q-gaussian densities and behaviors of solutions to related...

38
1 Information Geometry on q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related Diffusion Equations* Atsumi Ohara Osaka University January 24 2009 at Osaka City University (Updated April 23 2009) *Joint work with Tatsuaki Wada (Ibaraki University)

Upload: others

Post on 16-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

1

Information Geometry on q-Gaussian Densities

and Behaviors of Solutions to

Related Diffusion Equations*

Atsumi Ohara Osaka UniversityJanuary 24 2009 at Osaka City University

(Updated April 23 2009)

*Joint work with Tatsuaki

Wada (Ibaraki University)

Page 2: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Introduction (1)

2

Porous medium equation (PME)

Example: Diffusion coefficient depending on the power of u

Percolation in porous medium, intensive thermal wave, …

Slow diffusion (anomalous diffusion): Finite propagation speedm=1 (normal diffusion): Infinite propagation speed

Page 3: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Solution of the PME for 1D case (initial function with bounded support)

3

m =1.5

propagation speed is finite

Page 4: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Introduction (2)

Nonlinear Fokker-Planck equation (NFPE)

Corresponding physical phenomena Slow diffusion + drift force (by quadratic potential)

equilibrium density existsNonlinear transformation between the PME and the NFPE

4

Page 5: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Previous work

[Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others…

Existence, uniqueness & mass conservationW.l.o.g. we consider probability densities

Special solution: self-similar solutionConvergence rate to the self-similar solutionLyapunov functional (free energy) technique

5

Page 6: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

6

Introduction (3)

The purpose of the presentation:Behavioral analysis of the PME type diffusion eq. focusing on a stable invariant manifold

the family of q-Gaussian densities

A new point of viewTechnique and concepts from Information Geometry can be applied

Page 7: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Outline1.Generalized entropy and exponential family2.Information geometry on the q-Gaussian family and analytical tools3.Behavioral analysis of the PME and NFPE

Invariant manifoldThe second moments, m-projection, geodesicPeculiar phenomena to slow diffusionConvergence rate to the q-Gaussian family

7

Page 8: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

8

1.

Generalized entropy and exp family (1) [Naudts

02 & 04], [Eguchi04]

:strictly increasing and positive on generalized logarithmic function

generalized exponential function: the inverse of

convex function

- Strictly inc.- Concave-

to define entropy

Page 9: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

9

Generalized entropy and exp family (2)

Bregman divergence

Generalized entropy

Generalized exponential model

: canonical paramtr., : normalizing const: vector of stochastic variables (Hamiltonian)

Page 10: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Remark [Naudts 02, 04]

Requirements to the generalized entropy:1. For a certain , the entropy should be of the form:

2. -Gaussian is an ME equilibrium for Then in the previous slide is determined.

is called the deduced log func of

Page 11: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Another representation of

Conjugate function of

U-divergence [Eguchi 04]

Page 12: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

12

Example (1): used later

Generalized log q-logarithm q: real

Generalized exp q-exponential

PMEGeneralized entropy

(2-q)-Tsallis entropy

Page 13: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Example (2): used later

Bregman divergence

Gen. exp family q-Gaussian family

When q goes to 1, all of them recover to the standard ones. 13

q-Gaussian density

Page 14: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

14

2. Information geometry [Amari,Nagaoka00]

on q-Gaussian family

:finite dimensional manifold in Potential function on

:Legendre transform of Legendre structure on compatible with statistical physics

Riemannian metric, covariant derivatives, geodesics and so on.

Page 15: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

15

Important tools from IG (1)

1. dual coordinates (Expectation parameters)

Expectation of each (= the 1st and 2nd moments for q-Gaussian)

2. m-geodesica curve on represented as a straight line in the -coordinates

Page 16: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Important tools from IG (2)

3. m-projection of

16

(-1)

m-projection

Page 17: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

17

Useful properties of the m-projection

Rem: The property i) claims that the 1st and 2nd moments are conserved.

Page 18: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

3. Behavioral analysis of PME and NFPE

PME:

NFPE:

Relation between u and p [Vazquez 03]

Page 19: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Key preliminary result

Assumption: 1<m=2-q<2Proposition

The q-Gaussian family is a stable invariant manifold of the PME and NFPE.

Idea of the proof)Show the R.H.S. of the PME is tangent to when is on .

19

Page 20: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Trajectories of m-projections (PME)

The 1st and 2nd moments of u(t)

where

ThmThe m-projection of the solution to the PME

evolves following an m-geodesic curve, i.e., its expectation coordinate is a straight line.

20

Page 21: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

21

Properties of the m-projection and behavioral analysis

m-geodesic

Page 22: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Idea of the proof

Time derivatives of the moments:

straight line in the -coordinates

22

Page 23: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Implication of the theorem (1)

The theorem implies the existence of nontrivial N-1 constants of motions. N=dim

A solution of the PME on the invariant manifold is possibly solvable by quadratures. 23

Page 24: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Implication of the theorem (2)

Corollary: Let and be solutions of the PME.

If at , then

24

Page 25: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Implication of the theorem (3)

Idea of the proofThe formula of the 2nd moments + the property i) of the m-projection

The corollary shows that the evolutional speed of each solution depends on the Bregman divergence from .(=the difference of the entropies)When m=1 (normal diffusion), such a phenomenon does not occur.

25

Page 26: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Difference of the second moments

Page 27: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Difference of the evolutional speed

Page 28: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

Generalized free energy

It works as a Lyapunov functional for the NFPE:

The equilibrium density is a q-Gaussian:

28

Page 29: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

Difference of the free energy from the equilibrium density:

Thus, is monotone decreasing.

Interpreted as a generalized H-theorem

29

Page 30: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

1. The property ii) of the m-projection:

30

Page 31: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

2. The known convergence result [Toscani05]

3. The property of the transformation between the PME and the NFPE

If is transform of , then is an m-projection of u

is an m-projection of p

31

Page 32: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

Using 1, 2 and 3, we have the following:

Convergence rate to the q-Gaussian familyL1-norm convergence rate is derived from this result via the Csiszar-Kullback inequality.

32

Page 33: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

33

Page 34: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Convergence analysis for the NFPE and its application to the PME

Page 35: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Remark: L1-norm convergence rate

Csiszar-Kullback inequality [Carrillo & Toscani 00]

The proposition implies that L1 convergence rate to is

faster than L1 convergence rate to the self-similar solution[Toscani 05]

Page 36: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Self-similar solution

PropositionSelf-similar solution is an m- and e-geodesic

Page 37: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

Conclusions

Behavioral analysis of the solutions to the PME and NFPE focusing on the q-Gaussian family.

Constants of motions, evolutional speeds, convergence rate to .Generalized concepts of statistical physics

Future work Relation with Otto’s resultThe other parameter range: m<1 (fast diffusion), 2<m, or the other type of diffusion equation 37

Page 38: q-Gaussian Densities and Behaviors of Solutions to Related ...matsuzoe.web.nitech.ac.jp/infogeo/OCAMI2009/Ohara2.pdf · [Aronson], [Vazquez], [Toscani] and many others… Existence,

ReferencesS. Eguchi, Sugaku Expositions, Vol. 19, No. 2, 197-216 (2006), (originally S¯ugaku, 56, No.4, 380-399 (2004) in Japanese.)J. Naudts, Physica A 316, 323-334 (2002).J. Naudts, Reviews in Mathematical Physics, 16, 6, 809-822 (2004).A. Ohara and T. Wada, arXiv: 0810.0624v1 (2008).F. Otto, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 26, 101-174 (2001).G. Toscani, J. Evol. Equ. 5:185-203 (2005).J. L. Vazquez, J. Evol. Equ. 3, 67-118 (2003).