service tax valuation rules, 2006 by: a.saiprasad b.com, llb, aca, disa, amima advocate 1
TRANSCRIPT
Service Tax Valuation Rules, 2006
By:
A.Saiprasad
B.Com, LLB, ACA, DISA, AMIMA
Advocate1
Session Overview
Valuation Vis-à-Vis Negative List Historical Background Valuation Section Valuation Rules Alternative Valuation Mechanisms
Service Tax Rules, 94 (word document)
Abatement Notification No.26/12 ST (word document)
2
Valuation Vis-à-vis Negative List
Broad Scheme remains as before Marginal changes to align with new system of taxation
Works Contract Previously - Rule 2A of Valn Rules or Composition scheme – Alternative/
Mutually exclusive
Presently – Unified scheme – Subsumes Composition Scheme
Catering Service/ Restaurant Service Previously – Abatement – Ntfn No. 1/06 ST
Presently – New Rule 2C of Valuation Rules
Additions to inclusions/ exclusions - Rule 6 Abatement Notification – Provision of Credit
3
Historical Background Section 67 – Initial Avatar – Separate valuation for
each service.
FA, 2001 Inserted New S. 67 Value = Gross amount charged by the service provider
for such service rendered by him. Explanation – Inclusions and Exclusions.
FA, 2006 w.e.f.18.4.2006 Present S.67 inserted. ST Valuation Rules Notified Press Release (II) F.No.B1/4/2006-TRU dt.19.4.06
4
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision - I
Where consideration is entirely in monetary terms: Value = Gross amount charged By the service provider For such service provided or To be provided by him;
Sec. 67(i) Significance of ‘provided or to be provided’ R/w Rule 3 of POTR, 2011
5
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – II
Where consideration is not entirely in money: Consideration not wholly or partly consisting of money, Be such amount in money as, With the addition of service tax charged, Is equivalent to the consideration;
Sec 67(ii)
6
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – III
Where consideration is not ascertainable: Be the amount As may be determined In the prescribed manner
Prescription – Service Tax Valuation Rules, 2006 Sec 67(iii)
7
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – IV
What is Gross Amount when service tax not charged separately?
Sec 67(2) Cum Duty Value MRF Case – 1987 (27) ELT 553 (SC)
Value = (Cum Duty Price)/ (1 +R) R = Rate of Tax
For those demands where ST has not been charged.
8
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – V
Meaning of Sec 67(2) CCE & C V. Advantage Media Consultant, 2008 10 (STR),
449 (T) Amount collected should be considered as inclusive of
service tax. – But Why?
Municipal Corporation of Delhi V. CST, 2009 16 STR 654 (T)
Bholanath Oberoi Sons V. CCE & ST, 2009 15 STR 61 (T)
9
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – VI
The gross amount charged shall include Any amount received Towards the taxable service Before, During or After Provision of such service.
Advance sought to be taxed Sec 67(3)
10
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – VII
Subject to sub-sections (1), (2) and (3), the value shall be determined in such manner as may be prescribed Prescription is as per Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules,
2006 Valuation Rules is applicable only if value not ascertainable as
per S.67(1),(2) & (3) or In addition to Sec 67 ? Similar to S.4(1)(a) & 4(1)(b) of CEA, 1944 or Section 14 of
Customs Act, 1962 ? S.67(4)
11
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – VIII
Consideration includes any amount that is payable for the taxable services provided or to be provided;
Expln (a) to S.67 Actual Meaning – Quid Pro Quo Contract’s Act – S.2(d)
Service V. Declared Service S.65B(44) V. S.66E Agreeing to the obligation to refrain from an act, or to
tolerate an act or a situation, or to do an act S.66E(e)
12
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – X
Explanation (c) to Sec 67: Gross amount charged includes Payment by cheque, credit card, Deduction from account and Any form of payment by issue of credit notes or debit
notes and
13
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – XI
Gross Amount charged - Associated Enterprises: Book adjustment, and Any amount credited or debited, To any account, whether called “Suspense account” or by any
other name, In the books of account of A person liable to pay service tax, Where the transaction of taxable service is with any associated
enterprise. Inserted w.e.f. 10.5.2008
14
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – XII
Associated Enterprise means AE as per Sec.92A of the IT Act, 1961.
Person Liable to pay tax – Defined U/r 2(1)(d) of STR, 94 – 8 categories of persons
To avoid transactions where service is rendered but payment is not made
Book Adjustment and A/c Cr & Dr applicable only for AE Circular No.334/1/2008-TRU dt.29.2.08
15
Sec.67 – Valuation Provision – XIII
Money defined – S.65B(33) “money” means legal tender, cheque, promissory note, bill of exchange, letter of credit, draft, pay order, traveller cheque money order, postal or electronic remittance or any such similar instrument but shall not include
any currency that is held for its numismatic value Transaction in money – S.65B(44)
16
Valuation Concepts - I
If service performed free of charge? Fee Collected by Public Authority for performing statutory
functions/ duties? Required to perform as per law Collect fee, which is deposited to Govt A/c. Circular No.96/7/2007-ST dt.23.8.07.
Audit by C & AG Regional Reference Std Laboratories RTO Directorate of Boilers Department to certify petroleum storage tanks
17
Valuation Concepts - II
Consideration vis-à-vis Donation With obligation Without any obligation CKP Mandal V. CCE, 2006 5 STT 1 (Bom.)
Consideration Vis-à-vis Grants for R & D Cultural Society of Angamally V. CCE, 2007 8 STR 155 (T) Circular No.127/9/2010-ST dt.16.8.10 Amount must be charged for provision of service
Amounts other than for provision of service
18
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006
Inserted w.e.f. 19.4.06 a/w new S. 67 Notification No.12/06-ST Power to Notify - U/s 94(2)(aa) Section 94 – Power delegated to CG to make rules S.94(2)(aa) - The determination of amount and value
of taxable service under section 67
19
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 – Rule 2A
Valuation of Works Contract – Rule 2A Amended by Ntfn No.24/12 ST dt.6.6.12 Value of service portion of Works Contract
(Gross amount charged - Value of transfer of property in goods transferred)
Gross amount charged shall not include Value Added Tax (VAT) or sales tax paid on transfer of property in goods. Explanation (a) to Rule 2A(i)
20
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Value of works contract service shall include, - (i) labour charges for execution of the works; (ii) amount paid to a sub-contractor for labour and
services; (iii) charges for planning, designing and architect’s fees; (iv) charges for obtaining on hire or otherwise,
machinery and tools used for the execution of the works contract
21
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
(v) cost of consumables such as water, electricity, fuel, used in the execution of the works contract;
(vi) cost of establishment of the contractor relatable to supply of labour and services;
(vii) other similar expenses relatable to supply of labour and services; and
(viii) profit earned by the service provider relatable to supply of labour and services; Explanation (b) to Rule 2A(i) Gannon Dunkerley & Co V. State of Rajasthan, 1993 (88) STC
204 (SC)
22
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Where VAT paid on actual value of goods, Such value adopted for VAT Taken as value of goods transferred Reduced from Gross Amount
Rule 2A(ii)
If VAT not paid for any reason?
If VAT paid but on composition scheme?
23
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Valuation – Step I Where VAT paid on actual value of goods:
Such value adopted for the purposes of VAT, Shall be value of transfer of property
W/C = (Gross Value – Value of goods adopted for VAT)
24
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Valuation – Step II When not determined as per Step I, and not merely as an
option: (A) - Original works: 40% of the total amount (B) - Maintenance or Repair or Reconditioning or Restoration or
Servicing of goods: 70% of total amount Other that (A) & (B) – 60% of total amount
25
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Original works means : Expln 1 to Rule 2A(ii)(C) All new constructions; Additions and alterations to abandoned or damaged structures
on land, required to make them workable Erection, Commissioning or Installation of plant, machinery or
Eqpt or Structure, pre-fabricated or otherwise
Cenvat Credit on inputs – Expln 2 to Rule 2A(ii)(D) Input Definition - Rule 2(k) of CCR, 04
It allows Cr in certain cases for W/c, Construction Service!! How to reconcile the aforesaid provisions?
26
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2A
Total Amount – Rule 2A(ii)(D) Gross Amt Charged and Fair Market Value of all goods and services supplied In or in relation to execution of W/c Whether or not supplied under the same contract or any
other contract After deducting
Amount charged for such goods and services VAT or ST levied thereon
27
Determination of Total Amount
1. Gross amount received excluding taxes 80,00,000
2. Fair market value of goods supplied by the service receiver excluding taxes 50,00,000
3. Amount charged by service receiver for (2) above 10,00,000
4.Total amount charged (1+2-3) 1,20,00,000 5.Value of service portion(40% of 4 in case of
original works) 48,00,000
28
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2B
Foreign Exchange Broking Service & Banking & Other Financial Service
R.2B -Valuation of Sale of Foreign Currency $1,000 sold @ Rs.45/$ RBI Reference Rate Rs.45.50 Taxable Value = (Selling Rate - RBI reference Rate) X Total Units of Currency (Rs.45.50 – Rs.45) X 1,000 = Rs.500
29
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2B
R.2B – Valuation of Purchase of Foreign Currency INR 70,000 changed for GBP @ Rs.70/GBP
Hence 1,000 GBP exchanged
RBI Reference Rate – Rs.69
Taxable Value = (Rs.70 – Rs.69) X 1,000 = Rs.1,000
30
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2B
RBI Reference Rate not available Taxable Value = 1% of the Gross Amount of INR
PROVIDED OR RECEIVED Neither Currency exchanged in INR
Taxable Value = 1% of the LESSER of the two amounts the person charging the money would have RECEIVED by converting any of the two currencies into INR at the reference rate provided by RBI
31
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 2C
New Rule 2C inserted in Valuation Rules, 2006 by Notification No.24/12 ST dt.6.6.12
Service portion in an activity of serving food Restaurant – 40% of Total Amount Outdoor Caterer – 60% of Total Amount
Cenvat available ? On Capital Goods, Input Services ? On Inputs from chapter 1 to 22 of CETA, 85
Total Amount – Similar to works contract. Bundled Service – Food + Premise – Ntfn 26/12
32
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 3
Consideration received is not wholly or partly in money Value = Gross amount charged by the service provider to provide
similar service to any other person in the ordinary course of trade and the gross amount charged is the sole consideration;
Nat Steel Equipment Pvt Ltd V. CCE, 1988 (34) ELT 8 (SC) Meaning of the term ‘similar’
Rule 3(a)
33
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 – Rule 3
When value finally not determinable Value = Equivalent Money Value Which shall, in no case be less than the cost of
provision of such taxable service. Cost V. Value - Difference
Rule 3(b)
34
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 4
Value can be verified by CEO Rule 4(1)
When value is not determined according to Sec 67 and Rules then; SCN to be issued
When can SCN be issued? What does SCN ask ?
Value provided in SCN should not be adopted Rule 4(2)
CEO shall determine value after hearing Rule 4(3)
35
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Expenditure or Cost Incurred by Service Provider & Not Receiver In course of providing taxable service Treated as Consideration Shall be included in the value
Rule 5(1) Circular No.B1/4/2006-TRU dt.19.4.06
36
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Intercontinental Consultants & Technocrats P Ltd V. UOI, 2013 (29) STR 9 (Del)
Sercon India Pvt Ltd V. CST, 2013 (30) STR 454 (Del) Rule 5(1) struck down as Ultra vires S. 67 Gross amount charged does not cover expenditure or
costs Rule 5(1)
37
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Expenditure or Cost incurred by ‘Pure Agent’ Excluded from Value of Taxable Services
Conditions: Service Recipient actually uses the goods or services Service Recipient actually liable to make payment to the third
party; Service Recipient authorises service provider to incur
expenditure or Cost;
38
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Service Recipient aware that goods and services for which payment is made by service receiver is actually provided by a third party
Such payment separately indicated in the invoice issued by the service provider to the Service Recipient;
Only Actual amount recovered by service provider
Goods or services procured by the service provider are in addition to the actual services provided.
39
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Meaning of Pure Agent: Contractual agreement with Service Recipient to act as pure
agent and to incur expenditure or costs Neither intends to hold nor holds any title to the goods or
services so procured or provided Service provider does not use such goods or services for himself Receives only actual amount from Service Recipient
40
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Re-imbursement not includable in value: Bhagyanagar Services v. CCE, 2006 (4) S.T.R. 22 E.V. Mathai & Co. v. CCE 2006 (3) S.T.R. 116 Keralam Enterprises v. CCE 2008 (9) S.T.R. 503 U.M. Thariath & Co. v. CCE 2007 (8) S.T.R. 161 Nandhini Warehousing Crop. v. CCE 2007 (8) S.T.R. 511 Jaylaxmi Enterprises v. CCE 2008 (9) S.T.R. 19 B.S. Refrigeration Ltd. v. CCE 2006 (4) S.T.R. 103 Rolex Logistics P. Ltd. v. CST 2009 (13) S.T.R. 147
41
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Re-imbursement includable in value: Naresh Kumar & Co. Pvt. Ltd. 2008 (11) S.T.R. 578 Kirloskar Pneumatics Co. Ltd. 2011-TIOL-453-CESTAT-MUM and Harveen & Co. [2011-TIOL-848-CESTAT-DEL]
42
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Rule 5 – Basically relates to re-imbursement of expenses Legal or contractual Obligation of service receiver To pay to third party The said amount paid by service provider The amount is paid on behalf of service recipient
Whether the expense was in the nature of inputs or input services? If yes – not a reimbursement. Cr may be available as input/ input service
43
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 5
Costs in the nature of inputs and input services cannot be treated as reimbursements.
No legal justification to artificially split cost: Partly as cost of services (inputs + input service)
Rest as reimbursable expenses
Sri Bhagavathy Traders V. CCE, 2011 (24) STR 290 (T - LB) When will re-imbursement arise? Service provider under no obligation, but pays & recovers from
service receiver – reimbursement Then not included in the value of service
44
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 6
Inclusions: - Rule 6(1) Commission or Brokerage charged by Broker Premium charged by the insurer from the policy holder; Commission received by the air travel agent from the airline; Commission, received by an actuary, or intermediary or insurance
intermediary or insurance agent from the insurer; Reimbursement received by the ` service station, from
manufacturer for carrying out service of any motor car
45
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 6
Commission - rail travel agent from the Railways or the customer; Remuneration or commission, paid to a C & F agent Commission - insurance auxiliary services provided by an
insurance agent. Demurrage charges - service beyond period originally contracted –
Inserted w.e.f. 1.7.12
46
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 6
Exclusions:- Rule 6(2) Initial deposit made by the subscriber at the time of application
for telephone connection or pager or FAX or telegraph or telex or for leased circuit;
Airfare collected by air travel agent in respect of service provided by him;
Rail fare collected by [rail travel agent] in respect of service provided by him;
Interest on loans.
47
Service Tax (Determination of Value), Rules 2006 - Rule 6
Taxes levied by Government on passenger traveling by air, if shown separately on the ticket
Inserted w.e.f. 1.7.12 Accidental damages due to unforeseen action not relatable to
the provision of service; Subsidies or grants disbursed by the Government, not in the
nature of directly influencing the value of service.
48
Thank You
49