numerical simulation of internal tide generation at a ... · pdf filenumerical simulation of...

9
29 th Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics Gothenburg, Sweden, 26-31 August 2012 Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break Laura K. Brandt, James W. Rottman, Kyle A. Brucker and Douglas G.Dommermuth Naval Hydrodynamics Division, Science Applications International Corporation 10260 Campus Point Drive, San Diego, CA 92121, USA ABSTRACT A fully nonlinear, three-dimensional numerical model is developed for the simulation of tidal flow over arbi- trary bottom topography in an ocean with realistic strat- ification. The model is capable of simulating accurately the generation of fine-scale internal wave tidal beams, their interaction with an ocean thermocline and the sub- sequent generation of solitary internal waves that propa- gate on this thermocline. Several preliminary simulation results are shown for uniform and non-uniform flow over an idealized two-dimensional ridge, which are compared with linear theory, and for flow over an idealized two- dimensional continental shelf. INTRODUCTION It is important to have a good understanding of the ocean environment in which surface and subsurface ships op- erate. In particular, submarines operating in the littoral ocean environment can be significantly affected by the presence of large-amplitude internal waves. A gener- ation mechanism for these waves is the motion of the barotropic tide over continental shelf breaks, as dis- cussed, for example, by Pingree and New (1989), Hol- lowy, Chatwin and Craig (2001), Lien and Gregg (2001), and Garrett and Kunze (2007). The ultimate objective is to produce a forecast model for the generation and prop- agation of large amplitude internal waves in a realistic ocean in the regions about a continental shelf. The numerical modeling of this generation pro- cess is difficult because of the complexity of the topogra- phy, the complicated structure of the ocean stratification and currents, and the wide range of spatial and tempo- ral scales. When the continental slope is near a criti- cal value, which occurs often, a fine-scale internal wave beam is generated that must be accurately resolved in a domain that has the very large length scale of the ocean shelf region. Also, it is possible for this internal wave beam to produce internal solitary waves by the interac- tion of the beam with a moderately strong ocean thermo- cline, as described by Gerkema (2001) and Maug´ e and Gerkema (2008). In this paper, we develop a numerical scheme capable of accurately simulating the generation of these beams with realistic ocean stratification and bottom to- pography. The numerical method is fully nonlinear, and uses a technique similar to the Cartesian-grid free- surface capturing code called Numerical Flow Analysis (NFA) of Dommermuth, OShea, Wyatt, Ratcliffe, Wey- mouth, Hendrickson, Yue, Sussman, Adams and Va- lenciano (2007) and Rottman, Brucker, Dommermuth and Broutman (2010a), but modified to handle nonlinear background stratification and ocean bottom topography. The scheme is sufficiently robust to simulate the genera- tion of the internal wave beams, the interaction of these internal wave beams with an ocean thermocline, and the subsequent propagation of the generated internal solitary waves shoreward over realistic bottom topography. This paper also describes some preliminary simulations for stratified flow over idealized two- dimensional ridges, which are compared with linear the- ory, and a two-dimensional shelf break, including the generation of internal wave beams and the interaction of these beams with idealized ocean thermoclines. THE NUMERICAL MODEL We consider nonlinear, three-dimensional, stratified fluid flow over bottom topography. A Cartesian coordinate system (x, y, z) is used with z as the vertical coordinate and (x, y) as the horizontal coordinates. The background stratification is assumed variable in the vertical but ho- mogeneous in the horizontal. Typically, we will impose a background stratification that represents an ocean with a seasonal thermocline. The background current is as- sumed to be forced by a barotropic tide. The computer code Numerical Flow Analy- sis (NFA), Dommermuth et al. (2007), originally de- signed to provide turnkey capabilities to simulate the free-surface flow around ships, has been extended to have the ability to perform high-fidelity stratified sub-surface arXiv:1410.1896v1 [physics.flu-dyn] 7 Oct 2014

Upload: buithuy

Post on 04-Mar-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

29th Symposium on Naval HydrodynamicsGothenburg, Sweden, 26-31 August 2012

Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at aContinental Shelf Break

Laura K. Brandt, James W. Rottman, Kyle A. Brucker and Douglas G.DommermuthNaval Hydrodynamics Division, Science Applications International Corporation

10260 Campus Point Drive, San Diego, CA 92121, USA

ABSTRACT

A fully nonlinear, three-dimensional numerical modelis developed for the simulation of tidal flow over arbi-trary bottom topography in an ocean with realistic strat-ification. The model is capable of simulating accuratelythe generation of fine-scale internal wave tidal beams,their interaction with an ocean thermocline and the sub-sequent generation of solitary internal waves that propa-gate on this thermocline. Several preliminary simulationresults are shown for uniform and non-uniform flow overan idealized two-dimensional ridge, which are comparedwith linear theory, and for flow over an idealized two-dimensional continental shelf.

INTRODUCTION

It is important to have a good understanding of the oceanenvironment in which surface and subsurface ships op-erate. In particular, submarines operating in the littoralocean environment can be significantly affected by thepresence of large-amplitude internal waves. A gener-ation mechanism for these waves is the motion of thebarotropic tide over continental shelf breaks, as dis-cussed, for example, by Pingree and New (1989), Hol-lowy, Chatwin and Craig (2001), Lien and Gregg (2001),and Garrett and Kunze (2007). The ultimate objective isto produce a forecast model for the generation and prop-agation of large amplitude internal waves in a realisticocean in the regions about a continental shelf.

The numerical modeling of this generation pro-cess is difficult because of the complexity of the topogra-phy, the complicated structure of the ocean stratificationand currents, and the wide range of spatial and tempo-ral scales. When the continental slope is near a criti-cal value, which occurs often, a fine-scale internal wavebeam is generated that must be accurately resolved in adomain that has the very large length scale of the oceanshelf region. Also, it is possible for this internal wavebeam to produce internal solitary waves by the interac-tion of the beam with a moderately strong ocean thermo-

cline, as described by Gerkema (2001) and Mauge andGerkema (2008).

In this paper, we develop a numerical schemecapable of accurately simulating the generation of thesebeams with realistic ocean stratification and bottom to-pography. The numerical method is fully nonlinear,and uses a technique similar to the Cartesian-grid free-surface capturing code called Numerical Flow Analysis(NFA) of Dommermuth, OShea, Wyatt, Ratcliffe, Wey-mouth, Hendrickson, Yue, Sussman, Adams and Va-lenciano (2007) and Rottman, Brucker, Dommermuthand Broutman (2010a), but modified to handle nonlinearbackground stratification and ocean bottom topography.The scheme is sufficiently robust to simulate the genera-tion of the internal wave beams, the interaction of theseinternal wave beams with an ocean thermocline, and thesubsequent propagation of the generated internal solitarywaves shoreward over realistic bottom topography.

This paper also describes some preliminarysimulations for stratified flow over idealized two-dimensional ridges, which are compared with linear the-ory, and a two-dimensional shelf break, including thegeneration of internal wave beams and the interaction ofthese beams with idealized ocean thermoclines.

THE NUMERICAL MODEL

We consider nonlinear, three-dimensional, stratified fluidflow over bottom topography. A Cartesian coordinatesystem (x, y, z) is used with z as the vertical coordinateand (x, y) as the horizontal coordinates. The backgroundstratification is assumed variable in the vertical but ho-mogeneous in the horizontal. Typically, we will imposea background stratification that represents an ocean witha seasonal thermocline. The background current is as-sumed to be forced by a barotropic tide.

The computer code Numerical Flow Analy-sis (NFA), Dommermuth et al. (2007), originally de-signed to provide turnkey capabilities to simulate thefree-surface flow around ships, has been extended to havethe ability to perform high-fidelity stratified sub-surface

arX

iv:1

410.

1896

v1 [

phys

ics.

flu-

dyn]

7 O

ct 2

014

Page 2: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

calculations. The governing equations are formulated ona Cartesian grid thereby eliminating complications asso-ciated with body-fitted grids. The sole geometric inputinto NFA is a surface panelization of the ship and/or bot-tom. No additional gridding beyond what is used alreadyin potential-flow methods and hydrostatics calculationsis required. The ease of input in combination with aflow solver that is implemented using parallel-computingmethods permit the rapid turnaround of numerical simu-lations of high-Re stratified fluid interactions with a com-plex bottom.

The grid is stretched along the Cartesian axesusing one-dimensional elliptic equations to improve res-olution near the bottom and the mixing layer. Away fromthe bottom and the mixing layer, where the flow is lesscomplicated, the mesh is coarser. Details of the grid-stretching algorithm, which uses weight functions thatare specified in physical space, are provided in Knuppand Steinberg (1993).

GOVERNING EQUATIONS

Consider a turbulent flow in a stratified fluid.Physical quantities are normalized by characteristic ve-locity (U0), length (L0), time (L0/U0), density (ρ0), andpressure (ρ0U2

0 ) scales. Let ρ and ui, respectively de-note the normalized density and three-dimensional ve-locity field as a function of normalized space (xi) andnormalized time (t). The conservation of mass is

∂ρ

∂t+∂ujρ

∂xj= 0 . (1)

For incompressible flow with no diffusion,

∂ρ

∂t+ uj

∂ρ

∂xj= 0 . (2)

Subtracting (2) from (1) gives a solenoidal condition forthe velocity:

∂ui∂xi

= 0 . (3)

The normalized density is decomposed in termsof the constant reference density plus small departuresthat are further split into a known mean perturbation(ρC), a continuous fluctuation (ρC) due to the mean den-sity gradient, and a fluctuation with a discontinuous jumpin the density (ρJ ) corresponding to the bottom of themixing layer:

ρ = 1 + γCρC(x3) + γC ρC(xi, t) + γJ ρJ(xi, t) . (4)

γC and γJ quantify the magnitudes of the density fluc-tuations for the continuous and discontinuous portions,

respectively :

γC =L0

ρ0

∂ρ

∂x3

∣∣∣∣0

(5)

γJ =∆ρ

ρ0. (6)

Here, (∂ρ/∂x3)0 is the dimensional characteristic mean-density gradient and ∆ρ is the dimensional density jump.The density fluctuations are split into two parts becausethey require different theoretical and numerical treat-ments.

The splitting requires an additional equationthat we choose as follows.

∂ρJ∂t

+∂uj ρJ∂xj

= 0 . (7)

Substituting (4) and (7) into (1) gives

∂ρC∂t

+∂uj(ρC + ρC)

∂xj= 0 . (8)

For an infinite Reynolds number, viscousstresses are negligible, and the conservation of momen-tum is

∂ρui∂t

+∂

∂xj(ρujui) = − ∂p

∂xi− δi3F 2r

− τi , (9)

where p is the normalized pressure and τi is a normalizedstress that will act tangential to the surface of the bottom.δij is the Kronecker delta function. Fr is a Froude num-ber:

Fr ≡gL0

U20

, (10)

where g is the acceleration of gravity. The Froude num-ber is the ratio of inertial to gravitational forces. AsO’Shea, Brucker, Dommermuth and Wyatt (2008) dis-cuss, the sub-grid scale stresses are modeled implicitlyin 9.

The pressure, p is then decomposed into the dy-namic, pd, and hydrostatic, ph, components as

p = pd + ph . (11)

The hydrostatic pressure is defined in terms of the refer-ence density and the density stratification as follows.

∂ph∂xi

= −(1 + ρC)δi3F 2r

. (12)

The substitution of (4) and (12) into (9) and us-ing (7) and (8) to simplify terms gives a new expressionfor the conservation of momentum:

∂ui∂t

+∂

∂xj(ujui) = − 1

1 + γC(ρC + ρC) + γJ ρJ[∂pd∂xi

+ (γC ρC + γJ ρJ)δi3F 2r

+ τi

]. (13)

2

Page 3: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

If γC << 1 and γJ << 1, a Boussinesq approximationmay be employed in the preceding equation to yield

∂ui∂t

+∂

∂xj(ujui) =

−[∂pd∂xi

+ (RiBCρC +RiBJ

ρJ) δi3 + τi

]. (14)

where RiBCand RiBJ

are bulk Richardson numbers de-fined as

RiBC≡ γC

F 2r

ρC =L0

ρ0

∂ρ

∂x3

∣∣∣∣0

gL0

U20

(15)

RiBJ≡ γJ

F 2r

ρJ =∆ρ

ρ0

gL0

U20

, (16)

The bulk Richardson numbers are the ratios of buoyant toinertial forces for continuous and discontinuous densityfluctuations.

The momentum equations using either (13) or(14) and the mass conservation equations (7) and (8) areintegrated with respect to time. The divergence of themomentum equations in combination with the solenoidalcondition (3) provides a Poisson equation for the dy-namic pressure. The dynamic pressure is used to projectthe velocity onto a solenoidal field and to impose a no-flux condition on the surface of the body. The details ofthe time integration, the pressure projection, the formu-lations of the body boundary conditions, and the formu-lations of the inflow and outflow boundary conditions aredescribed in the next three sections.

TIME INTEGRATION

A second-order Runge-Kutta scheme is used tointegrate with respect to time the field equations for thevelocity and density. During the first stage of the Runge-Kutta algorithm, a Poisson equation for the pressure issolved:

∂xi

[1

1 + γC(ρC + ρkC) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

=

∂xi

(uki∆t

+Rki

), (17)

where Rki denotes the nonlinear convective, buoyancy,

and stress terms in the momentum equation, (13), at timestep k. uki , ρkC , ρkJ , and pkd are, respectively, the veloc-ity components, continuous fluctuating density, discon-tinuous fluctuating density, and dynamic pressure at timestep k. ∆t is the time step. For the next step, this pres-sure is used to project the velocity onto a solenoidal field.

The first prediction for the velocity field (u∗i ) is

u∗i = uki + ∆t

(Rk

i

−[

1

1 + γC(ρC + ρkC) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

). (18)

The densities are advanced using the mass conservationequations (7) and (8):

ρ∗C = ρkC −∆t∂

∂xj

(ukj (ρC + ρkC)

)(19)

ρ∗J = ρkJ −VOF(ukj , ρ

kJ ,∆t

). (20)

The advective terms for ρC are calculated using a third-order finite-volume approximation, whereas the advec-tion of ρJ is calculated using the Volume of Fluid (VOF)method. A Poisson equation for the pressure is solvedagain during the second stage of the Runge-Kutta algo-rithm:

∂xi

[1

1 + γC(ρC + ρ∗C) + γJ ρ∗J

]∂p∗d∂xi

=

∂xi

(u∗i + uki

∆t+R∗

i

), (21)

ui is advanced to the next step to complete one cycle ofthe Runge-Kutta algorithm:

uk+1i =

1

2

(u∗i + uki

)+

∆t

2

(R∗

i

−[

1

1 + γC(ρC + ρ∗C) + γJ ρ∗J

]∂p∗d∂xi

), (22)

and the densities are advanced to complete the algorithm:

ρk+1C =

ρ∗C + ρkC2

− ∆t

2

∂xj

(u∗j (ρC + ρ∗C)

)ρk+1J = ρkJ −VOF

(u∗j + ukj

2, ρ∗J ,∆t

). (23)

ENFORCEMENT OF NO-FLUX BOUNDARYCONDITIONS

A no-flux condition is satisfied on the surface ofthe bottom using a finite-volume technique.

uini = vini , (24)

where ni denotes the unit normal to the body that pointsinto the fluid and vi is the velocity of the bottom. If thebottom is not moving, vi = 0. Cells near the bottom mayhave an irregular shape, depending on how the surface ofthe bottom cuts the cell. Let Sb denote the portion of the

3

Page 4: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

cell whose surface is on the bottom, and let S0 denotethe other bounding surfaces of the cell that are not on thebottom.

Gauss’s theorem is applied to the volume inte-gral of (17):∫

S0+Sb

ds

[ni

1 + γC(ρC + ρkC) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

=

∫S0+Sb

ds

(uki ni∆t

+Rini

). (25)

Here, ni denotes the components of the unit normal onthe surfaces that bound the cell. Based on (18), a Neu-mann condition is derived for the pressure on Sb as fol-lows[

ni1 + γC(ρC + ρ∗C) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

=

− u∗ini∆t

+uki ni∆t

+Rini . (26)

The Neumann condition for the velocity (24) is substi-tuted into the preceding equation to complete the Neu-mann condition for the pressure on Sb:[

ni1 + γC(ρC + ρ∗C) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

=

− v∗i ni∆t

+uki ni∆t

+Rini . (27)

This Neumann condition for the pressure is substitutedinto the integral formulation in 25:∫

S0

ds

[ni

1 + γC(ρC + ρ∗C) + γJ ρkJ

]∂pkd∂xi

=

∫S0

ds

(uki ni∆t

+Rini

)+

∫Sb

dsv∗i ni∆t

. (28)

This equation is solved using the method of fractional ar-eas. Details associated with the calculation of the areafractions are provided in Sussman and Dommermuth(2001) along with additional references. Cells with a cutvolume of less than 2% of the full volume of the cellare merged with neighbors. The merging occurs alongthe direction of the normal to the body. This improvesthe conditioning of the Poisson equation for the pressure.As a result, the stability of the projection operator for thevelocity is also improved (see Equations (18) and (22)).

ENFORCEMENT OF NO-SLIP BOUNDARYCONDITIONS

The stress τi is used to impose partial-slip andno-slip conditions on the surface of the bottom using a

body-force formulation as follows.

τi = β(ui − vi)δ(x− x+b ) , (29)

where β is a body-force coefficient, vi is the velocityof the body, x is a point in the fluid, and x+

b is a pointslightly outside the body. Equation (29) forces the fluidvelocity to match the velocity of the body. Note that free-slip boundary conditions are recovered with β = 0 andno-slip boundary conditions are imposed as β →∞.

Dommermuth, Innis, Luth, Novikov, Schlageterand Talcott (1998) discuss modeling using body-forceformulations. Recently, there have been several stud-ies which use similar body boundary conditions in bothfinite volume (Meyer, Devesa, Hickel, Hu and Adams(2010a), Meyer, Hickel and Adams (2010b) and finite el-ement (Hoffman (2006a), Hoffman (2006b), John (2002)simulations. The finite element simulations of Hoffman(2006b) at very high Reynolds numbers are able to pre-dict the lift and drag to within a few percent of the con-sensus values from experiments, using a very economi-cal number of grid points. The finite volume implemen-tations have also shown promise albeit at more modestReynolds numbers (Re = 3, 900). Rottman, Brucker,Dommermuth and Broutman (2010b) show that finitevolume simulations with Re → ∞ are able to accu-rately predict flow about bluff-bodies using a partial-sliptype boundary condition to model the effects of the un-resolved turbulent boundary layer.

FORMULATION OF INFLOW AND OUTFLOWBOUNDARY CONDITIONS

The effects of oscillating tidal currents can bemodeled by including an oscillatory current in velocity:

u1 ← u1 + U c cos(ωt). (30)

U c is the amplitude of the current at inflow normalizedby U0 and ω is the frequency of the current normalizedby L0/U0.

The velocities near the inflow and outflowboundaries are nudged every N time steps toward targetvelocities that conserve flux:

u1 ← u1 − βN∆tf I(x)(u1 − U I) for x ∈ ∨Iu1 ← u1 − βN∆tfO(x)(u1 − UO) for x ∈ ∨0.

(31)

β is a relaxation parameter, and f I(x) and fO(x) aretapering functions at the inflow and outflow regions, re-spectively. U I and UO are the target velocities at theinflow and outflow boundaries, respectively. ∨I and ∨0denote regions near the inflow and outflow boundaries,respectively.

Away from the inflow boundary, f I(x) = 0.At the inflow boundary, f I(x) = 1. f I(x) smoothly

4

Page 5: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

1 1.5 2 2.5 3

−2

−1.8

−1.6

−1.4

−1.2

−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

z/L

o

ρ /ρo

1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

−2

−1.8

−1.6

−1.4

−1.2

−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

z/L

o

ρ /ρo

(a) (b)

Figure 1: Normalized density ρ/ρ0 as a function of normalized depth z/L0, where L0 = H − h0: (a) uniform stratification; and(b) nonuniform stratification representing a typical seasonal thermocline.

transitions between the two regions. Similarly, fO(x) =0 away from the outflow boundary, and fO(x) = 1 at theoutflow boundary.

At inflow, the target velocity is set to zero,U I = 0, then by conservation of flux,

UO =

(SI

S0− 1

)U c cos(ωt) (32)

where S0 is the surface area at the outflow boundary, andSI is the surface area at the inflow boundary.

VALIDATION

We desribe several preliminary simulations using NFA toassess the accuracy of the numerical scheme for simulat-ing realistic internal wave tidal beams and their interac-tions with an ocean thermocline.

FLOW OVER A TWO-DIMENSIONAL RIDGE:COMPARISON WITH LINEAR THEORY

A first step to validate the numerical techniqueis to compare its results for an idealized two-dimensionalproblem with linear theory. Echeverri and Peacock(2010) developed a linear model using a Greens func-tion approach to simulate internal tidal beams generatedby tidal flow over two-dimensional topography with non-uniform stratification. The relevant parameters in thiscase are ω, the tidal frequency; N , the buoyancy fre-quency; h0, the topographic height; H , the water depth;L, a horizontal length scale representative of the topogra-phy; and U0, the barotropic tidal current amplitude. Thegoverning nondimensional parameters are: the frequencyratio ω/N ; the relative height of the topography h0/H;the tidal excursion parameter, defined as the tidal excur-sion distance normalized by the topographic length scale,εex = U0/(ωL); and the steepness parameter, defined as

the ratio of the slope of the topography to the slope of thetidally generated internal waves, εS = h0/(Ls), where s=√ω2/(N2 − ω2).

We performed two-dimensional numerical sim-ulations for tidal flow over an asymmetrical ridge withuniform stratification, as shown in figure 1a, or nonuni-form stratification, as shown in figure 1b. The nonuni-form stratification represents an idealized seasonal ther-mocline. The simulations have ω/N = 0.67 andh0/H = 0.5. For linear theory to be accurate, the flowmust have a subcritical value for the steepness parameter(εS < 1) and a small value for the excursion parameter(εex << 1). In figures 2 and 3, εS = 0.42, 0.75 andεex = 0.029, 0.062, for the shallow slope side of the to-pography and steep slope side of the topography, respec-tively. The steepness parameters are subcritical, but closeenough to critical for some nonlinear effects to exist.

Figure 2a shows results from an NFA simula-tion of uniformly stratified flow over a ridge after 10 tidalperiods of adjustment. Visually, the comparison betweenNFA and linear theory (figure 2b) is very good. The tidalbeam is generated at the steepest part of the slope and isseen as a straight line in the flow, since the backgroundstratification is homogeneous. The dashed line in figure2a shows the ray path predicted by linear theory, whichagrees well with the primary beam shown in the nonlin-ear simulation. Figure 2c compares the nonlinear andlinear results at z/L0 = −0.64, where L0 = H − h0.While the nonlinear results show some nonlinearly gen-erated harmonics, which of course do not exist in the lin-ear theory, the magnitudes of the beams and the large-scale behavior compare very well.

Figure 3 shows a similar computation for non-uniform stratification. This stratification is more realis-tic, with an idealized thermocline profile near the surface.Figure 3a shows results from NFA after 18 tidal peri-ods of adjustment. When comparing it with linear theory(figure 3b), the NFA results have a slightly stronger mag-

5

Page 6: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

(a)

(b)

(c)−10 −5 0 5 10−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

x/Lo

u’/U

o

Figure 2: Normalized horizontal velocity u/U0 for tidal flowover isolated topography with uniform stratification: (a) ver-tical cross-section of nonlinear simulation results using NFA.The dashed line shows the beam path predicted by linear the-ory; (b) vertical cross-section of linear theory results; and (c)comparison of NFA with linear theory for a horizontal line atz/L0 = −0.64, where L0 = H − h0.

nitude. We believe this stronger amplitude is due to non-linearities in the flow caused by the strong stratificationnear the surface. The dashed line in figure 3a shows theray path predicted by linear theory, which agrees wellwith the primary beam shown in the nonlinear simula-

(a)

(b)

(c)−10 −5 0 5 10−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

x/Lo

u’/U

o

Figure 3: Normalized horizontal velocity u/U0 for tidal flowover isolated topography with non-uniform stratification: (a)vertical cross-section of nonlinear simulation results usingNFA. The dashed line shows the beam path predicted by lin-ear theory; (b) vertical cross-section of linear theory results;and (c) comparison of NFA with linear theory for a horizontalline at z/L0 = −0.64, where L0 = H − h0.

tion. Figure 3c compares the nonlinear and linear re-sults at z/L0 = −0.64. Linear theory captures the mainflow behavior, but the nonlinear simulation shows somehigher frequency perturbations about the main flow.

The process of energy transfer from semi-

6

Page 7: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

diurnal internal tides (M2) to subharmonic internal tides(M1) and higher harmonics (M4, M6, etc.) has been atopic of recent interest. Gerkema, Staquet and Bouruet-Aubertot (2006) discusses how energy can transfer tosubharmonic internal tides which produce features thatappear as “slices” in the generated internal tidal beam.As time goes on, more and more “slices” appear. Theslices are the troughs and crests of the M1 beams. Higherharmonics are generated when the beam reflects off thebottom due to the nonlinear interaction of the incomingand outgoing beams. We will show that this is also truefor beams that reflect off the surface and thermocline.

(a)1 1.5 2 2.5

−1.6

−1.4

−1.2

−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

z/L

o

ρ /ρo

Figure 4: Normalized density ρ/ρ0 as a function of normal-ized depth z/L0, where L0 = H − h0: nonuniform stratifica-tion for a thermocline (approximated as a density jump) over acontinental shelf.

FLOW OVER A TWO-DIMENSIONAL CONTINENTALSHELF

NFA results for the internal wave tidal beamgenerated by the interaction of the barotropic tide with anidealized, two-dimensional continental shelf break, withthe vertical density profile shown in figure 4, is shown infigure 5a. In this example, ω/N = 0.13; h0/H = 0.375;the tidal excursion parameter is εex = 0.0046; and thepeak steepness parameter is εS = 0.81. Note that thetidal frequency in this example is two orders of magni-tude higher than it is in the real ocean. This was doneas a computationaly inexpensive way to obtain a regimein which internal solitary waves are formed by internalwave tidal beams (for testing purposes). In future stud-ies, other flow parameters will be adjusted to reach thisregime with the tidal frequency set to the semi-diurnaltidal frequency.

The NFA numerical domain was 8192x512grid points with ∆x/L0 = 0.007 and the minimum∆z/L0 = 0.0007 and maximum ∆z/L0 = 0.007.There were approximately 188 grid points across the in-terface. There were 170 and 703 grid points across the

bathymetry in the z-direction and x-direction, respec-tively.

The tidal beams associated with M1, M2 andM4 harmonics, according to linear theory, are plotted aswhite dashed lines. Close to the generation site, para-metric subharmonic instability causes the observed fanof weaker beams about the main beam, while furtheraway where the beam reflects from the thermocline, orthe lower boundary, higher harmonics are generated dueto the nonlinear interaction of incoming and reflectedbeams. These instabilities grow over time and can even-tually cause the internal wave tidal beam to break.

The interaction of the internal wave tidal beamwith the thermocline also generates internal solitarywaves (ISW) that propagate horizontally along the ther-mocline. Figure 5b shows the vertical displacement ofthe thermocline as a function of x at two successivetimes. Comparing the red line with the the blue line infigure 5b at x/L0 ≈ −13, a lead wave and successivesmaller waves are seen propagating up the shelf. A roughestimate of the wave velocity is C/C0 = 1.123, whereC0 is the linear long-wave speed for internal waves in atwo-layer fluid, which is consistent for a two-layer soli-tary wave with the shown amplitude.

CONCLUSIONS

We have described the formulation and implementationof a fully nonlinear, three-dimensional numerical modelthat is capable of simulating with great accuracy tidalflow of a stratified ocean over arbitrary bottom topogra-phy, even though the range of scales from the long scalesof the shelf topography to the fine scales of the resonantlygenerated internal wave tidal beams is very large. Thisnew numerical model is an extension of the existing NFAcode, which originally was designed for the computationof the motion of ships in a free-surface flow. Further-more, we have used the newly modified numerical modelto compute tidal flow over an idealized two-dimensionalridge and found the simulations to agree very well withlinear theory for both uniform and nonlinear stratifica-tion. Finally, the model was used to generate a tidal beamby the interaction of the barotropic tide with an idealizedtwo-dimensional continental shelf break. The simulationresults show the generated beam and its harmonics, gen-erated by nonlinear interactions, as well as the solitarywaves generated by the beam’s interactions with the ther-mocline.

Acknowledgements

This research was sponsored by Dr. Ron Joslin at theOffice of Naval Research (contract number N00014-08-C-0508), Dr. Tom C. Fu at the Naval Surface War-

7

Page 8: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

−25 −20 −15 −10 −5 0 5 10 15

−0.075

−0.07

−0.065

−0.06

−0.055

x/Lo

η/L

o

(a) (b)

Figure 5: (a) Contours of u/U0 after 8.25 tidal periods, depicting the generation of an internal wave tidal beam and its interactionwith the thermocline. The beam paths associated with the M1, M2 and M4 tidal modes are shown as white dashed lines. (b)Elevation of thermocline: (red) at 8.25 tidal periods (a); (blue) at 8.5 tidal periods

fare Center, Carderock Division, and SAIC’s Researchand Development program. The numerical simulationswere supported in part by a grant from the Departmentof Defense High Performance Computing Moderniza-tion Program (http://www.hpcmo.hpc.mil/). The numer-ical simulations were performed on the SGI R© Altix R©

ICE 8200LX (Silicon Graphics International Corpora-tion) at the U.S. Army Engineering Research and De-velopment Center. Animated versions of the numeri-cal simulations described here as well as many othersare available online at http://www.youtube.com/waveanimations

References

Dommermuth, D., Innis, G., Luth, T., Novikov, E., Schlageter,E., and Talcott, J., “Numerical simulation of bow waves,”Proceedings of the 22nd Symposium on NavalHydrodynamics, Washington, D.C., 1998, pp. 508–521.

Dommermuth, D. G., OShea, T. T., Wyatt, D. C., Ratcliffe, T.,Weymouth, G. D., Hendrickson, K. L., Yue, D. K. P.,Sussman, M., Adams, P., and Valenciano, M., “An applicationof cartesian-grid and volume-of-fluid methods to numericalship hydrodynamics,” Proceedings of the 9th InternationalSymposium on Numerical Ship Hydrodynamics, held 5 – 8August 2007 in Ann Arbor, Michigan, 2007.

Echeverri, P. and Peacock, T., “Internal tide generation byarbitrary two-dimensional topography,” J. Fluid Mech., Vol.659, 2010, pp. 247–266.URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0022112010002417

Garrett, C. and Kunze, E., “Internal tide generation in the deepocean,” Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., Vol. 39, 2007, pp. 57–87.

Gerkema, T., “Internal and interfacial tides: beam scatteringand local generation of solitary waves,” J. Mar. Res., Vol. 59,2001, pp. 227–255.

Gerkema, T., Staquet, C., and Bouruet-Aubertot, P., “Decay ofsemi-diurnal internal-tide beams due to subharmonicresonance,” Geophys. Res. Let., Vol. 33, 2006, p. L08,604.

Hoffman, J., “Adaptive simulation of the subcritical flow pasta sphere.” J. Fluid Mech., Vol. 568, 2006a, pp. 77–88.

Hoffman, J., “Simulation of turbulent flow past bluff bodies oncoarse meshes using general galerkin methods: drag crisis andturbulent euler solutions.” Comput. Mech., Vol. 38, 2006b, pp.390–402.

Hollowy, P., Chatwin, P., and Craig, P., “Internal tideobservations from the australian northwest shelf in summer1995,” J. Phys. Ocean., Vol. 31, 2001, pp. 1182–1199.

John, V., “Slip with friction and penetration with resistanceboundary conditions for the navier-stokes equations -numerical tests and aspects of the implementation,” J. Comp.Appl. Math., Vol. 147, 2002, pp. 287–300.

Knupp, P. M. and Steinberg, S., Fundamentals of gridgeneration, CRC Press, 1993.

Lien, R.-C. and Gregg, M. C., “Observations of turbulence in atidal beam and across a coastal ridge,” J. Geophys. Res., Vol.106, 2001, pp. 4575–4591.

Mauge, R. and Gerkema, T., “Generation of weakly nonlinear

8

Page 9: Numerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a ... · PDF fileNumerical Simulation of Internal Tide Generation at a Continental Shelf Break ... olution near the bottom and the

nonhydrostatic internal tides over large topography: amulti-modal approach,” Nonlin. Processes Geopgys., Vol. 15,2008, pp. 233–244.

Meyer, M., Devesa, A., Hickel, S., Hu, X. Y., and Adams,N. A., “A conservative immersed interface method forlarge-eddy simulation of incompressible flows,” J. Comput.Phys., Vol. in press.

Meyer, M., Hickel, S., and Adams, N. A., “Assessment ofimplicit large-eddy simulation with a conservative immersedinterface method for turbulent cylinder flow,” Int. J. Heat FluidFlow, Vol. in press.

O’Shea, T. T., Brucker, K. A., Dommermuth, D. G., andWyatt, D. C., “A numerical formulation for simulatingfree-surface hydrodynamics,” Proceedings of the 27thSymposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, Seoul, Korea, 2008.

Pingree, R. D. and New, A. L., “Downward propagation ofinternal tidal energy into the bay of biscay,” Deep-Sea Res. I,Vol. 36, 1989, pp. 735–758.

Rottman, J. W., Brucker, K. A., Dommermuth, D., andBroutman, D., “Parameterization of the near-field internalwave field generated by a submarine,” Proceedings of the 28th

International Symposium on Naval Hydrodynamics, held 12 –17 September 2010 in Pasadena, CA, 2010a.

Rottman, J. W., Brucker, K. A., Dommermuth, D. G., andBroutman, D., “Parameterization of the internal-wave fieldgenerated by a submarine and its turbulent wake in auniformly stratified fluid,” Proceedings of the 28th Symposiumon Naval Hydrodynamics, Pasadena, California, USA, 2010b.

Sussman, M. and Dommermuth, D., “The numericalsimulation of ship waves using cartesian-grid methods,”Proceedings of the 23rd Symposium on Naval ShipHydrodynamics, Nantes, France, 2001, pp. 762–779.

9