numbers need context
Post on 19-Sep-2014
13 views
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Context Numbers need
Although not everyone might agree, Statistics are…
Although not everyone might agree, Statistics are…
Interesting
Although not everyone might agree, Statistics are…
Interesting Educational
Although not everyone might agree, Statistics are…
Interesting Educational Important
But it can often be hard to understand them without CONTEXT
Our media abounds with context-less numbers
Let’s take a look at a few…
“Bacon increases risk of colorectal cancer by 20%”
“Bacon increases risk of colorectal cancer by 20%”
“1 extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman’s risk of breast cancer by 12%”
“Bacon increases risk of colorectal cancer by 20%”
“1 extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman’s risk of breast cancer by 12%”
“Just 2 units of alcohol a day reduces risk of heart disease by 17%”
But what do the percentages really mean in real life?
And is there a more relevant way we could
be describing this information
“Bacon increases risk of Colorectal cancer by 20%”
But just how bad is that?
Lets assume that ordinarily 5 out of 100 people develop Colorectal cancer.
Therefore if all 100 ate 3 extra rashers every day... The number could rise to six
Therefore if all 100 ate 3 extra rashers every day... The number could rise to six
So therefore…
So therefore… Bacon increases risk of Colorectal cancer by 20%
So therefore… Bacon increases risk of Colorectal cancer by 20%
Is the exact same as saying
So therefore… Bacon increases risk of Colorectal cancer by 20%
Is the exact same as saying
About 1 extra case per 100 people
Next up…
“One extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman's risk of breast cancer by 12%”
But just how bad is that?
Let’s assume about 10 out of 100 women have breast cancer in a lifetime
If all 100 drink an extra unit a day, that number rises to 11.
If all 100 drink an extra unit a day, that number rises to 11.
So therefore…
So therefore…
One extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman's risk of breast cancer by 12%”
So therefore…
One extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman's risk of breast cancer by 12%”
Is the exact same as saying
So therefore…
One extra unit of alcohol a day increases a woman's risk of breast cancer by 12%”
Is the exact same as saying
About 1 extra case per 100 people
And Finally…
“Just two units a day reduces risk of heart disease by 17%”
But just how GOOD is that?
About 32 out of 100 women have coronary heart disease in a lifetime.
If all 100 were to drink 2 units of alcohol every day… that number would fall to 27
If all 100 were to drink 2 units of alcohol every day… that number would fall to 27
So therefore…
So therefore… Just two units a day reduces risk of heart disease by 17%
So therefore… Just two units a day reduces risk of heart disease by 17%
Is the exact same as saying
So therefore… Just two units a day reduces risk of heart disease by 17%
Is the exact same as saying
About 5 fewer cases per 100 people
So we have a little problem
Depending on the story
20% can equal 1 person in 100
20% can equal 1 person in 100
12% can equal 1 person in 100
20% can equal 1 person in 100
12% can equal 1 person in 100
17% can equal 5 people in 100
So…
Percentage figures without CONTEXT are meaningless and can often misleading
When talking about health matters it isn’t enough to deal with percentages
Think about number of lives affected
And…
We must hold our media to account and ensure that journalists do not go for the FLASHY, SHINY and TRENDY (not to mention misleading) sounding story rather than the more relevant and helpful one...
Because…
Those… “Who might rely on the news for guidance, deserve something more relevant”
(M. Blastland)
You can find me at:
www.clearpreso.com
www.twitter.com/clearpreso