our of c ^^ pu^suqn-t ° x^vj b^ _^ftm ^^le's cs vk^^^^^ ^^ *1 5ls, ^`^m^ ^`^q^' ^ ck od...
TRANSCRIPT
^^ ^ 5 :SLA?^r ^
^ OUR-1- OF^^t^
^U,t.i.^. i
md.^^^^ ^._.
7
^ -^
^e5^ ^^u ^^ ^^^ ^^^^ pon AeTi-^C)^^^^
-^'^-^on. on - so a^ a.^ ^^'6cvm ACL-+C^f.^ ^ ^ ,^^^ ^^ ^^^^^^^ 1^ ^^^I a^ on S; in
^ ^^ ^^^^^ ^ ^^^^ ^L Q ^^^ ^^ ^me:n a -
C>^h^U°^ ^o°r^ ^ v-^^ ^^e- j-^ 2-, a^^ ^ ^ ^ ^^
-1-L 7-Z^^
^ ^i-A^^^^l-Q^=^ecli 1^ 'be- cAe^ 8 e- ^.a I
^1: ^^^ieci ^^^^n a^^ ^^^ ^ o^- -'Me- cx-w:s m Also
^^^^ ^^^^^^^^+ :5a^^+e-^^ "4
"^ ^^^ fe:qie-W - ^^. ^ne 8r^^Ke-+
^
I:^^^^^^^ ^^^^^^ ^^^ ^^ie- cl^ ^^ ^^^^ ^^ 2-6175.
;. ^cl ^0 i2ha^ In
ZC^
"he^ ^^^^^ ^ ^^ ^^ ge-1C,^^^^t
ir
c; ^ a
Ckt^ in°"
^^ ^^^)le
^yi
hi-5 (3ffic^Q^ cDuy^
NIX^^cps
^ l D^^^CL S
♦ l e. 0 ^ 9 A +.
F.V^^n C,^ Z5 ^^) CA I r^ q^
^^ ^ ^ (^^^^^ )clcxl^^ ^Olpc-^N^ 1:5 a on ^^e-e-
g^^^°^ i ^ ^ ^O-8al U-n + c^^ 13 t o,°n
^° ^ ^^^^^' â ^a^^, ^ yyl`^alcl O'n t ^ ),rou.y)cl,5
Fo, cc^^^lc^V^^^ ^^ ^^ ^-qptf^u^^^^
^^cl Wim o •m <^^^^
U^tl
^ ^ ^l +3,,3^ vi^rem e ' nc .e ^ r
5 'V
^. ^^^
5^^^^` ^^vi - 6)^io
y 9L Q, ^'g
-, 1 ^. ^^^^ • F^ ^ L90 V 9c^ e ^^'0.: .}
^^^. 2-cl ci b^ ap ^0^5c>If /
C C>M, -m o'), ^^ bwl °^ The ^^^yi q).k
eY,. ^ ^^^^^ ^^^^+I^^^^^
^^^^^^ ^^ ^^^^^^^ ^^^^^ 5^^^ ^1Uo^ ^ l)i gfc^^^^) -i11lq I k 16 1 ( q^ cils) IZI I,
11 ^ ^ ^^^^^^^ ^ ^^^^ 1 2- (q3 ^s®
^ ll 4l ;Sc^l I n CA ^ ^ ^ ^ ^^^ Ae,
^^ Onct iwls couct sees
^
or w ^^e-n+o
rn^ p^^^ ^^)^ ^e^,fne
.5Co yt^-8°^ 3g- ^&d
^ ^ e-441 8 +^ 835c^^^ e^{ ^ ^
;ck,^ ^.
. ^^ ^^
41
^^ ^ ^ 7-1 Tile ^ Cian
J4>
S63 Ke. -L ^^t'K.
CD6^^^^^^^
c,;5?. ^^^ ^ ^ Z^ 12.1 Lo -7d •
- - - ..: e •,aa ^_.gs^^,^,^„^^'•;9 8 7 C =J„j_.^
Lk^'5- ^^^^9^^° °^° •^^ e ^C_e q
°^^ oNil c 5^ 38 ^^^ ^^ ^^ ^ ^^^ . 21 _76L-1,U .mCAI o - v'Q l
^ ^^â ^ ^°^^ ^°^^^ r^ `
^_y:nAQ^^^^^^^.^^^^ ^ect^Aez In" ^ P i-^
^^^ RossC^^^^^ ^nzi-fr^uli o -n^ ^^ ►^ ^►^^; a
'me.^^s *> ^ft
^^ ^ ct^8 L,2'an ^W,5
^^) ^ ^ ^
s ..,-^^
^C^°^ c
^
^
^ ^ F WA"4 "T
^uIT-7eel as i^.^ +^-te,
,^c. ^ s t^ o'^2 ^^^^^^'Y,c ^ .^,5, ^1a`^e ^ ^°^ I ie^ Q n u
o ^, ^ Ac,- ^^ic> n
-li
cl
:8 ci Y) 8
^--s^w of o*My Cometaston 6cpkes MMH 07, 2098
Avvif2`^^^.M0
^-q P^^5-C-PJC-S
Qkt
^Q f5L C
AF F D A N1 d
5 Nntca^^
^M ca^^e_r_^ ^.a^ 4IVIQg^-6 ^ .:.
cl ° 8 Y rp^
^•/a m^ ^ ^ ® ^^g ^ '^^ ^^^^^^ ^^'^'^' ^^.ck "^^^ s e-
-OZ5^° QYO OcQ n^^cc^,kA i^
Af^^^1^v.0 e
^,^,On^:q^us 0^i
-. ,e -n ^ I C^c;;^^O^^ ^1, ^' `^'^,'^^^
eOL lyt Q-n a Ziq_^
^ ti Aia^ ^+
ck'^^1 )^ t^o^^^^i-Ocp49b10^^lA^^ g+ '®
^e^^ ^^zc^
. s . . ^ + . ... S p > ,
•'^^*^
8d81AA111S^.^^1-AiN- -PUf)L-'l C_
STA`^^. 0F ^^
P'w yi+;2^ - ^^lite- on ^^ ^*^^rn^ ^^uy^^
^
ce
^' Cc:°^ `^.c> `^°^ ^i
1'! AFFIVANI ^ ^F NO^
^^+ Yli^^
n cxn^^c^^ epo^f'-^ ^o^ c1-n°^ata^^ C;^ra, ^^6'^^^^^t^°^ ^ +^`^
cl^
c ^^ Pu^SUQn-t ° X^Vj
b^ _^ftm ^^le's CS vk^^^^^^ ^^ *1
5Ls, ^`^m^ ^`^Q^'^
Ck ^od ^cucl+ 8^,
,^ /C^^'^^-^^7,c'2^^UL d ^-"^
Usa M aROwrN
^y A^pR.1 Mstate of ow. ^'Y ^Q^ ^^1rp^Ww14971 UOy 6018
t O/®^^ ^ ^® ti^
^C^^^^^ ^^^^^ ^ •®°^j^f^9^^^;^*tq
Court of Appeals of OhioJuI3GEs
GENE DONOFRIo
JoSEPH J. VuKOVIC1i
CIiERYL L. WAITE
MARY DEGENARO
COURT ADDrIImSTR.FITOR
ROSEI2T BUDINSKY, ESQ.
Mr. Nathaniel Dumas#622-439Ross Correctional InstitutionP.O. Box 7010Chillicothe, Ohio 45601
RE: S TA 7"E V. DUMASAPPEAL NO. 12 MA 31
Dear Mr. Dumas:
July 24th, 2013
131 WEST FEâERAI. STREETYouNOSTOwN, OKio 44503
www.seventh.courts.state.ok.us
(330) 740-2180FAx (330) 740-2182
Court records show that your supplemental brief was filed on June 28, 2013, Todate, and answer brief has not been filed by the state. We presume that you mailed acopy of your brief to Assistant Prosecutor Ralph Rivera who handles criminal appealsfor Mahoning County, Ohio.
Under the appellpte E:^uies, a ^ap^;ei,a^it i-ias ten F days tc^ fiie: a -repiy .i^,rief to t;eanswer brief filed by the prosecutor.
Yours truly,
Robert Budinsky,Court Administrator
RBJrs
^ of ay^.
Seventh Appellate District
®' Aw1z BELIvIONT - CkRRGLL • C®LUMBIANA • HARRISON. JEFFERSON• MAHQNING< MONROE • NGBLE
^t^ ^^^ 21c,13
recela7Z-j-Lij. ^,°^, l^05p ^°6 ^`^e^e ^^^ ^^ ^
^ ^^^^^ no-,5
(a Y) ,^°^^^ ^^ ^^ ^^ ^^^ ^4,2-013- +We-, ^°^^^ ^^^ ^^^ ^^^^ o^^ •^^ r^ ^^ ^^^ A
%I n m^c-'I 9^Cxy^^ +^Ie, m.
^c^ ^ ^ ^^^^^ ^ ^^+C^,Cne,^ Y^el
^
CA P-401 R , ^^PCL cx cc>,.^ ^ 0 -s"P^^emen-^co
I mQ° ^^^ a c L->^A ^^ ^ ^5fiz4m $^ in
^^^^^^^ ^^ ^^^ ^^^^^ ^^ ^^^^^^ ^^ ^^^-vq CA p a9
e^°^ec^4c^r 9n crxse WC1,5
p^^ ^^oa3 o.^i! ^^^erc^ ^^^ ^^^a VOLP C, U5 nq I c)^^^
A ocxei ic> ^^ ^ ^^J +^e
^^'se^^^ ^ ^ ^ ^Ae-f-Y,g.^ ^ j" ^LL "^ec^ cl^f^ A^^
$^ <-qe cl
03^' % c-Q, cl ' ^^ce-nqe. *,'^ cc^
.j,^`i,a.a 9^ n^^i 4^ ^«a•,Q^^b ^.^ p^^ti,^-, ^^'^',_^p `^ ^. ^",^,^ ^ f.^.^^^ e^^^^ ^ ^.^ ..
c,,u c yvq
)Y"'t ^^^^o LE_t a^S*Rz-,,
(OLY)
YI
Ck ^^ ^ 0:1 c^^e-d
Ick.88C`Z5r^8 ^4uclf^3 -m Oc^^ A-r,<,^^+ss
^^^a ^4 c;^, o^ -^^^^ ct>ncern
M^i C ^ c=c-i °r f-u\ \jCd-,
l ii^4
(AT fibMEJ Ja.C^F-AN CARRO"S SNF-Pf I
.IN
Speedy Trial
®a#e^ipaY$ I Tolling Event8/17/2011'TOLLED -
-^^8/18/2011,T OLLED8/19/2011 TOLLED hearing held.g jMotii
--- --- --- -/20/2011 TOLLED ;
8/21/2011 TOLLE[.? ^^ - -^8/22/2011 TOLLED8/23/2011 TOLLED t - -^- -`8/24/2011 TOLLED ^_ ---_
8/25/2011 TOLLED - v ^ - - --- - : ^^.----8/26/2011 ^ 518/27/2011 52--8/28/2011 53 ^-- - - -
^8/29/2011 f 54^1------ -------------8/30/2t711; 55
- 56^ - -- -8/31/20111--- -9/1/2011 57 C------- -----
9/2011 1 58-- --- ---9/3/2011 59,
-- ` - ---- - ---- ---- --- -9/4/2011, 60 '9/5/2011-- --- - - ----9/6/20119/7/2011 63 i - -9/8/2011
------- -9/9/2011' 65,
g/10/2011 ^ _66{ -
9/11/2011 s7 ----- - -9/12/2011 681
-^ -_9/13/2011 g
9/14/ 10 1 70 - -- --- - -9/15/2011^ 71'
- - ---- ----9/16/2011 l -72-_^ ^---^- ----- - ----9/17 2011 73-- -- - ---1__^. -__-9/18/2011
- 741-----=^---,^._- _=---- _-•--- 4
Pre-trial. Parties agree ta trial date of9/19/2011 75 1/31/1.1._________
ED9/2®/201^. 'E^E- --
9/21/2011'D9/22/2011TC7LLED : " - -- T
-- ---- ---------9/23/2t3^1 TOLLED E_ ^i ^°^'f^►1P^r.. 6B^ "(ii[ s ^s^9/24/20111 TOLLED 7---^---------------9/25/2011
+TOLLED
_ ----!9/26/2011 TOLLED9/27/2011jTOLLED _--t:= --4/28/2011 TOl.LED --9/29/2011. TOLLED
Resume speedy trial days
Deft's Mation to Dismiss overruled.
No MmC10145 ^
^^^ 103111 -1-
^._
Speedy TrialDate I Days
9/30/2011 T_OLLED
10/1/2011TOLLED_
10/2/2011j TOLLE_D10/3/2011 i TOLLED-.10/4/2011 ^TOLLED10/S/2011,T OL.LED10/6/2011 rTOLLED10/7/20 11 ^ OLLED10/8/2011 TOLLED .10/9/20 1 OLLED
10/10/2011 TOLLED
10/11/2011,TOLLED
10/12/207,1 TTOLLED10/13_/2011 T^OLLED10/14/2011 TOLLED10/15/2011 TOLLED10/16/2011;TOLLED-10/17/2011 TOLLED
^-------10/18/2011 , TOLLED
- -^--- ---10/19/20-11 TOLLED10/20/2011 IT.OLLED10/21/2011 TOLLED10/22/2011 TOLLED '
10/23/2011 TOLLED10/24/2011 ,TOLLED
10/25/2011 TOLLED
10/26/2011TOLLED
1®/27/201i,TOLLED10%28/20111ULLED_
10/29/2011^TOLLED10/30/2011 iT®LLED
10/31/2011! TOLLED
11/1/2011 i TOLLED
11/22011 TOLLED
11/3/2011 : TOLLED
11/4/2011 TOLLED-^------
11/5/2011'Tj OLLED
11/6/2011 TOLLED
11/7/2011, TO LLED
Event
Motion to Dismiss filed by Deft(Carfolo). (iqcl, jA)
"Matter set for trial. Matter set for
hearing on Motion to DismissTsial
continued based ®ri Deft°s newest
i r. Speedy trial time tolled
Juring period of continuance."
Resume speedy trial days
Pmse WVAI obla de-^Ie4l.-dqyk+ Seyv+ad b(IJD V14b,+ +)V,:' GibC ^ ^^^ ►^^-°
°^ ^elaca^`!4 a,^^► ^ ^^^ ^ ^;^t ls^a^^e31-^^^^t^^2P12R.°-06f^ a> °`SI4 1 A _ `31t
Speedy Trial
Date T Days Tolling Event Resume speedy trial days
^ ii °-c re^.^cu^ ^!°`^y^Deft's motion for notice of intention
Ckto use evidence. Pro se.; Request fordisclosure of due process material
11/8/2011 ITOLLED !filed by Deft._" -r- ---I -- ---- --- - - --^------
^^D^ir'Motion for discovery package °
te^l'^Iq ncR t`6^"^lif^. 5s-$ ^/P''„including narrative supplement filed1 by Deft. Pro se.; State's response to
11J9j2011!TflLLED !Deft's motion to dismiss filed.------^-^----- -- - _.---11/10/2011'7OLLED ......
------- ---11J11/2011 TpLLED Z - -_ T-- ------ '^T----11/12/2011iTOLLED -- -- -
- ---;------- -- _______--------------__^_____11/13/201 TOLLED ^G ^ --11/14/201 Tt7LLED 5 ^
------- -- --11j15/2011 TOLLED.-T
D ---11j16/2011 TOj ^
11j17J2011,TC)D--- ^--- ._-- - ----------
Hearing held on Deft's Motion to Dismiss.Jud9'ment Entry, p. 2: "(Deft] was alsocautioned that his written motions have andiwiif continue to stay the o f provisions ORC
11/18/2011 TOLLED §2945.71, et seq. "- --- -- -^-- ---- ------- ----- -__762011 't ------ ---11/20/2011,
- -F---_"".-..-^_____ ^ q ^•,- - . ^ __--------- -----11/21/2011 -- -------
----- --11/22 j2011 _ 79 , . `' ---- --------1^- ^-
11/23/2011 (^{ 80 ^ -- ^^. _.__^. -- -- --- -- ----11/24%2011 ^ --------11/25/2011 82-'
-11j26/2011:
-----_ ----- ---- ---1j217j2011 84^--11/28/2011 4,_4 85 ^ - - - - - -
11/29/2011 2.v 861Li" - -- ^
11/30j2011.^---____-_.______ --- -----
------ - -^- y - A ---[
Motion for P.R. bond under terms of +^,ymanitored house arrest with work
lgb-ll-eoprivileges filed by Deft.; Motion fornew counsel filed by Deft.; Motion F^^^^^re 1^^ Pc^ ^^-^for hearing to receive all evidence to ^ ^ ^ .go forward with trial without any ^• ^ f ^^b^further continuances filed by Deft.
12/1/2011 88 !ALL pro se.12/2/2011 TOLLED iS
Speedy Trial
Date Days L- - Tolling Event Resume speedy triai days------ -------12/3/2011;T{?LLED Z,
-----+------ i-------- ----_._------- --------- -12/4/2011 TOLLED
12/5/2011 TOLLED-Zr^-- - - - --------- - - -12i6/2011 TOLLED ?-7 _- -^
12/7/2011TOLLED yg - - -- --- -- - -
12/8/2011jTOLLED
12/9/2011 TOLLED ^ - --- - - - --- ------ ------ ---
12/10/2011 TOLLED'r,/ - - - - -- - - - - ,12/11/2011 TOLLED ;,Z. --^
---- - - -12/12/2011^TOiLED
12/13/2011 TOLLED 3^f - - - -- --- -
12/14/2011^TOLLED--------- ----------- ------- --- - ------ ---
Motion to Dismiss filed by Deft. Pro12/15/2011 TOLLED se.
---- ---- ----------------12/16/2011 TOLLED
12/17/2011 TOLLED --- --- ---- -- ---
12/18/2011 TOLLED -- ^--- ------- T ---- ------------------ ------____--_--------- --------------------12/19/2011 TOLLED
---------------------- ---- --------12/20/2011 TOLLED " -
-------- -------- -------------------------- -- -- -12/21/2011' O LEQ
-+-_---- - ---- - -^ - -Motion to Dismiss filed by Deft. Pro
12/22/2011 TOLLED----- ----------------
12/23/2C311 TOLLED v • `---
12/24/2011 TOLLED
12/25/2011 TOLLED- -- - -- ------- --^ ----------
12/26/2011TOLLED
12/27/2011 TOLLED
12/28/2011TOLLED_ ---------------------------------- ------12/29/2011 TOLLED +, -
- ------------------------------------------ ----------------12/30/2011ITOLLED . ------------ -12/31/2011 ^TOLLED
------- ----- ---- ----------- --- - -- -1/1/2012 TOLLED ^ ---
-- -- -1/2/2012 TOLLED ----------------------------
1/3/2012 TOLLED , -^- - ----
1/4/2012 TOLLED
1/5/2012 TOLLED ^,_ --- -
-_1/6/2012 TOLLED
1/7/2012 TOLLED
1/8/2012 TOLLED---^ ------- - --- -
1/9/2012 TOLLED ^ ------ --- - -_.^
1/10/20121TOLLED ------------v^-- ------^- ---- , ` - -
1/11/2012ITOLLED ' ;; - -----,---;---- -_--- ------- --- -
1/12/2012'TOLLED^-- ---,--- I---_----------
1/13/2012 TOLLED---------^---------------- - _
1/14/2012 TOLLED
Speedy Tria!
Date Days ^,. Tolling Event Resume speedy trial days-- --
1/15/2012iTOLLEQ V- ----- --^---------
1/16/2012' TOLLED ^---- - ^-- ------- -------------
1/17/2012 TOLLED Notice of Alibi filed by Deft.-----
Motiort to appoint private
1/18/2012 ;TOLLED investigator filed by Deft. (Carfolo)---------------- ------------- --
1/19/2012 TOLLED----- -1/20/2012 TC•LLED ----- --- --^1/21/2012'TOLLED . ----- - --___--- ^
- - -- - -1/22/2012 TOLLED
-------
^ Status hearing held. Trial scheduled
for 01/23/12. Any pending motions
will be addressed prior to the start of
trial. -Judgment Entry, dated
1/23/2012 TOLLED 1/19/12, filed 1/23/12- - - -- ---------------
1/24/2012, 69 ^ BEGIN TRIAL
^^^^ A-v^^^WE^ ^^^^^^ ^RE^^^^^^ ^^ Cf^l qlt9^ ^ ^
^:S MADE M -T"F- ^^^^^E_C-T PRE^^^ii^^ ^^^E C^f^^ `^^E,IOURNAL- ^ ^_3hI -^ ^4YETI -THA`^ ^ 005 i° tl-^ ^^ ^A-116
^^ SCI ® ^l +^ ^ 9-5.
iN i14 E R
R E 5
n
Ml^ ^^i^WCj C'/bUNTI,__^_
5TATE- 6F bgi bPlAtN►1FF - A 9 PFLr-- C
^ ^5 -
NBtTRA1411-:L DLA i`'P! A...^
^^^^O'DANT- APPFI-tAt4T
C^Ab 1J6_ 1Q--MA-S1
09 AP ^ E - A L. r ^^^t -T1--^ ^.
C6UK-TN
^ LEE-AA11 -csk- -1-2-9
-s-af' PLF-PqGj,^-TAL_ E?R 1v-:F c^ T: APVCLLA KI-T MAt`i'14AR1EL f? uMAS
RAL914 R^^ ERA (®l>92.L^c,3)Mokho^r,lnq Cz-,Un4y Vrc^se-c.uttbvi^ we-54
C-GU.i^,5F-L ^bR f r P PFLL' F-
.^ .WlOFNAMIE'L DIAM&^ 6^^2--1-39/ Psbsa,Rc53 ntAREC..MMAL mm3mPbbi Bc>X `7616
F-F F-r^ ^AI^T- A PPEz^M7j, ^^ 5e-
`rAf)LF- OF- LD WM14`t_5 .i.4_^4^ ^V. ^^.^^a^Lb®! O{ ^
^`^^^ ^^ ! l.^^ t Y63 f. \^ G f^.c^J t t 4- 4 4i^ s i o ti& 4 li-4 L t- S t. e s. a r. i. . a L a u >^ 1
A?*tA1- S G.1 V-T AN4,1 i.,./"E W - ... a- c. a^,,. .. . c c o-• r -r c r a Y f. ^. a E a v x: 1-
A551C-4,1{1^^^ O'F "T'^E V, 1A L C.^URT ^,:DM M1T I ED
^^^wH^.h^ Yi '^Pt1L.^..D `Tb tqt t.^G A^' P ^.^^...A^`°'iP -TR^AI- \al°Mt^ (qc>) VM5 AFi f-^ ARAF-5® PLOt:50-AWT -TC^
^^^& fV-fl5V-V COIDS 2AA-5.°l1 (00-) cxnACO) - i^ -qlbLA-T1.OlJ
OF "15 51x--Al4,A9lD VocaRTF-^Wni AwD^DKEN-" f,tGM-5
" ^ D - T V t F - u - ^,- e t r ^ ^ 5 - - f I ^R 0 blk t 0 6.0 ^:S-rl -T LXT lbl^ AV^T Ag^--.1^
T-11.... AWD t.>j2.,C 20q45 11 w g2.. ,T3..C'°tr- oc^p^
A.UrC°^8 MEho or- E P,t2l '^--- -TVkV-P,F- WA3 WO`t' 5UF^IC-1NT
10 *SU5°T1'N AC^0r,Ntc:T1WJ df,, cjXXlY"^ bt^S C1^1t^P.fl^R1` cDutq-r
I'WO CAGGP,AIVA ^°ED p,^9lKRj)r r,St tiA AVIRSARM 5P50-1^tCA-t"`tbtJ.
Tt^ ^ AL ^^ W:SE.1.S ^iAL^ III . Vttmc^O .^ RbU^ KANE 19r^.F-Tt C-RA14TED`
P L1C- i b A i .ACY, OV Fv 11llElW-E- i ^ PLACS1 AP 9 OLt ^IA-T A-T `N ^ 4Y--IN V-
^^ ^ ^^ME:^ DF F=f:&bj=- 60^TVk.`r^ ^AL CC^UM5^L MAIRY, Cl.Pf^rb ►-b
AWO A'VPF-.1LAAT cz>uA5EL.. ^.*MAi^ CARRC^ ft^^ l OVD F-
A561sTmct c>,F ^u-tasFi.- \AN60 FA11.V-D +i"b M^^^ ^HF-155l^^ ^^ ^^^F-LLAM-T'S `TR$AL 'V 6LA7 1^O3 IM VjQA"ijW
&V iRV- S l\ 1 F\ ^^f F-Lt:..A0. 6 6^'"-rL4i'+ 3aac.a^ cLd'm 5 T I -T U-T6tbl3a.
^^tP,^^ i rr^^.^ 14 E ;^'b^ ,^ ^. Mti I o ts ^°^ ^^^{'^^^ 5"'CA^°^'. 5
^ ^ ^^tt^^t ^°^1^^^^'F^.^ l^G^r'^^M^^!"TR^ r^^w`-TWf-55 L1 STr Bt S6,^^ VM PAGEb, ,
111A LF- Or- AWTAe^^^t°^^= ^
5e.^au^.
5-ka4e.. V.13^ucc>fn^.` oDg o1^^^^^o-2.®15Sac,^°>-or N. %nl; n3t> 1-5°1 U.S. 5 4 530 1:1 -2. 5. C+. C tq-7z7. _u ..5 . +f.. f5L.arn c> v'"1 qq 2- 5 2A 16 (>9 1 ^ ^ q"wi c i ir_ n q 5).
5 i(cl e- nsc , o C i 9^5 c u 6 (116^ > A^. 23
5-i`•dliL V<Bly tA 14 0. °a 1,4 3.5! C/-% W 5-^ t CJ..-_b f
^^^5PT8^s^8r'{H116 `.'.."N./ f^^ ta+E^ V^^^`^.^®E^°°aas^^f3 i.+^s4Ste.6F:14..triiii^V
va U05 0 5c^5 Um S.lcz+ tm
^^""t.^^++ V.r4.04t}tl^ 6^^ ^iti,.)^r'`"^{^^^f17^^ 6V.(E^xb..v-ESs.f+(..t.alkaacasci< ♦ i\d.'4.^N^^
^ i ♦+^Pi. & `w V .u. ^'<_. i q ^-{ ^^ tl p ^ ^ eF ^ {. ^ ^ B^. 13A^ i.i / t! fr . . ( . _ . < i . ( E 6 . , o s C 4t E a e ¢ f ¢ ! \ ^
^^^.^^. ^^ ^^^-z..^1^^z.^Izaz^^, -^h, ^ ^ ^ ^^, y`•'^ .i a 6 0. :. a. Y ts ca a^ s B. (+t o \ i( 4 i. 4 6 w.Ee^
5,tAit?'. \J. GCql (iqdA) `^ Dlh t C^ 5-t> 2-a 2. t . a < . s . . ..a 4 . . a:,a
4q4b^ 1 -3 l&^ 4` 1 (^Lsr"'°^.. *-1 i ( a c .( . . B.dF..•
1 1^f..gd+ Y^q V r 5*Vl+e- 43 y /i6 S^ a^ M esL./ti. ^Z 13', 2-23,^ ,qnf 6. C+ t Lto-i t ( a i a 4.k c f^¢
^ ^ ."Y-SSS^`av, ^ s Y, I! y,/ 2-6 6-1 ^'a.3' F ( ^: (.B - a 4^/*1-J F. Y " a F a , < - v 8. E { \< ,
v. :Y^^^^^^l -t- -^^ ^- -25cl 6toD,6 6^,°^^ C;^^V W!. Lc+16..i^♦.w^ i E( 4 i ti a Q.. (.,( a F'27
^..V'4 `P^^^+w4^ V.^!` 4fl^^ ^w^^ a^ 4^^ Y^. 4{ ^4^ ♦ V( ^9U M Lsy^6^s')a 0.6aV.,' 4 4 tl J ( MS
5icbte Y W^4/ J ^"^ V^ 1 V Ca/^ r. 2-8 10 II j°(^, V i{G l.ss C jA\ TJ E. ^ i t 1 L 6. t YL- $X e
,51^1^ p/he-fd B iF-oM -C l Wl o - V A-Y 5 f 2- ^ L c . . . < .a t d a i . ( . s , . `< g !` °..ei
C ^ ^♦/t p[)^ !.+ p^ ^y 7 /1 ..r^ ^ ^ ^^^^t^t F i !^` •`e ^.w.J 4^^^^ 6sl <.^+s LLA^^ 6^X 0^
^°eap^' , C tqTa-?, 5 5 6^.) c^ S`^'.PG.8 2-5^F.
LA-5. V. °^^5e-tl' q-io 5^ 2.d at62/ litai- ('zC4 ^^^'^ ^^q^..^E . .. . ► . ( a ( G r ^^^^ •^ ^ Nla
V\:6^Ie ^.o ^Lfts° 1^^^^^ ♦./ f7 0 A..<.^.J 6J ^^ ^ l^" 4^^ `-+aR^. ^Ero ^^F♦ a E a. i Y o13
6:.R 6.^+s y b 'Y(-,EAy1 ^ ^ ^^^ V-238 Ar^^/ +1 trai"V1 C ,1 6 2.t> 10,. . . > . s. . a. .. : A 9-1
-yo ♦^'(y-glg 6'"tJ n 1 p+.J^ cu l 8 B^: a. a 4 ( . F i r G A a G,t3 i 4 c.. l C+.. a.. t.. t.6$ i..^ ^ Q.a,,.;C ^! ^\ b
2.. jq^jj^) Cuye^^^c3a App.tAa.i^1 ^o 8,.^,LiC}4r1/l.w^..41 {C.b Y 4 AtAaJ, @ 8 0 Q^ lAl- l 1' l+) 6J4/ 4./' IP 1^ / 51 ys ^^6 J id5f C ♦a+k( 7 s (^ ^^ ^^ ^^ f i^6X^ 1
tw. b, 2A ,^3
ea^o
^R^
'RmC, - 2.qA54-^t CC?C-2-)(D) - - _ (0,3a
^^ V^c^ Oe ^ F^'<-^ +Y- 4 ^ ^<.,! s^' i ♦ ^ . a- e. t s.- w . ^ 4- s a .- G a. a, x. ^. .. . .. Y-. 6-- a.- 4 "L. f.-.F^/^S^
c (F-)
2 LaI?
1^XL- sAliz-
't. l .. 3 G i ^. L 4. L 9... y t.- .. ..,. ... : < ^ l r (-.^ ..rT .`. ^,fer[e`
?"UN40. Iua 6.O } 'M^) .. w.. a.. .. . - -
Rkiltir 1b1^ ^ ^. .. .. . e . .. . . ^ . u- ^ . « . • K_ L. . r .- 3 0... ..w-n 2^77
We 1.2- ( C-) (^) cty, d 1 b-1 Cb) - . . . . _ . _ . .. < . .. . _ .- f. . . o- I ._
" D N 5 -11- 1 i E1°TIOAld 3,
R Am antlm^f)+ -b> AVie Lt-,5 C:b yj<s ^► ^ Lt°^ jza
. o^
'' / + ^
(^
L 7^ 1 Y,+Ii 1^^en cline-^'6 -^^e ^ ^. 5 C^^6 •
M4 9.r D C-A>
x
10A cowi
\A'k^br^^3 clvellay)^ -^ ^ ^ IOA 14IN6Y) Cgb) Clap
q /t vi b^^.^° i wlc^ Wi -s 'F -1 ^ iM t 5ix-% , c^^ 'Fo ur-^ec:n *iAm enc4 rnen-^
E+^.:-^Ion, Qyiclr13)ft's iD -16le, 5-^
O'nr c^ CM^^4^ionOACI ° -1 3
Pursuant Ao - ;o -^ 'p2^5_^. an
^.^,6ed 5`n^.1k `^. N , c noi-
Vr ou31^ io ^r i q\ iy1f-> qer i acl
. . r
2^^ o 5^►^^ t s 0" )Caf Ao CLOI
CfAfnlylcxl Fc^^^ea q035 ac)aln^^ i^^
accLx5ej^ )Oc^Se-d U. ^O^ -^,^.^ ,
0 3
^11-TA in A1^ ^^ ^tt.c^,1 ^^^^C)^
cL 5^^^
^f 4 i:s a5 a's ani O^ %e
r i ^^° s 5 ^ c^,t'^ `b^ i
ct Bg , l 3 1, l F i A m M 1 CAa61-1^ c^^^^
^ure-me ^^^f-t %e-
qfc^^e^cu-^Ibn cLricl -^c IcA cbut`-^s I^he- rrvaLricAOL-
^^ee-ay
. ^.
`^t^^f ^-C>5j 3^a^, ^. ^.?-i 1^z , ^2A^1i o 6^`G 2-8
C^,^
coa+5 Ymks^ ^^1-iCA°1
'5if^e. A^he. S^^^^ :5 QL3CA"'M ^'
63, ,5-1, totaZ
n ^ . -rne- ^^^n.4(afcl o^ reii e^ ^ 5 -^o c^ "Y,+
cic^ ^ ^ pq^ ^cl cLnca cAeAet' Ml ^ ^ e ^^c^ ^^ ^ 0,1
C1oc^r^e^,`I(t CL5 8*imc+c--c4
2-0^ -
loWi c^ -° ^ 2-3 Lo,1 ci .
eA p^^^c^n a^a^n5i vAiwm cx ^^^ ^^^^j c^jac3e,
` % i^t
2.10 c^ ^^ ,5 a-^^t'
Z3)
^a^e^"^,.r, `^.e i '5^c^,^
.ct45. ;n (r--), plruq icle-5 -Y^ia-^, ol` com pLk^cxi `on
Furpases, ec^e1't aay i^a^ a ^n aecu^ s^^t^ds
1^^^ ^^ ^^^ ^^ ^^ qe-nSlri!)
^^^ ^o u %n^ ^s -% me, dCL^^ ^ ^^^^ e^ -^ a±e.
. ° `2^^ N
1neNci 3^r1 &rec of°; ^,^.a^^^ `o ^i^^
cce^*e-8 c^^ A&4l\ 1 S, 2-c^^^ ^ ^^^^^,e. -^D ps
11DOD, o" o . 5 kA^^^j 'bonCl, \ne- fievnqt`fie
incaf ceccAeA Lxni'l l W^s -^ V°l cx^ d^-^ e
ck 'fnc>n4^ ^ WVefl Yl^.M-
(4)
appl^l -Vhe s^q^e hcxcl Cqa`? dcay s-^b
a^pe-^^cLft+ . App6\aq+ 'Wi^^ ^se, -%e ^pu^-na1
^^^ ^^ -,Ma^ Wi s .^ Qeth( - -^ 16 cA r `^Ik^
we-^,e
en ^ ^ 5Tni^ ^ ^^l o^ A!re cx-ocl
P4^etk^^^- `^e:Inc^ ^'s^`^:af^e8 , i ;s s^ ^mF-> onl^
5^.^
F`Ps ^- 4^^1 ^r^ ^^-^-^ c^oe ,^ N^iis C^ufi^'
1 a 3re ^. vs i ^1n ^e (^W1c^ Sa^^^e c ^up -^ `^,-^^
^^n^,^° ^` o, ce^^^^ ^^^^ ),\taca1t It^
(5)
st tf.
5^^s ^^c^^ '^ ^^ ^ ` ^u^ ^^1 ^ n1 ^ ^^^.^ .^^-► ^..^®^`^
/ C'ni^5, ^uviln^^ cc> OWic^ AfP ^
521, -5t>.S 28 ^WI
I ^256 O1n c o ,
c 0 ut`^` Lxn uc^ca^1^
:rP *i 5 coufi°-^ wau1(A ^\e-cx:se- ioov^e- 0', ^ c^^)^
CXi -^Ae (a-Iricx^nejA t^^^On5e Mo+i^n it,
Q ^po1(O,M's sqeQA° ^ ^^ rL)`^
V 1 CA cx+ 4 o n 6 J +Nmt-.^ V^ 'W M ^ee^ A^I(lCA
! m.a6e o, C-.1e,6 ca\ e-fif bf ® cxncl mexi° Nyle- ACA-e,
C(Q)
-k^,Tnne-- ^^ee, ^' raie^^, I1^ ^c^rle ^`^^ ^cne c^^^'i col
once k^,e- )OCA 0^- %ene e-c^^^^s cxve-
cofmaie^, N^en, acco^,dyn3 *D %^ ^^uf n.ctl ,
mciiOn frny^5 -Yne ane-lIO,n*g6 s^ee--Al -
^^ ^^^ aoLls . ine Aq-^e.
0^ O^^^ ^l W^5 -qef ^ ^^^ ^^ W13
oO
S1AaU18 Nlcxqe 'oeen ^ ^ 5&10r^8 c^n -V6 ^s cl c,^e- a
(^)
; ^^. ^ ^ ^^ t° t`^^-^'^ ^^ `^ ^^ -^^1^^ i ^ ►^.^ {^ ^,^ ^`c.^:^^ ^ C° ^`^^r
^^^^^ ^I Z-5111 ^ ^ ^^^ ckk^ 5BcO A-
mCeY18C.AOi° I
^^^ ^^ ^^^c ^^},O^: P ^,^ ► ^ ^.^^ ^^r^^'^ A'c.^ 'be- 8
.IsC^)Ck cx 5 o, vyv c *ei
c,
^,^.nna^ ^c^c^e ^^`^r^S^- -^-1^e.
\ . -t-be. j^^^^a^ ^^^ ^ ^°^►^^. ^^^ ^^.^^^ CL
Aa-^e ofl q^tq^1y.. AYO W '%e^C^ ^^6 CL
<4 wlo^ - %en cL C\e.^l ca1 e- v r c^ ^
(s)
^M iMe
t'ec1\
b, -^ne^ jWIMCA
AqPe-V^avi+$5 8a+e^ o-Y 11 2.4jm wa^ ^^^
-^Wl c,CA cl ckl c^ Wl^ ^^ o\al-^^^ ^^ S :5p 8jv
ct^ °CA cxl 0^
^ ^i^r►^ ^ CL-^
Iou c-^ -^^ ^^ec ^^^ ^) aqpe\1cxn^-"5
ayid -^mm ^^^ ^ 5-e-e,-L^g^
0q7
V.
,[^ ^^ a ( ^. t
WC^,5 8 1 `>c^^9^ ^"5^ (2-) ^C^,,^^ °^ 1C^^^,1^^
^^^ ^oe^eAl -^ci^^ ^'l f^*S.
-Tnp- ^c^ ^ecuio(N cLrtcl -^ne C..Our^ Nlc^^ ^^ cx^^w-o,
Mo,^lve
mckAloef'^
^ 3 -1^9 2- ^ Lc, ^n C^i f 9S 2-) ID Ck^
;^^b^^^ ^e scru^A^^z^ \41 ^^^^^^^^^^ ^^^^^ ^
ayycl `!ae ^
ds {aa^,^icuiQx1l e.am^tN1q3 vNtev^ %e-
cxflt
(tO)
2-ct^^.^ 5e. a Z<,
OA -^o ^Yco4e ^aee n
^-^ r-j ^. -7
^41 c1r^^ ^^ ^ 5c, cl cti
ItA1^ 2..61 IAc^^ 1.5111 -^^ 61z-5I11^
Z-j ai (qt cl CL q s)i^2^11^ -^ 9^^1JA
ip 1\1^q^^d io
f
`
^° t°^^ Q^-^t^^^ c^rt^. ewC^1UaL
;5ox-IM A,cneyiclmen-^ c1Qim -. 0)
1en2^Nn C>Y de^Q^ , (2..) -^m °^^^'5c^^ ^^(- ^^ ^^\cl^,
cAI 5 o r 1,5
r ^311+® aq6 C1`^ 9 l(-e..^^^ ^ ^e, -k^ ^he- de!^el,n^^^+ . 5ep-,
t:. dl U,,.5b 53C^j q2... 5. C-=^ ...`'°
2..1 62., 2-^12- , 33 L -`9A. 244 tc^1 ^ IT7E^. -rne ^^Vt',5 i
laa^^e-r - ^me ov de%Cq - 'se, "es
Y, ^#
a,5 0^ ^°^fie,* cA tl o ir cL mu A n (::kn 15^
OL
I^rr,^^'h
^ ^^^^^ - -^ rw ^^ cl n (:^i^ 5"15 . TA ® -^Wp-
i s rYtec^ 5 i.u ^e(A eCxfi Cr^- -Vhe..,
Oxr^5+ w- -VoE^ ^^Ap- O^
Cit'® 2.oiv). ApQeO1an-V r4e16 -V^i" (R)
,Oes^om -^c^. ^16a^ .. ICA ^`^.^' wv:o1:*,s 0^-
1t^ny-ir
W.
b If,,- b , ('^f€at / °7 2. r-elA . R% m V--4 i8 ,
erf.. 210k>p2- 06'"1 T- V..-D, A^,^ ^^ ^^^ffi C^tfiz 6 c;i
B "k"k3 ^F."58
^11 c^ . 'Sec`v " 1006 e 12. A a 1.. Jk _ ^cl . ,Z.cl a L.^ (-1 *b
ct B ( 4+^n C:) (`A 2.6 6 .5) - e^^ I ct A 2 V. 2A
f
1
0,61 cq'.^ t
F.2A ^ito 2. / MA ( 2A C,c^ca..) A
c^elc^: ir► `1Y1^ <ayy c^^Cu5ec^ ^c^ -^CiOA As
q^^.t,^^r aC1^.f1^' . ^ ^^°°°^1^^vo^
A15wp cQQe1^qn+
^^^e-f°^^cl W1^ 6^^I+s'
(13)
^^cl
vw^ a^ ce-, ®
. (^loa^ a`Y.^ i
^,s1eA "C i Ct
Imd° ^ oln -^o cl ^ smi 155
o,,
iile cIJ=erdcrrl^ a5sec+erl W,s s¢eedl_
C 1 5 ,w^ °^ a^.^` Cct,x `Y15^^ ^f^l^vis
^.^.^^ -^,a^ -^^^ ^ ► e^eMc^o+'-5 c^ s:s^,cA^lt-^n 6s^-
^.^ M -90c cx
^^^s ^6(, ft. ' ^,eckz5on3 a^ -%e de.\a^.s- a^" %e
icxc^flc- 'Wa5 -^Z>
( I z-)
a,n cl 8 eAQ, u^^ 1^
We-C^ ^^N(t -^^ ^ M55Qfi^ Uarne5 Vvlt^MQ5
, j
^-^+c4^ -^b aVp^1\qn+ -Yrt--)m
ucle
{^ct^^
►'nt^MQ5 no-^ A'Ik1 ,Inc^ ^^ ^^c^^M^^
^^^ ^^^^ ^cs^
^ I d ^,n ^. ^ dct-^^^
^ necl ^^^ ^ f'^^ ^^^' ^ ^ ^'^1^ ► ^ '+^^^
Q.^^^^5*
CD 0 e t'n,-N^l c^fl,
na Cct3e, QL^)q.)riS+ app^^ 1 Qn^-° ti AqQe^\c^ a-^
^s -^tAq'
Yi-sel as:^i ^5°^e8 -%e, 5+ca^e ^ cle-^aj b^
(1,5)
n3 mo-^Ir^n,5 ~°o. 8,5rn i ^3 Ab(a+
r r c>c^ ^ QC^)tx M^.()+5 (3,3 N4eX^
^^t^^^^^ ^-^ ^.^^-^=^^ ^^^^^ ^ ► °^ti^-l^c^a^° ^^^^^^
;C^r1^-@^ I..Cla\ ...^h'IC 5 >
1. O(Q) CLI, CI ^., (b) (:rnyc>meA c^^ 5eM-)- ^..-^ wq3
; Ck S^5ie-rraii c `bceeLY,,Aorjn
611
56tp LL 83 12.e^-3 , m!a^o,1-T 3 PL_ r, F-^
2-cl 2-3 1 (2..60,9) .. -rr1e ComMw1 ^\ecCc^.,i`^
O^n^ ^ .^ ^^
^^^^ ^^^^^^l N41ekk ^6r ^
c-t
(11,Q)
^ ,^kcxn 5
4)a+ -Y.^ 8e\cxl wc. 5 cltte. -^c^
Pc^bz5e- m u^^^^ ^ A)Q^- S \ea _
.. _ d A e ^ `R a . ® . _
?^ "^ ^ a t. <
.lcu1i_
/ 2..012. - OWi b °° 5 4r1 5 / 2-1 - M c)fi°e c),\le V /
floile Cj^ N11^:^e ^0°0 5-4^t MC^^16^^ ^eM P-\
r UkeA oil r aA am of ^^^ lnc^k 'u^^.8
,, ` cL ^t ® <
out°neA ^^ ^^^5j (3) OW10 OL^Q^11ca^e.
^% m\
^^^^
^ ^^^1►^ ° ^` r^ ^\ f) me . 5 eey M s
*,n) o (OL150 6e v .. aq ta, wc> .
^\ e ,
-^^1i o ^,r 1^^ ^-^ `^^ +e^
serV^ on c^e^'F.^ai1^ ^e c1 i 5^a^9ec^ ^i 5
ic ^^^ ^^N ^aLd COLxC^ ^^^^
^wy-, cx-^ *e^ '^vma1 (an^ ^ ^^^5c^ ^^ pajE. 2a.^
^^ 4^lai appe1lcrl+ Tl(z-^elr Ctfl
^ ^ `^, ^^.ce$«ve. ^, c^^^^^n^^^^ c^5 Qfl3-^
('i)
^^^ ,5e- ^^^^ ^^ ^ ^ ^^iNe- ^11', -5
Nhe Nvi(::k1 .. ^
12-°
Oe14y ccause8 b1 rtecj'1; ^ence. i s w^i q^'teA
cx j3a; n 5i -k^e z5icaie. ld. ^ yid ^ e.-Ic^^ ca1 cula+CJ
^10+^lyl Col cLC1.-qQyl+CL3^ ^',^elr 4"ne Qccuzed
<
i^.^^ ► ^n^^
^►-^i^ ^° ^-^ ^^^.^~^ ^ ^^^ 1^t ^.^ ^ ^^^ c^^
urt-ril ^1^^ ^^^^ a^^^ ^^ ^r^^^^ ► r^.
^-^^. 5 -^a^^. . ^^ . a ^- 3 9 ^-=3S 3 . Ms n-^^) -^
vt F^
,v^c^ .^ alk c^^ c^, s^c^.^e.pt^
(11)
hj Cal cl Ov'^e(A -}-C^
cc>qeva^ie- a -rne :5.ka-^e a^ qe-i ^^^^ iy)c-a,f-
; c^pra^ ^ ^ ^^ ^ Vp- ir^ -^ oby--, -^be-m 0) rnc^n+)1,3 i^
^^ cc^c.^f^^ ^^e^ --i^^l e\yj w.^,^
15b ^^w ct^ -^a varn i z-)e 411,15 ^^^ ^ -T)Idmq:57 +C.,^
^^ai-^^ v4'+n mu^^ef1 ;^ ^.^cchc^^ ^.^
coopefaiiL3"n!
-ffie- ^^^^^^^^^ ^^^ ^^^ ^^eyi
jon ih^ 5ce"Ge- ^^^ ^ven 00,cecl 'WAM ^1^►^^'^ ^
(2-6)
As -^oc -ffie- 'ucllce ^^Ke-^r
liesio,- +"ne coui'-^
c^^A C-QAcefin
!
^^.Jense
p
^,^- ^SA-1 )12. .5.. C-^ . (OA ZIQ92. ^ ^^ ^re- -
A1^^ S-^Ct^-e liS 9c4er, F^.^^^
b1^ ^^ qi*,e5.^^^e -Tvib,^^^ ^^ ^^c^pef-a^e ,.
II C2^ ^
^
bet^3 cknea5ed ^.^- °mt^
^c4. 'Yi m^
5 o;n ^^ t' ^, c^'►^r^ ^^ ^^^ ^^^` e Y)
qub1 "Ic^ r^-
c^5 ,5^^^^ p- fi -96
WQ3
^(Yte c^e^'en^e wct5 irYti^4ireJ beccCU5e a^
^e ^.^, ^ '^ ^^ ^^ ^°^^ ca 1 -^^.e 5-^a,^r^. ^.a^1 ^^ ` ^`-^ ll
nc>i N
needed 4D
cqyl
e5+41bl 4e-
C^.^.^
, ^. . - .ZZA ^ ^ ^. ^^ I c^c^ ^ is c ^ ^ ^ ^ l -06^
-^c> o, ^^eejAj--^6(al c1c.t'lyyj,b^.o-QLAse
4^I^^^.^^^Sl°^^, c^^^^°^ 1^ ^`^'^t^'^^^1^^^`i^ ^^C^,^ ►^A^t"°
TA U . S.. oL+ 6 5 51 Il 1 5w. Ci. (4°^ 2
A Qpeltain+'^ias $1taTc^u#y -5un°ciec1 1enat)
^^c3u^^^^^ 'In ^ t,5
^^^^kw4e .1ec^e^1 -^.5, o^ -s 'w ei t
A coa► (-^ ^^^qY-,-s
^C^^s 6, c ^.y^°^^3a ^.^.), 2.R o`^^ o
► ^ 3 c) .:^2- 1, SO 9 N dIE d 22f3 ^^^ - A`^a,(°ll e^ ^cw fi.6
(2:3)
(gct) 112-31 It '13
,Hk\k33, 13-'M 0;s^.,o^^e,t^ 84,,Oc^^0+ -NO Z5. <4^ ^ °^-
j ^a^ 36laf^e ^
4^^^•^--}61ct^ ylc^+
^d^c°^ c ► l 0^ ^^' Qe-ci\ rwci^. 0^
912,3 11t, c^ncl oo^r 11191 It ^
A1,56, ce>n cl^fi
4
CX+ ^^Umq^ov
^c> 1 °^ ^ ^ ^ ^oylq)^)^ ^fiqf Yt et d^
C 29-^
{
-(YB4>+♦
Oni a ^ e5^e,08qn+ re-qfe..^ eY'1..A7e
bi cbuy,^^^ ^^ flc^+ i81 l ^^ee,81_ ^^i QLl
ac> nci^
J5^°^
Zt ^, A1,-5e,>p a+ 8as-' C ic^ c ^ qe-1 ^ a*-
,- ^ w ^ :5 . e -%cr^ " mb°^^ ^ ^ * Yl^^ ^ ^ le-^
^ ^ e-ck5o'°1,qb\e A`iyne clc> nu'' +c^)t
cli - -Vti a MIZ. ±^aucna,
0`nir^
vt35^ <3* _, vi"hem C^^^ clct^ :s 'WQ:s
4yi ,ir.>u fvt.q k %,
-V'1a`^ 4''te ct>r^ ^i Ina(A lk^ OT)^ ^d Cc^8^^^^^
(26)
9r^ Z5,e ^O-^^On 5 °^^ ^^ ^^ IS 116111 aYj c4 1z1 2.-Zl 11
(,5eat,tt -i'lie- Jaie. o°^ ^ IZ-tl 1 2.. )_ ^D'ae OT )^ Oi:'°!eC
9c`^"5e m^rflon^ Ae-`e
ep
+4b -^ ^ ^ 3 I I-L^^^^ -V r;
-k
%I
e ct1
aD(^^mcXyl`12,5 Pf e°vurlat 5^ee-
2..y tOt``^^^
C-Lt^ ck'a^,qcL ^^ ^ . t4c> a -51`Z toa , At^r->, seg-.; c!Apnfe^
, OYlcl
it J(
ct1 1613, Ajj^ or^
^^^ ^h,,,-, 3+o,^^ ^^ ^^^ ^Mzseyj+ ^ ^6n,5en+
^om %4iA-ln cL^>-.+' ^ ^ yac^um, ^3
Wn-^ ^^ ^^^^^^^^^ ^b cty) ,
F1 ^W) c:.s : ^^lp-5^ ca,id
^- -T-^ ^^^^^ ^^
[-^]paranp h ( b) rII-'ltu;res i^,e )Cvw^ei- io
o`^^, yi -^1^^ ^^^f Y-heci c,^^^^n+
iyot
Q^ 5C^ ;5t qt eLi, A l`i-W,^ei :!Nictil
fccniD*'/ 41p- jeci5it^
^^(NB)
!n^yof mecl con^em`°^ q:s rtej`I Y)
^^^^^^
9 5
^ C^;
14,
^^oLit
n Y-nP %A CL15
° -^s', ^ ^ 84-^e ^0. cL
(^.t ,
w'l'* cm o^- i1^^ i^acye„er -^cLCA-ors rrts+/ ayid
^^^^
? ^.^^^^ i^3 N1^fiO^^^ 1^,^^A cw^^^nen-^^
cx^. ^ -Vne3 b^.^~ ^.a l how ^i s s .pz^.^ ^ ^- ^° ^ i cA c i 3^s
^
Qc; 5ai't - see-, .r^ ^.^ . ^5-7 'F. 3a c^k -*15 -
I^^^ f ^^^^^^^ ^^^eAqy^+
ilt `b^. ^tnIC^^u^ ^ i ^ ^qfi ^^.fiq ,°^^.v^ , O^^ ^i^1b^^
^QtYYied ecLLtctl ^mie-^i'lon qyv^ ^^^ ^ l-^ Q'
0 ^^ ^ ^^^^ oWic>
11 ^L. Qn.cA lb - Alse^/ -*I^ ^oui°^e-„e-nAr1l Amc-naa
( Lq^
^
flrbPef^'^,, NAiiNiOLk* aLke pj'cc^^^ ^^ ^(:XW .
^9p4tani^5 TnCA"'lc^n ^^(" yiem afpe-IW.^e- c6uft^^ j
ikCaN'^ , is v4pa11
C^tx(O,1 i^ ie-cl cZkylct Goynqe°^e-q-^ ^c^ ^^N4e. cLS
^ppektca,k^ ^c>^c -n5el . Ccw^` o ccA(au\ca, +ed (61)
_ W) 5s ^yj ► ^ Cqi, 0 LA `^CX)^jCja ^^ ^4^>
^^-
I-^c^`rcL k c^cx^°^ ^^ ^^ Yn^.^^. ^^ ^cl'O-:^ q3
1-1OLWYl^l,5, oln 912.311t, -%ell
^}ee c^ i °- '' C' 1®l ^ C 1 ^y 1^ s P^lCL,5 bpel1 q 1 6^ak,^ecl )b^
C37 c.^a^s . K2 ^^au1d aisclnq('TcI
^^^
j nf
i3tAi
CkYICI YP4eq q
e^e^ ^`^e^ APa^^ ^^-^
-rne-
W^^ici
(Al5 c:h^ ^^r '^Iyn A^ae ^033 CofMCJ^jcqM1
a COU n+
8ue- +^ ^,C-Y, el e-^1,^ ^,. .
(31)
111 ^1 5 ',^ i C:9 e'n+ e- v 1 clence- ib Ct'>,Tv i Q+
AMra,^^^^^ )3ejky
place5 QPpe1^^^+ cxi
A.^ ^f ck:^^j )CN i1^
Du f , -,^ ^ D'i ;^1 ./ 2-4> 12" 0^1i c^ - -16 cl I )Sd rA^e-n i'e:\ie.^ \1 q3
ia r,ei^ cy CrT A-Ine e,vi c^^ oc-e CLY1 4 ^Av1e-+,heS'
Mc^^nQ^te-
ubi ..r._Y-1 bii-^Pa wc,fi^^, cja,^+e-v ViQM ti
p- a ce , ea^^ e(:ac^) i^^e^en ck>-^
be. J(`(awy) A-^eve-^mrn, i n CL 1; `1`- r^,os^°^
+11,C--I ^DUO (:A,^ ^
( 5:L)
I r on^ l +6`kx °^^ - PQC-:^ lG(a°v(t-> -^c^uylc^ ^^t ^^en-^ i Iq^
^^^Yyve.^^s o^ 4m ^Wem^^ ^^ ^^ 8 o, reo,^orvq)Ae^
App1jin3 -li^ 5-^anciac8 +o 41e. ^-'ac+5 or^r) NVIs
iv,k)efi4-
-j^Qc-^ c®ulck It1c've- ^'^u^n<4 A^cx+ Qwt,1'$cml^ vQo qi
,5cem^ 0^-, -!^r:s ccime, AfpetActyl^o -Yt"y^l
QC^uY15e-l ^oAe an
clcm
+cak^^ s
^^er flA\e^ 'I -V ( `^w ^ r `19 c>, 13 -^ 19 ) . ^-e^5 ^ oo', cL+ %^>-
f
i ^^^^ 0^ *le- 00,5P- ..
-iYr- 5+ccA,,e,in ccoe, ^f'le8 ^^ 5aLl ANt,cA
'0n^ ^b^c^^ m3 ca-^ Al^ Ga1 cLxj -^oA
acXie
AqC ^l 1 ^ 0 2.c°1 , Vhen i'e- ^^ c>o'^t Cl ^ ^^^^ ^kqc^-' tl 6 rvet
2-) ec>pi^..^ 9 c^,nc. ^mr^^^° ^1,q^C'^ cL^"l
;Scx^^ ^c^,ms^
^ ^ M<-,>. (`tra ^ I C> t 2.^ ^-L` 1-1 ) - ^l c, -^ o ne a^ I&te-f n e,4e f
ca.nj 6ne, 04^ ,5i ^P- -ffi^ 5-^6^ ^
ic, W, I Yl .^^-4ei-q^
Ovid
II
K^^ ^.^^n w^.5 O^^ S^ a- ^^. G^1qy l ^^^^^ p
^,.^t31^ '0'R^)^^- "^^,
^
rt CL n^ I Lip 'neq Ir
^^ c>M Sh-p- ^ye.^^ ^ z-q,^
Gtppej^^yl-^ ^yl^-Vhem
15be ^^^ef 6QV4 `^C-LfTeA QYla ^^^^5 \Aj+11`z G.,
40 (35)
t- (Tb.p . I t> x 1 , 6 y-Z ) o 5 he- qp-°^^^ 5ctw Nhot,;^ ft^l 4e '^P,
r^^^^ ^^ ^i, ^^ ^^^^y^^^^ d ^^^ ^^.^fi ^^^ ► ^-1^^r1
wqty-, iowa^^b 0, CQ r, CInct ne-^^^ 5Q^ q vw) O1.e-
ck n,Cl Z5hf,
^.^ au^°^`1 ^^, ^^` ^ P^.^ ^.^c - ^t^►^,. ^..^^^ `
p^r^^,, ^ 1^i -^^^^S^
C^Q.'Im.P-C1 kr\ WI,^ ^^54^lm.e^yj j , T-Y ckpqe-11,C(ii+ Wq5
^^1 ^^1^. `^ i ^ ^ ii^, YoL.t
Ko,cli ^on ,wwlc^ ^^^ 6b5`c^`ve8 ^^^ -
070MP-5 lbz>rs^^ e-VeY\ 'M W15 ^e-5Aryjcnj
-$^o,`k cL qpe°1kcm--^ 0'^acl a tte-y-cl 11c`r. ['z^^^. qocl
^le V4)e^ ^dcl wcyl-^ (T- 9 --tas, 3°1 t)
Vf30
-^^^,^ Se^ qqpt:^k^y^' w^s '°A Ace ^O^fq
i^ +^Ie Re- c1c(IM5 -^-^-^` Ile-
wa.^s Qs "r^^ C-T.P.'
13LtA- Inc.\4 .cc^u18 Vp^ be- ?wlti^^ OLIN rl^ ^,.. )aclcl
akve'O.^^ cm^^ecllj d ^O've, OWp QLYYCI "np- c^ ^^ ne^,+
^ ^e I W^^+?C^'r . . .-zRSq-- j2) ,a tte ^l ^6^ /
sa^ .^ ^^ 8'lcl a^^ ct^peltcxfvi pulL
^aw^^ ^ 0-^ ^ow WOLS 1ae- *Iet'p'?
aa^ ^^- ^ I^► {^^^.k 0^ q, ^a^^ ^
t£^^e-%ZCN \4CLS 1^^
i 's
-.. (3-7 )
\4)c^^ ^^ ^ ^ ouffi 'has -^c> r^^me.-m^: ^-. t s -%cx^ "Vnz,-gn,5
-1^n -1^^^n-^^^
^^^^^ becau5e- ),Ie- CyLv^ 5e--qefa1 0^
vi`hcL+ Ina ^qev3e-,8 . "e- ^ven in wl:5
men+ because c^ ce-f-^ ^^^ iVjr^^,5 J1nck-^
mt1(`-I' ln wa^ Saj'in^ "^'^cL+ Ma<Ae f ^lm C\Ac^^2^^
^me -W^In..^ ^^^ d^ C^t".^-^^? } ^-1^^.^e ^,A^^^ ^
rn)'++eA or 5+an8 4,hqi Kac^Iyl i^^cl Wim ha-^
^le- ..^u1<l_ 'be (z^lcf^eci \41^^1
v^zo.(A oLnd Nha+ *oa^ i
s ^^)
f . ^ n +o d^'1^a^3e 'n i :5
1h,^A
00 8e°^e-&^W^S ^A^ WaS OCA- inNO-°^6A (TWPa °7'7^,
2-6 °2-3 ). ^,^ Ccmn^^^ ^^ ic) cxn8 :5cc^ ^ -v4cL:s
no°^ i nqol f eyp-yl in ^^ ^ ^cDncA
lqc^ ^^lll -^^^a wim Wla^ 0. ^aal *na-}
Wi M WaI Y-,tM3 Wii^°t \4 aX Cen T. 1°11, 2-t -2-3) .
I`Thr^^^ ^ 0,lci on --.^c.wa h^eA -^C1a Raxl^)n
^^'• i.^ t ^^^ 1 S 1 WIS Ses^Oncl 'o L-e.^^e^ C 6rQ
^aw-eveCl '1n Wr 5 t^ecoiicl ev^, ^a^
lKar^^n *0A aPPe\1ay,+ Wc^^ -no^-
'ne- KaLcA3 n on
_ (.3q)
re-corr,leA 0.`co. A`na^ appel.r^yi+ was
^ze-I
jW^^ ^^^ec Alne-
°" .1 k^^^^^ ' CM8 ^^ Du ^^^^ ^^n^ ^^,^ ^^^(:al
,l,5e i ^ ^^^ ,<A ^Iave ^ ^^^ ^^ ^ ^ .!Dti ^^ ^ mpe^^^,
on_
t{ ir^
^ ^ ILO, 1-3) _ °^^n "np- ^ ^ ^^(ay)a c.^^ 5CL^ s
dl
_ Q+ ._WcLt' (°^►^1 _.cxnt:
^^Im Qg (T - p - 1011013°6)^ AnQ%e-t' ^ / ckfl oll't"
oB (Aib)
,5+Q+eme-ni, a,noibet-
ll^
.5+6r^ .^ wefie ^nco'n ^mfn eac),1
6A,her, oil :5^qncl -Vncxyl -w)-P^ )-le$d +C1cl
gal ; ce, a ,^d iW5 c1enc `Ma* 'ne,
4 ^^-^- `^ b^ ^ r^q5 ke^ ^^^^ l ^ e 5 e^^ ^. `^ Yi ANI^
^^mo f1 „ 0', DN,4^ ^ afl(4 -,rhc^ VrrtQ5
c^ ^ ^ N4e p` ^"^.cc^ ^f^^ee^ ^.p on ^1^.^^ v
c(-^^^c! . vl ^ ^ Scc'Vefij
i^ c41>
ayid scat^ ^he- C3^ ^^ ^^ We-n^-^
A^ie s-^^-^e Inacl^
`bLt^ 5^,e1^j )-Inc^1 Cca^ ^tt^^^-^
a I te^y-8^^ ic^ld ^ef ^^ wc:1,5 . ^^ ^ ^qpoc--^
0? r^^^^^^^yl^ Y^CW cA ,^ s^:^^ C^^^i -^ ^
^ e cypet^^.,+ fla
OL ^Iatlwa ^
cl 6n 5+and 4^-^ ^ne Clcyrl,+ Y"Icv^ N"^)^+ ^Wc.$. ^ ,
V2...d19gZ3i gqji'Re 45o
Cl^dP ® ^^
(1-2)
5afn^ ^cusln 1WLd 'ba^ ^^e-k35
I-3 r-23).^`^^c^^
ryiDn^ 15 a^^ ^^^^n -^o
'rl and CbO..A- Ck^^.^1qj^^P^^^ ^qcLs
,51) +b^ ^^^ ^^ e- - ^' 5+c^ c ^; ,'Wi /
^
^%e PY^CI+6 a v ra ^ as -?ne_ :s u s^^o-+ CTe 9 ^ ^ 5 +,6-i,37 a
.r^af-^-^^ ^^ s ^je m^^e, Qcre3A- -Yr^^ qm
^
": rr p f i tJ ae5+V ^Ys, 15
I C^ kll(6 ^^ ^^^^^e Vz-z.3),
, ^^Itc^ ► ^° 15 .-^a. I ! . °ei,t,a,^ Ae-^.^-.5 L^s -f1n6M5'
^IC4^)
-ib 'Wile- ,evCl
c PPel `l^^t+ ^ ^e^^
MS-QY)d
T^ick1 ccUn z5e^ ca^'Z5
+^ i^f!A+j% ^y^^^o'-ne-
+wo o-I C'ctc^j
cxn I i^^^efi+/
ft (+'t)
abe,t^+ +0 in, bLt+ ^e(afid
w QPpl,^ltQo+ 1 s ^Nt ^3 0, ;la it^
q
°v^.^^v^,-
e^
^ J\ne, VO^^^^^ cl^
5ccwi 4t^ Mv^'r3e
a-0a^^ ^^
^wi y YI
^ ^o L4 Y) ^^II LI°6 ^s,5^^^
C,55- clQ
^^ ^^^^
t q ^
i`^'t^^ 'S cbtt p^ ^(3-,-> ^le^84^jck-^ -^
^n\ii^.-^i^^ ^^nql C13
^^ CC>LA,^5*P1 j a d ^^^^^ ayjj ra^^^ ^3-+Q`b`l 'l A
Ln F-ci. 2.cl ^ ^!`1 Q
BA
ec^%, ^^^^^^^ ^^^ ^^^^(Q^^ ^^nr,,ef^,3
JACLc. + -r-ctk c^C>I-A^^^1 x4cuZ^ ^Q\J-e
\Acx;s(i ^,)
Y)^
P.i +cc^^^^^13M
QY18 Q^ PpeltqY14<
A ^^eyl +^ ^
;ic^6^^^^ 5e. i-F, 5 1^^^ if
^ e^ ^,^^ °P ^r^^,^
^^^^^ ^4,5Fge4p tyl Q
^c^u rmer^ ^ ^^^ ,\/
f R-7 F. ^^ ^ 9-1, al-t C; r .
54^ '^^^^ ^^cSt j ^^^^^^^^ ^ ^^^
^ \f\e iqq,57 Vjbe_tl )0'^^+^l
(47)
v' lc.."'"l^^` i ^'1 ^ 1 ^. ^^ ^`^'► ^ ^ y1^1 1
'^^1 ^ 5 Cc^^ t'^ ^^uld CeM^,d^ NY ^ ^ U^^^^^"U
lcon^ilc-^ C4 0.^^ ^^^^^^^^^3 W, 1--i
^^ ^ cc>LAfi^ ^^^^ ^^^ ^ ^
icLI
Speed^-
^^^^
irn Irc" fn RcN5:su^^, C.^ Y,
Rc(i^hqn^lelP^5 e-
(/t s )
^^^^'^.-, -^s T
.
` ^C4 Yl SL^^^^^^^^
^^^ leA
'Af2-1 \Ae5-^+ 'Ya\
*5 2-5+h^
^
^^^