8/2/2019 Ram Ban

1/2

ShiraHochh

Gemara.

In 1238,

Ramban a

on halach

The Ram

they were

of the nee

to convin

Pablo con

religion w

The debat

Judaism a

to visit th

After the

should cowas broug

The Ram

North of

his sefer oThe Ram

The Ram

scattered.Saladin, a

Yerushala

arrived in

desecratidesolate p

.Even in it

The RamRosh Has

Yerushaly

peirush on

eimer2012

any Jews we

nd explained

, gemara and

an lived duri

demanding th

to become

e other Jews

vince King Ja

as correct. Th

began in fro

nd that Pablo

Rambans sh

ebate, evil p

vert. The Raht to trial for

an had to lea

pain and the

n Chumash, tan wrote the

an then move

Yerushalayimnd invasions

yim but few c

Yerushalyai

n. The more slace of all. . .

s destruction,

an worked toanah that ye

aim that laste

Chumash an

Ra4954

The

died.of R

RebWhil

Shas

beca

beco

learn

re suspicious

who should le

Chumash.

g a very sad t

at Jews conv

hristian. Duri

o do the sam

mes I of Arag

e Ramban ag

nt of a large a

Christiani wa

ul as a sign o

ople spread r

ban got perblasphemy an

e the commu

outh of Fran

he Ramban iseirush for hi

d to the Land

had been invy Tartars, M

ame. In 1267,

on the 9th

of

acred the pla. There are te

it is an excee

rebuild Yerur. The Ramba

d 700 years u

died at the a

ban (Rabb5029;1195

amban was

The Rambabbonim and

eim who also

e a teenager,

. The Ramba

e a physicia

me the chief r

ing and teachi

f some sefari

arn these sefa

ime in Jewish

rt to Christia

ng this time,

.

on to call the

eed to debate

udience. The

incorrect. T

f respect.

mors claimin

ission from td was kicked

nity he led, hi

e for three y

always very rstudents to l

of Israel. At t

aded many tingols and M

Seven years

Elul. He wrot

ce, the greaten men who m

dingly good l

halayim. Hen then set up

til 1948. The

ge of 75.

17

i Moshe be1270

orn in Geron

died when has a relative

taught him k

he Ramban

did not wan

n. He was als

abbi of the en

ing Gemara a

m that the Ra

rim and who

history. The

ity. They trie

Jew Pablo C

Ramban to th

on the condit

Ramban prov

e debate last

g that the Ra

he king to puout of Spain

s Yeshiva an

ars. He bega

espectful ofarn on many

hat time, the

es in 100 yemelukes. Th

after the last i

e to his son "

the devastatet on the Sab

nd."

ook a ruinedyeshiva. In o

Ramban then

n Nachman

a, Spain in 11

e was 10 yearof Rabbeinu

abbalah accor

rote a sefer o

to make mo

the town Ra

tire province

nd Kabballah

mbam wrote.

should not. T

Christians ha

d whatever m

hristiani con

e palace for a

ion that he co

ed that Jews s

d four days.

ban had lost

lish the recohen he was

country. Th

writing his c

ashi even whlevels.

ewish comm

ars. There weMamelukes

nvasion, theany are its

ion it has suffbaths they ho

home and mae year, he sta

left the city t

)

94, 90 years

s old. He desYonah. He ha

ding to the m

n the Gemara

ey from learn

v of Gerona a

of Catalonia.

and writing p

The Ramban

e Ramban w

gotten contr

eans possible

erted to Chri

public debate

uld say whate

hould be allo

fter the deba

the debate an

ds of the deblready 69 ye

Ramban wa

ommentary o

en he has a di

unity in Israel

re Crusades, clet Jews mov

amban cameorsaken place

ered. Jerusaleld services at

de it into a shrted a commu

o return to A

fter Rashi ha

ended from fvery import

sorah, traditi

and knew all

ing Torah, so

nd would late

He spent his t

eirushim on t

defended the

ote sefarim a

ol of Spain an

to convince J

tianty and w

to prove whi

ver he needed

ed to practic

te, the king c

d that all Jew

te.The Rambrs old. .

dered around

n the Chumas

fferent opinio

was very po

onquests byback into

to Israel. Hes, and great i

m is the mosttheir home. .

l. It was readnity in

co. He finish

"

amilyant

on.

ofhe

r

ime

e

s well

d

ews

nted

ch

to.

e

me

s

an

the

h. In

n.

r and

s the

.

y for

d his

8/2/2019 Ram Ban

2/2

ShiraHochh

10 years

his father

the Yeshi

was contr

came to

became t

York.

Posek H

R

halacha b

o f t h e I

Dibros Mklal yisra

Brachos.

got older

help all t

R

one hundShushan

Yerushal

In Russi

T

charged hhis job be

His famil

the gover

Feinstein

notebook

wrote on

As a Reb

Isomeone

depressed

depressed

his best a

R

would no

Once, a s

eimer2012

old, he kne

, who was a

va of Slutzk

olled by the

merica whe

he Rosh Yes

Dor

eb Moshe w

y people frgros Mosh

oshe, his co

el Every day

Reb Moshe a

, he decided

e people w

eb Moshe w

ed and fiftyurim. 300,0

yim since th

he Communi

igh taxes tocause he did

was forced

ment took o

family could

, he wrote hi

ledger sheets

be

portant Advbecoming a

over not doi

! Chazal pro

d keeps tryi

eb Moshe w

be hurt. He

udent was ve

410 blatt (

av, but whe

. In 1921, he

ommunists

re he was gre

hiva of Yesh

as recognize

m all over t

e with his a

mentaries, men, wom

lways made t

not to go to

o came to s

s niftaron

housand peo

00 people c

e second Ba

sts tried to pe

abbis and wnot want to c

to live with h

ver the shul,

live. Reb M

s chiddushim

in between c

ice: Reb Moalmid Choch

ng as well as

ise that if s

g, Hashem

s always con

would alway

ry poor. He

Rav

7th of

Reb M

Uzda,Rebbe

birthd

Reb M

820 pages) o

n he became

became Rav

nd they mad

eted by man

ivas Tiferet

d as the Ga

e world. Du

nswers to th

n the Talmun and child

ime for all o

Eretz Yisrae

e him.

oanisEsth

le at the lev

me to the le

s Hamikdas

rsecute the R

ould throw threate a chillu

is in-laws an

a shoemaker

she learned t

on any pape

olumns of nu

he would oftom. Either h

he wanted. S

meone learn

ill help him!

siderate of h

answer a qu

idnt want t

18

oshe Feinst

Adar. 5655

oshe was bor

a suburb ozen Foyga

y of Moshe

oshe was uni

f Gemorah a

older he le

of Luban an

e life very h

people exci

Yerushala

ol Hador. H

ring his lifese question

d. Reb Moshren would co

f them, andl for a visit

rin1986 (5ya in New Yvaya in Eret

.

abbis in Rus

em in jail byl Hashem an

d two other p

built a room

hrough it all

r he could fin

mbers.

en say that tdoesnt app

omeone who

s Torah they

w he answe

estion in a w

come to yes

in

13 Adar 57

n on the 7th

Minsk, to

ittel. Beca

Rabbeinu, hi

que from a v

nd Rashi; b

rned under

d he remain

rd for Rabba

ed that he w

im on the

e was asked

time, he pus. He also p

e felt a treme to him f

made every

ecause he c

746) at theork. He wasYisrael. It

sia and made

tricking thebecause the

eople in a ro

over the stov

and kept his

d. His famil

ere are two treciate how

studies with

will be succe

ed his talmid

ay that made

hiva because

6 (1895-19

of Adar. 56abbi David

se he was

s parents na

ery young ag

heart. His

Rabbi lssered there for

nim . Finally

s in Americ

ower East S

thousands o

blished seve

blished 13

endous resp

or help, advi

ne feel imp

ould not ma

age of 91. T

buried in Y

as the large

teaching To

. Reb Moshre were no ot

om attached t

e in his kitch

focus. When

still has his

hings that stareat is the T

hasmada sho

ssful. As lon

ims questio

the student f

his parents c

86)

5 (1895) inFeinstein an

orn on the

ed him M

e. When was

ain teacher

olman Melt

15 years. Ru

, in 1936, h

. In 1937, he

ide of New

questions i

n large volu

volumes ofonsibility fe, comfort, a

rtant. When

e enough ti

here were ov

erushalayim

st levaya in

ah a crime.

refused to rher Rabbis le

o a shul. Wh

n where the

he had no

notes that he

nd in the warah, or he is

uld never be

g as a Talmid

s so their fe

el important

ouldnt pay t

"

she.

only

was

er in

ssia

n

mes

rnd

he

e to

er

on

hey

signft.

en

of

tries

lings

.

uition