non profit accounting and financial reporting update...non profit accounting and financial reporting...
TRANSCRIPT
John R. Null Audit Shareholder
Non profit Accounting and Financial Reporting Update
Financial Statements of Not-for-Profit Entities
Disclosure Framework
Simplification Initiative
Private Company Council (PCC)
Leases
Revenue Recognition
Government Assistance Disclosures
Agenda
2
• Net asset classification • Liquidity, financial performance and
cash flows Standards
• Study communications other than f/s that NFPs use to tell their “story”
(removed from agenda 1/29/14) Research
NFP Financial Reporting Initiative
4
Net asset classification
Financial Performance
Reporting of Expenses
Cash Flow Statement Liquidity NFP Note
Disclosures
Financial Statements of Not-for-Profit Entities: Topics
5
Project Timeline – Steps To-Date
NAC Recommendations
Sept. 2011
Nov. 2011
Project Added to FASB Agenda
Project Planning / Board Education /
Initial Outreach
2012
Early 2013
Deliberations Begin
Meeting with NACUBO APC on
“Blank Slate” Project
April 2013
2013 – Early 2014
Board
Deliberations Continue
Meeting with HFMA
April 2014
6
Project Resource Group Consultation
Net Assets - Issues UPMIFA and PRNA/TRNA distinction
- Ability to spend from donor-restricted endowments even if underwater
- Board action required to appropriate investment returns for spending
TRNA considered by many to be “Hodgepodge” - Need for better disclosure of the nature and availability (timing)
of donor restricted resources
URNA open to misinterpretation - Better disclosure surrounding availability/liquidity would be
helpful, including limits imposed by an entity’s governing board 7
Net Assets – Two Approaches
8
Approach 1 – Restrictions as primary cut
Without Restrictions
Operating Endowment Plant
Approach 2 – Purpose as primary cut
Operating Without
restrictions With restrictions
With Restrictions
Operating Endowment Plant
Endowment Without
restrictions With restrictions
Plant Without
restrictions With restrictions
Net Assets Can we streamline and make more meaningful?
Unrestricted Temp. Restricted
Perm. Restricted
Without Donor Restrictions With Donor Restrictions
Amount and purpose of board
designations Nature and amount
of donor restrictions
Current GAAP
Proposed GAAP
Disclosures
+
9
Financial Performance: Operating Measure – Current Landscape
Required operating measure
Health Care
Higher Ed.
X Other NFPs
(FAS 117)
Yes No C
ompa
rabi
lity
Gre
ater
Le
sser
10
Financial Performance: Operating Measure – Approaches Rejected
Recurring / Non-recurring
Large or Unusual
“Beyond management’s control”
11
Financial Performance: Operating Measure
12
Defined a required intermediate operating measure—based on two dimensions:
Mission (Business and Charitable Activity)
Availability
Require display of all available revenues separate and before board designations that make
any resources unavailable
(show gross instead of net)
Remove requirement to display an operating measure, if
reported, in same statement that reports the change in
unrestricted net assets
(ASC 958-225-45-10)
Additional Outreach: • Health care • Community and private foundations
Financial Performance: Operating Measure
13
Financial Performance: Statement Approach
14
1 Statement
Ability to present total revenue and contributions
Effect of transfers easier to identify
Too much information in one statement
Labeling of totals difficult
2 Statement
Greater emphasis on the operating measure
Facilitates multi-year comparison
Some may ignore the second statement
Incorrectly equate the operating measure to net income
Retain Flexibility
Without Donor Restrictions
With Donor Restrictions
Total
Revenue and support:Fees for services 495$ 495$ Bequests 600 600 Other contributions 425 1,500 1,925 Restricted support released for current period 1,375 (1,375) Total revenue and support 2,895 125 3,020
Expenses:Total expenses 1,950 - 1,950
Excess/(Deficit) before appropriations/transfers 945 125 1,070
Board appropriations/transfers to/(from) operations:Investment returns appropriated from donor endowment 60 a 60 Investment returns appropriated from quasi-endowment 90 b 90 Bequests transferred to quasi-endowment (500) c (500) Total appropriations/transfers to/(from) operations: (350) - (350)
Excess/(deficit) from operations 595$
Investment return, net 170 445 615
Board appropriations/transfers from/(to) operations:Investment returns appropriated from donor endowment (60) a (60) Investment returns appropriated from quasi-endowment (90) b (90) Bequests transferred to quasi-endowment 500 c 500 Total appropriations/transfers from/(to) operations: 410 (60) 350
Total change in net assets 1,175 510 1,685 Net assets at the beginning of the period 1,500 2,100 3,600 Net assets at the end of the period 2,675$ 2,610$ 5,285$
One Statement Approach Statement of Activities
15
Operating Revenue and Support:Fees for services 495$ Bequests 600 Other contributions 425 Restricted support released for current period 1,375 Total Operating Revenue and Support 2,895
Operating Expenses:Total Operating Expenses 1,950
Excess/(Deficit) before appropriations/transfers 945
Board appropriations/transfers to/(from) operations:Investment returns appropriated from donor endowment 60 aInvestment returns appropriated from quasi-endowment 90 bBequests transferred to quasi-endowment (500) cTotal Board transfers to/(from) operations: (350)
Excess/(deficit) from operations 595$ d
Two Statement Approach Statement of Operations
16
Two Statement Approach (cont’d) Statement of Changes in Net Assets
17
Without Donor
Restrictions
With Donor Restrictions
Total
Excess/(deficit) from operations 595$ d $ 595$
Nonoperating activitiesContributions 1,500 1,500 Restricted support released for current period (1,375) (1,375) Investment return, net 170 445 615
Board designated transfers from/(to) operations:Investment returns appropriated to operations from donor endowment (60) a (60) Investment returns appropriated to operations from quasi-endowment (90) b (90) Bequests transferred to quasi-endowment 500 c 500
Changes in Net Assets 1,175 510 1,685
Net assets at the beginning of the period 1,500 2,100 3,600
Net assets at the end of the period 2,675$ 2,610$ 5,285$
Cash Flow Statement – Issues
18
#1 • Understandability / utility
#2 • Relation to Statement of Activities (and any operating measure therein)
Cash Flow Statement – Board Decisions
Require direct method for operating cash flows
No longer require indirect method - Ask in ED if it should still be required for certain NFPs
Re-categorize certain items to better align “operating” with activities statement (next slide)
19
Cash Flow Statement
20
Cash Flows from Operating Activities Cash received from service recipients Cash received from donors Cash paid to employees Cash paid to vendors Purchase of property and equipment Contributions restricted for property and equipment
Net cash from operating activities Cash Flows from Investing Activities
Cash received from interest and dividends Purchase of investment assets Proceeds from sale of investment assets
Net cash from investing activities Cash Flows from Financing Activities
Payments of principal on long-term debt Interest paid on long-term debt Contributions restricted for endowment
Net cash from financing activities Net increase in cash Cash at the beginning of year Cash at end of year
Reporting of Expenses – Issues AICPA Issue
- Who should be required to present a Statement of Functional Expenses?
FASB Deliberations • Should natural expenses be required? • Should functional expenses still be required? • Should both be required together? • Which breakout on the Statement of Activities? • Should investment / other nonoperating expenses be
functionalized? 21
Expense by nature and function one place in the F/S (statement of activities, separate statement, or schedule in notes)
Reporting of Expenses
22
Program Activities Supporting Activities Total
Operating Expenses
Non- Operating
Total Expenses Program A Program B M&G Fundraising
Salaries & Benefits Grants to Others Equipment Rental & Maintenance Occupancy Cost Depreciation Information Technology Professional Service Fees Supplies Travel Printing & Publication Interest Other
Total
F U N C T I O N
NATURE
*
*
*Either (or both) on face of Statement of Activities
Not-functionalized
Reporting of investment expenses (Board discussion begun) Liquidity and financial flexibility
(Board discussion begun) NFP-specific notes
(in-process) Expiration of capital restrictions and
other display issues concerning capital transactions
Remaining Topics
23
Gross v. net?
If net, which expenses netted?
If netted expenses disclosed, which expenses included in disclosure?
(at issue: fees embedded in funds)
Reporting of Investment Expenses – Key Questions
24
Liquidity and Financial Availability
Being discussed: Classified balance sheet Separate presentation of assets whose use is limited Additional note disclosure
25
Asset type / debt
maturity
Donor / other
external restrictions
NFP-Specific Notes
e.g., endowment/ investment /
fair value
e.g., accounting policies
e.g., cost allocation
approaches
26
Capital
27
Display alternatives
• Separate line(s) within operating
• Subsection within operating
• Separate section
Expiration of capital restrictions
• Current U.S. GAAP (2 alternatives) 1) when placed in service 2) over time, to match depreciation
• For comparability, do we need to eliminate one of the U.S. GAAP alternatives?
Board Deliberations
First half 2014
Q3 2014
Exposure Draft
Comment Period
Q4 2014 – Q1 2015
2015
Final ASU
Project Timeline
28
Objective:
Improve the effectiveness of disclosures in notes to financial statements by clearly communicating the information most important to users of those statements.
Disclosure Framework Project
30
Are financial statements a vehicle for communications with investors? Or are
they more of a compliance exercise?
Field Study Results
31
More guidance around discretion facilitates more qualitative considerations
The word “materiality” has a strong quantitative connotation in practice
Preparers thought notes were generally more effective after applying their assigned discretion criterion
Obstacles in the financial reporting system discourage the application of discretion
Pensions
Fair Value Measurement
Income Taxes
Entity’s Decision Process Next Steps
32
Develop ways the Board can promote the appropriate use of discretion. This will include exploring section-specific disclosure modifications
Examine in the context of the Proposed Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts, Notes to Financial Statements.
Findings may become a basis for other Codification modifications
To reduce narrow sources of unnecessary complexity in current standards - To identify aspects of GAAP that might be streamlined for all
companies—both public and private—as well as for not-for-profit organizations
- To consider whether improvements can be made to simplify GAAP while maintaining or improving the relevance of reported financial information
Objective
34
Types of Complexity To Be Addressed
35
Complicated, dense standard obscures its meaning
Accounting treatment is clear, but applying it is lengthy, convoluted & expensive
Goodwill
37
Do not amortize goodwill Test for impairment at least
annually or more frequently Goodwill impairment test
- At reporting unit level - Two-step test - Optional qualitative assessment
Amortize goodwill Test for impairment upon
occurrence of triggering event Goodwill impairment test
- At entity level or reporting unit level
- One-step test - Optional qualitative assessment
Final Alternative Current U.S. GAAP
PCC projects Completed: Goodwill, Simplified Hedge Accounting, and VIE guidance
In-process: Intangible Assets Pre-agenda Research: Stock Compensation
Proposed Right-of-Use Model
39
A lease contract conveys the right to use an asset (the underlying asset) for a period of time in exchange for consideration
Lessee Model Approaches
40
Current U.S. GAAP (IFRS) IASB FASB
Capital (Finance) Leases Type A Type A
Operating Leases Type A Type B
All leases are financing.
Not all leases are the same. Classification is
based on IAS 17 (similar to FAS 13).
Lessee Accounting Overview
41
Type A
Type B
Right-of-use asset Lease liability
Amortization expense Interest expense
Cash paid for principal and
interest payments
Right-of-use asset Lease liability
Single lease expense on a straight-line basis
Cash paid for lease payments
Income Statement
Cash Flow Statement Balance Sheet
Lessor Accounting Overview
42
Type A
Type B
Net investment in the lease
Interest income and any profit on the lease
Cash received for lease payments
Continue to recognize
underlying asset Lease income, typically on a straight-line basis
Cash received for lease payments
Income Statement
Cash Flow Statement Balance Sheet
Next Set of Topics for Board Discussion
43
• Lease Modifications and Contract Combinations • Variable Lease Payments • In-Substance Fixed Payments • Discount Rate
April 2014
• Definition of a Lease • Separating Lease and Non-Lease Components • Initial Direct Costs and Lease Incentives
May 2014
• Residual Value Guarantees • Subleases • Sale and Leaseback Transactions
June 2014
Future Topics include: initial direct costs, presentation, disclosures, leveraged leases, related party leases, transition, effective date, etc.
Objective: single, principle-based revenue standard Improve accounting for contracts with customers
- More robust framework for recognizing revenue - Increased comparability across industries & capital markets - Better disclosures
Excludes contributions and collaborative arrangements
Revenue Recognition
45
Substantially converged on major decisions Final standard expected in 1H 2014
Core Principle and Application
46
1 • Identify contract(s) with the customer
2 • Identify performance obligations
3 • Determine the transaction price
4 • Allocate the transaction price to the identified performance obligations
5 • Recognize revenue when performance obligation is satisfied
Core principle: Recognize revenue to depict the transfer of promised goods or services to customers in an amount that reflects the consideration to which
the entity expects to be entitled in exchange for those goods or services
Rev Rec—Issuance & Effective Dates: Timeline
47
Issue final standard 2Q 2014
Establish Transition
Resource Group 2Q 2014
Effective Date – Public Entity
Jan. 2017
Effective Date – Nonpublic
Entity Jan. 2018
A nonpublic entity has the option to early adopt (no earlier than a public entity)
An entity may apply the guidance retrospectively, either to
1) Each prior period presented 2) The current period with supplemental footnote disclosures