presented by: joseph l. dilorenzo, ph.d. najarian associates coastal storm characteristics and...
TRANSCRIPT
Presented by:
Joseph L. DiLorenzo, Ph.D.NAJARIAN ASSOCIATES
COASTAL STORM CHARACTERISTICS AND CHANGES IN FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS FOR COASTAL MONMOUTH COUNTY
OVERVIEW OF PRESENTATION
• Characteristics of coastal storms in New Jersey
• Changes in new FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs) for Monmouth County
• Map accuracy
Najarian Associates
TWO TYPES OF COASTAL STORMS
Tropical cyclones(hurricanes)
Najarian Associates
Extra-tropical storms
(Nor’easters)
No central eye
TROPICAL CYCLONES (HURRICANES)
warm-core systems that derive energy from oceanic evaporation
cause intense, short-duration surges and wind
potential catastrophic damages, but somewhat localized
Najarian Associates
HURRICANE TRACKS (SINCE 1850)
Najarian Associates
Most hurricanes skirt NJ and weaken
HURRICANE DONNASeptember 12, 1960 at Sandy Hook
Najarian Associates
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
9/12/600:00
9/12/606:00
9/12/6012:00
9/12/6018:00
9/13/600:00
9/13/606:00
9/13/6012:00
9/13/6018:00
9/14/600:00
EL
EV
AT
ION
(ft
, MS
L)
Predicted Observed
MSL
MONMOUTH COUNTY INUNDATION ZONES
Category 1 & 2 hurricanes since 1850
On Sept. 3, 1821, a Category 4 hurricane passed over LBI
EXTRATROPICAL STORMS (NOR’EASTERS)
– cold-core cyclonic systems
– formed in areas where strong surface temperature gradients coincide with a strong jet stream aloft
Najarian Associates
EXTRATROPICAL STORMS – NOR’EASTERS
– Cause prolonged flooding when blocked by presence of high pressure systems in northeast Canada
– large scale systems – can flood and erode east coast regions
Najarian Associates
HISTORIC NOR’EASTERDecember 11, 1992 at Sandy Hook
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
12/10/9212:00
12/11/920:00
12/11/9212:00
12/12/920:00
12/12/9212:00
12/13/920:00
12/13/9212:00
12/14/920:00
EL
EV
AT
ION
(ft
,MS
L)
PREDICTED OBSERVED
MSL
TIDAL DATUMS AT SANDY HOOK
Najarian Associates
(Source: NOAA)
Sea level Datum of 1929
1.09 ft
North American Vertical Datum of 1988
Mean Sea Level
0.86 ft
Mean Lower Low Water
Mean High Water
1992 NOR’EASTER – NOAA SITES
Najarian Associates
Maximum Stillwater Elevations
Highest observed water level over ~100 year record
(January 1910 - present)
JOLINE AVENUE, LONG BRANCHDEC. 11, 1992
Najarian Associates
1992 NOR’EASTER – USGS SITES
Najarian Associates
Amplification at head of funnel-shaped Raritan Bay
Like Atlantic City maximum elevation (7.35 ft)
COASTAL FLOOD RANKINGS
Najarian Associates
RANKDATE STILL-WATER ELEVATION
(FT, NGVD-1929)
1 12/11/92 8.69
2 9/12/60 8.37
3 11/12/68 7.09
4 1/23/66 7.06
5 3/29/84 6.95
6 3/14/93 6.94
7 1/02/87 6.91
8 9/27/85 6.86
Top Eight Coastal Storms at Sandy Hook (1910-present; Source: NOAA)
FEMA’s BASE FLOOD
Najarian Associates
• The flood event having a probability of 0.01 (1%) of being equaled or exceeded in any given year
• Commonly called the “100-year flood” (on average)
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION (BFE)
• The corresponding water surface elevation of the 1% annual chance flood (100-year flood)
• Often determined by numerical modeling of coastal hydrodynamic processes
Najarian Associates
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION (BFE)IN NO WAVE ZONES
Najarian Associates
Community100-Year Stillwater
Elevation (ft)
NGVD29 NAVD88
Highlands 10.8 9.7
Atlantic Highlands 11.6 10.5
Middletown 11.6 10.5
Keansburg 11.6 10.5
Union Beach 11.8 10.7
Keyport 11.8 10.7
Sea Bright 9 7.9
Monmouth Beach 10.1 9.0
Long Branch 8.6 7.5
Neptune 8.5 7.4
Asbury Park 8.5 7.4
Avon 8.5 7.4
Belmar 8.5 7.4
Spring Lake 8.5 7.4
Manasquan 8.5 7.4
BASE FLOOD ELEVATION (BFE)IN AREAS AFFECTED BY WAVES
• Combines 100-year stillwater elevation, 100-year wave crest elevation and inland extent of wave runup
• BFEs used to delineate Flood Hazard Areas inundated by 100-year storms on Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs)
Najarian Associates
NEW FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS (FIRMS)
Najarian Associates
• New FIRMS delineate Flood Hazard Areas inundated by 100-year flood with blue dot shading
• BFEs labeled (in feet, NAVD-1988) in Zone AE (e.g., EL11)
• Areas inundated by 500-year flood (0.2% chance flood) are shaded with black dots
KEY QUESTIONS
Najarian Associates
• Are delineated flood hazard areas significantly different from previous maps for coastal Monmouth County?
• What are the reasons for the changes?
CHANGES IN THE NEW FIRMSFOR MONMOUTH COUNTY
Najarian Associates
• Some changes are due to re-delineations of flood hazard areas based on updated topographic data
• Major changes along Bayshore are due to new FEMA standards for dunes and flood control structures
RE-DELINEATION OF FLOOD HAZARD AREAS
• New maps re-delineate 100-year floodplain boundary using the SAME BFEs but with updated Monmouth County topography (2 foot contours)
Najarian Associates
CommunityPrevious stillwater elevation (ft)
NGVD29 NAVD88
New stillwater elevation (ft)
NGVD29 NAVD88
Highlands 10.8 9.7 10.8 9.7
Atlantic Highlands 11.6 10.5 11.6 10.5
Middletown 11.6 10.5 11.6 10.5
Keansburg 11.6 10.5 11.6 10.5
Union Beach 11.8 10.7 11.8 10.7
Keyport 11.8 10.7 11.8 10.7
Sea Bright 9 7.9 9 7.9
Monmouth Beach 10.1 9.0 10.1 9.0
Long Branch 8.6 7.5 8.6 7.5
Neptune 8.5 7.4
Asbury Park 8.5 7.4 8.5 7.4
Avon 8.5 7.4
Belmar 8.5 7.4 8.5 7.4
Spring Lake 8.5 7.4 8.5 7.4
Manasquan 8.5 7.4 8.5 7.4
MINOR CHANGES IN MOST COASTAL AREAS
Example of minor re-delineation of 100-year (1%) flood lines due to use of updated topography
Old: Yellow Line
New: Blue Line
Najarian Associates
MAJOR CHANGES ALONG BAYSHORE
• Massively expanded flood hazard area due to more stringent FEMA standards for protective dunes/levees
Najarian Associates
PROJECT HISTORY
• 1968-73: Keansburg area project constructed 1968-1973. Dune and levees built 15 ft high based on highest storm to date
• Early 1980s: FEMA provisionally approves 14,700 foot long “levee,” with minimum flood insurance burden to residents
• Over time, dune thickness decreased significantly - area vulnerable
Najarian Associates
PROJECT HISTORY
• 2000-2007: Army Corps plans repairs
– Beach renourishment proposed
– Use same 15 ft dune crest elevation (not 18 ft BFE)
– Benefit/Cost >1 Keansburg, Port Monmouth & Union Beach
Najarian Associates
PROJECT HISTORY
• 2007: FEMA revises standards (44 CFR 65.10-11)
– No longer considers the “levee” a levee or a protective dune
Najarian Associates
LEVEE STANDARD
• 44 CFR §65.10– Must be non-eroding structure during the 100-year storm
– Must be 1 ft above 100-year storm wave height (i.e., no wave over-topping)
• In this case:– “Structure” erodes
– About 40% of “structure” below required height 17.7 ft NAVD-1988 (10.5 ft + 6.2 ft+ 1 ft)
Najarian Associates
DUNE STANDARD
• 44 CFR §65.11 (Dune standards)
– Cross-sectional area must exceed 540 sq. ft and have vegetative cover
(seaward of dune crest and above 100-year SWE of 10.5 ft NAVD-1988)
• In this case:– Bayshore dune cross-section too small (<70 sq. ft.) – FEMA still giving credit by eliminating V-zone behind dune– BFE 11 ft behind dune, essentially same as 100-year SWE
Najarian Associates
PRESENT DILEMMA
• U.S. Army Corps shelved previous (non-compliant) dune repair plans which would not eliminate flood insurance burden
• Compliant new plans will not satisfy benefit-to-cost criteria
Najarian Associates
ISSUE: AGENCY DISCONNECTIN INITIAL DESIGN LEVEL
• ARMY CORPS: whichever design level provides maximum net benefits to the government (may be as low as a 5-yr level with 50% assurance)
• FEMA: 100-yr design with 95% assurance
Najarian Associates
BIGGER DISCONNECT INLONGEVITY REQUIREMENTS
• USACE: 50-year design life is typical; however all maintenance is the local responsibility, and is subject to budgetary constraints
• FEMA: Full design level required throughout actuarial policy life, NOT dependent on budgetary constraints or human intervention
Najarian Associates
POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS(Chris Rasmussen, USACE)
• USACE changes their optimum benefit requirement and only designs for a 100-yr event with 95% assurance for the full 50-year project life (e.g., the very few projects with benefits exceeding costs).
• FEMA changes their actuarial rate calculations to allow varying levels of protection (e.g., homeowner would pay vastly higher rates reflecting a 20-yr level in year 1, a 15-yr level in year 3, etc.).
RECOMMENDATION
• Beneficially use dredged sand from offshore navigation channels to enlarge protective dune
(using geotextile tubes)
Najarian Associates
MAP ACCURACY LIMITATIONS
• FIRM delineations based on County’s topographic data
– Aerial survey with 2-foot elevation contour intervals– Typical accuracy: about half a contour interval (~ 1
ft)
Najarian Associates
ACCURACY ISSUE EXAMPLE
• Our field survey crews checked the topography along 5 Hazlet streets as they crossed into the mapped A zone
• Along Tavern and Central Avenue there are 4 homes that may be moved out of the FHA
• Along Holly, Laurel and Pinewood there are 4 homes that should be in the FHA
Najarian Associates
WHAT CAN BE DONE TO CORRECT MISTAKES?
• LOMA– land survey of site– File application (Next Presentation)
Najarian Associates