responsible research and innovation: transforming science jacqueline broerse athena, vu university...

10

Click here to load reader

Upload: francis-clark

Post on 18-Jan-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen 3 MORE THAN A SOCIAL INNOVATON RRI requires different routines, structures, way of thinking  novel way of doing science Not easy to realize Need for change of incumbent regime – dominant culture, structure and practice System change!

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION:TRANSFORMING SCIENCE

JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Page 2: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen2

KEY WORDS

• Responsive – to societal needs• Multi-actor – academia, public, private, civil society• Inclusive – gender vulnerable groups (e.g. poor,

ethnic minorities, disabled)• Transdisciplinary – multidisciplinary perspectives,

integration scientific and experiential/practical knowledge• Open and transparant – accountability• Flexible reflexive, learning process

Page 3: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen3

MORE THAN A SOCIAL INNOVATON

• RRI requires different routines, structures, way of thinking novel way of doing science

• Not easy to realize• Need for change of incumbent regime – dominant

culture, structure and practice

System change!

Page 4: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

MULTILEVEL PERSPECTIVE

4 Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen

‘Niches’ Innovative experiments in which actors create alternative practices (compared to regime)

‘Regime’ Dominant structure, culture and practice of system

Regime

Landscape

Niche

‘Landscape’ Broader societal trends

Page 5: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen5

CHALLENGES

• Lack of sense of urgency– No observed surplus value of participation– Fear for delay and complication of decision making

• Dominant structures and procedures– Financing structure dominated by scientists– Appraisal procedures based on scientific criteria– No additional means for involvement

Page 6: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen6

CHALLENGES

• Characteristics research community:– Strong specialization in monodisciplines– Importance of scientific achievement and publications– Importance of scientific autonomy and curiosity– Undervalution of experiential/practical knowledge

• Characteristics civil society:– Limited will to participate (I don’t have time)– Lack of scientific knowledge (I don’t know)– Limited ability of objectification and abstraction– Lack of self-confidence and empowerment

Page 7: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen7

STRATEGIES OF TRANSITION MANAGEMENT

DEEPENING BROADENING SCALING UP

Learn in niche Replicate & link Embedding CSP

• What is RRI?• How to do it?• What are

benefits?• What CSP most

conducive

Fragmentation

Isolation

Page 8: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen8

STRATEGIES OF TRANSITION MANAGEMENT

DEEPENING BROADENING SCALING UP

Learn in niche Replicate & link Embedding CSP

• What is RRI?• How to do it?• What are

benefits?• What CSP most

conducive

• Increase experiments in different locations

• Awareness raising

• Networking• Coalition

building Talk without action‘Green washing’

Page 9: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen9

STRATEGIES OF TRANSITION MANAGEMENT

DEEPENING BROADENING SCALING UP

Learn in niche Replicate & link Embedding CSP

• What is RRI?• How to do it?• What are

benefits?• What CSP most

conducive

• Increase experiments in different locations

• Awareness raising

• Networking• Coalition

building

• Training competences

• Policies• Incentives• Monitoring &

evaluation

Evasive behavio

r

Page 10: RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH AND INNOVATION: TRANSFORMING SCIENCE JACQUELINE BROERSE ATHENA, VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM

Faculteit der Aard- en Levenswetenschappen10

timetime

Indi

cato

rs fo

r cha

nge

Indi

cato

rs fo

r cha

nge

InitialInitial phasephase TakeTake--offoff

AccelerationAcceleration

StabilizationStabilization

Lock inLock in

BacklashBacklash

PHASES IN TRANSITIONS

Transitions run into resistance of actors and constraining regime factors