Setting agendas, reaching consensus: tools for online deliberation

@clkao 2016-04-27 TICTeC, Barcelona

My name is CL, and I am from the future

UTC+2

Taiwan, UTC+8

I write software

@clkao

civic hacker network by Stefan Baack

Breaking down Don-DemocracyETBlue

citizen-participation tools

specific use cases

How to evaluate

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Deliberation Life Cycle

Before

During

After

Problem Definition

Planning

Legislation

Execution

Evaluation

Policy Life Cycle

Current tools are mostly useful here

Deliberation Structure

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Loomio in public deliberation

Loomio in public deliberation

Problem Definition

Planning

Legislation

Execution

Evaluation

Policy Life Cycle

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Deliberation Life Cycle

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Deliberation Life Cycle

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Deliberation Life Cycle

National Affairs Conference on Trade and Economics (Taiwan)

Problem Definition

Planning

Legislation

Execution

Evaluation

Policy Life Cycle

Right after the sunflower movement

Economy Strategy for Taiwan under globalization

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

Deliberation Life Cycle

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Some Controversial

Yes

Yes

Yes

?

No

No facilitation

Inconsequential

….

No

Agenda Setting

Research

Inform

Discussion

Voting

Decision Making

Responding

Accountability

vTaiwan

Using pol.is to explore opinion spectrum

contracted legal services doing intl comparison

Ministry to respond within 7 days

gitbook + discourse

ORID facilitation

legalisation if required

Uber is a broker platform, just like ebay

Group 1

Group 2

The Uber company registration should be revoked, given their appeal has been rejected

Uber is an unfair competition

When not in a hurry, I call uber rather than flagging one of the many taxis on the street.

Uncertified vehicle with passengers is a public safety threats

UberX should provide insurance for passengers

Uber should pay taxes in Taiwan

government should regulate transport sector in a fair way, not protecting vested interests

Consensus

Thank you!

~50 speakers from 16 countries, 750 people