published by: asian network for the rights of occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · osh rights |...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Issue Number: 25 ● Leading Workers Rights Movement in Asia ● July - Sep 2012
Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and Environmental Victims
![Page 2: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
OSH Rights | July - September 2012 Page 2
Issue Number 24
July - September 2012
Copyright Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and Environmental Victims (ANROEV)
EDITOR Mohit Gupta
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) Rights is a quarterly newsletter on occupational and safety issues in Asia. It is prepared by the ANROEV Secretariat. The newsletter contains information and news about the campaigns of the network in Asia – Mining, Victims Organising, Lung Diseases, and Electronics Articles and information in OSH Rights may be reproduced in non-profit publications with clear citations, credit to author/s and OSH Rights. Opinions and suggestions to the editor are encouraged. Please send enquiries to
The Editor Secretariat – ANROEV
c/o Environics Trust Khasra Number 177, Neb Sarai
Ne w Delhi – 110068 Ph – (91-11)2953-3957 Fax – (91-11)2953-1814
Email – [email protected] URL - www.anroev.org
Inside This IssueInside This IssueInside This IssueInside This Issue
New Asbestos Mine in Canada-Business or Shameful Profiteering!....................................................................................
3
Update from Partners....... 4
Laurie Kazan-Allen Receives Prestigious Award for
Raising Global Awareness of Asbestos Diseases……..
7
Short News from SHAPRs 8
News from Busan, Korea…………………… 9
Osaka High Court Judgment 10
3 Gandhinagar units under lens for health hazards 10
Pro-asbestos advocacy group shuts its door 11
Landmark verdict on i llegal mining 13
Workers Memorial Day and Labour Day Activities 13
Kobe earthquake rubble handler develops cancer 17
years later
16
The Future We Want is Asbestos-Free 17
Campaigners urge permanent closure of Indian asbestos
plants
17
Safety NGO calls for comprehensive probe on Butuan
killer fire
18
Grinding stone factories have claimed 30 lives since
2004-Pakistan
18
Tributes…………………………………………………….... 20
The Environmental Impact of the Manufacturing of
Semiconductor’s
20
Regional News……………….. 15
All readers are welcome to provide feedback and suggestions to
articles of OSH Rights. In the coming issues, we will offer space
for reader feedback.
For any questions about Occupational Health and Safety in Asia,
send an email to [email protected]. Our panel of experts will
attempt to reply to all questions.
![Page 3: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 3
New Asbestos Mine in Canada-
Business or Shameful
Profiteering!
The Government of Quebec on 29th June
announced that it had given a $58 million loan
guarantee to a consortium to develop a new
underground chrysotile asbestos mine at the
Jeffrey Asbestos Mine. The decision was
immediately praised by the President of Jeffery
Mines, Bernard Coulombe, Quebec National
Assembly member Yvon Vallieres and trade
unionist Francois Vaudreuil. The government’s so
called “courageous decision” to support the
controversial project and employment prospects
for people in the mining region; up to 500 direct
full-time jobs and 1,000 indirect jobs will be
created was a step in the right direction.
However the decision has been blasted by
environmentalists, activists, doctors and other
concerned people. Commenting on the
government subsidy, Paul Lapierre, of the
Canadian Cancer Society, said:”This decision
means the Quebec Government is in direct
conflict with global cancer control as all forms of
asbestos cause cancer. We urge the Quebec
government to reconsider its decision and cancel
the loan guarantee. We believe these funds
should instead be directed to projects to help the
affected communities diversify their economic
base.”
Most of the Asbestos from this mine will be
shipped to Asian countries like India and
Indonesia and thousands of workers and their
families will be exposed to the deadly Asbestos
Fibre.
Activists across the globe have raised this issue of
the double standards of Canada of no using
Asbestos within Canada but exporting it to
developing nations.
In Korea, under the banner of BANKO,
a protest was organised outside the Canadian
Embassy in Seoul. A protest letter was handed
was also handed over. To read the letter Click
here
Some Photos of protest from Korea
Photo of Protests from Nagoya, Japan
Read Blog written by Laurie Kazan-Allen
More protests and events are being held in other
countries.
![Page 4: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4
With the internet and widespread use of social
media platforms, the global ban asbestos
community will make sure that the news of
Quebec’s plans is known around the world. This is
not over!
Update from Partners
SHARPs- Supporters for the Health
and Rights of People in the
Semiconductor industry
1. Four female workers at the Samsung LCD and
semiconductor factories died of cancer this year
so far; fifty-six workers at Samsung reportedly
died of occupational illness until now - We are
witnessing continuous tragedies: four female
workers at Samsung lost their lives to cancer
during the first half of this year. In January, a
worker in charge of assembling semiconductor
parts (wire-bonding) at Samsung’s On-Yang
factory died of ovarian cancer at age thirty-seven.
In March, a worker who worked at Samsung’s Gi-
Heung factory implant process (radioactive
exposure; night-time shift) died of breast cancer
at age thirty-six. In May, a worker in charge of
testing semiconductor chips in high temperature
at Samsung’s On-Yang factory died of malignant
brain tumor at age thirty-two. In June, a worker at
Samsung’s LCD factory died of aplastic anemia at
age thirty-one. SHARPS is planning to hold a
meeting in front of the Seoul City Hall on July
20th, 2012 to commemorate the fifty-six deceased
workers and denounce Samsung.
Photographs: May 7, 2012. Yun-Jeong Lee, a worker at
Samsung died of malignant brain tumor
2. Republic of Korea Ministry of Employment and
Labor announced in February that carcinogenic
chemicals such as benzene are produced during
the semiconductor manufacturing process and
required businesses to take correction measures
- On February 6th, the Ministry of Employment
and Labor announced that carcinogenic materials
such as benzene, formaldehyde, arsenic and
radioactive rays are produced as by-products at
wafer production and semiconductor assembly
lines. The Korea Occupational Safety and Health
Institute conducted in-depth research from 2009
to 2011 on the working conditions of
semiconductor workplaces at Samsung, Hynix,
and Fairchild Semiconductor Korea and derived
the above-mentioned result. It is noteworthy that
the workplaces under this inspection had the
most up-to-date facilities but still produced
carcinogenic by-products. Therefore, we can
reasonably conjecture that there used to be
higher levels of carcinogenic exposure in inferior
working environments in the past. This research
announcement thus shows that semiconductor
works are related to the outbreak of blood-
related cancer such as leukemia. According the
research that carcinogenic materials are
produced as by-products during the high-
temperature manufacturing process, the Ministry
of Employment and Labor declared a
recommendation decision that semiconductor
businesses use safe alternative materials and
protect occupational health of their employees.
This announcement of the Ministry is the result of
common efforts during the last five years by
![Page 5: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 5
semiconductor workers, their families and
SHARPS to advocate and fight for the approval of
compensation for occupational disasters. In
response to the Ministry’s announcement,
SHARPS demanded that Samsung approve the
compensation for occupational disasters and stop
obstructing workers’ efforts to fight for such
approval.
3. Korea Workers’ Compensation and Welfare
Service approved the occupational disaster
status for a semiconductor worker’s blood-
related cancer for the first time - On April 10,
2012, Korea Workers’ Compensation and Welfare
Service declared an “approval decision” on the
occupational disaster compensation application
of Ji-sook Kim, who fell sick of aplastic anemia
during her employment at Samsung’s On-Yang
semiconductor factory. Korean press widely
reported and covered this news. Ji-Sook Kim is
the eighteenth victim of occupational disaster at
Samsung and the first one out of twenty
applicants who requested approval and
compensation from the Service. There are similar
workers like Ji-Sook Kim who worked during the
same period and conducted the same task as she
did, but could not get approval decision from the
Service; the recent decision thus shows that there
exist open possibilities for approval and
compensation for blood-related cancer (including
serious blood-related diseases). SHAPRS
welcomed this recent decision and urged for
further approval decisions for other victims. Ji-
Sook Kim will receive medical treatment fees and
temporary suspension salaries (70% of average
salaries for the period of medical leave from
work) as benefits according to the Service’s
approval decision.
4. Global Strategy Meeting on Sustainable
Electronics Industry held at Suwon, Korea from
June 18 to 21, 2012; Press Conference in front of
Samsung’s main building to deliver the message
“No More Death at Samsung” in protest against
the corporation’s measures - Global Strategy
Meeting on Sustainable Electronics Industry was
held at Suwon, Korea from June 18 to 21, 2012.
The conference, organized jointly by SHAPRS,
Asia Monitoring Resource Centre (AMRC), Citizen
of the Earth Taiwan(CET), Good Electronics,
International Campaign for Responsible
Technology(ICRT), gathered activists of 36
organizations from 10 countries to share the
issues and problems of the world’s semiconductor
industries and protest experiences, and discuss
measures and ways to strengthen local struggles
and international cooperation. In addition, the
participants of the conference held a press
conference in front of Samsung’s headquarter in
Seoul on June 20th to express solidarity for
workers and their families and protest Samsung’s
inhumane workplace conditions and attitude.
Activists from various countries including Taiwan,
Hong Kong, U.S., China, and Indonesia held
pickets with the message “No More Death as
Samsung” in their own languages and made a
resolution to protest worldwide Samsung’s
occupational illness issues and crack-down on
basic labor rights.
Global Strategy Meeting held at Suwon, Korea from June 18
to 21
![Page 6: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 6
Protest in front of the Samsung’s headquarter in Seoul on
June 20, 2012
Hesperian Health Guides
We have been hard at work finishing the drafts
for “Work Hazards in Electronics Factories” and
“Work Hazards in Shoe Factories” for the book A
Workers’ Guide to Health and Safety. We have
written stories based on the experiences of some
ANROEV members and are currently looking for
people interested in contributing to the
development of these two sections. Please
contact [email protected] if you are
interested or if you would like to review and
comment on these sections.
During the last 3 months we also launched the
Fair and Health Work Section of the People’s
Health Movement-US and planned the first work-
specific plenary and workshop at the 3rd People’s
Health Assembly being held in Cape Town, South
Africa on July 7 to July 11th. Miriam was able to
interview Dr. Kong about SHARPS during her visit
to Korea in June and her video statement will be
part of the subplenary “Fair and Healthy Work.”
After the subplenary there will be meeting titled
“Work and the Right to Health” that will build
upon the experiences from many groups around
the world. We would be happy to share any of
the outcomes from this meeting and
subsequently formed group with anybody that is
interested.
We are looking forward to participating in the
annual American Public Health Association
meeting in San Francisco in October, along with
several ANROEV members, to bring awareness
and built momentum for campaigns against
electronic corporations in Asia.
IBAS A-BAN Related Developments-
2012
An idea which was developed after a chance
meeting at the A-BAN conference in Jaipur in
November 2011 came to fruition on June 27, 2012
when Barrister Krishnendu Mukherjee made the
keynote presentation to the annual asbestos
seminar of the All Party Parliamentary Asbestos
Sub-Group. Krishnendu, known to his friends as
Tublu, told Members of Parliament about the
experience of people living in the world's biggest
asbestos importing country: India. With virtually
no effective health and safety legislation and no
controls on workplace exposures, commercial
interests are able to make huge profits from
asbestos processes whilst workers endure
industrial conditions last seen in Britain in the
Co-chair John Cryer making presentation to Krishnendu
Mukherjee
1950s. Mukherjee challenged delegates to the
seminar to confront British companies, including
New ANROEV Website
The new look ANROEV network website is now online. The site has a new domain in keeping with the new name of the network and can be seen at www.anroev.org. Please send in your suggestions / comments and any material /reports/photos you would like to be a part of the website.
![Page 7: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 7
banks and financial institutions, which invest in
the Indian asbestos industry; the naming of
British financial stakeholders stimulated a great
degree of concern and discussion about how such
immoral investments might be publicized.
See: Westminster Asbestos Seminar
Cividep
In April 2012 Cividep India organized a labour
rights training in Pondicherry on Freedom of
Association and Collective Bargaining for workers
from the mobile phone industry. The training was
attended by 21 workers from Nokia, Foxconn and
Wintek.
Workers were educated about their right to
Collective Bargaining, the historical and legal
background of trade unions and learned how to
formulate a charter of demands. Workers also
reported on their working conditions in the
factory and challenges they face during work.
In May 2012 Cividep-India together with Suedwind
from Austria published the report 'Shiny Phone -
Paltry Pay' on living conditions of electronics
sector workers in the mobile phone
manufacturing industry.
The report can be accessed here:
Laurie Kazan-Allen Receives
Prestigious Award for Raising
Global Awareness of Asbestos
Diseases
By Steve Allen
Fighting for asbestos victims is my family’s work. I
am very proud to announce that my sister, Laurie
Kazan-Allen, coordinator of the International Ban
Asbestos Secretariat (IBAS) since its inception in
2000, received the distinction of being named
the 2012 winner of the Emeritus Professor Eric G
Saint Memorial Award on Sunday, March 25 at the
Annual General meeting of the Asbestos Diseases
Society of Australia (ADSA) in Perth, WA.
The Emeritus Professor Eric G Saint Memorial
Award has been awarded 21 times and includes
medical professionals such as doctors and nurses,
asbestos disease clinicians and researchers as well
as representatives of the ADSA. Laurie-Kazan
Allen is the only non-Australian recipient of this
highly prestigious award.
Announcing the 2012 recipient, Rosemarie
Vojakovic, an Executive Officer of the ADSA said:
“Over the year, our organization (the ADSA) has
greatly benefitted from information provided by
our worthy recipient. Of particular importance
and benefit to all Australians was information
mainly relating to white asbestos and its
carcinogenic properties which cause malignant
Mesothelioma. Our worthy recipient has
represented our organization with pride and
dignity in all parts of the world and placed our
organization on the global scene.”
The award was presented to Laurie Kazan-Allen
by the Honourable John Kobelke, MLA, member
of the legislative assembly, the lower house of
the Western Australian legislature.
The award’s namesake, Dr. Eric Saint, was born in
Britain in 1918. He qualified as a medical doctor
and served in the RAF in India World War II. In
1948 he went to Western Australia, where he
remained until he died at age 70.
He spent his career occupied in issues related to
public and occupational health including infant
welfare, insects and pests and the asbestos
mining industry. In the 1940s he sent a letter
regarding the Wittenoom blue asbestos mine to
![Page 8: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 8
the authorities predicting that “in a year or two,
[the company of] Australian Blue Asbestos will
produce the richest crop of asbestos disease in
the world’s literature.” The letter came to light
and was used successfully as Wittenoom miners
began to litigate against the mine owners for the
diseases they contracted working at Wittenoom.
Dr Eric Saint helped to found the medical school
in Western Australia and is widely regarded as an
iconic figure in WA history.
Short News from SHARPs
The First Historical Approval of Workers
Compensation for Samsung Semiconductor
Worker by the Korean Government
April 10, the Ministry of Employment and Labor
announced that KCOMWEL (Korea Workers
Compensation & Welfare Service) approved the
compensation for Ji-sook Kim, who got aplastic
anemia from Samsung semiconductor Onyang
factory.
Ji-sook Kim is the 18th victim who claimed
Workers' compensation to KCOMWEL with the
support of SHARPS.
She entered Samsung semiconductor at
December 1993, at her age of 19, as an operator
of Soldering and Trim/Form process until 1999
April.
The factory was operated 24 hours a day, so that
she worked 12 hours a day under two shifts for
several years. Later the shift system was changed
into three shifts.
When she worked at Soldering process, she was
diagnosed as <lead intoxication> and serious
anemia. She consulted with the doctor in the
factory and began to take iron supplement and
vitamin. But nothing was changed at her work
environment. Finally she quit the job because her
work got harder and her health got worsened.
She was exposed to lead and thinner which were
used at her workstation. Sometimes she must use
TCE to remove dirt from the chip, and clean the
workstation and facilities with <air gun> which
blow the dirt with high pressure of air. Also she
could not be protected from other chemicals such
as formaldehyde and benzene which were used
or produced in the neighbor processes like mold
and plating, because there was no spatial
separation between those workstations.
There was no protective equipment. All she was
provided was a cap which prevented pollution of
the chip by workers' hair, and cotton gloves
which could not protect workers from chemical
absorption. No respiratory protective equipment
she could get. Actually she never knew about
chemicals nor the toxicity.
There are other cancer victims who worked at the
same time and/or the same factory with Ji-sook.
Both Chang-ho Song (malignant lymphoma) from
the soldering and plating process and Eun-gyoung
Kim(acute leukemia) from the trim/form process
share the same time zone and the working place.
Myoung-wha You (aplastic anemia) and Yoon-
jeong Lee(malignant brain cancer) got cancer
from the neighbor workstation of Ji-sook. All of
these workers got cancer in their 20's or 30's.
For more detail information Click here [Korean]
Statement of SHARPS hailing
KCOMWEL’s first recognition of
workers’ compensation of a
Samsung worker victim
April 28, 2012 by stopsamsung
On 10th April 2012, Samsung occupational victims in
the semiconductor industry received a major boost
forward in their long struggle.
Below is the statement of SHARPS on April 10
regarding the ruling:
Today, April 10, The Ministry of Employment and
Labor announced its recognition of the aplastic
anaemia suffered by Ms. Jisook Kim as an
occupational disease from her work at Samsung
![Page 9: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 9
Semiconductor Onyang factory. Ms. Jisook Kim is
the 18th victim to make a workers’ compensation
application with SHARPS.
In SHARPS we believe this recognition of Ms.
Kim’s aplastic anemia as an occupational disease
by KCOMWEL is a completely correct and sensible
judgment.
The work conditions of Ms. Jisook Kim were
almost same as for the other victims of Samsung
Semiconductor Onyang factory who had applied
with SHARPS for workers’ compensation since
2007.
In that time, KCOMWEL had investigated the
illnesses (such as leukaemia, malignant lymphoma
, aplastic anemia and related blood diseases) of
the same type as Ms. Kim which had been
reported in the same workplace, but it had said
that no cancerous materials like benzene could be
found, and had repeatedly refused to give
recognition of the illnesses as occupational
diseases. But now it has recognized the worker’s
disease as an occupational one in the case of Ms.
Kim’s application.
This essentially shows KCOMWEL’s own
recognition that its previous refusals to recognize
occupational disease had been wrong.
We can say that with the approval ruling for Ms.
Jisook Kim, KCOMWEL has set a new benchmark.
We believe that this opens a path in the future for
workers’ compensation approvals for victims of
leukaemia, malignant lymphoma, aplastic anomie,
and other illnesses, not only in Samsung but also
in every semiconductor factory.
There are so many cases that should already have
been approved for workers’ compensation by
now. Although we feel it is very late for
KCOMWEL to give approval of workers’
compensation for the first time now, five years
after leukaemia and other diseases in
semiconductor factories had become known, we
still gladly welcome the ruling of KCOMWEL
based on reason and truthful evidence, even if
only now.
Above all, we can’t help but be glad that this
recognition ruling will give at least a little comfort
to the victims who struggle day by day to cope
with their diseases like aplastic anemia.
Moreover, this decision opens the way for
workers’ compensation approval for occupational
disease victims of Samsung Semiconductor who
had previously been rejected for compensation
and who are now in civil lawsuits -Chang-ho Song,
Eun-kyung Kim, Myeong-hwa Yoo, Yoon-jung Lee,
Yoo–mi Hwang (d), Sook-young Lee (d), Min-
Woong Hwang (d), and others – as well as other
victims.
Lastly, this is the chance for Samsung to stop
insisting and deceiving the public that it uses no
cancerous chemicals and that the sicknesses of
the workers are not occupational. Instead, with
the decision of KCOMWEL to recognize Ms.
Jisook Kim’s occupation disease, Samsung should
admit there was a serious problem in the work
conditions at its semiconductor factories, and
apologize to the victims and to the public.
For this, the first step of Samsung should be to
stop to its interference (application to
supplement the lawsuit) in the civil lawsuits of the
victims for workers’ compensation.
Original statement in Korean by SHARPS with
related statements and documents are here
Source
News from Busan, Korea
Survivors of two deceased Mesothelioma victims
who had lived near a major asbestos textile plant
in Busan and three asbestosis victims who had
worked for the company won their civil damage
case against the company (Jeil E&S) but lost
against the Korean government and Japanese
company (Nichias) at the Busan District Court. The
judgment ordered the company to pay 90 % of total
amount of damages for 3 former worker asbestosis
![Page 10: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 10
cases and 60 % for environmental Mesothelioma
cases.
Osaka High Court Judgment
Ms. Kazumi Yoshizaki, a member of the Asian
Solidarity Delegation to Quebec in 2010, won
again a civil case on her father's Mesothelioma
death against the Nippon Express at the Osaka
High Court.
The Nippon Express was the employer of late
Yoshizaki and supplied raw asbestos to a Nichias
plant in Nara.
She usually worked at a storage warehouse of the
Nichias.
The Osaka District Court ordered both companies
to pay jointly 26 million JPY to his family on March
31, 2011. Today's High Court Judgment absolved
the Nichias but didn't change the amount of
compensation (by the Nippon Express).
3 Gandhinagar units under lens
for health hazards
All employees handling polyacrylate material at
three industrial units in Gandhinagar district must
be sent to the National Institute of Occupational
Health for a complete health check-up, amicus
curiae Shalin N Mehta has told the Gujarat High
Court.
The three pharmaceutical units manufacturing
the material are Chhatral-based Vikram Thermo
(India) Ltd and Shree Chemicals, and Rakanpur-
based Maruti Chemicals.
The court is currently hearing a suo motu case
about occupational health hazards believed to be
caused by polyacrylate.
At least four workers at a factory owned by Corel
Pharma Chem at Kadi in Mehsana district are
believed to have died from pulmonary
complications caused by the material. Two others
are currently ill.
Occupational health experts who first examined
four of the victims in June 2011 were alarmed to
observe that severe ailments were setting in and
killing the workers faster than silicosis.
The Directorate of Industrial Safety and Health
(DISH) had subsequently been directed by the
court to inspect pharmaceutical units across the
state, where it was found that three out of 146
such units manufactured polyacrylate, while two
used the material in one or the other process.
Mehta also submitted that the three units must
be asked to explain whether the safety
equipments (gloves, masks, etc.) provided to
workers are of industrial grade, and if the workers
came into direct contact with the material.
He also told the court that at least eight raw
materials with “their own peculiar properties and
ill-effects upon coming into contact with human
beings” were used by the units.
Separately, DISH’s certifying surgeon had
conducted follow-up health checks on nine
workers employed in Vikram Thermo and Maruti
Chemicals. They were found suffering from
ailments such as anaemia, high values of serum
bilirubin and SGBT, and alveolitis.
DISH told the court that all nine were showing
signs of improvement after treatment.
The factory manager at Shree Chemicals,
however, told the certifying surgeon that all three
workers at the unit earlier diagnosed with
![Page 11: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 11
ailments (one with interstitial lung disease) no
longer worked there.
Click here to read the article
Pro-asbestos advocacy group
shuts its doors
INSTITUT DU CHRYSOTILE
SURRENDER OF CHARTER
For 27 years, the federal government has financed
the Chrysotile Institute (previously called the
Asbestos Institute) and has given it over $20
million in funding. In April 2011, in the face of
mounting strong criticism, the Harper
government stopped its funding, although the
Quebec government continued its funding.
Around the world the Chrysotile Institute has
played the leading role of propagandist for the
global asbestos industry and has been
condemned by scientists for the false and
dangerous misinformation it has disseminated.
The Chrysotile Institute had earlier tried to put
pressure on the federal government to continue
financing it, by stating that, if the funding from
the federal government was withdrawn, it could
not survive. On the Chrysotile Institute’s website,
no explanation is provided.
Around the world, there will be a cheer from all
those working to protect people from asbestos
harm, when the Chrysotile Institute finally closes
its doors.
For the past year and more, Montreal asbestos
investor, Baljit Chadha and the public relations
agents he has hired, have been leading the battle
in Canada to promote the interests of the
asbestos industry, to complete and open the
underground Jeffrey mine and to re-start the
asbestos industry in Quebec all over again.
Other asbestos lobby groups in other countries,
such as Russia, are working to continue the
deadly role of the Chrysotile Institute overseas.
By Robert Hiltz, Postmedia News, Montreal
Gazette, April 29, 2012 Source
A decades-old pro-asbestos lobby group,
currently funded by the Quebec government, will
be shutting its doors after notifying the federal
government of its plan to dissolve.
The Montreal-based Chrysotile Institute issued
the notice in the Canada Gazette — the
government’s official publication for announcing
new laws and other public information. The
institute, first formed in 1984, promotes the safe
use of chrysotile asbestos on behalf of Canada’s
asbestos mining industry.
NDP MP Pat Martin — a long-time critic of the
asbestos industry and former miner himself —
said the closing of the institute signals the “death
knell” of asbestos mining in Canada.
“I see it as a real tipping point in the movement to
get Canada out of the asbestos industry,” Martin
said. “It’s just another demonstration of the
death rattle of the asbestos industry in this
country.”
He said he first learned of the institute’s intention
to dissolve Saturday, International Workers’
Memorial Day — a day of commemoration for
workers injured and killed around the globe.
“I’ve lost an awful lot of friends and colleagues to
asbestos in my time as an asbestos miner and a
carpenter in the building trades,” Martin said. “It
was very poignant for me to learn that (the
institute was closing) on the very day of mourning
for injured and fallen workers with the flags at
half mast — it was very, very fitting.”
Asbestos is a fibrous construction material used
as insulation that has been linked to a number of
lung diseases, including certain types of cancer.
In a number of Asian countries, including India,
activists are increasingly holding demonstrations
to protest asbestos exports because they say the
substance is harming workers.
![Page 12: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 12
The Chrysotile Institute has long countered by
saying that as long as asbestos is handled in a safe
and controlled manner, it causes little risk to
workers.
Canada’s asbestos industry is centred on two
mines in Thetford Mines and Asbestos, both in
Quebec — and both currently out of production
for the first time in 130 years.
Quebec’s industry department has offered
Balcorp Ltd. of Montreal a loan guarantee of $58
million if the company is able to find $25 million in
financing to reopen the Jeffery Mine in Asbestos.
Kathleen Ruff, senior human-rights adviser to the
independent research group the Rideau Institute,
said the closing of the lobby group sends a signal
to the international community that the industry
is collapsing in Canada.
“It will be noticed all around the world because
the Chrysotile Institute has been the key leader in
pushing the interests in the asbestos industry
around the world,” Ruff said.
The majority of asbestos mined in Canada is
exported abroad to developing countries where
asbestos regulations are less stringent. More than
50 countries have banned asbestos use.
Canada drew international scorn when it moved
to block the listing of chrysotile asbestos on a
United Nations list of restricted chemicals last
June. Listing the material on Annex III of the UN’s
Rotterdam Convention would have required
“prior informed consent” to be provided by
exporting countries.
Once an importing country is informed of the
dangers of the material, it could refuse to accept
the potentially cancer-causing substance if they
felt they would be unable to handle it safely.
Under the convention protocol, chrysotile
asbestos remained off Annex III because
consensus was not reached between attending
countries.
The European Parliament has chastised the
Canadian government over its asbestos exports
— as well as for the seal industry and oilsands
development — and issued a news release
expressing members’ concerns of the harm the
substance caused to miners. The use and
processing of asbestos is banned within the
European Union.
Australia’s Upper House also passed a motion in
November calling on its government to apply
pressure to Canada to end its asbestos exporting.
The link between exposure to asbestos and other
types of cancers is not clear, Health Canada says
on its website. However, the International Agency
for Research on Cancer, affiliated with the World
Health Organization, has concluded after a full
review of the scientific research that asbestos,
including chrysotile asbestos mined in Quebec, "is
carcinogenic in all its forms."
Recently, asbestos research conducted at
Montreal’s McGill University was called into
question by a documentary aired on CBC
television.
The university launched a preliminary review of
the work of one of its retired professors following
allegations the university had close ties to the
industry.
Along with the documentary, a letter making
similar allegations was sent to McGill officials by
doctors, scientists and academics that included
McGill faculty on the same day the documentary
was aired. Both the letter and the film suggested
researchers at McGill received funding from the
industry to publish research that would make
chrysotile asbestos seem less harmful to health
than it is.
The World Health Organization estimates that
globally, more than 100,000 people die from
asbestos-related illnesses, including cancer, every
year.
![Page 13: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 13
Emails to the Chrysotile Institute were not
immediately returned Sunday and the phone
number listed on the institute’s website was no
longer in service.
Landmark verdict on illegal
mining
The Rajasthan High Court in its landmark verdict,
has imposed the largest ever penalty of 50 crores
upon the mining association of Makrana,
Rajasthan, India. Makrana is known for its best
quality marble - used for construction of the
wonder of the world TAJMAHAL. But
the scenario of mining in the said area is pathetic
and the greed of the mining operators has left no
land free from mining.
The petition had been filed in the year 1996, by
the Ministry of Railway, Union of India
highlighting the facts that the entire land below a
railway track - running from makrana to parbatsar
has been dug for mining and left the railway
track hanging in air. The mining operators have
continued the illegal mining despite the clear stay
order passed by the Hon'ble Court.
Rajasthan High Court, in wake of illegal mining
going on across the state, has taken the
matter seriously and called a factual report by
court commissioner. The level of illegality was
very high and apparent, in case of makrana.
Mining of makrana has also earned a bad name
due to the most unsafe and unscientific mining,
resulting of deaths of labours in frequent
intervals.
The division bench of the Rajasthan High Court
headed by Chief Justice - Arun Kumar Mishra, in
its remarkable verdicts has imposed penalty of
Rs. 50 crores upon the mining association of
makrana. There apart ordered for recovery of
amount @ 10 times of loss of mining royalty
caused to state government (which may also go
in many crore). The Court has also imposed a
clear ban on mining up to 45 meters along with
railway tracks and roads across the state. The
court further ordered for CBI probe in this
matter, so that all govt. official remained posted
in makrana during the entire period of illegal
mining may be handled.
For more information - Article 1, Article 2
Workers Memorial Day and
Labour Day Activities
New Report Highlights Crisis of
Occupational Safety and
Health in Asia
Regional Worker Rights Network Releases
Grassroots Research for International Workers
Memorial Day
Hong Kong, China - Asia is home to some of the
most dangerous workplaces in the world. The ILO
estimates that 1.1 million work-related deaths,
accounting for over half of the world’s fatalities,
take place annually in Asia. On the eve of
International Workers Memorial Day on April 28,
Hong Kong-based Asia Monitor Resource Centre
(AMRC) released a detailed report from six Asian
countries namely China, India, Cambodia,
Philippines, Thailand and Indonesia to portray the
real situation of occupational safety and health
(OSH) on the ground and the struggle of workers,
victims and their families to gain recognition,
compensation and justice.
The report was prepared in collaboration with the
Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and
Environmental Victims (ANROEV) – a network of
victims groups, trade unions, labour and
environmental organizations based in 16 Asian
countries all working towards a safe and healthy
workplaces, OSH rights and environmental
justice. These grassroots groups, frustrated by
years of apathy by their governments and
negligent employers, decided to produce their
own report to show the extent of the problem at
the ground with the hope it will draw public
attention to the senseless massacre of workers
across the region.
![Page 14: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 14
“Sick and injured workers in Asia remain invisible
as most countries in Asia do not adequately
report work-related deaths, injuries and
diseases,” said AMRC Executive Director Sanjiv
Pandita. “These victims are are denied justice.
Their dignity. Their deaths are the price that we as
society have paid for the sake of development.”
Ramesh Makwana, a silicosis victim from Gujarat,
India spoke about the problems of gem polishing
workers. He comes from a village that is covered
with a film of deadly silica dust from the gems
that causes the occupational disease. “First it kills
the men who are the primary breadwinners for
their families. Then the disease kills the women
who are forced to take over the work to survive
and finally it takes our children,” he said. “Yet, we
remain largely invisible to our governments and
are denied compensation.”
The battle for compensation and justice was also
echoed by an occupational disease victim from
China. Ms. Wang, a former worker at a battery
manufacturing plant, spoke about her working
conditions in China where she was poisoned by
cadmium. Her kidneys are damaged and she has
not received any compensation for her illness.
Instead she has been harassed by the company
and government officials in her fight for justice.
The report is aimed to bring recognition for
victims like Ramesh and Wang so that they
receive treatment, compensation, rehabilitation
and justice.
May Day Rally by Agate
Workers-Gujarat
International Workers Memorial Day was
observed on May 1, instead of 28 April by Agate
workers. Victims of silicosis, mothers-widows-
children and other family members of the
diseased workers came together at Shakarpur to
pay homage to the workers who died in Silicosis
during last one year. Pictures of the diseased
workers were garlanded and then two minute
silence was observed. Jayesh Dave, Ramesh
Makwana and Jagdish Patel spoke on
the occasion. Jagdish congratulated them for
organizing rally for the first time. Ramesh-who
returned from Hong Kong after attending various
programs organized by Asia Monitor Resource
Centre to launch their latest report "Invisible
victims of Development - Report on H & S in 6
Asian Countries." shared his experiences
and learning.
Later rally set out from Shakarpur to Khambhat.
They all walked 3 km distance in soaring heat (41+
degree Celsius.). They demanded that the officer
climb down to accept the Memorandum but he
refused. Later, representatives of the victims
visited him in his office and presented the
memorandum. He promised to forward it to the
higher ups in Government.
Earlier, on 27 April when Health Minister Jay
Narayan Vays visited Khambhat for a Government
public function, Memorandum was presented to
him by the victims
![Page 15: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 15
Rally in Hong Kong
Over 300 people assembled and participated in a
rally and demonstration on April 28th, which
included injured workers, families of dead
workers, and labour organizations from mainland
China. Overseas participants from India,
Indonesia, USA, Thailand also joined. 200 crosses
you see in the photos represented the almost 200
workers who die on the job per year.
More Details of Programs all over the
world can be seen at
www.hazards.org/wmd,
Labour Day Program in Panna, Madhya
Pradesh
A May day event was organized in Panna, Madhya
Pradesh. Almost 300 workers and villagers
participated in the rally and program. Workers
were informed about their labour rights and
information was given about how to work in a
safe environment
A memorandum of demands was given to the
elected Government representative.
Documentary film dedicated to
workers who died due to work
launched on Workers Memorial
Day
More than 200 people flocked to the Bantayog ng
mga Bayani auditorium to watch the premiere of
PIYON, a documentary film tackling the life and
struggle of workers who died due to work, last
April 28, 2012, coinciding with the worldwide
commemoration of Workers Memorial Day.
Workers and activists joined the families of
victims of work-related accidents, to catch the
first glimpse of the documentary dedicated to
those who died due to work. “Workers Memorial
Day is commemorated across the globe and this
documentary is our humble contribution to this
event,” said Noel Colina, Executive Director of the
![Page 16: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 16
Institute for Occupational Health and Safety
Development (www.IOHSAD.org). “We wanted
to show the human side of the tragedy happening
in many workplaces and not merely display the
victims as mere statistics.”
The 32-minute HD film was made by Mayday
Multimedia. “PIYON plays an important role in
exposing the realities that are brought about by
work-related accidents due to that lack of safety
and security for the workers. It aims to humanize
the victims of these accidents, beyond the
numbered list of names, giving them light as
members of their own families and of society,”
said Kathy S. Molina, co-director of PIYON.
According to Colina, PIYON will soon be available
online. “Although the setting of the documentary
is local, the theme of human loss is universal and
anyone who will watch the film can relate to its
narrative. Hopefully, this will encourage more
people to take up the cause of promoting safe
workplaces across the globe.”
Synopsis:
They work to live not to die.
Benbon Cristobal and Chris Xander Papna are just
two among many who have become victims of
their working conditions — conditions that
neglect their safety and took for granted their
humanity. PIYON is a short video documentary
that aims to give faces to these names and to
shed light on the circumstances that left their
families with lingering emptiness and hopeful
struggles. Woven together by their commonality
of loss, their families share their stories beyond
the tragedies that struck them and their
continuous search for justice.
Source – www.iohsad.org
Kobe earthquake rubble
handler develops cancer 17
years later
KASHI, Hyogo -- A municipal government
employee who worked in rubble processing
following the 1995 Great Hanshin Earthquake has
developed Mesothelioma, the Akashi Municipal
Government announced on July 6.
With massive amounts of rubble generated last
year by the Great East Japan Earthquake and
ensuing tsunami, the latest revelations are likely
to result in further calls for the use of anti-dust
masks and the implementation of other anti-
asbestos measures.
According to the municipal government, at the
time of the massive earthquake that hit Kobe and
its surrounding environs, the employee, a
member of the environment division, handled
garbage collection. For three weeks following the
earthquake, he loaded debris from homes in the
eastern part of the city of Akashi into compactor
trucks, and for the subsequent two to three
months, transported rubble from temporary
storage to processing facilities. Although he wore
a mask and gloves while he worked, the mask did
not protect against fine dust.
The man, now in his 40s, developed swelling on
his right side in January of this year, and
consulted medical professionals in May when the
swelling increased. In June, he was diagnosed
with malignant peritoneal Mesothelioma and is
receiving chemotherapy and other treatment.
The municipal government says that while it is
unclear whether the man's handling of debris
caused his cancer, it considers it a possible cause,
and is planning to hold asbestos screenings for
192 employees who were involved in rubble
treatment. The municipal government also says
that it will interview the man's colleagues from
the period after the earthquake, and test for
asbestos and other flotage from the garbage
processing facilities to shed light on the situation.
![Page 17: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 17
The man is expected to file for public workers'
compensation shortly.
According to the Hyogo prefectural branch of the
Fund for Local Government Employees' Accident
Compensation, there have been no cases of such
applications being accepted in Hyogo Prefecture
in the past.
This is believed to be the first time that a case of
Mesothelioma in a civil servant who handled
rubble resulting from the 1995 Kobe earthquake
has been made public.
Source
The Future We Want is
Asbestos-Free
Rio+20, the 2012 United Nations sustainable
development summit in Brazil, is history. The
long-anticipated three-day event which started on
June 20 had been intended to commemorate the
1992 Earth Summit, also held in Rio de Janeiro,
and reignite the commitment of global leaders to
achieving “The Future We Want,” the 2012
summit's slogan. That it fell far short of both goals
has much to do with the non-attendance of heads
of governments from major polluters; amongst
the list of absentees were President Obama,
Prime Minister David Cameron, Chancellor Angela
Merkel, President Vladimir Putin and Prime
Minister Stephen Harper. In the face of strong
pressure from corporate stakeholders, the lack of
political will and the ongoing economic crisis,
there was a pronounced failure to engage with
agenda issues such as: curbing CO2 emissions,
eliminating subsidies on fossil fuels, providing
universal access to clean water and adequate
food supplies, safeguarding women's
reproductive rights and pushing forward the
green agenda. Summing up the mood as the
Summit ended on Friday (June 22), Sha Zukang,
the Secretary-General of the conference,
described the lack of progress as “an outcome
that makes nobody happy. My job,” he noted
“was to make everyone equally unhappy.”
Unlike the sense of disappointment which
pervaded the Summit's official proceedings, the
spontaneity, diversity and inclusivity of the Rio+20
People's Summit for Social and Environmental
Justice, a parallel event open to all-comers,
created a spirit of subdued optimism. The
allocation of spaces for events organized by more
than 200 non-governmental bodies from June 13
to June 22 enabled discussions on alternative
solutions to the planet's environmental and social
challenges to proceed. The fact that these
debates took place on Flamengo Beach, just a
short distance away from its more famous sibling:
Copacabana, was entirely appropriate; despite
the challenges presented by the unusual
surroundings, organisers and participants made
great use of the time and space available in the
heart of the “cidade maravilhosa” (marvellous
city), Rio de Janeiro.
One constructive happening held under the
umbrella of the People's Summit was a day of civil
action called Rio+20 Asbestos Toxic Tour. The June
15th activities mounted to draw attention to the
deadly threat to humanity and the environment
posed by the continuing production and use of
asbestos began in the morning with a
demonstration and continued in the afternoon
with a bilingual dialogue on strategies for
achieving the aims of the seminar “The Future We
Want is Asbestos-Free” (O Futuro Que Queremos
é Sem Amianto).
The article has been written by Laurie Kazan-Allen
and can be accessed by clicking here
Campaigners urge permanent
closure of Indian asbestos
plants
For two years, villagers in the Indian state of Bihar
have tried to prevent the construction of a new
chrysotile (white) asbestos factory.
![Page 18: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 18
According to internationally-renowned civil
society leader, Medha Patkar, the company
behind the plant published a seriously-flawed
environmental impact assessment, and has also
framed false charges against local opponents.
Backed by a number of Indian political parties,
last month the villagers’ campaign received
support from Dr Barry Castleman, a world expert
on the control of asbestos and other chemical
hazards.
Dr Castleman says that closing of all asbestos
plants in the state “is enormously important in
protecting public health and can serve as an
example for the rest of India in reducing the
impact of a public health disaster in coming
decades.”
For Details: Ajit Kr Singh, Khet Bachao Jeevan
Bachao Jan Sangharsh Committee (KBJBJC),
Vaishali, Mb: 08002903995, E-mail:
Safety NGO calls for
comprehensive probe on
Butuan killer fire
18 workers died after being trapped inside their
workplace
A safety NGO on Wednesday called on the
Department of Labor and Employment (DoLE) to
conduct a comprehensive probe on a fire which
killed 18 workers and injured 2 more. The fire
started around 3 in the morning, May 9, 2012 at
the Novo Jeans and Shirts department store
along Montilla Boulevard, Butuan City. According
to news report, there were a total of 22 stay-in
female workers when the fire broke-out.
“The regional office of the DoLE must investigate
the death of the workers and why they were
trapped inside the burning building and prosecute
those responsible for the neglect of the workers
safety,” said Noel Colina, Executive Director of
the Institute for Occupational Health and Safety
Development (www.IOHSAD.org). “Rule 1943.03
of the Philippine Occupational Health and
Standards (OHSS) outlines the need to have 'at
least of 2 exits every floor and basement capable
of clearing the work area in five (5) minutes'.
There must also be a safety plan in case of fire
which the workers should made familiar with.”
“Workplaces remain to be the top killer of
workers, with 2.2 M dying annually across the
globe based on the International Labor
Organization (ILO) estimates. The DoLE
Department Order 57-04, allowing workplaces
with 200 or more workers to conduct self-
assessment on adherence to labour standards
have failed to protect workers,” said Colina.
Colina reiterated the need to improve and add
strong penal provision to the existing OHSS. “We
should also legislate Industrial Manslaughter to
prosecute employers who neglect their duty to
protect the health and safety of their workers.”
Grinding stone factories have
claimed 30 lives since 2004-
Pakistan
As many as 30 persons have lost their lives since
2004 while 76 are on deathbed due to gross
violations of environmental laws by grinding
stone factories in Lahore, Gujranwala and
Sheikhupura.
Stone grinding results in the emission of fine
grained dust particles, which if not controlled
through appropriate measures, causes fatal
![Page 19: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 19
diseases, like Silicosis and Pulmonary
Tuberculosis.
The 30 men, who lost their lives, were workers at
these stone grinding factories. All over the world
stone-grinding is identified as the chief
contributor to Silicosis and Pulmonary
Tuberculosis, and therefore, special heavy-duty
air purification systems with special filtration, like
wet-scrubbers, are installed at such factories to
avoid health hazards.
In a majority of the cases, appropriate measures,
such as wet-process cutting equipment, is
employed which reduces the possibility of the
fine stone dust from getting airborne and
entering the respiratory system of the workers.
In Pakistan, however, due to the high rate of
unemployment, low level of health care
awareness and toothless environmental laws, the
factory owners hardly practice the safety
standards imperative. The survey conducted by
the Environment Protection Department, Punjab,
revealed that not only did the factories owners
choose not to employ any air-purification system,
they didn’t even provide their workers with the
masks required to give some level of protection
to the workers.
The average age of the men who lost their lives
working for these factories was 35 and they
belonged to roughly the same area near Choti
Bala in the Dera Ghazi Khan district. Due to the
high unemployment in these areas, it is easy for
the factory owners to recruit from these areas
and once a few men return home with the
money, other join in to feed their homes.
‘We have appealed to the government several
times to check the practices at these factories
after our men started dying, but nobody paid
heed to our complaints, said Nazeeraan Bibi’,
widow of Shahnawaz who died due to the disease
and is now getting her brother treated for
Pulmonary Tuberculosis at a government hospital
in Lahore.
At least 60 percent of the unfortunate deceased
are married and their families have now sunk
deeper down into the abyss of misery. While
those who were not even married, took the
prized dreams of their families with them. The
MNA of the area, Sardar Mohammad Jaffar Khan
Leghari, wrote a letter to the chief minister
explaining this precarious situation. A copy of the
letter was sent to the secretaries of the Health,
the Labor and the Environment departments.
Punjab Environment secretary Saeed Iqbal
Wahlah took the initiative to visit the factory and
found them guilty of criminal negligence and
blatant violation of environmental safety
standards.
According to National Environmental Quality
(NEQ) Standards the permissible limit of the
Mean Measured Level of Suspended Particular
Matter (MMLSP) is 500 parts per million.
The sampling of the EPD measured the MMLSP at
these factories ranging from 3,400 to 4,000 parts
per million, which is 700 percent more that of the
permitted range. The staggering fact, however, is
that, despite plausible proof of the criminal
negligence of these factories and the clear
responsibility for the death of 30 men, the
environmental department does not have legal
powers to seal these death-dispensing units.
When contacted, the Environment secretary
confirmed the death toll and the fact that they
had been caused due to the negligence of the
factories owners. However, he said, due to the
Environmental Protection Act 1997 and its
amendments in 2012, the department did not
have the powers to take definite action against
these offenders. The best we can do, he added,
was to refer the case to the environment tribunal,
which too, at maximum could fine these factories.
The lives of the 76 currently suffering from
Silicosis and Pulmonary is still hangs in the
balance as these factories are still operating
![Page 20: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 20
without the equipment mandatory to curtail the
health hazards.
source
Tributes
Lee Yunjeong - 55th Death from Samsung
Born in 1980. She worked in Samsung
semiconductor Assembly & Test factory in
Onyang for six years from 1997 to 2003.
Was Diagnosed with
malignant brain cancer
at 2010. She underwent
Brain surgery and
chemotherapy.
She died 7 May 2012,
only 32 years old,
leaving behind a loving
husband and two
children.
Lee Yunjeong had applied for Workers’
Compensation to the Governments, which is one
of Korean social insurances, but the Governments
refused to compensate her because she could not
prove which toxic chemicals she had been
exposed to.
Lee raised lawsuit against the Governments’
decision at 2011, but could not survive long
enough to see the result of lawsuit. Samsung has
involved the lawsuit by hiring lawyers to support
the Governments and to prevent the workers and
the families from getting compensation.
• Korean Government and Samsung should
apologize in front of the death of Lee.
• Korean Government and Samsung should
guarantee the solemn funeral ceremony can
be finished in peace at May 10th.
• Samsung should stop undermining the just
right of workers to be compensated, and
respect the labour rights.
• Korean Government should compensate to all
the victims from electronic industry including
Samsung.
The story of Lee was shown at TV “Chujuk
60boon” in KBS. You can see the interview of her
and her husband on the
http://youtu.be/wOTRp9Hl4e4 at the scenes from
2:25 to 5:50.
The Environmental Impact of
the Manufacturing of
Semiconductor’s
Module by: Jason Holden, Christopher Kelty. E
Summary: This module gives a brief general
overview of semi-conductor manufacturing and
some of the components and processes used to
produce them that can potentially cause harm to
humans or the environment.
Note:
"This module was developed as part of a Rice
University Class called "Nanotechnology: Content
and Context" initially funded by the National
Science Foundation under Grant No. EEC-0407237.
It was conceived, researched, written and edited
by students in the Fall 2005 version of the class,
and reviewed by participating professors."
![Page 21: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 21
What is a semiconductor?
The semiconductor industry is one of the fastest
growing manufacturing sectors in not only the
United States but also in the world. According to
the American Electronics Association, the
domestic sales of electronic components have
skyrocketed, jumping from $127 billion to $306
billion over the course of the 1980’s. In the first
three quarters of the 2003 fiscal year alone, the
export of technology goods from the United
States increased by $19 billion.
The word “semiconductor” technically refers to
any member of a class of solid, crystalline
materials that is characterized by an electrical
conductivity better than that of insulators (e.g.,
plastic) but less than that of good conductors
(e.g., copper). Semiconductors are particularly
useful as a base material in the manufacturing of
computer chips, and the term semiconductor has
actually come to be synonymous with the
computer chips, themselves. However,
semiconductors are not only used in computers.
Computers only make up 44% of entire industry
consumption (see Figure 1). Semiconductors are
also used for military, automotive, industrial,
communications, and other consumer purposes.
To read more click here
Regional News
Mass fainting in Cambodia
A total of 107 workers at the Sabrina Garment
factory in Kampong Speu's Sambo commune
were sent to hospital after becoming dizzy and
fainting late yesterday [4 Apr 2012] morning.
Choek Borin, the Labour Department's Kampong
Speu bureau chief, said that 107 factory workers
fainted, with nearly 60 sent to the provincial
federal hospital.
He said that after investigations by officials, it is
believed the faintings were caused by a
poisonous chemical used to manufacture gloves
in another section of the factory building.
Chea Mony, president of the Free Trade Union,
travelled to the scene and said that a few workers
fainted in the factory after 9 am. 2 hours later,
there was a mass fainting on the factory grounds
which affected nearly 100 Sabrina Garment
employees.
"Workers were panicked after becoming dizzy
and seeing their co-workers fainting, so they
rushed out from the building," Chea Mony said.
An employee at the factory who fainted in the
factory but later recovered at the scene, said
workers smelled a chemical which made it
difficult to breathe. Workers were ordered to
leave the building to avoid mass fainting.
Sabrina Garment could not be reached for
comment.
Hundreds riot and dozens arrested
at Foxconn iPhone factory in China
in protest at poor working
conditions
• Estimated 1,000 staff clash with security
guards in factory dorm rooms
• Foxconn is world's biggest gadget maker and
produces iPhone and iPad
• Firm has been slammed for forcing staff into
long hours and low pay
• Latest incident after suicides and explosion
at Foxconn plants
Hundreds of workers at the world's largest
electronics manufacturer have rioted at a factory
in China, resulting in dozens of arrests.
An estimated 1,000 Employees at the Foxconn
plant in Chengdu, southwest China, clashed with
security guards who had attempted to prevent a
man stealing on Monday night, according to
Taiwan-based news website Want China Times.
Foxconn makes many of the world's most popular
gadgets, including Apple's iPhone and iPad, the
Amazon Kindle and the PlayStation 3 and Xbox
360 video game consoles.
![Page 22: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 22
The manufacturer has previously come under fire
for forcing staff to work long hours and in unsafe
conditions for low pay.
The riot at the Foxconn factory in Chengdu,
southwestern China, comes after reports of poor
working conditions at the plants
Workers reportedly threw bins, chairs and even
fireworks at security officers from the upper
floors of the building after the riot broke out in a
dormitory at the plant.
Two guards had called out to stop a thief but staff
took the opportunity to air their grudges at
working conditions.
The clash ended after two hours when hundreds
of police officers were called to the scene and
dozens were arrested.
The riot is the latest high-profile incident to affect
Foxconn, which employs up to 120,000 people at
its Chengdu plant, and more than one million in
total.
Under fire: Workers queue to enter the Foxconn
factory in Shenzhen, Guangdong province. The
company employs more than one million people
Blast: A Foxconn worker arrives at a hospital in
May last year after an explosion on an iPad2
production line
Up to 14 Workers at a separate plant in Shenzhen,
Guangdong province, committed suicide by
throwing themselves from the top of the factory
in 2010.
Apple CEO Tim Cook has vowed to work for
better conditions for Foxconn employees
An explosion in May last year killed two and
injured 16 employees who were working on the
iPad 2 production line at the Chengdu factory.
Foxconn's customers, including Apple, have been
criticised for failing to encourage changes at the
Chinese manufacturer's factories.
An investigation ordered by Apple earlier this year
found 'significant' problems at the plants.
Employees can work 76-hour weeks and for 11
days in a row, yet are paid as little as £150 a
month, around three-quarters the country's
average wage and less than half the price of the
iPads they produce.
Apple CEO Tim Cook has vowed to work to
improve conditions at the plants, where 90 per
cent of the technology firm's products are made,
including reducing overtime, which the report
found some workers were not paid for.
'We want everyone to know what we are doing,
and we hope that people copy. We've put a tonne
of effort into taking overtime down,' Cook said in
May.
Source
![Page 23: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 23
U.S., Europe and Japan Escalate
Rare-Earth Dispute With China
By PAUL GEITNER Published: June 27, 2012
BRUSSELS — The European Union, the United
States and Japan ramped up their dispute with
China over its restrictions on exports of rare
earths Wednesday after failing to resolve the case
through negotiations at the World Trade
Organization.
The European trade commissioner, Karel De
Gucht said that the European Union and its
partners in the case had asked for a dispute
settlement panel to be formed in the wake of
inconclusive consultations with China, which were
held after the complaint was filed last March.
Mr. De Gucht noted that in January, an appeals
tribunal at the W.T.O. upheld a ruling from last
year in a related case, in which China was told to
dismantle export duties and quotas on nine other
industrial raw materials, including bauxite.
The current complaint involves restrictions on
rare earths, tungsten and molybdenum, which
were imposed by China in 2006 and tightened
since then.
“Despite the very clear W.T.O. ruling earlier this
year in the first raw materials case, Beijing has not
taken steps to remove these export restrictions,”
Mr. De Gucht said in a statement. “We regret that
we are left with no other choice but to solve this
through litigation.”
China currently produces more than 90 percent of
the world’s rare earth metals, which are essential
to high-technology products from smart phones
to electric car motors. The W.T.O. case argues
that Beijing is violating free trade rules by putting
pressure on companies to move factories to China
if they want access to Chinese raw materials.
Chinese officials have previously signaled that
their defense in that case will be to use a
provision of W.T.O. rules that allows export
restrictions for environmental protection and the
conservation of scarce natural resources.
In what may have been an effort to buttress that
argument, China’s cabinet last week issued its
first white paper on rare earth industry policies,
saying that poorly regulated mining of rare earth
metals had caused widespread environmental
damage and promising an extensive cleanup and
a crackdown on illegal mines.
The W.T.O. dispute settlement panel, once
established, has six months to deliver its report to
the parties, who then can later file an appeal.
Keith Bradsher contributed reporting from Hong
Kong.
A version of this article appeared in print on June
28, 2012, in The International Herald Tribune.
Source
2nd Trade Union Assembly on
Labour and Environment
Just before governments were set to begin the
Rio+20 negotiations, trade unions from all over
the world gathered at an Assembly to launch an
urgent call for action for sustainability and
decent work. From June 11–13, 2012 close to 400
delegates from 56 countries discussed how to
get governments to commit through concrete
obligations for social and environmental change,
that translate into binding agreements, in order
to transform in a fundamental way, the current
profit-based model of production and
consumption.
Trade unions came to Rio with a plan in hand:
immediate action on universal social protection,
green and decent jobs, and financing for
sustainable development, but they also wanted
to agree on an ambitious agenda for their own
organizations related to socio-environmental
issues.
The shameful tendency in recent years of growing
inequalities in the world must be eliminated; and
![Page 24: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 24
instead access to food, energy and water must be
urgently provided to millions of people who are
lacking it, respecting the planet’s ecological limits.
Trade unions of the world propose an ambitious
agenda on climate action, and are prepared to
demand of governments an increase of a
maximum of 1.5ºC in the planet’s average
temperature; an investment of 2% of the GDP in
sectors that reduce environmental impact and
that of natural disasters, and the ban of the use
and the marketing of extremely hazardous
substances such as asbestos, paraquat, benzene,
cadmium, mercury and lead.
A sustainable world is not possible when 60% of
workers do not have a contract for safe work, 75%
of them are not covered by any type of social
protection system, and when the neo-liberal
policies on cuts are resulting in the violation of
trade union and labour rights. For this reason,
trade unions demand that advances be made on
social protection for all and in the implementation
by 2030, of ILO´s recent recommendation on the
social protection floor, through the allocation of
the necessary resources so that it may become a
reality.
This transformation demands responsible and
democratic governments that can ensure the
public control of common goods for their fair
distribution and environmental preservation, and
that urgently reform fiscal systems to make this
possible. The wealthy and the biggest polluters
must pay taxes. It is precisely in this area that
strong and efficient public services should play
their corresponding role to guarantee social
cohesion, the equitable distribution of wealth and
access to education, health, social services and
other essential services, necessary for all
societies.
The financial transaction tax is also part of trade
unions´ demands: it will help to gather funds in an
immediate way for sustainability policies and it
will reduce the scandalous speculation of financial
systems. In 2000, more than 5 billion dollars were
shuffled around through financial transactions all
over the world, ten years later this figure has
multiplied by 7. Isn’t it about time to act already?
More information available here.
OSHA, NIOSH Issue Hazard Alert on
Silica Exposure in Hydraulic
Fracturing
Last Thursday, OSHA and NIOSH issued a joint
hazard alert to ensure that employers are
properly protecting workers from silica exposure
in hydraulic fracturing (“fracking”) operations.
The hazard alert follows a cooperative study by
NIOSH and industry partners, part of the “NIOSH
Field Effort to Assess Chemical Exposures to Oil
and Gas Extraction Workers,” that found that
overexposure to airborne silica is a health hazard
to those working in the fracking industry. Large
quantities of silica sand are used during fracking,
and NIOSH found seven primary sources of silica
dust exposure during fracking operations.
According to NIOSH, workers downwind of sand
mover and blender operations—especially during
hot loading—had the highest silica exposures.
During the agency study, NIOSH found that 47
percent of the 116 full-shift air samples showed
silica exposures greater than the calculated OSHA
permissible exposure limit (PEL), and 79 percent
of the samples showed silica exposures greater
than the NIOSH recommended exposure limit
(REL) of 0.05 mg/m3. The air samples were taken
at 11 different fracking sites in five states:
Arkansas, Colorado, North Dakota, Pennsylvania
and Texas.
Read OSHA’s press release. The hazard alert is
available to view as a PDF or as a Web page.
Last month, AIHA® members Eric J. Esswein,
MSPH, CIH, and John Snawder, PhD, DABT—both
of NIOSH—recently presented findings (with
Michael Breitenstein) from the field effort on the
health hazards of fracking. Read more.
![Page 25: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 25
78% corporate’s suffer sleep
disorder
New Delhi, Apr 6 (IBNS) Due to demanding
schedules and high stress levels, nearly 78% of the
corporate employees sleep less than 6 hours on a
daily basis which leads to sleep disorders
amongst them, according to a recent survey
conducted by ASSOCHAM on the occasion of
‘World Health Day’.
While releasing the ASSOCHAM survey its
Secretary General, D S Rawat said, “Loss of sleep
has wide ranging effects including daytime
fatigue, physical discomfort, psychological stress,
performance deterioration, low-pain threshold
and increase absenteeism”.
The survey also shows that women experience
more sleep problems than men. More than half of
women said they frequently experience a sleep
problem.
Around 55 per cent of the survey respondent’s
fall under the age bracket of 20-29 years, followed
by 30-39 years (26 per cent), 40-49 years (16 per
cent), 50-59 years (2 per cent) and 60-69 years
(approximately 1 per cent).
To read more click here
This noise can truly deafen
There is growing incidence of noise-induced
hearing loss, which results from exposure to high-
intensity sound, especially over a long period of
time.
Noise pollution is a bane of modern life — car
alarms, leaf blowers, gunshots, boom boxes and
traffic congestion among other causes fill our
cities with unhealthy decibel levels. Even rural
areas are not spared any longer, thanks to noisy
farm machinery.
The US Department of Labour's Occupational
Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) states
that exposure to 85 dB(A) of noise, known as an
exposure action value, for more than eight hours
a day can result in permanent hearing loss. It also
recommends that “exposure to impulsive or
impact noise should not exceed 140 dB peak-
sound pressure level.”
Noise-induced hearing loss is of two kinds: the
first is caused by acoustic trauma; and in the
second, the disorder develops gradually due to a
combination of sound intensity and long-term
exposure.
The disorder resulting from acoustic trauma
refers to permanent cochlear damage caused by
one-time exposure to excessive sound pressure
(above 120 dB) such as explosions, gunfire and
firecrackers.
But potentially harmful noise is not necessarily
unpleasant or unwanted. For example, the music
at a concert and the pounding of a jackhammer
on the street can be equally damaging to the
inner ear. It is the intensity with which the sound
(acoustic energy) is delivered, rather than the
source that determines the danger.
NOISE LEVELS ON A SHIP
On ships the main source of noise is the
propulsion mechanism, and therefore the highest
levels of noise are in its vicinity. In most ships the
noise exceeds 100 dB, and sometimes even
touches 110 dB.
This noise can harm the inner ear, bilaterally and
more or less symmetrically, and the damage will
worsen with extended exposure.
The symptoms of noise-induced hearing loss vary
depending on ear canal resonance, the frequency
of the harmful acoustic signal and the length of
exposure.
But as a general rule, any noise may be
considered damaging to one's hearing if it:
• becomes necessary to shout to be heard
above it;
• causes ear pain;
• makes the ears ring; or
![Page 26: Published by: Asian Network for the Rights of Occupational and … · 2013. 2. 16. · OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 4 With the internet and widespread use of social media](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022090604/6057bc76ac78692d9f118694/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
OSH Rights | July – September 2012 Page 26
• causes loss of hearing for several hours or
more after exposure.
Besides hearing loss, loud noise can also cause
ringing in the ears (tinnitus) and occasional
dizziness (vertigo), as well as non-auditory effects
such as increase in heart rate and blood pressure.
The following conditions are believed to increase
susceptibility to noise-induced hearing: blue eyes,
light skin, family history of hearing loss, diabetes
mellitus, Meniere disease, iron deficiency, vitamin
A deficiency, old age, atherosclerosis (hardening
of the arteries), and tobacco smoking.
PREVENTION
There are several simple, widely available and
economical devices that are useful in preventing
noise-induced hearing loss. Earplugs offer
effective protection against low-frequency noise
(such as that of a jackhammer), and earmuffs are
better against high-frequency noise (such as an
airplane taking off). Efforts to improve the
working environment for seafarers and fishermen
include compulsory workplace inspection, noise
measurements and mandatory training in safety
and health.
Combined use of earplugs and muffs is effective
when the noise exceeds 105 dB. The use of cotton
balls or tissue paper wads to cover the ear canals
will prove ineffective when the noise exceeds
about 7 dB.
Prevention is definitely the better option… as,
unfortunately, no treatment is available for noise-
induced hearing loss.
Source
115 mining companies operating
illegally in forest areas in
Indonesia
More than 100 mining companies are operating
without licenses in forest areas across 471,000
hectares in Indonesia, reports The Jakarta Post.
A recent report from Indonesia's Supreme Audit
Agency (BPK) found 115 companies are operating
in forests controlled by the Ministry of Forestry.
The agency called for an investigation into the
companies.
The findings are based on sampling in Sumatra,
Kalimantan and Maluku, among other areas.
Elfian Effendi, executive director of Greenomics-
Indonesia, said the number of companies
operating illegally in designated forest areas is
actually higher.
Read More
All readers are welcome to provide feedback and suggestions to articles of OSH Rights. In the coming
issues, we will offer space for reader feedback.
For any questions about Occupational Health and Safety in Asia, send an email to [email protected].
Our panel of experts will attempt to reply to all questions.
Contact Us - Secretariat
Environics Trust Khasra Number 177, Neb Sarai, IGNOU Road, New Delhi – 110068, India Email – [email protected] URL - www.anroev.org