sergio alberto macal-ventura, a200 589 069 (bia feb. 20, 2014)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
1/10
Garcia, Ana I., Esqhmad Law Oice PLLC333 Vine Street Suite 220exington, 4050
tt t
Executive Oce r Immgaon Rview
ard Immigatin AppealsOce he Clerk
5107 Lebg Pik St 000Fl Chuc, Vgn 20530
HS/ICE Oice of Cief Cousel - BUF30 Delaware Aveue Room 203Bao NY 4202
Name: MCAVENTURA , SERGO AL A 200-589-069
Date of this notice 2/20/204
closed s a cpy of he Boar's dcs a dr he bve-ece case.
cosre
P mb:Gendelserger ohndknslanch Charles Gran dad
Sceey,
D cD CCf Ck
Tm: ocke
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
2/10
p JEx f R
D p
FCu V File: 20 589 69-Balo, Dat
re SERGIO TO MV
EMOV PROCGS
PPE
ON BEH O SPO . c Esqie
ON BF O HS Mchl HenquAsistant Chif Counse
FEB 2 0 014
{
The rspondnt, native ad citizen o Mexico, was order rmod in absntia onJuy 1, 2011 n Januy 12, 2012, the respondent ed a timly motion to rpn pceings,hch th mition dg denied on My 212 h espondent d a tmey appal ohat dision e appeal wil e ustaied, prcdings will be reopend and the rod beremdd
Th mmiation Jdg deied e respondent's motion to pen nding h fai tostish xcptiona ccumstacs is iur to app at te hing oe, uponrview, e nd that te totaity of cicumstances psnt in this cas conit excna
crcmstce the repondent au to appe at s heig Secto 24(e) of th A;8 U.SC. 1229(e. Accordinly, w ll alo the rpondent other opponi to aper a harn
OER The appeal is suained, e n abena oder scind, th pocins erond, d t reord is rmde to the mmgaon Judge he pcedgs
Cite as: Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
3/10
'
UNITED S TES EP RM O JSTXECIVE OFFICE FOR IMMGRT EW
NTE STATES MMIGTION CORTBUFFALO, NEW YR
Fe o.: 200-5909
n the aer of:
MacalVena Sergo beo
Responden
ON BEHAF O RESPOENTAnna I. Gca Esq333 W e St Se 220Lexngton K 00
I Removal Poceedings
EHAL F THE GOVEMEchee Henues Cef Cne30 Deawae Ave Se. 203Bao NY 22
ORER OF E IMGI JDGE
I BACKGRO A PROCER ISTR
Responden a yeo me ae nd cze of exco He enee e Ue
Staes wou nsecon at n ow ace on an uow ae On arc 2 20
mgao aoes enconee esponde ook o cso an seed w a
Noce o pea NT cagg a eovae sua o IN 22(a)) as
alen reset e ed Saes o avng een ated o aoled o o ave a an
e o lace oe an as desgaed e oe enea x Te oeen nae
oceedns agans esonden n s wth e aaa Imgton Co on ac
30 2
n 1, 20 espode aee an a eae ase caea eang
and s cone Wae a " a aeaed teleonca o s oce in
1
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
4/10
engon Kentuy Ad r qu t d ddtol im pa ad reondent' e u Ar 27, 201 epondent w reeed o utody on 18, 201
d h ce w trrred to the Bao migao Co epondent w hedule o
ape a ater endr herng on June 4, 20.
On June 3, 20, repondent led utiey otion to er teehonicy r the
Jue 4, 20, heng eonde amed he led to ey e the otion due to
overgt o coune (oton o cet Utmey Fg t , ne 3, 0) On ne 14 20
reponden ed eond untey otion teehon heag. e une 4 oton w
cconed y adv o An Gc ria" ote n Mr. hd'
ofce lng e ied e Je oton o June 7 2, but eed er cling te
Court to ow up tha he Co ever eceive t
he Cor agreed to ow boh repode d r Ad to pear eephocay o
Mr d oce r the ne 4, 0 eaig t when he Cor cale Mr. Aad'
oce o begin te eaig repoen w not ere. r. d oe ired he Court
tht repodent hd bee tere erler ut e teporariy. We the Court le econd te
Mr Ahmd oce cied reoen h ered but r Aad e o tten other
earing en te Co led r. had oe a third tie he Court greed o continue
reondent' cae unti Jue 6, 20, n gin greed hat reondent d Ahma cod
ea teeonicly he Court ent repoe eang notce he Jue 16 herng
idicag ha he od e pepae o proee ce a te Co wod grt o
e couce
O Je , 201, epoden a . ha apeared eepoicy om M
a oce epoe te a o e aeao d concede te chge of
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
5/10
. J Jreviy n s N d sgna M xic t c01 r C respnen's missns d esalsed is namssii
Despie he urs wang tt d n inend grn ny rher cninuances, Mr
d was unreped and requesed dina tie ecie what relef resnden wuld be
seeking The Gveent jeced u iicaed wuld nt pse reques r vlunr
depareThe ur ased r a wat gruds e a r believing resndent my e
eligie r relief er an vunary dearure r ad dd n nswer, but se hat e
n ye ha an pruy t g hug exaustve list f pssible relief." he ur
greed ne nl cninunce set respndes cse r n indiviul earing n uy
201 a 00 PM e Curt prvied bt r m nd respnden, thrug he inerpreer,
wi ral nice f e dae nd me te eng e u als prvided respnen wi
wren ering ntice exressly saing a e d Mr d, uless herwise uthrized
were pear i persn i Bual, ew Yrk (Ex )
On uly 21 respdet ed t r a cange f venue sttng t e resides in
Lexingtn, Kency, nd t []ravel ua wuld be prhibively exensive and
dicult age" n r Cage Venue a 2 uly 2) Respnden cimed he
wul suer cserble dsip d ncveence i adequatey preprng and presentng
tesmny suppr f s pssbe pplca r asylum r withlng remvl becuse
his [pena wnesses d suppg evdece were cae etucy (I s n Juy
11 resde e a r a eepc earg case e ur deied hs mtin
chae eue
n Juy 7 e eren ed a eru psng respdens uy
ms On uly 1 1, e ur deed ms nd eressly stated a respdens
3
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
6/10
,
heing would g rwd n Bfo. Te Cor noted respodent stll a otset fr wt nyspecicity what relief e itene t seek, and ha ile t ieni any witnesses r evience
e wol be nabe to ring t Buo.
On Jly 8, 201, pety nawre o te Cr's Jy 2, 201, orer resnent
ed rely to te Govere s respse t is motios
Respoent ied t per r is Jy 1, 2011, inva eag e h ee
prvide wit wite notice the time, dte ocati o te earng te Co condcted
te earing in abset Te Crt d respoents ire to apper constitte abanonment
n appicatis r relef he ay have ee elge to e an oreed resnent remve
to Mexic
On Jany 12, 2012, resoet ed moton t reope cliing e i nt receive
roper notice of his Jy , 2011, earig O Febry 1, 202, the ovemet ed
respse to respodents oto o reoe O Mrc 5 202, te Cot otied te prties tat
t wol deer is decs o resonets o tl er tey ha resented ora arguments
O Mrc , 202, te Cot wtdrew respoes cae om te ora agment calendar n
ied te ies t it wl sse wrte ecis
I EG STDRDS and SIS
Any ie wo s to aper r removal pocees s e rdered reove in
bsenti he Govemet estbises y ce equivc d cvincing evience tt (1)
rite ce o e rceedgs ws prery prvie to te e (2) te len is
removable IA 240(b)(5)(A). Sectin 240(b(5)(C)(i) res he rescsso of in
bsei rem orer if e ie es o t reope w 180 days er e order n
demostes tt s re to aper ws becse ecepto circmstces Atetivey
4
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
7/10
ssecin ) prvdes r eoeng a ay e f the ae eoses th he i n re ode wh NA 239().
Te C deed resen reme J 19, 20 ad esode d s m
o ee 78 das ae aar 2 22 Resoen's moo, heee s iey. NA
24bSCi) We esode des expess age exe mses
sho ese hs e aea e ams e "d o reeve rper noie f s
2 heag soe ease Amad se o ae hs e ae an a
he r (Moo ee a 2 Jar 2, 22
esde's aim ha e dd reee e s ho mer A s e 16 2011
earg he ed esode ora g e eree a hs e eag
e y 19 211 a :0 PM e r s ded resoden h a e hearg e
ang he de, me ad ao e erig express sag a e ad Aha,
ess ese aozed ee ae ers Ba E. IA e a
esde dsegded e 's ss a wed hs ae's ereos oes does
e e aked e esne erere s o eed o have s emoa eedgs
eopee der NA 20S
Msdsg a e as e dae oao hs hearg ay se
ineeve assisae o ose eee asssae of ose "may se
ee rsae ag e reeg eoa eegs Aris v. y
57 F 595 56 (2"d Cr 2; of Gralv-Be 2 & De 42 4-
1996 A e seekg to reope emoval oceeg e upo a a eeve
assae o se s de w s o eoe a ada aesg e
reea s; 2 i e tte i qu o e egas a hm d ge m n
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
8/10
ooit to reso; and ( ) idcae a comp ef w aprdslar auhores n, if ot, exla w not.Matter of Lozada, I&N De. 3, 3
IA 88.The reueme o li a complan wh e apoiae splary ahoes
seres o "crease]conece te vality o te aes am a aso "rotets agans
ossible collusion between counse an he alien cie. Mae o Rivera-Claros 1 I&N Dec
599, 05 BA 1996)
Respoe staes ha e beeves Mr mas asg im not to o o Bao "was
eective bu does not "wrran .. [] lig o a bar compai] beause r ha
ate o he msake belef tat eier h Moon hge o Vee o . oon
eephoic [Hea ould be gre. espone's Adai a 3 Jauary , 0. A
bele a cosels eor as iavere is no an aequae explaao r the le o
e a bar coain an inmizes] sgncany the estios raise b he aoey's
apre codc at vaas & ec a 6 Beause respoen as ot
ed a ba complan aganst MrAmad or aequaely explaine s lre to o so he Cou
cao he reeie necte assisance o counsel constitin eceioa cirmsaces
s respone s ot ee o ave s reoval proeedgs reopene uner NA
240b5i)
he Cou nos at, i e cs are as preseted resonde a r. hmad's
adas Mr. Ahmas aions may ell ae aoe to neete asssane o ose
Ma o Gaa-Baa N ec at a so ave ow tat the
of spos oos r a cage eue a elpoc ea i not excuse
respoet om appear r is earg i Balo a so not ave avse resoen
no o go to Bo ase o s asspo a e or wol an e moos.Moreoe
6
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
9/10
.
ad "ov rook[ing] e Cou's deal of thos b hi iexusale. Fn M Aad's ilure o oac e Cou o e da of esonde
eg a is eliee decso o ait e loing sows a aag a o
ilgee. The or ae eay ho bee oceei asentia d, had a
oaed e ou o ae eizn he te esonens eig d coe
one espoet m ve est ee abe o e h sece o o eig odee
eoe.
Beon e os e ee o esodets ue o ae Aa
cosstenly upeae ouot spoens eov oeeng r Aa ed
epoes ue moo a telepoic eng ae bease o "ovesig.
e on Je 20 . ad e his oce ou s iri e Co e a
sced coic, s no resen e te o ce o oc espondens e
Dese seve coces s eve able to stae ay en a reief
resodent od be ee I c, . Ah ate a b the te o espoden's e
6 0 ea he hd o een cae to sss esoets cse i h (M
Ads d t 2, Jaar 2 22
e a r a's assoie, Ms G reare reoes oon o eoen
ses qesos o he aenti o respoes a e oes eieve M
ad's os waae lg ar oat. Noeheess resoe mkes oe cais
whc se eso bout s reby. o e esoent cams e we o
ce t A o 9 21 te :0 PM Respoe's
ad r 22 eses ei w o scee ul P a
esoden oers n ei r w e be wng u os bee e cod ave
7
-
8/12/2019 Sergio Alberto Macal-Ventura, A200 589 069 (BIA Feb. 20, 2014)
10/10
expece e Cou o cl Te Cu s alo keca of on' clai a he s n
o i M A oc avy wig o n, een u nl an o an a
lf ae Cou h coe g Thse qusos sae e fc nol
i eemg h aies l o e s uly e sl o ece asc
of cose n ggh ace o b coa iee Aa espe M.
as shcoig bcu o le a ba comlin ga o
ae exae h i o o so Cou cno has ao
one o ec asssac o cos
Dae:
Fo l of o sos eso moi o on i b i
OER
IT IS HEREB ODRED sos oio o o be EI
Pl J oe US Igo Jug