remedial investigation/feasibility study (ri/fs) scoping ... · site spocuic stntignj:hy ....
TRANSCRIPT
PJllllDIB SKilJIIGB Ylllgt SUI US BP A JBI W ~ JIJ 68~1-7250
ASSDHIIIJ JIJ 141-1Ll4 1111S SIDllll
MDBl 17 1917
US ZPA JBaiCif I ID[QJNUJJ6JDIIOI
~ by Dao srvic Inc-middotshyIa leCI1rmlogy Inc auzt Nw Jvj
I Introcbtia1of~
II lgtqlOTdod Sit JIJtory ond lthrcngtlogy of EYw1to
III Sit OOnetOrizoticn
IV Todlnical Cllta oep Egtdtirq gtMqont tD xdiat ~ lctlcn ord lloloticn ~~tlagt
- shyv Prelillinuy -lrq of ~ TodngtlOIJIbull for hulbillty study shy
IYaluotial ond Agtl~illty of ToaroolOIJI-
IV Riak ~ IUd oaaial of ARIiclblbull or Ralvant IUd
--lAta~ VII ~Plan wd Schdlle far qcent_a)_ ~ 1nvbullti911tim
ord hulbillty study
VIII Potmtial far~ Actim
IX lllpl~cn of Uty llolotlcn Plan
x ~-len
------- NOTICE If tho fll10 Image Ia le11 clear than thla notice It Ia due to tht PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORDof the documtnt
PIS002
middot-middot
-SOl--Bita --Bitambllty-~olshy
-uary 1970 - Ilaquobq Air raroo -middot - MECXI1tncta Avm c Brooln JR (eloctrioalCDitnctar) _on nplac tmo old tnlwf~ (1940a) trta the Ia- a1tnl -tbq - c ~ lccal oolvoqo blou-a on often trarwforn tar tr if blau-~u--
bull ~ trarwfonuw ~ trca bue~ 1979 tnNprlod -tum (llgtillod) or ~ of cJeloctric fluid s 41ntled
- MoiJw lEI cel1od by eloctrWal
-middotmiddot~ cxnarn1ng McJticnol cello - by otbon inYol-~~~gtillmiddot
) illogol ~ of dleloctric fluid
Jprill080 - - lEI agtllocta 01111 anal~ shy(2) ocil 0011gt1bull ord - Aroclor 1260 (Fal) orwita in -otntiorw of 30000 -d 58000 PPImiddot
- MoiJw lEI agtllocto odlliticnol ocil on ~tar (ourfoco wtar) _1 - (3) -1- ltDlfim tho _of Aroclar 1260 and trichl~ in ocll ~ Aroclar 1260 _ intho -of tho---shy00111bullmiddot
Soptar 1981 - Jpril 1982 - - lEI oatocto Lor1rq ~ finiuclal -~for ~~ CCI1tilwo 1Jtt_cy cxntact
- ra cxnbt8 aita inlpecticra anlMay 1982 oollecta toxr u MDPlbullmiddot Analysis indioat Aroclor 1260 cxna1tntiaw ~to 29000 pprr
shy
- B nctifibull Maine tEP that ~ SalWIJI Yard bullitbull hM riwd a HRS
-lll82
Soon or 39 61 juotiryiJq ito ireluaim en thll HPL in ocrtc 1982
~1982 - MaU tiP cap -gtill arM (95 X 100) with ooil ani 10 1111 po1ywthyl tD provont infiltnticn tna ~ CDltD1nltim
ICaith 1983 - EPA _u that IUIROOO clovolop JWtP to MEW u bMU for lB ooopirq
_ lllBl - ~to -1 Action (IliA) authariMd by EPA Roqicn IliA Authoriutim mitt to Dshy~-Divioicn
- EPA ani aixa1trlcton -UiMd tDbullitbull putially datU ~ of -~y1046
taw of CD1Ia1Mtod ooil shyirq 50 liP tol)Ot vollraquo ani llhlR-1 tD- __ City NY
- trial ~ ot bullite taJowl for orrioo of-ani -u -(CDR)
July 1985 - IUIFlT - Tedlniool ~w Doat (lUI) tD initioto bull llOIoticn ~~era at the bullita
- lliiFlT Cltlrlbto rint ~irq ran~ of u afaoa wter wd plltable woll ~yz port~ by ClP or by IUIFlT in holraquoo ocr-Urq
- IUInT Cltlrlbto ai1IIW)in ani ootoblUMo oaqgtlo grid of tha oito soan ran of oaqgtlirq of ooilo gron wtarallfece wter ard patable wall wtar ~ ard ~ inshy
- -t1njo _ PA ani IUIFlT 1shy tD cxrclulo that - SOlvage
-lll85-llllylll86 -middot Yard Site t not Utable far dlllletial rraa NPL _uy c11rwto IUIFlT tD ~ cno Wtional oaoplirq ran tD ciofino - or ~icbll COItainatim an plpaae a riold octivitibull --ry npgtrt
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
I Introcbtia1of~
II lgtqlOTdod Sit JIJtory ond lthrcngtlogy of EYw1to
III Sit OOnetOrizoticn
IV Todlnical Cllta oep Egtdtirq gtMqont tD xdiat ~ lctlcn ord lloloticn ~~tlagt
- shyv Prelillinuy -lrq of ~ TodngtlOIJIbull for hulbillty study shy
IYaluotial ond Agtl~illty of ToaroolOIJI-
IV Riak ~ IUd oaaial of ARIiclblbull or Ralvant IUd
--lAta~ VII ~Plan wd Schdlle far qcent_a)_ ~ 1nvbullti911tim
ord hulbillty study
VIII Potmtial far~ Actim
IX lllpl~cn of Uty llolotlcn Plan
x ~-len
------- NOTICE If tho fll10 Image Ia le11 clear than thla notice It Ia due to tht PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORDof the documtnt
PIS002
middot-middot
-SOl--Bita --Bitambllty-~olshy
-uary 1970 - Ilaquobq Air raroo -middot - MECXI1tncta Avm c Brooln JR (eloctrioalCDitnctar) _on nplac tmo old tnlwf~ (1940a) trta the Ia- a1tnl -tbq - c ~ lccal oolvoqo blou-a on often trarwforn tar tr if blau-~u--
bull ~ trarwfonuw ~ trca bue~ 1979 tnNprlod -tum (llgtillod) or ~ of cJeloctric fluid s 41ntled
- MoiJw lEI cel1od by eloctrWal
-middotmiddot~ cxnarn1ng McJticnol cello - by otbon inYol-~~~gtillmiddot
) illogol ~ of dleloctric fluid
Jprill080 - - lEI agtllocta 01111 anal~ shy(2) ocil 0011gt1bull ord - Aroclor 1260 (Fal) orwita in -otntiorw of 30000 -d 58000 PPImiddot
- MoiJw lEI agtllocto odlliticnol ocil on ~tar (ourfoco wtar) _1 - (3) -1- ltDlfim tho _of Aroclar 1260 and trichl~ in ocll ~ Aroclar 1260 _ intho -of tho---shy00111bullmiddot
Soptar 1981 - Jpril 1982 - - lEI oatocto Lor1rq ~ finiuclal -~for ~~ CCI1tilwo 1Jtt_cy cxntact
- ra cxnbt8 aita inlpecticra anlMay 1982 oollecta toxr u MDPlbullmiddot Analysis indioat Aroclor 1260 cxna1tntiaw ~to 29000 pprr
shy
- B nctifibull Maine tEP that ~ SalWIJI Yard bullitbull hM riwd a HRS
-lll82
Soon or 39 61 juotiryiJq ito ireluaim en thll HPL in ocrtc 1982
~1982 - MaU tiP cap -gtill arM (95 X 100) with ooil ani 10 1111 po1ywthyl tD provont infiltnticn tna ~ CDltD1nltim
ICaith 1983 - EPA _u that IUIROOO clovolop JWtP to MEW u bMU for lB ooopirq
_ lllBl - ~to -1 Action (IliA) authariMd by EPA Roqicn IliA Authoriutim mitt to Dshy~-Divioicn
- EPA ani aixa1trlcton -UiMd tDbullitbull putially datU ~ of -~y1046
taw of CD1Ia1Mtod ooil shyirq 50 liP tol)Ot vollraquo ani llhlR-1 tD- __ City NY
- trial ~ ot bullite taJowl for orrioo of-ani -u -(CDR)
July 1985 - IUIFlT - Tedlniool ~w Doat (lUI) tD initioto bull llOIoticn ~~era at the bullita
- lliiFlT Cltlrlbto rint ~irq ran~ of u afaoa wter wd plltable woll ~yz port~ by ClP or by IUIFlT in holraquoo ocr-Urq
- IUInT Cltlrlbto ai1IIW)in ani ootoblUMo oaqgtlo grid of tha oito soan ran of oaqgtlirq of ooilo gron wtarallfece wter ard patable wall wtar ~ ard ~ inshy
- -t1njo _ PA ani IUIFlT 1shy tD cxrclulo that - SOlvage
-lll85-llllylll86 -middot Yard Site t not Utable far dlllletial rraa NPL _uy c11rwto IUIFlT tD ~ cno Wtional oaoplirq ran tD ciofino - or ~icbll COItainatim an plpaae a riold octivitibull --ry npgtrt
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
------- NOTICE If tho fll10 Image Ia le11 clear than thla notice It Ia due to tht PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORDof the documtnt
PIS002
middot-middot
-SOl--Bita --Bitambllty-~olshy
-uary 1970 - Ilaquobq Air raroo -middot - MECXI1tncta Avm c Brooln JR (eloctrioalCDitnctar) _on nplac tmo old tnlwf~ (1940a) trta the Ia- a1tnl -tbq - c ~ lccal oolvoqo blou-a on often trarwforn tar tr if blau-~u--
bull ~ trarwfonuw ~ trca bue~ 1979 tnNprlod -tum (llgtillod) or ~ of cJeloctric fluid s 41ntled
- MoiJw lEI cel1od by eloctrWal
-middotmiddot~ cxnarn1ng McJticnol cello - by otbon inYol-~~~gtillmiddot
) illogol ~ of dleloctric fluid
Jprill080 - - lEI agtllocta 01111 anal~ shy(2) ocil 0011gt1bull ord - Aroclor 1260 (Fal) orwita in -otntiorw of 30000 -d 58000 PPImiddot
- MoiJw lEI agtllocto odlliticnol ocil on ~tar (ourfoco wtar) _1 - (3) -1- ltDlfim tho _of Aroclar 1260 and trichl~ in ocll ~ Aroclar 1260 _ intho -of tho---shy00111bullmiddot
Soptar 1981 - Jpril 1982 - - lEI oatocto Lor1rq ~ finiuclal -~for ~~ CCI1tilwo 1Jtt_cy cxntact
- ra cxnbt8 aita inlpecticra anlMay 1982 oollecta toxr u MDPlbullmiddot Analysis indioat Aroclor 1260 cxna1tntiaw ~to 29000 pprr
shy
- B nctifibull Maine tEP that ~ SalWIJI Yard bullitbull hM riwd a HRS
-lll82
Soon or 39 61 juotiryiJq ito ireluaim en thll HPL in ocrtc 1982
~1982 - MaU tiP cap -gtill arM (95 X 100) with ooil ani 10 1111 po1ywthyl tD provont infiltnticn tna ~ CDltD1nltim
ICaith 1983 - EPA _u that IUIROOO clovolop JWtP to MEW u bMU for lB ooopirq
_ lllBl - ~to -1 Action (IliA) authariMd by EPA Roqicn IliA Authoriutim mitt to Dshy~-Divioicn
- EPA ani aixa1trlcton -UiMd tDbullitbull putially datU ~ of -~y1046
taw of CD1Ia1Mtod ooil shyirq 50 liP tol)Ot vollraquo ani llhlR-1 tD- __ City NY
- trial ~ ot bullite taJowl for orrioo of-ani -u -(CDR)
July 1985 - IUIFlT - Tedlniool ~w Doat (lUI) tD initioto bull llOIoticn ~~era at the bullita
- lliiFlT Cltlrlbto rint ~irq ran~ of u afaoa wter wd plltable woll ~yz port~ by ClP or by IUIFlT in holraquoo ocr-Urq
- IUInT Cltlrlbto ai1IIW)in ani ootoblUMo oaqgtlo grid of tha oito soan ran of oaqgtlirq of ooilo gron wtarallfece wter ard patable wall wtar ~ ard ~ inshy
- -t1njo _ PA ani IUIFlT 1shy tD cxrclulo that - SOlvage
-lll85-llllylll86 -middot Yard Site t not Utable far dlllletial rraa NPL _uy c11rwto IUIFlT tD ~ cno Wtional oaoplirq ran tD ciofino - or ~icbll COItainatim an plpaae a riold octivitibull --ry npgtrt
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-SOl--Bita --Bitambllty-~olshy
-uary 1970 - Ilaquobq Air raroo -middot - MECXI1tncta Avm c Brooln JR (eloctrioalCDitnctar) _on nplac tmo old tnlwf~ (1940a) trta the Ia- a1tnl -tbq - c ~ lccal oolvoqo blou-a on often trarwforn tar tr if blau-~u--
bull ~ trarwfonuw ~ trca bue~ 1979 tnNprlod -tum (llgtillod) or ~ of cJeloctric fluid s 41ntled
- MoiJw lEI cel1od by eloctrWal
-middotmiddot~ cxnarn1ng McJticnol cello - by otbon inYol-~~~gtillmiddot
) illogol ~ of dleloctric fluid
Jprill080 - - lEI agtllocta 01111 anal~ shy(2) ocil 0011gt1bull ord - Aroclor 1260 (Fal) orwita in -otntiorw of 30000 -d 58000 PPImiddot
- MoiJw lEI agtllocto odlliticnol ocil on ~tar (ourfoco wtar) _1 - (3) -1- ltDlfim tho _of Aroclar 1260 and trichl~ in ocll ~ Aroclar 1260 _ intho -of tho---shy00111bullmiddot
Soptar 1981 - Jpril 1982 - - lEI oatocto Lor1rq ~ finiuclal -~for ~~ CCI1tilwo 1Jtt_cy cxntact
- ra cxnbt8 aita inlpecticra anlMay 1982 oollecta toxr u MDPlbullmiddot Analysis indioat Aroclor 1260 cxna1tntiaw ~to 29000 pprr
shy
- B nctifibull Maine tEP that ~ SalWIJI Yard bullitbull hM riwd a HRS
-lll82
Soon or 39 61 juotiryiJq ito ireluaim en thll HPL in ocrtc 1982
~1982 - MaU tiP cap -gtill arM (95 X 100) with ooil ani 10 1111 po1ywthyl tD provont infiltnticn tna ~ CDltD1nltim
ICaith 1983 - EPA _u that IUIROOO clovolop JWtP to MEW u bMU for lB ooopirq
_ lllBl - ~to -1 Action (IliA) authariMd by EPA Roqicn IliA Authoriutim mitt to Dshy~-Divioicn
- EPA ani aixa1trlcton -UiMd tDbullitbull putially datU ~ of -~y1046
taw of CD1Ia1Mtod ooil shyirq 50 liP tol)Ot vollraquo ani llhlR-1 tD- __ City NY
- trial ~ ot bullite taJowl for orrioo of-ani -u -(CDR)
July 1985 - IUIFlT - Tedlniool ~w Doat (lUI) tD initioto bull llOIoticn ~~era at the bullita
- lliiFlT Cltlrlbto rint ~irq ran~ of u afaoa wter wd plltable woll ~yz port~ by ClP or by IUIFlT in holraquoo ocr-Urq
- IUInT Cltlrlbto ai1IIW)in ani ootoblUMo oaqgtlo grid of tha oito soan ran of oaqgtlirq of ooilo gron wtarallfece wter ard patable wall wtar ~ ard ~ inshy
- -t1njo _ PA ani IUIFlT 1shy tD cxrclulo that - SOlvage
-lll85-llllylll86 -middot Yard Site t not Utable far dlllletial rraa NPL _uy c11rwto IUIFlT tD ~ cno Wtional oaoplirq ran tD ciofino - or ~icbll COItainatim an plpaae a riold octivitibull --ry npgtrt
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
shy
- B nctifibull Maine tEP that ~ SalWIJI Yard bullitbull hM riwd a HRS
-lll82
Soon or 39 61 juotiryiJq ito ireluaim en thll HPL in ocrtc 1982
~1982 - MaU tiP cap -gtill arM (95 X 100) with ooil ani 10 1111 po1ywthyl tD provont infiltnticn tna ~ CDltD1nltim
ICaith 1983 - EPA _u that IUIROOO clovolop JWtP to MEW u bMU for lB ooopirq
_ lllBl - ~to -1 Action (IliA) authariMd by EPA Roqicn IliA Authoriutim mitt to Dshy~-Divioicn
- EPA ani aixa1trlcton -UiMd tDbullitbull putially datU ~ of -~y1046
taw of CD1Ia1Mtod ooil shyirq 50 liP tol)Ot vollraquo ani llhlR-1 tD- __ City NY
- trial ~ ot bullite taJowl for orrioo of-ani -u -(CDR)
July 1985 - IUIFlT - Tedlniool ~w Doat (lUI) tD initioto bull llOIoticn ~~era at the bullita
- lliiFlT Cltlrlbto rint ~irq ran~ of u afaoa wter wd plltable woll ~yz port~ by ClP or by IUIFlT in holraquoo ocr-Urq
- IUInT Cltlrlbto ai1IIW)in ani ootoblUMo oaqgtlo grid of tha oito soan ran of oaqgtlirq of ooilo gron wtarallfece wter ard patable wall wtar ~ ard ~ inshy
- -t1njo _ PA ani IUIFlT 1shy tD cxrclulo that - SOlvage
-lll85-llllylll86 -middot Yard Site t not Utable far dlllletial rraa NPL _uy c11rwto IUIFlT tD ~ cno Wtional oaoplirq ran tD ciofino - or ~icbll COItainatim an plpaae a riold octivitibull --ry npgtrt
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
llly1916 - IUlPll - third -llzq rtUlllof u rcantter~wa~ater
- IUlPll CD1tncta IOlrVW)IzqAult)uot 1916 --middot ~tDIOlrVW)oitoon1---middot lilY 1917 - RfM-m tooo -i--lt -iPt 148-1134 to ontJct an RIPSinYooti9otiltln ot tho oito
- _m tooo cxnbto intcna1 --m _i on1lgtooirw pnpntiltln for fat1101 oocplzq tlzq aa~l7 1987
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
A Pint Soqgtlirq Jbrd ~20 1985
Blaloll to obtain agtrficW on tlrlaoo -1bull to ~ anal shyof PCB CU1taainltim or other CXIltallinatim awite
tyrtw of SlplM an sectW)lt Mldia
Spplbull Ipoundqtiqw See attadwd ap
1rpM of Iabgntqy AnllfM=
Ton (10) SoU (2) surtaoo Watar (2) Gmnl Watar (~lttable Wall)
siyolatilw an1 PCIVPasticidas (al) ~ Fa and lnot9anic too (inshy_)
Did1-shy124 - trict1~ (ax 367000 Rio) AroclCl 1260 (ax 500000 ~)
44 - [IE
44 - tED
Aroclor 1260 in ei~ of tan-lshy-141ala of dieltric fluid ~~ita ard IIMl alrleoa Pelticld in -u-faoa wtr _ (lOll lOYal) Aroclor 1260 detectMS across wade-lab ClCfltalldnatial in ss-os ss-oe SS-o5R (nplicate) detects 14 dictll- on di-n-bJtylphshythalata SS-o5 does 1J2t ss-oe irdicat MVerBl Mllli-voca DOt~ In orry other Plbull (fi~ phthalat ~)
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
2-3
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
tyblr pt SOJI2lbull SOpplbull Midibull
amp-1bull tpatiqw s- attaclwd ~middot
1lw pt INxmrtmy AnllfiM
Q=prde gntirwf frMlaquoltt
pegrw pt Site ominatiql
Pitty-fivo (55) Soil 1tlolr (4) Sedimont 1tlolr (4) Qrleoo watc IIlaquogt (2) ltlralRMtc Six (6) Tep WOtc (~gttable Well)
VOA U-wlatile ard ~ci- irorqanic iaw (CJgt) 1lt11 irorqanic icno (in-hcAJM)
ltrltXhl~ ( 56 Rigtl
Twtnchl~ 14 -clidgtlshy12 -didl~ 124 - tridU~ (llllX 12000 Rigtl 44 - liE 44 - IrD 44 -wr Arcclor 1260 (ax 1400000 sp)
MCdft)B)
Phthalat 33 shydictll-idono
-iamplamplo of dielectric fluid ~ craite in u at ltiepiM trca me to eiflt feet Dictll-- -1 in -m portion oo lirg grid - to bo dgratirgAroclor U60 in 23 ail Nq)lbull fral thne to eiltllt feet in depth Aroclor 1260 in N1iment atmp1e of cnoitA pcrd (9100 Rgtl surface wter eaplbull clean ~ for tnce of Hg
---CD1talllinatAd withctUorcbenzera no PCBII trace of -otic~ Tap wter clean except for ~ and
- the 2 ug1 ML
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-------of tho docuooont
IIOTlCE If the fllbull 1bullbull1bull 11 teu clear than thla PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notlco It lo duo to tho
middotmiddot-middot JIIR)Ij -- Siifld
31S fiiNA 30yen111yen8 II3113Nd lllel bull ~-CIIII10II CIN003B
SNOUvxJl ndiWS
bullbull -------- a a --
-__
_ nt~Ubullbull ~
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
------- ltOTICE t1 the 11111 lbullbulltbull lo le11 cloor tllan thlo PINETTES SALVAGE YARD ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD notice It le due to the
of thl dOCUIOIRI PIS002
bullbull-~ anobull~ lllill 0IIIIA 3DVA1W8 8lUJ3Nicl
----middot -l 1B110L00-C1M10t1 CIN0038 8NCIUYJ01 31oMYS
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
--
oyoc PntUbull Lob oontallllnation by tho foll~~ bla (2~1) prtllalata di - thy1prthalata di-n-blt)1Pgttllalata 33 - dichl~icWw Aroclor 1260 -s In oodlmont M~~ple ttl in varyirq ~ OWitntiarw in nplicate uplbull Data CXJUld Rlt validated Pield ocntudnatim allo paible to agtp1aln ot tho~ 1latadabow
c~ May 19-23 1986
~ To ctgttaln UUtianol onolyticol data - to dataislno tho 1ataru W vertical CICUnt ot PCB ~tion t tha bullita
~ (18) Soil lllc(2)shyIOlr(4)ClrcllrdAtar
Olsi-volKilbull ~ (~ Q aUy I vo s-1-Volatile ~(-)
Clgtl-Trldll- Tol-shyMithyl- Qllori6t
cutgtcn Dllfdo 1nrW - 12 - didlloroethane 0lorofom 2 - butanltno 1 11 - trichloratharw bull--Y1-2-~ 1 3- 1 4- ard 1 2shydichl==--shy124- tricbl~ aztylblnzy1prtllalata di - n - buty1Pgttllalata 4 4 - liE 4 - rot 4 4 - IIJ)
Arclor 1260
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
bullbullbull
l
2-16
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
QlqrM or Site QriMinltim
opIOCpnhlbull
au~ in five 5) aanplbull (3 to Rlbl Dioloctric fluill u tu DlctlorctlZOnO in fall (4) ~- (56 to 1300 Rlbl 1 2 4- trichlorotZMlll in five (5) ~- (141gt-3600 Rlbl ~ (ogricWturol -) Arclor 1260 UO to 1300000 Rlbl In oollto No --1-YOlatUbull in -1imlnt-1shysJyolatllbull trace s-ticidel In~shy
~ 11011 onal~ cuoplotoly nj-=tad tauM of -=-uiVII bgtlcllnr tl- (41 cloyo OIOV) All VCCa ~ WA ~tad Field bank u cxm-inatad with _ lobntory CgtCI1talllinont _t
ampgtrin fiold lwdlinshy- CXIItalnonto
cxn-inltim bJt nplicate ~--~middotshymiddot
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-Sal-Yard SitBit~
_ of IIEIP1r - IRI DIIICluoiaw
IRA ~tul in ~Jn) ~ly CXI1taainat 11 thcul Arolor 1260 an1 vari~ d1~ till cdst within bull 07 acr ana
ot -shy --thin 50 p Dopth of IXlntaalnotiCIgt only partially clofiiWI ooxiJuo dopth of ~~- olrJt (8) f- (ol +469 IISL) shycxntaainlltim by Arolclor 1260 a 11Jcely to cdst teuM of peroolatim parM~tim or diftuaim
xtorolly oontiJugtlo cloy loyor t1gta41t to oodat -=- tho oit eervin u an ~le barrie for vertical Arcclor 1260 lli9rotimiddot JU1zontal algroti of ~ ia -blo
) aou Q1~ (ro- di- trl- oonta1Mtion tUl awita
PlfticiIM (44 -laquo1 44 -mr 414 -axgt ~bull ttribltm to llioltural -middot
Jlo Ja9oniao- - nonel ~ felt Jig (035p) TypioollOiliJII 002-ltgt2 ppo in ournuding lo
~-auwt ~1bull WlamplyiJI indicate ID vocbulla _ ~-olaWbull czqonic CXIIIJCUo (ptrtholo-) dotoctod Aroclelt 1260 bullY llo prt (volldatiCIgt pltdgtlbull) bull
IOirfoco tr 11bull irdlcot ~cida Aldrin prt No IISL OlaquoJUgtlc ~ in GoMlnor crk tbcugt tnoo _ of Jig prt llolw ICL IAYol felt Hl
varlru VOCa -1-VOCa ard ~cidea in qrab lallplbull of CJlOlfd tr (taco tr) in tiaw~borirgo ltgtlt oeopofcliodwgo us Pcltmt1al fer aigmtian aita
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-ROble lloll shy
No Aroclor 1260 CE Chl~ dlltected low 1-1 s-tJcilila (bullbullbull -mr) In~ clonoo (loOrtl-t of opUl ora) lbdcipal w11 hod 111 1ove1 - 3 u11 111 prably moted to 091icultunl - (fnlicido)
JIIVD-1111shy
nwtoll _-tor ocnitarirq U In - to doflno flOII _u-
ldYonoo otntiqroplc lxrlngo to __ ord ~middot~ continlaloly
No Wtiono1 90CP~Pical imootqotaw
Piald u ot GC to ~ alllllbullmiddot ~ctt-=ticr~ Uait Span ~(col~ 1C p1WK ~ ard MrO air - _ lxrlngo ___ _~rq dCCWit -rq oyot
Belocted ~- IIIDild bo onolfMII rcc Diaodno
)
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
Si te spocUic Stntignjhy
lgtlCXniOlidotacl Hater~
thi- of oqdforsfoqdtardognin aize d18tribJtion (clay NJd gravel) ~otubJntim
FnctUrod ~ artooo
clopth on thishy-ofshyeydrwlic augtcoticn vith 0Wlyilq shy- typo on - of -thorilq
~-
-ll)olrolshytmcnoolidat-1 Hater~
Mturatd thi~ tinod ourficW oqdfor (pudwcl) -1-oonfinod or cDifinod oqdfen now clincticn flow velcxity eydrwlic anlgtctivity oqdfor ~dltgtargo arou ourfaco wter~ter ~ dividoo aigraticn potbeyo (~ogic f turoo)
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
YA
RD
R
EC
OR
D
----
iiOTUif~=~
loiiM
clu
r-tllll
oot1ce It It M
to tho P
INE
TT
ES
SA
LV
AG
E
AD
MIN
IST
RA
TIV
Eof tilt decu
nt
~ II il
1 I~i
J H
Jl Jl
~i ~-
It 111
111 I Imiddot
IIi Iff I ill lil
jlmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotJmiddotmiddotmiddotjmiddotmiddotmiddot j
(
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
PINETTES SALVAGE FEASIBILITY STUDY
PRELIMINARY SCOPING
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ACTIONS
No Action Libullited Action (1) Soil Remdiation Only (2) Groundwater Re11adiation Only Coeplete Re111adiation of Soil and Groundwater
RESPONSE OBJECTIVES
Reduce hUIIampn health risks fr011 exposure to PCh and other contuinanta to acceptable l evels (10-bull to 10middot ranae)
Reduce threat of environmental daaa fro PCh and other eontuinanu to acceptable levels
Prevent bulliaration of PCBs and other eontuinanta to other anviron~~antal media and additional exposure points (aa Aroonook River)
C011ply with federal atata and local AltARs
Provide a perbullanent coat- middot tfactiva solution to the contuination preblebull at the site
RESPONSE CATEGORIES
Ko Action Source Control (1) Containment (2) Treatment 11anaaeeent of Hiaution (1) Contairw~ent (2) Trutmant
REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
TSCA naulationbull prohibit land dbpoul of 11ateriab containinamp IDOU than SOO ppm PCS
PCBbull an included in California Lilt wastes recently restricted under RCRA Land Disposal Ban-land disposal of materials conlidarad RCRA wastes that also contain more than SO ppm PCBs is proh i bited a s of July 7 1987
232Sd081487
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
Undar Land Dilpoul Ban land dhpoul of soils and debris containina 50-500 ppl and re110vad undar CERCI Sections 104 and 106 will be perbullittad until Nova~abar 7 1988
UNUSUAUUNIQUE FEATURES OF PINETTES SALVAGE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMJmiddot
bull Site location bullaku costs of transportation for off-site traatbullant ~middot disposal vary hiah but abo contributes aianificantly to ~ tJ obilbationdaiiObilization costs for on-sita trut1nnt Conlidarina ~ this tradeoff will bbull a bullbullJor componut of tb fusibility study (will ba stronaly dependent on the aount of bullbullterial requirinamp trut11ant)
Groundwnar aituation is essentially a coa~plata unknown-may ba coe~plataly uncontaminated due to confininamp layer and low 110bility of PCBI or 111ay contain a tromiddotphua system (oilwatar) that has arutly anhancad the 1110bility of PCBI and resulted in aianificant miaration
Problabull is apparently confined to PCBs and chlorobanzanasbullthus 11any sinalamiddotstap innovative tachnoloaiu for PCB traatbullant bullay ba affective at the site (La c011plex trutbullant trains for re1110val dutruction of multiple contaminants are unlikely
Hany innovative cost-cortpatitiva tachnoloaiu are availaoh for traat11ant of PCB-contuinatad materials at the bench scala however bullany of tlasa tachnoloaiu have not baan pilot bulltastad Jntorbullation fr011 currant pilot testa in Raaion I (New Bedford) and Raai n II (Wide Buch) should ba available for Pinettas FS
A ver) Uaitad nu11bar of facilitiu are currently pn1dttad for PCB diaposl either by incineration or landfillina (preliminary uti111ata - 3bull4 incineration facilities 3middot4 land disposal facilities)
POTENTIAL REMEDIAL ALTERNATIVES
Source Control (1) Contain~~ant bull Cappina
bull Cappina wSubsurfaca Barrier bull Iaobilization - Solidification - Excavation wOff-lita Disposal
(2) Trutbullant bull Incineration (4 options) bull Direct Treat111ent (4 options) - Solvent Extraction (l options) bull InmiddotSitu Vitrification
Hanaauant of Hiaration (l) Contailllllant - Cappina wSubsurface Barrier
bull Plu11a Capture (2) Treatment - OilWater Separation
bull Carbon Adsorption (water only) - UV Otenation (water only) bull Direct Traat111ent - Incineration
232Sd081487
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
middotlmiddot
All trutllent alternativu (wexcaption of in-aitu vitrification) i nvolve excavation - in-aitu tnet11ant bullathoda for PCImiddotcontalllinetad 111teriah an not aanually 1vailabh
PRELIMINARY SCREENING
Tnatbullant tachnoloaiu 111ay be classified into l aroupa
(1) Comucidly available proven taehnoloaiaa (2) Pilotbulltutad uchnoloaiu (3) Banch-acala tachnoloaiu that have not bn fiald-testad
~ ~achnoloaiu could be alibullinatad in praliainary acreenina on tha ~Jmiddot nil of pilot-tutina (La tachnoloaiu that are available only at1TV h bench scala would be ali11inated)
232Sd081487
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
)
I 8 N
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
iOncEifnll=~ It leu oloor thu thlo PINETTcS SALVAGE YARD notice It 11 4u to tho ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
of the docubulltnt
lU~tAUe M(l 01 e j18lJaq
6up--lue -AI8J1-IID
8S881 MtllIU -OOd 0Sj8 IUOf l _6amp1 J lU-llaJllllfS
bullUJ 01 DlqtJJidd8 lOU_ lfMtl
pol8 1-oo f A18 Pifllo_lUOJ alfllb
bullraquobull~middot -t6ototq albullP 01
II lOS PlWbullIluoJ-~ IOJ p8l181Uftbulljj0
1-0JSUUl JOJ lUll 88~middot1D d
flMfJ8u middotseu 101
jnJIIISII Cjj8 1U810
bull qlftlfl UIGJ IIUaAO 18t6ot0U~l
IMtl0 Ol paltiMoJ USOJAIioeue-o
bull I Lal$ Dl CKI$
-ubullbulltmiddotDIil bull1~--01-J
finS IOlJt) bull000 [$ Ol 0001$
I t--NP) bull IMlS
bull061$ Dl fKI$
UOj ltJfjddt Still IOJ C6ot0Ull381
UOId 8 lOU It 1 1 J8Aatto0tt II I DS 111 1 p8ltjlOSII8
SJjUtlioO lltllO put 18~ ltootsep A C6otouHil bulltill
middot1etU -011uoJ bullt SJIOIl-bullbullIMI1 JO SSIIUIIA1~JJII ltq1 pue pell f11113U~3middot11-ueeq
lOU IIA UMtpOId UO jlleotlll bullst~lUO Zl middotlt Ul Hd 01 U~l SSIII 01 Sll st)j piiJilj)lll
Sllj 0318() middotslSIIl 11183S bullIIJUIICI Uj oedd l Uetl1 ISII SSII 01 tIIIW JO Uf p1111ns s bull 3-01
S IIII Hd-qos 01 SUOf11111UIIJU03
st)j 6ut3ftP_ JO lqadeJ ltlbullt1U111Gl bull3111 Z03 01
SJfue61o s nopbull~ez~ llttflO pue Sft)l JO UOf1ep fxO Uf S1 11S811
SljUI6JO 18410 put SQ)I J O UOlMUlSiitp
Uj SlPlSitl UOliPUIj UO~OM put OS Mfl
-oJ S IIW JO UQjllOUlltll llf spje JUUaue 3ftHKeOJn ltlll
middotJtUaua ~tuMultn pue uonbullt PbullI 111JOfAU11n o1
pesoclxa JtJsnoeue11ntS S n1x1bull lltl1 po~e peppe st -lO 8111~ IU81 6utxtbull
I 01UI tlftiS e se Plll _ SJjOS PllleUtbullbull1uoJ
bull(bull3111 IltU1011) IIICIIJeAe ale SIISSII3
-oul e3tOOOCI 1IMI10 middotst~luoel u-lt 101
paamp~ej-pue pue S1UIIjllllU ptJe S8-qOIIJbull JO UOjl
-ntos bull 1111 pe1~flt SjjOS pe1emiddotlfbullbull1U03bullX018()
bullsJtep _[ S tnb SSIIIOI middot1 Z8
01 1)811111 S I _n pue MIIIIllte 1snr bullPbull S OJ Jtllnjs
010lle_ 3 t CIOIOe Ue Ul j)ll3etd _ Sf lOS pe1autbullbullluo~-ueai)-Of9
1013elll PlltOj~ a U JO II-d-p e Ul 11311d 111bull1 (-JtIJnS OS JO
UOjlejlftSSagtd6ut1eetl bullspunoctoJ es~tql JO 11011
-ePJXO PjdeJ Uf 6ut1JftS pue (Srtl bull middot6middota) SltueUo letod-~ JO lt1tiCI111M
6utSeJUj 1UIIAJOS Jetocl-uou bull bull-JIICI 1bull4M
middotz~t gtllttl od 3 bull 1 113 WOqe POZjllliS_d pue ponettt~ Sf 1~1 1 111
Hlltt80pfCU
M3jUOSU1Jn
~middot~ j 111_1 middotmiddot~t6o09
(SSII301d (p11UOI)_ IIVOON middot middot 6middote1
uopeppco 1a1e bullbull3t1fJ~e6oJS bull~~
S lM)WWIX) SlAI13lntO JSMCUSJII JAiltMIIIJnv JAillfIUOtlV A~llt3 AIIYIII Nl]llt 10 JO NOJItiMgtSJO WIOJHJV JSNOoiS)II
UtlNIUV11V
CpenutluoJI SlAlttiiiiJtlV bulltVIOlNJIII JO raquotltoJS AWMINI lJIIIol
( )
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
0
)
I 8 N
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
bullbull -~ ~i ~~
tgtfi
~5
~rtjif
--middot ishy~~r~ ~87
L
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
iOTaifth-shy -thla Htlct It lo to tho PINETTES SALVAGE YARD
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD oftllo _t
S1UUJbullI1U03 IMlO pus ltrW (OO l SIP1111- 01
peltnb -ca 11111 HlSAS Mil Uf Pl11dl3 Ptnbtt snoeonbs
-uou JOPn 111~6 JO lUliDIl UOt11J6 t bull
IN011fP9S 1UIIIIcl pu t OI1~DI6 PI 11N fbull11U03
JO -middotqd M~l aJI11dl3 Ill Hltlts s6eutso p 1311Jntqnt
JO lklt_d 111MpUnGI6 bull
_lOA 10 t1t31101 tltl t Qa 131pel Anueushy
-otgtd 1au soo middot-u _ bullpu11016 tUUOljIOampf 6ut 131Jlt
Ill pus uotlllliJUt 6utZtbull tutbull Ill Aq uop
-LI6tbull luutbullnuo~ s1u--o4
S1U Inb t)Sl pue ~11bull pabulltooa llln tleuope1s pus bull 11qo Ut
Sllj)UIIItJJII pall SUo-a(l
middot-p S f1 31Jf3edSbullI1S (o 11 ~-_ US03 tnl~ 1~1 bull
3t6o1CUPlti4 _ 11103 WfO 3t6ot086 3tJtIINh IAUtll
bullliltbull uo puacl~ 01 060H$ Ill Spoofl-ISMtl
JO ltUO 6utCtddl 1S03 jllfdl3 JO ClttCIIIIJ liMU U OL6t 01 llt6$
UO tldo t oI1U03 bull~nos --s
01 (JIIUOJ1US 00 ll t QOII
Uf ljqllfiAI lljioj0Uif3el A6ot~raquoal UliMoOOd UO i lltlltUI MI I lbullt110
peltIOI-bullPmiddotIIW 1111- 1111~
bull1ua1uot n1bull t-Jol1S -11
QI 0006[ _ uet ltlln luau
middot-lf C1f-UII UO ltt_ SU II-P 113SJJIISQnS Slllllii -111SI
-puono~ll JO uorutndtushy113bull S IOoUI ikltctnd
JIIliiKHO-l middotsu tbull-P 11311J-nsqns IZI pua
6utcllllnd eaopuno~ll Ill 1stbullbull s uopdo OoloJ
eq 11311J- -qns Al t ltqa-otoci-O I bull pull dat pa~~cudda-AIllll bull JO lSfSU03 pjllOA bulllllSC$
bulluopdo 10-lUOt eunos bull sa IIAoqa PIKI I - 3SIIO
~ 01 S81nutbull ~ Sj SP IOS lllSSI -OJ -11 lt)UitPP Sitll
middot an1uect81 1~ 1 11 111 U0 t1)nJ1Sttp IIIUOiltPPII
JOJJIIqlaSIItCupouooes II 116n0-lll ss SUOSSshy
IIIliiOA bull6ampqxt bull p006 13 01 bullbull 8111
6ut tca-n bullstbullbull 8111 1o1oqe Go 113tlf-~11113 UOlSnQIIIOI 11131Jput l-lt3
tlllUOZI-IMt II OlU PltJ _ sttos pa1au tbullbullluot
U 1 aut3Ut UI IM Ca101111
middotct-Utbulll paIII-JU I 01 -bullttbulltbull nutnbLI 6ut
-ssa301cl stbullt-111_ middotuot1 x~po~d ISII Sllxlpal 11111
middot 111-118Uj pubull IIIJSUIII1 lllltlj poo6 SffAO- d paq JO
IIWjOA 1t6J111 middot uot130lJ1S -119 a 111tdlo3 IOJ 1~nq -o~bullubull ua ~o~6n0-111 ssacl
J itqlllftl3 Sttt1 _J SUOjS middot Stbullll Sno8SII) middot middota811S bullbull6 1uq bull ut pepuitdsns
11111111 -tnuaJ6 1-IIUI
Lftll iiOPiiZtZ
e~n1drJ
1U-111UO)bull 1U-111UD) UOtliiI~IM JO
1t111tdlaoJ 1U-11611UIIN
IP11U03) 1U1IIilljbull
IP 1U03) 10-luoJ UOf11118U fIU I IIUI05
Aata)]llf)
AIJWI N IIJ JO JO NOllllllt)$]0 WIOlHlllll ]SiiiOIIISlllll UIONNOCI 1500 Ol1YW11Sl SlAU)lf80 lSIIIOIIISlll lAtlWH]lTt lAilWHU11f
U~YUIf
IHioooUt1uoJI SJAtllfIIIIIIIJlll 11ft0lNllll JO lllloJS utlfIIIINITJIW
(
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
i ~~ 5 lishy
~ i i f
~ tcmiddot~ ~1t1r ~ti ~~~~~ ~
imiddot ~
ii~i ~
1~~-bulli s middot~
~Jampit ~i$~~
Ei ~~~=~i~5
illilmlill~i i-s~~E~j
-~~ mHi~~~ middotmiddotrmiddotmiddot middotr
~ ~ ~~~ ~sl ~~ ~i~ i~Ss
~~B~Jv~ iH~i~im~~~ghHi mi~tH
~meuro~Jm 8
~~v Ji~- ~~=lii~~
~L~
~ c
2c~middot ~ ~
fj~o
-iiL~~= ~
E~ijioi~ ti~immm ~i
~~~slji mhHm~J~gtfE
~~ ~~~~~~~f~h H~wmm~
bulleh=~~Pi~~~q~rmiddot~~i
~middot ~mi1hH
H~~~h~Fmiddot i~iiii~i
~
h I
bullbull amp
bull -~
~i ~ee
w~
-a ~
ozeJ ~~
middotshy~middot
~~d
iE5
io
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
PINETTES SALVAGE
POTENTIAL FOR EXPEDITED RESPONSE ACTION
Expadiud Response Action (ERA) would be applicable only to contuinatad soils at the site
Because the ERA would be a non-timemiddotcritieal removal action (La the aite dou not present an illllediate uvue thrut to public health and the environment) an anatnrina avaluationcoJt analysis (EECA) il required The EECA should aatilfy four aoals
(1) provide a 11athodoloay for avaluatina and uleetina an altunative uchno loampY for waste disposition to 11nsun that the uchnology is sound and appropriate for the apacific aita
(2) fulfill the n~uinmantl of the Natioral EnviroMantal Policy Act (NEPA) for non middottile-critical u1110val actions ERAs
(3) provide n provad documentation for re110val action aahetion to hcilitate cost reeovary afort1o and
(4) provide better documentation of the dechion-maltinamp procus for removal actions for inclusion in the adlllinistrative record
Substantively the EECA is vuy similar to a focuud Fusibility Study - shyllternltives are developed evaluated for efhctivenen enaineerinamp practicability and cost and a prahrnd alternative is uhcted and i11plemented for the re110val action The EECA includes the followinamp steps
Site Characterization Identification of Removal Action Objectives Identification of Removal Action Alurnativu Initial Scresnina of Removsl Action Alternltivu Analysis of Remlininamp Removal Action Alternatives Compantive Analysis of Removal Action Alternatives
The 11ajor adventaaa in perfor~~~ina an ERA It the Pinettes Salv1ae site would be that the sehcted source control alternative I be i11plemented 110re rapidly than throuah the RIFS-ROD-RDRA procen However there are aeveral potential problams that could delay tha ERA procen or result in the implementation of a re1110val alternative that b not cost-effective or pen~anent Then problems inc lude
Lack of volume data for the source area at the site Evaluation of reiDedial alternatives in the FS or tbe EpoundCA process will stronaly depend on the
232Sd081481
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-2shy
volume of contuinaud bulleterhl to be re110ved treeted and this inforMetion will not be vdhble without site chuacurhation efforu
A detdled risk anbullnbullent hu not bn perfor11ad Thus clunbullup levels for soils caMot be adequetely specified and the n110vel action 11ay rnult in re110valtnatbullent of either 110re or len soil than would be required by riskmiddotbaud criuria
Alurnativu for PCI trnt11ent and disposal include a wida unabull of apparently costmiddotcompatitiva tachnoloaiu which are 1110ra thorouamphly evaluated throuah the FS process than the EECA proceu Also land disposal options for PCBs as uhcted for the previous removal action are vary limited
The EECA process would addreu only the aourca ana whereas the RIFS proceu wJuld i ntearate source control and manaaement of miaretion options to se lect the 1110st afacttve remedy for the entire site For axuple traet11ent of conumineted oil could pouit-ly be achieved by the sue Method used for soH trUtllent which could lead to the selection of an warall solution that is 110ra costbullaffective than sapuate ra11edial acdons for soil (based on the EE CA) and aroundwatar (baud on the FS)
The EECA Guidance Hanual is i n draft forbull and experience within EPA and ita contractors with the EE CA procns is limited (ea Merican TherMOstat)
Based on thua factors we beHave that a permanent costbulleffective reaedy for the Pinattaa Salvaae eite can but be selected throuah the RIFS process
232Sd081487
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
Pt4anl AIAi e ltbull tL)
(middot Chlorobenaene 0 418
1 2-Dichlorobenaene
1 3-Dichlorobenaene f J-1-14-Dichlorobenaene 0 075
1 2 4-Trichlorobenaene
PCII obull ~)1
I
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
~lUmiddotatgt ~l~~=middotttlPHh sbulldbullh bullka) ~ fruiiiDQ IIWM IIWM IIUIJIIa
rl PCis 235 1400 91
1 24-Trtchlorobtnztnt 235 12 12
12-Dtchlorobtnztnt 329 021 006
1 3-Dtchlorobtnztnt 006
14-Dt chlorobtnztnt 6U 012 2J Chlorobtnztnt 529 006
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
- attadgtoll
~ -of splbull to~ tolgtonltary Anal~ for ~- s-ishyVolatilbull vo 8ld ~
lllo (2) pQblo wll wtr(~flr)- D WJ-fJriw(5)- r- u IQgtr (4) ourtooo wtr ~(14)__
Ton (10) ooil
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424
-------IIO
TICE If tllo fllbull 1-t
It ltN oltor tlo
uth
lt netlct It lo
~ to tho
PIN
ET
TE
S
SAL
VA
GE
Y
AR
D
AO
HIN
IST
RA
TIV
E
RE
CO
RD
o
f tllo bullbullbullbullbullt
~~ ~-~ ~
~
t i ~ ~
~ i tl i
s I 1
~ s
6 sJ ~
l iEi 1
~ ~~~i
~ ~ E
iffbullj I ~
ifff-fli l ifi~~~~
~ 1
a~~~~ ~~~
i ~~~ ~~
~ i
I ~o~
~ ~a
1~ ~
I ~ itJli l N
tli 1 1 1fl il ~ ii1~1-il
11 1 lI
IJIll itlfilill middotlitit l
J
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
~ I
~I8
(
0
- barcode 581424
- barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 581424