ft -4ui ATIER OF A. WORKIA. D t. (RADON

iTWEN:

EOR E BROWN 01 OF AMtF RTs AND TECHNOLOGY

- The pi oy

INTARIO PUBLIC •.',S.ti:RVICE OCAL„

AND IN THE MATTEK THE work-16A of litmlbar Cooke„ So So Ho haron 'tidy Lindop,. Josephine Lehi S ;Indy Masoll. Delyarke Sirityk: arid Dee Dee TOhin

Workl oad R kwn Arb t toward Soly,4

On behalf or the Erri oyer David I:vary

:PAULA .Price

Patricia 'caritegy

Or beillff. (tithe tirtioal. :Dartitto-'Wtt htda.

Sakti ft,,T COOke

Sharon Jeffiley 11,4-,lynne Struyk Dce Dee I °ban

Hearing

ManagernentC Chaff, College .'orkload Morkito.riat.

Nttnaug Autit.,'Nttrsity.„

lem 11-C:bahknI 'Worklod Monitoli Great) Cis float Complainant Compktinant Corriplainattt

000 :in Toronto, Ontario,

A

RODUCTION

The: work idcompliaints, (:1 17 eight Lieu hy membors:h oaring prOgnill („terthifez (704.'

Jo Jo 1,1 ,rtm leffr 14:11d4) .P Sandy Moon :1:11yro, tittitylk.

„;, Add Tiabin) 'Wert , .„ lead Ir'llther curnH.A..atilt% ro0r d n

determitation.„

.7d ,,vorkkmO Ia hing ant whet- . dt. I 1tritanber Were

laitottltd tato t eight .compiairtants: e firm issue itt dispate: wits what I nty,rme

shouild apply far this adnittted violation, . the .-eolltvtive ap,ireetnent

Tht,, 0011mtve 49:00 t ;Fent' tilIMAS boil! :alert her* to devo

dri.,VilItIttent. Three . Moat, MeMbers (Cooke, 30

assigned: lity9tkInod prevented thr,..411 from takittg the Ci Ei4),

*iR:,t each year- to prokaiional.

mni.pland hat -thei.r.

proftNstortal 41evektv.ment

staff of .-fiv .nursowi. rir 't 'o thee, other Toroftto are:a

- urtiversittes attonpung tO Wort niote DISCUMit3IS tivolvirkg the fa.culty

nignams ,nre "Akin I :Iry r •i;t7 . :mrd I rieredAed ntorabon, I faculAy mentlimpi iHoy

and Moon) Au) :Lave beettt tovolvtlii hose, di MAI SS1 in comgairwA1 that I kov h

Nen ;.Litent a „wo RN,' no evtintit On this is ,mo had in mmti: that the 14 bolos

that Mectint vAild Lave been addtttltu thc' t ,,,t' indard %markt fourr zi.$ two thoT

week,

Ftwalfy , •TblhEn :i'itsstetted tradt mAO and .Aligust find Ate_ cant • lained that hcr

I miner li e0,Ching k'issrggittett,: violated ti_h

VI:1)E

tf! r P."' the Sallyteird t'btititioad Parnis

The ,colle ,ctive aoTeemelltr quires= that a. stiipatvignr tarst distitss proposed teaching

usistp.MCIA V44111, . faetrity 1t 'workload,- anima:tent is then la otaratInicatic

ineara or the sturflard workload fotfa ineluded in. the crillectiN4,:. ligteerttertf. I he form must

be :delivered tc LICIA iililber et least ,six. weeis s.• hidm noi ittd hot

prim t , the Stall of he tiNtelling t

Alltbouth. %yrri,c, of "bete I 1rotmbers bad 0 discussitm 'with ,di e gopervisot- regard as. their

proo)stlf .1/4vt.q.kinad vvetks berme ti te Start thiiir 6 :-itrg. swum:1J ocaching

'Wan CV(1y ingarirC thC antekird wilNriktOnd VMS than stx before

the start:of the ass4:4111ten1 la rat Wag One', V. ,aSt lJLII Ut ImAiskac discuss's J. mith the

supervisor differcd from he worklo,:lodiied

kAtployer . tickinoWledged that the standald: ,i; . 3ildoad form .voere kite, Paula Puce,: the

6L4)erViSOr VAG Loiigned the wotkht all, held diN4:ars ,A oms vnh the facility mohbers ittui most

thoiwdiscu.f4,,O:Cti.:9 MCUIted 113(11C thitt 14X. Wee:b iriekt o the begi quint; of the assignment.

StippCtitt :Suer v..Nork who was to, tkyrelikie. the flows had WW1 threr,! weeks of

bercaviment leaw and 0104 Awn after :returning tiwork, Aiksi :milled for' jut duty A 8:

I Login:, the onii err tuft delivered ,ort firm

Ms hie- id the :department h.a.d: Ina& thaermiu m.Nure fliat tki".1 prOble, m would :not

regleektr4 another upr tartrurnix.,3- hld 'been Ir r iirt$. tOLpLtC t forms and steps bid

It takei . te citiStAre delivery t tit tOrm to the :faculit. i, •111:t1111.,. preiriptly _et -

CallIVOtielL MS .Price It this was a one ,,.titai,,4 even( unlikely to b& repeated,

Thelltilett di !F ;Led the requency valicht kd ddiVori y r Standard wiprkload forms

Gommio ddition 10 these tatt: formsor the spt-aag and. wiTirrier ti uS the tIrtuon.

evidence indicated OVA stzat:dard workload :forms It Ni4t5iLott. :1104 been 14c for

the :waiter 2000 term I nt i1me „lowed that there wvare ii-equent

instances of .standard witildo ,41.1brittsbin defiNerol :141 .te nad Aar 54-311,e

had even been delivered aft.a the MUM f the teaching assignraera,

complainants fitfaidedlite,ticatimg on rva.) .Other til*kplait40-411.s.

tritttift s tncteased 0.0 .1.i.bittorali.Pri: among too . uurtnL 1.4.:0 .,sTatos ..„ ow was te:CO:kitralg

surF,cr the eigilth

ofb 1stc assitTotent

:eaching, The :am( volio ,4,ere: atirmiance .clescribed the

k .4"1h4t during,:htr diEsi4::, 11$-svon with Ms tic- her sufthriaior„ npnon3

ihom wrisideted, Oui npon j teathing assipptne.nt tionqg aj AtgUSt, but

he :and .M0 ihilx htdtigroat on Pill ,WAVtincitt:I v n4 :j11:00. W1110 itrVOINed IWO ft.CIN

COMIC. PrePat jet Standard tikload font: 1:.ecrivol on Frikkiv April 2 !fr all

riS5ignitriettt to hgin-ott . ..Monday :May MSoli( 14 said s1 began preparaiitlita after .5.1be

received httr It HOWCM sibc, was witiotetiop - .her wolik

from he wimer "Had she imovin tr what hol AsNiE,TioTtent was, to he she would

have ban preparatioa them Int does thyt begin Ina :preparation mad -41..e ows 'what

hc. Strirq Ow cuporationsIn. ,Qemplicatcd by the fact ..that .she

bine retiovd: after le: 4c,, t112 eeks in the middle of the :grain

lettat and :she therefore had difficulty :cleating with bet replaaerhem Wb..natural y waracti

WOW what : ::She would bc u ivid he 1.10:s Struykcgtimattti: that she had to work 3

o &hours ,fxt .0crwcck Ylecattse of the bite hotification. of :Inc a rtent.: She .s..f4id that it

was alwrdfficuit: to : pitillarc7. tor !Ito Lacti ill the taSt cW WCik Ltem 'BS 1110O.

find •kw:Q.44s . art t ,wsiest Sh uci lit Irytnr thir,f( terrtl. while preparing. for the

- 4 -

pn next was et rig,

zio,o4 amptat mint Ms Tobin ad she UreCIVed her ms Ti.:111Ift .:t1.1: 031 WCalke$' : :..4ktir' A) 1.9.,

floweNr she . --was on protessional •do

be.O.ImnMoi d tpit 24 :fix 10

kvt, aSSitriiMtit. wits isitimottet ittakittng, 44adthtis ticr Nacatiett was scheilated for

and ,3)111g, kod .noti oMere d snprilies, done the cottirsi4.: citriitte„ devekped

exiatI,. booked Ext.est.spealers,„ constitied m, ,it11 tire coinator,, or many othrr dump> which

110Nied tole done, le said1i im1d u def, Lh thir r mt. be -own Iiirtr uiu she

•aartin. to te4ielt July • ,th titstwerkio:p;cAy her

thirdconipt untit t slid that ..ra h tttaidard 8SN:orkioad: form had (Ii

WO*, sl.t; bad lx:eu. 44:w .!4:tre volfith , :touir.s.:eliIi WI S . . tetteb li.(411 her

0g :with Mg AK!: 'was,,•ntnNil1iegm, i'Terate TOr utaielein until .she rectived the ibrat

With th arrtail assigurnota I I1):401-t,, 11.4.11 11 11 Ifl da:IA.(3 sss the

swainSitvotil teach 7 111 1 40 d wec,Ind 7 weeks: of the

lit 1u and . .A.ugust, AS' the teacher for the s.eesculd R Ithe ,.00,01$0 . k I nn been: assigfted,

she" hadA0 att orgae&zAtiri.. of Tr -1.af d other 11140 a two

PIttiOd .ktbot the course sffirted hit th ii lb tiodh h

to her -wintarterm :avows, 4 it :that iho• WOuld be math better it she had had the

6 vweek. period to p

hfrray s :aidth. La resuit of her :wiett,Ertg INith M rtico, she, had on

n:mro;teci tench cP:rs 1 tt. ,ixotiose g haLl h hot prepailltior that .aatitipatea work

When Ole Mwival wiakkjiild She reati!wei tft4 hat 4s4.1gomenit was different than 'the

one ffiscussva: he thus :11E14 to 'begirt her prepar ations aott, Sh ndi Lated that Jic : tertd9'

perroctionist and :does or it like If) 1 hirtAs a( the last Taitatte, thal she dms not kv

to , it a gilt: bas had to da hereii had mai c. titre ',she wvnild havt bccri

tat. oucto,140.'

-tiNy tiaac

they

Mad expea, are Fein b

I itell se

'111 , war, fow

tittitt$ t. ondo,

schedii[ad ter td..

ha' Lotto invets

t. that • r wt,tr

tv/.2, NI a

met

The"1% r tit. rot devehyparcat

thE

vollabmin

vtar., 25 arbitrawn hearing

Prioe of t'i' workload

ahools: fonts,

o

cep t 4,; ated

r

nipment, would Itmv ed idec tbr u course and. '.11iJa

provoll lit TA it

atii tio: d

Cooke,„ .J'effroy and W.Strkly

oproont *Jaya,

Price repti.1: tit sltt s Cf

of thC woibrik- • ••4 tro.r4L, t4vvov

ifitw Aiuld plate the . 17, ritdo„)r' roembees

at the: collabora it • ,-.40

. ut imply .volgo tta add hat. gontent

t.:1vattone pt4-iitton, :Anne would re ,y...

Uj .11LA:t icel that she stitmid,

6

Summer Tearlimg

:170biti w Hndtl): "Cach

eril.,:c4) to: durirtg

pri.ce feRportie...d that :the non !had tleted, fuly tind "gust fOr

mrs s..0ropqiel ii.ssigTted ( nc fttlty Slit.

he ties 4.1 attirh

usm.,tt 3, rt.itlitioit •

tIet. 11).sel1 te, of voluoto-ars, ate the

Nice nrtdorsto:od. IMS 'Tobin

to the stionc- gurnoi 'The: possibitily :of t 4 7'1 and %AS Iv

:dim;tisstd ttb Ms Tobin m the lequircd woit.idoad discussix,r4 hit Ms. Price ' had

updastot:id that rsils Tobin referred the thy and Augusi ;156A;gArait Mitch iuvoived t:cac [ling

COleSr5 Stn.' had tali previously,: Ms, maid OITA under dm rotation syslcrti Ms Tobin

huu noroulerg3i ii

the vtmrtet . tosc:lting tt.-was.

1d, hoi Ms 'Ibbln iid i pr4crence

I.VireCiFt?Y'MSCVSSIOIT

expiLiineddot

ening the: stAwit 2m15,1! on whit+ thc parI isked for :my con-yrnetos,

Whott these 4a,s,c3.1 cattuz ‘lef..ite tie or:kJ (tad Ittnrittaring ort,c of tilt goyer

inetrittas had a coalliLA.: of ca.hCs \We:n deud lt ci The Empkry 11'

tanderstood 1JU 1.11 41v would Ile eoitsiciero:I tthe ai ling Ow following t;ail: wilco .): itic

Employer Imolltd have art alternate ntetnbeT pre.I but the ectfiiplat tints and the Union

Teii:Troti t comploints to :inc.. ofidnati dutioit arbitnitar:Nni g '- WaS taken with

:tha rcrenA dtt, but kaistr4, -horn th ;it reb,:',:rtai. Nvois 1 .1R1 grIQ-.,..4:it,ito Whether, under

eachigii

Intaxio Come 1, of fot'

Ontaii.o Public

revata' the

t1odive,

and: 201ittok

t Lvy ovisiLltis ullleetk%k'

w. aj-,--- k...kiciad 41a t Er .41... w the s this

is ands thaillowatwt

profossiont .klevotopmebt,

,latt hj4:. figlOW101A

feellefit thq NUPCMS0( and arid th diet '31 e. t ti

ttidt tonAbty

AiSt

(a) facty Mt wrs: itewvtred, the is differ ertee their

dat.rmIces: address

arbittla.:0t:

4k o motuton n g, p

1 To twot : , :aa4ags.: '1411 saribtf,: by: con: , :0, 41 , 1 (,:r Aiill: •not. excit t• 1: noi3.., i .N.: to,: , li , to 36 VV ' ..0.t, 1 li. hif.*: 0 lea: Catitad: :II .W.Ii3: 14 fijr teatfic16 jag.

.. 7ig..0 .::3Ift.::030::1:::ftfituiii : t 40,, :7.1.-w ;7177.,.<. ria.et 1totio iltlito ca$,,e. .not :in. :" Iii.NeCiAlitity,rt.'

4i=9 cletrac loes4 amp its g d

IS 01 be c (8.; 131diePtif e• teachiug contact boats rifItittited ho .o rat attion

attithated boars 1170" nntilitA t '1.00 Z01 t voliap:igimentot : functiore.,,,

rking cta oks

114)2 A I Pirnr to the otahlWimitzt of a foaltillido.ad .for may teadter the. stapervigor th Npo4.44,1i. woldood •With the teapiteratiti . i-toroplete! .the SWF, attached ag Appendix L to

hn: provided by the Colko. The stiper*or 111 eye: oopy the tenhex 1atof than tibc: wcek.N.

Orttl •Mth owing rthe period cmered by the tirmable euludlothold4s. owid vovatiorks, It :46 if • swr i#:sti.b.Ntiettay levied rh ronete ; - wiLt mg be dale .witheut priot

consultation vkidithe leather

I I Al2 A 2 The .swr all d r L rth e total wvtrkinlid ineluding eaehiatt coot .1ct‘ beim 112M CAPIO n4f d ttd t each cont 11041 t intinh gt dAC Oirmt 14 , -WO *Rd

114111ther (Y1 pferiAtal l'1,Tict eva hiationikaork the cqtrictdUlti, !;,.,; .ottaitAIL 'PI u Ct VF, gu,vc, iruaTucli4Tri nrld- ecuiplem ,,,totary 14niLtiotiF,

11.02 A 4 En t1 evi,irit that the teaktion • is not i oproarmt with I 11nd it tit) be teviewed by t WM,C,J, the teRob,,..T 110.1.1tit :indicate in '04'01 I Li tO Wcitikitt

wential!• days fticart (lath it.itTrowird ofthe SWF,

(a)-I e or ttI diftertV.00 ftoto, th pu4.n.d.ott, applic4tion„. adminigrati.tio or i4:11.egoil. coitittavetitintt o it.„02i h 413.111: 504 di a'

INitia 'the tenchees::itittnettiate Mg: diamaf.400 ..oatt iplace Avithiat 14 T the ol4)414'11:StAnC:Qa 11,101.1k:' ' rise twthe . bave Ovoilrnt,4

C

tiitiZticii tt irt,Liudw. rn$ ,Aorkload nr;,,,Arivireittg rentral It the C.:43[04 e and,olirng

inequitable a its Etn iunit reviewitig specific dist-mks nit glIgh 1: ' I (12. A 4 a d.;( 1.:.41 A 6 .) yid whole pos6kAo rtlakingii rid a tilirri ,

I 0 ,04,' 41:844-41 p, individual WOrL

d8.0frintiv.:..intci where requested by tic Ueadi.e.r . or the tvittg the disputes;

mokhig IVCCIIII3Ifendridi,14111 ,

11:03 1114..- *mimic yew ,a.1.411I itat month* 4 durition and AWL tU , beI.I tittle tht, Cat to de q),,, he rim in Sqlterottet to thet tu ri JUDIC The,acliiernk... year

shall in al:pi tv,,,f)14 tlearCil lear4onott opetation. and ,Atere a College: fleit,zrmines, the w.t.)-4 .4g, .<fl prograirtVll‘TArige. that hi u. er .311, oirit : or both t the months of July attd Aup,ast th ill . 4! ,erit a 4;34.J1.. ,11.i rotta AMA basis,

he ted or -atiOo ..afolro. ay ' th,g.

400t311.-,4 weretitte , Thc

fr.oto of the ittfili

3ka tztryV r The do,

„Q. was. oppliv.p

Erri %fads:

111 1.ita0 .0 IpoptiS,

ti-4 VON

'0144 dr:a03,a

14:1 subrai ITIOnc 'OM

tatf .!,4) 115, tO

owiel that th

, A :Ira, IsittetAtt,,r • 414.. JP: reptcst 7rhe

1,p4nrind W f;.104 prior "Li) . lie 4..,'0.tilL11

vacation pelinds„

144•PCS 1 dr 10 , 4431 a onsonl

cons Ac„ ROA, resolving •

Posr tati -THr-

11„ Om t viu.:l i, c e rip Ert

.for . tr460.41,5, the p fOT ,14 r1:> took lartn.: Id the

inuttorwos that iii , ITC"' Tr 9n :',011.4, the

t5,01,0

I ola .r o$" F a.

Coriefe , WI nclbeir oribe vAerftion :ik tit

cAtion: witeddi may be :cli„a welt the iC7, Bop agret ,A ti3

on. liCITUC

siixviovi allrywc 4 toatiler pl.tt

bad o„ mambo- olinst: korikloo,

timi •Hit • ti.1 t .11-at t orther$: had

but That vv..1 glatift.:

that co,

tot•

and ails 111:4:4 0

provided VariCAISo

010141. 'be

-the difit"...t

-de .,PLitie

that d.. yrn

_Ltit iagllvtdLnd b:

permy,

muld be. Wised c a.fOontiln b)

the forni

coullbe

adif4id :4. mi(.L.:r.lkload t'abtl.

iin R tibUte

ihr r profes

mploy tailure ti 4°

a.gre contemplated

ion lt ro

three or TITOR

f d e wintizr

LEIL-1

EckIssiokrt

tonalaged

tab

WiarldOad 0

t rhe, n. low"

Azussed Tuld

Jthet

101

:::d ix :041(4d ibtrIS s

t Li L aid no, 7..„.loplvtottt - ,e. I.

ion ask-od: that

111t ,of S,P.

talc rkil

te . th_at. the. 4)1ere liaL4;

ad

L

iratirstri , :11-141s ad e 2:4 to till

at

ri r hel-

Rip

Winton); )ril7r?

Apphe Arts cold e nco

•niklY ollogir arvi hltar00

9„ 1995),,, toiropotte

Local 242, and Niagara Coil'

1!!...951, unreponed.

(Ittion . 141,61...mr • 41: ei. .1,401.4.4

11 -

compIementant .futicelotts,. tha tequi.temoutto :schedule va,4‘::ations. 1-n

sattd Aiwa To, stheaute aVaCatiort i. M M 141-11e, tdirifig Lhiwallerato yrao, and

lwittethite ttachingitt :July Awl August was thus of Article 1 L..01 B L 71110

too a. eke atation :that th Emplover hact violated the coil eLt rctm.schednithr

Tohih h in Jkily and Aiaguati,. Tho Ukitt. :asked :thAt dircct that Ms Tobia riot haw

to wach Ole dsS1

F. alLy. the tilattcys had val reikliva to tlic 1 j tttt grow

uudr tLi I A2 A. 4 not 11 W ith the stipetwisor •%.1t.,S

'The tfoim . s:ad tbr c inV Lnuler Atha 107, A

plattin the rileeting5kid iwiutotthL $tiaintard Uui1 It Artle I 1„02 A.

(a) rut !.-= to Atter L1k1U1J

" • Uniloidirt otted gilt to:Im. .kUu.Wthg awards: ai vanc ThthTic S'entree ::ftmloyeel

.Local 24,4 and piimlarez 014:1 Tcchnokof fltkIke a'nd other()

Ortobtx 23.LL catrcilorted.: (VisrhiteloNtd: and at Novemter8. 1995),

altror a Pubfie Scn .ve dval .242, 0/7f11 49,11:

and reChri0.4:frgy (OVOrkikielid arbrifrilnan ...0i13y,tristmtg 0011.a.CS

). (Migeti 1990, wirclr14

PG

rett1dYfor the li..ate .1,0*10 .Laril.y(T said. there Vi: 1,011f.telft.

tehtfiltft 10 Lippat $tatrr . .ib.senk,'"e7.., The }tmikyc.r gad this vms

request In

There

( y

cIrLy:..1 .vxt the .t,,,::,.010ver jji nssiqi.. teoetrg.m.. anri it regni red tun hou

not a ilectirting probiellit and th.ai. trate .47 wai5 appropriate I eViiitid Idcciaration hat ibt

assivirrient Was )04:e, The c4.3 rneavirs iivoLvd. had suffered up. bass or ditutukge as a.

resull of tin Empk i (Anton cif th 't-item The Ein Dyt„T at$0 said that I Quirikl, riot

gatiVfMi.10:

• tv.ity • Irlemos,

of tour : -ztat'vt1.1esibc.. e. sot:: ittnr or the

.A. the professional clopnierit

Eli e Firiployer (14,11P41 :11411 it had .vlalcd.

wroilent., Ntotlily triembets. h.w4 rsFhili fal15..0 .104j. tro 011ak0 a p:VIrOaail

for how th..,04; . vend that time ., yotto had nook a piliCipOS:4t bad

sztotumolatIA ..', Cure ; no sp tf fl. that the vrrtpfoyor iidvoirliheld :ig7:cerilent to tot:.

eVent the oi] iiv tive ifiZr • be 44.101ATd. 10 dp

.tiert •( •31: thr .E.10 „...1121yet to .1),n thc 1 .0 da. . rtittliiltV 'to lake the . 10

Itiz oyer NI that the.titne.Ji iittance lie ittitSing Raittark,i,oti

btp..t: S ....44A that,. it th faculty bC i ncluded .;01o, d Am:ik

rrierrit, W41:5 then rn ar Cvrtittlk::: 17.4,1:9110

Some atter aire•, The

penriitred iLtitdet Iii tafort:.4.!tnent,,.

J' %r! a wofkload ltiAt

A IfOr Tobitis aelitarloyersaiJ Oct uodir Artide "." mil eduled

40,11 ,4 •17.10 AiuCatip:t StbeT Utal :ll July :and .,AuguSt, Article .11,03

it be done on a: et e: tOtatitlin li$: M3 Price umterstood that :Ms Toliinvousehted

vatittrist lady la :shawl .1trtql gig to teachitot ttcw ,cotases Ntly

oto- L4tit,mativc,iIc PVi1 4: had ;hem . Wafk: On rototionit

nd the evidence ittdicatelfthat. M. IbbiliNittra ...aelyin the: r1.1 'was ,.4pproachirig...

hIti -ation the fairloyir wir. .A1LuJi the s L1p.p2rt stai ter scr

Art iA:1 .,:15,42, su titat the natation of mural:ILI temebid4L: ;:ind Vat atioo hmild belivied

attcl thc .Eml o had &Inc thi s,.

th ptoyer said these com)...tuttts involved. 10.1-ctlecs tctuAirt

ides I fill

and 1 L02 .arid !lbw 4i I. 2 A.45 the utupkiinrtffl . reqq.ired to first

weir complaittts with thottlolpenisec

Net.,,usloNs

Late :Cteirttery ffiStiMtett Wrk..f0,rors

'tat Pi:34N pød tho. stai44461rd . ,;! . 704114 4 .vere dehverdd .Laic 'The patteS

Ofl:Mittilr.=L!1.3..S'

S: 'ear particst. a oatieclive apcorromt are required to follow their

001Leeive ogreerri ,mt Whien *r3,,5 belt, the Erricoloyer violates e collective

ICANCS itself open, t0 1110f fig (4.34 ti 41 ( :*)ri ro s teror, t7y,

CIASC trIOIN3 . thk::: EtaplOyer C-(1111ptrISItiat th •.JnI)k>ees who

ViOilalifTft tVialetaly ,C-C)011141,„i41,14311i C0111.r0:1014, tit fl kkttnif arbitratiOn: irt the! t44tirts:

45id te,rite4y lev.b.tra otle ifty Viedities In Aigroz stifnits. itresalt,

But notL triortenir, "terne. .suiiiered ShOUld: be CItOfl ii Mad

COmpensattfor it5c the nvolved„ .A trton..elary remedy shouild. twit be

.0410WPUCIt eLiV tIor: rthisilt5 . the for its violation tit:the.Agrocoltnt:,, rtOt

N:644.04 it be ono valid" tyraid s a, witutihtirt Ufl jP.F the te4Qller,

rtplk t did r t do wit'. coad iriterit

tictotfing tite etioling of

14 -

11° 3

could h ed env so

emp oye

At wk." faro

S 1,1111C 1.1041's

iiiiiio su h li 3ro 'DIN.

r . ( tC4 ' ' t the : turno hat M1C

uort that the Employer r ttes tit

The 1 . idi Ited that it had 1 do, i - late

401,43W and

02

•

'the various

kto,Y

hhe deit y appeitrol to

don r

:ail c cpi Et I re,

it "61 1

IkLad forms

o all tout.

The t qudnh 1- ty MOM

Shi,-itild airtants

hc tont \12;"; ..ad she. haL

ttetrTqT with NI s Pit t I, firm

jri tina envirm Horn, 1. the

Ws to 'wait tor their tewhittg was

a SU C a rf that shot I litr,e

fr43 VrItSt is situ 'that

plo

41 4 et

fro oh r e bad

',:fita for t cuftv

.art to p. h. there

reinimiw pact .e

x-,priiate for them.

lc- 41114,. 31 . hirlk t 1'00 'V.i re

some measure: t. tartly

asse:,:sat

ript pit)),

worild t t

1444(1) had I I L i Ifs

ati.)013

est

tt .- tilft I dare d. tiw '4 .),.' - I that

3: a att$t:xt The • 47,cfryptal..ttatt itv, ) ,lie Vrt: it)

IT ipti.,(0)1,:. tO f.)4,„t!: , witil tit

[ 1 Z s , i.;. E1

L Icss r

haw h to Flo ne in an

COM

0.,ct sh.ortet tne, had.

wadi: I d

• voile! .1, 'Fpoke

offi-r• • tick 4.18

s d tio1-4 to (11.14'

t find that it appro . Yard

runcias: vrototrit Colleetive

ety volvipt(,c

Lk

r ate two vd

Tht Jim Ci'''t I ther :4e ocks . 31e. 11 41kiliv-,-',p..0 111

iment 0. dev,;,: detay (Tr catty. ti .1 v ..

del The ..tt: ,f Ill'. 43 VS onet lig A l.a ''' C lattSide: si

tile Moro hours4.f pr •• ate

abut oat tytad

0100:111111: NI • t I

OWS

'patt :003ztli Teta JOBxturj roatom

tro 'utte.nd lint) fallgylilv 72 .9mdud A0pam, JO Vr1.041 .1.0(1440.14 0041

t, palmlo c4 'AT C

in Tx*" 0411. 41.1ck paputiol • sn.td. 40 .Z .0X0

kw. VIM , • VOA( iT0424420 11 1 OIet SVEM:.:,13:icorktra frawk.str.twa." JaqttInti:

o;:top. IWV 310.3.0

tuk* atp.

J t p j ..apt irg $0.434(10110 anti

JO : leizo'0 si) van 1llawaladi ourpixiavo attl j.i Ao0301) 0.09 rm, .01 pappo Nag vium

otp. atopHam 11U1.114:1 Nij Silpjj:P 11110 . 04). ”tk1-13 04). I..: 1. Zi3utttp

zitit 111 lr plud. Wrig Aptn-lp Stat 5111$ aittliZ;:'.07 vaau zig moms

4plittm, d •tofiruilvarddt0 . otp, soptiol 04utoxidol...mis

patkil lit VI q n. 00041.9$ jo •01 rtio: up: :wok owls -0A.Rig 'A.mrS „TO: % 'Olt par:

:10111,:m.f.): N To' it 094V P t1V f 1. 0 I tHorl!'“V I 11-171. '01 P081:41mioli.ottio804:44

AsEo pue: jalslulvr!, ;AA. 71 pr yits :'41111:1•0,;):os -: :;11.119d01.4.1cittkil tittp;15 szurtitS

frrtpytrpts os rn zqui smut trowato ,s214735tip1 14p4A0 qt Jo% FUR :11. op ,01: "Inv

:41119 oto 1134.11tv rnp pAlom. -up:pclotaktto, AJst ago 'AsirtA 'SIIICakM1

aykt

pai .000.10.1 "'•A•• 41.141011.4 .4311:01 14.4.31140:474:06

i;loct : 113 Ott) . ..iNtp.M.$1103 rag &I' II 0100 ;$11 S! fl 'uomppu

°$zii.317.001, 7490 .th 4Vr1 LU„Term 'Flri);.!41, 00

talq. pupa:Jaw "poptvv.4. 1.1 LI 17 ,5 pittrIttl Q14 juit Did J0 . 1344111t1 041 atot S.:.titp

"suuol pooploW. p,4" -tkovT Tvip ttalltirdZUCh :10,1 plNittptt 11111,I w papatawr sAilm

0)11 Nutmgoidi joir4 p•-wart piron plloppon•pierni$ am. :1,14 .4tompp 21131

19::$4174:03, puuP I 1 qqft vim N.109'P'4dar,td 01.1011.1:.N.Atputteu:

91 -

177

As tn. .xmpk •ons :Am 4 . 1,..axadatd, wo•ektoad u ci.rh . d.ti ed 3

ta

VJf ft.h hall prVA* ere :ettribotedtbrprt *ration: The dgs 'wider this ibnr.uh.

wotild astithaNkiE •

3 x $15.:00 $36i1..00

Ike %-01.' to , Ogrripott 171

fartlit •110: egleo.hato the . aAtillir:I

:41ito41..ei4li II14 ppk w Wririttibt: 10, the . Odwr . i.7,74afrOptairta..atg • • At did not

teStifYJR 1Y11tI in the coraplaint ft offer Rtnriberg vofftich i being iss.,ued .. at: the game

th Ico•ntitided that 1 id RE sftffetett from the late del ,tveryor

tii:N:irktiottittlartrt. i ia 111115 r051.1bIC - that $fArtt(!.!.. or . 011 . •of the other thir conliantkant• in this

case t1.14 not incur . :=8ny ,ettlitt..„ • ft(ft. tiOW ordaint„e Employer !to 4,-.Artivertsate the:

.,.;thet river :eeirlitainant., I diteo-Me . •,Etteg to, collsit" r thi g mojor

b:046 .11g„ 10,1hgthOr gitta chinn..tor .. tiAiiwip•:,s :could bojo.444,0.ntod,„...t.it to,„

di1ku atos Idit he cakailiated, I. IRR to de3, 'wth any claim . tin

parties are tilVihtiz:- reSotlee,

on this imalt Alnibir tgt4thLA,w1 :tr.' : LL ,01 Arbitrator Whitek.v;Iti m -

c.,±77ipira

caleuillatint

thew

White It rirkicat h asonitig,1 h itt,,oprod diflotee.t itnetb041

whii.411 MQ17,12 11CCIS4iI:lly lACifetS:the kng• .i•1:41';•PO

tc.pcal ate trionev 3 s nOt: paid 113 witupensaotort ifor the %wok done,

11a, kir -o,litich have atrew4y t1•.0 paid fr theos.401 ntataut. This money

is init(.3tiiett tO tompeasw.e: to t 0.)m. oinonte

0114 DtJj1me Lo

It!LE0t,

zotilryr7 30, at ttoa ow '” tt :to

43trimi olgthcm 'tug stint) luattlxkluta,vop

VOA\ pluu

p IllatudApADp pncols id al. ns,,; .spx124. 'Kg

Jot

Sue. trtil

Jaq

10Imo " I

zint ttrit utcra

1100puns *no uo I.V-7111 17j1,111. trIM p=1.1.

)14 IAPh D110

11, TR 'u:1 -,Tatton jo

.111 tvoctit.

Naso.otr

lropq poq imser 111' oigt

UFEITYVI011'')-

01 ;FR.. RIVE) 904;.;

r. 4 op.,.

ow twit top 1: pur ouop trIK Itim,a uto: .111.1:0110. p

tE1101,,s.;) Sipn 0.# „AINs.OH

pfpl Wf4tWattttN

ip ,0.1i:111043.

A4tiv,.1

0 u4.

• "LtZt )ittet ato J.91 41- -

J.41T5'

;7.43 .q 774.14.1

4 4 'S0:91p

asnw

qttoo

7,117:444:1'.,

0

4 111-m,v.-4 Ix! 11/

ha ve no authority too en-163'4.x wistonS,

Lirroetint :Pds n. ht so i, valet" u otiou mnsets the 11P fl akinnt.

thi itsinient

wolidilati MUM kwc LFilLfilld 'any votottg ontr giatted by thc Emirjloyer In. declining

7,t1

the -atteadatim 4.0 these. ollabormive :nursing tnoetinv to the two hicWy tnentivta,

1vre*wu. f the Einp: r had assigne %Neck it. 444 have:, it sharlted, reduced

other or atisigurious Were); .L epm.dit otall work .0 withim the maximum allowed in

l}t f culluOive a :ectrwnt

I now adthi the. ..rteac;. :trigrtrneit

41!0 :: . votikiti;aii a tt hrt trti10:01 1.1:, at 1114 I I..:

trttOY" .0hurprovng fiLittoidinite 111 irtter)ittott Artleh,3: 1101 and; V2 but I

IflthiliiniAgoice the Union: aIed th Ff1t , iUlated Afldt ti .01 P 1 ty using hittiv and

june forMs Toinift.. vacation m1 d krif reservilig, thc:tn 1 .br Lompteineritary .filt1Ctions and

4.Meia Mere, t frewever Arovic I 3d3 ci tii y tUt round t caching

4 (ANN tcachiriStO bc's assigla.1 in July ttdJa &wont eit 1o t or rotation bjsis, lii

ctidence indicates that the 3418 decided that ;inr (Add be taught on a, ea,i . 0111314

• from L. evidence. •cit.)1c1431dio, ,ittat .Ms.. Tobin cnd to ..;tt.iity and At.

4417,40?.w hag tigpd faculty ør : totAon: seniority t develop ns ratatiori, and

.is Tobi. was. :soon &It soranwr -:$ipitnottt„ I: 'find no violation 01tL in

A ,4t:Complai--1$.

te tither hart&

differen,,,ce ari$ing

e) A 5 1110 which far 41,01

thu, isttorprisando, At.lpittsttion:, Iministration

14-

20 -,

1lL dismite . mho • 4 toirtpiLltinaints Ilya" ,(4.15(ussia.13. f their "workload

vorit0,113vth Iteir .supwoistyr .artt,$t!, dud:4K ,Owttver opd 'that the

prties ..htli .nn ..k jetzt Ahem '''t consitioltilow

I will cdilvicii

w that thepartics:-

suhrnissi cats oft this i,sstie may flave: Inert ihcoirtrt-

.ft,adim-tNt) , tnavrions *tic I. *fittrm F:tr warklotttl wmplattit9.. dus :tinct. I. j 3 C ,,„,. 41,..,Ripports that view :m speaking. of COrtiplirit115 tOritteir role 4.4 the other provisiritt

nnaViSiOnS allOW r#M) thi it w ni orbitairtinft access . t.t.tc- 'istxrkIsmd.:111ntriilyting,

it the gra: I.:t. thi•

fi'yr the refr:rhkolt prOb10176 44ricsin!--

4 1 14 that ltni3st prob! ,

Arbi.trator., Jr. ..Article 11 02. A. 4

the: .10.rms And

Atitifict trti, itits mmtnet.,.. d be

some probteno ittay dot, be, ' ',igt.,pidterri: throttit 1,07044,,e,,,$s the itgrtTlittl•

Artitte '11,02 A.: 6 •fi,), ottotttot Irc,410: of,'41:1.cessW t.,.....„0..doute

rairge

:0 the: boa.,io have 41, codn) •4:0171100inti: !As, lootteh: ttio.

:titfld4fd. workload fortrt aro addressed; under Artinie 4 obit 'whom re,toTod,

udriktoad f.LUU1 thur Is.no• ,,.:Natte.,,itker-4. that there be a distassion of that

pt:t mtiowever,. Villa he rtme.rabered that Article A. 1,, (a) there

requirern.ctit that 4,1:: fl1 tht dis.enss- Inc propoled ) .NN:?,r1(1.oad prior

to th ibiisbiT iii of a oad;as 000.4100(.:: to this usehL1 idi p1.iinw1 onet

disenssimi bnL :nefl thustnetlisor

-requttoni.etit not contairitc.1.

with Ms Price illoine is itt edtkir-otteritfbr

the Itiellity tis.ember about dtod kuc. Adam-

tin t02 itvi44

diffe

21

;alumni ' rue

l'Ad arise t point duri

olved taro ki

vas fix teamm, eve.,

pies pracee

lek 11,01A 6 4‘..

Tkload fcg

- 1:11,01; or

3 tatetitig, th. tile; LIITC

ond, lit my

1 bet'

spif

rq.1.L

Prt

triS

A 4.

tutu:

e ve.ii‘

Ng]

and k 1.114gr

solveci h:

'and art(

likely

t tifiti

ft • II' 4.1 t-

444iii4IS

aw. N.t in it

tr t

kie..0ther 10417 tompl ui7 at

1 thC pa

late deli% ay ofititir voFidoad

the „lawn and Employer

he yr! ti ovt.

de MLA 1

Tie Eup lid not

LITZ! L 111121111 a

"Road the co.t.taboy 7.10111tig raeettom,

difi not rrcj ett ut a5 .,..,.!iittiirkgM Tbi.n t told) in the

•ortfmter tilt.

retrain ,lsed

any matter wi

may arise:iiitho utt" ..:letilajtatin.. of this

awafd.

Dated

Ontatio tins 1301 . 1 f'Jung, 2000

1NOttitin:41: R coityg ..Affittra.tor