research into impact of coaching in organizations: a summary of … · interviews: “i mean, a 360...

9
Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of Findings, Discussions and Significance An Edited Extract from UK Master’s Thesis Andre Wai, M.Sc. This article first appeared in the International Journal of Coaching in Organizations, 2003, 1(4),119-126. It can only be reprinted and distributed with prior written permission from Professional Coaching Publications, Inc. (PCPI). Email John Lazar at [email protected] for such permission. ISSN 1553-3735 2003 © Copyright 2003 PCPI. All rights reserved worldwide. Journal information: www.ijco.info Purchases: www.pcpionline.com

Upload: others

Post on 07-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of Findings,

Discussions and Significance An Edited Extract from UK Master’s Thesis

Andre Wai, M.Sc.

This article first appeared in the International Journal of Coaching in Organizations, 2003, 1(4),119-126. It can only be reprinted and distributed with prior written permission from Professional Coaching

Publications, Inc. (PCPI). Email John Lazar at [email protected] for such permission.

ISSN 1553-3735

2003

© Copyright 2003 PCPI. All rights reserved worldwide.

Journal information:

www.ijco.info

Purchases:www.pcpionline.com

Page 2: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

119

Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations:A Summary of Findings, Discussions and Significance

Andre Wai, M.Sc.[An Edited Extract from UK Master’s Thesis]

The past twenty years have seen an explosion of new thinking about how adults develop, what organizations need to do toadapt to rapid change, how the change process itself is ongoing and cyclical, and that learning can be lifelong. We knownow, in ways that were unknown just a few years ago, that adults have the potential to learn and make dramatic changesthroughout their life span. By looking at what we currently know, what we observe, and what the research suggests, wehave a rich domain for interpretation and exploration. As part of the requirement for my Master’s degree program, Iconducted a qualitative study into how coaching has impacted organisations in China; I found that the results wereconsistent with other research findings around the world. Here is a summary of my findings, discussions, and perceivedsignificance of the benefits for other coaches around the world.

The coaching process affected individual lives byhelping people to know themselves better, learn how tomanage themselves better, how to relate moreproductively with others, and how to think about andaddress work situations. The process itself, being in acoaching relationship, had an impact. The overall effectof coaching might be summarized as “it surfaces mypotential a great deal and I am functioning better as aperson.”

Findings and Discussions

As the research findings reflected, the importance ofthe coaching relationship stood out as the key enablerfor change. The work of Carl Rogers (1961, l969) morethan any other kept springing to mind. Rogersemphasized that the facilitation of significant learningrests upon certain perceived attitudinal qualities in thepersonal relationship between the coach (facilitator)and the coachee. These include the facilitator’sauthentic acceptance, trustworthiness, and empathy.When these qualities are present, change can occur.

The research shows that while individuals who havebeen coached learn specific things about themselvesand concrete ideas for making changes, the value ofjust having someone who listens deeply is one of themost valued parts of the process. The way that coachingis different from therapy, most significantly, it does notlook backward, nor attempt simply to find insights aboutpast causes for current behavior. That does not changethe fact however that coaching can have a profoundtherapeutic effect. The relationship between the coachee(learner) and coach is key.

The acknowledgment of the significance of being heard

was expressed in almost every interview. Oneinterviewee noted that “maybe the most valuable part[of the coaching process] is saying this stuff out loud toanother person” and for another, “what stands out mostis the dialogue aspect.” As Bohm (I996) has pointed outin his work on dialogue, “saying things out loud” servesa critical purpose. It enables us to bring out our internalunconscious thoughts, and in doing so, to see how thesethoughts have formed our reality. One intervieweenoted, “once you say it, it’s out there.” Throughdialogue, we get feedback on our thought that canenable us to see our own blind spots and “blocks”. Themere process of open dialog creates a shared meaningthat allows for action (Bohm, 1996, p.17).

What was said in the interviews brought to mind a quotefrom Rogers that I came across during my research.

.....when a person realizes he has been deeplyheard...it is as though he were saying, “Thank God,somebody heard me. Someone knows what it’s liketo be me.” ….he is released from his loneliness, hehas become a human being again. There are many,many people living in private dungeons today,people who give no evidence of it whatever on theoutside, where you have to listen very sharply tohear the faint messages from the dungeon. [Rogers,1969, p. 224]

The metaphor of dungeon may be extreme, but otherwisereflects the kind of relief and comfort that exists in agood coaching relationship. The coaching relationship,when there is real trust, empathy and validation, createsa space for inner knowing to arise.

Andy
Typewritten Text
© Copyright 2003 by Andre Wai. Used with permission. All rights reserved worldwide.
Page 3: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

The International Journal of Coaching in Organizations

120

One interviewee talked about how important it was just“having her here, knowing that she would take seriouslyeverything I say.” Several people used the term“sounding board” and talked about the value of sayingthings out loud to another person. Another joked thathaving such a supportive relationship was so great thatwe should all be assigned a coach at birth.

The research supports the theories of relationalpsychology. The relationship- differentiation model ofdevelopment suggests that the skills we need foreffective relationship need to be learned and developedin relationship. The emphasis that relationalpsychology brings to the process of human developmentis exactly what the people I interviewed reported asbeing some of the greatest benefits of the coachingprocess. That is, they learned to be more empathic withtheir colleagues and direct reports; to “stop the action”and take time to listen deeply to others and find outwhere they are coming from before deciding on a courseof action; to develop a tolerance for ambiguity and morethan one way of looking at things; to question theirassumptions and understand their own role insituations; even how to listen deeply to and honorthemselves.

The study strongly suggests that Belenky’s (l997)prescription for helping women find their own authenticvoices could be a prescription for an effective coachingrelationship. In the process of being listened to andvalued, the self starts coming back into the process ofknowing. We learned to listen to what our senses tellus, and to express ourselves more honestly. One of theinterviewees, referring to the effect of coaching, talkedabout the importance of “having someone who is skilledin thinking with you.” Participants in the study referredin various ways to the importance of the elements of therelational approach (p. 229):

Connection over separation.

Understanding and acceptance over assessment.

Collaboration over debate.

Respecting and allowing time for the knowledgethat emerges from firsthand experience.

Encouragement for finding their own ways ofworking, rather than imposing expectations andarbitrary requirements.

This phenomenon of finding a new sense of self and anew voice was inspiring. To the many definitions ofcoaching I would add the following: “a process forbringing out the inner wisdom in an individual.”

Interviewees emphasized the important effect offeedback during the coaching process. There was oftena wide-eyed expression on the faces of interviewees asthey commented that they had “no idea” of the ways inwhich their actions affected others. While they may havehad a sense of things not being right, it was the concretefeedback that really provided the wake-up call. “It’smade me more effective because I have a greaterunderstanding of how I impact other people.”

Interviewees’ comment on feedback meshed with myexperience: feedback in organizations has become a lostart. It requires a certain amount of interpersonal skill,and an environment where feedback is expected,accepted and valued as a tool for individual andorganizational learning and performance improvement.We don’t like to give even constructive feedback. (Itfeels like conflict, may stir up feelings, and you neverknow what reaction you might get.) Unfortunately,feedback is often avoided like the plague until thesituation reaches a crisis point. Interviewees notedemphatically how valuable it was to get specific, timelyfeedback, and how much they learned about themselvesand their effect on others in the process. The feedbackduring the coaching process came in three ways: fromthe coach’s observations, from 360 interviewsconducted by the coach and fed back to the interviewee,and as directly solicited from other people.

The interviewees whose coaches had done extensive360 interviews and/or observed them in actual worksituations, commented that it was one of the mostvaluable parts of the process, because it gave veryconcrete descriptions of how they showed up in theorganization. A great example was the person whocontrasted the general information she had gotten froma 360 evaluation survey, versus the very concretefeedback that her coach had gleaned from 360interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need tolisten more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t knowexactly what it was she was doing, or what the effectwas on others, until she got the specific feedback thather coach had collected.

A number of the interviewees drew in more feedback byactively engaging their work associates in their changeeffort. Several commented that they let everyone knowthey were being coached, and what behaviorsspecifically they were trying to change. They explainedthat they were going to be trying new things, and askedfor ongoing feedback on how they were doing. Oneinterviewee noted that doing this had two very positiveimpacts. First, her group appreciated that she wasworking on things. This created a perceptual andattitudinal change. Secondly, they could give herspecific feedback in the areas they knew she was workingon. For these interviewees, acknowledging that they

Page 4: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

2003 Annual Edition (Issue Four)

121

were trying to change and needed help to do that, freedthem up to experiment, practice, and learn fromexperience. It also actively encouraged them to providefeedback. One interviewer wryly acknowledged thebenefit of this feedback – “What people end up tellingyou what you’ve done is always different from whatyou think you did.”

The other important part of the feedback was thefeedback loop created by the opportunity to practicenew behaviors. Key to adult learning theory is thisemphasis on experiential learning, and learning in thecontext of real and immediate issues of concern to thelearner. In order to practice in a way that we can reallychange the behavior, it takes an environment that issafe enough to try out new things, and feedback on howit went, time to reflect, and then do it again. Theimportance of practice also meshes with the findings inbrain research. Repetitive behavior is required to laydown the new neural pathways necessary to replaceold habits with new behaviors.

The research themes blended remarkably with the maincomponents of emotional intelligence (Goleman, I995,1998; Goleman, Boyatzis, McKee, 2001). Specificallythe themes “I am more self-aware and self-accepting,”“I understand how my actions impact others,” “I haveways to direct and manage my actions constructively,”“I have new ways to think about and approachsituations,” and “I have been able to make a positivedifference in how the organization works.” These mapalmost exactly with the emotional intelligencecomponents of Self-awareness, Self-management, Socialawareness and Relationship management.

The coaching process impacted each of thesecomponents. Interviewees placed particular emphasison self-awareness that came from understanding howthey showed up to other people – “I understand howmy actions impact others.” With that awareness camethe ability to self-manage better in situations that mayhave triggered an automatic response before. This isreflected in comments like “I manage myself in a waythat makes me more effective.” and “I understand howmy reactions feed dysfunction.” Being able to “look atwhat infuses a situation” is social awareness. Theacquisition of relationship management skills might besummed up by the interviewee who noted she hadlearned “you always have the opportunity to change,you can’t expect the other person to change.”

It was striking how many interviewees commented onthe fact that they had become more reflective. They hadlearned to examine their assumptions and to seesituations in a new light. What they experienced wasthe “perspective transformation,” as described byMezirow (1981) and others. Perspective changes are

transformational because the person’s view of reality,along with its attendant possibilities and opportunities,is fundamentally changed, providing an impetus forchanged behavior. Interviewees were able to changetheir perspective because they learned how to standback and from a situation and “stop and think,” reflecton what was going on, and bring new learning to bearon addressing the situation. They learned to ask“What’s the other person’s interest in this?...What isreally the issue here?” The self-described hard-chargingtypes in particular described this as a majortransformation in their operating style.

Several interviewees noted that they had gotten differentbusiness tools and models through training over theyears, but the value was in learning how to apply them,which they got through the coaching and feedback.Learning theory emphasizes that adults learn best whenthey can apply abstract concepts to an immediatesituation of personal importance to the learner.Coaching provided the means for integrating tools andtechniques, by giving the support and time to figure outhow to apply them to real situations. As one personcommented “so what good is it if I read all these books,but never have a sense from anyone else, you know, doI do this stuff?” Coaches also provided their own favoritemodels and techniques. Although these were noted asbeing extremely valuable, in no interview did any ofthese specific tools and models stand out as much asthe process of practice and feedback.

The cascading effect described in the interviews mirrorsthe Goleman (2002) statement that emotionalintelligence “moves like electricity along wires (p. 44).”The higher the organizational level, or the greater theinfluence level, the more dramatic this may be. On theother hand, the lessons of the new science wouldsuggest that individual change at any level can havean enormous ripple effect. If a butterfly flapping itswings in Tokyo can affect the weather in New York, anindividual contributor who has learned the personaland relationship skills as described in this study canhave a similar effect in an organization. In fact, one ofthe interviewees noted that the cascading effect wentup, two levels. Another was approached for someinformal coaching by someone who had worked for hertwo years before, after word of the changes she hadmade spread through the grapevine.

The nature of the coaching process, meeting over aperiod of months, provides the time to learn throughexperience. Whatever the reason why a person enteredcoaching, virtually everyone commented that itbroadened over time. The specific situation provided acontext for individuals to learn how to approach asituation, tease apart what was happening, reflect ontheir role in it, check assumptions, and take the time to

Page 5: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

The International Journal of Coaching in Organizations

122

consider the perspective of others involved. Oneinterviewee described it as learning “a structured wayof thinking about things, breaking things down pieceby piece….and then also how it all fits together.”

Learning how to approach new situations in this waygoes to the heart of creating a learning organization.Individuals who have acquired this skill are trulyprepared to deal with change. It’s hard tooveremphasize the importance of this part of thecoaching process. The essence of adult education canbe described as “learning how to learn.” The coachingprocess is more than just how to deal with immediatechallenges and performance issues. Its greater benefitmay be in using those issues as way to learn a processfor dealing with future challenges as well. (See, forexample, the discussion of double-loop and triple-looplearning in Hargrove (1995).)

The interplay between personal and organizationaldevelopment was apparent. Interviewees noted,sometimes dramatically, the changes that coaching hadcreated in their personal lives. For some it had made ahuge difference in their relationship with their spouse.For others, they had seen positive changes with theirchildren or friends.

The skills and behaviors learned in the workplace, suchas improved communication skills, being better able togive and receive feedback, being more open toconsidering other points of view, establishing an opendialog, and improved problem-solving — these wereall skills and behaviors that they were able to use athome as well.

There were no negative comments made about thecoaching process or the effects of coaching. This wasperhaps to be expected given that the overall effect waspositive for all interviewees. When asked about whatwas the most difficult part of coaching, the answerswere varied. One person had an initial issue with trustand concerns about confidentiality. Two peoplecommented that it was “very time consuming” and hardto carve out the time to work out an improvement planand then work to that plan. Others noted that it wasjust plain “tough work - hard resolving this stuff,”difficult getting feedback from a lot of people, and “justbeing very honest with myself about what I did welland didn’t do well.”

Significance

Organizations

Coaching can have a profound effect on improvingindividual effectiveness. In the past, much of what agood coach now does was performed, if at all, by one’s

manager. As discussed, today’s managers often do nothave the skills, desire or time to do such work. Inaddition, they, and/or the organization of which theyare a part, may not necessarily see employeedevelopment as one of management’s keyresponsibilities.

The learnings from this study have implications thatorganizations should consider in striving to becomemore effective.

As noted, recent research has demonstrated adirect link between emotional intelligence inleaders and the effectiveness of theirorganizations. This research indicates thatcoaching is an extremely effective way forindividuals to develop and hone emotionalintelligence skills. It follows that individualcoaching should be considered a key tool forleadership development.

A helping relationship over time is key toeffecting needed behavior changes. There areways besides coaching to provide employeesopportunities to experience a helpingrelationship.Mentoring programs, peercoaching, structured on the job training andgood management practices are other ways toprovide support for experiential learning.

Two key benefits of coaching – “getting concretefeedback to make specific changes” and“understanding how my actions impactothers” - can be provided by on an ongoingbasis by one’s manager. Provide training andsupport for managers in developing theseperformance coaching skills and encouragetheir use. All levels of management need at leasta basic awareness of employee developmentneeds, the importance of these needs, andtechniques for supporting individual growth.The lower on the management ladder that thisis instilled, the better.

Feedback is a necessary component of alearning individual, and critical to building alearning organization. Strive to instill the skillof giving and receiving feedback in each andevery employee. Managers in particular shouldmodel what effective feedback looks andsounds like. It is a core component ofperformance coaching.

The benefits of good coaching can “cascade” inall directions. A positive behavior change in oneindividual can have an ongoing positive effectthroughout his or her sphere of influence and

Page 6: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

2003 Annual Edition (Issue Four)

123

beyond, with a potential return of investmentfar exceeding one individual’s performanceimprovement. Coaching is not only forexecutives. The more that lower levels of theorganization develop self-management andrelationship skills, the sooner the organizationreaps the benefit. By the time a person withissues has reached the upper levels of thecompany, the likelihood is that they havealready cost the organization much more thanan initial investment in addressing the issueswould have cost. Prepare people to be a betterteam player, first level manager, or individualcontributor.

Training as an event can provide knowledge,but behavior change requires an ongoingprocess of practice and feedback. Whereverpossible, provide follow-up to employeedevelopment training and coaching to helppeople internalize the learnings from theclassroom. Training in key competencies andbehaviors identified as necessary to perform atask or role has value only to the extent that thelearner has the awareness of how to put the newknowledge into practice.

The benefits of coaching described in this studywere not merely about financially measurableperformance results (what work got done), butin the ways that the interviewees were able toform better relationships, problem-solve andthink better (how things got done). A caveat to acoaching investment may be the simple truththat the organization may not be able to directlyattribute the benefit of coaching to immediateperformance improvement. The benefit mayshow up in a “ripple” - to another project orperson, or sometime down the road.

Coaching does not provide benefits in a vacuum.The more the organization acknowledges thebenefits of the coaching process as positive andpromotes its use as a positive step towardemployee development, the more individuals canbe comfortable widening their network offeedback and support for change.

Good coaching is about relationships. Be carefulof taking a too formalized approach to coaching,or applying a one-size-fits-all model. A varietyof approaches to meet individual needs andpreferences may be most important.

Based on the research, it appears that what a personneeds from coaching is as unique as their individualperformance needs, supporting network, goals, life

stage, personality, work history…. and as simple assomeone who listens, dialogs, supports, reflects,suggests, and enables the process of critical reflection.The relationship creates the environment for thelearning and the eventual behavior change. It is thisrelaxing into oneself that then opens the door for themore tactical learning that follows.

This study did not look at the coaching process per se,but at the effect of having been coached. Neverthelessthe findings have clear implications for coaches.Attempts to control or standardize the coaching processmay be counter-productive. It is, at its core, a personal,helping relationship.

My prescription for an effective coaching process buildson Belenky’s (l997) work, and is as follows. First, theemphasis is on establishing a helping relationship frominside the coachee’s agenda. This relationship createsthe sense of genuine connection that is often missing inorganizations (and elsewhere), and from which theindividual can experience the safety and trust necessaryto risk making changes.

Second, the emphasis is on listening and seeking tounderstand the individual, with an attitude ofacceptance rather than judgment. The fine line here isthat while assessments such as 360s may be part of thecoaching process, such assessments are used to promoteself-understanding and not for judging or blaming.

Third, the coach enters into a collaborative relationshipwith the individual valuing his or her perspective. Theexpertise and experience of the coach is blended withthe expertise and experience of the individual. The coachencourages the individual to take the time to reflect onhis/her experience and suggests structures and modelsto help make sense of that experience. The emphasis ison “thinking with” rather than dictating courses ofaction. This helps the individual develop the ability tothoughtfully approach problems and developappropriate courses of action in future situations.

Fourth, there is deep respect for the knowledge thatemerges from firsthand experience in the course of thecoaching process. The coach provides exercises and“homework” to give the individual opportunities topractice new behaviors in actual work situations. Thecoaching engagement is of sufficient duration to allowtime for the individual to practice and integrate newbehaviors.

Finally, and perhaps most important, the emphasis ison helping the individual identify and develop acapacity and style for ongoing problem solving andwork performance that is congruent with his/her owninner voice. For a behavior change to be more than a

Page 7: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

The International Journal of Coaching in Organizations

124

quick fix, it has to be deeply internalized. It must fitwith the individual’s personal goals and sense ofpurpose. A critical part of the coaching process ishelping the individual find the path that createsorganizational success while maintaining personalintegrity.

Based on this approach, and the findings of this study,characteristics for organizational coaches include:

A broad base of life and work experiences fromwhich to draw.

An understanding of adult development andlearning.

An appreciation of the realities and dynamicsof an organizational environment.

Ability to balance performance and lifecoaching, as needed.

Personal congruence, modeling authenticthoughts and feelings.

Trust in the unlimited potential and innerwisdom of human beings.

Willingness to be a partner - not an expert - onthe journey.

If one valuable “technique” stood out, it was that ofdoing 360 interviews. Do more of these. It seemsimpossible for someone to get too much constructivefeedback.

Individuals

In my study it was often the case that many people aretrapped in “private dungeons” at work. There are amyriad of reasons for this. But a key reason is that weare often conditioned to separate our “work selves” fromour “real selves.” Certainly the ability to do productivework may necessitate certain behavior shifts betweenhome and work. But the sense that we have left our“real selves” (and this is a commonly used expression)somewhere else suggests a more profoundabandonment. When we cut off parts of ourselves, wealso abandon our own inner wisdom.

Changes in our work behavior can create change in ourpersonal lives, and vice versa. It is a reinforcing systemloop, for good or ill. As self-awareness increases, webecome more aware not just of our role in workrelationships, but in all relationships. The patterns ofbehavior we need to change in the workplace areprobably

The age of the interviewees ranged from 32-56, with anaverage age of 44. I think there are a couple of reasonswhy most coaching is for this age group. From anorganizational perspective, the person has had time toattain a certain level of responsibility and influence inthe organization. But from the perspective of adultdevelopment, middle age is also a time when lifepresents us with a wake-up call to change. This callmay come from within, as an inner sense that one’s lifeis somehow not working, or from an external source,such as feedback from managers, co-workers, friendsand spouses, or as a combination of inner and outermessages. As one interviewee put it, “This is that samething I keep getting hung up on - why do I keep endingup in the same place?”

Readiness to learn is a cornerstone for adult learning.The research seems to reinforce Jung’s philosophy ofadult development - that middle age and beyond is atime of great opportunity for finding new meaning inlife, if we only take advantage of it.

As Jung (1971) pointed out a century ago, we cannotlive the afternoon of life according to the program of themorning. Are there perhaps colleges for forty-year-oldswhich prepare them for their coming life and itsdemands as the ordinary colleges introduce our youngpeople to a knowledge of the world (p.16)? This is thequestion that sparked my study of adult development,and ultimately my investigation of organizationalcoaching. Mid-life, when we often think we’ve learnedit all, is exactly when we may learn our most challenginglessons. This is a good opportunity for beginning toreveal what we don’t know what we don’t know.

We could view the coaching process as this college foradults. In it, we learn the skills necessary to functionbetter in the world. We become more self-aware. Webecome conscious of patterns of behavior that have beendeveloping unconsciously over our whole lives. Wethink deliberately about the patterns we want to keepand those we want to change. We learn our truestrengths, and acknowledge our weaknesses. We learnto question our assumptions, and reflect on our role inthings. We wake up to how our actions impact others,and learn to look at things from another’s point of view.We learn how to approach a difficult situation, tease itapart, work it through, and apply the learning to futuresituation.

With the pace of change and pressures of the workplace,we don’t often get the opportunity to stop the actionand look deeply at ourselves, what we are doing, andwhere we are going. When we start to question ourperformance gaps, we open the door to questioning ourbroader functioning in the world. This broadened

also wreaking havoc in our personal lives.

Page 8: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

2003 Annual Edition (Issue Four)

125

thinking was a theme in every interview, in one form oranother.

The simple truth is that most work in organizationsgets done through relationships. Yet in our traditionaleducation, relationships skills are not in the curriculum.The need for a college for forty year olds is greater thanever. The curriculum is a process that facilitates learningfor life. In this college I get assistance with an ongoingcycle of learning:

Increased awareness as to where things aren’tworking.

Feedback about how I’m perceived and myimpact.

Becoming conscious of my assumptions,beliefs and patterns of behavior.

Determining ways I want to change andsetting personal goals.

Getting an infusion of ideas, models and newways of looking at things.

Taking action and practicing new behaviors.

Reflection on progress and getting morefeedback.

Making adjustment and practicing some more.

My dream is that entering a learning process for greaterself-knowledge at forty would be as widely anticipatedand accepted as going to college after high school. The“professor” in this college just might be anorganizational coach.

A recent article on the origins of findings inneurogenesis just appeared in Smithsonian magazine.This article reviews the research of Fernando Nottenohmwhose studies of birds first opened eyes to the fact thatthe adult brain does change and develop new cellsthroughout life. In birds “the volume of the part of the....brain that controls song-making changes seasonally. Itpeaks in the spring...and shrinks in the summer. It thenstarts expanding again in the fall - a time to learn andrehearse new tunes.”

Even though it is still not clear exactly what new neuronsdo in humans, it is a beautiful metaphor. The secondhalf of life just may be a time to learn and practice newtunes.

I believe that coaching will be a key process for adultand organizational development and success in the

future. To what degree is the goal of organizationalcoaching in performance improvement or individualdevelopment? My firm belief is that the two are ultimatelyinseparable. The stages and phases and challenges ofjust being an adult cannot help but influence workperformance, and success (or lack thereof) in work willlikewise influence personal development. Where theemphasis is placed in any given coaching session sothat both individual and organization benefit is the trueart of effective coaching.

I started this research with great excitement about thepotential of organizational coaching. Through thevoices of the people I interviewed that enthusiasm hasbeen greatly reinforced. Coaching at its best is truly aprocess of learning for life.

_____________________________________________

References

Belenky, Mary Field, Blythe McVicker Clinchy, Nancy RuleGoldberger, and Jill Mattuck Tarule. l997.Women’s Ways ofKnowing: The Development of Self, Voice and Mind. New York, NY:Basic Books.Bohm, David. l996. On Dialogue. Edited by L. Nichol. London:Routledge.Goleman, Daniel. 1995. Emotional Intelligence. New York, NY:Bantam Books.Goleman, Daniel. 1998. Working with Emotional Intelligence. NewYork, NY: Bantam Books.

Goleman, Daniel, Richard Boyatzis, and Annie McKee. 200l(December). “Primal Leadership: The Hidden Driver of GreatPerformance.” Harvard Business Review, 42-51.Hargrove, Robert. 1995. Masterful Coaching. San Francisco, CA:Jossey Bass.Jung, Carl G. l971. The Stages of Life. In The Portable Jung,edited by J. Campbell. New York, NY: Penguin Books.

Mezirow, Jack. l981. “A Critical Theory of Adult Learning andEducation.” Adult Education, 32(1):3-24.Rogers, Carl R. 196l. On Becoming o Person. Boston, MA: HoughtonMifflin.Rogers, Carl R. l969. Freedom to Learn. Columbus, OH: Merrill._________________________

Andre Wai

Email Address: [email protected]: http://www.tophuman.com

Andre is currently the General Manager, Franchise andCooperation in Top Human Technology Limited. Hespecializes in leadership, team building, changemanagement, and corporate coaching. Andre has closeto 20 years of experience in hospitality management,training and coaching and has held leading salespositions in major hotel chains. He majored inInstitutional Management and is currently pursuing aMasters of Science from Leicester University, UK.

Page 9: Research into Impact of Coaching in Organizations: A Summary of … · interviews: “I mean, a 360 evaluation says ‘you need to listen more’ - what does that mean?” She didn’t

The International Journal of Coaching in Organizations (IJCO) is the signature publication of

Professional Coaching Publications, Inc. (PCPI). In addition to this internationally acclaimed

journal, PCPI publishes books on topics of interest to those in the coaching community, whether

practitioner, decision maker, or end user. You can count on PCPI, Inc. to provide content that

pushes the envelope — bringing theory, research and application together in ways that inform,

engage and provoke. Visit the PCPI website, www.pcpionline.com, to view and purchase our

growing line of products.

If you have administrative questions, please refer them to our IJCO Office Manager, at

[email protected]. For advertising, marketing and operations inquiries, please refer

them to John Lazar, IJCO Co-Executive Editor, at [email protected]. Please submit unsolicited

manuscripts for peer review consideration to the IJCO office manager at [email protected].

Visit Both Our Sites at Your Convenience

Journal information:www.ijco.info

Purchases:www.pcpionline.com

Resource Center for Professional Coaching in Organizations