smu cox school of business january 31, 2005. 2 amr investment services, inc. 1) oversee management...
TRANSCRIPT
SMUCox School of Business
January 31, 2005
2
AMR INVESTMENT SERVICES, INC.
1) OVERSEE MANAGEMENT OF AMERICAN AIRLINES $16.5 BILLION PENSION PLANS
2) MANAGE $3.0+ BILLION IN SHORT-TERM CASH FOR AMERICAN AIRLINES
3) MANAGE $7.7 BILLION IN SHORT-TERM CASH FOR EXTERNAL CLIENTS
4) MANAGER / ADMINISTRATOR OF $12.7 BILLION AMERICAN AADVANTAGE MUTUAL FUND FAMILY
3
DEFINED BENEFIT PLAN ISSUES IN THE NEWS
• FEW DB PLANS BEING STARTED– DB PLANS BEING FROZEN
– SOME CONVERTED TO CASH BALANCE OR DC• IMPLICATIONS FOR WORKERS
• MASSIVE UNDERFUNDING– PERFECT STORM OF LOWER INTEREST RATES AND INVESTMENT RETURNS
• PLAN TERMINATIONS– RESULT IN LOWER BENEFITS TO BENEFICIARIES
• BUSH PLAN FOR PENSION REFORM– SIMPLIFIED FUNDING STANDARDS
– ADDITIONAL STRAINS ON NON-INVESTMENT GRADE COMPANIES
– REDUCED BENEFITS FOR SOME
4
AMERICAN AIRLINES PENSION PLANS
• FIXED BENEFIT PLANS -- $7.3 BILLION
• PILOT VARIABLE BENEFIT PLAN -- $3.8 BILLION
• 401(K) SALARY DEFERRAL PLAN -- $5.4 BILLION
5
IMPORTANCE OF ASSET ALLOCATION
The Asset Allocation Decision:
How to distribute investment dollars among a variety of asset classes.
Copyright 1990-1993 Ibbotson Associates, Chicago, Illinois
Determinants of Portfolio Performance
Security Selection 4.6%Luck 2.1%
Market Timing 1.8%
Asset Allocation Policy 91.5%
6
DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO ASSET ALLOCATION
• MATCH ASSETS TO LIABILITIES / INCOME REQUIREMENTS
• ESTABLISH LONG-TERM ALLOCATION AND REBALANCE– USING EFFICIENT FRONTIER ANALYSES
• QUANTITATIVELY ANALYZE VALUATION LEVELS OF DIFFERENT MARKETS– EARNINGS YIELD VERSUS TEN-YEAR BOND YIELD
• FUNDAMENTAL ANALYSIS
7
ROLE OF SPONSOR IN FIXED BENEFIT PLANS
• TO PROVIDE BENEFITS PROMISED AT THE LOWEST COST
• ENSURE PROPER FUNDING
• INTEGRATE INVESTMENT POLICIES WITH CORPORATE FINANCIAL POLICIES, GOALS AND CHARACTERISTICS (I.E., ASSET ALLOCATION / EQUITY PHILOSOPHY, ETC.)
8
FIXED BENEFIT PLAN PHILOSOPHY
• MINIMIZE VOLATILITY / RISK TO OFFSET CYCLICAL NATURE OF AIRLINE AND MINIMIZE COMPETITIVE DISADVANTAGE– ASSET / LIABILITY BOND HEDGE
– USE VALUE APPROACH TO EQUITIES
– LONG-TERM ORIENTATION
• ENHANCE RETURNS TO MINIMIZE COST– OVERWEIGHT INTERNATIONAL, EMERGING
MARKETS, AND PRIVATE EQUITY
9
FIXED BENEFIT PLANSMARKET VALUE OF ASSETS vs. ACCUMULATED BENEFIT
OBLIGATION
5.305.90
7.30
5.50
6.20
2.913.54
3.30
4.55 4.565.17
5.605.30
5.70
8.10
3.24 3.25
4.28 4.284.73
2.61
5.01 4.705.20
2.02.53.03.54.04.55.05.56.06.57.07.58.08.59.09.5
Jan-93
Jan-94
Jan-95
Jan-96
Jan-97
Jan-98
Jan-99
Jan-00
Jan-01
Jan-02
Jan-03
Jan-04
Jan-05
Assets Liabilities
BEGINNING - OF - YEAR VALUE
BIL
LIO
NS
OF
DO
LL
AR
S
10
AA FIXED BENEFIT PLANS12/31/04
HEDGED ASSET / LIABILITY BONDS $2.8 BILLION 38%
U.S. EQUITIES $2.2 BILLION 30%
EAFE EQUITIES $1.6 BILLION 22%
EMERGING MARKET INVESTMENTS $401 MILLION 6%
ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS (PRIVATE EQUITY, REAL ESTATE PARTNERSHIPS, VENTURE CAPITAL)
$305 MILLION 4%
11
AA PILOT VARIABLE FUND12/31/04
DOMESTIC EQUITIES $2.8 BILLION
EAFE EQUITIES $798 MILLION
EMERGING MARKET EQUITIES $172 MILLION
74%
21%
5%
12
401(K) PLANS
• GENERAL– INCREASING IN SIZE AND USAGE AS PRIMARY
RETIREMENT PLAN
– INCREASING DESIRE FOR MORE OPTIONS AND FLEXIBILITY
– INCREASING SHORT-TERM ORIENTATION
• CURRENT ISSUES – DIVERSIFICATION
– COMPANY STOCK
– LATE TRADING
– MARKET TIMING
– FIDUCIARY TRUST
13
$UPER $AVER INVESTMENT OPTIONS
Fund Type AMR Investments Other Managers
Cash AA Credit Union -- --TIPS AA TIPS Fund -- --Short Term Bond AA Bond Fund -- --Intermediate Bond AA Bond Fund -- Fidelity US BondHigh Yield Bond AA Bond Fund -- T.Rowe PriceBalanced AA Fund -- Fidelity PuritanLarge Cap Value AA Fund -- Dodge & CoxLarge Cap Growth AA Fund AA S&P 500 Index Janus FundMid Cap Value AA Fund -- DreyfusMid Cap Growth -- -- T.Rowe PriceSmall Cap Value AA Fund -- BergerSmall Cap Growth -- AA SmallCap Index DreyfusInternational Equity AA Fund AA Int’l EquityIndx Fidelity Int’lEmerging Markets(max 10% investment)
AA Fund -- Dreyfus
Sector Fund – Tech.(max 10% investment)
-- -- T.RowePriceScience&Tech
Lifestyle Funds Conservative Moderate Aggressive
--
AMR Stock(max 10% investment)
-- -- Company Stock Fund
14
401(K) PLAN12/31/04
CREDIT UNION 16.4%
BONDS 5.1%
TOTAL BONDS 21.5%
BALANCED (INCLUDING LIFESTYLE PORTFOLIOS)
DOMESTIC EQUITIES
9.8%
51.5%
EAFE EQUITIES
EMERGING MARKET
10.3%
2.5%
TOTAL EQUITIES 74.1%
OTHER (PARTICIPANT LOANS) 4.4%
15
TOP 10 INVESTMENT TIPSSHARED WITH AA EMPLOYEES
#1 DON’T PROCRASTINATE OR DELAY
#2 AVOID BUYING LAST YEAR’S PERFORMANCE
#3 PATIENCE IS A VIRTUE -- BE A LONG-TERM INVESTOR
#4 TIMING THE STOCK MARKET CAN BE HAZARDOUS TO YOUR FINANCIAL HEALTH
#5 BUY LOW … SELL HIGH
#6 BUY NO-LOAD, LOW-COST INVESTMENTS
#7 GET PROTECTION FROM INFLATION
#8 DON’T PUT ALL OF YOUR EGGS IN ONE BASKET
#9 GO FOR TAX-DEFERRED FIRST
#10 THE EARLY BIRD GETS THE WORM
16
THE COST OF WAITING TO SAVE
Saving $2,000 per year from:
Amount Invested
Value at Age 65
$10,000
$110,000
$210,000
$310,000
Age 25-35 Age 35-65 Age 50-65
$291,546
$20,000
$60,000
$226,566
$30,000$54,304
A CASE FOR BEING INVESTEDValue of $1 Invested From 1/1/62 Through 12/31/04
$69.64
$11.46
$21.91
$0
$10
$20
$30
$40
$50
$60
$70
$80
S&P 500 T-Bills S&P 500
Top 10 MonthsOct-74 16.57%Jan-87 13.40Jan-75 12.51Aug-82 12.17Jan-76 11.99Oct-82 11.52Dec-91 11.43Aug-84 11.28Nov-80 10.95Nov-62 10.86
(Less 10 Best Months)
Source: Hotchkis and Wiley Capital Management; Frank Russell18
18
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE ON U.S. EQUITY RETURNSS&P 10-Year Return Just Above Long-Term Average
Source: OFI Institutional Asset Management
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
S&P 500 S&P 500 Trailing 10-Year Return
79-YrAverage10.4%
S&P 500 Annualized 10-Year Return Through:December 1979 (Decade of the 70s) 5.9%December 1989 (Decade of the 80s) 17.5%December 1999 (Decade of the 90s) 18.2%December 31, 2004 12.1%
19
S&P VALUE/GROWTH INDICESJanuary 1, 1975 through December 31, 2004
*The standard deviation measures the variability of monthly returns versus their average monthly return.
12.0%
12.5%
13.0%
13.5%
14.0%
14.5%
15.0%
14.5% 15.0% 15.5% 16.0% 16.5% 17.0%
Volatility (Standard Deviation)*
Ave
rage
Ann
ualiz
ed T
otal
Ret
urn
S&P Value
S&P 500
S&P Growth
20
Boeing
MARKET
I
II
III
IV
HIGH
HIGHLOW
9.4
%
GROWTH
P/E20.2 X
QUADRANT ANALYSISDECEMBER 31, 2004
Washington Mutual
EDS