Partizipation durch Standardisierung?

Erschließung vor dem Hintergrund fortgeschrittener

Nutzeremanzipation

Karsten Kühnel

Offene Archive 2.1, Stuttgart, 3./4. April 2014

„Forscher suchen nicht nach Herkunftsstellen, sondern nach Inhalten.“

Fonds nach ISAD(G)

„[…] the fonds has served to codify archival description as a singular, fixed representation of a whole and its parts and as a linear, top-down process, which doesn‘t adequately reflect or address the complex realities of recordkeeping.“

(Jennifer Meehan, 2014)

ISAD(G), 3.5.3

ISAD(G): „Fonds“

„The whole of records, regardless of form or medium, organically created and/or accumulated and used by a particular person, family or corporate body in the course of that creator‘s activities and functions.“

Funktionale Provenienz

Archiv

Function

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Function

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Function

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Sub-Function

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

Process/Activity

„Scott added an important conceptual element by stressing the power of description, indeed, by eventually preferring description to arrangement.“

(Peter Horsman, 2002)

Horsman: „Fonds“

„A fonds (F) is any set of relationships (r1, r2, r3, etc.), where a record (a1, a2, a3, etc.) is an element in any of the identified (and non-identified) relationships. Evidently, a record can be part of two or more relationships, and two or more fonds.“

(Peter Horsman, 2002)

„This is Weinberger‘s ‚third order of order‘, in which resources can bei arranged into as many sequences as may be desired and users can organize their work independently of the limitations imposed by analog systems.“

(Geoffrey Yeo, 2012)

Conceptual Reference Model

Conceptual Model for Archival Description in Spain / Comisión de Normas Españolas de Descripción Archivística, 2012

Multiple Archival Unit

Partizipierung

Addressed Sourcing:

Identifikation von

Communities

Interaktive Ko-operation (beid-

oder mehrseitiges „Prosumieren“)

durativ-dialogische

Kommunikation

„Participatory Archives“

Partizipation

Web 2.0

Addressed Sourcing

Emanzipier-te Nutzer

Standardi-sierung

“Rather, an ‚Archives 2.0‘ mode of description might encompass participatory archives, which ‚posits a more radical user orientation, where both archivists and users collaborate to build the archive itself.”

(Jennifer Meehan, 2014; Joy Palmer, 2009)

Thank you for your attention!