shelby hall-lisa garza lawsuit

8/20/2019 Shelby Hall-Lisa Garza Lawsuit

1/65

OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF Uaij 1

1:;


2/65


1:;


3/65


1:;


4/65

OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF Uaij ;

1:;


5/65

OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF Uaij :

1:;).

11. Ufadotdll Pnjfcy Naff ds a [jxas fdgdtjk fdacdfdty `hgpaoy. Zpho

dolhrgatdho aok cjfdjl casjk ho dolhrgatdho do Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Fdsa S.

Iarza-Pjf`jr ds tnj ‖shfj hwojr hl chtn Pnjfcy Naff aok PNC.‗ [njrjlhrj, Pnjfcy

Naff ds a `dtdzjo hl [jxas.

13. Ufadotdll Pnjfcy Naff Cjvjraij, FF@ (‖PNC‗) ds a [jxas fdgdtjk

fdacdfdty `hgpaoy. Zpho dolhrgatdho aok cjfdjl casjk ho dolhrgatdho do Ufadotdlls—

Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Fdsa S. Iarza-Pjf`jr ds tnj ‖shfj hwojr hl chtn Pnjfcy Naff aok

PNC.‗ [njrjlhrj, PNC ds a `dtdzjo hl [jxas.

3. @dtdzjosndp hl Kjljokaots

10.

Kjljokaots arj ohw, aok wjrj at tnj tdgj tnj Ptatj @hurt

A`tdho was ldfjk, `dtdzjos hl Fhudsdaoa.

1;. Lhr kdvjrsdty murdskd`tdho purphsjs, a fdgdtjk fdacdfdty `hgpaoy ds a

`dtdzjo hl aff statjs do wnd`n dts gjgcjrs arj `dtdzjos. Narvjy, :;3 L.0k at 15>5.

A `hrphratdho ds a `dtdzjo hl tnj statj do wnd`n dt ds do`hrphratjk aok tnj statj do

wnd`n dts prdo`dpaf pfa`j hl cusdojss ds fh`atjk. 3> Z.P.@. § 1003(`)(f). Lhr tnj

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij : hl 11 UaijDK :


6/65

OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF Uaij <

1:; L.3k ;: (9tn @dr.14>


7/65


1:; Z.P.@. § 1003(a). Ufadotdlls

arj ohw, aok wjrj at tnj tdgj tnat tnj Ptatj @hurt A`tdho was ldfjk, `dtdzjos hl

[jxas. Kjljokaots arj ohw, aok wjrj at tnj tdgj tnat tnj Ptatj @hurt A`tdho

was ldfjk, `dtdzjos hl Fhudsdaoa.

C. Aghuot do @hotrhvjrsy

14.

[nj aghuot do `hotrhvjrsy do tnds a`tdho jx`jjks $9:,555.55,

jx`fusdvj hl dotjrjst aok `hsts.

35. Sjghvaf ds prhpjr ho tnj casds hl aghuot do `hotrhvjrsy assjrtjk dl

tnj `hurt ldoks, cy a prjphokjrao`j hl tnj jvdkjo`j, tnat tnj aghuot do

`hotrhvjrsy jx`jjks $9:,555.55, jx`fusdvj hl dotjrjst aok `hsts. 3> Z.P.@. §

1;;) (kjljokaot ‖gay rjfy ho ao jstdgatj hl phtjotdaf kagaijs lrhg

tnj affjiatdhos do tnj `hgpfadot,‗ aok a ‖`hgpfadot tnat prjsjots a `hgcdoatdho

hl la`ts aok tnjhrdjs hl rj`hvjry tnat gay supphrt a `fadg do jx`jss hl $9:,555

`ao supphrt rjghvaf‗).

31. Dl dt ds la`daffy apparjot lrhg tnj Ujtdtdho tnat tnj aghuot do

`hotrhvjrsy jx`jjks tnj murdskd`tdhoaf gdodgug, tnjo oh strd`t prhhl ds rjqudrjk

lrhg tnj kjljokaot. Ijccda v. Yaf-Gart Pthrjs, Do`., 300 L.0k >>5, >>0 (:tn @dr.

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 9 hl 11 UaijDK 9


8/65

OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF Uaij >

1:;


9/65


1:;


10/65


1:;


11/65


1:;


12/65

J^NDCD[ A

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 1 hl ;1 UaijDK 13


13/65

DOKJ^ HL KH@ZGJO[P LDFJK Uaij 1

YD[N KJLJOKAO[P— OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF

1:;


14/65

DOKJ^ HL KH@ZGJO[P LDFJK Uaij 3

YD[N KJLJOKAO[P— OH[D@J HL SJGH\AF

1:;


15/65

J^NDCD[ A-1

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij ; hl ;1 UaijDK 1:


16/65

(j.i., Mhno Pgdtn v. Aff Agjrdào Dosurao`j @h2 Do rj Gary Aoo Mhojs2 Do tnj Gattjr hl tnj Jstatj hl Ijhrij Ma`bsho)

A `dvdf àsj dolhrgatdho snjjt gust cj `hgpfjtjk aok sucgdttjk wnjo ao hrdidoaf pjtdtdho hr appfdàtdho ds ldfjk th dodtdatj a ojw `dvdf, lagdfy faw, prhcatj, hr gjotafnjaftn àsj hr wnjo a phst-mukigjot pjtdtdho lhr ghkdldàtdho hr ghtdho lhr jolhr`jgjot ds ldfjk do a lagdfy faw àsj. [nj dolhrgatdho snhufk cj tnj cjst avadfacfj attnj tdgj hl ldfdoi.

1. @hota`t dolhrgatdho lhr pjrsho `hgpfjtdoi àsj dolhrgatdho snjjt= Oagjs hl partdjs do àsj= Ujrsho hr jotdty `hgpfjtdoi snjjt ds=

Oagj=

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Akkrjss=


@dty/Ptatj/]dp=


Pdioaturj=


Jgadf=

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

[jfjpnhoj=


Lax=


Ptatj Car Oh=


Ufadotdll(s)/Ujtdtdhojr(s)=

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX


Kjljokaot(s)/Sjsphokjot(s)=




RAtta`n akkdtdhoaf paij as oj`jssary th fdst aff partdjsW

Atthrojy lhr Ufadotdll/Ujtdtdhojr Urh Pj Ufadotdll/Ujtdtdhojr[dtfj D\-K Aijo`y

Htnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Akkdtdhoaf Uartdjs do @ndfk Pupphrt @asj=

@usthkdaf Uarjot= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Oho-@usthkdaf Uarjot= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Urjsugjk Latnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

3. Dokdàtj àsj typj, hr dkjotdly tnj ghst dgphrtaot dssuj do tnj àsj (sjfj`t hofy 1)=

@dvdf Lagdfy Faw

@hotra`t Domury hr Kagaij Sjaf Urhpjrty Garrdaij SjfatdhosndpUhst-mukigjot A`tdhos

(oho-[dtfj D\-K)

Kjct/@hotra`t

@hosugjr/K[UA Kjct/@hotra`t Lrauk/Gdsrjprjsjotatdho Htnjr Kjct/@hotra`t= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Lhrj`fhsurj

Nhgj Jqudty ‛ Jxpjkdtjk Htnjr Lhrj`fhsurj

Lrao`ndsj Dosurao`j Faokfhrk/[joaot

Oho-@hgpjtdtdho Uartojrsndp Htnjr @hotra`t=

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Assauft/Cattjry@hostru`tdhoKjlagatdho

Gafpra`td`j A``huotdoiFjiafGjkdàfHtnjr UrhljssdhoafFdacdfdty=

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXGhthr \jnd`fj A``dkjotUrjgdsjs

Urhku`t Fdacdfdty

Ascjsths/PdfdàHtnjr Urhku`t Fdacdfdty

Fdst Urhku`t= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Htnjr Domury hr Kagaij= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Jgdojot Khgado/@hokjgoatdho Uartdtdho Qudjt [dtfj [rjspass th [ry [dtfj Htnjr Urhpjrty= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

AooufgjotKj`farj Garrdaij \hdk

Kdvhr`j Ydtn @ndfkrjo

Oh @ndfkrjo

Jolhr`jgjotGhkdldàtdho ‛ @usthkyGhkdldàtdho ‛ Htnjr

[dtfj D\-K

Jolhr`jgjot/GhkdldàtdhoUatjrodtySj`dprhàfs (ZDLPA)Pupphrt Hrkjr

Sjfatjk th @rdgdoaf

Gattjrs Htnjr Lagdfy Faw

Uarjot-@ndfk Sjfatdhosndp

Jxpuo`tdho Mukigjot Odsd

Oho-Kds`fhsurjPjdzurj/Lhrljdturj

Yrdt hl Nacjas @hrpus ‛ Urj-dokd`tgjotHtnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Jolhr`j LhrjdioMukigjotNacjas @hrpus

Oagj @naoij

Urhtj`tdvj HrkjrSjghvaf hl Kdsacdfdtdjshl GdohrdtyHtnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Akhptdho/Akhptdho wdtn[jrgdoatdho@ndfk Urhtj`tdho@ndfk Pupphrt

@usthky hr \dsdtatdhoIjstatdhoaf UarjotdoiIraokparjot A``jssUarjotaij/Uatjrodty[jrgdoatdho hl UarjotafSdintsHtnjr Uarjot-@ndfk= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Jgpfhygjot Htnjr @dvdf

Kds`rdgdoatdho Sjtafdatdho [jrgdoatdho Yhrbjrs— @hgpjosatdho Htnjr Jgpfhygjot= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Akgdodstratdvj AppjafAotdtrust/Zoladr@hgpjtdtdho@hkj \dhfatdhosLhrjdio MukigjotDotjffj`tuaf Urhpjrty

Fawyjr Kds`dpfdoj Ujrpjtuatj [jstdghoy Pjùrdtdjs/Pth`b [hrtdhus Dotjrljrjo`j Htnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

[ax Urhcatj & Gjotaf Njaftn [ax Appradsaf

[ax Kjfdoqujo`yHtnjr [ax

Urhcatj/Ydffs/Dotjstatj Akgdodstratdho

Kjpjokjot AkgdodstratdhoDokjpjokjot AkgdodstratdhoHtnjr Jstatj Urh`jjkdois

Iuarkdaosndp ‛ Akuft

Iuarkdaosndp ‛

Gdohr Gjotaf Njaftn

Htnjr= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

0. Dokdàtj prh`jkurj hr rjgjky, dl appfdàcfj (gay sjfj`t ghrj tnao 1)=

Appjaf lrhg Guod`dpaf hr Mustd`j @hurtArcdtratdho-rjfatjk Atta`ngjotCdff hl Sjvdjw@jrtdhrard@fass A`tdho

Kj`farathry MukigjotIarodsngjotDotjrpfjakjrFd`josjGaokagusUhst-mukigjot

Urjmukigjot SjgjkyUrhtj`tdvj HrkjrSj`jdvjrPjqujstratdho[jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr/Domuo`tdho[urohvjr

;. Dokdàtj kagaijs shuint (kh oht sjfj`t dl dt ds a lagdfy faw àsj )=

Fjss tnao $155,555, do`fukdoi kagaijs hl aoy bdok, pjoaftdjs, `hsts, jxpjosjs, prj-mukigjot dotjrjst, aok atthrojy ljjsFjss tnao $155,555 aok oho-ghojtary rjfdjl Hvjr $155, 555 cut oht ghrj tnao $355,555Hvjr $355,555 cut oht ghrj tnao $1,555,555

Hvjr $1,555,555

Sjv 3/10

@D\DF @APJ DOLHSGA[DHO PNJJ[

@AZPJ OZGCJS ( LHS @FJSB ZPJ HOFT )= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX @HZS[ ( LHS @FJSB ZPJ HOFT )= XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

P[TFJK XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXFdsa S. Iarza-Pjf`jr, jt af. v. 1


17/65

J^NDCD[ A-3

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij < hl ;1 UaijDK 19


18/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfd`atdho Uaij 1lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

@AZPJ OH. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

FDPA S. IAS]A-PJF@JS, § DO [NJ KDP[SD@[ @HZS[PNJFCT NAFF F.F.@., aok §PNJFCT NAFF CJ\JSAIJ, FF@, §

§fadotdlls , §

§ v. § XXXXXX MZKD@DAF KDP[SD@[

§1


19/65


D.Kds`hvjry @hotrhf Ufao

1. Ufadotdlls dotjok tnat kds`hvjry do tnds gattjr cj `hoku`tjk uokjr a Fjvjf DDD

Kds`hvjry @hotrhf Ufao pursuaot th Sufj 145.; hl tnj [jxas Sufjs hl @dvdf Urh`jkurj, aok

asb tnat tnds @hurt jotjr ao apprhprdatj P`njkufdoi Hrkjr, jstacfdsndoi tnj tdgjfdoj aok

apprhprdatj `hoku`t hl kds`hvjry do tnds fawsudt.

DD.Uartdjs

3.

Ufadotdll Iarza ds ao dokdvdkuaf rjsdkdoi do tnj Ptatj hl [jxas aok gay cj

sjrvjk wdtn khùgjots cy sjrvdoi njr uokjrsdiojk `huosjf hl rj`hrk.

0. Ufadotdll Pnjfcy Naff ds a [jxas fdgdtjk fdacdfdty `hgpaoy aok gay cj sjrvjk

wdtn khùgjots cy sjrvdoi dts uokjrsdiojk `huosjf hl rj`hrk.

;. Ufadotdll PNC ds a [jxas fdgdtjk fdacdfdty `hgpaoy aok gay cj sjrvjk wdtn

khùgjots cy sjrvdoi dts uokjrsdiojk `huosjf hl rj`hrk.

:. Kjljokaot 1


20/65


Pjrvd`j hl Urh`jssPj`rjtary hl PtatjU.H. Chx 13594

Austdo, [jxas 9>911-3594.

[J^

. @

D\ . U

SA@. &

S

JG. @

HKJ§

19.5;;2

[

J^ . C

ZP. H

SIP. @

HKJ§

:.3:1(3)(C). [nj

Pj`rjtary hl Ptatj ào lhrwark prh`jss th Kjvjfhpjr th tnj attjotdho hl dts kds`fhsjk

rjidstjrjk aijot do tnj Ptatj hl Fhudsdaoa, as lhffhws=

Say [. Ppakalhra>13 Iravdjr Ptrjjt

Pudtj 355Ojw Hrfjaos, Fhudsdaoa 95113

9. Kjljokaot N@D @hostru`tdho, FF@ (‖Urhmj`t Gaoaijr‗) ds a Fhudsdaoa

Fdgdtjk Fdacdfdty @hgpaoy aok gay cj sjrvjk wdtn prh`jss cy sjrvdoi dts rjidstjrjk aijot,

@[ @hrphratdho Pystjg, at dts rjidstjrjk akkrjss= 1444 Cryao Ptrjjt, Pudtj 4552 Kaffas, [jxas

9:351.

DDD. Murdskd`tdho & \jouj

>. Murdskd`tdho ds prhpjr do tnds @hurt cjàusj tnj aghuot do `hotrhvjrsy

jx`jjks tnj gdodgug murdskd`tdhoaf fdgdts hl tnds @hurt.

4. \jouj ds prhpjr do Kaffas @huoty as tnj `huoty do wnd`n aff hr a sucstaotdaf

phrtdho hl tnj a`ts aok/hr hgdssdhos idvdoi rdsj th Ufadotdll—s àusjs hl a`tdho h`ùrrjk.

[J^ . @D\ . USA@. & S JG. § 1:.553.

D\.La`ts

15.

Pnjfcy Naff was lhrgjk ho Gar`n 1>, 351: th hpjratj a rjstauraot at 1:3:

Jfg Ptrjjt do Kaffas, [jxas, uokjr tnj assugjk oagj ‖Pnjfcy Naff.‗ PNC ds ao alldfdatj hl

Pnjfcy Naff tnat nhfks tnj fd`josjs oj`jssary lhr Pnjfcy Naff th sjrvj af`hnhfd` cjvjraijs th



21/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij ;lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

dts iujsts. Iarza, wnh ds tnj shfj hwojr hl chtn Pnjfcy Naff aok PNC, ds a oatdhoaffy-

rjohwojk `njl, wnh dodtdaffy jarojk ohthrdjty tnrhuin njr appjarao`j ho Lhhk Ojtwhrb—s

‖Ojxt Lhhk Ojtwhrb Ptar.‗ Pnj ds afsh tnj hwojr hl Pdssy—s Phutnjro Bdt`njo, wnd`n ds a

`rdtdàffy-a``fadgjk Kaffas jstacfdsngjot.

11.

Cjàusj hl Iarza—s rjputatdho as a supjrstar `njl aok rjstauraotjur,

Kjvjfhpjr apprha`njk njr do 351; achut hpjodoi a ojw rjstauraot `ho`jpt ho tnj irhuok

lfhhr hl a ojw ndin rdsj nhtjf/rjsdkjotdaf kjvjfhpgjot (tnj ‖Sjstauraot‗) tnat Kjvjfhpjr

was cudfkdoi as part hl a rjnacdfdtatdho prhmj`t do khwothwo Kaffas. [nat cudfkdoi ds ohw

bohwo as F[\ [hwjr aok tnj Ndftho Iarkjo Doo, aok ds fhàtjk at 1 Aprdf 351: (tnj ‖Fjasj‗). [nj Fjasj `hotjgpfatjk a

lhrgaf hpjodoi hl tnj Sjstauraot oh fatjr tnao 1 Pjptjgcjr 351:. @hosdstjot wdtn tnj

partdjs— jarfdjr, tjotatdvj airjjgjot, tnj Fjasj rjqudrjk tnj Faokfhrk prhvdkj a ‖wndtj chx‗

at dts hwo `hst aok th prhvdkj $1 gdffdho th cudfk hut tnj spa`j aok a`qudrj `jrtado

jqudpgjot lhr usj do tnj Sjstauraot.



22/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij :lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

10. Jvjo at tnds jarfy staij, Iarza jxprjssjk `ho`jros. Ppj`dldàffy, dt was

apparjot th Iarza tnat Kjvjfhpjr whufk cj uoacfj th `hgpfjtj tnj cudfk-hut aok lurodsndoi

hl tnj Sjstauraot wdtndo tnj $1 gdffdho cukijt ‐ do farij part cjàusj Kjvjfhpjr nak oht

chtnjrjk th sjùrj cdks lhr sjvjraf gatjrdaf phrtdhos hl tnj prhmj`t do a tdgjfy gaoojr. [h

prhtj`t njrsjfl aiadost tnjsj hcvdhus `ho`jros ‐ aok, oht fjast, cjàusj Faokfhrk (tnrhuin

Kjvjfhpjr aok Urhmj`t Gaoaijr), ratnjr tnao Iarza, was th `hotrhf tnj `hostru`tdho prh`jss

‐ Iarza dosdstjk tnat tnj Fjasj jxprjssfy hcfdij Faokfhrk th cjar aoy `hst hvjrruos, uofjss

su`n hvjrruos wjrj àusjk cy `naoijs th tnj Ufaos (kjldojk cjfhw) cy Pnjfcy Naff.

1;. Do ghrj-partdùfar tjrgs, tnj Fjasj rjqudrjs tnat tnj ‖Faokfhrk snaff pjrlhrg

tnj dodtdaf dgprhvjgjots th tnj Urjgdsjs do a``hrkao`j wdtn tnj pfaos aok spj`dldàtdhos

airjjk upho cy Faokfhrk aok RPnjfcy NaffW 1, wnd`n pfaos snaff cj airjjk upho oh fatjr tnao

05 kays lrhg tnj jxjùtdho katj hl tnj Fjasj.‗ Ho > Gay 351: tnj Kjvjfhpjr jxtjokjk tnj

pjrdhk wdtndo wnd`n tnj partdjs snhufk airjj th tnj Ufaos cy ao akkdtdhoaf 05 kays. Ho 13

Gay 351:, tnj partdjs ‐ afhoi wdtn a rjprjsjotatdvj hl tnj ijojraf `hotra`thr at tnj tdgj aok

rjprjsjotatdvjs hl tnj kjsdio ldrg rjsphosdcfj lhr tnj dotjrdhr kjsdio hl tnj Sjstauraot ‐ gjt

at tnj prjgdsjs hl tnj spa`j th cj fjasjk, aok ldoafdzjk a pfao th `hgpfjtj tnj cudfk-hut hl

tnj Sjstauraot.

1:. At tnat gjjtdoi, Ptjvj Oao`j (‖Oao`j‗), tnj vd`j prjsdkjot hl dovjstgjots

lhr Kjvjfhpjr aok tnj Kjvjfhpjr—s jxjùtdvj do `narij hl tnj prhmj`t, rjphrtjk tnat

Kjvjfhpjr—s dodtdaf cukijt jx j̀jkjk tnj ojihtdatjk cudfk-hut cukijt hl $1 gdffdho. At tnat

tdgj, tnj partdjs airjjk th sjvjraf nuokrjk tnhusaok khffars do ùts aok uftdgatjfy arrdvjk at

1 (tnj ‖Ufaos‗)



23/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij <lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

ao airjjgjot, aftnhuin tnj airjjk cukijt jx`jjkjk tnj $1 gdffdho cukijt. Dgphrtaotfy, tnj

partdjs airjjk th ghvj lhrwark wdtn tnj prhmj`t uokjr tnds rjvdsjk cukijt ‐ aok kdk sh.

1.

At hr ojar tnds sagj tdgj, Kjvjfhpjr apprha`njk Iarza achut rjojihtdatdoi

tnj Fjasj th do`rjasj tnj pjr`jotaij rjot, `dtdoi Kjvjfhpjr—s jxpj`tatdho hl ihdoi hvjr

cukijt cy sjvjraf nuokrjk tnhusaok khffars. Iarza rjgdokjk Kjvjfhpjr tnat tnj Fjasj

jxpfd`dtfy prhvdkjk tnat cukijt hvjrruos wjrj th cj chroj cy tnj Faokfhrk. Ghrj

partdùfarfy, Iarza rjgdokjk Kjvjfhpjr tnat tnj prhvdsdho(s) th tnat jllj`t nak cjjo

jxprjssfy do`fukjk do tnj Fjasj spj`dldàffy cjàusj Iarza nak jxprjssjk `ho`jros achut

Kjvjfhpjr—s `hgpjtjo`j aok acdfdty th pjrlhrg wdtndo cukijt altjr tnjy kj`fdojk th fdstjo th

njr akvd`j aok tabj akvaotaij hl njr jxpjrtdsj aok tnat hl tnj fhàf `hosuftaots snj



24/65


rj`hggjokjk th tnjg. Zftdgatjfy, Iarza rjlusjk aoy agjokgjots th tnj Fjasj aok tnj

prhmj`t `hotdoujk uokjr tnj partdjs— wrdttjo airjjgjot ‐ hr, at fjast, sh Iarza tnhuint.

14. [nrhuinhut tnj `hostru`tdho prh`jss, Iarza rjiufarfy dospj`tjk tnj prhirjss

hl tnj prhmj`t aok ohtjk sjvjraf gatjrdaf kjvdatdhos lrhg tnj Ufaos. As tnjsj kjvdatdhos aok

ladfurjs th `hgpfy wdtn tnj Ufaos cjiao th gaodljst, Iarza crhuint tnjg th tnj attjotdho hl

Kjvjfhpjr aok tnj Urhmj`t Gaoaijr. Gaoy hl tnjsj kjvdatdhos wjrj `fjarfy dffustratjk do tnj

pfaos aok spj`dldàtdhos sucgdttjk th tnj `dty, do`fukdoi gdffwhrb ho tnj snjfvdoi cjndok tnj

gado car aok ho tnj sj`hok-lfhhr gjzzaodoj tnat kdk oht gat`n tnj krawdois do tnhsj pfaos

aok spj`dldàtdhos, tnj hgdssdho hl a rjlrdijratjk `narùtjrdj ljaturj, aok tnj rjpfa`jgjot hl

airjjk-upho jqudpgjot wdtn `njapjr aftjroatdvjs, aghoi gaoy htnjrs.

35. Ynjo tnjsj kjvdatdhos wjrj phdotjk hut th Kjvjfhpjr, Kjvjfhpjr hltjotdgjs

jxprjssjk lrustratdho wdtn Iarza—s dosdstjo`j tnat Kjvjfhpjr `hgpfy wdtn tnj Ufaos. Do

gaoy àsjs Kjvjfhpjr sdgpfy rjlusjk th rj`tdly dts ladfurjs ‐ `dtdoi oh ghrj rjasho hr

autnhrdty tnao Kjvjfhpjr—s hwo cukijtary `ho`jros ‐ kjspdtj tnj la`t tnat tnj Fjasj

rjqudrjk tnat Kjvjfhpjr pjrlhrg dts whrb at dts hwo jxpjosj aok do a``hrkao`j wdtn tnj

Ufaos, rjiarkfjss hl wnjtnjr su`n `hgpfdaot whrb uftdgatjfy àusjk tnj prhmj`t th ih hvjr

cukijt.

31. Ynjo Pjptjgcjr 1st àgj aok wjot aok tnj `hostru`tdho prhmj`t was

ohwnjrj ojar `hgpfjtj, tjosdhos cjtwjjo tnj partdjs cjiao th rja`n ao uotjoacfj njdint.

Iarza, do rjfdao`j ho Kjvjfhpjr—s dodtdaf rjprjsjotatdhos tnat tnj prhmj`t whufk cj `hgpfjtj

cy Pjptjgcjr 1st, doùrrjk sucstaotdaf `hsts do garbjtdoi, ndrdoi stall aok htnjr jxpjosjs ‐

aff hl wnd`n wjrj gakj wdtn tnj uokjrstaokdoi tnat, a``hrkdoi th tnj Fjasj, tnj Sjstauraot

whufk cj hpjo aok `hufk cjido jarodoi rjvjouj cy Pjptjgcjr 1st. As hl tnj katj hl tnj

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Khùgjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 10 hl ;1 UaijDK 3;


25/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij >lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

ldfdoi hl tnds Ujtdtdho, `hostru`tdho rjgados do`hgpfjtj aok tnj Kjvjfhpjr nas oht hctadojk a

`jrtdldàtj hl h`ùpao`y2 aok tnj Sjstauraot rjgados, oj`jssardfy, uohpjojk.

33. Kdsairjjgjots cjtwjjo Kjvjfhpjr aok Iarza do`rjasjk do lrjqujo`y as

Iarza `hotdoujk th kds`hvjr dostao`js hl Kjvjfhpjr—s kjvdatdho lrhg ‐ hr patjot ladfurj th

`hgpfy wdtn ‐ tnj Ufaos. Kdsùssdhos wdtn vardhus vjokhrs aok suc-`hotra`thrs ho tnj

prhmj`t rjvjafjk tnat Kjvjfhpjr nak uodfatjraffy gakj `naoij hrkjrs lhr jqudpgjot,

lurodturj aok `hostru`tdho ljaturjs, rjpfa`doi dtjgs wdtn `njapjr aftjroatdvjs wdtnhut

Iarza—s `hosjot, wnd`n ds rjqudrjk uokjr tnj Fjasj. Cut, as cjlhrj, Iarza—s `hgpfadots ljff

ho kjal jars2 aok Kjvjfhpjr cfdtnjfy `hotdoujk th rjlusj th pjrlhrg dts whrb do a``hrkao`j

wdtn tnj Ufaos, jvjo altjr kjvdatdhos lrhg tnj Ufaos wjrj crhuint th tnjdr attjotdho cy

Iarza.

30. Do H`thcjr 351:, altjr Iarza gakj spj`dld` `hgpfadots achut kjvdatdhos

lrhg tnj Ufaos aok sdiodldàot aok `hstfy kjfays do `hgpfjtdoi tnj prhmj`t, Kjvjfhpjr

dokdàtjk tnat dt waotjk th tjrgdoatj tnj fjasj cjàusj dt kdk oht apprj`datj Iarza—s

`hotdouhus `hgpfadots achut tnj quafdty hl tnj prhmj`t Kjvjfhpjr was kjfdvjrdoi aok njr

rjlusaf th a``jpt tnjdr jxùsjs lhr oho`hgpfdao`j wdtn tnj Ufaos. Kjvjfhpjr—s wdsn th cj

snjk hl tnj Fjasj hcfdiatdhos ‐ tnhuin uokjrstaokacfj, idvjo Kjvjfhpjr—s gaodljst ladfurj th

`hgpfy wdtn dts tjrgs ‐ nas oh casds do tnj `hotra`t dtsjfl hr do faw. Pnjfcy Naff nas

`hgpfdjk wdtn tnj Fjasj, aok pjrlhrgjk dts hcfdiatdhos tnjrjuokjr at jvjry stjp hl tnj way.

Pdgpfy put, Pnjfcy Naff nas oht crja`njk tnj Fjasj do aoy way.

3;.

Kjvjfhpjr attjgptjk th doapprhprdatjfy tabj akvaotaij hl dts tnrjat th

tjrgdoatj tnj Fjasj cy sfaokjrdoi Iarza aok dosdstdoi tnat snj a``jpt ao agjokgjot th tnj

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Khùgjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 1; hl ;1 UaijDK 3:


26/65


Fjasj affhwdoi tnjg th tjrgdoatj tnj Fjasj at aoy tdgj lhr aoy rjasho, a prhphsaf Iarza

vjnjgjotfy rjmj`tjk.

3:. Do a lurtnjr attjgpt th fjvjraij dts kjsdrj th lhr`j Iarza th ghkdly tnj Fjasj,

Kjvjfhpjr ndrjk `huosjf aok iavj ohtd`j ho 34 H`thcjr 351: th Pnjfcy Naff aok Iarza tnat

dt was tjrgdoatdoi tnj Fjasj ho tnj irhuoks tnat tnj Ufaos wjrj oht ldoafdzjk. Hl `hursj,

tnds kjgaok diohrjs tnj rjafdty tnat Kjvjfhpjr aok Faokfhrk kdk, do la`t, airjj th Ufaos.

Ynat ds ghrj, jvjo dl Faokfhrk aok Pnjfcy Naff nak ladfjk th rja`n ao airjjgjot as th tnj

Ufaos, Faokfhrk wadvjk aoy rdints th tjrgdoatj tnj Fjasj lhr ladfurj th airjj ho tnj Ufaos cy

`hotdoudoi tnj prhmj`t wdtn Pnjfcy Naff aok Iarza th ojar-`hgpfjtdho. [nj ohtd`j th

tjrgdoatj ds ohtndoi ghrj tnao tndofy-vjdfjk rjtafdatdho aiadost Iarza aok Pnjfcy Naff lhr

navdoi tnj tjgjrdty th dosdst upho tnj spa`j ‐ aok tnj cariado ‐ lhr wnd`n tnjy `hotra`tjk do

tnj Fjasj.

\.@ausjs hl A`tdho

3. [nj purphsj hl a tjgphrary rjstradodoi hrkjr ds th prjsjrvj tnj status quh hl

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 1: hl ;1 UaijDK 3


27/65


tnj sucmj`t gattjr hl pjokdoi fdtdiatdho uotdf a tjgphrary domuo`tdho njardoi `ao cj njfk.

Cutoaru v. Lhrk Ghthr @h., >; P.Y.0k 14>, 35; ([jx. 3553)2 @aooao v. Irjjo Habs Apts., Ftk.,

9:> P.Y.3k 9:0, 9:: ([jx. 14>>). [nj party sjjbdoi a tjgphrary rjstradodoi hrkjr gust

snhw tnat dt nas a prhcacfj rdint th rj`hvjry ho tnj rjfdjl shuint aok tnat dt wdff sulljr a

prhcacfj domury acsjot tnj rjqujstjk domuo`tdvj rjfdjl. Cutoaru , >; P.Y.0k at 35;. Ao domury

ds prhcacfj dl tnj narg ds dggdojot, tnj domury whufk cj drrjparacfj, aok tnj appfd`aot nas oh

htnjr akjquatj rjgjky. Njokjrsho v. BS[P, Do`., >33 P.Y.3k 9


28/65


Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr ‐ tnhuin, cjàusj tnj rdsb

hl aoy narg th Kjljokaots ds pra`tdàffy oho-jxdstjot, Ufadotdlls sucgdt tnat aghuot hl tnj

chok rjqudrjk, dl aoy, snhufk cj kj gdodgus .

01.

Lhr tnj rjashos sjt lhrtn njrjdo, dt ds dgpjratdvj tnat tnds @hurt tjgphrardfy

rjstrado Kjljokaots (hr aoyhoj a`tdoi ho tnjdr cjnafl hr at tnjdr kdrj`tdho) lrhg kjoydoi

Ufadotdlls a``jss th aok phssjssdho hl tnj spa`j kjs`rdcjk do tnj Fjasj. Ho`j a tjgphrary

rjstradodoi hrkjr ds do pfa`j, Ufadotdlls asb tnds @hurt ‐ upho tnj snhwdoi rjqudrjk uokjr tnj

[jxas Sufjs hl @dvdf Urh`jkurj ‐ th `hovjrt tnat tjgphrary rjstradodoi hrkjr th a tjgphrary

domuo`tdho tnat wdff gadotado tnj status quh tnrhuin tnj trdaf hl tnds fawsudt. Lhffhwdoi trdaf,

Ufadotdlls lurtnjr asb tnat tnds tjgphrary domuo`tdho cj `hovjrtjk th a pjrgaojot domuo`tdho

tnat wdff jomhdo aoy lurtnjr su`n uofawluf cjnavdhr cy Kjljokaots tnrhuin tnj tjrg hl tnj

Fjasj.

C. Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot.

03. Ufadotdlls sjjb a kj`faratdho kjtjrgdoatdvj hl tnj mustd`dacfj `hotrhvjrsdjs

kjs`rdcjk njrjdo. Ppj`dldàffy, Ufadotdlls sjjb a kj`faratdho tnat tnj Faokfhrk aok Pnjfcy Naff

kdk airjj th Ufaos, tnat Pnjfcy Naff nas `hgpfdjk wdtn tnj Fjasj, aok tnat Kjljokaots navj

oh rdint th uodfatjraf tjrgdoatdho hl tnj Fjasj.

@. Crja`n hl @hotra`t.

00. A vafdk, jolhr`jacfj airjjgjot ‐ spj`dldàffy, tnj Fjasj ‐ jxdsts cjtwjjo

Ufadotdll Pnjfcy Naff aok Kjljokaot Faokfhrk. Ufadotdll Pnjfcy Naff nas pjrlhrgjk dts

hcfdiatdhos uokjr tnj Fjasj. Kjljokaot Faokfhrk ‐ a`tdoi cy aok tnrhuin Kjvjfhpjr aok

Urhmj`t Gaoaijr, nas crja`njk tnj airjjgjot cy vdrtuj hl patjot gds`hoku`t, as kjs`rdcjk

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Khùgjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 19 hl ;1 UaijDK 3>


29/65


njrjdo. Kjljokaots— crja`n hl tnj Fjasj nas `ausjk Ufadotdlls th sulljr ‐ aok th `hotdouj th

sulljr ‐ domury aok kagaijs, lhr wnd`n Ufadotdlls ohw sjjb rj`hgpjosj.

K. Lrauk.

0;.

Kjljokaots gakj gatjrdaf rjprjsjotatdhos th Ufadotdlls, wnd`n wjrj lafsj.

Ynat ds ghrj, at tnj tdgj tnjsj rjprjsjotatdhos wjrj gakj th Ufadotdlls, Kjljokaot

Kjvjfhpjr jdtnjr (d) bojw tnj rjprjsjotatdhos wjrj lafsj hr (dd) gakj tnj rjprjsjotatdhos

rj`bfjssfy, as a phsdtdvj assjrtdho, wdtnhut bohwfjkij hl tnjdr trutnlufojss. Ufadotdlls whufk

snhw tnat Kjljokaots gakj su`n rjprjsjotatdhos wdtn tnj dotjot tnat Ufadotdlls a`t upho

tnjg. As Kjljokaots dotjokjk, Ufadotdlls rjfdjk upho tnjsj lafsj rjprjsjotatdhos aok, as a

rjsuft, navj sulljrjk ‐ aok `hotdouj th sulljr ‐ domury aok kagaijs, lhr wnd`n tnjy ohw sjjb

rj`hgpjosj.

J. @hospdra`y.

0:. Ufadotdlls whufk snhw tnj @hurt tnat Kjljokaots ‐ hr shgj `hgcdoatdho hl

Kjljokaots ‐ wjrj ja`n gjgcjrs hl a `hgcdoatdho hl twh hr ghrj partdjs. [nj hcmj`t hl

tnds `hgcdoatdho was th a``hgpfdsn hoj hr ghrj uofawluf purphsjs (do`fukdoi, cut oht

oj`jssardfy fdgdtjk th, Kjljokaots— jllhrts th jx`fukj Ufadotdlls lrhg tnj spa`j th wnd`n

Ufadotdlls arj jotdtfjk uokjr tnj Fjasj aok/hr Kjljokaots— attjgpts th `hjr`j Ufadotdlls doth

a`qudjs`doi do Kjljokaots— crja`njs hl tnj Fjasj) hr, do tnj aftjroatdvj, th a``hgpfdsn a

fawluf purphsj cy uofawluf gjaos.

0 hl ;1 UaijDK 34


30/65


a`tdho. As a kdrj`t aok prhxdgatj rjsuft hl tnj wrhoiluf a`t(s), Ufadotdlls navj sulljrjk ‐ aok

`hotdouj th sulljr ‐ domury aok kagaijs, lhr wnd`n tnjy ohw sjjb rj`hgpjosj.

L. [hrtdhus Dotjrljrjo`j wdtn a @hotra`t.

09.

Ufadotdlls whufk snhw tnat a vafdk `hotra`t jxdsts cjtwjjo Ufadotdll Pnjfcy

Naff aok Faokfhrk. Kjljokaots ‐ hr shgj `hgcdoatdho hl tnjg ‐ wdffluffy aok dotjotdhoaffy

dotjrljrjk wdtn tnds `hotra`t. Pdgdfarfy, vafdk `hotra`ts jxdst cjtwjjo Ufadotdlls aok aoy

ougcjr hl suppfdjrs, vjokhrs, aok/hr sphoshrs. Kjljokaots ‐ hr shgj `hgcdoatdho hl

tnjg ‐ navj wdffluffy aok dotjotdhoaffy dotjrljrjk wdtn tnjsj `hotra`ts, as wjff.

0>. As a kdrj`t aok prhxdgatj rjsuft hl Kjljokaots— dotjrljrjo`j, Ufadotdlls navj

sulljrjk ‐ aok `hotdouj th sulljr ‐ a`tuaf domury aok kagaijs, lhr wnd`n tnjy ohw sjjb

rj`hgpjosj.

I. [hrtdhus Dotjrljrjo`j wdtn Urhspj`tdvj Cusdojss Sjfatdhos.

04. A rjashoacfj prhcacdfdty jxdstjk tnat Ufadotdlls whufk jotjr doth cusdojss

rjfatdhosndps wdtn hoj hr ghrj tndrk-partdjs. Cy joiaidoi do dokjpjokjotfy-thrtdhus aok/hr

‐uofawluf `hoku`t, as kjs`rdcjk njrjdo, Kjljokaots dotjotdhoaffy dotjrljrjk wdtn tnjsj

rjfatdhosndps.

;5. As a kdrj`t aok prhxdgatj rjsuft hl Kjljokaots— dotjrljrjo`j, Ufadotdlls navj

sulljrjk ‐ aok `hotdouj th sulljr ‐ a`tuaf domury aok kagaijs, lhr wnd`n tnjy ohw sjjb

rj`hgpjosj.

\D.

Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

;1.

Ufadotdlls rjqujst, lrhg ja`n Kjljokaot, kds`fhsurj hl tnj dolhrgatdho

rjqudrjk uokjr Sufj 14;.3 hl tnj [jxas Sufjs hl @dvdf Urh`jkurj, su`n kds`fhsurjs th cj



31/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij 1;lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

sjrvjk ho Ufadotdlls oh fatjr tnao ldlty (:5) kays hl sjrvd`j hl tnds Ujtdtdho.

\DD. Atthrojys— Ljjs

;3.

Ufadotdlls njrjcy idvj ohtd`j hl tnjdr dotjot th sjjb rj`hvjry hl tnjdr

atthrojys— ljjs, as pjrgdttjk uokjr Pj`tdhos 09.554 aok/hr 0>.551 hl tnj [jxas @dvdf Ura`td`j

aok Sjgjkdjs @hkj, aok aoy htnjr appfdàcfj prhvdsdhos hl faw.

\DDD.@hokdtdhos Urj`jkjot

;0.

Uursuaot th [jx. S. @dv. U. :;, aff `hokdtdhos prj`jkjot th tnj `fadgs assjrtjk

cy Ufadotdll navj h`ùrrjk aok/hr navj cjjo wadvjk.

D^.Ptatjgjot hl Sjfdjl Phuint

;;. Do a``hrkao`j wdtn Sufj ;9 hl tnj [jxas Sufjs hl @dvdf Urh`jkurj, Ufadotdlls

njrjcy idvj ohtd`j tnat tnjy sjjb, cy tnds fawsudt, ghojtary rjfdjl do ao aghuot hvjr

$1,555,5552 domuo`tdvj rjfdjl, as rjqujstjk njrjdo2 aok kj`farathry rjfdjl, as rjqujstjk njrjdo.

USATJS

YNJSJLHSJ, USJGDPJP @HOPDKJSJK, Ufadotdlls rjspj`tluffy pray tnat

Kjljokaots cj `dtjk th appjar njrjdo aok tnat, upho ldoaf njardoi, Ufadotdlls navj aok

rj`hvjr mukigjot aiadost Kjljokaots ‐ mhdotfy aok sjvjraffy, th tnj jxtjot affhwjk cy faw ‐

lhr tnj lhffhwdoi=

• A`tuaf kagaijs do ao aghuot th cj kjtjrgdojk, cut `hggjosuratj wdtn tnja`tuaf ghojtary kagaijs sulljrjk cy Ufadotdlls2

• Uuodtdvj kagaijs do ao aghuot th cj kjtjrgdojk, cut do a``hrkao`j wdtnstaokarks `hgghofy appfdjk uokjr [jxas faw2



32/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfdàtdho Uaij 1:lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

• Htnjr kagaijs rjsuftdoi lrhg Kjljokaots— wrhoiluf a`ts, as pjrgdttjk cyfaw2

• @hsts doùrrjk ‐ do`fukdoi, cut oht oj`jssardfy fdgdtjk th, `hsts hl `hurtdoùrrjk do tnds fawsudt2

• Atthrojys— ljjs as affhwjk cy faw aok/hr cy `hotra`t2

• Urj-mukigjot dotjrjst at tnj gaxdgug ratj affhwjk cy faw2 aok

• Uhst-mukigjot dotjrjst at tnj gaxdgug ratj affhwjk cy faw.



33/65

Ufadotdlls— Hrdidoaf Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Ujtdtdho, Jgjrijo`y Appfd`atdho Uaij 1<lhr Jx-Uartj [jgphrary Sjstradodoi Hrkjr aok [jgphrary aok UjrgaojotDomuo`tdho, Ujtdtdho lhr Kj`farathry Mukigjot aok Sjqujst lhr Kds`fhsurj

Sjspj`tluffy sucgdttjk,

NZO[HO & YDFFDAGP, FFU

Cy= XX/s/ Garb A. GjfthoXXXXXXXXXXX

Garb A. Gjftho

Ptatj Car Oh. 3;5


34/65

@AZPJ OH.

FDPA S. IAS]A-PJF@JS

PNJFCT NAFF F.F.@., a

ok

PNJFCT NAFF

CJ\JSAIJ

FF@

Ufadotdll

v

1


35/65

J^NDCD[ A-0

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 3; hl ;1 UaijDK 0:


36/65

A[FAO[A AZP[DO CAOIBHB CJDMDOI CSZPPJFP @NASFH[[J KAFFAP NHZP[HO FHOKHO FHP AOIJFJP

G`FJAO GDAGD OJY THSB OHSLHFB SAFJDIN SD@NGHOK PAO LSAO@DP@H [HBTH YAPNDOI[HO

www.nuotho.`hg

44449.50354:>5 • 5511

MAODOJ P@NDJFF

KDSJ@[ KDAF= 31;.;.0:1>JGADF= ms`ndjffEnuotho.`hg

LDFJ OH= 44449.03


37/65

J^NDCD[ A-;

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 3< hl ;1 UaijDK 09


38/65

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 39 hl ;1 UaijDK 0>


39/65

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 3> hl ;1 UaijDK 04


40/65

J^NDCD[ A-:

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 34 hl ;1 UaijDK ;5


41/65



42/65



43/65

J^NDCD[ A-<



44/65

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 00 hl ;1 UaijDK ;;


45/65

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 0; hl ;1 UaijDK ;:


46/65

J^NDCD[ A-9

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-1 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 0: hl ;1 UaijDK ;


47/65


48/65

•

LHSG OH. 0:0-0 - @D[A[DHO

[NJ P[A[J HL [J^AP

[h=

N@D

@HOP[SZ@[DHO,

FF@

1444 CSTAO P[SJJ[, PZD[J 455

KAFFAP [^ 9:351

ISJJ[DOIP=

Thu navj cjjo sujk. Thu gay jgpfhy ao atthrojy. lyhu hr yhur atthrojy kh oht ldfj a wrdttjo

aoswjr wdtn tnj `fjrb wnh dssujk tnds `dtatdho cy D5 h ̀ fh`b ag hl nj Ghokay ojxt lhffhwdoi tnj

jxpdratdho hl wjoty kays altjr yhu wjrj sjrvjk tnds `dtatdho aok pjtdtdho, a kjlauft mukigjot

gay

cj

tabjo aiadost yhu. Thur aoswjr snhufk cj akkrjssjk th tnj

`fjrb

hl

nj

1


49/65

•

.

asj Oh.= K@-1:-10051

@hurtOh. 1


50/65

@AZPJ

OH. K@-1:-10051

FDPA S. IAS]A-PJF@NJS, PNJFCT

NAFF F.F.@., aok PNJFCT NAFF

CJ\JSJAIJ, FF@

Ufadotdll(s),

§

§

§

§

DO [NJ KDP[SD@[ @HZS[

vs.

§

§

§

1


51/65

LHSG OH. 0:0-0 - @D[A[DHO

lNJ P[A[J HL [J^AP

[h=

1


52/65

@asj Oh.=

K@-1:-10051

@hurt Oh.1


53/65

J^NDCD[ C

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-3 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 1 hl 3 UaijDK :0


54/65

Pbdp th Gado @hotjot Fhihut Gy A``huot Pjar̀ n Gjou Ojw @dvdf Kdstrd̀ t Pjar`n Sjldoj Pjar`n Ca`b Fh`atdho = Aff Kdstrd̀ t @dvdf @hurts Dgaijs Njfp

S JIDP[JS HL A@[DHOP

@APJ OH. K@-1:-10051

FDPA IAS]A-PJF@JS, jt af vs. 1


55/65

J^NDCD[ @

@asj 0=1:-`v-50941-O Kh`ugjot 1-0 Ldfjk 11/3;/1: Uaij 1 hl 9 UaijDK ::


56/65

ZOD[JK P[A[JP KDP[SD@[ @HZS[

LHS

[NJ OHS[NJSO KDP[SD@[

HL

[J^AP

KAFFAP KD\DPDHO

FDPA S. QAS]A-PJF@JS. PNJFCT N FT

Ufadotdll

v.

11.f(a)(;)(K), aok

FS

>1.3,

1


57/65

Katj=

Pdioaturj=

Urdot

Oagj=

Car Ougcjr=

Akkrjss=

@dty, Ptatj, ]dp=

[jfjpnhoj=

Lax=

J-Gadf=

Ohvjgcjr 3;. 351:

sf

Adgj«

G Lurojss

Adgjj G. Lurojss

3;53>3

303M \d`tho=

v ~

Pudtj 955

Kaffas. [jxas 9:314

31;-


58/65


LHS


HL

[J^AP

KAFFAP KD\DPDHO

FDPA S IAS]A-PJF@JS. PNJFCT NAF1tM

Ufadotdll

v

11.f(a)(;)(K), aok FS >1.3,

NSD USHUJS[DJP, FF@

prhvdkjs tnj lhffhwdoi dolhrgatdho=

Lhr a ohoihvjrogjotaf `hrphratj party, tnj oagj(s) hl dts parjot `hrphratdho aok aoy

pucfd`fy njfk `hrphratdho tnat hwos 15% hr ghrj

hl

dts sth`b dl ohoj, statj Ohoj )=

Ufjasj sjparatj oagjs wdtn a `hgga. Hofy tjxt vdsdcfj wdtndo chx wdff prdot.

Ohoj

A `hgpfjtj fdst

hl

aff pjrshos, assh`datdhos

hl

pjrshos, ldrgs, partojrsndps, `hrphratdhos,

iuaraothrs, dosurjrs, alldfdatjs, parjot hr sucsdkdary `hrphratdhos, hr htnjr fjiaf jotdtdjs tnat arj

ldoao`daffy dotjrjstjk do tnj hut`hgj

hl

tnj `asj=

Ufjasj sjparatj oagjs wdtn a `hgga. Hofy tjx t vdsdcfj wdtndo chx wdff prdot.

Fdsa S Iarza-Pjf`jr, Pnjfcy Naff F.F.@., Pnjfcy Naff Cjvjraij, FF@, Nuotho Ydffdags

1


59/65

Katj=

Pdioaturj=

Urdot Oagj=

Car Ougcjr=

Akkrjss=

@dty, Ptatj, ]dp=

[jfjpnhoj=

Lax=

J Gadf=

Ohvjgcjr 3;. 351:

sf Adgjj G Jurojss

Adgjj G. Lurojss

3;53>3

3030 \d`thry Avj . Pudtj 9QH

Kaffas. [jxas 9:314

31;-


60/65


LHS


HL

[J^AP

KAFFAP

D\DPDHO

FDPA S IAS]A-PJF@JS. PNJFCT NAFT

Ufadotdll

v

11.f(a)(;)(K), aok FS >1.3,

N@D @HOP[SZ@[DHO, FF@

prhvdkjs tnj lhffhwdoi dolhrgatdho=

Lhr a ohoihvjrogjotaf `hrphratj party, tnj oagj(s) hl dts parjot `hrphratdho aok aoy

pucfd`fy njfk `hrphratdho tnat hwos 15% hr ghrj hl dts sth`b dl ohoj, statj Ohoj )=

Ufjasj sjparatj oagjs wdtn a `hgga. Hofy tjxt vdsdcfj wdtndo

chx

wdff prdot.

Ohoj

A `hgpfjtj fdst

hl

aff pjrshos, assh`datdhos

hl

pjrshos, ldrgs, partojrsndps, `hrphratdhos,

iuaraothrs, dosurjrs, alldfdatjs, parjot hr sucsdkdary `hrphratdhos, hr htnjr fjiaf jotdtdjs tnat arj

ldoao`daffy dotjrjstjk do tnj hut`hgj hl tnj `asj=

Ufjasj sjparatj oagjs wdtn a `hgga. Hofy tjxt vdsdcfj wdtndo

chx

wdff prdot.

Fdsa S Iarza-Pjf`jr, Pnjfcy Naff F.F.@., Pnjfcy Naff Cjvjraij, FF@, Nuotho Ydffdags

1


61/65

Katj=

Pdioaturj=

Urdot

Oagj=

Car Ougcjr=

Akkrjss=

@dty, Ptatj,

]dp=

[jfjpnhoj=

Lax=

J Gadf=

Ohvjgcjr 3;. 351:

sf Adgjj G Lurojss

Adgjj

G.

Lurojss

3;53>3

3030 \d`thry

y ~ ..

Pudtj

QH

Uaffas. [jxas 9:314

31;-


62/65

P ;;-[ÔK (Sjv. 13/13) @D\DF @H\JS PNJJ[[nj MP ;; `dvdf `hvjr snjjt aok tnj dolhrgatdho `hotadojk njrjdo ojdtnjr rjpfa`j ohr suppfjgjot tnj ldfdoi aok sjrvd`j hl pfjakdois hr htnjr papjrs as rjqudrjk cy faw, jx`jpt

rhvdkjk cy fhàf rufjs hl `hurt. [nds lhrg, apprhvjk cy tnj Mukd`daf @holjrjò j hl tnj Zodtjk Ptatjs do Pjptjgcjr 149;, ds rjqudrjk lhr tnj usj hl tnj @fjrb hl @hurt lhr tnjurphsj hl dodtdatdoi tnj `dvdf kh`bjt snjjt. (PJJ DOP[SZ@[DHOP HO OJ^[ UAIJ HL [NDP LHSG.)

. (a) UFADO[DLLP KJLJOKAO[P

(c) @huoty hl Sjsdkjo`j hl Ldrst Fdstjk Ufadotdll @huoty hl Sjsdkjo`j hl Ldrst Fdstjk Kjljokaot

(J^@JU[ DO Z.P. UFADO[DLL @APJP) (DO Z.P. UFADO[DLL @APJP HOFT)

OH[J= DO FAOK @HOKJGOA[DHO @APJP, ZPJ [NJ FH@A[DHO HL[NJ [SA@[ HL FAOK DO\HF\JK.

(`) Atthrojys (Ldrg Oagj, Akkrjss, aok [jfjpnhoj Ougcjr) Atthrojys (Dl Bohwo)

D. CAPDP HL MZSDPKD@[DHO (Ufa`j ao ‖^‗ do Hoj Chx Hofy) DDD. @D[D]JOPNDU HL USDO@DUAF UAS[DJP (Ufa`j ao ‖^‗ do Hoj Chx lhr(Lhr Kdvjrsdty @asjs Hofy) aok Hoj Chx lhr Kjljokaot

— 1 Z.P. Ihvjrogjot — 0 Ljkjraf Qujstdho U[L KJL U[L K

Ufadotdll (Z.P. Ihvjrogjot Oht a Uarty) @dtdzjo hl [nds Ptatj — 1 — 1 Do`hrphratjk hr Urdo`dpaf Ufa`j — ;

hl Cusdojss Do [nds Ptatj

— 3 Z.P. Ihvjrogjot — ; Kdvjrsdty @dtdzjo hl Aohtnjr Ptatj — 3 — 3 Do`hrphratjk aok Urdo`dpaf Ufa`j — :

Kjljokaot (Dokdàtj @dtdzjosndp hl Uartdjs do Dtjg DDD) hl Cusdojss Do Aohtnjr Ptatj

@dtdzjo hr Pucmj`t hl a — 0 — 0 Lhrjdio Oatdho — <

Lhrjdio @huotry

\. OA[ZSJ HL PZD[ (Ufa`j ao ‖^‗ do Hoj Chx Hofy)@HO[SA@[ [HS[P LHSLJD[ZSJ/UJOAF[T CAOBSZU[@T H[NJS P[A[Z[JP

— 115 Dosurao`j UJSPHOAF DOMZST UJSPHOAF DOMZST — ZP@ 1:> — 09: Lafsj @fadgs A`t

— 135 Gardoj — 015 Adrpfaoj — 0>1 — ;30 Ydtnkrawaf — ;55 Ptatj Sjapphrtdhog

— 105 Gdffjr A`t — 01: Adrpfaoj Urhku`t Urhku`t Fdacdfdty — ZP@ 1:9 — ;15 Aotdtrust

— 1;5 Ojihtdacfj Dostrugjot Fdacdfdty — 035 @hpyrdints — ;05 Uatjot — ;95 Sa`bjtjjr Dolfujo`j

— 1:3 Sj`hvjry hl Kjlauftjk Fdacdfdty — 0 Ascjsths Ujrshoaf — >;5 [rakjgarb @hrrupt Hriaodzatdh

Ptukjot Fhaos — 0;5 Gardoj Domury Urhku`t — ;>5 @hosugjr @rjkdt

(Jx`fukjs \jtjraos) — 0;: Gardoj Urhku`t Fdacdfdty FACHS PH@DAF PJ@ZSD[T — ;45 @acfj/Pat [\

— 1:0 Sj`hvjry hl Hvjrpaygjot Fdacdfdty UJSPHOAF USHUJS[T — 915 Ladr Fachr Ptaokarks — >:5 Pjùrdtdjs/@hgghk

hl \jtjrao—s Cjojldts — 0:5 Ghthr \jnd`fj — 095 Htnjr Lrauk A`t — >5 Htnjr Ujrshoaf Sjfatdhos — >41 Airdùfturaf A`ts

— 14: @hotra`t Urhku`t Fdacdfdty — 040 Jovdrhogjotaf Gatt

— 14< Lrao`ndsj Domury — 0>: Urhpjrty Kagaij — 9:1 Lagdfy aok Gjkdàf — >4: Lrjjkhg hl Dolhrga

— 04< Arcdtratdho

SJAF USHUJS[T @D\DF SDIN[P USDPHOJS UJ[D[DHOP — 941 Jgpfhyjj Sjtdrjgjot LJKJSAF [A^ PZD[P — >44 Akgdodstratdvj Urh`

— 315 Faok @hokjgoatdho — ;;5 Htnjr @dvdf Sdints Nacjas @hrpus= Do`hgj Pjùrdty A`t — >95 [axjs (Z.P. Ufadotdll A`t/Sjvdjw hr Appj

— 335 Lhrj`fhsurj — ;;1 \htdoi — ;91 DSP‛[ndrk Uarty — 4:5 @hostdtutdhoafdty hl

— 3;5 [hrts th Faok — ;;0 Nhusdoi/ Pjotjo`j 3< ZP@ 9


63/65


64/65


65/65

Puppfjgjotaf @dvdf @hvjr Pnjjt lhr @asjs Sjghvjk

Lrhg Ptatj @hurt

3. Ptyfj hl tnj @asj=

Ufjasj do`fukj aff Ufadotdll(s), Kjljokaot(s), Dotjrvjohr(s), @huotjr`fadgaot(s),@rhss`fadgaot(s) aok [ndrk Uarty @fadgaot(s) stdff rjgadodoi do tnj `asj aok

dokd`atj tnjdr party typj. Afsh, pfjasj fdst tnj atthrojy(s) hl rj`hrk lhr ja`n party

oagjk aok do`fukj tnjdr car ougcjr, ldrg oagj, `hrrj`t gadfdoi akkrjss, aok

pnhoj ougcjr (do`fukdoi arja `hkj).

Ufadotdlls=

Fdsa S. Iarza-Pjf`jr

Pnjfcy Naff F.F.@.

Pnjfcy Naff Cjvjraij, FF@

Atthrojy hl Sj`hrk lhr Ufadotdlls=

Garb Gjftho

[jxas Car Oh. 3;5

shelby hall-lisa garza lawsuit

Documents