1 haJ jt JLfdluJud PdN(

(j rtf1fUd middot v0A f

fj_Wl) NfdMt - fi oz5 4si1vv $uu ~~J1Avv dpwiV Jt6b wi4(

NA 1J (Jt YbAIAf~cent tJJ I titJJ ltiA ~ iJIJIIA A

xJIItf_ ~F d~ ttl tf j J J irfdJtlAf

DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL

-~~~-----j E013526 SECTION 53(b)(3)

ISCAP APPEAL NO 2012-042 document no 11 DECLASSIFICATION DATE September 292014 L r

IJ_Jt()tj) (Dj~J[VU nJM ~((MI ~1 r iUf ft d rJ Ju~Ar~~ fittAtJ ~J-1 lldJ~ jllaAI - dtlcAfPIJ 1- liau

fil1J1f~~~ ~~r~ c1 rIPetU~

iAJIt)ta r)f Jit IJf poundA1ltJ~ h ~IV nair ~ fJ ~r middot middot middot

-rfwiuJ tj

()1~J-4~J (dl() ftt-t(pound1U itlaquo 1J JPulqtv Jaud Jtttt) Tntl3 middot dLJ lnf c) tlJt4A1~

2

r 11M )ct4 ~~ I t 1 - ~j () ~u tJAilo J~J-Wfl1 M ~ P)v_~fVJaj

[5 frv~ 14kfd It t1I co~ IIYIVtlraxJAJ

~~- shy

M~~~ -

~~Wfuo ~ - ISUftplvd AL ~aM ~ ifXwVLtlaquo Jtt~Vt_ p1j~MA~

middot middot CEJ r -- albmp- 11 mf~ )ljl ym lJA~fYrJaJoct~ _ - middot

3

)J) J

o tl CJzAdt Mrlvd~ Afjfj -

1 middot middot Cttol1 11_~AJ071 - 11 ()) u17 ~ ~

rJtvttf fiw s w ftrlu() N bull- dplaj k 4zt6 -

rSzw_~if I fJ ~tlaquoJ

JuIUJU 1 ~- AJ~vJ ldt-~1fj (JI tffl(lt 1~jt r

~ M41 ~ J)atL-amp-11 (KfLcJRdf~ )1Jvid JIj1t1 utcnltpound jJMtiJ~ I middot

duMfMAI t2 5~Ptp iJJW(JM vyJhJ 11-uJ Wt ~4 h (~ ~~ JNft 1J

MA M loAM tvfiL jJVhcu Mt1 riltJIyJ h ~4-

AIftiU1tt4 JJ ~4 1J iwt J1dvd r AJIJiWJd CAtJu_J bull IJJ~tttu tf4JJI M 1 A-uJr

AAI( JtW_j WtlJ ~1 kJ JrJ7ltiJIYJfd lqjyt~lt-~ A Jlvt1

oamp ()middot ~~[aiJ --shy

-1 JfPJ) wd7AJA p c~ t~A h-uAvcr jjjIY-~ auuicl ~ zJ ~~kJL~

3

)J) J

o tl CJzAdt Mrlvd~ Afjfj -

1 middot middot Cttol1 11_~AJ071 - 11 ()) u17 ~ ~

rJtvttf fiw s w ftrlu() N bull- dplaj k 4zt6 -

rSzw_~if I fJ ~tlaquoJ

JuIUJU 1 ~- AJ~vJ ldt-~1fj (JI tffl(lt 1~jt r

~ M41 ~ J)atL-amp-11 (KfLcJRdf~ )1Jvid JIj1t1 utcnltpound jJMtiJ~ I middot

duMfMAI t2 5~Ptp iJJW(JM vyJhJ 11-uJ Wt ~4 h (~ ~~ JNft 1J

MA M loAM tvfiL jJVhcu Mt1 riltJIyJ h ~4-

AIftiU1tt4 JJ ~4 1J iwt J1dvd r AJIJiWJd CAtJu_J bull IJJ~tttu tf4JJI M 1 A-uJr

AAI( JtW_j WtlJ ~1 kJ JrJ7ltiJIYJfd lqjyt~lt-~ A Jlvt1

oamp ()middot ~~[aiJ --shy

-1 JfPJ) wd7AJA p c~ t~A h-uAvcr jjjIY-~ auuicl ~ zJ ~~kJL~

4

bullmiddot (~(jim J-ed ~1YrYt~ ldtlu- diJ~-t~tj h iffirNl ~~ 4 Jjtl

Gm Jdk JfJlJod 4 campuql Wv J ~-AMh ft~d l-Zfvmiddot middot lo JLtJfUb 7j fcl - h1-J kd

1J nd hitpound 4111~f

11Jil~~ 11) alampAav dt4J- pound middote ~tNd ~

ampdadj ~14 - (1u~f JY[L

fJJ) rnn ~ JJ I fet ()lr [ f(pJ4uviJ

6

f)Jlf 6

jf lfr c tJtt ( lJ t MJJI 1( A~YtliJ IAJj tnf I ~~) )tic_ AI tkt afJ

i)r pi t ~ Mlt fLid ~ JJuuJ AJ bf fJ ~ u

t-4J lvl ftLAJI Juwf dat

cflJ middot Cutw- ft_ ~M cfJtvMat ktf tLNJ ~) ~ iJhl ~VIvlt (f JV v JvttUf ( yen JMt pound1fltu)

I~ bull cfuJJ A I)Ai) 1-J 6z - [amp rY~ wuJ~ etrW b t)itt-tJ n7b rh) JJ IJtAJIItfiAI

amp h Jhllamptd

7 ~II 7shy

~fffib tq YriUj ~kd_ j-t lctJ Lhd (() lUndtdrtU - 1-

Vtqduk Ai Mdw 1laquo middot ~ kttJP-- LNf~dit~ OVUJJltJ)

8 )J1 t

0fwcL ~ ( middot~ t1 h~AJd J(i1) - ~ ~~Dt middot

1()cpJvlh~ i o~ FhiJJbull JJ~Ww ekJ)UfJ ~u I M~Au-jJuid4A 1tJzNyen middot h1v Jw Jqt Ai ~middot

middot middot ttvt CJa1unVLL tJr ~Pel lwA OftUN~l middotGvtA t)qiP J-- lt a1~ JtutJlt06c ~Jklw AJvd

flj_)Yi f1 INW~V jAI 5ttup tJNu Cf9 waJ - - ttlftAI

~tu-rt~ ~t-lt1 6tJJ((d- D h~L ftllf_ A middot I EO 13526 section 14(g) I

0r--~----------~~~~~~--

rhJ - 0tJJ Jwrl P ~~ frt-middoti u 11~ulul - jj It ()AJ ()d) p plM middot tffv ~~ fhll(ampch li-P k h-It )p

WJw fJtJ)I a0l J fl~al ~ 111shyi 1 tuf qo I hJ

-----------

9 I)JII 1

)JhUu a Atrdt k ~lt N~h luk ltd Jw MJ twc 0 PMltfbt( r pftW _o

J(-jlAvtf middot (IJNr j Jt 1 bull

r_)(A1w Cw afq- u11WNt7~Mvtf

zpd fts ampjsf middot middot

---------- - -v tf hd Pi lrrf k tfla ---~

~~v~d Jv wwl aaw Yftltl 111flfi bull dttiJJ j7~ liJ ttM-ouAlaquout6

~

-- lk1JJP rJJ1rl Jlj) ~iAwU-J ( ~pound~

ViqtiOI-fu OVnfJ ltdu( ampJ~bldupound

1UIV t(J middot

CJ Jm ipound Jc twltP Jp ftJf

W f)ftw ~a du )Mf AU Clc PI uupH(

6

f)Jlf 6

jf lfr c tJtt ( lJ t MJJI 1( A~YtliJ IAJj tnf I ~~) )tic_ AI tkt afJ

i)r pi t ~ Mlt fLid ~ JJuuJ AJ bf fJ ~ u

t-4J lvl ftLAJI Juwf dat

cflJ middot Cutw- ft_ ~M cfJtvMat ktf tLNJ ~) ~ iJhl ~VIvlt (f JV v JvttUf ( yen JMt pound1fltu)

I~ bull cfuJJ A I)Ai) 1-J 6z - [amp rY~ wuJ~ etrW b t)itt-tJ n7b rh) JJ IJtAJIItfiAI

amp h Jhllamptd

7 ~II 7shy

~fffib tq YriUj ~kd_ j-t lctJ Lhd (() lUndtdrtU - 1-

Vtqduk Ai Mdw 1laquo middot ~ kttJP-- LNf~dit~ OVUJJltJ)

8 )J1 t

0fwcL ~ ( middot~ t1 h~AJd J(i1) - ~ ~~Dt middot

1()cpJvlh~ i o~ FhiJJbull JJ~Ww ekJ)UfJ ~u I M~Au-jJuid4A 1tJzNyen middot h1v Jw Jqt Ai ~middot

middot middot ttvt CJa1unVLL tJr ~Pel lwA OftUN~l middotGvtA t)qiP J-- lt a1~ JtutJlt06c ~Jklw AJvd

flj_)Yi f1 INW~V jAI 5ttup tJNu Cf9 waJ - - ttlftAI

~tu-rt~ ~t-lt1 6tJJ((d- D h~L ftllf_ A middot I EO 13526 section 14(g) I

0r--~----------~~~~~~--

rhJ - 0tJJ Jwrl P ~~ frt-middoti u 11~ulul - jj It ()AJ ()d) p plM middot tffv ~~ fhll(ampch li-P k h-It )p

WJw fJtJ)I a0l J fl~al ~ 111shyi 1 tuf qo I hJ

-----------

9 I)JII 1

)JhUu a Atrdt k ~lt N~h luk ltd Jw MJ twc 0 PMltfbt( r pftW _o

J(-jlAvtf middot (IJNr j Jt 1 bull

r_)(A1w Cw afq- u11WNt7~Mvtf

zpd fts ampjsf middot middot

---------- - -v tf hd Pi lrrf k tfla ---~

~~v~d Jv wwl aaw Yftltl 111flfi bull dttiJJ j7~ liJ ttM-ouAlaquout6

~

-- lk1JJP rJJ1rl Jlj) ~iAwU-J ( ~pound~

ViqtiOI-fu OVnfJ ltdu( ampJ~bldupound

1UIV t(J middot

CJ Jm ipound Jc twltP Jp ftJf

W f)ftw ~a du )Mf AU Clc PI uupH(

7 ~II 7shy

~fffib tq YriUj ~kd_ j-t lctJ Lhd (() lUndtdrtU - 1-

Vtqduk Ai Mdw 1laquo middot ~ kttJP-- LNf~dit~ OVUJJltJ)

8 )J1 t

0fwcL ~ ( middot~ t1 h~AJd J(i1) - ~ ~~Dt middot

1()cpJvlh~ i o~ FhiJJbull JJ~Ww ekJ)UfJ ~u I M~Au-jJuid4A 1tJzNyen middot h1v Jw Jqt Ai ~middot

middot middot ttvt CJa1unVLL tJr ~Pel lwA OftUN~l middotGvtA t)qiP J-- lt a1~ JtutJlt06c ~Jklw AJvd

flj_)Yi f1 INW~V jAI 5ttup tJNu Cf9 waJ - - ttlftAI

~tu-rt~ ~t-lt1 6tJJ((d- D h~L ftllf_ A middot I EO 13526 section 14(g) I

0r--~----------~~~~~~--

rhJ - 0tJJ Jwrl P ~~ frt-middoti u 11~ulul - jj It ()AJ ()d) p plM middot tffv ~~ fhll(ampch li-P k h-It )p

WJw fJtJ)I a0l J fl~al ~ 111shyi 1 tuf qo I hJ

-----------

9 I)JII 1

)JhUu a Atrdt k ~lt N~h luk ltd Jw MJ twc 0 PMltfbt( r pftW _o

J(-jlAvtf middot (IJNr j Jt 1 bull

r_)(A1w Cw afq- u11WNt7~Mvtf

zpd fts ampjsf middot middot

---------- - -v tf hd Pi lrrf k tfla ---~

~~v~d Jv wwl aaw Yftltl 111flfi bull dttiJJ j7~ liJ ttM-ouAlaquout6

~

-- lk1JJP rJJ1rl Jlj) ~iAwU-J ( ~pound~

ViqtiOI-fu OVnfJ ltdu( ampJ~bldupound

1UIV t(J middot

CJ Jm ipound Jc twltP Jp ftJf

W f)ftw ~a du )Mf AU Clc PI uupH(

8 )J1 t

0fwcL ~ ( middot~ t1 h~AJd J(i1) - ~ ~~Dt middot

1()cpJvlh~ i o~ FhiJJbull JJ~Ww ekJ)UfJ ~u I M~Au-jJuid4A 1tJzNyen middot h1v Jw Jqt Ai ~middot

middot middot ttvt CJa1unVLL tJr ~Pel lwA OftUN~l middotGvtA t)qiP J-- lt a1~ JtutJlt06c ~Jklw AJvd

flj_)Yi f1 INW~V jAI 5ttup tJNu Cf9 waJ - - ttlftAI

~tu-rt~ ~t-lt1 6tJJ((d- D h~L ftllf_ A middot I EO 13526 section 14(g) I

0r--~----------~~~~~~--

rhJ - 0tJJ Jwrl P ~~ frt-middoti u 11~ulul - jj It ()AJ ()d) p plM middot tffv ~~ fhll(ampch li-P k h-It )p

WJw fJtJ)I a0l J fl~al ~ 111shyi 1 tuf qo I hJ

-----------

9 I)JII 1

)JhUu a Atrdt k ~lt N~h luk ltd Jw MJ twc 0 PMltfbt( r pftW _o

J(-jlAvtf middot (IJNr j Jt 1 bull

r_)(A1w Cw afq- u11WNt7~Mvtf

zpd fts ampjsf middot middot

---------- - -v tf hd Pi lrrf k tfla ---~

~~v~d Jv wwl aaw Yftltl 111flfi bull dttiJJ j7~ liJ ttM-ouAlaquout6

~

-- lk1JJP rJJ1rl Jlj) ~iAwU-J ( ~pound~

ViqtiOI-fu OVnfJ ltdu( ampJ~bldupound

1UIV t(J middot

CJ Jm ipound Jc twltP Jp ftJf

W f)ftw ~a du )Mf AU Clc PI uupH(

-----------

9 I)JII 1

)JhUu a Atrdt k ~lt N~h luk ltd Jw MJ twc 0 PMltfbt( r pftW _o

J(-jlAvtf middot (IJNr j Jt 1 bull

r_)(A1w Cw afq- u11WNt7~Mvtf

zpd fts ampjsf middot middot

---------- - -v tf hd Pi lrrf k tfla ---~

~~v~d Jv wwl aaw Yftltl 111flfi bull dttiJJ j7~ liJ ttM-ouAlaquout6

~

-- lk1JJP rJJ1rl Jlj) ~iAwU-J ( ~pound~

ViqtiOI-fu OVnfJ ltdu( ampJ~bldupound

1UIV t(J middot

CJ Jm ipound Jc twltP Jp ftJf

W f)ftw ~a du )Mf AU Clc PI uupH(