7/25/2019 Roman Catholic Bishop of Malolos, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Intermediateappellate Court, And Robes-francisco Realty a

1/3

G.R. No. 72110 November 16, 1990

ROMAN CATHOLIC BISHOP OF MALOLOS, INC., pe!!o"er, v#. INT$RM$%IAT$APP$LLAT$ CO&RT, '"( ROB$S)FRANCISCO R$ALT*AN% %$+$LOPM$NTCORPORATION, re#po"(e"#.Ro(r!o L'- O!/e or pe!!o"er.A"o"!o P. B'rre(o '"( N'poeo" M. M'!"'# or pr!v'ere#po"(e".

% $ C I S I O N

SARMI$NTO,

T!# !# ' pe!!o" or rev!e- o" /er!or'r! -!/ #ee3# e rever#' '"( #e!" '#!(e o e(e/!#!o" 1 o e Co4r o Appe'#, 2 e (!#po#!!vepor!o" o -!/ re'(#5

H$R$FOR$, e (e/!#!o" 'ppe'e( rom !# ereb rever#e( '"( #e '#!(e '"( '"oer o"ee"ere( or e p'!"! or(er!" e (ee"('")'ppeee Rom'" C'o!/ B!#op o M'oo#, I"/.o '//ep e b''"/e o P128,000.00 be!" p'!( b p'!"!)'ppe'" '"( ere'er oee/4e!" 'vor o Robe#)Fr'"/!#/o Re' Corpor'!o" ' re!#er'be %ee( o Ab#o4e S'e over 20,6:: #;4're meer# por!o" o ' p'r/eo '"( #!4'e( !" S'" o#e (e Mo"e, B4'/'" (e#/r!be( !"OCT No. :7:

7/25/2019 Roman Catholic Bishop of Malolos, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Intermediateappellate Court, And Robes-francisco Realty a

2/3

o" 'er e ep!r'!o" o e :)(' r'/e per!o(.B'#e( o" e 'bove /o"#!(er'!o"#, e r!' /o4r re"(ere( ' (e/!#!o" !" 'vor o epe!!o"er,e (!#po#!!ve por!o" o -!/ re'(#5H$R$FOR$, !"(!" p'!"! o 've '!e( o m'3e o4 !# /'#e, e /o4r ereb (e/'re#e#4b@e/ /o"r'/ /'"/ee( '"( p'!"!?# (o-"p'me" o P2=,9=0.00 ore!e( !" 'vor o (ee"('", '"( ereb (!#m!##e# e /omp'!"'"( o" e /o4"er/'!m, e Co4r or(er#p'!"! o p' (ee"('". Aor"e?# ee# o P10,000.00 L!!'!o" epe"#e# o P2,000.00'"( 4(!/!' /o##. SO OR%$R$%. 18No #'!#!e( -! e #'!( (e/!#!o", e pr!v'e re#po"(e" 'ppe'e( o e re#po"(e"I"erme(!'eAppe'e Co4r I" oer -or(#, e re#po"(e" /o4r, !"(!" ' epr!v'e re#po"(e" '( #4!/!e" 'v'!'be4"(#, !p#o '/o /o"/4(e( ' e 'er '( e"(ere( p'me". I# #4/ /o"/4#!o" -'rr'"e(b e'/# prove"D Te pe!!o"er #4bm!# ' ! !# "o. LeL!bHe"/e, !# pe!!o". 16Te pe!!o"er pre#e"# e oo-!" !##4e# or re#o4!o"5 A. I# ' !"(!" ' pr!v'e re#po"(e" '( #4!/!e" 'v'!'be 4"(# o" or beore e r'/eper!o( or e p'me" o !# ob!'!o" proo' ! o ee/4e ' (ee( o 'b#o4e #'e !"'vor o e pr!v'e re#po"(e"

7/25/2019 Roman Catholic Bishop of Malolos, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Intermediateappellate Court, And Robes-francisco Realty a

3/3

-eer ' m'"'er ?# /e/3 or or(!"'r /e/3, !# "o e'e"(er, '"( '" oer o ' /e/3 !" p'me" o ' (eb !# "o ' v'!( e"(er o p'me"'"( m' bere4#e( re/e!p b e ob!ee or /re(!or. He"/e, -ere e e"(er o p'me" b e pr!v'e re#po"(e" -'# "o v'!( or '!4re o/omp-! e re;4!#!e p'me" !" e' e"(er or /4rre"/ #!p4'e( -!!" e r'/e per!o( '"( '##4/, -'# v'!( re4#e( re/e!p b epe!!o"er, e #4b#e;4e" /o"#!"'!o" (!( "o oper'eo (!#/'re e ormer rom !# ob!'!o" o e 'er.I" v!e- o e oreo!", epe!!o"er !" e e!!m'e eer/!#e o !# r!# p4r#4'" o e#4b@e/ /o"r'/, (!( v'!( or(er ereore e /'"/e'!o" o e #'!( /o"r'/,e ore!4re o e prev!o4# p'me", '"( e re/o"ve'"/e !p#o '/o o e '"( !" ;4e#!o".

H$R$FOR$, e pe!!o" or rev!e- o" /er!or'r! !# GRANT$% '"( e %$CISION o e re#po"(e" /o4r prom4'e( o" Apr! 2:, 19: !#ereb S$T ASI%$ '"( ANN&LL$% '"( e %$CISION o e r!' /o4r ('e( M' 2:, 191 !# ereb R$INSTAT$%. Co## ''!"# e pr!v'ere#po"(e". SO OR%$R$%