pp vs sumicad

6
G.R. No. L-35524 March 18, 1932 THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, plaintiff-appellee, vs. JULIAN SUMICAD, defendant-appellant. Felipe K. Medina for appellant. Attorney-General Jaranilla for appellee. STREET, J.: This appeal has been brought to reverse a judgment of the Court of First Instance of the Province of Occidental Misamis, finding the appellant, Julian Sumicad, guilty of the offense of homicide and sentencing him to undergo imprisonment for twelve years and one day, reclusion temporal, and requiring him to indemnify the family of the deceased in the amount of P1,000, as well as to pay the costs of prosecution. On February 23, 1931, the accused, a resident of Buenavoluntad, in the municipality of Plaridel, Occidental Misamis, was engaged with others in the gratuitous labor of hauling logs for the construction of a chapel in the barrio above-mentioned. At about 5.30 o'clock in the afternoon on the day mentioned, when the laborers were resting from the work of the day, one Segundo Cubol happened to pass the place where the accused was sitting. Prior to this date the accused had rendered five and one-half days service to Cubol, and as the latter passed, the accused said to him, "Segundo, pay me for the five and one-half days work for which you owe me." Cubol replied, "What debt!," an exclamation which was followed by an insulting expression. At the

Upload: maia-delima

Post on 16-Aug-2015

233 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

CRIM LAW

TRANSCRIPT

G.R. No. L-35524 March 18, 1932THE PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDS, !a"#$"%-a&!!&&, '(.)*LIAN S*MI+AD, ,&-,a#$-a&!!a#$.F&!"& .. M&,"#a -or a&!!a#$.A$$or#&/-G&ra! )ara#"!!a -or a&!!&&.STREET, ).0Th"( a&a! ha( 1& 1ro23h$ $o r&'&r(& a 42,35$ o- $h& +o2r$ o- F"r($ I#($a#c& o- $h& Pro'"#c& o- Occ",$a! M"(a5"(, 6#,"#3 $h& a&!!a#$, )2!"a# S25"ca,, 32"!$/ o- $h& o%(& o- ho5"c",& a#, ($c"#3 h"5 $o 2#,&r3o "5r"(o#5$ -or $7&!'& /&ar( a#, o#& ,a/, r&c!2("o# $&5ora!, a#, r&82"r"#3 h"5 $o "#,&5#"-/ $h& -a5"!/ o- $h& ,&c&a(&, "# $h& a5o2#$ o- P1,999, a( 7&!! a( $o a/ $h& co($( o- ro(&c2$"o#.O# F&1r2ar/ 23, 1931, $h& acc2(&,, a r&(",$ o- :2a'o!2#$a,, "# $h& 52#"c"a!"$/o- P!ar",&!, Occ",$a! M"(a5"(, 7a( a3&, 7"$h o$h&r( "# $h& 3ra$2"$o2( !a1or o- ha2!"#3 !o3( -or $h& co#($r2c$"o# o- a cha&! "# $h& 1arr"o a1o'&-5$"o#&,. A$ a1o2$ 5.39 o;c!oc< "# $h& a-$&r#oo# o# $h& ,a/ 5$"o#&,, 7h $h& !a1or&r( 7&r& r&($"#3 -ro5 $h& 7or< o- $h& ,a/, o#& S&32#,o +21o! ha&, $o a(( $h& !ac& 7h&r& $h& acc2(&, 7a( ("$$"#3. Pr"or $o $h"( ,a$& $h& acc2(&, ha, r,&r&, 6'& a#, o#&-ha!- ,a/( (&r'"c& $o +21o!, a#, a( $h& !a$$&r a((&,, $h& acc2(&, (a", $o h"5, =S&32#,o, a/ 5& -or $h& 6'& a#, o#&-ha!- ,a/( 7or< -or 7h"ch /o2 o7& 5&.= +21o!r&!"&,, =>ha$ ,&1$?,= a# &@c!a5a$"o# 7h"ch 7a( -o!!o7&, 1/ a# "#(2!$"#3 &@r&(("o#. A$ $h& (a5& $"5& h& ($r2c< $h& acc2(&, 7"$h h"( 6($. Th& acc2(&, aro(& -ro5 $h& !o3 2o# 7h"ch h& 7a( ("$$"#3 a#, 5o'&, 1ac