petroleum watch california energy commission october … · product of the energy assessments...

16
Product of the Energy Assessments Division’s Supply Analysis Office PETROLEUM WATCH California Energy Commission October 2015 Recent Petroleum News and Outside Analyses Prices California Gasoline Prices: The gasoline price difference between California and the rest of the United States fell from 90 cents above the national average in July to 75 cents during the third week of September. California Diesel Prices: The diesel price difference between California and the rest of the United States increased by 3 cents from August levels, to 36 cents during the third week of September. Refining News Plains All American Crude Oil Line 903: This line remains closed and reduces crude oil shipments to the Phillips 66 Santa Maria Refinery by roughly 44,500 barrels per day. Phillips 66 Santa Maria Refinery: The Santa Maria Refinery continues to operate at restricted levels, and Phillips has accelerated planned maintenance at the refinery. Exxon Mobil Torrance Refinery: Refinery crude oil processing units remains offline for maintenance. Minimal blending component processing is occurring, but crude oil processing will be offline until 2016. Exxon Mobil Torrance Refinery: On September 30, Exxon Mobil announced that it had reached an agreement to sell the refinery to PBF Energy, an American refining company that owns three refineries, all on the East Coast, and has agreed to purchase a fourth in Louisiana. This will be the company’s fifth refinery and its first on the West Coast.

Upload: hacong

Post on 17-Nov-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Product of the Energy Assessments Division’s Supply Analysis Office    

PETROLEUM WATCH California Energy Commission

October 2015

Recent Petroleum News and Outside Analyses

Prices � California  Gasoline  Prices:  The  gasoline  price  difference  between  California  and  the  rest  of  the  United  

States  fell  from  90  cents  above  the  national  average  in  July  to  75  cents  during  the  third  week  of  September.  

� California  Diesel  Prices:  The  diesel  price  difference  between  California  and  the  rest  of  the  United  States  increased  by  3  cents  from  August  levels,  to  36  cents  during  the  third  week  of  September.  

Refining News

� Plains  All  American  Crude  Oil  Line  903:  This  line  remains  closed  and  reduces  crude  oil  shipments  to  the  Phillips  66  Santa  Maria  Refinery  by  roughly  44,500  barrels  per  day.  

� Phillips  66  Santa  Maria  Refinery:  The  Santa  Maria  Refinery  continues  to  operate  at  restricted  levels,  and  Phillips  has  accelerated  planned  maintenance  at  the  refinery.  

� Exxon  Mobil  Torrance  Refinery:  Refinery  crude  oil  processing  units  remains  offline  for  maintenance.  Minimal  blending  component  processing  is  occurring,  but  crude  oil  processing  will  be  offline  until  2016.  

� Exxon  Mobil  Torrance  Refinery:  On  September  30,  Exxon  Mobil  announced  that  it  had  reached  an  agreement  to  sell  the  refinery  to  PBF  Energy,  an  American  refining  company  that  owns  three  refineries,  all  on  the  East  Coast,  and  has  agreed  to  purchase  a  fourth  in  Louisiana.  This  will  be  the  company’s  fifth  refinery  and  its  first  on  the  West  Coast.  

2  

Crude Oil Prices

Figure 1: Daily West Coast Spot Crude Oil Prices, April 2014 to Present1

Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration, Oil Price Information Service (OPIS), and Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Although  crude  oil  prices  dipped  slightly  in  late  August,  on  September  21,1  the  prices  had  returned  to  roughly  the  levels  seen  in  mid-­‐‑August.  The  California  Estimated  Refiner  Acquisition  Cost2  (CA-­‐‑RAC)  of  crude  oil  was  just  $1.28  higher  than  it  had  been  on  August  17  (Figure  1).  The  spread  between  West  Texas  Intermediate  (WTI)  and  Brent  crude  oil  continued  to  narrow  and  was  only  97  cents  on  September  21.  

During  late  August  and  September,  the  dollar  moved  in  tandem  with  crude  oil  prices,  which  is  contrary  to  the  usual  pattern,  but  the  price  moves  were  quite  small  compared  to  what  occurred  over  the  past  year.  

                                                                                                             

1  Shaded  areas  on  all  graphs  indicate  previous  report  data.  Unshaded  areas  indicate  new  data  since  last  month’s  Petroleum  Watch.  2  California  estimated  refiner  acquisition  cost  is  an  estimate  of  the  average  price  of  crude  oil  paid  by  California  refineries.  It  is  created  using  California  refinery  input  proportions  of  California  crude,  Alaskan  crude,  and  foreign  crude  and  multiplying  them  by  the  prices  of  San  Joaquin  Valley,  Alaskan  North  Slope,  and  Brent  crude  oil,  respectively.        

60

65

70

75

80

85

90

95

100

105

$0

$20

$40

$60

$80

$100

$120

$140

01-A

pr-1

4

01-M

ay-1

4

01-J

un-1

4

01-J

ul-1

4

01-A

ug-1

4

01-S

ep-1

4

01-O

ct-1

4

01-N

ov-1

4

01-D

ec-1

4

01-J

an-1

5

01-F

eb-1

5

01-M

ar-1

5

01-A

pr-1

5

01-M

ay-1

5

01-J

un-1

5

01-J

ul-1

5

01-A

ug-1

5

01-S

ep-1

5

Ind

exed

Val

ue

of

the

U.S

. Do

llar

(197

3 =

100

)

Do

llars

per

Bar

rel (

No

min

al)

Brent West Texas Intermediate CA Estimated Refinery Acquisition Cost Trade Weighted U.S. Dollar Index: Major Currencies

Crude Oil Prices

September 2014 vs 2015 (Percent Change)

WTI 51% lower Brent 51% lower CA-RAC 52% lower

August 2015 Averages

WTI $42.87 Brent $46.52 CA-RAC $42.30

September 21, 2015

WTI $46.67 Brent $47.64

3  

Crude Oil Production and Storage

The  price  of  crude  oil  has  levelled  off,  U.S.  production  of  crude  oil  has  declined  over  the  past  month,  and  the  amount  of  crude  oil  in  storage  has  levelled  off.  U.S.  refinery  utilization  has  fallen  to  90  percent  from  95  percent.  Nevertheless,  storage  inventories  remain  well  above  five-­‐‑year  averages,  and  production  remains  at  high  levels  when  compared  to  historical  averages.  

� U.  S.  crude  oil  output  declined  from  9.3  million  barrels  per  day  (bpd)  in  July  to  9.1  million  bpd  in  August,  according  to  U.S.  Energy  Information  Administration  (EIA)  estimates.  

� Imports  of  Canadian  crude  oil  still  remain  strong,  averaging  more  than  3  million  bpd  during  September.  

� Crude  oil  inventories  in  the  United  States  continue  to  remain  at  unusually  high  levels  and  have  levelled  off  at  about  455  million  barrels  over  the  past  two  months  (Figure  2).  Since  motorists  are  entering  a  season  of  reduced  petroleum  consumption  due  to  the  end  of  the  summer  driving  season  and  the  onset  of  refinery  maintenance  season,  there  is  a  good  chance  that  inventories  will  cease  the  decline  and  possibly  even  increase,  which  is  normal  at  this  time  of  year.  

Figure 2: U.S. Crude Oil Inventories, December 2013 to Present  

 Source: EIA.

� According  to  the  most  recent  data  from  the  Organization  of  the  Petroleum  Exporting  Countries  (OPEC),  Saudi  Arabian  crude  output  has  fallen  slightly  since  the  second  quarter  but  in  August  was  5.6  percent  higher  than  in  the  fourth  quarter  of  2014.  Total  OPEC  production  hasn’t  increased  quite  as  much  but  is  up  4.1  percent  over  the  same  period.  

4  

�  

Gasoline and Diesel Retail Prices and Margins Figure 3: Regular Grade Gasoline Retail Prices, California vs. West Coast vs. United States

Source: EIA.  

California  retail  gasoline  prices  have  declined  $0.83  since  setting  a  record  high  for  2015  during  the  week  of  July  20,  dropping  by  21  percent  (Figure  3).  This  decline  includes  a  $0.51  drop  over  the  past  five  weeks  from  the  week  of  August  17  to  the  week  of  September  21.  Retail  prices  in  California  averaged  $3.16  for  during  the  first  three  weeks  of  September,  keeping  the  monthly  average  below  the  2015  annual  average  price  of  $3.30.  The  corresponding  national  price  also  shows  a  decrease  of  $0.39  over  the  same  period  with  an  average  of  $2.38  for  the  month  of  September.  This  is  a  decline  of  16  percent  for  California  and  30  percent  for  U.S.  gasoline  prices  from  a  year  ago.  

The  difference  between  California  and  U.S.  retail  gasoline  prices  peaked  at  $1.10  during  the  week  of  July  20.  Since  then,  the  difference  in  prices  has  slowly  decreased  to  $0.74  for  the  week  of  September  21,  a  change  of  $0.36.  California-­‐‑to-­‐‑West  Coast3  price  differences  have  decreased  over  the  same  

                                                                                                             

3  West  Coast  is  being  defined  as  all  PADD  5  states  minus  California  for  this  report.  PADD  stands  for  Petroleum  Administration  for  Defense  Districts.  PADD  5  includes  the  states  of  Hawaii,  Alaska,  Washington,  Oregon,  California,  Nevada,  and  Arizona.  

period,  dropping  from  $0.80  to  $0.44,  a  change  of  $0.36,  which  is  similar  to  the  change  in  U.S.  gasoline  price  to  California  price  difference.    

Regular Gasoline Prices

September 2014 vs 2015 (Percent Change)

California 16% lower U.S. 30% lower West Coast 26% lower

September 2015 Averages

California $3.16 U.S. $2.38 West Coast $2.71

$1.80

$2.10

$2.40

$2.70

$3.00

$3.30

$3.60

$3.90

$4.20

$4.50

1-A

pr-1

4

1-M

ay-1

4 1-

Jun-

14

1-Ju

l-14

1-A

ug-1

4 1-

Sep

-14

1-O

ct-1

4

1-N

ov-1

4 1-

Dec

-14

1-Ja

n-15

1-

Feb

-15

1-M

ar-1

5

1-A

pr-1

5

1-M

ay-1

5 1-

Jun-

15

1-Ju

l-15

1-A

ug-1

5 1-

Sep

-15

Do

llars

per

Gal

lon

(N

om

inal

)

California

U.S.

West Coast (less California)

5  

Week of September 21,

2015 California $3.07

U.S. $2.33 West Coast $2.63

Figure 4: No. 2 Diesel Ultra-Low-Sulfur Retail Prices, California vs. PADD5 vs. United States

Source: EIA.

California  retail  diesel  prices  fell  $0.42,  since  setting  a  2015  high  at  $3.27  in  May,  to  $2.85  for  the  week  of  September  21.  As  California  diesel  prices  decrease  to  an  annual  low,  the  2015  diesel  year-­‐‑to-­‐‑date  (YTD)  average  price  is  $0.89  cents  lower  than  the  2014  year-­‐‑to-­‐‑date  diesel  price  average.  Since  the  beginning  of  the  year,  diesel  prices  from  the  rest  of  the  West  Coast  averaged  $0.04  cents  more  than  the  U.S.  diesel  prices.  Meanwhile,  California  diesel  prices  stayed  high  and  ran  parallel  to  U.S.  diesel  prices,  maintaining  an  average  difference  of  $0.30  (Figure  4).  

From  a  historical  look,  retail  California  diesel  prices  have  not  been  this  low  since  October  2009,  at  $2.79  a  gallon.  Since  2009,  the  average  price  per  gallon  of  diesel  started  at  $3.78  and  rose  to  as  high  as  $4.49  a  gallon  in  September  2012.  

 

 

 

 

Diesel Prices

September 2014 vs 2015 (Percent Change)

California 29% lower U.S. 34% lower West Coast 35% lower

September 2015 Averages

California $2.86 U.S. $2.51 West Coast $2.57

Week of September 21,

2015 California $2.85

$2.20

$2.40

$2.60

$2.80

$3.00

$3.20

$3.40

$3.60

$3.80

$4.00

$4.20

$4.40

1-A

pr-1

4 1-

May

-14

1-Ju

n-14

1-

Jul-1

4

1-A

ug-1

4

1-S

ep-1

4 1-

Oct

-14

1-N

ov-1

4 1-

Dec

-14

1-Ja

n-15

1-F

eb-1

5 1-

Mar

-15

1-A

pr-1

5 1-

May

-15

1-Ju

n-15

1-

Jul-1

5

1-A

ug-1

5

1-S

ep-1

5

Do

llars

per

Gal

lon

(N

om

inal

)

California

U.S.

West Coast (less California)

6  

U.S. $2.49 West Coast $2.55 Figure 5: CA-RAC to Ex-Tax California Gasoline and Diesel Margins

Source: EIA and OPIS.

The  CA-­‐‑RAC–to–ex-­‐‑tax  retail  margins4  decreased  in  late  August  and  September  from  early  July  highs.  The  CA-­‐‑RAC–to–ex-­‐‑tax  retail  gasoline  margin  decreased  $0.30  from  the  beginning  of  August  until  the  end  of  the  month,  finishing  at  $1.70  (Figure  5).  The  CA-­‐‑RAC–to–ex-­‐‑tax  retail  diesel  margin  remained  steady  throughout  August,  moving  between  $1.00  and  $1.10.  

Reduced  demand  from  driving  has  reduced  demand  pressures  for  gasoline  throughout  the  state,  in  turn  lowering  retail  prices.  Even  with  the  $0.36  decrease  in  the  gasoline  margin,  it  remains  73  percent  greater  than  the  same  time  last  year,  as  the  reduction  in  available  gasoline  production  from  the  continued  maintenance  of  the  ExxonMobil  Torrance  refinery  puts  upward  pressure  on  gasoline  prices.  

                                                                                                               

4  The  RAC-­‐‑to-­‐‑retail  margin  refers  to  the  difference  between  the  retail  price  and  the  refiners’  acquisition  cost  for  crude  oil.  Thus,  it  includes  all  costs  of  producing  gasoline  or  diesel.  "ʺEx-­‐‑tax"ʺ  refers  to  the  removal  of  all  California  taxes  on  the  price  of  fuel,  which  is  done  to  remove  any  distortions  from  taxes  that  may  affect  this  calculation.  

Crude to Retail Margins

September 2014 vs 2015 (Percent Change)

Gasoline 73% higher Diesel 1% lower

August 2015 Averages

Gasoline $1.90 Diesel $1.14

Sept 21, 2015

Gasoline $1.54 Diesel $1.07

$0.00

$0.50

$1.00

$1.50

$2.00

$2.50 1-

Apr

-14

1-M

ay-1

4

1-Ju

n-14

1-Ju

l-14

1-A

ug-1

4

1-S

ep-1

4

1-O

ct-1

4

1-N

ov-1

4

1-D

ec-1

4

1-Ja

n-15

1-F

eb-1

5

1-M

ar-1

5

1-A

pr-1

5

1-M

ay-1

5

1-Ju

n-15

1-Ju

l-15

1-A

ug-1

5

1-S

ep-1

5

Do

llars

per

Gal

lon

(N

om

inal

)

CA RAC to CA Ex-Tax Retail Gasoline

CA RAC to CA Ex-Tax Retail Diesel

7  

Figure 6: California Spot Gasoline to NYMEX Futures Price Spread

 Source: EIA and OPIS.

The  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑New  York  Mercantile  Exchange  (NYMEX)  spot–futures  spread5  remained  elevated  in  August,  averaging  $0.41.  After  a  2015  high  was  reached  on  July  9  at  $1.35  a  gallon,  the  differential  remained  volatile  for  the  rest  of  July  before  easing  in  early  August  (Figure  6).  The  differential  continued  to  decrease  in  early  September,  reaching  a  three-­‐‑month  low  of  $0.17  on  September  21,  but  increased  the  next  day  to  $0.32.  

The  San  Francisco-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spot–futures  spread  did  not  show  the  volatility  in  July  that  the  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑New  York  Mercantile  Exchange  spot–futures  spread  did.  This  differential  reached  a  July  high  of  $0.60  on  July  23  and  lessened  in  August  to  $0.16  on  the  final  day  of  that  month.  

                                                                                                             

5  A  higher  spread  between  the  state’s  spot  fuel  prices  and  the  NYMEX  futures  price  indicates  supplies  are  tighter  in  California,  and  a  lower  or  negative  spread  indicates  the  market  is  relatively  well-­‐‑supplied  compared  to  the  rest  of  the  country.  The  NYMEX  futures  price  reflects  the  national  market,  while  California  Reformulated  Gasoline  Blendstock  for  Oxygenate  Blending  (CARBOB)  is  a  gasoline  blend  unique  to  California  and  is  usually  sold  at  a  premium  to  the  NYMEX.  

 

Gasoline Spot–Futures Spread

August 2014 vs 2015 (cents)

Los Angeles 41¢ higher San Fran. 19¢ higher

August 2015 Averages

Los Angeles 49¢ San Francisco 31¢

-40

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160 1-

Apr

-14

1-M

ay-1

4

1-Ju

n-14

1-Ju

l-14

1-A

ug-1

4

1-S

ep-1

4

1-O

ct-1

4

1-N

ov-1

4

1-D

ec-1

4

1-Ja

n-15

1-F

eb-1

5

1-M

ar-1

5

1-A

pr-1

5

1-M

ay-1

5

1-Ju

n-15

1-Ju

l-15

1-A

ug-1

5

1-S

ep-1

5 CA

RB

OB

Sp

ot

Pri

ce L

ess

NY

ME

X M

on

th-A

hea

d P

rice

(c

pg

)

Los Angeles

San Francisco

Tight Supplies

Ample Supplies

8  

Figure 7: California Spot Diesel to NYMEX Futures Price Spread

Source: EIA and OPIS.

Diesel  spot  market  activity  in  California  remained  calm  in  July  and  August.  The  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  moved  between  $0.02  and  -­‐‑$0.02  during  August,  while  the  San  Francisco-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  moved  between  $0.05  and  -­‐‑$0.02  (Figure  7).  Values  for  these  differentials  denote  a  balanced  market  with  adequate  supply  to  meet  California’s  heavy-­‐‑duty  vehicle  demand.    

Moving  into  September,  the  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  and  the  San  Francisco-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  have  moved  in  opposite  directions.  The  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  decreased  to  -­‐‑$0.07  in  mid-­‐‑September  before  returning  to  near  even  with  the  NYMEX  on  September  22.  The  San  Francisco-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX  spread  tightened  relative  to  the  Los  Angeles-­‐‑to-­‐‑NYMEX,  increasing  to  roughly  $0.06  in  September.  This  is  a  possible  indication  of  a  slightly  undersupplied  northern  market  relative  to  the  southern  one,  with  either  increased  demand  pushing  the  spot  higher,  or  lower  Northern  California  diesel  production  numbers  elevating  the  spread.  (See  Weekly  Fuels  Watch,  week  of  September  18  at  http://www.energyalmanac.ca.gov/petroleum/fuels_watch/index.php).

Diesel Spot–Futures Spread

August 2014 vs 2015 (cents)

Los Angeles 11¢ lower San Fran. 10¢ lower

August 2015 Averages

Los Angeles 0¢ San Francisco 2¢

 

 

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60 1-

Apr

-14

1-M

ay-1

4

1-Ju

n-14

1-Ju

l-14

1-A

ug-1

4

1-S

ep-1

4 1-

Oct

-14

1-N

ov-1

4 1-

Dec

-14

1-Ja

n-15

1-F

eb-1

5 1-

Mar

-15

1-A

pr-1

5 1-

May

-15

1-Ju

n-15

1-Ju

l-15

1-A

ug-1

5

1-S

ep-1

5

Die

sel S

po

t P

rice

Les

s N

YM

EX

Mo

nth

-Ah

ead

Pri

ce (

cpg

)

Los Angeles

San Francisco

Mildly Tight Supplies

Ample Supplies

9  

California Gasoline and Diesel Production and Inventories Figure 8: Gasoline Production and Inventories

Source: Petroleum Industry Information Reporting Act data.

In  the  past  five  weeks,  production  of  California  reformulated  gasoline  averaged  6.7  million  barrels  per  week.  Gasoline  production  reached  a  high  of  7.2  million  barrels  on  September  4,  2015,  before  settling  to  6.9  million  barrels  on  September  18,  2015  (Figure  8).  Year-­‐‑to-­‐‑date  gasoline  production  for  2015  has  averaged  6.5  million  barrels  per  week,  still  lower  than  the  6.6  million  barrels  per  week  seen  during  the  comparable  period  for  2014.  Inventory  levels  of  California  reformulated  gasoline  and  blending  components  rose  from  10.1  million  barrels  on  August  14,  2015,  to  11.1  million  barrels  on  September  18,  2015.  This  10  percent  increase  has  brought  inventory  levels  to  the  middle  of  the  five-­‐‑year  historical  range.  

4600

5100

5600

6100

6600

7100

7600

8100

8600

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/1

4 10

/31/

14

11/1

4/1

4 11

/28/

14

12/1

2/1

4 12

/26/

14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

California CARB Gasoline Production (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

8525

9525

10525

11525

12525

13525

14525

15525

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/14

10/3

1/14

11/1

4/14

11/2

8/14

12/1

2/14

12/2

6/14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

California CARB Gas and Blendstocks Inventories (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

10  

Figure 9: Northern California Gasoline Production and Inventories

 

 Source: PIIRA data.

Northern  California  gasoline  production  continues  at  five-­‐‑year  historical  highs.  Throughout  the  past  five  weeks,  from  August  21,  2015,  through  September  18,  2015,  Northern  California  produced  an  average  of    3.2  million  barrels  of  gasoline  per  week.  During  the  comparable  period  in  2014,  Northern  California  produced  2.9  million  barrels  per  week  (Figure  9).  

Inventory  levels  in  Northern  California  have  responded  by  rising  from  4.9  million  barrels,  seen  on    August  21,  2015,  to  5.3  million  barrels,  placing  current  levels  at  the  upper  end  of  the  five-­‐‑year  historical  high-­‐‑low  band.  

1650

2150

2650

3150

3650 9/

19/1

4

10/3

/14

10/1

7/1

4 10

/31/

14

11/1

4/1

4 11

/28/

14

12/1

2/1

4 12

/26/

14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

Northern California CARB Gasoline Production (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

3575

4575

5575

6575

7575

8575

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/14

10/3

1/14

11/1

4/14

11/2

8/14

12/1

2/14

12/2

6/14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

Northern California CARB Gas and Blendstocks Inventories (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

11  

Figure 10: Southern California Gasoline Production and Inventories

Source: PIIRA data.

Southern  California  production  remains  subdued  from  the  closure  of  ExxonMobil  Torrance  in  March.  The  region  produced  an  average  of  3.5  million  barrels  per  week  of  California  reformulated  gasoline  since  August  21,  2015 (Figure  10).  This  rate  remains  unchanged  since  the  publication  of  the  September  Petroleum  Watch.  During  a  comparable  period  in  2014,  the  five-­‐‑week  production  average  was  3.9  million  barrels  per  week.    

Inventory  levels  in  Southern  California  have  stayed  above  5.7  million  barrels,  placing  them  above  the  minimum  of  the  five-­‐‑year  historical  high-­‐‑low  band.  This  has  contributed  to  the  equalization  of  San  

2475

2975

3475

3975

4475

4975

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/1

4 10

/31/

14

11/1

4/1

4 11

/28/

14

12/1

2/1

4 12

/26/

14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

Southern California CARB Gasoline Production (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

4425

4925

5425

5925

6425

6925

7425

7925

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/14

10/3

1/14

11/1

4/14

11/2

8/14

12/1

2/14

12/2

6/14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

Southern California CARB Gas and Blendstocks Inventories (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

12  

Francisco  and  Los  Angeles  wholesale  spot  prices  of  California  gasoline.

13  

 

Figure 11: Diesel Production and Inventories

 

 Source: PIIRA data.

California  diesel  production  has  increased  steadily  since  August  18,  2015.  Total  production  of  on-­‐‑road  diesel  averaged  2.7  million  barrels  of  production  per  week.  This  bests  the  year-­‐‑to-­‐‑date  production  average  of  2.5  million  barrels  per  week  (Figure  11).  

Inventory  levels  have  fallen  since  publication  of  the  September  Petroleum  Watch,  from  3.5  million  barrels  to  3.0  million  barrels,  a  level  below  the  five-­‐‑year  historical  high-­‐‑low  band.  The  coupling  of  high  production  with  low  inventory  levels  has  caused  wholesale  spot  pricing  of  diesel  to  rise  closer  to  the  New  York  Mercantile  price.  However,  California  is  approaching  the  middle  of  the  agricultural  harvest  season.  As  California  farmers  push  the  demand  for  diesel  up,  increasing  rates  of  production  and  declining  inventory  

1425

1925

2425

2925

3425

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/1

4 10

/31/

14

11/1

4/1

4 11

/28/

14

12/1

2/1

4 12

/26/

14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

California CARB & EPA Diesel Production (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

2150

2650

3150

3650

4150

4650

5150

9/19

/14

10/3

/14

10/1

7/1

4 10

/31/

14

11/1

4/1

4 11

/28/

14

12/1

2/1

4 12

/26/

14

1/9/

15

1/23

/15

2/6/

15

2/20

/15

3/6/

15

3/20

/15

4/3/

15

4/17

/15

5/1/

15

5/15

/15

5/29

/15

6/12

/15

6/26

/15

7/10

/15

7/24

/15

8/7/

15

8/21

/15

9/4/

15

9/18

/15

Th

ou

san

ds

of

Bar

rels

per

wee

k

California CARB & EPA Diesel Inventories (with 5-Year High-Low Band)

14  

levels  should  be  expected.  

15  

 

California  Gasoline  Imports  Figure 12: California Gasoline Imports, 2010 to 2015

 Source: California Lands Commission, Port Import Export Reporting Service, and PIIRA.

During  the  second  quarter,  imports  continued  near  the  high  level  seen  in  March  2015  (Figure  12).    These  are  at  least  double  the  levels  seen  in  2014,  and  the  five-­‐‑year  high  for  the  months  of  May  and  June  was  shattered.  More  recent  information  shows  that  this  high  level  of  imports  has  continued  into  September.  

In  California,  high  levels  of  gasoline  imports  generally  occur  when  there  is  an  unplanned  refinery  outage  for  a  significant  period,  as  is  the  case  with  ongoing  outage  at  Exxon’s  refinery  in  Torrance  (discussed  below).  After  the  refinery  comes  back  on-­‐‑line,  imports  return  to  the  usual  lower  levels.  

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Mill

ion

Bar

rels

per

Mo

nth

5 year maximum

5 year minimum

2015

2014

16  

Figure 13: Southern California Gasoline Net Imports (Imports Minus Exports)

 Source: California State Lands Commission, Port Import Export Reporting Service, and PIIRA.

Southern  California  gasoline  imports  have  continued  to  climb:  increasing  from  740,000  barrels  in  March  to  1.7  million  barrels  in  May  and  1.8  million  barrels  in  June  (Figure  13).  These  cargoes  are  arriving  in  response  to  the  ongoing  outage  at  the  ExxonMobil  refinery  in  Torrance.  Since  this  refinery  will  be  offline  for  several  months,  it  is  likely  that  high  levels  of  imports  will  continue.  

Such  high  levels  have  been  reached  partially  through  diversion  of  import  tankers  from  Northern  California.  This  can  be  seen  by  comparing  Figure  12  and  Figure  13.  In  January  and  February  2015,  Southern  California  net  imports  are  small  or  zero,  but  statewide  imports  in  these  months  are  close  to  a  million  barrels.  By  May  and  June,  the  situation  is  reversed,  with  Southern  California  claiming  the  lion’s  share  of  imports;  statewide  imports  are  1.9  million  barrels  in  both  months,  with  Southern  California  imports  at  1.7  million  and  1.8  million  barrels.    

-0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Mill

ion

Bar

rels

per

Mo

nth

Five-year average

2014

2015