rapport mark mills - cloud begins with coal

8/20/2019 Rapport Mark Mills - Cloud Begins With Coal

1/45

"#$ %&'() *$+,-. /,"# %'0& ! "# % &'& ( ! "# ) *'+,-./ ( ! "# " )0-&/'-12'1-* ( &)% ! "# 3 ,+*- !" $%&'%(&) $* + ,& & -&.+'(.(+/ 0 1&2 3/ + ,& 4-$3!- 2(4(+!- & .$1/1+&5

"#$% &' "())*+,-. /(0(1#) &234$ 5$267

666789:;?@A87:BC

8729*2$4: ;#1(29#) "(9(90 ?**2@(#1(29

?A4$(@#9 +2#)(1(29 B2$ +)4#9 +2#) ,)4@1$(@(1<

?606*1 CDEF


2/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

2

"#$ %&'() *$+,-. /,"# %'0& ! "# % &'& ( ! "# ) *'+,-./ ( ! "# " )0-&/'-12'1-* ( &)% ! "# 3 ,+*-

!" $%&'%(&) $* + ,& & -&.+'(.(+/ 0 1&2 3/ + ,& 4-$3!- 2(4(+!- & .$1/1+&5

"#$% &' "())*

+,-. /(0(1#) &234$ 5$267666789:;?@A87:BC

8729*2$4: ;#1(29#) "(9(90 ?**2@(#1(29

?A4$(@#9 +2#)(1(29 B2$ +)4#9 +2#) ,)4@1$(@(1<

?606*1 CDEF

+291491*

,G,+HIJK, 8H""?LM

IN, 8I?I, ?>/ OHIHL, -O IN, J>O-L"?IJ-> ,+-8M8I," E' &L,O?+, P Q,RK, ,>I,L,/ ? >,Q ,S,+ILJ+JIMT+,>ILJ+ /J5JI?S ,L?

C' IN, 5S-U?S +->I,GI P ,>,L5M /,"?>/ 5L-Q8. UHI ,S,+ILJ+JIM 5L-Q8 O?8I,L

F' IN, H'8' +->I,GI P /,"?>/ O-L ,S,+ILJ+JIM 5L-Q8

V' IN, LJ8, -O IN, J>O-L"?IJ-> ,+->-"M P UJ5 ?>/ 5,IIJ>5 UJ55,L. O?8I

W' IN, J>O-L"?IJ-> ,+->-"M P N-Q "H+N ,S,+ILJ+JIM /-,8 JI H8, X QN,L, J8 JI H8,/Y

,S,+ILJ+ /,"?>/ J> IN, J>O-L"?IJ->T+-""H>J+?IJ->8 I,+N>-S-5J,8 ZJ+I[ ,+-8M8I,"

\' /?I? +,>I,L8

]' +-""H>J+?IJ->8 >,IQ-L^8

_' ,>/TH8, /,KJ+,8

`' "?>HO?+IHLJ>5

ED' &HIIJ>5 JI ?SS I-5,IN,L

EE' QN,L, /-,8 X QN,L, QJSS IN, &-Q,L +-", OL-"Y

EC' ?&&,>/J+,8

?&&,>/JG ? TT /-,8 H8J>5 IN, +S-H/ 8?K, ,>,L5MY

?&&,>/JG U TT IN, J"&?+I -O ,OOJ+J,>+M -> ZJ+I[ ,S,+ILJ+JIM /,"?>/

L,O,L,>+,8 X >-I,8

Ia(* $472$1 7$2b(:4* #9 (9:4749:491 #**4**A491 2B 1a4 14@a9(@#) )(14$#16$4 #9: 1a4 9#16$4 2B 4c(*1(90 4*1(A#14* #9: *6$b4


3/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

3

"#$ %&'() *$+,-. /,"# %'0& ! "# % &'& ( ! "# ) *'+,-./ ( ! "# " )0-&/'-12'1-* ( &)% ! "# 3 ,+*-

!" $%&'%(&) $* + ,& & -&.+'(.(+/ 0 1&2 3/ + ,& 4-$3!- 2(4(+!- & .$1/1+&5

$1$%(",2$ .(33045

Ia4 (9B2$A#1(29 4@292A< (* # ;)64T3a#)4 4@292A< 3(1a (1* 494$0< 6*4* A2*1)< 261 2B *(0a1' U#*4: 29 #A(:T$#904 4*1(A#14. 1a4 32$):R* J9B2$A#1(29T+2AA69(@#1(29*TI4@a92)20(4* ZJ+I[ 4@2*


4/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

4

"#$ %&'() *$+,-. /,"# %'0& ! "# % &'& ( ! "# ) *'+,-./ ( ! "# " )0-&/'-12'1-* ( &)% ! "# 3 ,+*-

!" $%&'%(&) $* + ,& & -&.+'(.(+/ 0 1&2 3/ + ,& 4-$3!- 2(4(+!- & .$1/1+&5

Where Electricity Is Consumed in the Digital Universe

Global Electricity Demand: The Cloud, Illumination, and EVs

The global ICT ecosystem uses as much electricity as global lighting did circa 1985, and in two decades will likely use triplethe energy of all EVs in the world by then, assuming an optimistic 200 million EV forecast.

[“Cloud” is used here to refer to the entire global ICT ecosystem, and not to a more narrow definition of Cloud business services.][Red triangles indicate global ICT estimates from Greenpeace. Coal use is based on current global 40% share of electricity generation.]


5/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

5

67 84$90%$ : /$;2$ $-"$4$) 0 -$/ $&$%"4,%,"5


6/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

6

5)2;#) (9b4*1A491 (9 1a4 (9B$#*1$6@16$4 2B 1a4 :(0(1#) 4@292A< (* #)$4#:< 2b4$ nW 1$())(29. #9: 3()) 0$23#921a4$ nF 1$())(29 3(1a(9 # :4@#:4' 5)2;#) U(0 /#1# @#7(1#) *749:(90 (* 923 (9 1a4 *#A4 )4#064 #* U(0-()'V U61 3a()4 U(0 -() 7$2:6@4* 494$0


7/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

7

>23. 1a4 *@#)4 #9: 1a4 @a#$#@14$ 2B 1a4 J+I 4@2*


8/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

8

N7 "#$ +&'*0& %'-"$1" : $-$4+5 )$30-) +4'/.O *(" $&$%"4,%,"5 +4'/. 9 0."$4

,94$0< B2$4@#*1(90 a#* 4914$4: # 943 4$# :$(b49 ;< $#:(@#) @a#904* 29 ;21a 1a4 :4A#9: #9: *677)<*(:4* 2B 1a4 4d6#1(29' &276)#1(29 #9: 4@292A(@ 0$231a #$4 1a4 :$(b(90 B2$@4* (9 1a4 32$):R* 944: B2$494$0< (9 0494$#) #9: 4)4@1$(@(1< (9 7#$1(@6)#$' ,b49 3(1a *6;*1#91(#) 0#(9* (9 4BB(@(49@


9/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

9

P7 "#$ (7.7 %'-"$1" : )$30-) 9'4 $&$%"4,%,"5 +4'/.

H'8' 4)4@1$(@ :4A#9: 0$43 FDf 2b4$ 1a4 7#*1 132 :4@#:4* #9: (* B2$4@#*1 ;< 1a4 ,J? 12 0$23 #921a4$EWf 2b4$ 1a4 @2A(90 132'\ "4#93a()4. 929T4)4@1$(@ 929T1$#9*72$1#1(29 494$0< 6*4 *1#$14: :4@)(9(90 (9E``W P A#$%(90 # 16$9(90 72(91 (9 1a4 @291(964: 4)4@1$(B(@#1(29 2B 1a4 4@292A


10/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

10

-BBT*411(90 1a4 0#(9* (9 #b4$#04 4BB(@(49@< 2B @29b491(29#) 4d6(7A491 #$4 1a4 A#@$2T4@292A(@ B4#16$4*1a#1 :$(b4 A2$4 :4A#9:' -b4$ 1a4 7#*1 132 :4@#:4*= 7276)#1(29 #9: @2AA4$@(#) ;6():(90 *7#@4 ;21a0$43 CWf. 121#) $4*(:491(#) *7#@4 0$43 WDf. #9: 5/& #9: (9:6*1$(#) 261761 0$43 \Df #9: WDf$4*74@1(b4)


11/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

11

Q7 "#$ 4,.$ '9 "#$ ,-9'430",'- $%'-'35 : *,+ 0-) +$"",-+ *,++$4O 9 0."

-b4$ nE 1$())(29 2B 1a4 H'8' 4@292A< (* #**2@(#14: 3(1a 1a4 4@2*


12/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

12

U4B2$4 4c7)2$(90 (9B2$A#1(29R* 494$0< #7741(14. @29*(:4$ 1a4 @2$4 :$(b(90 B2$@4 B2$ J+I 0$231a=+2A761(90 #9: 1a4 94132$%* 12 @2994@1 7427)4 #9: 1a(90* 12 @2A761(90 a#b4 ;4@2A4 *1699(90)<@a4#7' +29*4d6491)


13/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

13

&427)4 @#9 6*4 29)< *2 A#9< )6A49* 74$ *d6#$4 B221. 4#1 *2 A6@a. 2$ *749: *2 A6@a 1(A4 (9 # @#$.*411(90 )(A(1* 29 121#) )(0a1(90. B22: #9: B64) @29*6A71(29' U61 1a4 #7741(14 B2$ ;(1* *a23* 92 ;269:*',b49 7$2*74$(1< B2$ 4A4$0(90 4@292A(4* (* 92 )2904$ A4#*6$4: h6*1 ;< 1a4 74941$#1(29 2B 4)4@1$(@(1<#9: )(0a1 ;6);* Z1a260a 1a#1 (* *1()) b(1#)[. ;61 ;< ;(1*T74$T@#7(1#' Ia(* (* # $#:(@#) *a(B1 B$2A 1a4 E`_D*3a49 4@292A(*1* 76gg)4: 2b4$ J+IR* oa(::49R 7$2:6@1(b(1< 0#(9*' >2;4) 4@292A(*1 L2;4$1 82)23

B#A26*)< #*%4: (9 E`_]= M/B> :G? D99 8;9 :BC=>89F GJ9 9I9FH6;9F9 K>8 A? 8;9 =FB@>:8AIA8H D8G8AD8A:D7 m_

Global Wealth Correlates With ICT Penetration

Source: Telecommunications Union ICT Development IndexICT penetration is measured as a composite of 11 deployment and availability indicators.

Ia4*4 ;$2#: J+I 1$49:* P :4@)(9(90 @2*1*. $(*(90 0)2;#) :4A#9:* TT #$4 923 ;4(90 #A7)(B(4: ;< 1a44A4$0(90 1$#9*B2$A#1(29 2B 1a4 J914$941 (912 3a#1 (* ;4(90 7276)#$)< (B )22*4)< 14$A4: 1a4 +)26:. #9:1a4 "2;()4 J914$941' Ia4 *@#)4 2B 1a(* 94c1 1$#9*B2$A#1(29 (* A2$4 *(09(B(@#91 1a#9 1a#1 B$2AA#(9B$#A4* 12 &+* #9: 1a4 3($4: J914$941' J9 CDEF. 1a4 32$): 3()) *749: nF'_ 1$())(29 29 J+I. 294b4$


14/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

14

R7 "#$ ,-9'430",'- $%'-'35 : #'/ 3(%# $&$%"4,%,"5 )'$. ," (.$ S /#$4$ ,. ," (.$)T

"#96B#@16$4$* 923 7$2:6@4 4#@a


15/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

15

Ia4 494$0< @a#$#@14$(*1(@* 2B 1a4 J+I 4@2*


16/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

16

Ia4$4 #$4 B26$ A#(9 494$0


17/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

17

U7 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 : ) 0"0 %$-"$4. VUWX Y ZWX +) , [

Ia4 149* 2B 1a26*#9:* 2B :#1# @4914$* #$269: 1a4 32$): @2A7$(*4 # a(0aT7$2B()4 B4#16$4 2B 1a4 J+I#$@a(14@16$4. B$2A J23# #9: 8261a +#$2)(9#E_. 12 I4c#*E` #9: +#)(B2$9(#. #9: B$2A J$4)#9: 12 J@4)#9:.#9: B$2A +a(9# 12 J9:(#' ? FDD.DDD *d'B1' VD A40#3#11 Z"Q[ O#@4;22% :#1# @4914$ 27494: (9 CDEC (9>2$1a +#$2)(9# 3a4$4 4)4@1$(@ $#14* #$4 EDTFDf ;4)23 1a4 H'8' 9#1(29#) #b4$#04 Z1a4 )2@#) 0$(: (* W\f

@2#). FCf 96@)4#$[' Ia4$4. 1a4 O#@4;22% B#@()(1< 3()) *#b4 nEDD A())(29 (9 274$#1(90 @2*1* @2A7#$4: 129#1(29#) #b4$#04 $#14*.CD #9: 6*4 294 A())(29 129* 2B @2#) 2b4$ 1a4 94c1 :4@#:4'CE

The Size & Power Of Leading-Edge Data Centers Keeps Rising

Source: Sun Microsystems

-94 2B 1a4 32$):R* ;(004*1 @2AA4$@(#) :#1# @4914$*. (9 >4b#:#. #1 VDD.DDD *d6#$4 B441 923 Z*4b49B221;#)) B(4):*[ (* *)#14: 12 4c7#9: 12 132 A())(29 *d' B1'CC "4#93a()4. 1a4 2394$* 2B # nE'\ ;())(29. CDD"Q 294 A())(29T*d6#$4TB221 :#1# @4914$ 69:4$ @29*1$6@1(29 (9 +a290d(90. +a(9#. #:b4$1(*4* 1a4$4@a4#7 7234$ ZB$2A +a(9#R* _D 74$@491 @2#)TB($4: 4)4@1$(@ 0$(:[. 921 @a4#7 )#;2$. #* 1a4($ @2A741(1(b4#:b#91#04 (9 76$*6(90 0)2;#) +)26: *4$b(@4*'CF

5)2;#))


18/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

18

,b49 #* 1a4 4BB(@(49@< 2B @2A761(90 4d6(7A491 (A7$2b4*. #9: $#:(@#) 0#(9* a#b4 ;449 #@a(4b4: (92b4$#)) :#1# @4914$ 274$#1(29#) 4BB(@(49@< (9 $4@491


19/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

19

&$20$4** (9 :#1# @4914$ 4d6(7A491 4BB(@(49@< 3()) @291(964C`. ;61 B2$4@#*1* *1()) *a23 *6;*1#91(#) 0$231a(9 :#1# @4914$ 494$0


20/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

20

/#1# @4914$* a#b4 4914$4: # 943 4$# (9 14$A* 2B 1a4 @a#$#@14$ 2B 1$#BB(@' "2*1 :#1#T@4914$ 1$#BB(@ 691()$4@491)< 3#* #**2@(#14: 3(1a A#9#0(90 :#1# B)23(90 12T#9:TB$2A 6*4$*' J91$#T:#1#T@4914$ 1$#BB(@ (*923 0$23(90 B#$ B#*14$ 1a#9 1$#BB(@ 12T#9:TB$2A 49:T6*4$* :64 12 1a4 $(*(90 6*4 2B JI *4$b(@4*. $4A214*12$#04. #9: 1a4 (9@$4#*(90 6*4 2B $4#)T1(A4 7$2@4**(90 Z49#;)4: ;< a(0aT*744: 6*4$ @2994@1(b(1


21/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

21

Ia4 69(b4$*4 2B :#1# @4914$* (* $#7(:)< 4c7#9:(90 #9: @29*1$6@1(29 261*(:4 2B 1a4 H'8' (* 0$23(90 #113(@4 1a4 7#@4 2B >2$1a ?A4$(@#' "#9< #$4 )2@#14: 3a4$4 7234$ (* @a4#7 #9: ;#9:3(:1a #b#()#;)4.21a4$* 3a4$4 7234$ (* A2$4 4c749*(b4 ;61 7$2c(A(1< 12 A#$%41* (* @$(1(@#)' ?* B#*1 #* 1a4 *744: 2B )(0a1(*. @2A761(90 (* *2 B#*1 1a#1 :(*1#9@4* 12 :#1# @4914$* 2B 29)< # B43 149* 2B A()4* #$4 72**(;)4 B2$ l$4#)1(A4m 4c@a#904* B2$ *6@a 1a(90* #* @$(1(@#) ;#@%67*. B(9#9@(#) 1$#9*#@1(29*. 2$ (9@$4#*(90)< @2AA29:


22/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

22

V7 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 : %'33(-,%0",'-. -$"/'4W. VUWX Y \XX +) , [

>4132$%* #$4 @2A7$(*4: 2B 1$#9*72$1 a#$:3#$4 (9 1a4 3($4: ZB(;4$. @2#c. #9: )40#@< @2774$[ #9:3($4)4** :2A#(9* Z@4))6)#$. Q("#c. #9: Q(O('[ I2:#


23/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

23

?1 1a4 49: 2B CDEC 1a4$4 34$4 F'C ;())(29 @4))6)#$ *6;*@$(;4$*. 2B 3a(@a E'C ;())(29 34$4 ;$2#:;#9:*6;*@$(;4$* P 1a4 )#114$ (* 13(@4 #* A#9< #* 1a4 121#) )#9:T)(94 ;$2#:;#9: *6;*@$(71(29*'F_ >21 29)< #$41a4$4 # )21 A2$4 7427)4 29 3($4)4** 94132$%*. ;61 1a4 1$#BB(@ 29 1a2*4 94132$%* a#* 0$239 B#*14$'+29*4d6491)


24/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

24

+a(9# "2;()4R* 4c74$(49@4 *6004*1* 1a#1 @6$$491 4*1(A#14* 2B 0)2;#) 94132$% 494$0< 6*4 #$4 )23',c1$#72)#1(90 +a(9# "2;()4R* 4c74$(49@4. 3a4$4 7$4T;$2#:;#9: 1$49:* 326): a#b4


25/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

25

Ia4 943 a(0aT*744: SI, 94132$%* 1a#1 #@@4)4$#14 1a4 A2;()4 J914$941 $4d6($4 67 12 1a$44 1(A4* A2$4:#1# 74$ a26$ 74$ 1#*% @2A7#$4: 12 1a4 7$4b(26* *)234$ F5 94132$%*. #9: 1a6* A2$4 494$0


26/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

26

5)2;#) J914$941 1$#BB(@ (* 02(90 A2;()4' "(0$#1(29 12 1a4 3($4)4** J914$941 (* a#7749(90 B#*14*1 (94A4$0(90 A#$%41*. ;61 (* 2@@6$$(90 4b4$


27/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

27

Ia4 69:4$)


28/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

28

X7 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 -- $-)


29/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

29

816:(4* B2@6*4: 29 IK* #9: *41T127 ;2c4* 4*1(A#14 H'8' @29*6A71(29 #1 `D T EDD IQa'WF.WV 5)2;#))


30/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

30

K(:42 0#A4 @29*2)4*. (9a4$491)< @2A761(90T@491$(@ #9: (9@$4#*(90)< J914$941T@2994@14:. #$4 #921a4$b#$(#;)4 (9 1a4 49:T6*4 #@@2691(90 #)*2 2B149 2A(114: 2$ 69:4$T@26914:' 5)2;#) 4)4@1$(@ 6*4 B$2A 0#A4@29*2)4* (* 4*1(A#14: 12 ;4 FD 12 \D IQa'\E ,#@a 0494$#1(29 2B 0#A4 @29*2)4 a#* 4ca(;(14: $(*(907234$ $4d6($4A491* Z29 #b4$#04 :26;)(90 (9 1a4 7#*1 :4@#:4[ #9: 1a4 0#A4* #$4 (9@$4#*(90)< 7)#


31/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

31

M41 B6$1a4$ 69:4$T@2691(90 2B J+I 494$0< 6*4 #$(*4* B$2A 1a4 )40#@< #77$2#@a 12 :#1# @2))4@1(29' ,J?R*4*1(A#14 B2$ 2BB(@4 &+* #9: A29(12$* :24* 921 (9@)6:4 #)) 1a4 494$0< 6*4: ;< 4d6(7A491 (9 1a4 JIo@)2*41*R 2B @2AA4$@(#) ;6():(90*' Q4 @#9 B(9: 1a4 $4*1 2B @2AA4$@(#) J+I a#$:3#$4 (9 # @#1@aT#))@#1402$< )#;4)4: l21a4$m ;< ,J?. # o;6@%41R @$4#14: (9 1a4 7$4TJ914$941 4$# 12 #00$40#14 A


32/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

32

Y7 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 : 3 0-(90%"(4,-+ VW\X Y _XX +) , [

J1 1#%4* 494$0


33/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

33

O2$ # *A#$17a294. 1a4 4A;2:(4: 494$0< $#904* B$2A ]D 12 `Df 2B 1a4 4)4@1$(@(1< 1a4 7a294 3()) 6*42b4$ (1* )(B4. @2691(90 $4@a#$0(90 (1* ;#114$


34/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

34

&$4b#()(90 4*1(A#14* 2B J+I A#96B#@16$(90 494$0< 69:4$T@2691 12:#


35/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

35

6Z7 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 : 8("",-+ ," 0&& "'+$"#$4 VTRTXX Y UR_XX +) , [

,*1(A#14* 2B J+I 494$0< 6*4 #$4 ;#*4: 29 A#9< #**6A71(29*. 921#;)< B2$ 4c#A7)4 3a#1 *a#$4 2B IK 12#))2@#14' "2*1 4*1(A#14* 2$(0(9#14 (9 :#1# B$2A 1a4 7$4T1#;)41 #9: 7$4T*A#$17a294 4$#. 7$4T:#1(900$231a (9 1$#BB(@ #9: 494$0< 6*4 B$2A 3($4)4** ;$2#:;#9:'`D ?9: 4b49 1a4 7$4@(*(29 2B 4*1(A#14* B2$:#1# @4914$* A#*%* 1a4 B#@1 1a#1 A6@a (* (9B4$$4: #9: 921 ;#*4: 29 #@16#) Z7$27$(41#$


36/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

36

667 $&$%"4,% )$30-) ,- "#$ ,%" $%'.5."$3 : /#$4$ )'$. S /#$4$ /,&& "#$ 8'/$4 %'3$ 94'3T

Ia4 J+I 4@2*#1(29#) ?@#:4A< 2B 8@(49@4*

J9 4b4$< @$4:(;)4 B2$4@#*1 TT (9@)6:(90 B$2A 1a4 ,J?. J,?. U&. ,cc29 TT @2#) @291(964* 12 ;4 1a4 )#$04*1*(90)4 *26$@4 2B 4)4@1$(@(1< B2$ 1a4 32$):' +2#)R* :2A(9#9@4 #$(*4* B$2A 1a4 (A72$1#9@4 2B %447(90 @2*1*:239 3a()4 7$2b(:(90 4b4$T0$4#14$ d6#91(1(4* 2B 4)4@1$(@(1< 12 1a4 0$23(90 4@292A(4*. #9: #* 1a4 J,?$4@491)< 9214:. 1a4 #;*49@4 2B @2*1T4BB4@1(b4 #)14$9#1(b4* #1 1a4 *@#)4* 1a4 32$): 944:*'`] Ia4 J,? #)*2B2$4@#*1* 1a#1 1a4 *4@29: )#$04*1 *26$@4 2B 943 4)4@1$(@(1< 3()) @2A4 B$2A $4943#;)4* P 74$a#7* B2$*2A4 1a4$4 (* ($29< (9 1a4 :(0(1#) 4@2*


37/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

37

Ia4 0$231a (9 1a4 494$0


38/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

38

088$-),1 0


39/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

39

S(*149(90 h6*1 29@4 12 # *290 *12$4: (9 1a4 +)26: 6*4* )4** 494$0< 1a#9 76$@a#*(90 #9: *a(77(90 # +/.1#%(90 (912 #@@2691 A#96B#@16$(90 #9: 1$#9*72$1 494$0


40/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

40

?9 ,H 7$2h4@1 :($4@14: #1 $4:6@(90 @4))6)#$ 494$0< 6*4 P ;4@#6*4 1a4 l94132$%* #$4 (9@$4#*(90)<@291$(;61(90 12 0)2;#) 494$0< @29*6A71(29m TT (:491(B(4: 14@a92)20(4* 1a#1 @#9


41/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

41

088$-),1 *


42/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

42

,BB(@(49@< (A7$2b4A491* *1(A6)#14 :4A#9:. # 34))T$4@209(g4: 4@292A(@ 7$(9@(7)4 #9: # B#A()(#$7#114$9 (9 a(*12$


43/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

43

82A4 #9#)


44/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1&

! #$%$&'( )*+,- %-*.)

44

4$9$4$-%$. S -'"$.

E >43 $4B$(04$#12$ FWD %Qa 74$ ,&? ,94$0< 81#$i v]DD %QaqE9Di U&. &?9FJH $>8EBBb CDFDi #9: ,cc29. +;9 $>8EBBb LBF &?9FJH\ ,J?. !??>GE &?9FJH $>8EBBb R 29:9CK9F UXTU ] ,J?. lH8 4@292A< #9: 4)4@1$(@(1< :4A#9: 0$231a #$4 )(9%4:. ;61 $4)#1(29*a(7 (* @a#90(90.m "#$@a CDEF'_ e#@% ,' I$(7)411. Ia4 82)23 &$2:6@1(b(1< $#:2c= Qa#1 /2 +2A7614$* /2 12 &$2:6@1(b(1F?GE BL &:B?BCA:D. "#< E``_` x/>41 . l5#$194$ 670$#:4* CDEF JI *749: 12 n F']I.m e#96#$< CDEFED U$(#9 N#41 . lIa4 CE*1 +4916$< /#1# +4914$= ?9 2b4$b(43.m ?7$() C. CDEF'CF .;B?JfA?J 5>?A:A=GE 4BI9F?C9?8 "96D. CDEE. #9: $1O 5GJGgA?9. l.;A?GdD .EB>@ .A8A9D.m e694 CDEC. CV 82A#b#1 #9: >#A;22:($(CW 5$44974#@4. CDEDC\ H'8' ,&?. '9=BF8 8B .B?JF9DD B? 19FI9F G?@ 2G8G .9?89F &?9FJH &LLA:A9?:H R?606*1 C. CDD] C] /#1#@4914$/?A:G8AB? 1HD89CD . CDD`F\ I6@%4$ 41 #). l,b2)61(29 2B Q/" -71(@#) J& >4132$%*= ? +2*1 #9: ,94$0< &4$*74@1(b4.m cB>F?GE BL -AJ;86GI9 +9:;?BEBJH . O,ULH?LM E. CDD`F] +IJ? 84A(T?996#) Q($4)4** J9:6*1$< 86$b444:4: 12 L69 # Q($4)4** >4132$% Ym. ,94$0< ?3#$4 L#:(2 #9: 94I32$% 14@N92)20(4*. e#9' CDED 12 e694 CDECVD N#*#9 41 #). l5$449 +4))6)#$ >4132$%*= ? 86$b4F?GE . lQa< J* M26$ >43 (: 86@a # /#1# N20Ym "#$@a CD. CDEC Z199 F9EG89@ %A@9B 1=99@ +FG= ->FbD A? "96 AOG@ 7hVV ?;:6)%#B( 41 #). l,94$0< ,BB(@(49@< 2B N414$2049426* +4))6)#$ >4132$%*= ? L4b(43.m cB>F?GE BL !==EA9@ 1:A9?:9DR CDECVW -,+/. 3FBG@KG?@ D8G8AD8A:D >=@G89. ] O4;$6#$< CDEFV\ ,$(@**29. 5BKAEA8H '9=BF8 -+& G?@ DCGF8=;B?9 >=8Gb9 @FAI9D IA@9B 8FGLLA: JFB68;. e69 F. CDEFV] E` %Qaq5U 74$ ?I^4#$94< B2$ 58"?. +;9 5BKAE9 &:B?BCH CDEF. vC %Qaq5U 74$ +,,I. +;9 OB69F BL )AF9E9DD .EB>@ . ?7$() CDEFV_ O2$*14$. 41 #)V` U2*129 +29*6)1(90 5$267 8"?LI4$CDCD. 5$44974#@4. 82A#b#1 #9: >#A;22:($(WD ,94$0< 8#b(90 I$6*1. lIa4 4)47a#91 (9 1a4 )(b(90 $22A= a23 26$ #77)(#9@4* #9: 0#:041* #$4 1$#A7)(90 1a4 0$449 :$4#A.m CDEE


45/45

!"# %&'() *#+,-. /,0" %'1& 45

WE ,J? B2$4@#*1* (9@)6:4 943 6*4* B2$ 4)4@1$(@(1< ;61 921 94@4**#$()< #))2@#14: 12 J+I. 92$ $4B)4@1(90 $4@491 #@@4)4$#1(29 2B 943 J+I 1$49:*'WC >L/+. lIa4 JA7#@1 2B +29*6A4$ ,)4@1$29(@* 29 N2A4 ,)4@1$(@(1< H*4.m CDEEWF O$#69a2B4$ +4914$ B2$ 86*1#(9#;)4 ,94$0< 8C=8AB? BL .B?D>C9F &E9:8FB?A:D A? 0717 ,BC9D A? UXTX. /4@4A;4$ CDEEi T]Z +);A? UXTX LBF GEE .&R WW +); LBF (?LB +9:; . _X +); LBF +% i D98 8B= WV ^3#1$# 41 #). 5AD:9EEG?9B>D &?9FJH -BG@D A? 3>AE@A?JD. ?+,,,. e694 CDEFWW O2$*14$. 41 #)W\ J,?. 4G@J98D G?@ 4AJG6G88DR OBEA:A9D LBF &?9FJH &LLA:A9?8 &E9:8FB?A:D R CDD`W] $% 41 #). lIK ,94$0< +29*6A71(29 I$49:* #9: ,94$0214= J,? CDD_ 4*1' C]W IQaW_ N41B)(c. I4*1(A29LG:8>FA?J &?9FJH LBF G OFB@>:8 R CDD`\_ >#b(0#91 +29*6)1(90. B2$ ,J?. lL4*(:491(#) #9: +2AA4$@(#) U6():(90 I4@a92)20(4* P L4B4$49@4 +#*4.m 84714A;4$. CDEE. #9:L' S6@%C. 84714A;4$ CDEC\` H71(A4 J9*1(1614 CDEC /#1# +4914$ J9:6*1$< 0)2;#) *6$b4<]D (?89F?G8AB?GE +9:;?BEBJH 'BG@CG= LBF 19CA:B?@>:8BFD UXXj 9@A8AB? TT E'` %()23#11Ta26$* 74$ *d6#$4 @491(A414$ 2B A(@$2@a(7]E L' /24$(90. M' >(*a(. lS(A(1* 2B J9140$#14: +($@6(1 "#96B#@16$(90.m OFB:99@A?JD BL 8;9 (&&& . "#$@a CDDE]C +IJ? 84A(T?996#) Q($4)4** J9:6*1$< 86$b4 IN, L-?/ J> CDCD= ? )(B4T@4132$%* X /+ #$4 CDD] :#1#_E U2*129 +29*6)1(90 5$267_C J9 #921a4$ #9#)89F 5G?>LG:8>FA?J B2$ 4c#A7)4. 1a4 494$0< $4d6($4: 12 A#96B#@16$4 &+* (* 921 *449 # \DD %Qa #*@(14: (9 8"?LI4$. ;61 @)2*4$ 12 E.DDD TT C.DDD %Qa'_F U2*129 +29*6)1(90 5$267 8"?LI,Li H*4* :#1# B$2A CDEE B2$ 1#;)41* *a(774: Z]D A())(29[ X * A#$1 7a294* ZF\D A())(29[i ;21a :26;)4: ;< CDEC 12EFD X ]CD A())(29i 94132$% :#1# B$2A CDD]. *(9@4 1a49 wWDf (9 @4)) 1234$* Z#9: #**2@(#14: A#96B#@16$(90[i :#1# @4914$ 4A;2:(4: 494$0< CDD]'_V +IJ? 84A(T?996#) Q($4)4** J9:6*1$< 86$b4<_W 29DAJ? "96D. lIa4 J914$941 2B Ia(90*z JA7#@1 29 "4:(@#) +#$4.m "#< C. CDEF_\ "(@a#4) 41 #). l&)#941#$:8BFD R CDEC__ &&+AC9D. lIa4 J914$941 2B Ia(90*z 94c1 3#b4.m 84A(@2 L4*4#$@a. "#< EW. CDEF_` &3+. .;A?GlD AC=G:8 B? 8;9 D9CA:B?@>:8BF A?@>D8FH . e694 CDEC`D U2*129 +29*6)1(90 5$267 8"?LI,Li lIa4 $#7(: (9@$4#*4 (9 1$#BB(@ b2)6A4 3()) 94@4**(1#14 3($4)4** 94132$% @#7#@(1< 670$#:4* #9: #:271(29 2B

B26$1aT0494$#1(29 ZV5[ SI, 94132$%*'m P ;61 #61a2$* @)#(A TT l,BB(@(49@< (A7$2b4A491*. a234b4$. #$4 4c74@14: 12 )234$ 1a4 494$0< @29*6A4: 74$69(1 2B A2;()4 1$#BB(@.m`E J,,, I$#9*#@1(29*. CDEEi "#$@6* Q4):29. +I- ?)@#14)TS6@491. CDEEi Ia(4$$< ^)4(9. a4#: 2B 0$449 $4*4#$@a. ?)@#14)TS6@491 U4)) S#;*'`C &2)% . &E9:8FA: %9;A:E9 29CG?@N 4EBKGE LBF9:GD8 8;FB>J; UXZX R -@12;4$ CDEE ZCDD4\ ,K*[i @#)@6)#1(29 sED% A()4*qb4a(@)4 s D'W %QaqA('`F Q2$): U#9%. !AF +FG?D=BF8 !?@ &?9FJH &LLA:A9?:H R UXTU `V U2*129 +29*6)1(90 5$267 8"?LI,L`W /#1#@4914$ /@ .BC=>8A?J G?@ 1>D8GA?GKAEA8H . CDEC= l,94$0< 6*4 12 1$#9*A(1 :#1# ;413449 6*4$* #9: *4$b4$* 3#* 921 A2:4)4: (9 :41#()' pN234b4$p :#1#T(9149*(b4 Z@29*6A4$[ #77)(@#1(29*. *6@a #* A6*(@ :239)2#: 2$ b(:42 *1$4#A(90. p @291$(;614* # *(09(B(@#91 *a#$4 12 1a4 2b4$#))B2217$(91 #9: $4d6($4* A2$4 (9T:471a #9#)?9N +;9 ,A@@9? &?9FJH .BD8 $L 2AJA8GE 5>DA: .B?D>C=8AB?. U#@a I4@a92)20< $472$1 B2$ "6*(@I#9%=l*1$4#A(90 #9 #);6A 2b4$ 1a4 (914$941 C] 1(A4* @#9 6*4 A2$4 494$0< 1a#9 1a4 A#96B#@16$(90 #9: 7$2:6@1(29 2B (1* +/ 4d6(b#)491mED\ 8441a#$#A 41 #). 1;A==A?J 8B 18F9GCA?JN (D 8;AD D;AL8 JF99?Q 0?AI9FDA8H BL 5GDDG:;>D988D 29=8 BL .BC=>89F 1:A9?:9 ED] ,?LIN 34;*(14= ,94$0< ?3#$4 L#:(2 #9: 94I32$% 14@N92)20(4*'ED_ ?;:6)%#B( 41 #). ,94$0< ,BB(@(49@< 2B N414$2049426* +4))6)#$ >4132$%*= ? L4b(43. cB>F?GE BL !==EA9@ 1:A9?:9D. ?606*1 DE. CDECED` U)4(@a4$. l? 86$04 (9 8A#)) +4)) 8(14*.m (&&& 1=9:8F>C. e#96#$< CDEFEED ?;:6)%#B( 41 #)EEE Q4))4$ #9: UQ22:@2@%. (?89F?98 +FGLLA: &P:;G?J9N 5GFb98 29I9EB=C9?8D G?@ OBEA:H .;GEE9?J9D. -,+/ /(0(1#) ,@292AF +;G8 )B>E@?l8 2A9 EEF . J,?. -AJ;8D -GKB>FdD -BD8R OBEA:A9D LBF &?9FJH

rapport mark mills - cloud begins with coal

Documents