overview and summary of the third aiaa high lift ... · overview and summary of the third aiaa high...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
OverviewandSummaryoftheThirdAIAAHighLiftPredictionWorkshop
ChristopherL.RumseyNASALangleyResearchCenter
Hampton,VA
JeffreyP.SlotnickTheBoeingCompany
Seattle,WA
AnthonyJ.SclafaniTheBoeingCompany
LongBeach,CA
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 1
![Page 2: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Overview• GeneralsummaryofHiLiftPW-3results.• CFDcomparisonsagainstitself(consistency,verification).• CFDcomparisonsagainstexperiment(validation).
• HavethingsimprovedsinceHiLiftPW-2?• Whathavewelearned?• WhatshouldbedonedifferentlyforHiLiftPW-4?
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 2
![Page 3: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Outline• Introduction• Highliftgeometriesandexperimentaldata• Gridsystems• Summaryofentries• Results• Turbulencemodelingverification• HL-CRM• JSM
• Statisticalanalysis• Conclusions
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 3
![Page 4: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Wherewe’vebeen(somehighlights)• HiLiftPW-1(2010).• NASATrapezoidalWing-Body;includingeffectofflapdeflection.• CFDtendedtounderpredict lift;bigspreadnearstall.• NosupportbracketswereincludedintheCFD(whentheywere,predictedliftwasevenlower).• Transitionmodelingseemedtohelpimprovecomparisonswithexperiment.• Flownearwingtipwasverydifficulttopredict.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 4
![Page 5: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Wherewe’vebeen(somehighlights)• HiLiftPW-1(2010).• NASATrapezoidalWing-Body;includingeffectofflapdeflection.• CFDtendedtounderpredict lift;bigspreadnearstall.• NosupportbracketswereincludedintheCFD(whentheywere,predictedliftwasevenlower).• Transitionmodelingseemedtohelpimprovecomparisonswithexperiment.• Flownearwingtipwasverydifficulttopredict.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 5
![Page 6: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Wherewe’vebeen(somehighlights)• HiLiftPW-2(2013).
• DLR-F11Wing-Body;includingeffectofReynoldsnumber.• CFDsometimesunderpredicted,sometimesoverpredicted lift;againshowedbiggerspreadnearstall.
• Separationbehindslattrackswasprobablyinfluentialininitiatingstall;evenwhenincludingbrackets,CFDusuallygotitwrong(e.g.,separationbehindwrongbrackets).
• Nocleartrendswithtransitionmodelingstoodout.• Attainingsteady-stateconvergencesometimesdifficult.• ExperimentaloilflowswereextremelyusefulfordeterminingwhetherCFDwascapturingthephysicscorrectlyornot.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 6
![Page 7: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Wherewe’vebeen(somehighlights)• HiLiftPW-2(2013).
• DLR-F11Wing-Body;includingeffectofReynoldsnumber.• CFDsometimesunderpredicted,sometimesoverpredicted lift;againshowedbiggerspreadnearstall.
• Separationbehindslattrackswasprobablyinfluentialininitiatingstall;evenwhenincludingbrackets,CFDusuallygotitwrong(e.g.,separationbehindwrongbrackets).
• Nocleartrendswithtransitionmodelingstoodout.• Attainingsteady-stateconvergencesometimesdifficult.• ExperimentaloilflowswereextremelyusefulfordeterminingwhetherCFDwascapturingthephysicscorrectlyornot.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 7
![Page 8: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Quickcomparison
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 8
HiLiftPW-1 HiLiftPW-2 HiLiftPW-3
37submissions 48submissions 79submissions
![Page 9: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
HiLiftPW-3geometriesandexperimentaldata
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 9
HL-CRM JSM
NotyetbuiltTestedinJAXA-LWT1inearly2000s- Notripping
ForcesMomentCpOilflowSometransitioninfo
![Page 10: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
HiLiftPW-3geometriesandexperimentaldata
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 10
HL-CRM JSM
NotyetbuiltTestedinJAXA-LWT1inearly2000s- Notripping
ForcesMomentCpOilflowSometransitioninfoHiLiftPW-3alsopartnered
with thefirstGeometryandMeshGenerationWorkshop(GMGW-1),usingHL-CRM
![Page 11: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Committee-providedgridsystems
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 11
Averagemedium grid:approx 71Mpointsand120McellsMedianmedium grid:approx 52Mpointsand107Mcells
ForHL-CRMandJSM
![Page 12: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Summaryofentries• 35individuals/groupswith79entries.
• 14differentcountries(40%U.S.).• Broadrepresentationfromindustry,academia,CFDvendors,andgovernmentresearchlabs.
• Turbulencemodels:• MostusedSAorvariant(RC,R,neg,QCR,noft2).• K-omegatype:BSL,SST,SST-V,SST-V-sust,SST-2003,SSTwmods,Wilcox1988,Wilcox1988CC.• Lag-EB-ke.• SSG/LRR-RSM-w2012.
• Transitionmodels:• SST-gamma,AFT2017b,gamma-Ret-SST.
• Non-RANS:• FiniteelementwithimplicitSGSmodel.• LBwithVLESwallmodel.• LBwithWALESGSmodel.• DDES.
• Noteveryonesubmittedallrequestedcases.• Detailsinpaper.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 12
![Page 13: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Results• Turbulencemodelingverification• HL-CRM• JSM
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 13
![Page 14: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Results• Turbulencemodelingverification• HL-CRM• JSM
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 14
DSMA661(ModelA)airfoil,M=0.088,alpha=0deg,ReC=1.2million(JFM160:155-179,1985)
![Page 15: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Turbulencemodelingverification
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 15
OnlycompletedforSAmodel(SA,SA-neg,SA-noft2)
![Page 16: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Theimportantroleofverification
2-Dverificationcase
VERIF/2DANWcasefromTMRwebsite:https://turbmodels.larc.nasa.gov
VerificationremovesonepossiblesourceofCFDuncertainty,foragivenmodel.Othersources:grid(size,extent,adherencetogeometry),BCs,iterativeconvergence.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 16
8differentcodesproducenearlyidenticalresultsforSAmodel(CFL3D,FUN3D,Kestrel/COFFE,CFD++,OVERFLOW,BCFD,TAU,andLAVA)
Approximately30% ofthecodesthatrantheverificationcasewerefullyverified fortheSAmodel
Additionalverificationexercisesstillneededforothermodels,includingSAvariants
![Page 17: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Results• Turbulencemodelingverification• HL-CRM• JSM
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 17
Focusingononlyafewmainpointshere;furtherdetails(suchaseffectofflapgaptreatment)aregiveninthepaper
![Page 18: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
HL-CRMgridconvergence(allresults)
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 18
alpha=8deg. alpha=16deg.
DragandmomentshowninpaperNote:bluecurvesrepresentgrid-adaptionresults
![Page 19: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Theimportantroleofverification
2-DverificationcaseHL-CRM
SAmodelsonly
BluelinespassedtheverificationtestforSA
VERIF/2DANWcasefromTMRwebsite:https://turbmodels.larc.nasa.gov
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 19
8differentcodesproducenearlyidenticalresultsforSAmodel(CFL3D,FUN3D,Kestrel/COFFE,CFD++,OVERFLOW,BCFD,TAU,andLAVA)
![Page 20: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Theimportantroleofverification
2-DverificationcaseHL-CRM
SAmodelsonly
VERIF/2DANWcasefromTMRwebsite:https://turbmodels.larc.nasa.gov
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 20
8differentcodesproducenearlyidenticalresultsforSAmodel(CFL3D,FUN3D,Kestrel/COFFE,CFD++,OVERFLOW,BCFD,TAU,andLAVA)
BluelinespassedtheverificationtestforSA
![Page 21: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
HL-CRMvelocityprofiles
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 21
FLAP:x=1615,y=638 MAIN:x=1495,y=638
![Page 22: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Results• Turbulencemodelingverification• HL-CRM• JSM
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 22
Focusingononlyafewmainpointshere;furtherdetailsaregiveninthepaper
![Page 23: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
JSM,nonacelle/pylon
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 23
Liftcoefficient Dragcoefficient Momentcoefficient
![Page 24: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
JSM,withnacelle/pylon
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 24
Liftcoefficient Dragcoefficient Momentcoefficient
![Page 25: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
JSM,deltasbetweennacelle/pylononandoff
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 25
Liftcoefficient Dragcoefficient Momentcoefficient
Exceptforoneoutlier,participantspredicteddeltaswell(albeitlargescatternearmaxlift)
![Page 26: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
CFDresultsthatagreed“best”withJSMCL data
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 26
Nonacelle/pylon Withnacelle/pylon
Minimize!"Σ 𝐶𝐿, 𝐶𝐹𝐷 − 𝐶𝐿, 𝑒𝑥𝑝
2
(ignoringresultswithno/lateCL,max)
SASALBVLESSASA-RC-QCRSA-RC-QCRW98CC+transLBWALESST[mod]
SA-QCRSA-negSA-negSA-RC-QCRSA-RC-QCRW98CCW98CC+transLBWALESST[mod]
![Page 27: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Generalobservationfromtheworkshop• MostoftheRANScodesproducedsurfaceflowsthathadtoomuchseparationnearthewingtipcomparedtotheexperimentandnotenoughseparationnearthewingrootatandbeyondmaxlift.• Notableexceptions:scale-resolvingmethods(likeLB).
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 27
Exp,alpha=18.58deg. Exp,alpha=21.57deg.
![Page 28: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Generalobservationfromtheworkshop• MostoftheRANScodesproducedsurfaceflowsthathadtoomuchseparationnearthewingtipcomparedtotheexperimentandnotenoughseparationnearthewingrootatandbeyondmaxlift.• Notableexceptions:scale-resolvingmethods(likeLB).
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 28
Exp,alpha=18.58deg. Exp,alpha=21.57deg.
(notionaltypicalRANS)
![Page 29: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
JSM:surfacepressurecoefficients
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 29
A-A B-B C-C
E-E G-G H-H
Mainelement,alpha=21.57deg.,nonacelle/pylon
![Page 30: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
JSM:issuesnearCL,max
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 30
Nonacelle/pylon Withnacelle/pylon
GridandtemporaltreatmentbothhavebiginfluenceSamecode&model,differentgrid
Samecode&model,differentgridSamecode,model&grid,time-accuratevs.steady-state
![Page 31: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
JSM:furtherevidenceofinsufficientgriddensity
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 31
All“SA-verified”codesdonotagreewellusingSAon(different)mediumgrids
COFFE,gridC1TAU,gridBTAU,gridf(nc)OVERFLOW,gridATAU,gridBLAVA,gridAFUN3D,gridC1FUN3D,gridC2
Andbluecurvespointtominorissueswithinsufficientiterativeconvergenceand/orcodesetting/versiondifferences
![Page 32: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
JSM:effectoftransitionmodels
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 32
Nonacelle/pylon Withnacelle/pylon
• TransitiondefinitelypresentatthisRe• For030.1vs.030.3(committeegridE),littleinfluenceoftransitionnoted• For030.2vs.030.4(participantgridb),transitioncausedhigherCL inthe
linearrangeandanearlierstall,inbetteragreementwithexperiment
SST-gammaSA-RC-QCR+AFT2017bW98CC+transW98CC+trans
SA-RC-QCR+AFT2017bW98CC+trans
![Page 33: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Statisticalanalysis:HL-CRM• Mainconclusion:generalscatterdidnotalwaysdecreasebetweenthemediumandfinegrids,aswouldbeexpectedifnumericalerrorduetogridresolutionwastheprimarysourceofvariation.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 33
Notch=medianDiamond=mean
Upperandlowerquartiles
Minvaluethatisconsideredstatisticallysignificant
OutlierShadingrepresentsdistribution
![Page 34: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Statisticalanalysis:JSM
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 34
alpha=4.36deg. alpha=14.54deg. alpha=20.59deg.
Cv=σ/𝜇 =standarddeviation/medianScatterlimits=µ ± 𝐾𝜎(𝐾 = 3� )
Focusingononlyafewmainpointshere;furtherdetailsaregiveninthepaper
![Page 35: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
HasCFDgottenanytightersinceHiLiftPW-2?
Cases Cv,lowalpha Cv,midalpha Cv,highalpha
HiLiftPW-2,alpha=7,16,20deg.
0.038 0.057 0.060
HiLiftPW-3, alpha=4.36,14.54,20.59deg.
0.025 0.017 0.073
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 35
LowRe,withbrackets,mediumgrids
YES YES NO
![Page 36: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Conclusions• Intheverificationcase,only30%oftheCFDcodesthatparticipatedwiththeSAturbulencemodelwerefullyverified.• HL-CRMcaseexploredgridconvergence.
• SpreadbetweenCFDresultsdidnotdiminishonfinegrids(similartoHiLiftPW-2).• Lackofverificationinsomecodesmayexplainpartofthespread.
• JSMexploredeffectofnacelle/pyloninstallation.• Useof“medium”gridonly;deltasweregenerallywellpredicted.• LargespreadinCFDresultsnearCL,max (similartoHiLiftPW-1and2).• SignificantinfluenceofgridnearCL,max,so”medium”gridprobablynotfineenough.• Transitionshouldbeimportantforthiscase,buttransitionmodelswerenotalwaysbetter(gridinfluence?).
• Manyindividualresultscomparedverywellwithexperimentalliftcurve;butwedonotknowwhy.
• Itwaspossibletogetintegratedquantitiesrightforthewrongreasons.• Scale-resolvingmethodsappearedtopredictseparationpatternsbetterthanRANS.• Participantsweremoreconsistent(comparedtoHiLiftPW-2)predictingcomplexhigh-liftconfigurationatlowRewithallmountingbrackethardwareatlowalphas– BUTNOTNEARCL,max.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 36
![Page 37: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
HiLiftPW-4statusandotherquestions/thoughts• WhatshouldbedonedifferentlyinHiLiftPW-4,sothatwelearnmore?• Proposal:requiretheuseofoneormorespecific(verified)models.
• Identifythe“best”(publicly-available)RANSmodel(s)fromthisworkshop,andrequestthatallRANSparticipantsverifyit intheircodeanduseit.
• Allowadditionalresultsusinganymodelormodelvariant.• NearCL,max: encouragelargergrids,moregridadaption,higherorder,time-accurate,moreuseofscale-resolvingmethods.• Nomorefree-airCFDruns;trytomatchthewindtunnelsemispan testinggeometryandBCs.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 37
![Page 38: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
End
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 38
![Page 39: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Backup
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 39
![Page 40: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Introduction• Specificworkshopseriesfocusedonthepredictionofswept,medium/high-aspectratiowingsinlanding/takeoff(highlift)configurations.• GoalsofHiLift workshopseries:• Assessthenumericalpredictioncapability ofcurrent-generationCFDtechnology.• DeveloppracticalmodelingguidelinesforCFDpredictionofhighliftflowfields.• Advancetheunderstandingofhighliftflowphysicstoenabledevelopmentofmoreaccuratepredictionmethodsandtools.• EnhanceCFDpredictioncapabilityforhighliftaerodynamicdesignandoptimization.• Provideanimpartialforum.• Identifyareasneedingadditionalresearchanddevelopment.
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 40
![Page 41: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Testcases• Case1- GridConvergenceStudyontheNASAHL-CRM(freeair,fullyturb).
• 1a:Fullchordflapgap,M=0.2,ReMAC=3.26M,alpha=8,16deg.• 1b:Sameas1a,withgridadaption.• 1c:Sameas1aexceptpartially-sealedflapgap.• 1d:Sameas1c,withgridadaption.
• Case2- NacelleInstallationStudyontheJSM(freeair,fullyturb orwithtransition).• 2a:Nacelle/pylonoff,M=0.173,ReMAC=1.93M,sixalphas.• 2b:Sameas2a,withgridadaption.• 2c:Sameas2aexceptNacelle/pylonon.• 2d:Sameas2c,withgridadaption.
• Case3- TurbulenceModelVerificationStudy(fullyturb).• VERIF/2DANWfromhttp://turbmodels.larc.nasa.gov
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 41
Black=requestedBlue=optional
![Page 42: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Gridsystems
Label Gridtool Org Type Coarse Medium Fine Extra-fine Notes
A-HLCRM ANSA+Chimera
NASA str 24/23 65/64 189/185 564/554 Overset
B1-HLCRM Pointwise Pointwise unstr 8/48 26/157 70/416 206/1228 Tet
B2-HLCRM Pointwise Pointwise unstr 8/22 26/65 70/170 206/541 Mixedprism/tet
B3-HLCRM Pointwise Pointwise unstr 8/18 27/48 71/119 208/397 Mixed
C-HLCRM GridPro GridPro str 10/8 77/68 338/311 n/a One-to-one
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 42
HL-CRM“committeegrids”
Points/cells
![Page 43: Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift ... · Overview and Summary of the Third AIAA High Lift Prediction Workshop Christopher L. Rumsey NASA Langley Research Center Hampton,](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041216/5e055a36b8295572ca6d52f4/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Gridsystems
Label Gridtool Org Type Medium,noN/P
Medium,with N/P
Notes
A-JSM Chimera NASA str 221/216 235/230 Overset
B-JSM DLR-SOLAR DLR unstr 102/162 126/207 Mixed
C1-JSM VGRID Spaceship&Gulfstream
unstr 16/97 21/124 Tet
C1-JSM VGRID Spaceship&Gulfstream
unstr 16/52 21/65 Mixed
D-JSM JAXAtools JAXA unstr 50/120 59/139 Mixed
E-JSM ANSA UOxford&BETA-CAE
unstr 52/107 58/120 Mixed
AIAASciTech,Kissimmee,FL,January8-12,2018 43
JSM“committeegrids”