux. Note d’information du Secrétariat. TN/RL/W/8/Rev.01, 1 août 2002.

______. Groupe de travail de l’Accord relative au Marché Commun du SudkNWVJ5"bVl :LDJ5NLHDBDV+K?G? CB #&'#9-+ GccB?

„„„„„„? N+&(3%*.+ ,#/- $( L-(3*,(-+3&+ 2+* >&-2* ..+-&%(/=-R8%#3(/=? HR&%*%#3 2/ Gj 2R&+.9-+ CFFt? :LDIDtdGf Ge 2R&+.9-+ CFFtf,(-(8-(,7+ GF?

„„„„„„? NR.#-(32/. 2O(&-2 */- $O%3'+-,-R'('%#3 2+ $O(-'%&$+ yyi@ 2/ X>LL2+ Gccj?

„„„„„„? N#2}$+ 2+ 3#'%


42/436

H> • $< =:? @2AD9:

STEGER, Debra P. “Introduction to the mini)*[.,#*%/. #3 '-(3*,(-+3&[ %3the WTO” F*2,@'A *; J@&",@'&$*@'A 9>*@*.$> H'Q GG kjlf #&'#9+- CFFe?

„„„„„„? “Introduction to the mini)*ymposium on transparency in the WTO” F*2,@'A *; J@&",@'&$*@'A 9>*@*.$> H'Q GG kjlf #&'#9+- CFFef ,,? dFB)dGB?

SUTHERLAND, Peter. L’avenir de l’OMC: relever les défis institutionnels du3#/K+(/ .%$$R3(%-+? V(,,#-' 2/ J#3*+%$ */$'('%< r N? "/,(&7(%0(3%'&7,(;2%f H%-+&'+/- XR3R-($? X+3}K+p 5-8(3%*('%#3 .#32%($+ 2/..+-&+f CFFj?

:L5 "+&-+'(-%('? !"-$*@'A$%. '@) &:" N*,A) C,')$@- "=$)* ". YU *2&S XUYZS


43/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • H=

&"!!*!$%-*a X"$ )* 'J'&" ")$!"$&* b %",0!'P1' P' %*4$")')" )" !$%4*

!1+23 4#*5 6%21*1+%5

!"%2.*U( *#&%+2(2+ '+.,#-q3+( — como quer que seja denominada: “sociedade de risco”

ou “reflexiva” (ULRICH BECK), sociedade “hipermoderna” (GILLES LIPOVETSKY), “pós).#)derna”, “líquida” (ZYGMUNT BAUMAN) —, o valor “segurança” assume um( -+$+Kq3&%( +='-()#-2%3`-%(f *+4( .# '-(,#*%aT# r* &-+*&+3'+* (.+(a(* + -%** 8$#9(%* 8+-(2#* ,+$# ,-S,-%#7#.+. +. 2+--n3&%( 2# (K(3a# '+&3#$S8% k(-.(* 3/&$+(-+*f (]/+&%.+3'# 8$#9($f .(3%,/$()ag+* 8+3R'%&(*f 8/+--(* 9%#$S8%&(*f '+--#-%*.#f %3'+$%8n3&%( (-'%:'#"H%-+%'# r *+8/-(3a(? WK#$/aT#? "#&%+2(2+ 2+ -%*? ^%,+-.#2+-3%2(2+? L+--#-%*.#?

0-%3&1,%# 2( ,-#,#-&%#3($%2(2+?

C9!!K!J


44/436

HH • $< =:? @2AD9:

#,,#*+2 '# '7+ %3&-+(*%38 8$#9($ '7-+('* (32 -%*;* ,#*+2 9[ .(3 (* ( -+*/$' #< '+&73#$#8%&($ (2)K(3&+.+3' k3/&$+(- _+(,#3*f 8$#9($ _(-.%38f 8+3+'%& +38%3++-%38f 9%#$#8%&($ _(-


45/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • H:

U+**( $%37(f # 0-#


46/436

H; • $< =:? @2AD9:

2+ K%2(f R &(,(E 2+ ,-#K#&(- -+(ag+* ,-%.%'%K(*f %.#2+-(2(* + ('R K%#$+3'(* 2+(/'#2+*. * ;2&2,* 0 .'%'-*,' b @' $@%"-2,'@3' c2"] >')' #"W .'$%] #$#"0%" * [,"%"@&"SK '.=$"@&" )' >$#$A$W'34* )* ";d.",* ;"W .2)', * &*. ".*>$*0@'AS ? %"@%'34* )" $@%"-2,'@3' $@#')$2 *% "%[a,$&*%e ' %'f)" %"$.[g" >*.* *=%"%%4* )'% .'%%'%e * &",,*,$%.*] '% >'&R%&,*;"%]'% "[$)".$'% %4* ,"-2A',."@&" @*&a>$' )" [,$."$,' [R-$@'? >*$/'(* *#&%(%* + #* 2%*&/-*#* &-1'%* 3T# .(%* #


47/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • HE

"\$-d@>$' -"@",'A$W')' )" [,*&"34*? ‡???ˆ W%* (8#-( # '+.,# 2# 2+)*+3&(3'# . ( ,-S,-%( ,S*).#2+-3%2(2+f 2( 2+*.%*'%' ."@*% ;,a#*A'] .'$% "%&,"%%'@&"] .'$% '[,""@0%$#'? ? &*.')' )'% "\$%&d@>$'% ["A' $@%"-2,'@3' %2[A'@&' ' )"%0preocupação “pós0moderna”. É com os traços de um composto[',')*\'A )" ;,$#*A$)')" " '@%$")')"] )" "2;*,$' " #2A@",'=$A$0)')"] c2" %" )"%"@:' ' .*)",@$)')" )* %"-2@)* &$[*?

U# ]/+ ,+-'+3&+ (# H%-+%'# ,`'-%#f ( JMDee 4` 3# *+/ 0-+q.9/$# (**+3'(a segurança como um dos “valores supremos” do Estado Democrático de Di-

-+%'# 9-(*%$+%-#?B O valor “segurança” é positivado expressamente em vários dispositivos

2( JMDeef . 2%$'A “na forma desta Constituição”dw 3# (-'? Gjjf $*_?:f

B “Nós, representantes do povo brasileiro, reunidos em Assembleia Nacional Constituinte para%3*'%'/%- /. W*'(2# H+.#&-`'%f 2+*'%3(2# ( (**+8/-(- # +=+-&1&%# 2#* 2%-+%'#* *#&%(%* + %32%K%)2/(%*f ( $%9+-2(2+f ( "WXbV>U†>f # 9+.)+*'(-f # 2+*+3K#$K%.+3'#f ( %8/($2(2+ + ( 4/*'%a(J5N5 @>I5VW" "b0VWN5" 2+ /.( *#&%+2(2+ "WXbV>U†>f ( ,-+K%2n3&%( *#&%($f ( ,-#'+aT# r .('+-3%2(2+ + r %3


48/436

HF • $< =:? @2AD9:

( *+8/-(3a( ,Z9$%&( -+K+$()*+ .# )$,"$&* )$;2%*e ] ,(**1K+$ 2+ ,-#'+aT# .+)2%(3'+ (aT# &%K%$ ,Z9$%&(c. Para além disso, há ainda menção à “segurança na-cional”GF, à “segurança interna do País”GG k&/4( 2+? ‡???ˆ ƒ G‰ > *Z./$( '+-` ,#- #94+'%K# ( K($%2(2+f ( %3'+-,-+'(aT# + ( +


49/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • HG

'%K# #/ */94+'%K# 2+ %3*+8/-(3a( (*.* 2. $@%&,2."@&* )" %"-2,'@3' + #*2%-+%'#*


50/436

:D • $< =:? @2AD9:

C2)* "%&',$' [",)$)* %" * ."%.* :*.".] *2 * ."%.* >*,[*)*% [,$@>$['$%] *2 )*% @*=,"%] *2 )* [*#* "\",>"%%" *% &,d% [*0)","%G * )" ;'W", '% A"$%] * )" "\">2&', '% ,"%*A23g"% [f=A$>'% " *)" `2A-', *% >,$."% *2 '% c2","A'% "@&," *% [',&$>2A',"%?GB

… */( K+Ef I5JxWGt +3*@:">", %"2 )"#", + ;$>', %"-2,* "[,*&"-$)* )"@&,* )*% A$.$&"% )' A"$f ]/(3'# #* 8#K+-3(3'+*f .(3)'%2#* 2+3'-# 2#* *+/* 2+K%2#* $%.%'+*f 3T# $)'% )* [*#* + '-`-%(* (

*/( K#3'(2+?H+ #/'-( ,(-'+f # 2%-+%'#


51/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • :9

kGddtlf 3( J#3K+3aT# >.+-%&(3( *#9-+ H%-+%'#* ^/.(3#*CF k0(&'# 2+ "T# Q#*R2( J#*'( V%&(lf 3( J#3K+3aT# ,(-( ( 0-#'+aT# 2#* H%-+%'#* 2# ^#.+. + 2(*I%9+-2(2+* M/32(.+3'(%*CG 2# J#3*+$7# 2( W/-#,( kV#.(f GcBFl + 3( J(-'(2#* H%-+%'#* M/32(.+3'(%* 2( b3%T# W/-#,+%(CC kCFFFl?

tj %",0!'P1' V0!d)$4'_ P'&0!"c' " 4*P4"$&*"+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( R /. &+%'# .2A&$;'>"&')*? > *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&(

,#2+ '+- .Z$'%,$#* 2+*'%3('`-%#* k# ,(-'%&/$(-f ,+**#(* 4/-12%&(*f ( $+'%K%2(2+f# ,-S,-%# W*'(2#f +'&?lf ,#2+ (**/.%- ( 3('/-+E( 2+ ,-%3&1,%#f 2+ 2%-+%'# %32%)K%2/($f 2+ 2%-+%'# *#&%($f 2+ 2%-+%'# 2%


52/436

:> • $< =:? @2AD9:

J#3*#(3'+ J>U5LiI^5Cjf *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( + ,-#'+aT# 2( : “A segurança jurídica é entendida como sendo um&+%'# #/ /. ,-%3&1,%# 4/-12% ]/+ *+ -(.%$.%-# 2# J#/'# +? 5 ,-%3&1,%# 2( *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( k,-#'+aT# r .%3%*'-(aT# 0Z9$%&( 2+ (3/$(- *+/* ,-S,-%#* ('#* (2.%3%*'-('%K#*p # ,-(E#2+&(2+3&%($ 2# (-'? Bj 2( I+% 2# 0-#&+**# >2.%3%*'-('%K# 2( b3%T# kI+% 3‰ c?dejDccl? i3p Hi>"f Q#-8+ 2+ M%8/+%-+2#w J5"L>f Q#*R 2+ M(-%(w J>U5LiI^5f Q#*R Q#(]/%. X#.+* k5-8*?l >V"i@HiJ>UHi? W*'/2#* +. 7#.+3(8+. (# 0-#


53/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • :=

( ,-#%9%aT# 2+ -%1#2% $(1:2* Q*$:?; _2(_2#?;c 7(K%2( .# /.( 2+--n3&%( 2()]/+$(Ct?

^bNYWVL5 P@iI>Cd +3&(-+&+ # ,(,+$ 2( Q?1+*;%1:*RZ( 2*$#(1*" 2(* 2+&%)*g+*p

0#2+)*+ &+%'/(- ( *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( .# *+32# /.( 3#-.(),-%3&1,%# ]/+ +=%8+f 2#* 0#2+-+* I+8%*$('%K#f W=+&/'%K# + Q/2%&%`)-%#f ( (2#aT# 2+ .,#-'(.+3'#* ]/+ '-%9/(. .(%* ,(-( (+=%*'n3&%(f +. 9+3+


54/436

:H • $< =:? @2AD9:

-+,-+*+3'('%K#* 2# ,#2+- + 2( *#&%+2(2+f + 3T# *%.,$+*.+3'+ 2( K#3'(2+ 2(.(%#-%( 3/.R-%&(f .# 3( >3'%8/%2(2+? H(1 ( %.,#-'q3&%( 2( -+,(-'%aT# 2#,#2+-f ( +=%8%- %3'+3*( 3+8#&%(aT# ]/(32# #* %3'+-+**+* 2+ /. *+8.+3'# $%)2%-+. . #* 2+ #/'-# 3( +**( $/Ef # ,-%3&1,%# 2( *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( 2+*,#3'( .# /.( 2(*.(%* %.,#-'(3'+* -','@&$'% 2#* 2%-+%'#* U†> QbV‹HiJ>" – @>I5VW"MbUH>NWUL>i" dFK'KFXK, !M K,X!4M 4KGM9'kXd9M 4K 4d'KdXM [...]”. kN" AGjGC>8Vf V+$? N%3? JWI"5 HW NWII5f "+8/32( L/-.(f 4/$8(2# +. CcDGFDCFGA?l

AG J#.# R *(9%2#f 3+. '#2# 2%-+%'#


55/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ::

Ij %",0!'P1' 4*-* X$-$&" '*% )$!"$&*% 30P)'-"P&'$% " b )"-*4!'4$'

"+32# /. 2%-+%'# ,-S,-%( J#3*'%'/%aT# %.,g+ $%.%'+* ( K`-%#* 2%-+%'#* $R. 2(* $%.%'(ag+* %.,#*'(* +. '+.,#* 2+ 3#-.($%2(2+ %3*'%'/&%#3($f( J#3*'%'/%aT# ,-+Kn (%32(f %; _2(" +* 5%J?2*1R* (defesa da “ordem pública” ouda “paz social”if $%.%'(ag+* .(%* *+K+-(* +. '+.,#* 2+ (3#-.($%2(2+f 2+ %3*)'(9%$%2(2+ 2+.#&-`'%&(f ( *(9+-f 3#* &(*#* 2+ "%&')* )" )";"%' *2 )" %a&$*?Ad

Aj “Os direitos e garantias fundamentais consagrados pela Constituição Federal não são ilimita-2#*f ?;* -%E g?% %1$(1:2*; 5%?5 "#;#:%5 1(5 +%;*#5 +#2%#:(5 #J?*";%1:% $(15*J2*+(5 _%"* $*2:* G*J1*l_2#1$W_#( +* 2%"*:#-#+*+%m.” kN5V>W"f >$+=(32-+ 2+? J/-*# 2+ H%-+%'# J#3*'%'/&%#3($? GjŽ +2? "T#0(/$#p >'$(*f CFFAf ,? tG?l

AB “5" HiVWiL5" W X>V>ULi>" iUHi@iHb>i" UŠ5 LN J>VPLWV >Y"5IbL5? UT# 7`f 3#*%*'+.( *'%'/&%#3($ 9-(*%$+%-#f 2%-+%'#* #/ 8(-(3'%(* ]/+ *+ -+K%*'(. 2+ &(-`'+- (9*#)$/'#f .+*.# ,#-]/+ -(Eg+* 2+ -+$+K(3'+ %3'+-+**+ ,Z9$% #/ +=%8n3&%(* 2+-%K(2(* 2# ,-%3&1,%#2+ K%Kn3&%( 2(* $%9+-2(2+* $+8%'%.(.f (%32( ]/+ +=&+,&%#3($.+3'+f ( (2#aT#f ,#- ,(-'+ 2#*S-8T#* +*'('(%*f 2+ .+2%2(* -+*'-%'%K(* 2(* ,-+--#8('%K(* %32%K%2/(%* #/ $+'%K(*f 2+*2+ ]/+ -+*),+%'(2#* #* '+-.#* +*'(9+$+&%2#* ,+$( ,-S,-%( J#3*'%'/%aT#? ‡???ˆ k"LMf N" CAjBCf V+$? N%3?

JWI"5 HW NWII5f L-%9/3($ 0$+3#f 4/$8(2# +. GtDFcDGcccf HQ GC)FB)CFFF?lAt > JMDee ,-+Kn ]/+ # 2%-+%'# r *+8/-(3a( 2( *#&%+2(2+ + 2# W*'(2# 2+K+ ,-+K($+&+- *#9-+ # 2%)reito individual à prestação de informações pessoais: “Art. 5º. [...] XXXIII ) '#2#* 'n. 2%-+%'# (-+&+9+- 2#* S-8T#* ,Z9$%* %3


56/436

:; • $< =:? @2AD9:

UT# 7` 3+8(-f ,#-'(3'#f ]/+f 3#* &(*#* 2+ +*'(2# 2+ 2+


57/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • :E

,-S,-%( 2+ /.( --+3'+ ,#$1'%)%2+#$S8%&( +*,+&1*@%&$&2>$*@ "% j* )"=" %",i @"2&,'A "@&," A'% )$#",%'% >*@0>"[>$*@"% j 2&"/%+06"3'" porque es, o debe ser, “nuestra”, co-.2@iS 0#- $# '(3'#f *% /'%$%E(.#* $( (,$%&(&%#3 4/2%&%($ 2+ $( *)'%'/&%#3 ,(-( 2%-%.%- +$ LVi>f M+-3(32#? W$ H+-+&7# [ $( '%38+3&%( 2+ $# ,#$1'%? H%*,#31K+$ +.p Œ7'',pDD___?&+-)K(3'+*K%-'/($?.D#9-(D+$)2+-+&7#)[)$()'%38+3&%()2+)$#),#$'%)FD? >&+**# +.p GG .(%?CFGB? X-%


58/436

:F • $< =:? @2AD9:

5 '+--#-%*.#f 3( */( -t. 303. […] ƒ C‰ W*8#'(2#* #* .+%#* +-&%'%K#* $+8($.+3'+ ,-+)K%*'#*f ( (+-#3(K+ *+-` &$(**%


59/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • :G

.")$)' )" )"%&,2$34*f 3#* &(*#* 2#* %3&%*#* 2# $*_?: 2+*'+ (-'%8#+ '[/% '2&*,$W'34* )* +,"%$)"@&" )' !"[f=A$>' *2 '2&*,$)')"[*, "A" )"A"-')'?

V+8/$(.+3'(32# +*'+ 2%*,#*%'%K# $+8($f # H+&-+'# B?GjjDCFFj %3K#&( +=),-+**(.+3'+ # ,-%3&1,%# 2( *+8/-(3a( ,Z9$%&( ,(-( 4/*'%-'? G‰? W*'+ H+&-+'# +*'(9+$+&+ #* ,-#&+2%.+3'#* ( *+-+. *+8/%)2#* . -+$(aT# ( (+-#3(K+* 7#*'%* #/ */*,+%'(* 2+ '-` *+/ '/-3#f # H+&-+'# e?CtBDCFGj 2+$+8#/ (# J#.(32(3'+ 2( >+-#3`/)'%&( .,+'n3&%( ,(-( 2+&%2%- (&+-&( 2# (9('+ 2+ (+-#3(K+* ]/+ (.+(a(**+.( *+8/-(3a( 2# +*,(a# (R-+# 9-(*%$+%-# 2/-(3'+ # ,+-1#2# 2( J#,( 2# N/32#

2+ CFGj?J#3]/(3'# ( JMDee *S ,-+K+4( ( ,+3( 2+ .#-'+ ,(-( # &(*# 2+ 8/+--(

2+&$(-(2(f (-8/.+3'()*+ ]/+ # (9('+ 2+ (+-#3(K+ R *'%'/&%#3($ 3( 7%,S'+*+2+ "%JW:#;* +%Q%5* _2%-%1:#-* ,(-( -+,+$%- (.+(a( %34/*'(f ('/($ #/ %.%3+3'+f (#2%-+%'# r K%2( + r *+8/-(3a( +% (?:2*5 _%55(*5? >**%.f 3/. 4/1E# 2+ ,#32+-(aT#f# 2%-+%'# I@W" MWVVWiV> MiI^5: “Se se pode distinguir a segurança da comuni-2(2+ 2( *+8/-(3a( 2#* %32%K12/#* ]/+ ( %3'+8-(.f 3( K+-2(2+ +*'T# (1 2#%* (*,+&'#* 2+ /..+*.# ]/(2-#f #* ]/(%* *T#f 3#


60/436

;D • $< =:? @2AD9:

]/+ ( %"-2,'@3' 2( $+'%K%2(2+ ,#2+ *+-K%- 2+ 5%6%'" ( 2%-+%'#* %32%K%2/(%*II> "iJbVW>, alla libertà, alla dignità umana.”

jt > +*'+ -+*,+%'#f "5 Xib005Ui: “Nell’ambito dell’affermazione dei,-%3&%,% 2+$ *'%'/E%#3($%*.# $%9+-($2+.#&-('%f $( J(-'( 2+$ Gcje -%#*&+ (.,%+ *II> "iJbVW> U>i5U>IWf ($$( .#-($+f ($$( *($/'+f ($$( ,-+)K+3E%#3+ 2+% -+('%f ($ 9+3+**+-+ +#.%f ( II> HWN5JV>)i>f anche se, da ultimo, con l’indicazione della necessità di salvaguardare il contenuto essen-E%($+ 2+% 2%-%''% + %$ &-%'+-%# 2% ,-#,#-E%#3($%'r.” kXib005Uif L#..(*# M? I( *%&/-+EE( + $+ */+“dimensioni” costituzionali. H%*,#31K+$ +.p Œ7'',pDD___?(&(2+.%(?+2/DGGBteGjdDI(„*%&/)-+EE(„+„$+„*/+„2%.+3*%#3%„*'%'/E%#3($%? >&+**# +.p GG .(%? CFGB?l kX-%


61/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ;9

.(%* *+3*1K+$ ( -%** $%8(2#* ( '+--#-%*.# 2# ]/+ ( +/-#,+%(f (# ,(**# ]/+ +*'(*+ ,-+#&/,( .(%* . -%** +$S8%* 2# ]/+ (]/+$(?

J#3*#(3'+ 2#&/.+3'#* 2%,$#.`'%* ('R 7` ,#/ *%8%$#*#*f 2%K/$8(2#*,+$( M#$7( 2+ "T# 0(/$#f r R,#&( 2( (,-#K(aT# + 2( -+8/$(.+3'(aT# 2( I+% 2#>9('+f #* Wb> '+-%(. ,-+**%#3(2# .(Em3%(?

H+ ]/($]/+- *#-'+f ,+*+ +.9#-( ( 2%"*:#-* %3&($&/$(9%$%2(2+ 2#* -%** 3(*#&%+2(2+ ('/($f R 2+ .%*'+- -+%+&+- ]/+f 3# 8+-($ 2#* &(*#*f 7` ,(-q.+'-#*

-(&%#3(%* + #94+'%K#* ,(-( ( *+8/-(3a(f ($R. 2+ _2#1$W_#( $(15:#:?$#(1*"f R '(.9R. /. +#2%#:( Q?1+*];%1:*"f +f .# '($f *'%'/% /. :2?1Q( '-( # W*'(2#f 2+*'%3(2# ( ,-#'+8+-#/'-#* '-/3


62/436

;> • $< =:? @2AD9:

“paz social”), limitações mais severas em tempos de anormalidade, de instabi-$%2(2+ 2+.#&-`'%&(f ( *(9+-f 3#* &(*#* 2+ +*'(2# 2+ 2+,R&$>* )" 5$,"$&*@4* [*)" &,'$, %2' "%%d@>$'] %"2% #'A*,"% ;2@)'@&"%] '* >*.='&", 'c2$A* c2">*@&,'#"@:' ' "%%"% ."%.*% #'A*,"%] %*= ["@' )" $-2'A',0%" '*% %"2% $@$.$0-*%? Não se pode manipular o conceito de “ameaça à segurança nacional”>*. * ;$&* )" `2%&$;$>', #",)')"$,'% #$*A'3g"% '*% )$,"$&*% ;2@)'."@&'$%? V+*)'-%ag+* *+K+-(* (#* 2%-+%'#* '0

,R&", 2"&603"3'" )"%%' %2[*%&' -2",,'] $@>*.['&a#"A >*. ' [,/[,$' @'&2,"W')* "%&')* )" %a&$*] &,'@%$&/,$* [*, )";$@$34* j',&S YkV )' 87lVVi?je >&+%'`)$# *+-%(.,(&'/(- . K%#$(ag+* ,+-.(3+3'+* (#* 2%-+%'#* HbV>†Š5f (* 3#-.(* 3+&+**`-%(* ( */( +=+&/aT# + (* 8(-(3'%(* *'%'/&%#3(%* ]/+ficarão suspensas [...].”


63/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ;=

U/.( .,$+=( *#&%+2(2+ 2+ -%* +. *'(3'+ ./'(aT#jcf # 2%-+%'# r*+8/-(3a( -( -+$+K# + (2]/%-+ 3#K#* '#-3#*? Q` 3T# 9(*'( 8(-(3'%- ( $%) 9+-2(2+ %32%K%2/($ '-( # (-91'-%# +*'('($p R 3+&+**`-%# (**+8/-(- ( I@iNf Q? W? J(--+%-(? >aT# &%K%$ ,Z9$%&( + 2%-+%'# 2%"%%*f K? GCjf ,? jF)BCf 4/3? CFFB?

>UHV>HWf Q#*R J(-$#* @%+%-( 2+? K% )$,"$&*% ;2@)'."@&'$% @' 8*@%&$&2$34*[*,&2-2"%' )" Ymno? BŽ +2? J#%.9-(p >$.+2%3(f CFGC?

>LVi>f M+-3(32#? 9A 5",">:* P A' >*@&$@-"@>$' )" A* [*Aa&$>*? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?&+-K(3'+*K%-'/($?.D#9-(D+$)2+-+&7#)[)$()'%38+3&%()2+)$#),#$'%)FD? >&+**# +.p GG .(%? CFGB?

P@iI>f ^/.9+-'#? $*@'A " &"*,$' )'8*@%&$&2$34*? dŽ +2? J#%.9-(p >$.+2%3(f CFFA?

J•YWVLWVV5Vi"N? i3p :%;%,+2%(p L7+ M-++ W3&[&$#,+2%(? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD+3?_%;%,+2%(?#-8D_%;%DJ[9+-'+--#-%*.? >&+**# +.p GG .(%? CFGB?

jc “=#


64/436

;H • $< =:? @2AD9:

Hi 0iWLV5f N(-%( "[$K%( (3+$$(? 0-%3&1,%#* 2( *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( 3# H%-+%'#>2.%3%*'-('%K#? i3p $' [*%%a#"A? BŽ +2? "T#0(/$#p "(-(%K(f Gcdc?

„„„„„„? ?%[">&*% )* 5$,"$&* 8*@%&$&2>$*@'A >*@&".[*,p@"*? AŽ +2? "T# 0(/$#p"(-(%K(f CFGG?

„„„„„„? 82,%* )" 5$,"$&* 8*@%&$&2>$*@'A? AeŽ +2? "T# 0(/$#p "(-(%K(f CFGC?

„„„„„„? K "%&')* )" %a&$* @' 8*@%&$&2$34* =,'%$A"$,' )" Ymqo " @' %$%&".R&$>')'% .")$)'% "\&,'*,)$@R,$'% )" )";"%' )' *,)". >*@%&$&2>$*@'A? L+*+ 2+ $%K-+2#&n3&%( ) M(&/$2(2+ 2+ H%-+%'# 2( b"0f "T# 0(/$#f Gctj?

Xib005Uif L#..(*# M? La sicurezza e le sue “dimensioni” costituzionali?

H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?(&(2+.%(?+2/DGGBteGjdDI(„*%&/-+EE(„+„$+„*/+„2%.+3*%#3%„*'%'/E%#3($%? >&+**# +.p GG .(%? CFGB?

X5NW"f I/%E M$`K%#? H"$ )* '='&"p %3*'%'/&%#3($%2(2+? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD$&+**# +.p GG .(%? CFGB?

IW>If V#8+- "'%+ ,-#,-%+2(2+ .# 2%-+%'# 3'm3%# Y(32+%-( 2+? > +*'(9%$%2(2+ 2#* ('#* (2.%3%*'-('%K#* +( *+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&(f 9#()


65/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ;:

0-#&+**# >2.%3%*'-('%K# 2( b3%T# kI+% 3‰ c?dejDccl? i3p Hi>"f Q#-8+ 2+M%8/+%-+2#w J5"L>f Q#*R 2+ M(-%(w J>U5LiI^5f Q#*R Q#(]/%. X#.+* k5-8*?l?!< JT5J8?E5JS W*'/2#* +. 7#.+3(8+. (# 0-#


66/436


67/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ;E

' 4*P4!"&$c'12* )* +!$P4d+$* 4*P%&$&04$*P'X)' %*X$)'!$")')" P* e-J$&* )' #$*X`P4$' %"f0'X

4*P&!' 4!$'P1'% " ')*X"%4"P&"% !1+23#* +* ,#"-* 9(5:*

4%1#5% !";%#+* +% !1+2*+% '(?$@

!"%2.*U# Y-(*%$f (,+*(- 2(* ./2(3a(* '-(E%2(* ,+$( J#3*'%'/%aT# M+2+-($ 2+ Gcee + ,+$# W*'('/'#

2( J-%(3a( + 2# >2#$+*&+3'+f &-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+* '%3/(. ,-%K(2#* 2+ 2%-+%'#*f 2+*(.,(-()2#* 3# .+%# *#&%($ + */4+%'#* ( '#2( #-2+. 2+ K%#$n3&%(f %3&$/*%K+ ( +=,$#-(aT# *+=/($w # ]/+ +K%)2+3&%( ]/+ ($R. 2# -+%+&%.+3'# 2+ 2%-+%'#* *+


68/436


69/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • ;G

K%#$n3&%( *+=/($f #/ *+4(f GF?ACB &-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+*f *+32# eAfC€ 2# *+=#


70/436

ED • $< =:? @2AD9:

> *#&%+2(2+ 9-(*%$+%-( +$+8+/ ( 2%83%2(2+ 2( ,+**#( 7/.(3(.# /. 2#* ,-%3&1,%#*


71/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • E9

.%3%.%E(- ( %3f CFGFf ,? GGl

V+


72/436

E> • $< =:? @2AD9:

0-%3&1,%# G – > &-%(3a( 8#E(-` '#2#* #* 2%-+%'#* +3/3&%(2#* 3+*'(H+&$(-(aT#? L#2(* (* &-%(3a(*f (9*#$/'(.+3'+ *+. ]/($]/+- +=&+)aT#f *+-T# &-+2#-(* 2+*'+* 2%-+%'#*f *+. 2%*'%3aT# #/ 2%*&-%.%3()aT# ,#- .#'%K# 2+ -(a(f -f *+=#f $138/(f -+$%8%T#f #,%3%T# ,#$1'%&(#/ 2+ #/'-( 3('/-+E(f #-%8+. 3(&%#3($ #/ *#&%($f -%]/+E(f 3(*&%).+3'# #/ ]/($]/+- #/'-( %aT#f ]/+- */( #/ 2+ */( &-%(3a( 8#E(-` ,-#'+aT# *#&%($ + *+-)$7+)T# ,-#,#-)&%#3(2(* #,#-'/3%2(2+* + ,(-'%- 2+**+ '-('(2#f ,(**#/ ( *+- ./. K+- ,#)*%'%K(2#* #* ,-%3&1,%#* 2# .+$7#- %3'+-+**+ 2( &-%(3a(f 2( ,-+


73/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • E=

+=%8%- ,-#'+aT# +*,+&%($ + ,-%#-%2(2+ (9*#$/'(? k0i5@W">Uf CFGFf,? AAel

W. CB 2+ *+'+.9-# 2+ GccFf # Y-(*%$ -('%2#$+*)&+3'+ – WJ>f +. GccFf ,(-( &/%2(- 2#* %3'+-+**+* + (**+8/-(- 2%-+%'#* ( +**(,(-&+$( 2( ,#,/$(aT# + *(8-(- ( 2#/'-%3( 2( ,-#'+aT# %3'+8-($?

> $+8%*$(aT# 9-(*%$+%-( &$(**%l? V+2#$+*&+3'+f (* &-%(3a(* + #* (2#$+*&+3'+* 2# Y-(*%$f(# $(2# 2+ #/'-(* &('+8#-%(* *#&%(%* K/$3+-`K+%* k./$7+-+* + 3+8-#*f ,#- +=+.),$#lf K%K%(. *#&%($.+3'+ *+8-+8(2#*f *#


74/436

EH • $< =:? @2AD9:

> J#3*'%'/%aT# M+2+-($ 2+ Gcee + # WJ> ,#**%9%$%'(-(. “uma ./2(3a(,(-(2%8.`'%&( 3( .(3+%-( 2+ '-('(- ( %3


75/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • E:

>-'? j‰ | 2+K+- 2(


76/436

E; • $< =:? @2AD9:

J-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+f ./$7+-+*f %2#*#* *T# *%2+-(2#* 8-/,#* K/$)3+-`K+%*w %3'+8-(. /. 8-/,#


77/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • EE

2+3'-+ +$+* # 2%-+%'# r *+=/($%2(2+ #/ #* “direitos sexuais”, .# '(.9R. *T#%+&%2#*? "+8/32# W$%2( "R8/%3 kCFGFf ,? G)Clp

> *+=/($%2(2+ %3'+8-( ( ,+-*#3($%2(2+ 7/.(3(? "+/ 2+*+3K#$K%).+3'# 2+,+32+ 2( *('%*I J5ULV> JVi>U†>" W >H5)IW"JWULW"f CFFef ,? CBl

> *+=/($%2(2+ 3T# *+ -+*'-%38+ ( NWUL5 … @i5IUJi> "Wyb>I J5ULV> JVi>U)†>" W >H5IW"JWULW"f CFFef ,? CBl?

> *+=/($%2(2+ '(.9R. R %3


78/436

EF • $< =:? @2AD9:

,-+*+3'+ +. '#2#* #* +*,(a#*f 2+ I HW WUMVWUL>NWUL5 … @i)5IUJi> "Wyb>I J5ULV> JVi>U†>" W >H5IW"JWULW"fCFFef ,? Ctl?

U+**+ '+='#f '+.)*+ #* 2%-+%'#* *+=/(%*f ]/+ #94+'%K(. 8(-(3'%- ( '#2(+ ]/($]/+- ,+**#(f *+. 2%*'%3aT# 2+ ]/($]/+- 3('/-+E(f # +=+-&1&%# 2( *+=/($%)2(2+f $%K-+ 2+ (.+(a(f 2%*&-%.%3(aT#f -%*f K%#$n3&%( #/ +-aT#?kL5VVW"fCFFcl?

5* 2%-+%'#* *+=/(%* (%32( &(-+&+. 2+ /.( -+8/$(.+3'(aT# .(%* &$(-( +2+ /.( ,-#'+aT# %3'+-3(&%#3($ .(%* +*,+&1


79/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • EG

]/+*'T# (**/.+ #/'-( .,$+=%2(2+f 3#'(2(.+3'+ ,#- &%-&/32(- # 2%-+%'# 2+$%9+-2(2+ + ( (/'#3#.%( 3# /*# 2# ,-S,-%# -,#f ]/+f +. -+8-(f *+-T# $%.%'()2#* ,(-( '(%* */4+%'#*? 5/ *+4(f *+32# &-%(3a( #/ (2#$+*&+3'+f ( -+8-( R ]/+ (,-#*'%'/%aT# *+ %2+3'%


80/436

FD • $< =:? @2AD9:

*+. +2/&(aT#f 3( +='-+.( ,#9-+E(w *+. ,+-*,+&'%K( 2+ 2%(* .+$7#-+*? "T# 2+),#%.+3'#* 2%`-%#* 2+ K%#$n3&%( 3T# (,+3(* *+=/($f 2+ (8-+**T# r 2%83%2(2+ 3(.(%* '+3-( %2(2+f 2+ 2+*-+*,+%'#* 2+ 2%-+%'#* .(%* 9`*%*f 2+ 2+*&(*# 2(


81/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • F9

7` /.( -+$(aT# 2+ 2#.%3(aT# +3'-+ +=,$#-(2#- + +=,$#-(2#f ]/+ *+ 9(*+%( 3(K%#$n3&%( %32%K%2/($ ]/+ # .(%* *#$%2(aT# 2(* $%9+-2(2+*


82/436

F> • $< =:? @2AD9:

> JMDee '-#/=+ *%8# #/'-(* ./2(3a(* + '-(3*VIWLf CFFAf CFFj + CFGAlf */4+%'(32#)#*f (**%.f r 2%*&%,$%3( 2+2%&(2( (#* 2%-+%'#*


83/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • F=

2+ */(


84/436

FH • $< =:? @2AD9:

2+K+32# #* '-n* +3'+* -+*,+%'(-f ,-#'+8+- + ,-#.#K+- #* 2%-+%'#* 2+**+ 8-/,#w.# 3( -+*,#3*(9%$%E(aT# ,+$( K%#$(aT# 2+ 2%-+%'#*f #/ *+4(f ]/(32# %3


85/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • F:

%8/($2(2+ 3T# *#


86/436

F; • $< =:? @2AD9:

ii ) ,-#'+aT# %3'+8-($ + ,-%#-%'`-%(p ( %3'+-,-+'(aT# + (,$%&(aT# 2+'#2( + ]/($]/+- 3#-.( '%2( 3+*'( I+% 2+K+ *+- K#$'(2( r ,-#)'+aT# %3'+8-($ + ,-%#-%'`-%( 2#* 2%-+%'#* 2+ ]/+ &-%(3a(* + (2#$+*)&+3'+* *T# '%'/$(-+*w

iii ) ,"%[*@%'=$A$)')" [,$.R,$' " %*A$)R,$' )* [*)", [f=A$>*p (,$+3( +$' )' ;'.aA$'p 3( ,-#.#aT# 2+ 2%-+%'#* + 3( ,-#'+aT#2( &-%(3a( + 2# (2#$+*&+3'+ 2+K+ *+- 2(2( ,-+K($n3&%( r* .+2%2(*]/+ #* .(3'+37(. #/ -+%3'+8-+. 3( */(


87/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • FE

yii ) #%'%K( #9-%8('S-%( + ,(-'%&%,(aT#p ( &-%(3a( + # (2#$+*&+3'+f+. *+,(-(2# #/ 3( .,(37%( 2#* ,(%*f 2+ -+*,#3*`K+$ #/ 2+,+**#( ,#- *% %32%&(2(f 9+. .# #* *+/* ,(%* #/ -+*,#3*`K+$f'n. 2%-+%'# ( *+- #/K%2#* + ( ,(-'%&%,(- 3#* ('#* + 3( 2+U 2# N%3%*'R-%# 2( "(Z2+l? W. CFGAf # H%*]/+ GFFf &(3($ 2("+&-+'(-%( 2+ H%-+%'#* ^/.(3#* 2( 0-+*%2n3&%( 2( V+,Z9$%&(f -+8%*'-#/ ( .R)2%( 2+ ed 2+3Z3&%(* ,#- 2%( 2+ K%#$n3&%( *+=/($ '-( &-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+*?

k"WJVWL>Vi>???f CFGjl? Q` 3# ,-%.+%-# '-%.+*'-+ 2+ CFGBf


88/436

FF • $< =:? @2AD9:

NiUi"LWVi>I 0bXU>UH5 0WI> J5UHWU>†Š5 U5" LWV)N5" H> Wy5VHi>I >Jb">LhVi> ) iN05""iYiIiH>HW )MV>XiIiH>HW 0V5Y>LhVi> ) J5ULV>VV>W" VWJbV)">i" 0IWiLW>UH5 > >Y"5I@i†Š5 HW bN> H>" V|" H>"">U†W" H5 >VL? CCcf H5 JhHiX5 0WU>I ) iU"bY"i"LU)Ji> >VXbNWUL>Li@> ) HWJi"Š5 N5U5JVPLiJ> QbViHi)

J>NWULW iUJWU"bVP@WI ) VWJbV"5 HW"0V5@iH5? o>0W)I>†Š5 ) W"Lb0V5 ) >b"UJi> HW –iU5JUJi>O H>" @‹Li)N>" ) 0VW"bU†Š5 HW @i5IUJi> J5U"L>ULW H> IWLV>–>O H5 >VL? CCj H5 JhHiX5 0WU>I >M>"L>H> ) M>@5VW)JiNWUL5 H> 0V5"LiLbi†Š5 ) >VL? Cjj)> H> IWi e?Ftc ) V|b\bW N>UL|N J5UQbU†Š5 J>VU>I J5N >" @‹LiN>" )>Y"5I@i†Š5? 5


89/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • FG

K%#$n3&%(? [...]’ kLQJW – >0+3 Gcce?FdeCF)t – CŽ J?J-%.? – V+$? H+*?M-(3&%* X%$*#3 @%(3( N(-'%3* – HQJW Ct?j?CFFFl?

‘CRIME J5ULV> 5" J5"LbNW" – W"Lb0V5 – 0VW"bU†Š5HW @i5IUJi> – @‹LiN> NWU5V HW Gj >U5" – >b"UJi>HW ‘INOCENTIA CONSILLI’ 05V 0>VLW H> @‹LiN>f J5UHi)†Š5 W""WUJi>I 0>V> 5 VWJ5U^WJiNWUL5 H> 0VW"bU)†Š5 HW @i5IUJi> \bW | VWI>Li@> – >Y"5I@i†Š5 N>U)LiH> – U#* &(*#* 2+ +*'/,-# . K%#$n3&%( ,-+*/.%2(f 3T# *+2+K+ (,$%&(- ( -+8-( 2( “inocentia consilli” .# (9*#$/'(f ,#-]/+( *%.,$+* "/3aT# &(-3($ . .+3#- 2+ Gj (3#*f ,#- *% *Sf 3T#R */-8/.+3'(aT# 2+ V#9+-' >$+=[f ,-#


90/436

GD • $< =:? @2AD9:

2+ ,#$1'%&(? i**# 3T# R *+- 2+.#&-`'%? 5 &(.,# 2+ ('/(aT# 2# 4/%E 2+K+ *+- 3#-.('%K#? k"LVWJxf CFGB? 0? cBl?

W**+ 2+*K%-'/(.+3'# ,#2+ *+- &$(-(.+3'+ ,+-&+9%2# 3#* 4/$8(2#* (&%.($(&%#3(2#*f +. ]/+ #* .(8%*'-(2#* 2+%=(. 2+ (,$%&(- ( J#3*'%'/%aT# + # JS)2%8# 0+3($f 3#'(2(.+3'+ ( -+8-( &$(-( 2( K%#$n3&%( ,-+*/.%2( ,(-( #* &-%.+*

'-( K1'%.(* .+3#-+* 2+ Gj (3#*f *#9 ,-+'+='#* *#&%(%*f .#-(%* + 2+ 8n3+-#f]/+ -+


91/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • G9

W**( R /.( 2(* -(Eg+* ,+$(* ]/(%* *+ (


92/436

G> • $< =:? @2AD9:

2+K+ 2+%=(- 2+ *+- +3=+-8(2( .# /. '(9/ + ,(**(- ( .,#- #* 2%`$#8#*


93/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • G=

H+**( NiUf >32-R( V#2-%8/+*? WK#$/aT# 7%*'S-%&( 2# 2%-+%'# 2( &-%(3a( + 2#(2#$+*&+3'+? i3p N>JiWIf x`'%( V+8%3( M+--+%-( I#9# >32-(2+ k#-2?l? 82,%*)" )$,"$&* )' >,$'@3' " )* ')*A"%>"@&"p (*,+&'#* '+S-%* + ,-`'%*? t? W2? "T#0(/$#p "(-(%K(f CFGA?

>UHV>HWf H+3%*+ >$.+%2( 2+w V5HViXbW"f Y(-9(-( 2+ "#/*(? @%#$+3&%(*+=/($ + '-(f >32-+%( 2( "%$K( k#-8*?l? 1"@",* " C,';$>* )" M2A:","%S

M$#-%(3#,#$%*p J#3&+%'#f CFGA?Y>VV5"5f I/1* V#9+-'#? ? )$-@$)')" )' ["%%*' :2.'@' @* 5$,"$&*8*@%&$&2>$*@'A >*@&".[*,p@"*p ( *'-/aT# 2+ /. &+%'# 4/-12% r $/E 2( 4/-%*,-/2n3&%( ./32%($? Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+p MS-/.f CFGA?

„„„„„„? U+#*'%'/&%#3($%*.# + *'%'/&%#3($%E(aT# 2# H%-+%'#p # '-%/3VV5"5f I/1* V#9+-'#? K@*#* 5$,"$&* 8*@%&$&2>$*@'A =,'%$A"$,*? Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+p MS-/.f CFGA

Y>bN>Uf %[8./3'? ?.*, Aac2$)*p *#9-+ ( $9+-'# N+2+%-#*? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#f (7(-f CFFj?

Y5U>@iHW"f 0(/$#? C"*,$' >*@%&$&2>$*@'A )' )".*>,'>$' [',&$>$['&$#'p ,#-/. H%-+%'# J#3*'%'/&%#3($ 2+ $/'( + -+*%*'n3&%(f ,#- /.( 3#K( ^+-.+3n/'%&(f,#- /.( -+,#$%'%E(aT# 2( $+8%'%.%2(2+? A? +2? "T# 0(/$#p N($7+%-#*f CFFe?

J>J^>0bf V#E(3+ 2( V#*(? M")$'34* @*% >*@;A$&*% " )$,"$&* )" ;'.aA$'?J/-%'%9(p Q/-/`f CFFj?

J>U5LiI^5f Q? Q? X#.+*? 5$,"$&* 8*@%&$&2>$*@'A " C"*,$' )' 8*@%&$&2$34*?

d? +2? J#%.9-(p >$.+2%3(f GcjG?


94/436

GH • $< =:? @2AD9:

J5NiL U>Ji5U>I HW WUMVWUL>NWUL5 … @i5IUJi> "Wyb>IJ5ULV> JVi>U†>" W >H5IW"JWULW"? YV )" .'$* – J(2+-3# '+.`'%pH%-+%'#* "+=/(%* *T# 2%-+%'#* 7/.(3#*? J#$+'q3+( 2+ '+='#*? Y-(*1$%(p J#.%'nU(&%#3($ 2+ W3"@&"pI+% 3? e?Ftcf 2+ GA 2+ 4/$7# 2+ GccF? "T# 0(/$#p "(-(%K(f CFGF?

MiXbWiVWH5f H($%$(w U5@>W"f N(-%3( N? >*,+&'#* $+8(%* 2# '-`*.",>$'A )" ."@$@*%]."@$@'% " ')*A"%>"@&"% @' ?.b,$>' H'&$@' " 8',$=" – V+$('S-%# f Gccc?

I50W"f >3( N(-%( D’Ávila. K% )$,"$&*% ;2@)'."@&'$% >*.* A$.$&"% '* [*)",)" A"-$%A',? 0#-'# >$+8-+p "+-8%# >3'#3%# M(9-%* W2%'#-f CFFG?

„„„„„„? 5* 2%-+%'#* *+=/(%* + -+,-#2/'%K#* 2(* &-%(3a(* + 2#* (2#$+*&+3'+* 3#q.9%'# 2( +2/&(aT# *+=/($? !"#$%&' E9F – W$+'-m3%&(f K? Gtf 3? Cf ,? GFt)GCFf.(%#D(8#? CFGG?

„„„„„„? H%*&-%.%3(aT# 2+ 8n3+-# '-( (* ./$7+-+* + ( K%#$n3&%( *+=/($? i3p„„„„„„w N>b|"f >3'#3%# N#-+%-( k#-8*?l? ? ";$>R>$' @'>$*@'A " $@&",@'>$*@'A)*% )$,"$&*% :2.'@*%S V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#f I/.+3 Q/-%*f CFGAf ,?GB)Ct?

N>i>f J7-%*'%(33[ H%S8+3+*w @iH>If Q/(3 0(9$# J#$+-(w MV>U†>f :($$(&+M+-3(32+* 2(? J-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+* .# */4+%'#* 2+ 2%-+%'#*? i3p N>i>fJ7-%*'%(33[ H%S8+3+*w >UHV>HWf H+3%*+ >$.+%2( k#-8*?l? 5$,"$&*% :2.'@*%$@ A"-$%p ( &-%(3a( + # (2#$+*&+3'+ .# */4+%'# 2+ 2%-+%'#? M#-'($+E(p M(&/$2(2+J7-%*'/*f CFGF?

N>VL‹UWf X-+8S-%# 0+&+*)Y(-9(? H">>$*@"% )" )",">:*% ;2@)'."@&'A"%?N(2-%2p H[;%*#3f CFFj?

5VX>Ui>†Š5 H>" U>†W" bUiH>"? H+&$(-(aT# b3%K+-*($ 2#* H%-+%'#*2( J-%(3a(? B$=A$*&">' #$,&2'A )" )$,"$&*% :2.'@*% )' 6@$#",%$)')" )" d(D2+&$(-(&(#)2#*)2%-+%'#*)2()&-%(3&(?7'.$? >&+**# +.p GC 3#K? CFGj?

0i5@W">Uf M$`K%(? C".'% )" 5$,"$&*% D2.'@*%? j? +2? "T# 0(/$#p "(-(%K(fCFGF?


95/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • G:

">VIWLf i38# :#$'% )" ,"%[*@%'=$A$)')" %*>$'A >*,[*,'&$#' @*"@;,"@&'."@&* )" #$*A'3g"% )" )$,"$&*% :2.'@*% )" >,$'@3'% " ')*A"%>"@&"%?V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#p L+--( 2#* ^#.+3*f CFGj? H%*,#31K+$ +.p Œ7'',pDD___?*27?8#K?9-D(**/3'#*D9%9$%#'+&(K%-'/($D&-%(3&(*)+)(2#$+*&+3'+*D,/9$%&(+*)CFGjD,2$%4* `2,a)$>'S j? +2? "T# 0(/$#p V+K%*'(2#* L-%9/3(%*f CFGj?

LViUH>HWf W$%(3+? ?% ."@$@'% )' "%c2$@'p 2%`-%#* 2#* *#37#*f 2#-+* +(K+3'/-(* 2+ *+%* (2#$+*&+3'+* 2# Y-(*%$? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#p V+-2f CFFB?

:>iI"WIMi"f Q/$%# Q(#? M'[' )' #$*Ad@>$' XUYXp &-%(3a(* + (2#$+*&+3'+*2# Y-(*%$? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#f CFGC? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?&-%(3&(?2


96/436


97/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • GE

30P12* &!$J0&\!$' " '4$)"P&"% X'J*!'&$#*%_0-' 'P\X$%" )*% 40%&*% &!'P%'4$*P'$%

!1:C1#( D*E#"#( 6"(2#*1# F%:( G@2$#* 9*2"* H%2%#2* '#:'#"L-%9/'(aT#? >&%2+3'+ 2+ '-(9($7#? >3`$%*+ Wm.%&( 2# H%-+%'#? i3'+-K+3aT# 2# W*'(2#?

J/*'#* 2+ '-(3*(aT#?

C?L B6!59E ?E5 NK!O ?88J59EC


98/436

GF • $< =:? @2AD9:

#< '7(' 8#($f '7%* ,(,+- %2+3'%


99/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • GG

Fj ' +!*&"12* %*4$'X P* *!)"P'-"P&* 4*P%&$&04$*P'X J!'%$X"$!*

> J#3*'%'/%aT# 2+ Gcee &-%#/ /. ,-%3&1,%# 2+ ,-#'+aT# *#&%($ ('R +3'T#%3+=%*'+3'+ +. *#$# ,`'-%#f ,(/'(2# 3( /3%K+-*($%2(2+ 2( +-'/-( + 2# ('+3)2%.+3'#f .


100/436

9DD • $< =:? @2AD9:

-+'(* (2Kn. *#.+3'+ 2( 0-+K%2n3&%(f ,#%* ( "(Z2+ *'%'/% /. 2%-+%'# 2+ '#)2#* + 2+K+- 2# W*'(2#Af (# ,(**# ]/+ >**%*'n3&%( *+-` ,-+*'(2( ( ]/+. 2+$(3+&+**%'(-f %32+,+32+3'+.+3'+ 2+ '-%9/%aT#j?

5 (-'%8# GcBf 2( N(83( J(-'(f ,#-'(3'#f ,#2+ *+- *%2+-(2# # -+*,#3)*`K+$ ,#- -(&%#3($%E(- ( (**%*'n3&%( *#&%($ *+-` ,-+*'(2( ( ]/+. 2+$( 3+&+**%'(-f %32+,+32+3'+.+3'+ 2+ )tribuição à seguridade social, e tem por objetivos:”

B J#3


101/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9D9

,-+K%2+3&%`-%( *+- 2( +.,-+*( k(-'? AFf if (f 2( I+% e?CGCDcGl? J#.# *+]/n3)&%( 2( %aT# 2+ *+8/-(2#f # +.,-+8(2# ,#2+-`


102/436

9D> • $< =:? @2AD9:

5--+ ]/+ (# %3KR* 2+ &-%(- .+2%2(* ,-+K+3'%K(*f (/.+3'(- ( Ll R /.( '-%9/%aT# *#&%($ (&(-8# 2( +.,-+*(f %3&%2+3'+ *#9-+ ( $)"@&R,$* )" +,"#"@34* 7?+G b. U#K# 5$7(- "#9-+ ( "(Z2+ 2# L-(9($7(2#-?CFFe? Cjj


103/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9D=

# &S2%8# etGF '+-T# ( .+*.( ($1]/#'( ">Lf 2+ C€f W 2+**%2+-( #* 132%&+* 2+ (&%2+3'($%2(2+f $#&(32# +.*%'/(aT# 2+ %8/($2(2+ +.,-+*(* 2%Wf &(*#

(,+3(* /.( 2(* +.,-+*(* 2+ *+-K%a#* 7#*,%'($(-+* %3K%*'( +. *+8/-(3a( 2#**+/* '-(9($7(2#-+*f .,-+ .(]/%3`-%# .(%* *+8/-#f +]/%,(.+3'#* 2+ ,-#'+)aT# %32%K%2/($ + $+'%K( .(%* +L +. ('R BF€ #/.(4#-`)$(* +. ('R GFF€?

GB “?,&S YUS > ($1]/#'( 2+ '-%9/%aT# 2+ /.f 2#%* #/ '-n* ,#- &+3'#f 2+*'%3(2( (#


104/436

9DH • $< =:? @2AD9:

W*'+ ./$'%,$%&(2#- R 2+'+-.%3(2# ,#- '-n* K(-%`K+%*p k%l ]/(3'%2(2+ 2++3LDV>Lp( (/*n3&%( 2+ -+*,+%'# (# ,-%3&1,%# 2( -+*+-K( $+8($ '-%9/'`-%(f,#%*f ( -+


105/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9D:

tjtj * P5r< &NKM7K< "q7;5?77K< +=567;5MK7[=7< nP&"+o

> I+% GG?jAFDCFFt r I+%e?CGADcG +f . %**#f (/'#-%E(- ( ,+-1&%( .R2%&( 2# iU"" ( -+$(&%#3(- ( +3Wl?Y(*%&(.+3'+f ( f CFFef ,? GFel?

L($ 3+=# (&(9#/ ,#- +='%38/%- ]/($]/+- %3K+*'%8(aT# 'R&3%&( (&+-&( 2+/.( ,#**1K+$ -+$(aT# +3'-+ 2#+3a( + '-(9($7#f 2+ .#2# ]/+ # (&%2+3'+ ,(**#/( *+- W


106/436

9D; • $< =:? @2AD9:

U+*'( +*'+%-(f ,#2+. *+- */*&%'(2#* ]/+*'%#3(.+3'#* *+ # (.9%+3'+ 2+'-(9($7# *'%'/% +@W UWL5f CFFdf,?Gjcl?

>**+3'(2(* +*'(* ,-+.%**(*f &7+8()*+ r* (ag+* -+8-+**%K(*f #/'-# .+&()

3%*.# /'%$%E(2# ,(-( ,-#'+aT# r *(Z2+ 2# '-(9($7(2#-f *+8/32# ( 0-+K%2n3&%("#&%($?

tjkj '8 :Bs58 =5>=58876:8

W*'(* (ag+*f ,-+K%*'(* 3# (-'%8# GCFf 2( I+% e?CGADcGf 'n. .# #94+'#-+**(-&%- #* &+**# +.p FGDFeD CFGj?

CF H%*,#31K+$ +.p Œ7'',pDD___?,-+K%2+3&%(?8#K?9-D.+3/)*(/2+)+)*+8/-(3&()#&/,(&%#3($)3+=#)'+&3%)+,%2+.%#$#8%),-+K%2+3&%(-%#)3'+,D >&+**# +.p FGDFeDCFGj?

CG "+ 3( $+% *'( +=,-+**(.+3'+ ]/+ # &(9%.+3'# *+ 2` +. &(*#* 2+ 3+8$%8n3&%(f 3# *%'+ 2( 0-+)K%2n3&%(f 4` R


107/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9DE

5--+ ]/+f 3( ,-`'%&(f #9*+-K()*+ /.( &$(-( %3'+3aT# ,+&/3%`-%( 3+*'+.+&(3%*.#f ,#%* &+**# +.p FGDFeDCFGj?


108/436

9DF • $< =:? @2AD9:

]/+*'T# +3K#$K+ /. ,-#9$+.( 2+ 3('/-+E( -+&1,-#&(? 0#- '( 2%**#f *#.+3'+( -+.#aT# 2( 2+


109/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9DG

># '-(a(-)*+ /. ,(-($+$# . # ('/($ .#2+$# 9-(*%$+%-# 2+ ,-#'+aT# (#'-(9($7(2#-f ( .+*.( ,+-8/3'( ,(-+&+ +*'(- *+32# **%. *+32#f 2%(3'+ 2+ /. %3


110/436

99D • $< =:? @2AD9:

H+


111/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 999

2%2#* ,(-( --%8%- #* +--#*w k%%%l #* &/*'#* 2+ %3*'($(aT# + 0? i*'# W . ( JiH (,-+*+3'(2(? J#3IW"xi QbUi5Vf ,?GFdl?

UT# ,#- (&(*#f iK# L? X% Q/3%#- kCFGFf ,? GBl 2+* %3*'%'/%ag+*


112/436

99> • $< =:? @2AD9:

.(* 2+ .,#-'(.+3'#f K+3ag+*f &S2%8#* 2+ /'(l? Q/3'(*f +*'(* %3*'%)'/%ag+* 2+*,-%.+%-(*f .# (* -+8-(* 2# 4#8#f (# ,(**# ]/+ (* Z$'%.(* ,#2+. *+- +3'+3)2%2(* .# #* 4#8(2#-+* kU5VL^f Gccjf ,? AtGl?

>*sim sendo, “e. /. '+='# +. ]/+ #* &/*'#* 2+ '-(3*(aT# 3T# *T#2+*,-+E1K+%*f R 3('/-($ ]/+ */-4(. %3*'%'/%ag+* +m.%&(*f *#&%(%* + ,#$1'%&(*

]/+ ,+-.%'(. ( -+2/aT# 2+**+* &/*'#*f 2+ Lf 0 + &-%#/ # ULW0? >2+.(%*f K+. *+ K($+32# 2(* (ag+*-+8-+**%K(* ,(-( #9'+- # -+**(-&%.+3'# 2#* K($#-+* ,(8#* ( '1'/$# 2+ 9+3+


113/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 99=

L-('(.)*+ 2+ .+2%2(* ,-#'+'%K(*f (* ]/(%* (**%. *+32#f &(9+ (# (.9%+3'+ %3*'%'/&%#3($ %32/E%- --+'().+3'+ #* %32%K12/#* ,(-( *+ ('%38%- ( ($.+4(2( +$R. 2%**#f K#3'(2+ +*'('($ +. ,/3%- # &(/*(2#- 2# 2(3# *#9 # ,-+'+='#2+ &-%(- /.( *&%+3'%E(aT# (&+-&( 2#* -%** %3+-+3'+* r ('%K%2(2+ 2( +.)

,-+*(f ,#2+-%( *+- */9*'%'/12( . ( #IYb\bWV\bW)5Ii@WiV>f 0(/$# V#8R-%#? E"\* Cb>@$>* 9[$)".$*A/-$>*+,"#$)"@>$R,$* EC9+ " * 7'&*, ?>$)"@&R,$* )" +,"#"@34* 7?+G 6. E*#*KA:',


114/436

99H • $< =:? @2AD9:

„„„„„„? H"$ @r VSXYk] )" Xq )" `2A:* )" YmmY. H%*,g+ *#9-+ #* 0$(3#* 2+Y+3+*@*.$' @* B,'%$A? "T# 0(/$#p >'$(*p CFGC? ,? Cjt)Ctj?

J5>"Wf V#3($2? C:" +,*=A". *; &:" $'A 8*%&%? Q#/-3($ #< I(_ (32W#.%&* k5&'#9+- GctFl?

J55LWVf V#9+-'w bIIWUf L7#.(*? 5$,"$&* " ">*@*.$'? 0#-'# >$+8-+pY##;.(3f CFGF?

H>@i"f x+K%3 W?w LVWYiIJ5Jxf N%&7(+$ Q? ? ,"A'34* "@&," )$,"$&* "

)"%"@#*A#$."@&*G K&$.$%&'% #",%2% >b&$>*%? "T# 0(/$#p H%-+%'#X@f CFFcf ,?CGd)Cte

H>IIWXV>@W UWL5f Q#*R >$R,$*G %2=$@#"%&$."@&* ".>'[$&'A `2,a)$>* " %*=,"2&$A$W'34* )* F2)$>$R,$*? CFGC? Gjt


115/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 99:

0>"L5VWf Q#*R? > '-%9/'(aT# 2# '-(9($7# 3# Y-(*%$? d1p N>VLiU"f iK+* X(32-(2( "%$K( kJ##-2?l? K &,$=2&*G ,";A"\4* .2A&$)$%>$[A$@', %*=," %2' @'&2,"W'S V%#2+ Q(3+%-#p M#-+3*+f CFFd? ,? AAG)Ajj?

ViYWiV5f N(-&%( J(-$( 0+-+%-(? V(&%#3($%2(2+ $%.%'(2(? d1p „„„„„„w xIWiUf@%3%&%/* kJ##-2?l? K c2" b '@RA$%" ">*@s.$>' )* )$,"$&*p /.( %3'-#2/aT#? Y+$#

^#-%E#3'+p MS-/.f CFGG? ,? tA)tc?„„„„„„w X>IW"xi QbUi5Vf i-%3+/? C"*,$' -",'A )*% >*@&,'&*%G >*@&,'&*%".[,"%',$'$% " '@RA$%" ">*@s.$>'? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#p W$*+K%+-f CFFc?

"J^5bWVif I/1* W2/(-2#? "+8/-(3a( 4/-12%&( + 3#-.(* '-%9/'`-%(* %32/'#-(*?d1p ViYWVi5f N(-%( 2+ M`'%.( kJ##-2?l? 5$,"$&* C,$=2&R,$* " %"-2,'@3' `2,a)$>'? "T# 0(/$#p N0 W2?f CFFe? ,? GGd)GjB

:iIIi>N"5Uf 5$%K+-? ?% $@%&$&2$3g"% ">*@s.$>'% )* >'[$&'A$%.*? "T# 0(/$#p

0+Ef CFGG?^ !">"=$)* ". UX )"WS XUYZS


116/436


117/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 99E

' 3X"f$J$X$c'12* )* )$!"$&* )* &!'J'XQ*4*-* $P%&!0-"P&* )" )"%"P#*X#$-"P&*

"4*Pg-$4* "- 4*P3X$&* 4*- * +!$P4d+$* )'#")'12* )* !"&!*4"%%* %*4$'X

!2#(1 !?J?5:( F*2+%""( F*5#)J#" 62*1$#5$( 9*2"(5 4?*2:%

!"%2.*J#.#


118/436

99F • $< =:? @2AD9:

CD9 7H9LJBJHJt?CJKE K7 H?BK! H?N ?< ?E JE


119/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 99G

#/ *+4(f *+ ( -+2/aT# 2#* 2%-+%'#* *#&%(%* '-(9($7%*'(* ,#2+ – $+8($ + *'%'/&%)#3($.+3'+ – *+- (,$%&(2(f +*,+&%($.+3'+ 2(


120/436

9>D • $< =:? @2AD9:

%31&%# r /.( +-( 2+ $/'(*f .(/-% N(*&(-# U(*&%.+3'#f &+%'/(32# (


121/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9>9

'-(9($7%*'(* *T# -18%2(*f + ,#- '(%* ]/+*'g+*f -+3/3&%(.)*+ 2%-+%'#* ,(-( */*'+3)'(- ( -+$(aT# $(9#-($ k@>"J5UJWI5"f CFGjl?

>]/+$+* ]/+ 2+


122/436

9>> • $< =:? @2AD9:

3+8#&%(ag+* ]/+ 3T# $+K+. +. *%2+-(aT# (* K+-2(2+%-(* 3+)&+**%2(2+* + #* -+(%* 2%-+%'#* 2# '-(9($7(2#-? kxViWXWV + ^>")"5Uf CFGjl

5* .9('+3'+* 2(


123/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9>=

$/&-# 2(* +.,-+*(* &-+*a(. K++.+3'+.+3'+f .(=%.%E(32# ( +#.%(? H+#/'-( 9(32(f +*'/2%#*#* *T# %3&%*%K#* (# (&+**(2# +.p AF 4/$?f CFGj?

C “[...] important measures to increase wage bargaining flexibility and reduce excessive employ-ment protection […].”

A Vb""5f V#2-%8#? W/-#,( .+=+ 3( $+% '-(9($7%*'( '-( &-%*+? 7*A:' )"


124/436

9>H • $< =:? @2AD9:

,+2%.+3'#* +. .(**( *#9 (-8/.+3'#* +m.%*


125/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9>:

5/'-# -+$('S-%# não menos importante, o “Trade and Development Re-port, 2012”, expedido pela Conferência das Nações Unidas para o Comércio eH+*+3K#$K%.+3'# – bUJL>Hf '(.9R. (-8/.+3'( ]/+ # ,(-(2%8.( 2(


126/436

9>; • $< =:? @2AD9:

(,+3(* U5LiI^5f CFFGl> %2R%( (]/% +=,-+**( '(.9R. '+. *%2# 2+*%83(2( .# ,-#%9%)ção de “contrarrevolução social” ou da “evolução reaccionária”.J#. %*'# ]/+- 2%E+-)*+ ]/+ #* 2%-+%'#* *#&%(%* + +m.%* k+=?p2%-+%'#* 2#* '-(9($7(2#-+*f 2%-+%'# r (**%*'n3&%(f 2%-+%'# r +2/&()aT#lf /.( K+E ($&(3a(2#* #/ ]/%*'(2#*f ,(**(. ( *'%'/%-f*%./$'(3+(.+3'+ /.( 8(-(3'%( %3*'%'/&%#3($ + /. 2%-+%'# */94+&)'%K#? H+*'(


127/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9>E

K+2(aT# 2# -+'-#&+**# *#&%($ (,(-+&+ .# ,-#'+'#- 2+*'+* 2%-+%'#*f *+-K%32#.# *+/ 3Z&$+# *#&%($f 9+. .# %3&+3'%K(2#- + -+8/$(2#- 2(* %3#K(ag+* $+)8%*$('%K(*f 2+'+-.%3(32# .# %3*'%'/&%#3(%* ]/(%*]/+- .+2%2(* +*'('(%*]/+f *+. ( 2+K%2( .,+3*(aT#f K+37(. ( (3/$(-f -+K#8(- #/ (3%]/%$(- +**+3Z&$+# *#&%($ kJ>U5LiI^5f CFFCl?

U+*'+ *+3'%2#f '+.)*+ ]/+ #* 2%-+%'#* *#&%(%* ,#**/+. ( &(-(&'+-1*'%&( 2(,-#8-+**%K%2(2+? 5/ *+4(f */(* ($'+-(ag+* . %3'/%'# 2+ (2(,'(- ( *#&%+2(2+r* --%]/+%-(* ./'(ag+* +m.%&(* + *#&%(%* *T# ,+-.%'%2(*f .(* *+.,-+ .# +*,# 2+ ,-#8-+**T#f %*'# Rf 2+*2+ ]/+ '(%* ($'+-(ag+* %.,$%]/+. +. (&-R*)&%.#* r &(-8( 2+


128/436

9>F • $< =:? @2AD9:

f CFFel?

> N%3%*'-( J`-.+3 IZ&%( '(.9R. 2+


129/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9>G

VW"f CFGGl? >**%.f 3+&+**`-%# *+


130/436

9=D • $< =:? @2AD9:

H+


131/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9=9

edC 2( JIL ]/+ 3T# ,-+Kn +=+&/aT# 2+ 3#-.(* $+'%K(*f .(*f*%.f (aT# 2+ &/.,-%.+3'#? "#9 #/'-# (*,+&'#f *(9+.#* ]/+f +.8+-($f (* 3#-.(* $+'%K(* 'n. K%8n3&%( $%.%'(2( (# ,+-1#2# +.]/+ +*'(9+$+&%2(*? U# +3'(3'#f +. .('R-%( 2+ 2%-+%'#* \bW"f CFGFf ,?tGl

>**%.f ./%'# +.9#-( ( $%9+-2(2+ *%32%&($ 8(-(3'%2( ,+$# '+='# *'%'/)&%#3($f *S *+-T# -+,/'(2(* .# K`$%2(* (* 3#-.(* $+'%K(* 2# '-(9($7# *+ +*)'(*


132/436

9=> • $< =:? @2AD9:

+*'( ,-+K($+&+-`f 3T# %.,#-'(32# # H>"f CFFdf ,?C)Al

W3'-+'(3'#f R &+-'# ]/+ 3T# *+ ,#2+ (,$%&(- # ,-%3&1,%# 2( K+2(aT# 2#-+'-#&+**# *#&%($ 2+ .(3+%-( (9*#$/'(f %.,+2%32# ]/+ ]/($]/+- ($'+-(aT# $+)8%*$('%K( ]/+ -+'%-+ 2%-+%'#* '-(9($7%*'(* *+4( K($%2(2(? 5 ./32# +*'` +. ,$+3(8$#9($%E(aT# + # H%-+%'# ,-+&%*( *+ (2+]/(- r +$(? UT# *T# '#2(* (* 3#-.(* '-() 9($7%*'(* &-%(2(*f ,#- +=+.,$#f . ( J#3*#$%2(aT# 2(* I+%* 2# L-(9($7# 2+GcjA ]/+ (%32( 7#4+ *+ (2+]/(. . ,+-


133/436


134/436

9=H • $< =:? @2AD9:

H+*'(-'+f R 3+&+**`-%# ]/+ # H%-+%'# – %3&$/*%K+ # $(9#-($ – *+ (2+]/+ r-+($%2(2+? > 8$#9($%E(aT# + (* *'(3'+* .#2%


135/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9=:

(&+%'(- # (**#$(.+3'# 2( 2%83%2(2+ 2( ,+**#( 7/.(3( – ('-(KR* 2( 2+*'-/%aT#2+ 2%-+%'#* *#&%(%* – ,+$# *%.,$+* 2%*&/-*# 2( 3+&+**%2(2+ 2+ &-+*&%.+3'# +)3m.%f *+. ]/+ %**# *+4( 8(-(3'%2# 3( ,-`'%&(?

> ('/($ 7+-.+3n/'%&( 2+'+-.%3( ( ,-#8-+**%K%2(2+ 2( ,-#'+aT# r ,+**#(7/.(3( +. 3( 0(/$( 2+? ? ";$>R>$' `2,a)$>' )*% [,$@>a[$*%>*@%&$&2>$*@'$%p # ,-%3&1,%# 2( 2%83%2(2+ 2( ,+**#( 7/.(3(? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#pV+3#K(-f CFFC?

„„„„„„w Y>VV5"5f I/1* V#9+-'#? 5 .+a# 2( 7%*'S-%(p ( 3#K( %3'+-,-+'(aT#*'%'/&%#3($ + # ,(,+$ 2#* ,-%3&1,%#* 3# 2%-+%'# 9-(*%$+%-#? i3p Y>VV5"5fI/1* V#9+-'# k5-8?l? ? @*#' $@&",[,"&'34* >*@%&$&2>$*@'A? A? +2? Y-(*1$%(pV+3#K(-f CFFe?

Y>VV5"f "/E(3( 2+ L#$+2#? K [,$@>a[$* )' [,*[*,>$*@'A$)')" " * >*@&,*A")" >*@%&$&2>$*@'A$)')" )'% A"$% ,"%&,$&$#'% )" )$,"$&*% ;2@)'."@&'$%? Y-(*1$%(p

W2%'#-( Y-(*1$%( Q/-12%&(f CFFA?Y5UU>f >$%3+ 0(/$(? > @+2(aT# 2# V+'-#&+**# "#&%($ .# I%.%'+ rM$+=%9%$%E(aT# 2(* U#-.(* L-(9($7%*'(* Y-(*%$+%-(*? V+K%*'( 2# L-%9/3($V+8%#3($ 2# L-(9($7# 2( AŽ V+8%T#f Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+f K? jdf 3? ddf 4(3?D4/3? CFFe?

J>U5LiI^5f Q#*R Q#(]/%. X#.+*? 8*@%&$&2$34* )$,$-"@&" " #$@>2A'34* )*A"-$%A')*,p '-%9/'# ,(-( ( .,-++3*T# 2(* 3#-.(* *'%'/&%#3(%*,-#8-(.`'%&(*? C? +2? J#%.9-(p J#%.9-( W2%'#-(f CFFG?

„„„„„„? 5$,"$&* >*@%&$&2>$*@'A " &"*,$' )' >*@%&$&2$34*? B? +2? J#%.9-(p

>$.+2%3(f CFFC?„„„„„„? 5$,"$&* >*@%&$&2>$*@'A? B? +2?f J#%.9-(p >$.+2%3(f GccB?


136/436

9=; • $< =:? @2AD9:

H>IIWXV>@W UWL5f Q#*R >*@s.$>'? V+K%*'( J#3*/$'#- Q/-12%f A 4/3? CFFc? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?"/-?.?9-DCFFc)4/3)FAD2+*(Y>I^5?,2""5Uf V#$(32? K 5$,"$&* )* C,'='A:* ".&".[*% )" >,$%"? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?(92%-?.?9-D2#/'-%3(DK+-?(*,~(-'„%2—CFjt˜&('+8#-%(—>-9%'-(8+.?

IW>If V#8+- "'%+R>$' )*% )$,"$&*% %*>$'$%? "($K(2#-p Q/*0#2%/.f CFFe?

NWiVWIW"f W2%$'#3? 0-%3&1,%# 2# 3T#)-+'-#&+**# *#&%($ 3# 2%-+%'# 2# '-(9($7#?!"#$%&' $+8-+f K? GBf 3? Gdcf CFFj?


137/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9=E

NWI5f X+-($2# N(8+$(? > K+2(aT# (# -+'-#&+**# + # H%-+%'# 2# L-(9($7#?!"#$%&' )* C,$=2@'A !"-$*@'A )* C,'='A:* )' kv !"-$4*f Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+f K?BCf 3? eCf 4/$?D2+E? CFGF?

NbV>H>"f H(3%+$(? 8*@&,$=2&* '* 5$,"$&* J@&",@'>$*@'A )* C,'='A:*G ',"%",#' $.[Aa>$&' '* ,"&,*>"%%* %*>$*`2,a)$>* )* &,'='A:')*, @'% >*@#"@3g"%

)' K,-'@$W'34* J@&",@'>$*@'A )* C,'='A:*? CFFdf AcC,? L+*+ kH#/'#-(2#l )b3%K+-*%2(2+ M+2+-($ 2+ N%3(* X+-(%*f M(&/$2(2+ 2+ H%-+%'#f Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+?

U>"JiNWUL5f >.(/-% N(*&(-#? J@$>$'34* '* 5$,"$&* )* C,'='A:*? Cc? +2?"T# 0(/$#p IL-f CFFA?

0bYIiJ "WV@iJW WbV50W? 96 M".=", 3'/3+*? 5 ,-%3&1,%# 2( 2%83%2(2+ 2( ,+**#( 7/.(3(+ ( +=&$/*T# *#&%($? !"#$%&' J@&","%%" +f=A$>*f Y+$# ^#-%E#3'+f K? Gf 3? jf #/'?Gccc?

Vb""5f V#2-%8#? 92,*[' ."\" @' A"$ &,'='A:$%&' >*@&,' >,$%"? M#$7( 2+ "?0(/$#f J(2+-3# N/32#f FG (9-? CFGC?

">VIWLf i38# :#$R>$' )* 5$,"$&* 72@)'."@&'A h VW"f V%&(-2# N(/-1&%# M-+%'(*? ? #")'34* '* ,"&,*>"%%* %*>$'A? H%*,#31K+$+.pŒ7'',pDD___?9(7%(3#'%&%(*?.?9-DCFGGD%.,-%.+?,7,~'(9+$(—4/*'%&(„(-'%8#*˜—tC?

"5bL5 N>i5Vf Q#-8+ I/%E? K )$,"$&* )* &,'='A:* >*.* $@%&,2."@&* )" `2%&$3' %*>$'A? "T# 0(/$#p IL-f CFFF?

"LVWJxf In3%# I/%E? D",."@d2&$>' `2,a)$>' "j.i >,$%"p /.( +=,$#-(aT#7+-.+3n/'%&( 2( *'-/aT# 2# H%-+%'#? j? +2? -+K? ('/($? 0#-'# >$+8-+p I%K-(-%(2# >2K#8(2#f CFFA?

bUi0? +,*;"%%*, )' 6@$#",%$)')" )" 8*$.=,' ;'A' %*=," ' >,$%" )* &,'='A:*@' 92,*['? CA .(%? CFGA? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?/3%,+?9-D8-(2/(&(#D.(-;+'%38D3#'%&%(DCFGADFBDCAD,-#


138/436

9=F • $< =:? @2AD9:

@>"J5UJWI5"f @(83+- N#-`*? 7A"\$=$A$W'34* )'% E*,.'% C,'='A:$%&'%G6. ?#'@3* E">"%%R,$* *2 2. !"&,*>"%%* $'Awf CC 4/$? CFGF? H%*,#31K+$ +.pŒ7'',pDD___?4/-%*_([?#-8?9-DKCD27($$?(*,~%2„27—jAdd?

^ !">"=$)* ". Un `'@S XUYZS


139/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9=G

P*&'% %*J!" * +'+"X )' '0&*P*-$' +!$#')' P*"f"!4d4$* )" %$&0'1h"% V0!d)$4'% )" P'&0!"c' !"'X

K+?*2+( F?1%5 +% ,(?E*

!"%2.*5 ,-%3&1,%# 2( (/'#3#.%( ,-%K(2( 2+*+3K#$K+/)*+ 7%*'#-%&(.+3'+ 3# q.9%'# 2( *+(-(

'-('/($f (:'#"H%-+%'#* -+(%*? >/'#3#.%( ,-%K(2(? Y#()&L7+ ,-%3&%,$+ #< ,-%K('+ (/'#3#.[ 7(* 9++3 7%*'#-%&($$[ 2+K+$#,+2 %3 '7+ *,7+-+ #< )

'-(&' $(_f (_([ **+**#- 4/-12% 4/3'#(# L-%9/3($ 2+ Q/*'%a( 2# W*'(2# 2# V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#?


140/436

9HD • $< =:? @2AD9:

3# 4/$8(.+3'#f ,+$# "/,+-%#- L-%9/3($ 2+ Q/*'%a(f 2# V+&/-*# W*,+&%($ 3?G?GCj?BFtDVQ?G 5 &(*# +3K#$K%( # +=+-&1&%# 2+ /.( *+-K%2T# 2+ `8/(*f ,#- 32-%87%f ,-#),m* /.( (9#-2(8+. %3#K(2#-( ,(-( ( ]/+*'T#f (


141/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9H9

7#3#-`-%#* (2K#&('1&%#*


142/436

9H> • $< =:? @2AD9:

JS2%8# J%K%$fB ( $%9+-2(2+ 2+ ('/(aT# 2#* ,(-'%&/$(-+* ,(-(f . # ,#2+- k4/-%)2%&(.+3'+ -+%+&%2#l 2+ */( K#3'(2+f 3+8#&%(-+. *+/* 9+3* + 2+.(%* %3'+)-+**+* *+.,-+ *'%'/%/ ( #/'-( NWxf N(-&/* @%+%-( K#3 kJ##-2?l? X%;*5 +% +#2%#:( %;_2%]5*2#*"? "T# 0(/$#p N($7+%-#*f CFGjf ,? AGdl?

e A criação desta nova dicotomia é propugnada por Gustavo TEPEDINO: “a dignidade da pessoa7/.(3( %.,g+ '-(3*


143/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9H=

K($#-+* 9(*'(3'+ 2%*'%3'#* 2( $%9+-2(2+ 2+ +=+-&1&%# 2#* *+8/32#*l?c | ( +**($%9+-2(2+f -#$`-%#


144/436

9HH • $< =:? @2AD9:

3(32#)*+ ]/(*+ *+.,-+ (# &(.,# 2(* #9-%8(ag+*? W**+ /*# ,-+2#.%3(3'+).+3'+ *+'#-%($ 2+ 3#aT# 'T# -+$+K(3'+ ,(-( # 2%-+%'# ,-%K(2# .# /. '#2#,(-+&+ 2+--+- 2# *#.('S-%# 2+ ($8/3*


145/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9H:

,+$ 2( K#3'(2+ %32%K%2/($ 3( ('-%9/%aT# 2+ +


146/436

9H; • $< =:? @2AD9:

(%32( 3#* #%'+3'( (-'%8#* 2%*,+3*(2#* ,+$# %


147/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9HE

2# '-('#f +=%8%32#)*+ (%32( ( '-(2%aT# #/ # -+8%*'-#?Cj > /*/&(,%T#f #/'-(.#2($%2(2+ 2+ (]/%*%aT# 2( ,-#,-%+2(2+f '(.,#/ -+K+*'+ ( ,(-+3'+.+3'+f ( 2%*&%,$%3( +. 1?;%2?5 $"*?5?5 2#* 2%-+%'#* -+(%*f '(3'#]/(3'# r */( *'%'/%aT# ]/(3'# (# *+/ '+Z2#f (2.%'+.)*+f ,#- +=+.),$#f #9-%8(ag+* . +


148/436

9HF • $< =:? @2AD9:

2%-+%'#* -+(%* 3T# 2+--+. ,-+&%,/(.+3'+ 2+ */( '(=('%K%2(2+ + '%,%&%2(2+f.(* ./%'# .(%* 2+ */( ,/9$%&%2(2+?Cc i**# '+. ,+-.%'%2# ('R .+*.# ( (2.%*)*T# 2+ 2%-+%'#* -+(%* ('1,%*f '(%* .# ( ./$'%,-#,-%+2(2+ %.#9%$%`-%(AF #/ #*&7(.(2#* #.13%#* 2+ 2%**#&%(aT# +3'-+ 2%-+%'#* -+(%* +

(/'#3#.%( ,-%K(2( %83#-( (# .+3#* 2#%* (*,+&'#* VUWIbLLif (# 2%*'%38/%- #* 2%-+%'#* -+(%* 2#* #9-%8(&%#3(%*f +=,$%&(K( ]/+ 3+*'+**#9-+**(1( ( *%'/(aT# ,(**%K(f (# ,(**# ]/+ 3#* 2%-+%'#* -+(%* # ,(,+$ ,-+2#.%3(3'+ +-( # 2(posição ativa, pois “frente ao #?5 ‡#1 2%ˆ 3T# 7` /.( #9-%8(aT#f .(* /.( */4+%aT#f *%'/(aT# 9+.menos visível que a obrigação”; rematava, porém: “a obrigação só mais tarde surgirá, no mo-.+3'# +. ]/+ # #?5 . # #?55?;


149/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9HG

2#* %3'+-+**(2#*?AA G?:*:#5 ;?:*1+#5f '-('()*+ 2+ /. +=+-&1&%# ]/+ ,#/ *+ 2%*)'(3&%( 2( $%9+-2(2+ ,(-( .#2%


150/436

9:D • $< =:? @2AD9:

,(-( # +=+-&1&%# 2# 2%-+%'# --+*,+&'%K#?At > ,-#=%.%2(2+ . #* 2%-+%'#* 2+&-R2%'# -+*/$'( +K%2+3'+pAd 2+


151/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9:9

8-(* + ,-%3&1,%#* 2+**( `-+( 2# 2%-+%'# &%K%$ ]/+ ,(**(. ( f J$SK%* 2# J#/'# +? ! (


152/436

9:> • $< =:? @2AD9:

M#% # ]/+ -+%+&+/ # "LQf


153/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9:=

>*


154/436

9:H • $< =:? @2AD9:

+='%3aT# 2# 2%-+%'# -+($ 3# .#.+3'# +. ]/+ #* '%'/$(-+* 2# 2%-+%'# ,/2+**+.#9'+- `8/( 2+ #/'-# .#2#? J#.# *+ *(9+f *($K# 3# &(*# 2+ 2+*(,-#,-%(aT#f (**+-K%2g+* $+K(2(* ( -+8%*'-# (,+3(* *+ +='%38/+. 2#/'-%3(f ,#-R.f (.,$%(K( '($ ,-+K%*T#? 0#-'#2#*f K? W"0‹U5I>f W2/(-2#? M5 +#2%#:(5 2%*#5 "#;#:*+(5 (? +#2%#:(5 5(


155/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9::

2#* 2%-+%'#* -+(%*BA – + .+*.# ('/($.+3'+f r $/E 2# ,-%3&1,%# 2( &(*( ,#2+ ,+-.(3+&+-


156/436

9:; • $< =:? @2AD9:

"+-%( '+#-%&(.+3'+ ,#**1K+$f 2+ #/'-( ,(-'+f ($+8(- 5?__2%55#(f /.( (,$%)&(aT# 2( 9#()


157/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9:E

+ -+*'-%aT# (# +=+-&1&%# (9/*%K# 2+ 2%-+%'#*? J#3&$/%/)*+f 3# &(*#f ,+$( %.,#*)*%9%$%2(2+ 2+ -+'#.(2( 2( `-+( ./. ,+$# #.13%#f *($K# *+ ($8/.( ./)2(3a( 3(* &%-&/3*'q3&%(* 4/*'%


158/436

9:F • $< =:? @2AD9:

.+3'(f 2+ #/'-( ,(-'+f ( ,-+*&-%aT# +='%3'%K(l? W. *+2+ 2+ 2%-+%'#* -+(%*f ( )*+]/n3&%( 2# 3T# +=+-&1&%# *+-`f ]/(32# 7#/K+-f ( ,-+*&-%aT# (]/%*%'%K(tA – *+]/n3&%(f ,#-'(3'#f 3# &(.,# ,#**+**S-%#f *(3&%#3(32#)*+ ( %3R-&%( 2#'%'/$(- 2# 2%-+%'# ]/+ '(-2( +. 2+%32( (**%.f 3+8()*+ r ./3%2(2+ 2+ m.%3#* ( -+'#.(2( 2( `-+( )./. ,#- *%.,$+* '-#$+ K($#-('%K# 2# +=+-&1&%# 2( ,-#,-%+2(2+ r $/E 2( 9#()


159/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9:G

2+%=#/ 2+ -(- '(=( #.%3%($ ( /.( /3%2(2+ (/'m3#.(? J#.,-++32+/)*+ ]/+ +**( ('%'/2+ -+*/$'#/ +. ,-+--#8('%K( ,(-( # '%'/$(- 2( /3%2(2+f ]/+ *+'-(3*.%'%( ('R .+*.# (# 3#K# (2]/%-+3'+ 2+*'(?tt 5/'-( -+$+K(3'+ ,$%&(aT# 2Z,$%&+ 2( -+*,+%'#f K? '(.9R. "J^VWiYWVf >32+-*#3? !_2(#


160/436

9;D • $< =:? @2AD9:

Q/*'%a( 2+ "T# 0(/$# 3# ]/($ *+ ,-+'+32%( ( +='%3aT# 2+ /*/


161/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9;9

>* ,#**%9%$%2(2+* *T# %3'`K+%*f 9(*'(32# ,(-( '(3'# *%2+-(- ]/+ ( 9#() -+*,+%'# 2# '('# *#&%($f $+&%#3( Q/2%'7 N>VLiU")COSTA, “o contato social obedece a uma%3+*8#'`K+$ ./$'%,$%&%2(2+ 2+ '%,#*f 2+


162/436

9;> • $< =:? @2AD9:

,#*%'%K#*l '(.9R. +. .('R-%( 2+ 2%-+%'#* -+(%*f '+32n3&%( ]/+ *+ *#$%2( 3( 4/-%*,-/2n3&%( 9-(*%$+%-(?

H+3'-+ (* '-n* "JWU"Š5f Q#*R 2+ 5$%K+%-(? ? &$[$>$)')" )*% )$,"$&*% ,"'$%? I%*9#(p N%3+-K(fGcte?

YWLLif W.%$%#? C"*,$' -"@",'A" )"A @"-*W$* -$2,$)$>*S U(,#$%p W"if Gccj?J>VUWIbLLif M-(3&+*? C"*,$' -",'A )* )$,"$&*f "T# 0(/$#p "(-(%K(f GcjC?

J>LWViUif W3-%? JA [,$@>$[$* )$ A"-'A$&h @"$ ,'[[*,&$ ,"'A$? U(,#$%p W"if Gcce?

J5N05VLif N(-? 5$,$&&$ ,"'A$ $@ -"@",'A"? i3 JiJbf >3'#3%# + NW""iUW5fM-(3&+*? C,'&&'&* )$ )$,$&&* >$#$A" " >*..",>$'A"? @#$/.+ iiif '#.# G?N%$(3#p X%/f W2/(-2#? K% )$,"$&*% ,"'$% A$.$&')*% *2 )$,"$&*% %*=," ' >*$%''A:"$' " *% )$,"$&*% ,"'$% )" -','@&$' @* )$,"$&* >$#$A =,'%$A"$,*? V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#pJ#3]/%*'(f GcBe?

Xi5VXi>UUif N%&7+$+? “H%-%''% -+($% k2%-%''# &%K%$+l”? E*#$%%$.* 5$-"%&*

J&'A$'@*? @#$/.+ @? L#-%3#p bLWLf GctF?N>VLiU")J5"L>f Q/2%'7? ? =*'0;b @* )$,"$&* [,$#')*? "T# 0(/$#p V+K%*'( 2#*L-%9/3(%*f Gccc?


163/436

"#$%&'( )* +,*-,(.( )# +/&01,()2(34* #. 5%,#%'* )( 678 • 9;=

NiV>UH>f M?J? 0#3'+* 2+? C,'&')* )" )$,"$&* [,$#')*? L#.# ii? "T# 0(/$#pV+K%*'( 2#* L-%9/3(%*f CFGC?

N5V>W"f N(-%( J+$%3( Y#2%3 2+? >.,$%(32# #* 2%-+%'#* 2( ,+-*#3($%2(2+? i3@iWiV>f Q#*R V%9(* k5-8?lf XU '@*% )' 8*@%&$&2$34* 8$)')4 )" YmVVf V%# 2+ Q(3+%-#p M#-+3*+f CFFe?

„„„„„„? 5 ,-%3&1,%# 2( 2%83%2(2+ 2( ,+**#( 7/.(3(? E' .")$)

nomos - as formas da sociologia do direito

Documents