shanghai tower · design principle safety estimation • gusset plate design should ensure that...

48
SHANGHAI TOWER ARCH 631 Applied Arch Structure | Case Study | Professor Anna Nichols | 12-04-2014 GROUP MEMBERS | YUCHAO LIU | ZHI QU | WEILONG YUE | DI LIU

Upload: others

Post on 22-Mar-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

SHANGHAI TOWER

ARCH 631 Applied Arch Structure | Case Study | Professor Anna Nichols | 12-04-2014

GROUP MEMBERS | YUCHAO LIU | ZHI QU | WEILONG YUE | DI LIU

Page 2: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

• INTRODUCTION• STRUCTURE FEATURES• FOUNDATION SYSTEM• LOADING ANALYSIS• LATERAL LOAD BEHAVIOR

Page 3: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

PART 1 INTRODUCTION

• General Information• Design Concept• Building Layout

Page 4: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

General information

Status: Topped-outLocation: Lujiazui, Pudong, Shanghai

Architectural: 632 m (2,073 ft)Floor count: 121Floor area: 380,000 m2 (4,090,300 sf ) above

170 m2 (1,800 sf ) below

Architect: GenslerEngineer: Thornton Tomasetti

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 5: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 6: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Sculpted for EfficiencyThe wind tunnel test is used to find the most beneficial scaling factor of about 55% and rotation at 120°, which is account for the 24% savings of the wind load working on the structure.

Technical InnovationThe concrete core acts with outriggers and supercolumns are the advances science of super-high rises.

Vertical Community Shanghai tower embodies a new concept of super-tall building by emphasizing public spaces at the atrium levels.

Sustainable AchievementsThere are two lays of skin wrapping the entire building. The atriums created by the skins features as an insulation which keep the temperature stable.

Design Concept

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 7: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Building Layout Shanghai tower's program is organized into 9 vertical zones.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 8: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

PART 2 STRUCTURE FEATURES

• Structure System• Connection Description

Page 9: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Structure Component

• Curtain Wall System• Main Structure System

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 10: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Tower Top

Vertical fin-like trussTwo-way trussOctagonal steel frame bracing system

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 11: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Curtain Wall System

Diagram of positive and negative wind cladding loads (RWDI)

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 12: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Main Structure

Inner Cylindrical Tower • Core • Outrigger• Mega Frame: Super column system

and belt trusses

The lateral and vertical resistance of the tower will be provided by the inner cylindrical tower.

The primary lateral resistance is provided by the core, outrigger, and supercolumnsystem.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

two stories-outrigger truss

Core wall

Diagonal corner column

Super column

Belt truss

one story-radial truss

Page 13: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Inner Cylindrical Tower

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 14: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Core

Core of the zone 1 and basement

shear wall: steel plate and concrete combination

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 15: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Outrigger

Double storiesIn the steel section of the super columns, there are perpendicular cross ribs that align with belt trusses.

Radical Outrigger

One story

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 16: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Mega Frame

Supercolumn System: two at each end of each orthonormal axis

four diagonal supercolumns along each 45-degree axis

1-6 zone 7-8 zone

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Section of Super-column

Page 17: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Connection Description

• Complexity of stress state. • Connections should be broken

after the destructiveness of members

• Different connections have different design criteria, according to the variation of structure members.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 18: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Type A: The Joint of

Outrigger to Super-column

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 19: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Technical Features

• The chords of outrigger truss • Gusset plates, 120mm thickness, Q390GJC steel• The steel reinforced dual web of the super-

column • The belts trusses

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 20: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Stress State

Design Principle

Safety Estimation

• Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate.

• Gusset plate design should ensure that the joint action of webs and chords of outrigger have enough strength.

• The members of outrigger bear compress and tension bending.

• The final undermine performance are the local instability and over-large plastic deformation in each plates of diagonal web members of outrigger truss, while there is no damage in node area.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 21: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Type B: The Long Bolt Joint of the Belt Truss

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 22: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Technical Features

• Since there exist large member force of the chords in the belt trusses, there are large quantity of the bolts, and super length of the bolts set.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 23: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Axial Force

Bending Moment

Real Loading

• Internal Force Analysis under axial force• Internal Force Analysis under bending moment• Internal Force Analysis under real loading

Stress State

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 24: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Type C: The Detail of Interior Curtain Wall

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 25: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Type D: The Detail of Exterior Curtain Wall

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 26: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

PART 3 FOUNDATION

• Soil Condition• Foundation System

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 27: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Soil condition and test pile

• Soft soil area• Groundwater buoyancy

90%(practical design considerations 80% of water buoyancy)

• Select ⑨2 layer containing gravelly coarse sand layer, as pile bearing stratum

Sandy silt

Fine sand

Silt

Sandy silt

Silt

Silty clay

Silt

Silty clay

Silty clay

Clay

Mucky clay

Mucky silty clay

Clayey silt

Miscellaneous fillNatural Floor

Section of soil layers and test pile

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 28: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Foundation System

• Piled raft foundation • Diameter 121 m, 6 m thick

reinforced concrete circular platform

• Bored pile, pile length 56m in the core area, 52m in the extension area Sectttion

Load of Supercolumn and Core

Sandy silt

Fine sand

Silt

Sandy silt

Silt

Silty claySilt

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 29: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Excavation

• Tower foundation pits area of 11,500 square meters and a depth of about 31 meters

• Non-beamed single building pit

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 30: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Piles

• Staggered pile arrangement in load concentrated area

• Orthogonal shaped pile arrangement in other area

Piles Plan

56m length in core area, staggered

52m length in others, Orthogonal

52m length in s-column area, staggered

Method Ratio of load

Ratio of buoyancy

considered

Ratio of load

Ratio of buoyancy

considered

Ratio of load

Ratio of buoyancy

considered

Shanghai TowerSWFCJin Mao Tower

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 31: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Raft

• raft thickness is determined by the strength of anti-punching, and then check the flexural strength

• 6m thickness(3.7m of Dubai Khalīfa tower)• Variable Stiffness Design to control Settlement• Variable Stiffness iterative method to calculate

the resulting of pile stiffness after the amended merger

Width of raft /m

E-W axe /m

Settlement ofUniform stiffness design

Settlement ofVariable Stiffness Design

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 32: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

PART 4 LOADING ANALYSIS

• Lateral Load Resisting System Description• Gravity Loads Transfer Path• Lateral Loads Transfer Path• Multi-frame Analysis

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 33: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

The lateral load resisting system is comprised of:

a) an interior reinforced concrete coreb) exterior composite super columnsc) steel outrigger and belt trusses

Lateral Load Resisting System

Structure

componentsGravity loads Shear force

Overturning

moment

The Mega-

Frame50% 47% 76%

The tube of

Core50% 53% 24%

The proportion of loads carried by the mega-frame and tube of core

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 34: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Gravity Loads Transfer Path

Structure

componentsGravity loads

The Mega-

Frame50%

The tube of

Core50%

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 35: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

the belt truss of each reinforcement layer transfer the gravity load to the super-columns and corner columns.In addition, in the device layer above the reinforcement layers, multi-channel radial trussare arranged to bear the vertical loads produced by electromechanical device and entertainment layers. In the cantilevered end of the radial truss, there are cables hanging the exterior curtain wall of each zone below.

Gravity Loads Transfer Path

Structure components Gravity loads

The Mega-Frame 50%

The tube of Core 50%

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 36: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Load hanging the cable of the exterior curtain wall

Load from the electromechanical device and entertainment layers

Page 37: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Lateral Loads Transfer Path

Structure

componentsShear force

Overturning

moment

The Mega-

Frame47% 76%

The tube of

Core53% 24%

Wind loads reach to the surface of the building, and are transferred to the super-columns, thus the mega-frame could carry larger part of the lateral forces.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 38: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Lateral Loads Transfer Path

Structure

componentsShear force

Overturning

moment

The Mega-

Frame47% 76%

The tube of

Core53% 24%

In the reinforcement level, part of the wind load will be horizontally transferred through the outriggers to the concrete core, and then transferred to the foundation vertically.

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 39: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Building resist to Lateral loads through 3 layers of structure, they transfer wind and seismic load one by one, from inside to outside.

The Supper core is the first layer of Resistance.

The double belt truss and super column are the second layer of Resistance.

The outriggers and radial trusses are the third layer.

Multi-frame Analysis

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 40: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

• Shear

• Moment

• Tension

• Deflection

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Multi-frame Analysis

Page 41: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Multi-frame Analysis

Page 42: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

PART 5 LATERAL LOAD BEHAVIOR

• Wind Load Behavior• Seismic Load Behavior

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 43: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Seismic Analysis

0 1/2000 1/1000 1/666 1/500 1/4000

10F

20F

30F

40F

50F

60F

70F

80F

90F

100F

110F

120F

130F

层间位移角

楼层

小震作用下的层间位移角

X方向Y方向

0 1/1000 1/500 1/333 1/250 1/2000

10F

20F

30F

40F

50F

60F

70F

80F

90F

100F

110F

120F

130F

层间位移角

楼层

中震作用下的层间位移角

X方向Y方向

Building reposed to Minor Richer scale

Building reposed to Strong Richer scale

1. Core + Super Column

2. Core + Double Belt Truss

3. Core + Radial Truss

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 44: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Seismic Analysis

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 45: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Wind Analysis

0 1/2000 1/1000 1/666 1/500 1/4000

10F

20F

30F

40F

50F

60F

70F

80F

90F

100F

110F

120F

130F

层间位移角

楼层

风荷载下层间位移角

合成风1/475

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 46: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Wind Load Resisted Methods

The effective building shape modification methods

a) the twisting angle b) building orientationc) shrink ratio of building plan

along the building height

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 47: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset

Wind Load Resisted Methods

The tuned mass damper

Shanghai Tower | Introduction | Structure Features | Foundation System | Loading Analysis | Lateral Loads Behavior | Conclusion |

Page 48: SHANGHAI TOWER · Design Principle Safety Estimation • Gusset plate design should ensure that every rods of outrigger truss would be anchored strongly in the gusset plate. • Gusset