&rpplvvlrq 5dwh &rpsdulvrq 5hsruw $sulo · $765.73 $775.24 $1,004.86 $1,594.81 $838.45...

Pennsylvania Public Utility CommissionRate Comparison Report

April 15, 2007

Prepared By:The Bureau of Fixed Utility Services

Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Rate Comparison Report

April 15, 2007

Prepared by: The Bureau of Fixed Utility Services

The Honorable Edward G. Rendell Governor of Pennsylvania The Honorable Catherine Baker Knoll Lieutenant Governor of Pennsylvania Members of the General Assembly, I am pleased to submit for your review the Commission’s Rate Comparison

Report.

Act 201, signed into law on Nov. 30, 2004, added Section 308.1(b) to the Public

Utility Code, 66 Pa. C.S. §308. Section 308.1(b) requires the Public Utility Commission

to file an annual Rate Comparison Report (Report) with the Governor and the General

Assembly on April 15, every year. The Report compares all categories of ratepayers for

all electric and gas public utilities so that a reasonably accurate comparison of rates can

be made between similar ratepayers receiving services in different service areas of the

Commonwealth.

The first section of the Report provides information on electric service. The

second section provides information on natural gas service. Each section contains a

comparison table of all companies followed by individual company information.

Sincerely,

Wendell F. Holland

Chairman

1

Table of Contents

Table of Contents 2 Introduction 4 Section 1: Electric Utilities 6 Electric Utilities Comparison 7

Electric Utilities Residential Monthly Bill Comparison 8

Citizens Electric 10

Duquesne Light 11

Metropolitan Edison Company 12

PECO Energy Company 13

Pennsylvania Electric Company 14

Pennsylvania Electric Company in Elkland 15

Pennsylvania Power Company 16

Pike County Light & Power Company 17

PPL Electric Utilities Corporation 18

UGI Utilities Inc. 19

Wellsboro Electric Company 20

West Penn Power d/b/a Allegheny Energy 21

Section 2: Gas Utilities 22 Gas Utilities Comparison 23

Large Gas Utilities Residential Monthly Bill Comparison 26

Able Company Ltd. 28

Andreassi Gas Company 29

Barkeyville Gas Company 30

Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc. 31

Columbia Gas Company 32

CRG Inc. 33

C.E. Dunmire Gas Company 34

Equitable Gas Company 35

Herman Oil & Gas Co. Inc. 36

Herman Riemer Gas Company 37

2

Kaib & Kaib Gas Company 38

Larkin Oil & Gas Inc. 39

Mountain Energy Ltd. 40

Myers Gas Company 41

National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation 42

North East Heat & Light Company 43

PECO Energy Company 44

Peoples Natural Gas Company 45

Philadelphia Gas Works (PGW) 46

T.W. Phillips Gas & Oil Company 47

Pike County Light & Power Company 48

Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. 49

PPL Gas Utilities 50

Sergeant Gas Company 51

Sigel Gas 52

UGI 53

UGI Penn Natural Gas 54

Valley Energy Inc. 55

Walker Gas & Oil Company Inc. 56

Wally Gas Company 57

3

Introduction

To achieve an accurate comparison, the Commission established ratepayer

categories and monthly usage parameters. These usage parameters include a demand

component where applicable. The Commission also established that the rates used

would be as of Jan. 31, 2007, and would be based on the Provider of Last Resort

(POLR) default service for electric customers, or Supplier of Last Resort (SOLR) default

service for gas customers1. All rates are for ratepayers not currently purchasing their

gas or electric generation from competitive suppliers (non-shoppers) and reflect a

monthly bill at the given usage parameters. The ratepayer classifications and usage

assumptions are detailed below.

Ratepayer Classification Electric Usage Gas Usage1. Residential 500 KWH 2 MCF

2. Residential Heating 2,000 KWH 15 MCF

3. Small Commercial 5 KW demand 150 MCF/year

1,000 KWH

4. Medium Commercial 25 KW demand 500 MCF/year

10,000 KWH

5. Large Commercial 500 KW demand 9,000 MCF/year

200,000 KWH

6. Industrial 1,000 KW demand >9,000 MCF/year

400,000 KWH

7. Public Street Lighting (sodium vapor) 250 watts N/A

KWH = kilowatt hour, a standard measure of electricity usage calculated by multiplying total wattage by hours of use divided by 1,000, e.g. one 100-watt bulb will use 24 KWH in one month (30 days) if used 8 hours a day [(100*240) / 1,000 = 24 KWH]. KW = kilowatt (1000 watts), used as a demand measure for larger users of electricity. Essentially, it is a measure of the electrical capacity required by the customer at any instantaneous moment. MCF = 1,000 cubic feet of gas, a standard measure of gas usage. It is the measure of the flow of cubic feet of gas through the meter.

Street lighting is determined as the cost of running one 250-watt sodium vapor light for a month.

1 PPL Electric Utilities, PECO Energy, Metropolitan Edison Company, Pennsylvania Electric Company and West Penn Power rates are subject to rate caps resulting from restructuring decisions. All other electric and gas customers are subject to POLR or SOLR decisions.

4

The Commission issued a Secretarial Letter by certified mail to the appropriate

contact for every electric and gas utility. Utilities with Internet access were asked to

download and fill out a rate table based on the ratepayer categories and usage

parameters above. Utilities then submitted the forms via email with subsequent printed

copies mailed to the Commission. Utilities without Internet access were asked to fill out

enclosed hard copies of the rate tables and to submit those hard copies to the

Commission. The Commission is grateful for the timely response of the utility

companies.

The following sections present the rate tables for each utility, so an accurate

comparison between utilities can be made. Section 1 begins with a comparison table

between all of the electric utilities. After the comparison table, Section 1 presents each

of the electric utilities, in alphabetical order, with their individual rate tables and a brief

description of the utility, the applicable tariff number, and any unique company-specific

information that is relevant to the rate information provided.

Section 2 contains the same information, also in the same format, for the gas

utilities. The only exception is the beginning comparison tables, which are divided

between the 1307(f)2 and GCR3 gas utilities. The comparison tables in the beginning of

each section show the total charges for each rate classification between all of the

electric and gas utilities. The individual company rate tables detail the separate pieces

that make up the total charges for each rate classification. While the beginning tables of

each section present the easiest measure of comparison for rates, the Commission

encourages readers of this report to examine the full contents of Sections 1 and 2, to

understand the components that make up the rate for any company and any unique

situations that may affect the company’s rates.

2 Gas utilities with over $40 million in revenues and subject to rate filings under Section 1307(f) of the Public Utility Code, 66 Pa. C.S. § 1307(f). 3 Gas utilities with revenues under $40 million that file annual Gas Cost Rate (GCR) adjustments.

5

Section 1: Electric Utilities

Abbreviations Used In The Tables

KWH – Kilowatt Hours

KW – Kilowatt

CTC – Competitive Transition Charge, for companies still recovering deregulation

costs

ITC – Intangible Transition Charge, for companies still recovering deregulation

costs

STAS – State Tax Adjustment Surcharge

6

Electric Utilities Comparison

Citizens' Duquesne Met-Ed PECO Pennsylvania Pennsylvania Pike County PPL Electric UGI Wellsboro West Penn Electric Light (FirstEnergy) Energy Elec. Co. Power Co. Light & Utilities Utilities, Inc. Electric Co. Power d/b/a

Rate Classification Company Company (FirstEnergy) (FirstEnergy) Power Corporation AlleghenyResidential Power

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Public Street (Sodium Vapor Service)

Utilities

$18.64 $10.12 $16.58$19.72

$30,932.68 $44,456.39 $29,172.45 $22,436.62$40,964.27

at 250 Watts $14.83 $17.98 $26.14$13.43 $17.16 $10.76 $12.13

$24,825.78 $36,859.38 $57,513.55(1000KW Demand)

$25,779.70 $42,576.69 $29,263.03using 400,000 KWH

$15,466.33 $22,677.88 $16,755.64 $11,457.61$20,627.41 $14,237.03 $19,262.07 $28,770.63(500KW Demand)

$12,968.13 $21,381.31 $14,988.34using 200,000 KWH

$838.45 $1,201.86 $837.78 $658.38$765.73 $775.24 $1,004.86 $1,594.81(25KW Demand)

$719.43 $826.34 $773.17using 10,000 KWH

$120.25 $142.82 $97.88 $78.19$160.17 $86.78 $112.70 $182.92(5KW Demand)

$84.84 $121.63 $95.09using 1000 KWH

$107.73 $228.84 $143.14 $144.38$195.74 $180.60 $161.31 $314.95$136.88 $141.62 $170.94using 2000 KWH

$53.92 $75.60 $40.25 $39.87$79.19 $51.87 $80.81 $90.94using 500 KWH $38.31 $61.43 $54.85

7

$0.00

$10.00

$20.00

$30.00

$40.00

$50.00

$60.00

$70.00

$80.00

$90.00

$100.00

Citizens E

lectric

Company

Duques

ne Light

Met-Ed (F

irstEne

rgy)

PECO Energy C

ompany

Pennsy

lvania Elec

. Co.

(FirstEnergy

)

Pennsy

lvania Power C

o. (Firs

tEne

rgy)

Pike C

ounty Light &

Pow

er

PPL Electric

Utili

ties C

orporation

UGI Utili

ties,

Inc.

Wellsb

oro Electr

ic Co.

West Pen

n Power d/b/a Alle

gheny E

nergy

Electric Utilities: Residential 500 KWHTotal Monthly Bill Calculation as of January 31, 2007

Customer & Distribution Charges Generation & Transmission Charges CTC & ITC Other

8

($0.50)

$49.50

$99.50

$149.50

$199.50

$249.50

$299.50

$349.50

Citizens E

lectric

Company

Duques

ne Light

Met-Ed (F

irstEnergy

)

PECO Energy C

ompany

Pennsy

lvania Elec

. Co.

(FirstEne

rgy)

Pennsy

lvania Power C

o. (Firs

tEne

rgy)

Pike C

ounty Light &

Pow

er

PPL Electric

Utili

ties C

orporation

UGI Utili

ties,

Inc.

Wellsboro

Electr

ic Co.

West Pen

n Power d/b/a Alle

gheny E

nergy

Electric Utilities: Residential Heating 2,000 KWHTotal Monthly Bill Calculation as of January 31, 2007

Customer & Distribution Charges Generation & Transmission Charges CTC & ITC Other

9

Citizens’ Electric Company

Citizens’ Electric Company, a subsidiary of C&T Enterprises Inc., serves roughly

5,500 residential, 1,000 commercial and 40 industrial customers. Their service territory

consists of Lewisburg Borough and the townships of East Buffalo, Buffalo and Kelly in

Union County, as well as West Chillisquaque in Northumberland County. Citizens’

operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 14. With a service area of only

55 square miles, Citizens’ is one of the smallest electric companies both in area and in

number of customers included in this rate comparison. C&T Enterprises Inc. is a holding

company owned by the Claverack and Tri-County Rural Electric Cooperatives for their

for-profit enterprises. C&T also owns Valley Energy Inc. (gas), and Wellsboro Electric

Company.

Default Rate Schedule for Electric Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Rates for Default Service

Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal EducationRate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service Charges STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: ***We only have 100 watts at a flat rate of $8.28 per month, 400 watts at a rate of $13.43 per month.

at 250 Watts*** $13.43

$318.27 $25,779.70

$13.43

using 400,000 KWH(1000KW Demand)

$40.63 $4,440.40 $20,980.40

$12,968.13using 200,000 KWH(500KW Demand)

$40.63 $2,277.20 $10,490.20

$8.88

$160.10

$719.43using 10,000 KWH(25KW Demand)

$186.04 $524.51

$1.05 $84.84using 1000 KWH(5KW Demand)

$31.34 $52.45

$1.69 $136.88

$0.47 $38.31

using 2000 KWH $3.56 $26.73 $104.90

Utility: Citizens Electric Company

using 500 KWH $3.56 $8.05 $26.23

10

Duquesne Light Duquesne Light, a subsidiary of Duquesne Light Holdings, serves approximately

524,000 residential, 53,000 commercial and 1,600 industrial customers. Their service

territory consists of parts of Allegheny and Beaver counties in Western Pennsylvania.

Pursuant to its recently approved rate filing, Duquesne Light now operates under the

terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 24, effective Jan. 6, 2007. Duquesne Light

Holdings is currently the subject of a proposed acquisition by a consortium led by the

Macquarie Group, which is a diversified international financial services organization

based in Australia. As of the date of this Report’s compilation, the acquisition had not

yet been approved by the Commission.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Utility:

using 500 KWH $7.00 $21.16 $31.52

Duquesne Light Company

$1.72

using 2000 KWH $7.00 $54.02 $77.50 $0.08 $141.62

$0.03 $61.43

$79.91

$3.02

$0.09 $121.63using 1000 KWH $3.31(5KW Demand)

$30.00 $8.32

$826.34using 10,000 KWH $23.13(25KW Demand)

$30.00 $180.03 $592.46

$17,256.74

$0.72

$21.37

$34,513.48

$21,381.31using 200,000 KWH $445.00(500KW Demand)

$3,658.20

$0.00 $17.16

using 400,000 KWH $890.00(1000KW Demand)

$7,130.40 $42.81 $42,576.69

at 250 Watts $13.57 $3.59

11

Metropolitan Edison Company

Metropolitan Edison Company (Met-Ed), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy Corporation,

serves approximately 470,000 residential, 60,000 commercial and 1,900 industrial

customers. Met-Ed’s service territory consists of parts of the Easton, Lebanon and

Reading areas in Eastern Pennsylvania, and the York Area in South Central

Pennsylvania. Their total service area is roughly 3,300 square miles. Pursuant to the

terms of its recently approved rate filing, Met-Ed now operates under the terms of

Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 50, effective Jan. 11, 2007. FirstEnergy Corporation,

headquartered in Akron, Ohio, is one of the country’s largest investor-owned electric

systems through its seven electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania, Ohio and

New Jersey. Other FirstEnergy electric utility operating companies in Pennsylvania are

Pennsylvania Electric Company and the Pennsylvania Power Company.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Utility: Metropolitan Edison Company

using 500 KWH $8.11 $12.01 $23.29 $6.38 $3.88 $1.12

using 2000 KWH $11.00 $35.70 $93.16 $0.19 $170.94

$0.06 $54.85

$48.69

$1.34$21.54 $8.01

$0.10 $95.09using 1000 KWH $12.52 $10.19(5KW Demand)

$10.88 $12.71

$773.17using 10,000 KWH $125.20 $62.80(25KW Demand)

$21.52 $82.10 $480.70

$9,600.00

$0.85

$16.47

$18,432.00

$14,988.34using 200,000 KWH $2,356.00 $1,740.00(500KW Demand)

$60.87 $1,215.00

$0.01 $10.76

using 400,000 KWH $4,424.00 $3,803.60(1000KW Demand)

$235.28 $2,336.00 $32.15 $29,263.03

at 250 Watts $10.75

12

PECO Energy Company

PECO Energy Company (PECO), a subsidiary of the Exelon Corporation

(Exelon), serves approximately 1.4 million residential, 153,000 small commercial and

industrial and 3,100 large commercial and industrial customers. PECO’s service territory

consists of parts of the following counties in Eastern Pennsylvania: Philadelphia; Bucks;

Delaware; Montgomery; Chester; and York. PECO operates under the terms of Electric

Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3. PECO also provides gas service to approximately 470,000

customers in the Philadelphia area. Exelon’s proposed merger with Public Service

Enterprise Group Inc, has been withdrawn, despite having been approved by the

Commission on Jan. 27, 2006, and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on July

1, 2005. The withdrawal was primarily caused by the inability of the parties to reach

consensus with the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities.



Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal NDCAS*Rate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: *Nuclear Decomissioning Cost Adjustment *Nuclear Decomissioing Cost Adjustment (NDCA).

at 250 Watts $0.56 $0.71$7.11 $3.77 $0.00

$40.00 ($52.16) $40,964.27

($0.03) $12.13$0.01

using 400,000 KWH $1,900.00 $1,484.21 $9,675.79(1000KW Demand)

$291.43 $3,995.00 $23,630.00

$20,627.41using 200,000 KWH $950.00 $742.10 $4,837.90(500KW Demand)

$291.43 $1,992.50 $11,815.00

$1.00 ($1.08)

$25.00 ($26.52)

$765.73using 10,000 KWH $37.20 $50.92 $158.18(25KW Demand)

$8.81 $104.70 $406.00

($0.24) $160.17using 1000 KWH $7.44 $10.23 $31.59(5KW Demand)

$8.81 $21.04 $81.20

$2.20 $0.20$6.58 $8.10 $26.96

$0.10

($0.30) $195.74

$0.05 ($0.14) $79.19

using 2000 KWH $5.18 $52.28 $94.54

$2.75 $3.31 $11.84 $0.55

Utility: PECO Energy Company

using 500 KWH $5.18 $23.20 $32.45

13

Pennsylvania Electric Company

Pennsylvania Electric Company (Penelec), a subsidiary of the FirstEnergy

Corporation, serves approximately 506,000 residential, 78,000 commercial and 2,500

industrial customers. Penelec’s service territory consists of parts of the following

counties: Armstrong; Bedford; Blair; Bradford; Cambria; Centre; Clarion; Clearfield;

Crawford; Cumberland; Erie; Forrest; Franklin; Huntingdon; Indiana; Jefferson; Juniata;

Lycoming; McKean; Mifflin; Perry; Potter; Somerset; Sullivan; Susquehanna; Tioga;

Venango; Warren; Wayne; Westmoreland; and Wyoming. Penelec’s service territory

comprises 17,600 square miles in Northern and Central Pennsylvania. Pursuant to the

terms of its recently approved rate filing, Penelec operates under the terms of Electric

Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 79, effective Jan. 11, 2007. FirstEnergy Corporation,




the Metropolitan Edison Company and Pennsylvania Power Company.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Utility: Pennsylvania Electric Company

using 500 KWH $7.98 $15.39 $23.48 $3.21 $1.59 $0.19

using 2000 KWH $11.24 $59.41 $93.92 $0.11 $180.60

$0.03 $51.87

$50.94

$7.44$8.86 ($0.38)


$7.73 $16.37


$14.95 $143.93 $509.40

$9,654.00

$0.46

$8.54

$18,216.00

$14,237.03using 200,000 KWH $1,232.00 $875.00(500KW Demand)

$41.29 $2,426.20

$0.01 $14.83


$292.49 $2,086.80 $14.89 $24,825.78

at 250 Watts $14.82

14

Pennsylvania Electric in the Borough of Elkland in Tioga County

Pennsylvania Electric Company (Penelec), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy

Corporation, formerly operated under a separate tariff for the Borough of Elkland in

Tioga County in Northern Pennsylvania. Penelec had operated under a separate tariff

for this small borough after taking over from Elkland Electric Company in 1987.

Pursuant to its recently approved rate filing, Penelec customers in the Borough of

Elkland are now served under Penelec’s Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 79, effective Jan.

11, 2007. Because of the large difference in rates between customers in the former

Elkland territory and current Penelec customers, the former Elkland territory’s customers’

rates are being phased in over the next four years (ending Dec. 3, 2010) with the use of

a discount rider applied to their total bill (Rider O).



Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal Rider O Rate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service Discount** STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: **Rider O applies discounts to the rates of residential, small commercial and medium commerical customers of 16.16 percent, 10.65 percent and 14.46 percent, respectively.

$0.00at 250 Watts

Pennsylvania Electric Company - Elkland Territory



($112.03) $0.73 $663.48using 10,000 KWH $68.50 $38.00(25KW Demand)

$14.95 $143.93 $509.40


$7.73 $16.37 $50.94

$0.74 ($29.63)$12.82 $6.36

($9.24)

$0.17 $153.88

($8.38) $0.05 $43.51

using 2000 KWH $7.98 $61.54 $93.90

$3.21 $1.59 $0.19$23.48

Utility:

using 500 KWH $7.98 $15.39

15

Pennsylvania Power Company

Pennsylvania Power Company (Penn Power), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy

Corporation, serves approximately 138,000 residential, 19,000 commercial and 211

industrial customers. Penn Power’s service territory consists of parts of the following

counties: Allegheny; Beaver; Butler; Crawford; Lawrence; and Mercer. Penn Power’s

service territory comprises 1,100 square miles in Western Pennsylvania. Penn Power

operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 35. FirstEnergy Corporation,




the Pennsylvania Electric Company and Metropolitan Edison Company.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Utility: Penn Power Company

using 500 KWH $8.89 $11.34 $59.67 $0.31

using 2000 KWH $8.86 $31.68 $118.33 $1.20 $161.31

$0.60 $80.81

$88.70

$1.24

$0.84 $112.70using 1000 KWH(5KW Demand)

$14.44 $8.72


$14.44 $95.94 $887.00

$17,740.00

$7.48

$143.39

$34,920.00


$1,378.68

$0.13 $17.98


$1,664.99 $274.39 $36,859.38

at 250 Watts $9.16 $8.69

16

Pike County Light & Power Company

Pike County Light & Power Company (Pike), a subsidiary of Orange & Rockland

Utilities Inc., serves approximately 3,500 residential and 980 commercial customers.

Pike’s service territory consists of Westfall, Milford and Dingman (northern section)

townships, and Matamoras and Milford boroughs in Pike County, Northeastern

Pennsylvania. Pike operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 8. Pike

also provides natural gas service in Pennsylvania in Westfall Township and Matamoras

Borough, Pike County. Orange & Rockland Utilities Inc. (O&R), through their

subsidiaries Pike County Light & Power and Rockland Electric Company, provide service

to roughly 286,000 electric and 123,500 natural gas customers. Based in Pearl River,

New York, O&R’s service area covers 1,350 square miles in Southeastern New York,

Northern New Jersey and Northeastern Pennsylvania.



Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Universal SBC**Rate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: Distribution charges include transmission charges and the demand components are included where applicable.**System Benefits Charges.

Utility: Pike County Light & Power Company

using 500 KWH $5.29 $19.07 $66.43

using 2000 KWH $5.29 $69.02 $240.10 $0.30 $314.95

$0.06 $0.09 $90.94

$138.70

$0.24

$0.12 $0.17 $182.92using 1000 KWH(5KW Demand)

$5.30 $38.63


$5.30 $374.14 $1,212.67

$22,136.81

$1.20 $1.50

$24.00 $27.46

$44,249.06


$5.30 $6,577.06

$0.01 $26.14$0.01


$5.30 $13,156.31 $48.00 $54.88 $57,513.55

at 250 Watts $14.91 $11.21

17

PPL Electric Utilities Corporation

PPL Electric Utilities Corporation (PPL), a subsidiary of the PPL Corporation,

serves approximately 1.2 million residential, 165,000 commercial and 5,000 industrial

customers. PPL’s service territory consists of parts of the following counties in the

eastern half of Pennsylvania: Berks; Bucks; Carbon; Chester; Clinton; Columbia;

Cumberland; Dauphin; Juniata; Lackawanna; Lancaster; Lebanon; Lehigh; Luzerne;

Lycoming; Monroe; Montgomery; Montour; Northampton; Northumberland; Perry, Pike;

Schuylkill; Snyder; Susquehanna; Union; Wyoming; Wayne; and York. PPL operates

under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 201. PPL also provides natural gas

service in Pennsylvania. PPL Corporation, headquartered in Allentown, Pennsylvania,

delivers energy to nearly 5 million customers in Pennsylvania, the United Kingdom and

Latin America, and also generates and sells energy through various subsidiaries.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


at 250 Watts ($0.25) $1.38$14.12 $3.84 $0.64

$34.68 $30,932.68

($0.01) $19.72

using 400,000 KWH $2,272.00 $1,260.00 $3,683.00(1000KW Demand)

$2,429.00 $21,254.00

$15,466.33using 200,000 KWH $1,136.00 $630.00 $1,841.50(500KW Demand)

$1,214.50 $10,627.00

$0.84

$17.33

$838.45using 10,000 KWH $56.80 $18.70 $105.40(25KW Demand)

$118.78 $537.93

$0.09 $120.25using 1000 KWH $5.68 $3.81 $12.66(5KW Demand)

$11.41 $22.64 $63.96

$11.36 $0.64 $16.20 $0.10 $107.73

$0.03 $53.92

using 2000 KWH $16.45 $0.00 $62.98

$2.84 $1.10 $5.13

Utility: PPL Electric Utilities Corporation

using 500 KWH $7.96 $10.30 $26.56

18

UGI Utilities Inc. UGI Utilities, Inc. (UGI), a subsidiary of UGI Corporation, serves approximately

54,000 residential, 7,300 commercial and 160 industrial customers. UGI’s service

territory consists of parts of Luzerne and Wyoming counties in Northeastern

Pennsylvania. UGI operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 5. UGI

also provides natural gas service in Pennsylvania. UGI Corporation, with principal

offices in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, provides electric, gas, propane gas and energy

supply through its subsidiaries UGI Utilities Inc., AmeriGas Inc. and UGI Enterprises Inc.



Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Transmission CTC ITC Bundled EducationRate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Charges Charges STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


at 250 Watts** $18.37

$644.05 $44,456.39

$0.27 $18.64

using 400,000 KWH $778.00(1000KW Demand)

$6,971.80 $36,062.54


$3,569.30 $18,391.04

$17.41

$328.54


$345.10 $818.40

$2.07 $142.82using 1000 KWH $3.11(5KW Demand)

$6.75 $40.35 $90.54

$7.40 $3.32 $228.84

$1.09 $75.60

using 2000 KWH $5.50 $48.96 $163.66

$1.85

Utility: UGI Utilities Inc. - Electric Division

using 500 KWH $5.50 $15.83 $51.33

19

Wellsboro Electric Company

Wellsboro Electric Company (Wellsboro), a subsidiary of C&T Enterprises Inc.,

serves approximately 4,800 residential, 1,000 commercial and 14 industrial customers.

Wellsboro’s service territory consists of about 178 square miles in the Borough of

Wellsboro and the townships of Charleston, Delmar, and Middlebury in Tioga County in

North Central Pennsylvania. Wellsboro operates under the terms of Electric Tariff Pa.

P.U.C. No. 8. C&T Enterprises Inc. is a holding company owned by the Claverack, and

Tri-County Rural Electric Cooperatives for their for-profit enterprises. C&T also owns

Valley Energy Inc. (gas), and Citizens’ Electric Company.



Customer Charge Distribution Generation (Energy) Demand CTC ITC Universal EducationRate Classification Charges Charges Charges (if applicable) (if applicable) Service Charges STAS TOTALResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: Monthly Minimum Charge for residential is $7.20.Monthly Minimum Charge for small commercial is $6.85.Public Street (sodium vapor service) is at 150 watts.

Utility: Wellsboro Electric Company

using 500 KWH $11.79 $28.41

using 2000 KWH $29.30 $113.65 $0.19 $143.14

$0.05 $40.25

$56.83 $0.13 $97.88using 1000 KWH(5KW Demand)

$40.92

$837.78using 10,000 KWH $98.00(25KW Demand)

$170.41 $568.26

$11,365.20

$1.11

$22.24

$22,730.40

$16,755.64using 200,000 KWH $1,960.00(500KW Demand)

$3,408.20

$0.01 $10.12

using 400,000 KWH $4,828.00(1000KW Demand)

$1,575.33 $38.72 $29,172.45

at 250 Watts $6.25 $3.86

20

West Penn Power d/b/a Allegheny Power West Penn Power d/b/a Allegheny Power (Allegheny), a subsidiary of Allegheny

Energy Inc., serves approximately 610,000 residential, 78,000 commercial and 13,000

industrial customers. Allegheny’s service territory consists of parts of the following

counties in Southwestern and Central Pennsylvania: Adams; Allegheny; Armstrong;

Bedford; Blair; Butler; Cameron; Centre; Clarion; Clinton; Elk; Fayette; Franklin; Fulton;

Greene; Huntingdon; Indiana; Jefferson; Lycoming; McKean; Potter; Somerset;

Washington; and Westmoreland. Allegheny operates under the terms of Electric Tariff

Pa. P.U.C. No. 39. Allegheny Energy Inc. is a utility holding company that, through its

subsidiaries, provides electric and natural gas service to about 4 million customers in

Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Maryland, Virginia and Ohio. Allegheny Energy, Inc. also

has an electric generating subsidiary, Allegheny Energy Supply Company, LLC.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial


Notes: West Penn Power Company sodium vapor overhead service is rate schedule 57 and is 200 watts.

at 250 Watts $0.24$12.36 $3.70 $0.26

$28.62 $22,436.62

$0.02 $16.58


$3,293.60 $15,374.40

$11,457.61using 200,000 KWH $868.20 $1,025.80(500KW Demand)

$1,769.60 $7,779.40

$0.84

$14.61


$160.79 $409.57


$19.63 $47.96

$9.02 $9.36 $0.18 $144.38

$0.05 $39.87

using 2000 KWH $5.00 $37.48 $83.34

$2.27 $2.34

Utility: West Penn Power Company

using 500 KWH $5.00 $9.37 $20.84

21

Section 2: Gas Utilities

Abbreviations Used In The Tables

MCF – One Thousand Cubic Feet, a standard gas measure

TCC – Transition Cost Charge, for companies still recovering deregulation costs

CCC – Customer Choice Costs, for companies still recovering deregulation costs

GCR – Gas Cost Rate

STAS – State Tax Adjustment Surcharge

USC – Universal Service Charge

22

Gas Utilities Comparison - 1307(f) Companies*

Columbia Equitable National PECO People's Philadelphia PPL Gas T.W. Phillips UGI Penn UGI Gas Gas Fuel Gas Energy Natural Gas Gas Works Utilities Gas & Oil Natural Gas Gas

Rate Classification Company Company Dist. Co. Company (PGW) CompanyResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: *1307(f) companies are those companies whose annual revenues are greater than $40 million.

Utilities

Using 2 MCF $33.11 $39.61 $37.41$37.69$39.02 $32.04

$204.26

$47.17 $42.09 $36.02

$191.84

$34.01

$218.68Using 15 MCF $201.45$193.64 $183.55 $275.79$178.39 $221.35 $223.25

$195.30

$447.00 $597.04 $513.11 $811.23 $575.72 $477.53 $622.83

$170.41 $155.33

Using 500 MCF/year $534.57

$193.80 $166.15$256.91$144.22 $187.71 $173.35Using 150 MCF/year

$482.68

$7,460.84 $10,245.00 $8,383.83 $14,305.35 $9,524.88 $106,124.46

$8,903.12 $8,129.50

> 9000 MCF/year $8,357.75

$9,524.88 $8,049.75$14,273.12$7,778.15 $10,245.00 $8,532.63Using 9000 MCF/year

$7,925.37

$181.38

$571.27

$8,801.83

$17,015.25

23

Gas Utilities Comparison - GCR Companies

Able Co. Andreassi Barkeyville C E Dunmire Chartiers CRG, Inc. Herman Oil Herman Riemer Kaib & Kaib Larkin OilLtd. Gas Company Gas Company Gas Company Natural Gas & Gas Co., Inc. Gas Company Gas Company & Gas

Rate Classification Company, Inc.Residential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utilities

Using 2 MCF $45.00 $27.29 $23.50 $17.00 $21.93 $35.86 $12.08 $13.02$16.50

$45.00 $130.64 $114.50 $88.50 $86.49 $195.87 $90.57

$115.00 $77.08 $173.90

$12.95

Using 15 MCF

$150.00 $236.05 $109.38Using 150 MCF/year $74.25

$269.80 $236.50

$97.13 $88.00

$251.59

$75.48

$0.00

$80.94

Using 9000 MCF/year

Using 500 MCF/year $348.33 $221.92$467.92 $306.25

$6,099.03 $5,162.50 $6,015.00 $3,739.50

> 9000 MCF/year

$69.44

24

Myers Gas North East Pike County Pine-Roe Sergeant Gas Sigel Gas Valley Energy Walker Gas & Wally GasCompany Heat & Light Light & Power Natural Gas Company Oil Co., Inc. Company

Rate Classification Company Company Company, Inc.Residential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

> 9000 MCF/year

$9,747.83 $7,337.53

Using 15 MCF

$398.16 $335.74

$9,133.03 $9,747.83 $6,825.19

Using 9000 MCF/year

$517.35 $584.69 $415.00

$9,085.87

Using 500 MCF/year

Using 150 MCF/year $154.99$165.11 $183.66 $126.07 $105.97 $129.92$108.25

$159.89 $184.34

$33.24$23.26 $28.10Using 2 MCF $19.00 $29.62 $31.63

$204.72 $146.43 $0.00

$19.52 $22.86

Gas Utilities Comparison - GCR Companies

$20.74

$90.56

Utilities

$129.50 $186.62 $125.67

25

($0.50)

$4.50

$9.50

$14.50

$19.50

$24.50

$29.50

$34.50

$39.50

$44.50

$49.50

Columbia

Gas

Com

pany

Equita

ble G

as C

ompa

ny

Nation

al Fue

l Gas

Co.

North E

ast H

eat &

Ligh

t Co.

PECO Energy

Gas

People

's Natu

ral G

as

Philad

elphia

Gas

Work

s (PGW)

Pike C

ounty

Ligh

t & Pow

er

PPL Gas

Utilit

ies

T.W. P

hillip

s Gas

& Oil C

o.

UGI Pen

n Natu

ral G

as

UGI Utilit

ies, In

c. Gas

Valley

Energy

, Inc.

Large Gas Utilities (over 1,000 customers): Residential 2 MCFTotal Monthly Bill Calculation as of January 31, 2007

Customer & Distribution Charges Gas Commodity & Gas Cost Adj. Other

26

($0.50)

$49.50

$99.50

$149.50

$199.50

$249.50

$299.50

Columbia

Gas

Com

pany

Equita

ble G

as C

ompa

ny

Nation

al Fue

l Gas

Co.

North E

ast H

eat &

Ligh

t Co.

PECO Energy

Gas

People

's Natu

ral G

as

Philad

elphia

Gas

Work

s (PGW)

Pike C

ounty

Ligh

t & Pow

er

PPL Gas

Utilit

ies

T.W. P

hillip

s Gas

& Oil C

o.

UGI Pen

n Natu

ral G

as

UGI Utilit

ies, In

c. Gas

Valley

Energy

, Inc.

Large Gas Utilities (over 1,000 customers): Residential Heating 15 MCFTotal Monthly Bill Calculation as of January 31, 2007

Customer & Distribution Charges Gas Commodity & Gas Cost Adj. Other

27

Able Company Ltd. Able Company Ltd. (Able) provides natural gas service in Kittanning Township

and Wayne Township in Armstrong County; Upper Burrell and Hempfield townships in

Westmoreland County; and Armstrong Township in Indiana County. Able operates

under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1. Able provides a flat rate for all thousand cubic feet

(MCF) of gas consumed for both residential and commercial customers. Residential

rates are gauged according to the square footage of a building and consist of the

following categories: mobile home; detached garage with gas heater; and house and

swimming pool with heater.

For the purpose of this report, the residential rate was calculated using a house

consisting of between 1,300 and 1,500 square feet, and a commercial building

consisting of between 2,000 to 3,000 feet.

Default Rate Schedule for Gas Service in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania


Customer Distribution Gas Cost Customer Universal EducationRate Classification Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge ChargeResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Able charges flat monthly rates based on the square footage of the customers' buildings.

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year

$0.00(monthly bill)

$150.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year

$45.00

150 MCF/year$150.00

$45.00

15 MCF (monthly bill) $45.00

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $45.00

Utility: Able Company L.T.D.

Commodity STAS

28

Andreassi Gas Company

Andreassi Gas Company provides natural gas service to the public in portions of

Armstrong and Butler counties, Pennsylvania. They currently provide service to

approximately 342 residential customers and 19 commercial customers.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$6,099.03(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

$574.059000 MCF/year

$136.68 $5,388.30



500 MCF/year$136.68 $299.35 $31.89

$130.64

150 MCF/year$136.68 $89.81 $9.57

$27.29

15 MCF (monthly bill) $11.39 $107.77 $11.48

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $11.39 $14.37 $1.53

Utility: Andreassi Gas Company

Commodity STAS

29

Barkeyville Gas Company

Barkeyville Gas Company (Barkeyville) provides natural gas service to the public

in the Borough of Barkeyville and Irwin Township in Venango County. Barkeyville

provides service to residential, commercial and residential customers. Barkeyville

operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)


> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year$100.00 $5,062.50



500 MCF/year$25.00 $281.25

$114.50

150 MCF/year$25.00 $84.38

$23.50

15 MCF (monthly bill) $9.50 $105.00

TOTALCharge


Utility: Barkeyville Gas Company

Commodity STAS

30

Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc.

Chartiers Natural Gas Company Inc. (Chartiers) provides natural gas service to

the public in the Munntown, Nottingham and North Strabane townships, and in various

isolated lease areas in Washington and Allegheny counties, Pennsylvania. Chartiers

provides natural gas to approximately 250 residential customers and 10 commercial

customers throughout their designated service territory. Chartiers operates under Gas

Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: Chartiers Natural Gas Co.

Commodity STAS TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $9.65 $0.28 $21.93

15 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $72.39 $2.10 $86.49

150 MCF/year$15.00 $60.33 $1.75 $77.08(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$15.00 $201.09 $5.83 $221.92(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$15.00 $3,619.58 $104.93 $3,739.50(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$0.00(monthly bill)

31

Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc.

Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc. (Columbia) is a provider of gas service to the

public in the following counties: Adams; Allegheny; Beaver; Bedford; Butler; Centre;

Chester; Clarion; Clearfield; Elk; Fayette; Fulton; Green; Indiana; Jefferson; Lawrence;

McKean; Mercer; Somerset; Venango; Warren; Washington; Westmoreland; and York.

Columbia currently provides service to approximately 370,000 residential customers,

38,000 commercial customers and 340 industrial customers. Columbia operates under

Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 9.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: The Customer Charge reflects the effect of the state tax adjustment surcharge. The Customer Choice Costs and Universal Service Charges representColumbia's Rider CC and Rider CAP, respectively. These costs are reflected in Columbia's base rates included in the "Distribution Charge" column of this report.

Utility: Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania Inc.


2 MCF (monthly bill) $10.76 $15.42 $5.84 ($0.13) $0.02 $1.23 ($0.02) $33.11

15 MCF (monthly bill) $10.76 $115.63 $43.78 ($0.97) $0.15 $9.20 ($0.17) $178.39

150 MCF/year$14.46 $97.08 $33.47 ($0.81) $0.13 ($0.10) $144.22(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$14.46 $323.58 $111.56 ($2.68) $0.42 ($0.33) $447.00(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$22.50 $5,824.35 $1,977.88 ($48.30) $7.50 ($5.79) $7,778.15(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$71.76 $5,624.40 $1,817.03 ($48.30) ($4.05) $7,460.84(monthly bill)

32

CRG Inc.

CRG, Inc. (CRG) provides natural gas service to the public in the Townships of

Farmington, Highland and Millcreek in Clarion County; Millstone, Elk County; Barnett

and Jenks, Forest County; and Barnett, Eldred and Heath in Jefferson County. CRG

provides service to 271 residential customers and 34 commercial customers. CRG




Customer Distribution GCR Customer Universal EducationRate Classification Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge ChargeResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Please note that a additional 6 percent is added for sales tax for small commercial customers.

Utility: CRG Inc. (Clarion River Gas)


2 MCF (monthly bill) $11.48 $18.79 $3.84 $1.75 $35.86

15 MCF (monthly bill) $11.48 $140.93 $28.83 $14.63 $195.87

150 MCF/year$11.48 $117.45 $34.02 $10.95 $173.90(monthly bill)

500 MCF/yearn/a $0.00(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/yearn/a $0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/yearn/a $0.00(monthly bill)

33

C.E. Dunmire Gas Company

C.E. Dunmire Gas Company (Dunmire) furnishes gas service to 64 residential

customers in portions of North Buffalo, East Franklin and Washington townships in

Armstrong County. Dunmire operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: C.E. Dunmire Gas Co.


2 MCF (monthly bill) $6.00 $11.00 $17.00

15 MCF (monthly bill) $6.00 $82.50 $88.50

150 MCF/year$15.00 $100.00 $115.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$15.00 $333.33 $348.33(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$15.00 $6,000.00 $6,015.00(monthly bill)


34

Equitable Gas Company

Equitable Gas Company (Equitable) is a division of Equitable Resources, Inc., a

gas supplier to customers in Pennsylvania, Kentucky and West Virginia. In

Pennsylvania, Equitable provides gas service to the City of Pittsburgh and various

boroughs and townships in Allegheny, Armstrong, Butler, Clarion, Fayette, Greene,

Indiana, Jefferson, Washington and Westmoreland counties. Equitable operates under

Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 22. Equitable’s tariff lists two divisions -- Equitable and

Apollo. Although the same rates are applied to both divisions, Equitable has

approximately 210,000 residential customers, 14,000 commercial customers and 53

industrial customers. Equitable Resources Inc. is currently involved in a proposed

acquisition of Dominion Resources Inc.’s Pennsylvania Gas Utility, Dominion Peoples.

As of the date of this Report’s compilation, the acquisition has not been approved by the

Commission.



Customer Distribution GCR Transition Universal EducationRate Classification Charge Charge Adjustment Surcharge Service Charge ChargeResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: ***Industrial customers with annual throughput in excess of 25,000 MCF pay a monthly customer charge of $800.

Utility: Equitable Gas Company


2 MCF (monthly bill) $11.65 $17.66 $5.05 $4.20 $0.45 $0.60 $39.61

15 MCF (monthly bill) $11.65 $132.45 $37.85 $31.50 $3.41 $4.50 $221.35

150 MCF/year$17.00 $110.38 $31.96 $26.25 $2.13 $187.71(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$28.00 $367.92 $106.54 $87.50 $7.08 $597.04(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$150.00 $6,622.50 $1,770.00 $1,575.00 $127.50 $10,245.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$150.00 $6,622.50 $1,770.00 $1,575.00 $127.50 $10,245.00(monthly bill)***

35

Herman Oil and Gas Company Inc.

Herman Oil and Gas Company Inc. (Herman) provides for the distribution of gas

to customers in a portion of Summit, Clearfield and Winfield townships in Butler County,

Pennsylvania. Herman operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 4. Herman’s current

tariff offers one set rate of $6.0381 per MCF for all gas used for both residential and

commercial customers.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: Herman Oil & Gas Company




150 MCF/year$75.48 $75.48(monthly bill)


9000 MCF/year$0.00(monthly bill)


36

Herman Riemer Gas Company

Anna Pearl Riemer, t/d/b/a Herman Riemer Gas Company (Riemer Gas),

provides natural gas service in Buffalo, Clinton and Jefferson Townships, Butler County,

Pennsylvania. Riemer Gas provides service to approximately 560 residential customers

and 50 commercial customers. Riemer Gas operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year



500 MCF/year$251.49 $18.31

$97.13

150 MCF/year$75.45 $5.49

$12.95


TOTALCharge


Utility: Herman Riemer Gas Company

Commodity STAS

37

Kaib & Kaib Gas Company

Kaib & Kaib Gas Company (Kaib & Kaib) provides natural gas service to the

public in the Borough of Hazen and the Township of Warsaw in Jefferson County,

Pennsylvania. Kaib & Kaib provides gas service to 44 residential customers and two

commercial customers. Kaib & Kaib operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: All customers pay $5.50 per MCF plus a $5.50 monthly service charge.

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/yearN/A

9000 MCF/yearN/A



500 MCF/year$5.50 $231.00

$88.00

150 MCF/year$5.50 $68.75

$16.50


TOTALCharge


Utility: Kaib & Kaib Gas Company

Commodity STAS

38

Larkin Oil & Gas Company

Larkin Oil and Gas Company (Larkin) provides natural gas service in Perry

Township, Clarion County, and Madison Township, Armstrong County. Larkin’s

customer base consists of 25 residential customers. Larkin operates under Gas Tariff

Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year

$69.44

150 MCF/year

$13.02


TOTALCharge


Utility: Larkin Oil & Gas, Inc.

Commodity STAS

39

Mountain Energy Ltd.

On March 11, 2004, Mountain Energy Ltd. adopted as its tariff the current tariff of

Greenridge Oil Inc. of Pennsylvania. Mountain Energy provides gas service to 170

residential customers in the Townships of Richhill, Aleppo, Springhill, Jackson, Freeport

and Center in Greene County, Pennsylvania. Mountain Energy operates under Gas

Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year

$67.25

150 MCF/year

$12.00


TOTALCharge


Utility: Mountain Energy Ltd.

Commodity STAS

40

Myers Gas Company

Myers Gas Company furnishes natural gas service to the public in Rockland

Township, Venango County, Pennsylvania. Myers Gas currently has 190 residential

customers. Myers Gas operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 10.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: Meyers Gas



15 MCF (monthly bill) $129.50 $129.50





41

National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation

National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation (NFG) furnishes natural gas service to

the public in portions of the following counties: Armstrong; Butler; Cameron; Clarion;

Clearfield; Crawford; Elk; Erie; Forest; Jefferson; McKean; Mercer; Venango; and

Warren. NFG currently serves 199,000 residential customers, 15,000 commercial

customers and 600 industrial customers. NFG operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C.

No.9.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Customer charges are shown as a $/month and are not dependent on consumption.

Utility: National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation


2 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $20.60 $7.50 ($1.74) $0.66 $0.00 $39.02

15 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $154.47 $45.88 ($13.05) $4.96 $0.00 $204.26

150 MCF/year$19.89 $128.73 $35.61 ($10.88) $0.00 $173.35(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$27.53 $429.12 $92.72 ($36.25) ($0.01) $513.11(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$121.01 $7,723.58 $1,340.69 ($652.50) ($0.15) $8,532.63(monthly bill)


42

North East Heat & Light Company

North East Heat & Light Company (North East) provides natural gas service in

North East, Erie County, Pennsylvania. North East provides natural gas to

approximately 2,600 residential customers, 280 commercial customers and 14 industrial

customers. North East operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 12.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial



> 9000 MCF/year$75.50 $8,475.53 $582.00

$582.009000 MCF/year

$28.34 $8,475.53



500 MCF/year$14.15 $470.86 $32.33

$186.62

150 MCF/year$14.15 $141.26 $9.70

$29.62

15 MCF (monthly bill) $5.47 $169.51 $11.64

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $5.47 $22.60 $1.55

Utility: North East Heat & Light Company

Commodity STAS

43

PECO Energy Company

PECO Energy Company (PECO), a subsidiary of the Exelon Corporation

(Exelon), serves approximately 430,000 residential, 40,000 small commercial and

industrial, and 670 large commercial and industrial customers. PECO’s service territory

consists of parts of Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Lancaster and Montgomery counties in

Southeastern Pennsylvania. PECO operates under the terms of Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C.

No. 2. PECO also provides electric service to over 1.4 million customers in the

Philadelphia area. Exelon’s proposed merger with Public Service Enterprise Group Inc.

has been withdrawn, despite having been approved by the Commission on Jan. 27,

2006 and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on July 1, 2005. The withdrawal

was primarily caused by the inability of the parties to reach consensus with the New

Jersey Board of Public Utilities. Exelon, through its utility operating companies, is one of

the nation’s largest electric utilities. Exelon is headquartered in Chicago and provides

service to customers in Illinois and Pennsylvania.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Industrial rate is based on "Rate L" using 9,000 MCF/year.***Commodity Charge used here is PECO's PGC which includes Commodity Charge, Gas Cost Adjustment and the Balancing Service Cost.

Utility: PECO Energy Company

Commodity STAS TOTALCharge***

2 MCF (monthly bill) $7.20 $19.33 $5.62 $0.03 ($0.14) $32.04

15 MCF (monthly bill) $7.20 $144.95 $42.15 $0.20 ($0.86) $193.64

150 MCF/year$14.40 $120.79 $35.97 ($0.75) $170.41(monthly bill)


9000 MCF/year$14.40 $7,247.40 $1,680.67 ($39.35) $8,903.12(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$410.98 $7,247.40 $736.31 ($36.94) $8,357.75(monthly bill)

44

The Peoples Natural Gas Company d/b/a Dominion Peoples

The Peoples Natural Gas Company d/b/a Dominion Peoples (Dominion

Peoples), a subsidiary of Dominion, serves approximately 326,000 residential, 30,000

commercial and 200 industrial customers. Dominion Peoples’ service territory consists

of parts of the following counties in Southwestern Pennsylvania: Allegheny; Armstrong;

Beaver; Blair; Butler; Cambria; Clarion; Fayette; Greene; Indiana; Lawrence; Mercer;

Somerset; Venango; Washington; and Westmoreland. Dominion Peoples operates

under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 43. Dominion, through its many subsidiary companies,

is one of the nation’s largest producers of energy, and also delivers energy to over five

million customers in eight states in the Northeastern United States. Dominion is based

in Richmond, Virginia. Dominion Peoples is in the process of being acquired by

Equitable Resources Inc. As of the date of this Report’s compilation, the acquisition has

not been approved by the Commission.



Customer Distribution GCR** Customer Universal EducationRate Classification Charge Charge Adjustment Choice Costs Service Charge ChargeResidential

Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: The distribution charges for small commercial (150 MCF/year) and medium commercial (500 MCF/year) reflect a declining block rate structure. The rates are asfollows: First five MCF $3.2157, next five MCF $2.6684, next 20 MCF $2.2152 and over 30 MCF $1.9602. **The GCR includes capacity, commodity, and GCA.

Utility: Dominion Peoples


2 MCF (monthly bill) $11.00 $5.38 $17.67 ($0.04) $34.01

15 MCF (monthly bill) $11.00 $40.35 $132.50 ($0.30) $183.55



9000 MCF/year$52.25 $1,462.95 $6,625.13 ($10.83) $8,129.50(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$52.25 $1,257.30 $6,625.13 ($9.30) $7,925.37(monthly bill)

45

Philadelphia Gas Works

Philadelphia Gas Works (PGW) serves approximately 480,000 residential and

27,000 industrial and commercial customers within the City of Philadelphia. PGW is the

largest municipally owned gas utility in the nation. PGW operates under Gas Tariff Pa.

P.U.C. No. 2.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Customer choice cost includes restructuring and consumer education. The industrial bill assumes (9,000/12) MCF.The default service is assumed to be firm, sales service.

$998.05 $14,305.35(monthly bill)

$995.80 $14,273.12(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$50.00 $8,115.53 $3,227.18 $68.40 $49.65 $1,796.55

$68.40 $49.65 $1,796.559000 MCF/year

$18.00 $8,115.53 $3,229.20

$56.60 $811.23(monthly bill)

$17.92 $256.91(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$18.00 $450.86 $179.40 $3.80 $2.76 $99.81

$275.79

150 MCF/year$18.00 $135.26 $53.82 $1.14 $0.83 $29.94

$47.17

15 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $162.31 $63.19 $1.37 $0.99 $35.93

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $12.00 $21.64 $8.42 $0.18 $0.13 $4.79

Utility: Philadelphia Gas Works

Commodity STAS

46

T.W. Phillips Gas & Oil Company

T.W. Phillips Gas & Oil Company (T.W. Phillips), based in Butler, Pennsylvania,

serves approximately 57,000 residential, 4,400 commercial and 20 industrial customers.

T.W. Phillips’ service territory consists of parts of Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler,

Clarion, Clearfield, Indiana, Jefferson, and Westmoreland counties in Western

Pennsylvania. T.W. Phillips operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 6.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial (1)

Notes: T.W. Phillips used consumption of 20,001 MCF for the industrial customer as this is minimum usage to be considered an industrial customer.

Utility: T.W. Phillips Gas and Oil Company


2 MCF (monthly bill) $12.50 $18.75 $7.71 ($1.26) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($0.00) $37.69

15 MCF (monthly bill) $12.50 $140.62 $57.83 ($9.47) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($0.03) $201.45

150 MCF/year$28.00 $118.85 $42.57 ($8.02) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($0.03) $181.38(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$60.00 $396.18 $141.91 ($26.72) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($0.10) $571.27(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/year$380.00 $6,863.33 $2,004.68 ($444.45) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($1.73) $8,801.83(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$2,080.00 $14,203.54 $1,664.75 ($929.21) $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 ($3.83) $17,015.25(monthly bill)

47

Pike County Light & Power Company

Pike County Light & Power Company (Pike), a subsidiary of Orange & Rockland

Utilities Inc., serves approximately 1,154 customers. Pike’s service territory consists of

Westfall Township and Matamoras Borough, in Pike County, Northeastern Pennsylvania.

Pike operates under the terms of Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 6. Orange & Rockland

Utilities Inc. (O&R), through their subsidiaries Pike County Light & Power and Rockland

Electric Company, provide service to roughly 286,000 electric and 123,500 natural gas

customers. Based in Pearl River, New York, O&R’s service area covers 1,350 square

miles in Southeastern New York, Northern New Jersey and Northeastern Pennsylvania.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: Pike County Light & Power Company


2 MCF (monthly bill) $5.00 $24.70 $1.94 ($0.01) $31.63

15 MCF (monthly bill) $5.00 $185.25 $14.51 ($0.04) $204.72



9000 MCF/year$5.00 $9,018.93 $725.70 ($1.80) $9,747.83(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$5.00 $9,018.93 $725.70 ($1.80) $9,747.83(monthly bill)

48

Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. Pine-Roe Natural Gas Company Inc. (Pine-Roe) serves customers in the

Townships of Beaver, Clarion, Monroe and Piney in Clarion County, Western

Pennsylvania. Pine-Roe serves approximately 163 residential customers and operates

under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year

$146.43

150 MCF/year

$19.52


TOTALCharge


Utility: Pine Roe Natural Gas Company

Commodity STAS

49

PPL Gas Utilities Corporation PPL Gas Utilities Corporation (PPL Gas) distributes gas in Pennsylvania and

operates under PPL Gas Utilities’ Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 3. PPL Gas serves

approximately 66,000 residential, 9,800 commercial, and 313 industrial customers in

North Central and Eastern Pennsylvania. Although the rates below reflect those in effect

on Jan. 31, 2007, it should be noted that pursuant to its recently approved rate filing,

new rates will be going into effect on Feb. 9, 2007. PPL also provides electric service in

Pennsylvania. PPL Corporation, headquartered in Allentown, Lehigh County,

Pennsylvania, delivers energy to nearly 5 million customers in Pennsylvania, the United

Kingdom and Latin America, and also generates and sells energy through various

subsidiaries.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Utility: PPL Gas Utilities


2 MCF (monthly bill) $10.50 $22.37 $9.53 ($0.30) ($0.01) $42.09

15 MCF (monthly bill) $10.50 $164.07 $50.94 ($2.23) ($0.03) $223.25



9000 MCF/year$18.00 $8,222.91 $1,397.46 ($112.06) ($1.43) $9,524.88(monthly bill)


50

Sergeant Gas Company Inc. Sergeant Gas Company Inc. (Sergeant) serves approximately 103 residential

and 17 commercial customers. Sergeant’s service territory is comprised of Wetmore

Township in McKean County and Jones Township in Elk County, Northwestern

Pennsylvania. Sergeant operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 10.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Everything is included in commodity.

Utility: Sergeant Gas Company Inc.


2 MCF (monthly bill) See note $21.37 See note $1.49 $22.86

15 MCF (monthly bill) N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A $0.00

150 MCF/yearSee note $116.39 See note $9.68 $126.07(monthly bill)

500 MCF/yearSee note $366.87 See note $31.29 $398.16(monthly bill)



51

Sigel Gas Company

Sigel Gas Company (Sigel) based in New Bethlehem, Clarion County,

Pennsylvania, serves approximately 131 residential and 14 commercial customers.

Sigel’s service territory is comprised of Barnett, Clover, Rose and Union townships in

Jefferson County, Western Pennsylvania. Sigel operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C.

No. 3.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year



500 MCF/year$7.50 $269.78 $58.46

$125.67

150 MCF/year$7.50 $80.94 $17.54

$23.26

15 MCF (monthly bill) $7.50 $97.12 $21.05

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $7.50 $12.95 $2.81

Utility: Sigel Gas

Commodity STAS

52

UGI Utilities Inc. UGI Utilities Inc. (UGI), a subsidiary of UGI Corporation, serves approximately

280,000 residential, 30,000 commercial and 1,500 industrial customers. UGI’s service

territory consists of parts of Berks, Bucks, Carbon, Chester, Cumberland, Dauphin,

Lancaster, Lebanon, Lehigh, Luzerne, Monroe, Montgomery, Northampton, Schuylkill

and York counties in Eastern Pennsylvania. UGI operates under the terms of Gas Tariff

Pa. P.U.C. No. 5. UGI also provides electric service in Pennsylvania. UGI Penn Natural

Gas, Inc. is a wholly-owned direct subsidiary of UGI. UGI Corporation, with principal

offices in King of Prussia, Pennsylvania, provides electric, gas, propane gas, and energy

supply through its subsidiaries UGI Utilities Inc., AmeriGas Inc. and UGI Enterprises Inc.



Customer Distribution Gas Cost Customer Universal EducationRate Classification Charge Charge Rate (GCR) Choice Costs Service Charge ChargeResidential

Residential Heating(if different)

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes:

Utility:

Commodity STAS

UGI Utilities Inc., - Gas

TOTALCharge

2 mcf (monthly bill) $8.55 $6.89 $21.79 $0.25 ($0.06) $37.41

$8.55 $45.23 $163.40 $1.88 ($0.37) $218.6815 mcf (monthly bill)

150 mcf/year $8.55 $50.92 $136.16 ($0.33) $195.30

500 mcf/year $8.55 $161.46 $453.88 $622.83

9000 mcf/year NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

NA NA

($1.06)

NA $0.00

***Consistent with UGI’s Restructuring Filing and in accord with the Natural Gas Choice and Competition Act, UGI does not maintain an obligation to provide default service for customers having annual use of 4,000 MCF or greater. Service to new customers under, or transfers of existing customers or customer loads to, default (Rate N) retail service provided by UGI where annual use is projected to be 4,000 MCF or greater, is permitted only as determined by the Company, subject to reasonable limitations. Accordingly, as availability is determined on a case-by-case basis, UGI has not provided bill information for default service where usage exceeds 4,000 MCF annually.

NA $0.00

> 9000 mcf/year NA NA NA NA NA

53

UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc. UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc. (UGI Penn) was formerly PG Energy. PG Energy

was a division of the Southern Union Company (Southern Union). UGI Corporation

purchased UGI Penn on Aug. 24, 2006, and subsequently made UGI Penn a wholly

owned direct subsidiary of UGI Utilities Inc. UGI Penn serves approximately 144,000

residential, 15,000 commercial, and 280 industrial customers. UGI Penn service territory

consists of parts of Columbia, Lackawanna, Luzerne, Lycoming, Montour

Northumberland, Clinton, Snyder, Susquehanna, Union and Wyoming counties in

Northeastern Pennsylvania. UGI Penn operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 7. UGI

Penn, headquartered in Wilkes-Barre, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, is Northeast and

Central Pennsylvania's largest natural gas distribution company.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: For calculation purposes, 122400 MCF/year were used for the industrial category.Slight differences in totals are due to rounding.

$40.80 $317.42 $106,124.46(monthly bill)

$24.08 $8,049.75(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$45.00 $93,942.00 $13,235.80 ($1,456.56)

($107.10) $3.009000 MCF/year

$30.00 $6,907.50 $1,192.28

$0.17 $1.43 $477.53(monthly bill)

$0.50 $166.15(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year$20.00 $383.75 $78.14 ($5.95)

$0.57 $191.84

150 MCF/year$20.00 $115.13 $32.26 ($1.79) $0.05

$0.11 $36.02

15 MCF (monthly bill) $11.75 $138.15 $43.45 ($2.14) $0.06

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $11.75 $18.42 $6.02 ($0.29) $0.01

Utility: UGI Penn Natural Gas Inc.

Commodity STAS

54

Valley Energy Inc. Valley Energy Inc. (Valley), based in Sayre, Pennsylvania, serves approximately

4,500 residential, 700 commercial and 50 industrial customers. Valley’s service territory

is comprised of parts of Bradford County in Northern Pennsylvania. Valley operates

under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$7.21 $6,825.19(monthly bill)

$7.75 $7,337.53(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year$51.68 $890.42 $5,875.88

$5,875.889000 MCF/year

$7.76 $1,446.14



500 MCF/year$7.76 $80.34 $326.46

$0.17 $159.89

150 MCF/year$7.76 $24.10 $97.93

$0.03 $28.10

15 MCF (monthly bill) $7.82 $34.38 $117.52

TOTALCharge

2 MCF (monthly bill) $7.82 $4.58 $15.67

Utility: Valley Energy, Inc.

Commodity STAS

55

Walker Gas and Oil Company Walker Gas and Oil Company (Walker), based in Bruin, Butler County,

Pennsylvania, serves approximately 291 customers in Butler County, Western

Pennsylvania. Walker operates under Gas Tariff Pa. P.U.C. No. 1.




Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

Notes: Please note that an additional 6 percent is added for sales tax to the total for small commercial customers.

Utility: Walker Gas and Oil Company


2 MCF (monthly bill) $10.00 $15.32 $6.21 $1.71 $33.24

15 MCF (monthly bill) $10.00 $114.90 $46.63 $12.81 $184.34

150 MCF/year$10.00 $95.75 $38.56 $10.68 $154.99(monthly bill)

500 MCF/yearN/A $0.00(monthly bill)

9000 MCF/yearN/A $0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/yearN/A $0.00(monthly bill)

56

Wally Gas Company Wally Gas Company serves customers in the Townships of East Franklin and

North Buffalo in Armstrong County, Western Pennsylvania. Wally Gas Company





Residential Heating

Small Commercial

Medium Commercial

Large Commercial

Industrial

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

> 9000 MCF/year

9000 MCF/year

$0.00(monthly bill)

$0.00(monthly bill)

500 MCF/year

$90.56

150 MCF/year

$20.74


TOTALCharge


Utility: Wally Gas Company

Commodity STAS

57

Pennsylvania Public Utility CommissionP.O. box 3265

Harrisburg, PA 17105-3265www.puc.state.pa.us

&rpplvvlrq 5dwh &rpsdulvrq 5hsruw $sulo · $765.73 $775.24 $1,004.86 $1,594.81 $838.45...

Documents